1. Introduction
Lamb survival in the first few days of life, especially in multiple gestations, is one of the most common factors limiting sheep productivity worldwide [
1]. Lamb survival is a multifactorial trait [
2,
3]. Maternal nutrient restriction during gestation leads to fetal growth restriction and low lamb birth weight and is a key contributor to lamb mortality [
4,
5]. Several targeted interventions have been evaluated to explore options to reduce the negative effect of maternal nutrient restriction during pregnancy and improve the lifetime performance of the offspring [
6]. However, strategies during last third of gestation to improve lamb survival around birth in nutrient-restricted ewes remain elusive.
L-Arginine (Arg) is a versatile amino acid [
7], which has been shown to improve not only fetal growth when supplemented to nutrient-restricted ewes [
8] but also traits important for lamb survival in multiple gestations [
9,
10]. However, Arg is degraded in the rumen [
11], has a short biological half-life [
12], and the reduced availability and high cost of protected forms limits its use in extensive sheep systems [
13].
N-carbamylglutamate (NCG), an analogue of N-acetylglutamate (a key enzyme in the synthesis of Arg), is postulated to improve Arg synthesis, urea recycling, nitrogen utilization and antioxidant capacity in ruminants [
14]. Interestingly, NCG is not extensively degraded in the rumen [
11] and the cost of NCG compared to Arg is significantly lower [
15]. Supplementation of NCG to nutrient-restricted ewes (50% NRC) before 110 days of gestation ameliorates fetal growth restriction in multiple-gestation sheep [
16,
17], improving placental growth, antioxidant capacity in maternal and fetal plasma [
18], placental [
19] and intestinal [
20] amino acid transport, fetal thymus development and immune function [
21] when evaluated at 110 days of gestation. However, the impact on fetal growth and development after 110 days of gestation in sheep has not been reported. One study in dairy cows suggests that maternal supplementation with NCG during the last 28 days of pregnancy improved the newborn weight via improvement of angiogenesis, nutrient transport and urea cycle in the fetus [
22]. It is not clear if a similar time of intervention in pregnant sheep would improve the fetal outcome.
Nutrient restriction in sheep during pregnancy is common in Patagonia, with negative effects on ewes’ body condition score (BCS) and reproductive performance [
23]. This is critical in multiple gestations, as twin-bearing ewes have increased nutrient requirements compared to singletons [
24]. The nutrient requirements of twin-bearing ewes increase relative to singletons in the last third of gestation and interventions during this timeframe have the potential to improve intrauterine and fetal growth and development in twin pregnancies [
25].
The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of oral NCG supplementation from 100 days to term in naturally nutrient-restricted grazing twin-bearing ewes, on the maternal body weight (BW) and BCS, placental morphology, fetal weight and body composition and maternal and fetal blood biochemical and antioxidant parameters. We hypothesized that maternal NCG supplementation to naturally nutrient-restricted twin-bearing ewes from 100 to 140 days of gestation would enhance the growth, metabolic status and antioxidant capacity of the fetus compared to unsupplemented controls.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Ethics Statement
This study was performed in agreement with the Guide for Care and Use of Laboratory Animals (Eighth Edition, National Research Council, National Institute of Health, USA). The protocol was approved by the Bioethics Review Committee of the Instituto de Investigaciones Agropecuarias (INIA, Ministry of Agriculture, protocol N° 07-2022).
2.2. Animals and Experimental Procedure
This study was conducted at INIA-Kampenaike Research Farm, 60 km north of Punta Arenas, Chile (Chilean Patagonia, Lat. 52°41′ S Long. 70°54′ W). Corriedale ewes (4–6 years old) from a commercial flock were synchronized using an intravaginal progesterone device (CIDR G®, Pfizer, Santiago, Chile) for 12 days, followed by 300 IU equine chorionic gonadotrophin (eCG; Novormon, Syntex, Argentine) via i.m. injection. Mating was carried out via laparoscopic artificial insemination, using a single Corriedale ram to standardize the paternal effect. Transabdominal ultrasound pregnancy examination was performed 80 days after mating (Oviscan, BCF Technology Ltd, Livingston EH54 8TE, Scotland, UK), and 18 twin-bearing ewes were selected. The weight and body condition scores (BCSs, 1 to 5 scale) were similar for all the animals (57.98 ± 2.34 kg and 2.7 ± 0.36, respectively) at 100 days of gestation (dga). Ewes were randomly assigned into two groups. The first group, defined as NCG (n = 10), was orally dosed once daily with 60 mg/kg BW NCG (Inner Mongolia Tianyi Sci. & Tech. Co., Ltd., Ulanqab, Inner Mongolia, China) in a water carrier from 100 to 140 dga. Each NCG dose was prepared according to the individual ewe’s weight. The control group received no supplementation (CON; n = 8). All the animals received the same daily management and handling to reduce the impact of handling stress on the treatment response. The ewes were managed together as a single mob in a paddock with natural pasture (4.23% CP, 1.69 Mcal/kg ME), with a stocking rate of 0.9 ewes per hectare and a dry matter availability of 255 kg per hectare, representative of commercial Patagonian prairie conditions. Due to the severe nutrient restriction resulting from environmental conditions, all the ewes were supplemented with alfalfa hay (600 g/day/ewe; 13% CP and ME 2.2 Mcal/kg ME, on a dry matter basis) from 130 to 140 dga. The maternal BW and BCS were recorded every 10 days, from 100 until 140 dga.
