*Article* **The Potential of Tram Networks in the Revitalization of the Warsaw Landscape**

**Jan Łukaszkiewicz <sup>1</sup> , Beata Fortuna-Antoszkiewicz <sup>1</sup> , Łukasz Oleszczuk <sup>2</sup> and Jitka Fialová 3,\***


**Abstract:** The current crisis of worldwide agglomeration and economic, spatial, and ownership factors, among others, mean that there is usually a shortage of new green areas, which are socially very beneficial. Therefore, various brownfields or degraded lands along public transport routes, e.g., tram lanes, are effectively transformed for this purpose. The significant potential of tram systems is that they can became a backbone of green corridors across the city. This case study of the Warsaw tram system (total length over 300 km of single tracks in service in 2019) enables us to simulate the potential growth of a biologically active area connected with an increasing share of greenery around tram lanes in Warsaw. Experience allows the authors to present the types of greenery systems based on existing and future tram corridors best suited for this city. The suggested usage of tram lanes as green corridors is in line with the generally-accepted concept of urban green infrastructure. Therefore, the aim of the authors is to present in a condensed fashion their views on a very important issue within the program of the revitalization of the Warsaw landscape by converting where possible the existing tram lines, as well as planning new ones according to the "green point of view".

**Keywords:** cityscape visual perception; green infrastructure; linear parks; sustainable landscape planning; tram lanes; Warsaw

#### **1. Introduction**

Warsaw, Poland's capital, has a unique character as it was almost totally destroyed during the German occupation (the World War II period). Reconstruction of its infrastructure took decades and still is not complete. In addition, progression of the town's growth could not be based on the development of the existing structure, including the transportation system. The authors strongly believe that the growing demand for moving masses of people around the city is best fulfilled by the modernization and construction of the tram lines.

In the last few decades, there has been a fundamental change in the concept of designing tramway networks all over the world [1–5]. Concerning trams, passenger and environmentally friendly solutions are introduced by increasing accessibility, improving travel efficiency, and reducing energy consumption, thus reducing environmental costs [1–8]. The use of the multi-factor analysis method at each level of tram route planning and extensive promotional and information campaigns cause tramways to receive more and more social attention, as does the involvement of future passengers in the open debate at the design analysis stage (e.g., [5,7–11]). In this context, it is no exaggeration to say that the tramway as a form of public transport becomes a stimulus for developing and revitalizing cities [4,12]. Despite the multitude of solutions used in different countries, there are some similarities between them. One worth noting is the adaptation of degraded,

**Citation:** Łukaszkiewicz, J.; Fortuna-Antoszkiewicz, B.; Oleszczuk, Ł.; Fialová, J. The Potential of Tram Networks in the Revitalization of the Warsaw Landscape. *Land* **2021**, *10*, 375. https://doi.org/10.3390/ land10040375

Academic Editors: Alessio Russo and Giuseppe T. Cirella

Received: 26 February 2021 Accepted: 1 April 2021 Published: 4 April 2021

**Publisher's Note:** MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

**Copyright:** © 2021 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/).

fragmented, and marginalized space around buildings and elements of technical infrastructure within tram routes, and incorporating them again into the urban composition [1,2,4,5]. By introducing linear green systems accompanying tram lanes (insulating, ecological, and decorative functions) and new publicly accessible places for recreation and relaxation, a new quality in urban planning is achieved, which is also particularly important for the social quality during the COVID-19 pandemic [13–16]. logical, and decorative functions) and new publicly accessible places for recreation and relaxation, a new quality in urban planning is achieved, which is also particularly important for the social quality during the COVID-19 pandemic [13–16]. The crisis of urban and industrial agglomerations observed worldwide at the turn of the 21st century manifested itself in several severe dysfunctions. Therefore, in the 21st century, there is a growing need to transform cities towards restoring the urban land-

some similarities between them. One worth noting is the adaptation of degraded, fragmented, and marginalized space around buildings and elements of technical infrastructure within tram routes, and incorporating them again into the urban composition [1,2,4,5]. By introducing linear green systems accompanying tram lanes (insulating, eco-

*Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 2 of 24

The crisis of urban and industrial agglomerations observed worldwide at the turn of the 21st century manifested itself in several severe dysfunctions. Therefore, in the 21st century, there is a growing need to transform cities towards restoring the urban landscape's harmony and improving the inhabitants' living conditions. Among others, a skillful transformation with a humanistic approach to the entire complex cultural and natural structure of the urban fabric is needed (e.g., [17–22]). Phenomena such as the intensified global migration of people to cities (ca. 5.0 billion in 2030) [7], rising energy prices, and the degradation of the environment and landscapes—a light-hearted instrumental approach to natural resources [23]—overlap with the already existing various shortcomings of the existing functional and spatial solutions in cities, such as the density of buildings in city centers or the phenomenon of "urban sprawl" [13,14,20,22,24]. scape's harmony and improving the inhabitants' living conditions. Among others, a skillful transformation with a humanistic approach to the entire complex cultural and natural structure of the urban fabric is needed (e.g., [17–22]). Phenomena such as the intensified global migration of people to cities (ca. 5.0 billion in 2030) [7], rising energy prices, and the degradation of the environment and landscapes—a light-hearted instrumental approach to natural resources [23]—overlap with the already existing various shortcomings of the existing functional and spatial solutions in cities, such as the density of buildings in city centers or the phenomenon of "urban sprawl" [13,14,20,22,24]. One of the ever-present problems is the inadequate development of urban public transport systems, which must continuously be adapted to the arising social needs in

One of the ever-present problems is the inadequate development of urban public transport systems, which must continuously be adapted to the arising social needs in terms of quality and efficiency (e.g., [1,4,16,25–27]). It is already estimated that urban transport systems worldwide have such a significant impact on the environment that they are responsible for 20–25% of global energy consumption, CO<sup>2</sup> emissions to the atmosphere, gaseous pollutants (e.g., polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons—PAHs), and dust (e.g., particulate matter—PM) [27–35]. For these reasons, urban transport based on private cars and diesel buses is gradually becoming a thing of the past [2,3,6,9]. The future of urban passenger transport involves four areas that are developing very rapidly: electrification, autonomy, connectivity, and sharing [8]. terms of quality and efficiency (e.g., [1,4,16,25–27]). It is already estimated that urban transport systems worldwide have such a significant impact on the environment that they are responsible for 20–25% of global energy consumption, CO2 emissions to the atmosphere, gaseous pollutants (e.g., polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons—PAHs), and dust (e.g., particulate matter—PM) [27–35]. For these reasons, urban transport based on private cars and diesel buses is gradually becoming a thing of the past [2,3,6,9]. The future of urban passenger transport involves four areas that are developing very rapidly: electrification, autonomy, connectivity, and sharing [8]. In line with the concept of "sustainable transport", which is increasingly used all over

