Synthesis and Crystal Structures of the Quaternary Zintl Phases RbNa8Ga3Pn6 (Pn = P, As) and Na10NbGaAs6
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Delaware, Newark, DE 19716, USA
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Crystals 2012, 2(2), 213-223; https://doi.org/10.3390/cryst2020213
Submission received: 21 December 2011
/
Revised: 27 March 2012
/
Accepted: 31 March 2012
/
Published: 11 April 2012
Abstract
:The new Zintl compounds RbNa8Ga3Pn6 (Pn = P, As) and Na10NbGaAs6 have been synthesized from the corresponding elements at high temperatures. RbNa8Ga3P6 and RbNa8Ga3As6 crystallize with a novel structure type that features trigonal planar [Ga3P6]9– and [Ga3As6]9– motifs, which are isosteric with the 1,3,5-trioxanetrione (a cyclic trimer of carbon dioxide). Na10NbGaAs6, an unforeseen side product of the same reactions boasts a structure, which is based on NbAs4 and GaAs4 tetrahedra, condensed by sharing common edges into [NbGaAs6]10– dimers. The bonding characteristics of both structures are discussed. All three compounds reported herein represent the first compounds found in the respective quaternary systems.
1. Introduction
In the past 10–15 years, intermetallic clathrates have attracted widespread interest, largely due to their demonstrated potential in thermoelectrics development [1,2,3,4]. Having successfully synthesized Rb7.3Na16Ga20Si116 and Cs8Na16Ga21Si115—the first clathrate-II compounds with mixed Ga and Si [5], as well as the first arsenic-based clathrates of type-I Rb8Zn18As28 and Cs8Cd18As28 [6], we extended our attention to the A-Ga-Pn systems (A = alkali metal or mixtures of alkali metals, Pn = pnictogen, i.e., group 15 element). Our motivation here was the idea to produce gallium-phosphide and/or gallium-arsenide clathrates (in analogy with the well-known III-V semiconductors, which are isoelectronic with Si and Ge), but so far, all synthetic efforts have failed to provide any evidence for the possible existence of such compounds. Instead, these experiments afforded a number of binary, ternary, and even quaternary compounds, some of which are with novel structures.
With this paper we detail the synthesis and the structural characterization of the new quaternary Zintl compounds RbNa8Ga3As6 and RbNa8Ga3P6, which are isoelectronic and isostructural. They crystallize with a novel orthorhombic structure type, featuring a somewhat unusual building block—[GaPn3]6− trigonal planar units (isosteric with the borate BO33−, as well as carbonate CO32− anions), which are cyclically trimerized into [Ga3Pn6]9− (isosteric with the metaborate anion B3O63−, as well as the 1,3,5-trioxanetrione, a cyclic trimer of carbon dioxide). We note here that while the ternary A-Tr-Pn (Tr = triel i.e., group 13 element) phase diagrams have already been extensively explored, and many A-Tr-Pn compounds have been reported [7,8,9,10,11,12], very little is known about the corresponding A'-A''-Tr-Pn systems, where A' and A'' are two different alkali metals. The newly identified RbNa8Ga3As6 and RbNa8Ga3P6 (formally A3TrPn2) underscore the utility of mixtures of chemically and spatially dissimilar cations for the discovery of new compounds with novel structures. On this note, we point out that the prevailing motifs in the structures of most ternary A-Tr-Pn compounds are [TrPn4]9− tetrahedra, either isolated or condensed in different fashions to form diverse polyanionic structures, e.g., ![Crystals 02 00213 i001]()
and ![Crystals 02 00213 i002]()
chains in Na3AlAs2 [7] and K3Al2As3 [8], respectively; ![Crystals 02 00213 i003]()
and ![Crystals 02 00213 i004]()
layers in K2Al2Sb3 [9] and K3Ga3As4 [10], respectively; and 3-D framework in Na9In3Bi6 structure [11]. Planar [Ga3As6]9−, [Ga3Sb6]9− and [Ga3Bi6]9− units, analogous to the ones described herein are known only for K20(Ga3As6)2As0.66 and K20(Ga3Sb6)2Sb0.66 [12]; and K20(Ga3Bi6)2Bi0.66 [11].
and 
chains in Na3AlAs2 [7] and K3Al2As3 [8], respectively; 
and 
layers in K2Al2Sb3 [9] and K3Ga3As4 [10], respectively; and 3-D framework in Na9In3Bi6 structure [11]. Planar [Ga3As6]9−, [Ga3Sb6]9− and [Ga3Bi6]9− units, analogous to the ones described herein are known only for K20(Ga3As6)2As0.66 and K20(Ga3Sb6)2Sb0.66 [12]; and K20(Ga3Bi6)2Bi0.66 [11].Reported as well is the new compound Na10NbGaAs6, which is isoelectronic and isostructural to K10NbInAs6 [13]. This phase was identified as an inadvertent product from the unwanted reaction of the reaction vessel (niobium) with elemental arsenic; its structure comprises NbAs4 and GaAs4 tetrahedra, edge-shared into [NbGaAs6]10− dimers, which are isosteric with diborane molecule, B2H6.