At 140 dga, maternal and fetal blood samples were collected following caesarian section, as previously described [
25]. Maternal jugular (10 mL) and umbilical cord (5 mL) venous blood samples were collected for evaluation of the blood chemistry and oxidative status. The weight of each fetus, sex, crown–rump length (CRL), front and hind leg length, thoracic girth circumference and weights of the internal organs were recorded. Placentas were extracted and weighted. Each placentome was dissected from the maternal and fetal membranes and weighed individually for the assessment of the total placentome number, total placentome weight, mean placentome weight and placental efficiency, estimated as the ratio of total litter weight (g) per total placental weight (g).
2.3. Assessment of Oral NCG Flux into Maternal Circulation
The concentration of NCG in the maternal plasma was determined via liquid chromatography triple quadrupole mass spectroscopy (LC-QQQ-MS). Samples (100 µL) were first diluted with 500 µL of 50% methanol before briefly vortexing to mix, and then centrifuging (14,000 rcf for 10 min at 4 °C) using a Centrifuge 5427 R (Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany). A 500 µL aliquot of the diluted sample was added to a pre-conditioned (1 mL methanol followed by 1 mL of deionized water) reversed-phase anion-exchange solid-phase extraction cartridge (Strata-X-A, 33 µm, 200 mg/3 mL, Phenomenex, Torrance, CA, USA). The cartridge was rinsed with 1 mL each of 25 mM ammonium acetate solution then methanol. NCG was eluted using 2 × 1 mL of 5% formic acid in methanol. The eluate was dried using a CentriVap Concentrator attached to a FreeZone 4.5 L (−105 °C) freeze-drier (Labconco Corporation, Kansa City, MO, USA) before being reconstituted in 100 µL of methanol and transferred to amber HPLC vials for analysis.
NCG was detected and quantified using an LCMS-8060NX (Shimadzu Corporation, Kyoto, Japan). Separation of the NCG was achieved using a Poroshell HILIC-Z 150 × 2.1 mm (2.7 µm) column (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) eluted at a flow rate of 400 µL/min with 16 mM ammonium formate (A) and 97% acetonitrile containing 0.1% formic acid (B) using the following gradient: Start at 92.8% B, T 10 min 64.8% B, T 11.5 min 64.8% B, and T 12 min to initial conditions with a 3 min equilibration. NCG was detected and quantified using the 189–146 m/z mass fragmentation transition with the 186–128 m/z mass transition used for compound confirmation. The analyte peaks were detected and quantified using LabSolutions Insight v4.0 (Shimadzu Corporation, Kyoto, Japan). The limits of detection and quantitation using this method were 2 ng/mL and 6 ng/mL, respectively.
2.4. Assessment Umbilical Blood Gases, Chemistries, Hematocrit and Hemoglobin
At 140 dga, 1 mL of blood was obtained from the umbilical vein of all the fetal sheep into heparinized syringes for blood gas analysis. The analysis was performed immediately after blood collection with a portable blood gas analyzer (I-STAT
®, Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL, USA) and the CG8+ cartridge (Abbott Lab., Abbott Park, IL, USA), as previously described for ewes [
26]. The partial pressure of oxygen (PO
2), partial pressure of carbon dioxide (PCO
2), total carbon dioxide (TCO
2), hemoglobin concentration (Hb), bicarbonate (HCO
3), oxygen saturation (sO
2), base excess (BE), sodium (Na), potassium (K), calcium (Ca), hematocrit (Hct), and pH value were measured using this approach.
2.5. Assessment of Oxidative Stress Biomarkers
The maternal and fetal plasma redox statuses were evaluated at 140 dga by measurement of the malondialdehyde (MDA) concentration and total antioxidant capacity (TAC), as previously described [
23].