In line with the concept of "sustainable transport", which is increasingly used all over the world and is part of "smart cities" of the future, the aim is to create a public transport systems with a balanced impact on society, the environment, and climate [5,36]. There are attempts to combine specific engineering solutions, such as linear technical infrastructure with vegetation (e.g., green tram routes—Figure 1), aimed at crossing the border between the artificial and the natural in order to improve the quality of life on a social scale [20,21,37]. However, this is not a simple task, because it is known that urban mobility has two faces; on the one hand, it creates and stimulates economic growth, and on the other, it can also generate undesirable social, spatial, and environmental effects [3,4]. the world and is part of "smart cities" of the future, the aim is to create a public transport systems with a balanced impact on society, the environment, and climate [5,36]. There are attempts to combine specific engineering solutions, such as linear technical infrastructure with vegetation (e.g., green tram routes—Figure 1), aimed at crossing the border between the artificial and the natural in order to improve the quality of life on a social scale [20,21,37]. However, this is not a simple task, because it is known that urban mobility has two faces; on the one hand, it creates and stimulates economic growth, and on the other, it can also generate undesirable social, spatial, and environmental effects [3,4].

**Figure 1.** Tram lines as "green corridors" in the urban structure "smart city". Source: Smart City Blog, 29 June 2017 [38]. **Figure 1.** Tram lines as "green corridors" in the urban structure "smart city". Source: Smart City Blog, 29 June 2017 [38].

Simultaneously, urban planning formulates hypotheses (which have been confirmed many times in the past) that linear structures of public transport systems may support the revitalization of dysfunctional urban areas. Depending on the adopted priorities, strategies, and local spatial development policy, it is assumed that revitalizing activities will be concentrated along selected linear structures, necessary for the city and with a wide spatial range. It shall help connect the city's internal districts and bind the peripheries closer with the center [2,4,9,12,39]. For example, in the last several decades in urban planning in Europe and various regions of the world, a very positive, relatively new, and growing phenomenon has been observed, consisting of strengthening the integration of built-up areas thanks to the presence of tram systems [1,4,5,39].

Therefore, this publication makes a hypothesis that the tram—a necessary and environmentally friendly form of urban public transport—is a crucial urban tool enabling the simultaneous integration of dysfunctional and dispersed parts of the city and—no less important—an essential catalyst for a thorough restructuring of urban green systems and public urban spaces. This applies particularly to Warsaw, where very difficult and complex geological conditions make development of an underground transport system a very costly and time-consuming task.

This publication aims to present the importance and potential of a tram network for the reconstruction and development of the transport infrastructure in Warsaw. At the same time, based on the examples of other European cities that did not have as traumatic a past as Warsaw and that have developed in an evolutionary way, this paper tries to delineate how—drawing on the contemporary canons of sustainable development—the right proportions can be achieved in the design of the urban tram route surroundings, taking into account functional (optimum connection), environmental (resource enrichment), and landscape (the city's image) aspects.

#### **2. Materials and Methods**

The identification of the issues and the formulation of the main goals of the research allowed us to starting the first stage of work. An extensive literature search was conducted to compile examples of tram systems playing a key role on transformation of urban space. Combinations of keywords including "urban", "city", "tram lanes", "tramways", "revitalization", "green infrastructure", and "linear parks" were used in searching three online literature databases, including Scopus, ISI Web of Knowledge, and Google Scholar.

Issues identified during the literature review were divided synthetically in two major thematic groups:


The data collected at this stage of the research was from both the literature and the authors' own professional, scientific, and practical experience concerning the design and development of the tramway system in Warsaw. Such an example is the study and development concept of a tram route linking the Gocław and Saska K˛epa districts in Warsaw, which consisted of elaboration of different initial variants of spatial solutions, and then open social consultations and elaborations of the final design.

The analysis of collected data allowed us to state that tram systems are an extremely vital tool for the revitalization of urbanized spaces, especially when they are combined with linear green systems (e.g., concerning remediation abilities of plants and the influence of green structures on air filtration in the city). This fact is of great importance not only for urban environments but, what is more crucial, for the urban society and the quality of life.

At the final stage of the work, the data collected from the literature and as part of the authors' own research formed the basis for the actual design work, enabling the development of a theoretical model for the transformation of the city tram system that would fit the specific conditions of Warsaw.

In general, it is a kind of forecast for the quantitative and qualitative development of a linear greenery layout associated with the city tram system. This form of presentation of the results of the authors' experiments was to show, in a model manner, selected aspects of designing the green forms in the vicinity of tram routes, based on the facts (collected and processed data). Case studies are an adequate and convenient scientific method used successfully in research in the fields of architecture, urban planning, and landscape architecture.

The obtained results in the form of estimated quantitative and qualitative indicators were compared synthetically with the literature in the discussion. On this basis, the final conclusions from the research were formulated.

#### **3. Results—The Potential of Warsaw's Tram Network**

Tram transport is very common in EU cities. Trams are a key part of EU public transportation, which is responsible for an annual rate of some 50 billion passengers (in 2018) [40]. All the major EU capitals have retained their original tram networks from the 19th century. Some of these networks have been upgraded to light rail standards, called Stadtbahn in Germany, premetros in Belgium, sneltram in the Netherlands, elétrico in Portugal, and fast trams in some other countries. Many city tramway networks extend over municipal boundaries. The city tram has always been efficient and one of the most environmentally-friendly forms of city mass transportation. It is competitive and resourceefficient, and it is typically characterized by low-carbon emissions. As an electric vehicle (EV), unlike other road transport means, it does not emit exhaust gases into the atmosphere, and its durability is many times greater than, for example, a city bus fleet [6]. In terms of the emissions of fine particulate matter (PM 2.5), which poses a great threat to human health and life, a tram is undoubtedly the least harmful compared to a bus (diesel engine) or even an underground [28,29,31,41]. Such transport, like low-emission trams, is one of elements of the traffic sector of the *Zero Pollution Action Plan* draft by the European Commission. The European Green Deal highlights the need for transport to become drastically less polluting in urban areas, emphasizing the importance of a combination of measures aimed at reducing emissions, mitigating urban congestion, and improving public transport options. The tramway as a form of public urban transport seems to be a perfect match for these expectations [16,25–27].

