- freely available
Energies 2014, 7(3), 1483-1499; doi:10.3390/en7031483
Abstract: A new magnetless axial-flux doubly-salient DC-field (AF-DSDC) machine is proposed and implemented into the application of a range-extended electric vehicle (RE-EV). By employing the radial active part for the torque production, the proposed machine can produce satisfactory torque density to fulfill the requirements of the RE-EV system. With the support of the 3D finite element method (3D-FEM), the performances of the proposed machine are calculated and compared with the requirements of the typical passenger RE-EV applications. To offer a more comprehensive illustration, the common radial-flux (RF) machines are included for comparison.
With the ever increasing concerns on energy efficiency and hence environmental protection, the development of electric vehicles (EVs) has been speeding up [1–3]. However, conventional EVs rely merely on the battery as the sole power source, thus, these types of EVs can only be used for short duration trips and are not practical for normal daily usage [4,5]. To extend the range for normal applications, the range-extended EV (RE-EV) which also incorporates an internal combustion engine (ICE) as secondary source has been proposed [6–9].
As the key element of the RE-EV system, electric machines have to offer high efficiency, high power density, high controllability, wide-speed range, and maintenance-free operation [10,11]. To achieve these goals, permanent-magnet (PM) machines have been actively developed [12–15]. However, in recent years, the supply of PM materials has been limited and uneven, leading to soaring material costs [16,17], therefore, advanced magnetless doubly-salient (DS) machines have been gaining more attention [18–20].
Compared with PM machines, the magnetless machines have the definite merit of low material costs, but suffer from lower torque density [21,22]. Meanwhile, the axial-flux (AF) machine, which employs the radial length as the active part for torque production, can further improve its torque density, as compared with its profound radial-flux (RF) counterparts [23–26]. Nevertheless, the concept of implementing the DC-field excitation into the AF-DS machine has rarely been addressed yet.
The purpose of this paper is to newly incorporate the DC-field winding into the AF-DS machine, hence creating a new AF-DSDC machine, purposely for RE-EV applications. The design criteria and operating principles of the proposed machine will be discussed. Its performance will be analyzed by using the 3D finite element method (3D-FEM), and then quantitatively compared with the requirements of typical passenger RE-EV applications. For better illustrative purposes, the profound RF machines, namely the RF-switched reluctance (RF-SR), RF-DSDC and RF-doubly-salient permanent-magnet (RF-DSPM) machines are included for comprehensive comparison.
2. Systems Configuration and Operation Modes
Figure 1 shows the RE-EV system, which applies the in-wheel direct drive architecture. Based on the requirements of a typical passenger RE-EV, the targeted specifications of the system for each of the motors are listed in Table 1 [27,28]. This RE-EV system utilizes the motors as the major power source for the normal operations, while the ICE served as the supplementary part for range extension. Basically, the proposed RE-EV system can offer four major operation modes.
2.1. Mode 1: Torque Boosting
When the RE-EV needs to accelerate or run uphill, the motor has to operate with the torque boosting mode, namely, the motor is requested to output the peak torque under a short period of time. Under this mode, the current density of the DC-field excitation is purposely boosted up to strengthen the flux densities, resulting in the maximized output torque.
2.2. Mode 2: Flux-Weakening Operation
After the RE-EV has started up with the torque boosting mode, the generated electromotive force (EMF) among the armature windings starts to increase with the increased operating speed. In order to maintain a certain power level within the constant power operation region, the flux density should be weakened accordingly. By regulating the independent DC-field excitation, the proposed RE-EV system can effectively achieve this flux-weakening operation. Theoretically, RE-EVs can provide infinite speed ranges by regulating the DC-field excitations [18,19].
2.3. Mode 3: Fault-Tolerant Operation
Whilst the DC-field winding is under open-circuit fault or short-circuit fault conditions, the DC-field current should be cut off and the proposed motor can still be operated by the remaining sets of healthy armature winding . Once the DC-field current has malfunctioned, the remaining armature current can be purposely boosted up and operated with the unipolar conduction scheme, such that the torque level can be maintained. Meanwhile, by employing the profound fault-tolerant operating algorithms, the proposed machine can also achieve the fault-tolerant operation under the armature winding fault . This fault-tolerant operation is very important for RE-EVs as it can avoid traffic jams or even fatal accidents when the machine suddenly malfunctions due to a fault.