2. Results and Discussion
RbNa8Ga3As6 and RbNa8Ga3P6 both crystallize with the orthorhombic space group Pnma (No. 62, Pearson symbol oP72). The structure contains 18 independent sites in the asymmetric unit—one Rb, eight Na, three Ga, and six pnictogen atoms—all located at special position 4c. The structure can be viewed as being built from [Ga3Pn6]9− polyanions with alkali metal cations counterbalancing the charges and filling the space among them (Figure 1). The triangularly-shaped [Ga3Pn6]9− motif could be considered as a cyclic trimer of the [GaPn3]6− trigonal planar units, which form a 6-membered ring by sharing two of the Pn atoms from each [GaPn3]6−. Therefore, all three Ga atoms are 3-bonded, while the three Pn atoms on the 6-membered ring are 2-bonded and the three Pn atoms attaching to the ring are 1-bonded. The distances between Ga and the Pn atoms are all within the normal ranges for covalently bound Ga–As and Ga–P. For example, the Ga–As distances range from 2.335 to 2.422 Å; the Ga–P distances range from 2.245 to 2.337 Å (Table 1). These values compare very well with the sums of the corresponding covalent radii (rGa = 1.246 Å; rAs = 1.210 Å; rP = 1.10 Å) [14], as well as with the Ga–Pn distances found in compounds with Ga in similar 3-fold coordination environment of As or P (Table 2), e.g., dGa–As = 2.367 ÷ 2.426 Å in Rb2GaAs2 [15], dGa–As = 2.367 ÷ 2.442 Å in K20(Ga3As6)2As0.66 [12], and dGa–P = 2.226 ÷ 2.392 Å in Rb3GaP2 [16]. In general, the distances between Ga and the 2-bonded Pn are just about 0.08 Å longer than those between Ga and the 1-bonded Pn atom, which indicates that there is no appreciable π-bonding in the 6-membered ring. Hence, the formula RbNa8Ga3Pn6 represents a salt-like, electron-balanced Zintl phase [17]. According to the valence rules, the charges could be assigned as Rb+(Na+)8(Ga3+)3(Pn3–)6 based on oxidation states and counting the Ga and the Pn atoms as tri-valent species; alternatively, based on formal charges, the formula can be broken down to Rb+(Na+)8(3b-Ga0)3(2b-Pn1–)3(1b-Pn2–)3, where 2-bonded and 1-bonded Pn atoms carry different negative charges, consistent with the Zintl formalism.
Figure 1.
Crystal structure of RbNa8Ga3Pn6 (Pn = P, As).The different elements are color-coded as follows: Ga—green; Pn—orange; Rb—purple; and Na-grey. The covalent Ga–Pn bonds are emphasized as yellow-green cylinders.
Figure 1.
Crystal structure of RbNa8Ga3Pn6 (Pn = P, As).The different elements are color-coded as follows: Ga—green; Pn—orange; Rb—purple; and Na-grey. The covalent Ga–Pn bonds are emphasized as yellow-green cylinders.
Three-coordinated Ga (or a triel element in general) is much less common within the A-Tr-Pn compounds than the four-coordinated tetrahedral geometry, which appears to be the prevailing building block among such solids. Examples of borate-like (or carbonate-like) [TrPn3]6− units exist and can be exemplified by [InAs3]6− seen in the K6InAs3 structure [18]; [Ga2P4]6− found in the Rb3GaP2 structure [16] can be cited as an example of 4-membered rings formed via condensation of two [GaP3]6− units into [Ga2P4]6− dimers (isosteric with 1,3-Dioxetanedione). Higher oligomers, such as the cyclic trimers [Ga3Pn6]9− that present 6-membered rings are known in the K20(Ga3Pn6)2Pn0.66 structures [12] and in the structures of the title compounds. Since the [TrPn3]6− unit is a planar structural motif, it is not common for it to form structures in higher dimension. A search of the ICSD database only reveals ![Crystals 02 00213 i005]()
the chain found in the K2GaP2 type structure [19]. In this bonding arrangement, 5-memered rings are generated by sharing one common Pn and forming one Pn–Pn bond between every two [GaPn3]6– units—these 5-membered rings are further connected to form an infinite chain using the third Pn atom as a linker (Figure 2).