In Poland, tram networks are present in 14 cities. In 2018, the total length of tram lines in the country reached 2338.0 km (Table 1). Concerning individual Polish provinces (in 2016), the greatest length of tram lines was found in Silesia (405 km) and the second greatest in Masovia (363 km), of which Warsaw has the greatest share (Figure 2) [42].

**Table 1.** The total length of tram lines in Poland (km) changing in subsequent years (31 December 2019). Source of data: Statistical Yearbook of the Republic of Poland 2019 [43], compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz, 2021.


*Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 5 of 24

**Figure 2.** Trams in Poland in 2016—the total length (km) of tram lines in individual provinces (2408 km in total). Source of data: Statistics Poland [43,44], compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz, 2021. **Figure 2.** Trams in Poland in 2016—the total length (km) of tram lines in individual provinces (2408 km in total). Source of data: Statistics Poland [43,44], compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz, 2021. (2408 km in total). Source of data: Statistics Poland [43,44], compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz, 2021. Concerning the introduction of green tram lanes, the Polish tradition in this matter

Concerning the introduction of green tram lanes, the Polish tradition in this matter dates back to the 1930s (Figure 3). Unfortunately, the catastrophic World War II and the following 45 years of communism caused this interesting idea to abandoned for many years, and the first solutions of this type were introduced again only at the end of the 1990s. Fifteen years later, in 2014, green lanes were present in 9 out of 14 Polish cities with tramway transportation systems [42,45]. The estimated average balance of the length of green lanes was only 3.6% then (most in Warsaw (4.0%) and Poznań (4.6%)), which accounted for approximately 66.5 km of the total length of the Polish tram network (ca. Concerning the introduction of green tram lanes, the Polish tradition in this matter dates back to the 1930s (Figure 3). Unfortunately, the catastrophic World War II and the following 45 years of communism caused this interesting idea to abandoned for many years, and the first solutions of this type were introduced again only at the end of the 1990s. Fifteen years later, in 2014, green lanes were present in 9 out of 14 Polish cities with tramway transportation systems [42,45]. The estimated average balance of the length of green lanes was only 3.6% then (most in Warsaw (4.0%) and Pozna´n (4.6%)), which accounted for approximately 66.5 km of the total length of the Polish tram network (ca. 1855.0 km) (Figure 4) [46,47]. dates back to the 1930s (Figure 3). Unfortunately, the catastrophic World War II and the following 45 years of communism caused this interesting idea to abandoned for many years, and the first solutions of this type were introduced again only at the end of the 1990s. Fifteen years later, in 2014, green lanes were present in 9 out of 14 Polish cities with tramway transportation systems [42,45]. The estimated average balance of the length of green lanes was only 3.6% then (most in Warsaw (4.0%) and Poznań (4.6%)), which accounted for approximately 66.5 km of the total length of the Polish tram network (ca. 1855.0 km) (Figure 4) [46,47].

1855.0 km) (Figure 4) [46,47].

**Figure 3.** Poland, Łódź, T. Kościuszko Avenue, 1930s/1940s (?)—a tram track in a spectacular floral setting, defining an already existing representative and recreational space (photo: author unknown, private collection). **Figure 3.** Poland, Łódź, T. Kościuszko Avenue, 1930s/1940s (?)—a tram track in a spectacular floral setting, defining an already existing representative and recreational space (photo: author unknown, private collection). **Figure 3.** Poland, Łód´z, T. Ko´sciuszko Avenue, 1930s/1940s (?)—a tram track in a spectacular floral setting, defining an already existing representative and recreational space (photo: author unknown, private collection).

Regarding Warsaw, introducing vegetation into streets and along tram tracks is not only a recent story. At the end of the 19th century, Warsaw used widespread greening and decorating of the streets with trees, lawns, and ornamental flower beds. Stefan Starzy ´nski, the then distinguished president of Warsaw, transformed the capital into a modern European city under the slogan "Warsaw in flowers and greenery". The widespread introduction

of vegetation served to raise the overall aesthetics, but it was also a way to improve the living conditions in this extensive and populous city. "...Greenery in the city is a matter of the health of the population. After all, health is the most precious human treasure..." [48] Thus, new parks and squares were established, and trees and vines were planted en masse along the streets together with flower beds and lawns. The lawns were also used for green tram tracks. "...In central districts, where compact buildings made it impossible to establish larger uniform units of greenery, efforts were made to exploit squares, roadways, and streets by establishing a significant number of new green areas and green belts, and by tree-lining several streets and introducing grass into tram tracks..." [49]. These were highly innovative activities, interrupted by the outbreak of World War II. *Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 6 of 24

**Figure 4.** Poland, Katowice, W. Grassy tram lane along Kofranty Avenue. Photo: B. Fortuna-Antoszkiewicz, IV 2016. **Figure 4.** Poland, Katowice, W. Grassy tram lane along Kofranty Avenue. Photo: B. Fortuna-Antoszkiewicz, IV 2016.

Regarding Warsaw, introducing vegetation into streets and along tram tracks is not only a recent story. At the end of the 19th century, Warsaw used widespread greening and decorating of the streets with trees, lawns, and ornamental flower beds. Stefan Starzyński, the then distinguished president of Warsaw, transformed the capital into a modern European city under the slogan "Warsaw in flowers and greenery". The widespread introduction of vegetation served to raise the overall aesthetics, but it was also a way to improve the living conditions in this extensive and populous city. "...Greenery in the city is a matter of the health of the population. After all, health is the most precious In the second half of the 20th century, while rebuilding the city destroyed by war, efficient public transport was organized, including tram lines, which have been successfully used to this day. Main streets and important new arteries were given a carefully arranged floral settings. The accompanying linear spatial systems were arranged with rows of trees, hedges, and lawns [50,51]. Thanks to this, spatial order was introduced, and insulation and protection zones were consciously shaped, improving the city's climate and increasing street users' safety (Figure 5). Due to technological reasons, the greening of the tracks was abandoned in favor of lawns in parallel strips (Figure 6). *Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 7 of 24

human treasure..." [48] Thus, new parks and squares were established, and trees and vines

**Figure 5.** Cross-sections of streets with tram lanes surrounded by trees and greenery—standard **Figure 5.** Cross-sections of streets with tram lanes surrounded by trees and greenery—standard from the 1950s [51].