2.4. Mode 4: Battery Charging
Once the battery is almost exhausted, the ICE can be applied to operate the RE-EV and to charge the battery for range extension. As the engine speed varies along with the wide range of vehicle speeds, the generated voltage is varying accordingly. Meanwhile, when the RE-EV runs downhill or in braking occasions, the motor undergoes a regenerative braking stage and starts to charge the battery . This time-varying generated voltage may overcharge the battery and shorten its life cycle. In order to extend the battery life, the proposed motor can control its DC-field winding, leading to regulation of the flux density in a way that the generated voltage is kept as constant as possible.
3. Proposed Axial-Flux Doubly-Salient DC-Field (AF-DSDC) Machine
3.1. Proposed Machine Structure
Figure 2 shows the topology of the proposed 8/10-pole AF-DSDC machine, which consists of a double-sided-stator sandwiched-rotor structure. The stator and rotor construction of the proposed machine are similar to those of other conventional AF machines .
Based on this structure and accompanied by the proper dimensions, the proposed machine is able to mount its rotor to the tire directly, such that in-wheel motor drive can be achieved instinctively as shown in Figure 3.
The proposed machine is designed based on the four-phase topology due to considerations of stability and cost-effectiveness. The corresponding key design data are tabulated in Table 2. Meanwhile, the proposed AF-DSDC machine employs its radial part for torque production and hence its torque density is improved compared with its RF counterparts [23–26].
Since the AF-DSDC machine is derived from the conventional RF-DSDC machine, its design equations such as the pole arrangement  can be extended from that of the profound RF-DSDC machine. Thus, the pole arrangements for the AF-DSDC are governed by:
3.2. DC Flux-Linkage Pattern
The proposed AF-DSDC machine uses two types of winding, namely the DC-field winding and armature winding, in each of its sided-stators, and both sets of winding adopt the concentrated winding arrangement. With this configuration, each of the two sets of winding is installed with their magnetic axes parallel to each other, albeit in opposing directions. These lead to the fact that the flux in the rotor yoke is divided into two equal paths as shown in Figure 4.
Since the machine has a symmetrical structure, the torques produced by the two sided-stators are complementary with each other, leading to a balanced resultant torque. In addition, to simplify the operation complexity, each of the corresponding sets of windings in the two sided-stators can be purposely connected in series.
3.3. Operation Principles
With the additional DC-field excitation, the proposed AF-DSDC machine can be operated at two different conduction schemes, namely the bipolar conduction scheme and unipolar conduction scheme. To be specific, the bipolar conduction scheme mainly serves for normal operations, whereas the unipolar conduction scheme is devoted to fault-tolerant operation . A full-bridge inverter is installed for the armature winding, providing independent phase control capability. Meanwhile, a full-bridge DC-DC converter is installed for the DC-field winding, resulting in flux strengthening and weakening abilities .
3.3.1. Bipolar Conduction Scheme
When the DC-field excitation is available, the proposed AF-DSDC machine can be operated by using the bipolar conduction scheme, which is similar to the conventional RF-DSPM machine operation [13,14]. When the DC flux-linkage ΨDC is increasing and the no-load EMF is positive, a positive armature current IBLDC is applied to produce a positive torque TDC. Similarly, a negative armature current −IBLDC is applied when the ΨDC is decreasing and the no-load EMF is negative, hence also producing a positive torque. The operating waveforms under the bipolar conduction scheme are shown in Figure 5a.