the chain found in the K2GaP2 type structure [19]. In this bonding arrangement, 5-memered rings are generated by sharing one common Pn and forming one Pn–Pn bond between every two [GaPn3]6– units—these 5-membered rings are further connected to form an infinite chain using the third Pn atom as a linker (Figure 2). 
| RbNa8Ga3As6 | RbNa8Ga3P6 | RbNa8Ga3As6 | RbNa8Ga3P6 | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ga1– | Pn1 | 2.335(1) | 2.245(2) | Na3– | Pn2 | 3.015(3) | 2.935(3) | |
| Pn2 | 2.388(1) | 2.303(2) | Pn3 (×2) | 3.235(2) | 3.158(2) | |||
| Pn3 | 2.400(1) | 2.312(2) | Pn5 (×2) | 3.270(2) | 3.213(2) | |||
| Ga2– | Pn4 | 2.351(1) | 2.259(2) | Ga3 (×2) | 3.270(2) | 3.216(2) | ||
| Pn2 | 2.383(1) | 2.300(2) | Na4– | Ga2 (×2) | 3.336(2) | 3.260(2) | ||
| Pn6 | 2.391(1) | 2.309(2) | Ga3 (×2) | 3.346(2) | 3.257(2) | |||
| Ga3– | Pn5 | 2.351(1) | 2.259(2) | Ga1 (×2) | 3.364(2) | 3.282(2) | ||
| Pn3 | 2.418(1) | 2.329(2) | Pn3 (×2) | 3.375(2) | 3.265(2) | |||
| Pn6 | 2.422(1) | 2.337(2) | Pn6 (×2) | 3.416(2) | 3.314(2) | |||
| Pn1– | Ga1 | 2.335(1) | 2.245(2) | Pn2 (×2) | 3.500(2) | 3.401(2) | ||
| Pn2– | Ga1 | 2.388(1) | 2.303(2) | Na5– | Pn3 | 2.967(3) | 2.892(3) | |
| Ga2 | 2.383(1) | 2.300(2) | Pn2 (×2) | 3.190(2) | 3.116(2) | |||
| Pn3– | Ga1 | 2.400(1) | 2.312(2) | Pn4 (×2) | 3.338(2) | 3.278(2) | ||
| Ga3 | 2.418(1) | 2.329(2) | Ga2 (×2) | 3.296(2) | 3.244(2) | |||
| Pn4– | Ga2 | 2.351(1) | 2.259(2) | Na6– | Pn4 | 2.970(3) | 2.882(3) | |
| Pn5– | Ga3 | 2.351(1) | 2.259(2) | Pn1 (×2) | 3.211(2) | 3.126(2) | ||
| Pn6– | Ga2 | 2.391(1) | 2.309(2) | Pn3 (×2) | 3.386(2) | 3.328(2) | ||
| Ga3 | 2.422(1) | 2.337(2) | Ga1 (×2) | 3.240(2) | 3.181(2) | |||
| Rb– | Pn1 (×2) | 3.5491(9) | 3.487(1) | Na7– | Pn5 | 3.019(3) | 2.933(3) | |
| Pn6 (×2) | 3.5929(9) | 3.523(1) | Pn1 (×2) | 3.209(2) | 3.134(2) | |||
| Pn5 (×2) | 3.6975(9) | 3.623(1) | Pn2 (×2) | 3.343(2) | 3.280(2) | |||
| Ga3 (×2) | 3.735(1) | 3.6707(8) | Ga1 (×2) | 3.284(2) | 3.227(2) | |||
| Na1– | Pn5 (×2) | 2.992(2) | 2.931(2) | Na8– | Pn4 | 2.967(3) | 2.874(3) | |
| Pn1 | 3.018(3) | 2.965(3) | Pn4 (×2) | 3.239(2) | 3.176(2) | |||
| Pn5 | 3.117(3) | 3.051(3) | Pn6 (×2) | 3.330(2) | 3.250(2) | |||
| Na2– | Pn4 (×2) | 2.967(2) | 2.909(2) | Ga2 (×2) | 3.245(2) | 3.183(2) | ||
| Pn1 | 2.970(3) | 2.911(3) | ||||||
| Pn6 | 3.069(3) | 3.008(3) |
| RbNa8Ga3As6 | RbNa8Ga3P6 | RbNa8Ga3As6 | RbNa8Ga3P6 | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pn1-Ga1-Pn2 | 115.89(4) | 116.42(7) | Pn5-Ga3-Pn3 | 113.79(4) | 114.48(7) | |||
| Pn1-Ga1-Pn3 | 119.19(4) | 119.78(7) | Pn5-Ga3-Pn6 | 124.65(4) | 125.05(7) | |||
| Pn2-Ga1-Pn3 | 124.92(4) | 123.81(7) | Pn3-Ga3-Pn6 | 121.56(4) | 120.47(7) | |||
| Pn4-Ga2-Pn2 | 114.31(4) | 114.77(7) | Ga2- Pn2-Ga1 | 113.01(4) | 114.04(8) | |||
| Pn4-Ga2-Pn6 | 117.77(4) | 118.39(7) | Ga1- Pn3-Ga3 | 117.57(4) | 118.85(8) | |||
| Pn2-Ga2-Pn6 | 127.93(4) | 126.84(7) | Ga2- Pn6-Ga3 | 115.01(4) | 115.98(7) | |||
Figure 2.