**Figure 6.** Warsaw, 1950s. The newly arranged J. Marchlewskiego Avenue (currently Jana Pawła II Avenue)—a separate inner lane with a tram line surrounded by greenery (lawns with hedges) and regular rows of young trees on both sides of the road. Photo: Z. Siemaszko, collection: National

Currently in Warsaw, around 70 years later, only fragmentary arrangements remain (dismal remnants !!!) of the old projects. Along with the development of car traffic, parking spaces appeared in place of gradually dying trees and degraded lawns in many cases. Such depletion of natural resources is particularly acute in the city center, where the process of building densification has been progressing over the last decades, often at the expense of small green enclaves (squares, undeveloped areas), and there the green track becomes a solution. Tramlines penetrate the highly urbanized center, making it possible

At present (data from 2019) the length of green tram lanes in Warsaw has reached 25.0 km with a total length of approx. 433.0 km of tracks [46]. When renovating and constructing new tram routes, the Warsaw Trams have started to introduce green lanes as standard, implementing them both on concrete and ballast foundations [47] (Figures 7 and

to introduce a collision-free network of linear greenery [42,46,53,54].

from the 1950s [51].

Digital Archives [52].

8).

from the 1950s [51].

**Figure 6.** Warsaw, 1950s. The newly arranged J. Marchlewskiego Avenue (currently Jana Pawła II Avenue)—a separate inner lane with a tram line surrounded by greenery (lawns with hedges) and regular rows of young trees on both sides of the road. Photo: Z. Siemaszko, collection: National Digital Archives [52]. **Figure 6.** Warsaw, 1950s. The newly arranged J. Marchlewskiego Avenue (currently Jana Pawła II Avenue)—a separate inner lane with a tram line surrounded by greenery (lawns with hedges) and regular rows of young trees on both sides of the road. Photo: Z. Siemaszko, collection: National Digital Archives [52].

**Figure 5.** Cross-sections of streets with tram lanes surrounded by trees and greenery—standard

Currently in Warsaw, around 70 years later, only fragmentary arrangements remain (dismal remnants !!!) of the old projects. Along with the development of car traffic, parking spaces appeared in place of gradually dying trees and degraded lawns in many cases. Such depletion of natural resources is particularly acute in the city center, where the process of building densification has been progressing over the last decades, often at the expense of small green enclaves (squares, undeveloped areas), and there the green track becomes a solution. Tramlines penetrate the highly urbanized center, making it possible Currently in Warsaw, around 70 years later, only fragmentary arrangements remain (dismal remnants !!!) of the old projects. Along with the development of car traffic, parking spaces appeared in place of gradually dying trees and degraded lawns in many cases. Such depletion of natural resources is particularly acute in the city center, where the process of building densification has been progressing over the last decades, often at the expense of small green enclaves (squares, undeveloped areas), and there the green track becomes a solution. Tramlines penetrate the highly urbanized center, making it possible to introduce a collision-free network of linear greenery [42,46,53,54].

to introduce a collision-free network of linear greenery [42,46,53,54]. At present (data from 2019) the length of green tram lanes in Warsaw has reached 25.0 km with a total length of approx. 433.0 km of tracks [46]. When renovating and constructing new tram routes, the Warsaw Trams have started to introduce green lanes as At present (data from 2019) the length of green tram lanes in Warsaw has reached 25.0 km with a total length of approx. 433.0 km of tracks [46]. When renovating and constructing new tram routes, the Warsaw Trams have started to introduce green lanes as standard, implementing them both on concrete and ballast foundations [47] (Figures 7 and 8). *Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 8 of 24

**Figure 7.** Reconstruction of a tram line, Rakowiecka Street, Warsaw. Photo: J. Łukaszkiewicz, III 2015. **Figure 7.** Reconstruction of a tram line, Rakowiecka Street, Warsaw. Photo: J. Łukaszkiewicz, III 2015.

The apparent advantage of green tram lanes today is the reduction of the noise level during the tram operation, the improvement of ecological aspects—increase in biologically effective urban areas—and the improved aesthetic experience of streets in cities [45]. In addition, skillfully-applied greenery allows the sound level from traffic to be reduced by 10.0 to 15.0 dB. This shows how much the sound level of the direct wave emitted by a tram decreases when the side of the tram lane is planted with large deciduous trees. The values of additional attenuation by the green belt range from 0.10 to 0.25 dB/m, depending on its type and configuration. A series of narrower belts produce more damping than one belt of the same width combined. The first lane, up to 50.0 m wide, is always the most

**Figure 8.** Reconstruction of a tram line—laying a lawn, Rakowiecka Street, Warsaw. Photo: J.

spectrum shape by dispersing and absorbing high-frequency components [55–61].

Additionally, vegetation reduces the speed of rising and falling of the sound level, which reduces the annoyance of noise [62]. According to various studies carried out in different conditions, the scope of noise reduction varies, but the share of the vegetation itself, especially high vegetation, remains unchallenged in this process. Therefore, instead of building acoustic screens in every situation, it is better to plant dense trees, which are incomparably more favorable for environmental and aesthetic reasons [63] (Figures 9 and

The apparent advantage of green tram lanes today is the reduction of the noise level during the tram operation, the improvement of ecological aspects—increase in biologically effective urban areas—and the improved aesthetic experience of streets in cities [45]. In addition, skillfully-applied greenery allows the sound level from traffic to be reduced by 10.0 to 15.0 dB. This shows how much the sound level of the direct wave emitted by a tram decreases when the side of the tram lane is planted with large deciduous trees. The values of additional attenuation by the green belt range from 0.10 to 0.25 dB/m, depending on its type and configuration. A series of narrower belts produce more damping than one belt of the same width combined. The first lane, up to 50.0 m wide, is always the most critical. Tree belts with dense shrubs suppress noise by approx. 3.0 dB for every 30.0 m of width. Even a band of vegetation with a negligible acoustic attenuation changes the noise

Łukaszkiewicz, V 2015.

10).

critical. Tree belts with dense shrubs suppress noise by approx. 3.0 dB for every 30.0 m of width. Even a band of vegetation with a negligible acoustic attenuation changes the noise spectrum shape by dispersing and absorbing high-frequency components [55–61]. **Figure 7.** Reconstruction of a tram line, Rakowiecka Street, Warsaw. Photo: J. Łukaszkiewicz, III 2015.

*Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 8 of 24

**Figure 8.** Reconstruction of a tram line—laying a lawn, Rakowiecka Street, Warsaw. Photo: J. Łukaszkiewicz, V 2015. **Figure 8.** Reconstruction of a tram line—laying a lawn, Rakowiecka Street, Warsaw. Photo: J. Łukaszkiewicz, V 2015.

The apparent advantage of green tram lanes today is the reduction of the noise level during the tram operation, the improvement of ecological aspects—increase in biologically effective urban areas—and the improved aesthetic experience of streets in cities [45]. In addition, skillfully-applied greenery allows the sound level from traffic to be reduced by 10.0 to 15.0 dB. This shows how much the sound level of the direct wave emitted by a tram decreases when the side of the tram lane is planted with large deciduous trees. The values of additional attenuation by the green belt range from 0.10 to 0.25 dB/m, depending Additionally, vegetation reduces the speed of rising and falling of the sound level, which reduces the annoyance of noise [62]. According to various studies carried out in different conditions, the scope of noise reduction varies, but the share of the vegetation itself, especially high vegetation, remains unchallenged in this process. Therefore, instead of building acoustic screens in every situation, it is better to plant dense trees, which are incomparably more favorable for environmental and aesthetic reasons [63] (Figures 9 and 10). *Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 24

on its type and configuration. A series of narrower belts produce more damping than one

**Figure 9.** Single trees along the tram tracks—the remains of protective plantings from the 1960s, Warsaw, Puławska Street. Photo: Warsaw Trams, Llc., 2020 [64]. **Figure 9.** Single trees along the tram tracks—the remains of protective plantings from the 1960s, Warsaw, Puławska Street. Photo: Warsaw Trams, Llc., 2020 [64].

In the years 2017–2020, the authors conducted research in Warsaw, aiming to identify the condition of city tram lines in terms of their quantity (length in km), their location (spatial context), and the form of the surrounding development (e.g., green or technical lanes). The obtained data show that as of 31 December 2019, the length of the single tracks reached 303.3 km (kmst—km of single tracks) (The measurement unit is 1.0 running meter of a single track (mst) or 1.0 running kilometer of a single track (kmst) [65]) including the following:

In the years 2017–2020, the authors conducted research in Warsaw, aiming to identify the condition of city tram lines in terms of their quantity (length in km), their location (spatial context), and the form of the surrounding development (e.g., green or technical lanes). The obtained data show that as of 31 December 2019, the length of the single tracks reached 303.3 km (kmst—km of single tracks) (The measurement unit is 1.0 running meter of a single track (mst) or 1.0 running kilometer of a single track (kmst) [65]) including the

• separated tracks—211.2 kmst; including green lanes with vegetation cover—approx.

• not separated tracks available for cars, busses, and emergency vehicles—52.6 kmst

Tramlines in Warsaw connect distant districts, mainly on the north-south and eastwest axes (on both sides of the Vistula river), and they are concentrated within the city

• utility tracks in depots—39.5 kmst;

• utility tracks in depots—39.5 kmst;

• tracks used by passenger traffic—263.8 kmst.

following:

25.5 kmst;

[65].

• tracks used by passenger traffic—263.8 kmst.

Tracks applied for passenger traffic include the following:

Tracks applied for passenger traffic include the following:

center with a high density of high-rise buildings (Figure 11).


*Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 24

**Figure 10.** Trees in a row at the tram-track, Warsaw, 2019. Photo: J. Bernacki [53]. **Figure 10.** Trees in a row at the tram-track, Warsaw, 2019. Photo: J. Bernacki [53].

In the years 2017–2020, the authors conducted research in Warsaw, aiming to identify the condition of city tram lines in terms of their quantity (length in km), their location (spatial context), and the form of the surrounding development (e.g., green or technical Tramlines in Warsaw connect distant districts, mainly on the north-south and eastwest axes (on both sides of the Vistula river), and they are concentrated within the city center with a high density of high-rise buildings (Figure 11). *Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 10 of 24

**Figure 11.** Diagram of the tram system in Warsaw with the central zone of the city. Compiled by P. Wiśniewski, 2021. **Figure 11.** Diagram of the tram system in Warsaw with the central zone of the city. Compiled by P. Wi´sniewski, 2021.

In recent years, the Warsaw tram lines have been modernized, including the introduction of vegetation cover (turf or herbaceous plants). Currently, such green tracks account for approx. 8.0% of the total length of all tram lines in service, and approx. 12.1% in the category of separated tracks (as specified above) applied for passenger traffic. The green tracks are covered with turf or herbaceous vegetation from genera such as *Sempervivum* L. or *Sedum* L. (Figures 12–18). In recent years, the Warsaw tram lines have been modernized, including the introduction of vegetation cover (turf or herbaceous plants). Currently, such green tracks account for approx. 8.0% of the total length of all tram lines in service, and approx. 12.1% in the category of separated tracks (as specified above) applied for passenger traffic. The green tracks are covered with turf or herbaceous vegetation from genera such as *Sempervivum* L. or *Sedum* L. (Figures 12–18).

**Figure 12.** Warsaw: Grochowska Street, Praga district. The vegetation cover of tracks, mainly of *Sempervivum* L. and *Sedum* L. species—a very ornamental green carpet with extensive mainte-

nance. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65].

*vivum* L. or *Sedum* L. (Figures 12–18).

*vivum* L. or *Sedum* L. (Figures 12–18).

P. Wiśniewski, 2021.

P. Wiśniewski, 2021.

**Figure 12.** Warsaw: Grochowska Street, Praga district. The vegetation cover of tracks, mainly of *Sempervivum* L. and *Sedum* L. species—a very ornamental green carpet with extensive maintenance. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65]. **Figure 12.** Warsaw: Grochowska Street, Praga district. The vegetation cover of tracks, mainly of *Sempervivum* L. and *Sedum* L. species—a very ornamental green carpet with extensive maintenance. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65]. **Figure 12.** Warsaw: Grochowska Street, Praga district. The vegetation cover of tracks, mainly of *Sempervivum* L. and *Sedum* L. species—a very ornamental green carpet with extensive maintenance. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65].