2.6. Assessment of Maternal Plasma Metabolites
Maternal blood samples (10 mL) were obtained every 10 days from 100 to 140 dga. Blood was collected from the jugular vein and transferred to plain vacuum tubes (BD Vacutainer, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA). The tubes were centrifuged at 4 °C and 3000×
g for 10 min; serum was stored at −20 °C until assayed. The determined metabolites, methods and laboratory information is presented in
Table 1.
2.7. Statistical Analysis
All the data were assessed for normality and homogeneity and no transformation was necessary. The effects of the treatment on the ewes’ BW, BCS and plasma metabolites were analyzed using REML repeated measures analysis in R using the lme4 R package (R version 4.3.0.) with the time (dga) and treatment (and their interaction) as fixed effects and the ewe as the random effect. The serum NCG, feto-placental blood gases, chemistries, hematocrit and hemoglobin, oxidative stress biomarkers and placental traits were analyzed using REML analysis in R using the lme4 R package with the treatment as the fixed effect and the ewe as the random effect. The fetal weight, measurements and organ weights were evaluated considering the treatment, sex of the fetus and the interaction as fixed effects, with the ewe as the random effect, to account for twin pregnancies. When presented, all the post hoc tests were performed using Fisher’s Least Significant Difference (LSD) test. A treatment difference was considered significant if p < 0.05 and as a trend when p < 0.10.
4. Discussion
The key finding of this study was that while the serum concentrations of NCG were increased 15-fold in the supplemented ewes compared to the controls, there was no major effect on the dam or fetal body weight, composition or blood antioxidant parameters and only limited effects on the blood biochemical parameters. These results indicate that NCG supplementation (60 mg/kg) in mid-to-late gestation to grazing ewes was unable to rescue the negative physiological and developmental effects of severe natural nutritional restriction on both the dam and fetuses when supplemented from 100 to 140 dga.
Nutrient restriction normally occurs in rangeland areas, where sheep often experience bouts of nutrient restriction of less than 50% of their nutritional requirements [
27]. Similar levels of nutritional restriction of pregnant ewes during winter are observed in extensive grazing systems in Patagonia. Low forage availability and quality (i.e., low CP and ME), particularly during pregnancy [
28], make it difficult to meet maternal and fetal nutritional requirements, resulting in negative effects on production performance. Ewes tend to lose at least one BCS unit and over a 20% of their body weight during the early gestation period (before 100 dga) in twin-bearing ewes [
23]. In the present study, both the NCG and CON ewes exhibited a similar BCS and BW loss compared to what was observed in one of our previous studies [
29]; however, the negative effects of undernutrition on the dam and fetal parameters were not ameliorated with NCG supplementation. The absence of an effect of NCG on maternal weight is in agreement with Zhang et al., where twin-bearing ewes nutrient-restricted (50% NRC) were supplemented from day 35 to 110 of gestation with NCG and showed no effect on maternal weight at 110 dga [
17]. Similarly, Arg supplementation to 50% nutrient-restricted ewes from day 100 to 125 [
30], or from 60 to parturition [
8], or in 60% nutrient restricted ewes supplemented rumen-protected arginine supplement dosed at 180 mg/kg BW during last two-thirds of gestation [
31], resulted in no difference in maternal body weight, consistent with the results of the present study.
The high level of natural nutrient restriction had a metabolic impact in both groups, reflecting the harsh environment encountered in sheep-grazing systems in Patagonia. During late gestation, an increase in NEFA is normally expected, resulting from a negative energy balance and fat mobilization [
32]. However, this increase in more marked when ewes are under-fed. For example, twin-bearing ewes restricted at 30% of their nutrient requirements (CP and ME), during 15 days starting at 100 dga, showed a 200% fold increase in circulating NEFA [
33]. In the present study, the plasma NEFA concentrations observed in both groups exceeded the normal range for sheep (0–300 µmol/L) and the cutoff point for developing clinical adverse metabolic conditions (390 µmol/L) [
34], indicating severe nutrient restriction and negative energy balance in both groups of animals. The low nutrient supply was supported by the pasture nutrient composition analysis. The lower albumin and urea concentrations in the NCG relative to the CON ewes is consistent with the potential for increased urea recycling in response to NCG supplementation [
14]; however, this was unable to rescue the negative effects of severe maternal nutritional restriction on the maternal or fetal production parameters. It is important to note that the divergence in albumin and urea concentrations between the groups was evident between 130 and 140 dga, corresponding with the period of alfalfa supplementation. These results suggest that the effect of NCG could be related to the maternal nutrient level. Further studies are required to evaluate the interaction between the level of maternal nutritional restriction and NCG supplementation on urea recycling and other metabolic changes.