Each phase performs 90° conduction with θ2 − θ1 = θ4 − θ3 = 90°. The resulting electromagnetic torque TDC can be expressed as:
3.3.2. Unipolar Conduction Scheme
Whilst the DC-field winding is under any fault condition, the DC-field current should be cut off and the proposed machine can then be operated by using the unipolar conduction scheme, which is similar as the RF-SR machine [19,22]. Namely, a unipolar rectangular current ISR is fed to the armature winding during the increasing period of the self-inductance LSR, resulting as the positive corresponding reluctance torque TSR within θ2 − θ1 = 90° as shown in Figure 5b. However, under this conduction scheme, only half of the torque producing period is utilized, and thus the torque performance is degraded and the torque ripple is larger than that under the bipolar conduction operation conditions. Therefore, this mode is regarded as the fault-tolerant operation  for the scenario when the DC-field winding is under fault condition. The reluctance torque at this unipolar conduction scheme can be expressed as:
4. Electromagnetic Field Analysis
Electromagnetic field analysis has been widely applied for the design of electric machines, and it can be basically categorized as the analytical field calculation  and the numerical field calculation . In this paper, 3D-FEM is employed for the analysis of the proposed AF-DSDC machine performance [24,30]. The magnetic solver used to perform the finite element analysis for the proposed machines is the JMAG-Designer and each simulation process takes more than 10 h using a high-performance PC. Figure 6 shows the corresponding no-load magnetic field distributions of the proposed machine. It can be shown that the magnetic flux in the rotor yoke is divided into two symmetrical patterns via the two sided-stators. Hence, it can be predicted that the two individual torques produced by the two segments are identical.
Figure 7 shows the air-gap flux density waveforms of both air-gaps of the proposed machine under the no-load condition where the DC-field excitation is under the rated current densities of 5 A/mm2. These show that both air-gaps achieve the same flux pattern. Hence, it can be confirmed that under the same electric supply, the output torques produced by the two sided-stators should be the same.
Figures 8 and 9 show the DC flux-linkage waveforms for the bipolar conduction scheme (with the DC-field excitation set at 5 A/mm2) and the self-inductance waveforms for the unipolar conduction scheme (without any DC-field excitation), respectively.
In order to maintain the same torque level between both conduction schemes, the armature current at the unipolar one is given by Equation (5) in which the values of KDC, and KSR can be deduced from Figures 8 and 9, as summarized in Table 3. As calculated, in the unipolar conduction mode, the armature currents have to be boosted by approximately 129%, as compared with the bipolar conduction mode. At this current density range, the machine can still be operated for a relatively long period of time, say several hours, without thermal damage.
5. Performance Analysis
5.1. No-Load EMF Waveforms at Rated Conditions
By using 3D-FEM, the performance of the proposed machine can be thoroughly analyzed. Firstly, the no-load EMF waveforms at the base speed 300 rpm with the rated DC-field excitation of 5 A/mm2 are simulated as shown in Figure 10. It can be seen that the no-load EMF waveforms of both sets of windings have the balanced four-phase patterns. These confirm that the setting of the pole-pair arrangement and the winding configurations are correct. In addition, the results show that both no-load EMF waveforms provide the same polarities and values, and both of them can achieve up to a peak value of 153 V. Hence, even when both sets of armature winding are connected in series, the targeted DC supply voltage is still able to support normal operation.
5.2. Performance of Mode 1—Torque Boosting
Secondly, Figure 11 shows the torque performances of the proposed machine at rated DC-field excitation (5 A/mm2) and at strengthened DC-field excitation (10 A/mm2), respectively. Since the independent DC-field winding can be controlled effectively, it can be utilized to regulate the air-gap flux densities to fit different situations. It can be observed that the average steady torques of the machine at rated and at strengthened DC-field excitation are 154.2 Nm and 203.2 Nm, respectively. These confirm that the proposed machine can fulfill the torque requirements of normal operation, including the Mode 1, the torque boosting mode. Consequently, the torque ripples at rated and at strengthened DC-field excitation can be found to be 27.4% and 43.2%, respectively, which are both very acceptable for normal RE-EV applications [13,28].
Thirdly, the cogging torque waveforms of the proposed machine at rated and strengthened DC-field excitations are simulated as shown in Figure 12. It can be found that the peak values at rated and strengthened DC-field excitations are 18.6 Nm and 42.4 Nm, respectively. As compared with the corresponding average torques, they are only 12.1% and 20.9%, respectively, which are also comparable to those of conventional RF-DSPM machines .
5.3. Performance of Mode 2—Flux-Weakening Operation
Fourthly, the torque-speed characteristics of the proposed machine are simulated and shown in Figure 13. The DC-field excitation can be independently controlled easily and hence, the proposed machine can achieve high flux-weakening capabilities for wide-speed range operations, which is one of the major criteria for RE-EV applications. The result confirms that the proposed machine can maintain constant power characteristics over the wide range of speeds. Particularly, with the DC-field excitations set at 1.5 A/mm2, the operating speed of the proposed machine is approximately 907 rpm. The result can cover the whole targeted speed range and fulfill the requirements of the Mode 2, the flux-weakening operation.