**Figure 11.** Diagram of the tram system in Warsaw with the central zone of the city. Compiled by

**Figure 11.** Diagram of the tram system in Warsaw with the central zone of the city. Compiled by

*Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 10 of 24

In recent years, the Warsaw tram lines have been modernized, including the introduction of vegetation cover (turf or herbaceous plants). Currently, such green tracks account for approx. 8.0% of the total length of all tram lines in service, and approx. 12.1% in the category of separated tracks (as specified above) applied for passenger traffic. The green tracks are covered with turf or herbaceous vegetation from genera such as *Semper-*

In recent years, the Warsaw tram lines have been modernized, including the introduction of vegetation cover (turf or herbaceous plants). Currently, such green tracks account for approx. 8.0% of the total length of all tram lines in service, and approx. 12.1% in the category of separated tracks (as specified above) applied for passenger traffic. The green tracks are covered with turf or herbaceous vegetation from genera such as *Semper-*

**Figure 13.** Warsaw: Grochowska Street, Praga district. The vegetation cover of tracks, mainly of *Sempervivum* L. and *Sedum* L. species—the *Vicia cracca* visible in the middle as the ruderal species indicates the beginning of seminatural plant succession. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65]. **Figure 13.** Warsaw: Grochowska Street, Praga district. The vegetation cover of tracks, mainly of *Sempervivum* L. and *Sedum* L. species—the *Vicia cracca* visible in the middle as the ruderal species indicates the beginning of seminatural plant succession. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65].

**Figure 14.** Warsaw: Puławska Street, Mokotów district. Smooth, grassy track cover gives a representative appearance to the main streets of the city. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65]. **Figure 14.** Warsaw: Puławska Street, Mokotów district. Smooth, grassy track cover gives a representative appearance to the main streets of the city. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65].

**Figure 15.** Warsaw: Puławska Street, Mokotów district. Smooth, grassy track cover gives a representative appearance to the main streets of the city. Photo shared with permission: Tramwaje War-

**Figure 16.** Warsaw: Rakowiecka Street, Mokotów district. The grassy track cover after mowing

during summer. Photo: J. Łukaszkiewicz, VIII 2016 [65].

szawskie Llc., 2020 [65].

Trams Llc., 2020 [65].

Trams Llc., 2020 [65].

Llc., 2020 [65].

**Figure 15.** Warsaw: Puławska Street, Mokotów district. Smooth, grassy track cover gives a representative appearance to the main streets of the city. Photo shared with permission: Tramwaje Warszawskie Llc., 2020 [65]. **Figure 15.** Warsaw: Puławska Street, Mokotów district. Smooth, grassy track cover gives a representative appearance to the main streets of the city. Photo shared with permission: Tramwaje Warszawskie Llc., 2020 [65]. **Figure 15.** Warsaw: Puławska Street, Mokotów district. Smooth, grassy track cover gives a representative appearance to the main streets of the city. Photo shared with permission: Tramwaje Warszawskie Llc., 2020 [65].

**Figure 13.** Warsaw: Grochowska Street, Praga district. The vegetation cover of tracks, mainly of *Sempervivum* L. and *Sedum* L. species—the *Vicia cracca* visible in the middle as the ruderal species indicates the beginning of seminatural plant succession. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw

**Figure 13.** Warsaw: Grochowska Street, Praga district. The vegetation cover of tracks, mainly of *Sempervivum* L. and *Sedum* L. species—the *Vicia cracca* visible in the middle as the ruderal species indicates the beginning of seminatural plant succession. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw

*Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 11 of 24

**Figure 14.** Warsaw: Puławska Street, Mokotów district. Smooth, grassy track cover gives a representative appearance to the main streets of the city. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams

**Figure 14.** Warsaw: Puławska Street, Mokotów district. Smooth, grassy track cover gives a representative appearance to the main streets of the city. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams

**Figure 16.** Warsaw: Rakowiecka Street, Mokotów district. The grassy track cover after mowing during summer. Photo: J. Łukaszkiewicz, VIII 2016 [65]. **Figure 16.** Warsaw: Rakowiecka Street, Mokotów district. The grassy track cover after mowing during summer. Photo: J. Łukaszkiewicz, VIII 2016 [65]. **Figure 16.** Warsaw: Rakowiecka Street, Mokotów district. The grassy track cover after mowing during summer. Photo: J. Łukaszkiewicz, VIII 2016 [65]. *Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 12 of 24

**Figure 17.** Warsaw: Zieleniecka Avenue, Praga district. Grassy tram lane nearby National Stadium is accomplished with a low hedge and a row of street trees on the left. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65]. **Figure 17.** Warsaw: Zieleniecka Avenue, Praga district. Grassy tram lane nearby National Stadium is accomplished with a low hedge and a row of street trees on the left. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65].

**Figure 18.** Warsaw: A. Mickiewicza Street, Żoliborz district. Grassy tram lane lined with rows of

The presented general data show that ca. 185.7 km of single tram tracks in Warsaw can be potentially transformed into a biologically active surface with turf or herbaceous vegetation cover. Some of these tracks run in separate corridors along the streets or independently across areas excluded for traffic, which offers the opportunity to introduce additional accompanying greenery (insulation and protective belts—one or double sided) of

Considering diverse spatial conditions and possible plant arrangements (different configurations of trees and shrubs connected with more or less extensive grassy areas), the authors introduced several model versions of natural protection zones (Figures 19– 21). Linear vegetation belts make it possible to create insulation barriers of various densities of trees and shrubs, and in the broadest version—even to create structures like linear

1 The model assumes the hypothetical development of a track section, 100.0 m long, with a parallel linear strip of land of the same length; the purpose of developing the

street trees on both sides. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65].

parks, available for direct use (added recreational function).

*3.1. The Model—Detailed Assumptions* 

various widths.

sion: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65].