Diverse structural motifs based on the [TrPn3]6− unit (Tr = triel, Pn = pnictogen).
As we already mentioned, there are nine crystallographically different cations in the RbNa8Ga3Pn6 structure and they have subtly different coordination environments. The large Rb cation is coordinated to six pnictogen atoms that form trigonal prism, with Rb–Pn distances falling in the range from 3.549 to 3.698 Å for Rb–As, and from 3.487 to 3.623 Å for Rb–P (Table 1). Two Ga atoms are found at a little longer distance, enlarging the Rb first coordination sphere to the shape of a quadrilateral prism (Figure 3). Three different local environments could be found for Na: Na1 and Na2 are found in a tetrahedral surrounding of four pnictogen atoms; square pyramids formed by five next-nearest pnictogen atoms are observed for Na3, Na5, Na6, Na7, and Na8—notice that the bases of the square-pyramids are capped by two Ga atoms, enlarging the coordination number to 7; and a hexagonal prism for Na4, where each hexagonal base is formed by three Ga and three Pn atoms. The Na–Pn distances fall into a very wide range due to the different coordination numbers (CN) for Na, with the shortest Na–Pn distance noted for 4-coordinated Na, and the longest Na–Pn distance found for the 12-coordinated Na (Table 1).
Figure 3.
Cation coordination in RbNa8Ga3Pn6. The polyhedron around Rb is shown in purple (a); Na1 and Na2 in light blue (b); Na3, Na5, Na6, Na7, and Na8 in dark blue (c); and Na4 in olive (d). See text for details.
Figure 3.
Cation coordination in RbNa8Ga3Pn6. The polyhedron around Rb is shown in purple (a); Na1 and Na2 in light blue (b); Na3, Na5, Na6, Na7, and Na8 in dark blue (c); and Na4 in olive (d). See text for details.
Figure 4.
Side-by-side comparison of the cation packing in the crystal structures of K20(Ga3As6)2As0.66 and RbNa8Ga3As6, where the trigonal prisms formed by the cations are emphasized. Different shades represent the different heights in the projected directions. The corresponding elements are color-coded as follows: Ga—green;Pn—orange; K—light blue; Rb—purple; and Na—grey. The covalent Ga–As bonds and the unit cells are outlined too.
Figure 4.
Side-by-side comparison of the cation packing in the crystal structures of K20(Ga3As6)2As0.66 and RbNa8Ga3As6, where the trigonal prisms formed by the cations are emphasized. Different shades represent the different heights in the projected directions. The corresponding elements are color-coded as follows: Ga—green;Pn—orange; K—light blue; Rb—purple; and Na—grey. The covalent Ga–As bonds and the unit cells are outlined too.