5.4. Performance of Mode 3—Fault-Tolerant Operation
Fifthly, when the DC-field excitation is cut off, the proposed machine can be operated with the unipolar conduction scheme and the corresponding torque performance is shown in Figure 14. The averaged torque and the torque ripple under the unipolar conduction scheme are 148.2 Nm and 40.1%, respectively. These confirm that even if DC-field excitation malfunctions, the proposed machine can still offer the same torque level for normal operation under the unipolar conduction scheme. Meanwhile, because only half of the torque producing zone is utilized, the torque ripple and the armature current densities are higher than those of the bipolar conduction operation. Furthermore, the efficiency at the fault-tolerant mode is lower than that of the normal operation mode. Hence, the unipolar operation should only be adopted for the Mode 3, fault-tolerant operation.
5.5. Performance of Mode 4—Battery Charging
Finally, Figure 15 shows the no-load EMF waveforms at various speeds under two situations, namely without and with flux regulation operations, respectively. Obviously, without any DC-field control, the amplitudes of the output voltages vary with the operating speeds. This unstable generated voltage is not favorable for charging the battery. Meanwhile, by purposely tuning the DC-field excitation, the output voltages can be kept constant over a wide range of speeds in order to fulfill the expectation of the Mode 4, the battery charging mode.
6. Comparisons among RF Machines
The performances of the proposed AF-DSDC machine are thoroughly analyzed by 3D-FEM, and summarized in Table 4.
Meanwhile, to further illustrate the merits of the proposed AF-DSDC machine, the profound RF machines, namely the RF-SR, RF-DSDC and RF-DSPM are also included [2,11,13], and as shown in Figure 16a–c, respectively. To have a fair comparison, all machines have the same machine dimensions, namely the radial outside diameters, radial inside diameters, axial stack lengths, and air-gap lengths. In addition, the winding factors and current densities are also equalized.
Based on the FEM, the performances of the RF machines are calculated and summarized in Table 5. As expected, the magnetless RF-SR uses only half of its torque producing period, leading to the worst performance in terms of the gravimetric and volumetric rated torque densities. Meanwhile, by utilizing all the torque producing periods, the RF-DSDC can offer better torque performances than the RF-SR machine. With the application of the radial part for torque production, the proposed AF-DSDC machine can offer much higher torque densities than the profound magnetless RF counterparts, and is comparable with the RF-DSPM.
Even though the RF-DSPM machine provides the highest torque densities and outperforms its magnetless counterparts, the supply of the PM materials is limited and irregular, resulting to the surged materials cost . To increase the market penetration of the RE-EV adoptions, the concept of the cost-effectiveness should also be considered. The materials costs of the machines are calculated based on the current market prices of the raw materials. Without any installation of PM materials, the proposed AF-DSDC machine achieves the best performance regarding cost-effectiveness among all the counterparts, and thus is particularly favorable for RE-EV applications. Meanwhile, discussions on the efficiency maps of all machines will be included in our future papers.
In this paper, a new magnetless AF-DSDC machine has been proposed and implemented for RE-EV applications. By adopting the radial active part for torque production, the proposed AF-DSDC machine offers better performance than its conventional RF counterparts do, especially from a cost-effectiveness perspective. The AF-DSDC machine is under prototyping and the experimental data will be the substance of our future papers. With the support of the external DC-field winding, the proposed machine can accomplish different operation modes, namely the torque boosting, flux-weakening, fault-tolerant and battery charging modes. Hence, it is anticipated that the proposed machine will have great potential for implementation into RE-EV systems.