**Figure 18.** Warsaw: A. Mickiewicza Street, Żoliborz district. Grassy tram lane lined with rows of street trees on both sides. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65]. **Figure 18.** Warsaw: A. Mickiewicza Street, Zoliborz district. Grassy tram lane lined with rows of ˙ street trees on both sides. Photo shared with permission: Warsaw Trams Llc., 2020 [65]. mosaic pattern. 5 It is assumed that the tram track itself has a green cover, i.e., grassy or herbaceous

vegetation; the use of large trees (height > 10.0 m, Ø 7.0 m), smaller trees (height <

**Figure 17.** Warsaw: Zieleniecka Avenue, Praga district. Grassy tram lane nearby National Stadium is accomplished with a low hedge and a row of street trees on the left. Photo shared with permis-

The presented general data show that ca. 185.7 km of single tram tracks in Warsaw can be potentially transformed into a biologically active surface with turf or herbaceous vegetation cover. Some of these tracks run in separate corridors along the streets or independently across areas excluded for traffic, which offers the opportunity to introduce additional accompanying greenery (insulation and protective belts—one or double sided) of various widths. The presented general data show that ca. 185.7 km of single tram tracks in Warsaw can be potentially transformed into a biologically active surface with turf or herbaceous vegetation cover. Some of these tracks run in separate corridors along the streets or independently across areas excluded for traffic, which offers the opportunity to introduce additional accompanying greenery (insulation and protective belts—one or double sided) of various widths. 10.0 m, Ø 5.0 m), large shrubs (Ø 2.0 m), and lawns is assumed. *3.2. Model—Various Solutions*  Version 1. Development of the area along the tram route in the form of a green barrier—a compact insulating green belt (regular triangular spacing, approx. 90% of the land area coverage); estimated numbers of plants in individual categories were calculated

Considering diverse spatial conditions and possible plant arrangements (different configurations of trees and shrubs connected with more or less extensive grassy areas), the authors introduced several model versions of natural protection zones (Figures 19– 21). Linear vegetation belts make it possible to create insulation barriers of various densities of trees and shrubs, and in the broadest version—even to create structures like linear parks, available for direct use (added recreational function). Considering diverse spatial conditions and possible plant arrangements (different configurations of trees and shrubs connected with more or less extensive grassy areas), the authors introduced several model versions of natural protection zones (Figures 19–21). Linear vegetation belts make it possible to create insulation barriers of various densities of trees and shrubs, and in the broadest version—even to create structures like linear parks, available for direct use (added recreational function). (large trees, h > 10.0 m/crown Ø approx. 7.0 m; smaller trees h < 10.0 m/crown Ø approx. 5.0 m; large shrubs Ø approx. 2.0 m) for a strip of land with a length of 100.0 m. The width of the insulating green belt is a multiplication of the green double track width (Tr = 6.8 m); in the adopted version, the maximum width reaches the triple width of tracks lane exceeding 20.0 m and may be increased as far as possible and necessary, in accordance with the principle presented in the model (Figure 19).

**Figure 19.** Model—Version 1: Land development along the tram route (one-sided intake)—a compact insulating green belt (regular triangular spacing, approx. 90% of the land area coverage). On the left: green tram route cross-section with dimensions—the pictogram after [66]. Compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz. **Figure 19.** Model—Version 1: Land development along the tram route (one-sided intake)—a compact insulating green belt (regular triangular spacing, approx. 90% of the land area coverage). On the left: green tram route cross-section with dimensions—the pictogram after [66]. Compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz.

5.0 m; large shrubs Ø approx. 2.0 m) for a strip of land with a length of 100.0 m.

accordance with the principle presented in the model (Figure 20).

Version 2. Development of the area along the tram route in the form of a green barrier—a medium-dense insulating green belt (regular square spacing, approx. 80% of the land area coverage); estimated numbers of plants in individual categories were calculated (large trees, h > 10.0 m/crown Ø approx. 7.0 m; smaller trees h < 10.0 m/crown Ø approx.

The width of the insulating green belt is a multiplication of the green double track width (Tr = 6.8 m); in the adopted version, the maximum width reaches the triple width of tracks lane exceeding 20.0 m and may be increased as far as possible and necessary, in

**Figure 20.** Model—Version 2: Land development along the tram route (one-sided intake)—a medium-dense insulating green belt (regular triangular spacing, approx. 80% of the land area coverage). On the left: green tram route cross-section with dimensions—the pictogram after [66]. Compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz. **Figure 20.** Model—Version 2: Land development along the tram route (one-sided intake)—a medium-dense insulating green belt (regular triangular spacing, approx. 80% of the land area coverage). On the left: green tram route cross-section with dimensions—the pictogram after [66]. Compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz. *Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 15 of 24

**Figure 21.** Model—Version 3: The linear park. Land development along the tram route with nonregular open forms of high and low greenery, providing for possible recreational use; the required width of the linear park must be at least 3x Tr. On the left: green tram route cross-section with dimensions—the pictogram after [66]. Compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz. **Figure 21.** Model—Version 3: The linear park. Land development along the tram route with non-regular open forms of high and low greenery, providing for possible recreational use; the required width of the linear park must be at least 3x Tr. On the left: green tram route cross-section with dimensions—the pictogram after [66]. Compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz.

#### Currently, green tram lanes in Warsaw provide approx. 8.9 ha of biologically active *3.1. The Model—Detailed Assumptions*


**Total area of parks (ha) 502.24** 

There is still approx. a total length of 185.7 kmst (single tram tracks) in Warsaw potentially suitable for transformation into green lanes. If at least some of these resources are available for direct use (after excluding "technical" sections, i.e., intersections, viaducts,

• the introduction of low vegetation cover (lawns or herbaceous plants) using only 50% of the resources of available single track length (approx. 92.85 km) with the meannarrow version of track spacing (width of approx. 3.5 m) allows obtaining approx. 32.5 ha of biologically active area in total; connecting it with the area of already existing green tracks allows 41.4 ha of biologically active area to be obtained in the scale

• the possibility of introducing additional protection green belts along the tram lanes using only 20% of available 185.7 kmst of single track length (due to restrictions resulting from spatial or technical conditions), gives approx. 37.14 km length of tracks in total; green belts of such a length and approx. 6.8 m average width would allow

8 Dolinka Służewiecka 23.00 9 Moczydło 19.94 10 Morskie Oko—Promenada 17.90

stops, pedestrian crossings, etc.), the following can be assumed:

of the entire city's tramway system;

width equal to 3 times the width of the double tracks lane (ca. 20.4 m) = an area of ca. 2040.0 m<sup>2</sup>


#### *3.2. Model—Various Solutions*

Version 1. Development of the area along the tram route in the form of a green barrier a compact insulating green belt (regular triangular spacing, approx. 90% of the land area coverage); estimated numbers of plants in individual categories were calculated (large trees, h > 10.0 m/crown Ø approx. 7.0 m; smaller trees h < 10.0 m/crown Ø approx. 5.0 m; large shrubs Ø approx. 2.0 m) for a strip of land with a length of 100.0 m.