As already noted, the [Ga3Pn6]9− 6-membered motif is not without a precedent, having been reported for some time already in K20(Ga3Pn6)2Pn0.66 (defect Ho6Ni20P13 structure type, Pearson symbol hP39) [11,12]. However, in the latter hexagonal structure, in addition to the [Ga3Pn6]9− polyanions, there are isolated Pn3− anions (note the partial occupancy of this site). Apparently, a single cation like K+ cannot pack well enough with the [Ga3Pn6]9− polyanions, requiring some subtle rearrangements to accommodate the counterbalancing Pn3− anions. Following the notion of describing the structure from the standpoint of cation packing, in analogy with what has already been presented for K20(Ga3Pn6)2Pn0.66 [12], one can see that the cation arrangements in both cases are actually very similar. From Figure 4, it can be seen that in both structures, apart from the partially occupied Pn atoms in the K20(Ga3Pn6)2Pn0.66 structure, which reside in large hexagonal channels, all Ga and Pn atoms are at the centers of trigonal prisms formed by the cations. Nine such trigonal prisms are conjoined, forming a much larger prism that encloses the entire [Ga3Pn6]9− unit. The difference is that in K20(Ga3Pn6)2Pn0.66, these larger trigonal prisms can be noted as discrete components, while in RbNa8Ga3Pn6 (=Rb2Na16(Ga3Pn6)2, i.e., two cations less per formula) they further connect with each other along the a axis by sharing Rb atoms (Figure 4). It seems that the much bigger Rb brings the necessary distortion to the larger trigonal prisms, which leads to a slightly different packing of the cations compared with K20(Ga3Pn6)2Pn0.66.
Na10NbGaAs6 crystallizes with the monoclinic space group P21/n (No. 14, Pearson symbol mP36), and is found to be isoelectronic and isostructural to the Zintl compound K10NbInAs6 [13]. The structure is composed of isolated dimers of edge-shared tetrahedra (NbAs4 or GaAs4), which are isosteric with diborane, B2H6. These dimeric units are separated by the alkali metal cations (Figure 5). Note that there is only one tetrahedral site in the structure, which is co-occupied by Ga and Nb in equal amounts. In the earlier paper on K10NbInAs6, a diamagnetic response from the magnetic susceptibility of the compound can be inferred, suggesting the Nb to be assigned as Nb5+ (i.e., d0 closed-shell species) [13]. This argument allows for the structure to be rationalized readily as (K+)10Nb5+In3+(As3–)6. Clearly, the same approach will be applicable to Na10NbGaAs6 (e.g., (Na+)10Nb5+Ga3+(As3–)6), which means that it can be classified as a Zintl compound with a transition metal [13,20].
Figure 5.
(a)Crystal structure of Na10NbGaAs6, viewed along the a axis; (b) representation of [(As)2Nb(μ-As)2Ga(As)2]10– with thermal ellipsoids, drawn at the 95% probability. The atoms at the centers of the tetrahedra of As atoms are statistically distributed Nb and Ga. The corresponding elements are color-coded as follows: Ga/Nb—light blue; As—orange; and Na—grey.
Figure 5.
(a)Crystal structure of Na10NbGaAs6, viewed along the a axis; (b) representation of [(As)2Nb(μ-As)2Ga(As)2]10– with thermal ellipsoids, drawn at the 95% probability. The atoms at the centers of the tetrahedra of As atoms are statistically distributed Nb and Ga. The corresponding elements are color-coded as follows: Ga/Nb—light blue; As—orange; and Na—grey.
| Nb/Ga– | As3 | 2.4855(6) | As3-Nb/Ga-As2 | 114.20(2) |
| As2 | 2.4959(6) | As3-Nb/Ga-As1 | 108.68(2) | |
| As1 | 2.5274(6) | As2-Nb/Ga-As1 | 113.79(2) | |
| As1 | 2.5645(6) | As3-Nb/Ga-As1 | 111.17(2) | |
| As2-Nb/Ga-As1 | 106.78(2) | |||
| As1-Nb/Ga-As1 | 101.49(2) |
The Nb/Ga–;As distances fall in the range of 2.4855(6) to 2.5645(6) Å, and all of the As-Nb/Ga-As angles are close to the ideal tetrahedral angle 109°28' (Table 3). An examination of the structures of some compounds with ordered GaAs4 and NbAs4 tetrahedra reveals similar lengths for the Ga–As and Nb–As bonds. For example, the Ga–As bonds range from 2.444 to 2.556 Å in K3Ga3As4 [9], and from 2.435 to 2.599 Å in Na2Ga2As3 [21], respectively. The Nb–As distances, as reported for K38Nb7As24 [22] fall in the range of 2.444–2.571 Å; very similar values for dNb-As are seen in Cs9Nb2As6 (2.464–2.592 Å) [22]. Since the established ranges for the Nb–As and Ga–As distances are similar, refinements of the thermal ellipsoids in Na10NbGaAs6 do not show any abnormal behavior—in fact they are virtually spherical. This is not the case for K10NbInAs6, where the significant difference between the lengths of the Nb–As and In–As bonds gives rise to characteristic features in their thermal ellipsoids—the thermal ellipsoids of the bridging As atoms are elongated tangentially to the central square (Nb/In-As-Nb/In-As). This observation has been considered as a key evidence of these dimers being heteroatomic [(As)2Nb(µ-As)2In(As)2] species, and not an equimolar mixture of [(As)2Nb(µ-As)2Nb(As)2] and [(As)2In(µ-As)2In(As)2] dimers [13].