No effect on the fetal weight, placental weight, morphology or efficiency was observed, suggesting that NCG supplementation did not counteract the negative effects of maternal undernutrition on fetal growth in twin pregnancies. This result contrasts with the positive effect on fetal growth observed at 110 dga following maternal NCG supplementation to nutrient-restricted (50% NRC) twin-bearing ewes from day 35 to 110 of gestation, using an effective dose of 2.5 g of NCG per ewe (~60 mg/kg BW in 40 kg ewes). In this study, a 21% increase in fetal weight and some changes in placental parameters at 110 dga were reported [
17]. However, in that study fetal weight and placental parameters later in gestation were not reported. Therefore, it is possible that supplementation earlier in pregnancy may be required to elicit an effect on placental development and fetal growth in nutrient-restricted ewes, as previously shown to occur also in goats supplemented from day 0 to 90 of gestation [
35]. However, supplementation of nutritionally restricted (50% NRC) single-bearing ewes from 100 to 125 dga with Arg also failed to elicit a fetal growth or placental development effect [
30]. In contrast, when animals are fed to meet or exceed nutritional requirements, NCG supplementation during the last 28 dga in cattle [
22], or Arg supplementation from 100 dga to term in twin-bearing ewes [
10], has been reported to have a positive effect on fetal growth. Collectively, these results suggest that the level of nutritional restriction on the ewes in the present study may have been too severe to be rescued by NCG supplementation in mid-late gestation, when the nutritional requirements are the greatest.
Consistent with the lack of effect on the fetal weight, there were minimal differences in the fetal tissue and organ weights in response to maternal NCG supplementation. In contrast to prior studies, where brown fat deposition was enhanced with maternal Arg supplementation from 100 to 140 dga [
10], there was no effect observed in response to NCG supplementation in the present study. The smaller brain and lungs of fetuses from the NCG compared to the CON ewes was intriguing. The growth-restricted fetus adapts its circulation to preserve oxygen and nutrient supply to the brain (“brain-sparing”) [
36], and increased brain and lung weight have been previously described at 110 dga in fetuses from nutrient-restricted ewes supplemented with NCG [
17], contrasting with the results in the present study. Also, no effect of thymus growth was observed, contrasting with the previously described effect for NCG supplementation [
21]. It is likely that the level of nutrient restriction in the present study exceeded the capacity for the fetus to compensate for the normal growth of these organs. In contrast, the disproportionately larger combined small and large intestine weight in the NCG compared to the CON fetuses may be an adaptive mechanism to support enhanced nutrient uptake in the early post-natal period. It is important to note that the aforementioned differences in the brain, lung and intestine weights did not reach statistical significance, and the differences were relatively small and therefore may not be biologically significant, and they would require validation in future studies.
Twin pregnancies in nutrient-restricted gestations occur under a hypoxic environment, leading to oxidative stress and contributing to reduced fetal growth [
29]. Oxidative stress results from the imbalance between cellular the natural antioxidant defenses and pro-oxidant state, augmenting the concentration of reactive oxygen species (ROS) [
37]. Targeted interventions with antioxidants during the entire gestation has proved to counteract oxidative stress in naturally undernourished pregnant ewes, improving fetal growth, regardless of the liter size [
25]. The NCG antioxidant capacity has been demonstrated in lambs [
38,
39] and dairy cows [
40] and has also been proposed to improve the maternal–fetal–placental antioxidant capability in underfed twin-bearing ewes (50% NRC) at 110 dga by increasing TAC and reducing MDA in maternal and fetal plasma, and in the caruncle and cotyledon, when supplemented from day 35 to 110 of gestation [
18] via modification of specific metabolic pathways [
15]. However, in the present study, maternal supplementation with NCG during late gestation resulted in no effects on the materno-fetal antioxidant status. Previous studies have shown that pregnant ewes maintained in a nutrient imbalance given by low energy availability [
37] or undernutrition (30% NRC) leading to a lipid imbalance [
41] have decreased antioxidant capacity during late pregnancy, and the level of reduction in the antioxidant capacity is related to the severity of the nutrition insult. Therefore, some plausible explanations for the lack of response to NCG supplementation in the present study could be the timing of the supplementation during late gestation, contrasting with intervention before 110 dga [
18], or the level of maternal nutritional restriction was so severe that it could not be recovered via NCG supplementation at the level used in the present study. More research would be required to study the potential benefits of NCG for oxidative stress and the interaction with the level of maternal nutritional restriction.