This work was supported by a grant (Project No. HKU710612E) from the Hong Kong Research Grants Council, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- Ehsani, M.; Rahman, K.M.; Toliyat, H.A. Propulsion system design of electric and hybrid vehicles. IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron. 1997, 44, 19–27. [Google Scholar]
- Zhu, Z.Q.; Howe, D. Electrical machines and drives for electric, hybrid and fuel cell vehicles. IEEE Proc. 2007, 95, 746–756. [Google Scholar]
- Chau, K.T.; Chan, C.C.; Liu, C. Overview of permanent-magnet brushless drives for electric and hybrid electric vehicles. IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron. 2008, 55, 2246–2257. [Google Scholar]
- Hermance, D.; Sasaki, S. Hybrid electric vehicles take to the streets. IEEE Spectr. 1998, 35, 48–52. [Google Scholar]
- Chan, C.C. The state of the art of electric and hybrid vehicles. IEEE Proc. 2002, 90, 247–275. [Google Scholar]
- Ehsani, M.; Gao, Y.; Miller, J.M. Hybrid electric vehicles: Architecture and motor drives. IEEE Proc. 2007, 95, 719–728. [Google Scholar]
- Chau, K.T.; Chan, C.C. Emerging energy-efficient technologies for hybrid electric vehicles. IEEE Proc. 2007, 95, 821–835. [Google Scholar]
- Van Wieringen, M.; Pop-Iliev, R. Development of a dual-fuel power generation system for an extended range plug-in hybrid electric vehicle. IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron. 2010, 57, 641–648. [Google Scholar]
- Ott, T.; Onder, C.; Guzzella, L. Hybrid-electric vehicle with natural gas-diesel engine. Energies 2013, 6, 3571–3592. [Google Scholar]
- Cheng, M.; Hua, W.; Zhang, J.; Zhao, W. Overview of stator-permanent magnet brushless machines. IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron. 2011, 58, 5087–5101. [Google Scholar]
- Chau, K.T.; Li, W.; Lee, C.H.T. Challenges and opportunities of electric machines for renewable energy. Prog. Electromagn. Res. B 2012, 42, 45–74. [Google Scholar]
- Liu, C.; Chau, K.T.; Jiang, J.Z.; Niu, S. Comparison of stator-permanent-magnet brushless machines. IEEE Trans. Magn. 2008, 44, 4405–4408. [Google Scholar]
- Zhang, J.; Cheng, M.; Chen, Z.; Hua, W. Comparison of stator-mounted permanent-magnet machines based on a general power equations. IEEE Trans. Energy Convers. 2009, 24, 826–834. [Google Scholar]
- Liu, C.; Chau, K.T.; Jiang, J.Z. A permanent-magnet hybrid brushless integrated starter-generator for hybrid electric vehicles. IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron. 2010, 57, 4055–4064. [Google Scholar]
- Zheng, P.; Wu, F.; Lei, Y.; Sui, Y.; Yu, B. Investigation of a novel 24-slot/14-pole six-phase fault-tolerant modular permanent-magnet in-wheel motor for electric vehicles. Energies 2013, 6, 4980–5002. [Google Scholar]
- Li, J.; Chau, K.T. Performance and cost comparison of permanent-magnet Vernier machines. IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. 2012, 22. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Chen, M.; Chau, K.T.; Li, W.; Liu, C. Cost-effectiveness comparison of coaxial magnetic gears with different magnet materials. IEEE Trans. Magn. 2014, 50. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Liu, C.; Chau, K.T.; Zhong, J.; Li, J. Design and analysis of a HTS brushless doubly-fed doubly salient machine. IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. 2011, 21, 1119–1122. [Google Scholar]
- Lee, C.H.T.; Chau, K.T.; Liu, C. Electromagnetic design and analysis of magnetless double-rotor dual-mode machines. Prog. Electromagn. Res. 2013, 142, 333–351. [Google Scholar]
- Lee, C.H.T.; Chau, K.T.; Liu, C. Design and analysis of a new multitoothed magnetless doubly-salient machine. IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. 2014, 24. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Zhu, Z.Q. Switched Flux Permanent Magnet Machines-Innovation Continues. Proceedings of the International Conference on Electrical Machines and Systems (ICEMS), Beijing, China, 20–23 August 2011; pp. 1–10.