3. Experimental Section
All the manipulations involving alkali metals were performed either inside an argon-filled glove box or under vacuum. The starting materials were elemental Rb, Na, Ga, As, and P, either from Alfa Aesar or Aldrich with the stated purity higher than 99.9%. Crystals of RbNa8Ga3As6 were first identified from a reaction starting with Na/Rb/Ga/As with a molar ratio of 16/8/80/56, which was originally attempted for type II clathrate Na16Rb8Ga80As56. The elements with a total mass of ca. 500 mg were loaded into a niobium ampoule, which was subsequently arc-welded under high purity Ar and then jacketed in a fused silica tube under vacuum. The reaction mixture was heated up to 550 °C, and equilibrated for one week before it was slowly cooled to room temperature. This experiment resulted in black, small crystals of RbNa8Ga3As6, which were found to be extremely air-sensitive and had to be handled with great care. After the composition was established, the reaction was repeated with the correct stoichiometry. However, besides RbNa8Ga3As6, Na10NbGaAs6, which formed from a side reaction with the Nb container, was also identified. This observation indicated that Nb containers were not well suited for such reactions; more expensive Ta or Mo tubes should be considered. RbNa8Ga3P6 could be synthesized from the same setup as well as the same heat treatment, with the coexistence of another known Zintl compound, Na6GaP3 [23].
The crystal structures of the title compounds were established using single-crystal X-ray diffraction with a Bruker SMART CCD-based diffractometer (monochromated Mo Kα1 radiation). Crystals with suitable dimensions (<100 µm) were mounted on glass fiber with Paratone-N oil, and then quickly transferred to the goniometer of the diffractometer. A cold nitrogen stream (200(2) K) was used to keep the crystals at low temperature as well as to protect them from being oxidized. Full spheres of data were collected in four batch runs with a frame width of 0.4° for ω and θ. Integration of the intensity data was done with the SAINT program [24], and semi-empirical absorption correction based on equivalents was applied with the SADABS code [25]. The structures were solved by direct method and refined to convergence by full matrix least squares on F2 using the SHELXTL package [26]. The unit cell axes and the atomic coordinates of RbNa8Ga3Pn6 were standardized with the aid of the Structure TIDY [27] in the last refinement cycles.
The structure refinements for Na10NbGaAs6 required some specific attention. In this structure, the tetrahedrally coordinated site was originally assigned as Ga, which is a common coordination environment for it. However, the thermal displacement parameter in this situation was unreasonably small. Based on the discussion on K10NbInAs6 structure, the model that this site was co-occupied by Ga and Nb was considered, where Nb was from the reaction vessel. Such refinement lead to nearly half and half occupancy of Ga and Nb, i.e., 49% Ga and 51% Nb. Thus, the ratio was fixed at 1:1 in the final refinement cycle, which resulted in R1 values as low as 0.0263 and reasonable thermal ellipsoids.
Selected crystal data and refinement parameters are given in Table 4; important bond distances and angles are listed in Table 1,Table 2,Table 3. CIFs have also been deposited with the Fachinformationszentrum Karlsruhe, 76344 Eggenstein-Leopoldshafen, Germany, (fax: (49) 7247-808-666; Email: [email protected])—depository numbers CSD-423946 for RbNa8Ga3As6, CSD-423947 for RbNa8Ga3P6, and CSD-423948 for Na10NbGaAs6.
Table 4.
Selected crystal data and structure refinement parameters for RbNa8Ga3Pn6 (Pn = As, P) and Na10NbGaAs6.
| Empirical formula | RbNa8Ga3As6 | RbNa8Ga3P6 | Na10NbGaAs6 | |
| Formula weight | 928.07 | 664.37 | 842.05 | |
| Space group, Z | Pnma (No. 62), 4 | Pnma (No. 62), 4 | P21/n (No. 14), 2 | |
| Temperature | 200(2) K | |||
| Wavelength | Mo Kα, 0.71073 Å | |||
| Cell parameters | a (Å) | 22.843(6) | 22.276(3) | 8.3243(7) |
| b (Å) | 4.7892(12) | 4.6947(6) | 7.5173(6) | |
| c (Å) | 16.861(4) | 16.356(2) | 13.546(2) | |
| β(°) | 90.908(1)° | |||
| V (Å3) | 1844.6(8) | 1710.4(4) | 847.58(12) | |
| Calculated density (g/cm3) | 3.342 | 2.580 | 3.299 | |
| Absorption coefficient (cm−1) | 178.14 | 82.52 | 141.13 | |
| Crystal size (mm3) | 0.070 × 0.030 × 0.025 | 0.050 × 0.030 × 0.030 | 0.060 × 0.055 × 0.035 | |
| Reflections collected/independent | 24813/2575 | 22860/2382 | 10644/1948 | |
| Rint | 0.0888 | 0.0954 | 0.0528 | |
| Goodness-of-fit on F2 | 1.031 | 1.104 | 1.006 | |
| R1 (I > 2σI)a | 0.0326 | 0.0410 | 0.0263 | |
| w R2 (I > 2σI)a | 0.0521 | 0.0625 | 0.0464 | |
| Largest diff. peak/hole (e–/Å3) | 1.164/−0.928 | 0.802/−0.880 | 0.751/−0.578 | |
| Weight coefficient, A/Ba | 0.0163/0 | 0.0109/1.1965 | 0.0176/0 | |
a R1 = Σ | |Fo| – |Fc| |/Σ|Fo|, wR2 = {Σ[w(Fo2 − Fc2)2]/Σ[w(Fo2)2]}1/2, where w = 1/[σ2Fo2 + (AP)2 + BP], and P = (Fo2 + 2Fc2)/3. A and B are weight coefficients.
4. Conclusions
Quaternary compounds RbNa8Ga3Pn6 (Pn = P, As) and Na10NbGaAs6 have been synthesized and characterized. These findings suggest that although many ternary compounds of the alkali and alkaline-earth metals with the triels and the pnictogen elements have already been discovered, still little is known about the corresponding systems with two types of cations. Such seemingly trivial approaches can be the key for the synthesis of many more new compounds with novel structures.
Acknowledgments
Svilen Bobev acknowledges financial support from the US Department of Energy through a grant (DE-SC0001360).
References
- Blake, N.P.; Mollnitz, L.; Kresse, G.; Metiu, H. Why Clathrates are Good Thermoelectrics: A Theoretical Study of Sr8Ga16Ge30. J. Chem. Phys. 1999, 111, 3133–3144. [Google Scholar]
- Kuznetsov, V.L.; Kuznetsova, L.A.; Kaliazin, A.E.; Rowe, D.M. Preparation and Thermoelectric Properties of A8IIB16IIIB30IV Clathrate Compounds. J. Appl. Phys. 2000, 87, 7871–7875. [Google Scholar]
- Sales, B.C.; Chakoumakos, B.C.; Jin, R.; Thompson, J.R.; Mandrus, D. Structural, Magnetic, Thermal, and Transport Properties of X8Ga16Ge30 (X = Eu, Sr, Ba) Single Crystals. Phys. Rev. B 2001, 63, 245113. [Google Scholar]
- Saramat, A.; Svensson, G.; Palmqvist, A.E.C.; Stiewe, C.; Mueller, E.; Platzek, D.; Williams, S.G.K.; Rowe, D.M.; Bryan, J.D.; Stucky, G.D. Large Thermoelectric Figure of Merit at High Temperature in Czochralski-Grown Clathrate Ba8Ga16Ge30. J. Appl. Phys. 2006, 99, 023708. [Google Scholar]
- Bobev, S.; Meyers, J., Jr.; Fritsch, V.; Yamasaki, Y. Synthesis and Structural Characterization of Novel Clathrate-II Compounds of Silicon. In Proceedings of 25th International Conference on Thermoelectrics 2006 (ICT’06), Vienna, Austria, 6-10 August 2006; IEEE: NewYork, NY, USA, 2006; 25, pp. 48–52. [Google Scholar]
- He, H.; Tyson, C.; Bobev, S. Unpublished Results. Unpublished Results. University of Delaware: Newark, DE 19716, USA, 2012; 2012. [Google Scholar]
- Cordier, G.; Ochmann, H. Na3AlAs2, a Zintl Phase with SiS2-Isosteric Anions. Z. Naturforsch. 1988, 43, 1538–1540. [Google Scholar]
- Cordier, G.; Ochmann, H.; Schaefer, H. New Types of Al2As3-Chains in K3Al2As3. Rev. Chim. Miner. 1985, 22, 58–63. [Google Scholar]
- Cordier, G.; Ochmann, H.; Schaefer, H. Na2Al2Sb3 and K2Al2Sb3, Two New Zintl Phases with Layered Anions. Rev. Chim. Miner. 1984, 21, 282–291. [Google Scholar]