- Lee, C.H.T.; Chau, K.T.; Liu, C.; Wu, D.; Gao, S. Quantitative comparison and analysis of magnetless machine with reluctance topologies. IEEE Trans. Magn. 2013, 49, 3969–3972. [Google Scholar]
- Profumo, F.; Zhang, Z.; Tenconi, A. Axial flux machines drives: A new viable solution for electric cars. IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron. 1997, 44, 39–45. [Google Scholar]
- Ho, S.L.; Niu, S.; Fu, W.N. Design and analysis of a novel axial-flux electric machine. IEEE Trans. Magn. 2011, 47, 4368–4371. [Google Scholar]
- Madhavan, R.; Fernandes, B.G. Axial flux segmented SRM with a higher number of rotor segments for electric vehicles. IEEE Trans. Energy Convers. 2013, 28, 203–213. [Google Scholar]
- Zheng, P.; Song, Z.; Bai, J.; Tong, C.; Yu, B. Research on an axial magnetic-field-modulated brushless double rotor machine. Energies 2013, 6, 4799–4829. [Google Scholar]
- Olszewski, M. Evaluation of the 2010 Toyota Prius Hybrid Synergy Drive System; Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), U.S. Department Energy: Washington, DC, USA, 2011. [Google Scholar]
- Cao, R.; Mi, C.; Cheng, M. Quantitative comparison of flux-switching permanent-magnet motors with interior permanent magnet motor for EV, HEV, and PHEV applications. IEEE Trans. Magn. 2012, 48, 2374–2384. [Google Scholar]
- Yu, C.; Chau, K.T. New fault-tolerant flux-mnemonic doubly-salient permanent-magnet motor drive. IET Electr. Power Appl. 2011, 5, 393–403. [Google Scholar]
- Zheng, P.; Zhao, Q.; Bai, J.; Yu, B.; Song, Z.; Shang, J. Analysis and design of a transverse-flux dual rotor machine for power-split hybrid electric vehicle applications. Energies 2013, 6, 6548–6568. [Google Scholar]
- Wang, Y.; Chau, K.T.; Chan, C.C.; Jiang, J.Z. Transient analysis of a new outer-rotor permanent-magnet brushless dc drive using circuit-field-torque coupled time-stepping finite-element method. IEEE Trans. Magn. 2002, 38, 1297–1300. [Google Scholar]
|Peak DC voltage||360||V|
|Peak torque||130% for 10 s||-|
|Wheel dimension||195/65 R15||-|
|Radial outside diameter||381||mm|
|Radial inside diameter||100||mm|
|Axial stack length||195||mm|
|Air-gap length of both segments||0.5||mm|
|Number of stator poles of both segments||8||-|
|Number of rotor poles of both segments||10||-|
|Number of armature phases||4||-|
|Number of turns per armature coil||50||-|
|Rotor and stator material||Steel sheet: 50JN700 (JFE Steel Corporation, Tokyo, Japan)||-|
|Armature and DC-field winding material||Copper||-|
|Item||Winding 1||Winding 2|
|Rated current at bipolar conduction||10 A||10 A|
|Slope of DC flux-linkage KDC||1.04||1.04|
|Slope of self-inductance KSR||0.079||0.079|
|Rated current at unipolar conduction||22.9 A||22.9 A|
|Item||Bipolar conduction||Unipolar conduction|
|Rated Power||4.8 kW||4.6 kW|
|Power density||35.4 W/kg||33.8 W/kg|
|Operating frequency at base speed||50 Hz||50 Hz|
|No-load EMF of Winding 1||153 V||N/A|
|No-load EMF of Winding 2||153 V||N/A|
|Rated DC-field excitation||5 A/mm2||N/A|
|Rated torque||154.2 Nm||148.2 Nm|
|Torque ripple at rated torque||27.4%||40.1%|
|Cogging torque at rated torque||18.6 Nm||N/A|
|% Cogging torque at rated torque||12.1%||N/A|
|Boosted DC-field excitation||10 A/mm2||N/A|
|Boosted torque||203.2 Nm||N/A|
|Torque ripple at boosted torque||43.2%||N/A|
|Cogging torque at boosted torque||42.4 Nm||N/A|
|% Cogging torque at boosted torque||20.9%||N/A|
|Rated torque/mass||0.51 Nm/kg||0.61 Nm/kg||1.21 Nm/kg||1.13 Nm/kg|
|Rated torque/volume||4.12 kNm/m3||4.85 kNm/m3||9.51 kNm/m3||8.97 kNm/m3|
|Material cost||208.4 USD||209.8 USD||411.9 USD||239.5 USD|
|Rated torque/cost||0.34 Nm/USD||0.41 Nm/USD||0.39 Nm/USD||0.65 Nm/USD|
© 2014 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).