- Birdwhistell, T.L.T.; Stevens, E.D.; O’Connor, C.J. Synthesis and Crystal Structure of a Novel Layered Zintl Phase: K3Ga3As4. Inorg. Chem. 1990, 29, 3892–3894. [Google Scholar]
- Bobev, S.; Sevov, S.C. Five Ternary Zintl Phases in the Systems Alkali-Metal-Indium-Bismuth. J. Solid State Chem. 2001, 163, 436–448. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Cordier, G.; Ochmann, H. K20Ga6Sb12.66 and K20Ga6As12.66, Compounds with (Ga3Sb6)9- Anion and (Ga3As6)9- Anion Isostructural to (B3O6)3−. Z. Naturforsch. 1990, 45, 277–282. [Google Scholar]
- Gascoin, F.; Sevov, S.C. Synthesis and Characterization of Transition Metal Zintl phases: K10NbInAs6 and K9Nb2As6. Inorg. Chem. 2003, 42, 904–907. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Pauling, L. The Nature of the Chemical Bond, 3 ed; Cornell University Press: Ithaca, NY, USA, 1960; pp. 400–404. [Google Scholar]
- Cordier, G.; Ochmann, H. Crystal Structure of Dirubidium Catena-Diarsenidogallate, Rb2GaAs2. Z. Kristallogr. 1991, 195, 113–114. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Somer, M.; Peters, K.; Thiery, D.; von Schnering, H.G. Crystal Structure of Trirubidium Diphosphidogallate, Rb3GaP2. Z. Kristallogr. 1990, 192, 271–272. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Zintl, E. Internietallische Verbindungen. Angew. Chem. 1939, 52, 1–6. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Blase, W.; Cordier, G.; Somer, M. Crystal Structure of Hexapotassium Triarsenidoindate, K6InAs3. Z. Kristallogr. 1993, 206, 141–142. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Blase, W.; Cordier, G.; Somer, M. Crystal Structure of Dipotassium Catena-Diphosphidogallate, K2GaP2. Z. Kristallogr. 1991, 195, 115–116. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Kauzlarich, S.M. Transition Metal Zintl Compounds. In Chemistry, Structure, and Bonding of Zintl Phases and Ions; Kauzlarich, S.M., Ed.; VCH: New York, NY, USA, 1996; pp. 245–274. [Google Scholar]
- Cordier, G.; Ochmann, H. Crystal Structure of Disodium Phyllo-triarsenidodigallate, Na2Ga2As3. Z. Kristallogr. 1991, 197, 285–286. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Gascoin, F.; Sevov, S.C. Synthesis and Characterization of K38Nb7As24 and Cs9Nb2As6. Inorg. Chem. 2002, 41, 5920–5924. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Blase, W.; Cordier, G.; Somer, M. Crysal Structure of Hexasodium Triphosphidogallate, Na6GaP3. Z. Kristallogr. 1993, 206, 143–144. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- SMART & SAINT; Bruker Analytical X-ray Systems, Inc.: Madison, WI, USA, 2003.
- Sheldrick, G.M. SADABS; University of Göttingen: Göttingen, Germany, 2003. [Google Scholar]
- Sheldrick, G.M. SHELXTL; University of Göttingen: Göttingen, Germany, 2001. [Google Scholar]
- Gelato, L.M.; Parthe, E. Structure Tidy—a Computer Program to Standardize Crystal Structure Data. J. Appl. Crystallogr. 1987, 20, 139–146. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
© 2012 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open-access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).
Share and Cite
MDPI and ACS Style
He, H.; Tyson, C.; Bobev, S. Synthesis and Crystal Structures of the Quaternary Zintl Phases RbNa8Ga3Pn6 (Pn = P, As) and Na10NbGaAs6. Crystals 2012, 2, 213-223. https://doi.org/10.3390/cryst2020213
AMA Style
He H, Tyson C, Bobev S. Synthesis and Crystal Structures of the Quaternary Zintl Phases RbNa8Ga3Pn6 (Pn = P, As) and Na10NbGaAs6. Crystals. 2012; 2(2):213-223. https://doi.org/10.3390/cryst2020213
Chicago/Turabian StyleHe, Hua, Chauntae Tyson, and Svilen Bobev. 2012. "Synthesis and Crystal Structures of the Quaternary Zintl Phases RbNa8Ga3Pn6 (Pn = P, As) and Na10NbGaAs6" Crystals 2, no. 2: 213-223. https://doi.org/10.3390/cryst2020213