The width of the insulating green belt is a multiplication of the green double track width (Tr = 6.8 m); in the adopted version, the maximum width reaches the triple width of tracks lane exceeding 20.0 m and may be increased as far as possible and necessary, in accordance with the principle presented in the model (Figure 19).

Version 2. Development of the area along the tram route in the form of a green barrier a medium-dense insulating green belt (regular square spacing, approx. 80% of the land area coverage); estimated numbers of plants in individual categories were calculated (large trees, h > 10.0 m/crown Ø approx. 7.0 m; smaller trees h < 10.0 m/crown Ø approx. 5.0 m; large shrubs Ø approx. 2.0 m) for a strip of land with a length of 100.0 m.

The width of the insulating green belt is a multiplication of the green double track width (Tr = 6.8 m); in the adopted version, the maximum width reaches the triple width of tracks lane exceeding 20.0 m and may be increased as far as possible and necessary, in accordance with the principle presented in the model (Figure 20).

Version 3. The linear park—land development along the tram route with non-regular open forms of high and low greenery, providing high luminosity beneath the canopy, with a significant share of open grassy areas providing for possible recreational use (an implementation of path layout, equipment, etc.); on the edge of the green tram lane, the greenery of the diverse height creates a compact, insulating physical and optical green barrier. Estimated numbers of plants in individual categories (large trees, h > 10.0 m/crown Ø approx. 7.0 m; smaller trees h < 10.0 m/crown Ø approx. 5.0 m; large shrubs Ø approx. 2.0 m) were determined for a strip of land with a length of 100.0 m. The width of the green belt arranged as a linear park is a multiple of the width of the green tram lane (Tr = 6.8 m); . . . in the adopted version, the maximum width reaches the triple width of tracks lane

exceeding 20.0 m (Figure 21).

Currently, green tram lanes in Warsaw provide approx. 8.9 ha of biologically active area (a total length of approx. 25.5 km of a single track with the mean track width of approx. 3.5 m), which is only approx. 1.78% of the total area of the ten largest parks in Warsaw (Table 2).

There is still approx. a total length of 185.7 kmst (single tram tracks) in Warsaw potentially suitable for transformation into green lanes. If at least some of these resources are available for direct use (after excluding "technical" sections, i.e., intersections, viaducts, stops, pedestrian crossings, etc.), the following can be assumed:

• the introduction of low vegetation cover (lawns or herbaceous plants) using only 50% of the resources of available single track length (approx. 92.85 km) with the mean-narrow version of track spacing (width of approx. 3.5 m) allows obtaining approx. 32.5 ha of biologically active area in total; connecting it with the area of already existing green tracks allows 41.4 ha of biologically active area to be obtained in the scale of the entire city's tramway system;



**Table 2.** The area of the 10 largest parks in Warsaw.

In general, it can be assumed that the introduction of green tram lanes, including additional local green protection zones, would allow us to realistically obtain an additional biologically active area in the city, with a minimum size of approx. from 32.5 to 57.76 ha and even 82.64 ha—potentially enlarged by at least another 2.0 ha of "tram" linear parks. These numbers in total correspond to the average area of at least one large city park (from the group of largest in Warsaw) and an increase of ca. 6.5–16.5% in the combined area of all the largest parks in Warsaw. It is difficult to imagine introducing such a significant natural area into the dense and compact structure of the city in any other way.

Finally, the great importance of social participation in the design of green areas should be emphasized, especially linear parks in the vicinity of tram routes [10]. The authors' experiences in this area show that the recreational program of the planned park facility along the tram route should depend on public consultations. Residents of separate districts may have different preferences in terms of spending free time and using such places. The linear structure of the tram route crossing various parts of the city requires that the residents of these locations be able to comment on the recreational program. For example, this type of public consultation in Warsaw was carried out in the process of preparing an investment project—the construction of a new tram route: Saska K˛epa-Gocław [10] (Figure 22).

Public consultations in Poland are anchored in the currently applicable legal provisions (the Environmental Protection Act), in relation to the Directive of the European Parliament and the Council of Europe (2011/92/EU). In the discussed case, the study group consisted of participants in consultation meetings—mainly the inhabitants of Gocław and Saska K˛epa. In total, about 200 people participated in all four meetings (November–December 2017). It should be emphasized that over 1/3 of the participants (35.6%) called for the implementation of the widest developed strip of land, i.e., 60.0 m (Figure 23), because it allowed for the creation of new publicly accessible green areas. A deficit of places for sports such as running, rollerblading, and cycling was indicated. In general, the very assumption and approach to the problem of designing a tram route in a comprehensive

manner, taking into account the natural, landscape, and spatial context, was accepted and positively assessed by the majority of the consultation participants. Ultimately, thanks to the social dialogue, the version of the linear park next to the tram route will provide a green isolation zone of the track up to a width of 28.0 m and balance the interests and needs of various social groups interested in the investment (see Figure 21; model—Version 3: the linear park). places. The linear structure of the tram route crossing various parts of the city requires that the residents of these locations be able to comment on the recreational program. For example, this type of public consultation in Warsaw was carried out in the process of preparing an investment project—the construction of a new tram route: Saska Kępa-Gocław [10] (Figure 22).

*Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 16 of 24

greenery.

an additional biologically active area of approx. 25.26 ha or approx. 50.14 ha to be

would give an additional 2.0 ha of biologically active area for a 1.0 km long belt of

In general, it can be assumed that the introduction of green tram lanes, including

Finally, the great importance of social participation in the design of green areas

should be emphasized, especially linear parks in the vicinity of tram routes [10]. The authors' experiences in this area show that the recreational program of the planned park facility along the tram route should depend on public consultations. Residents of separate districts may have different preferences in terms of spending free time and using such

additional local green protection zones, would allow us to realistically obtain an additional biologically active area in the city, with a minimum size of approx. from 32.5 to 57.76 ha and even 82.64 ha—potentially enlarged by at least another 2.0 ha of "tram" linear parks. These numbers in total correspond to the average area of at least one large city park (from the group of largest in Warsaw) and an increase of ca. 6.5–16.5% in the combined area of all the largest parks in Warsaw. It is difficult to imagine introducing such a signif-

icant natural area into the dense and compact structure of the city in any other way.

achieved—with green belts along tram lanes of approx. 13.5 m average width; • the possibility of establishing a linear park in areas 20.0 m wide along the tram tracks

**Figure 22.** Public consultations regarding the development of the surroundings of the new Saska Kępa-Gocław tram route in Warsaw, conducted in the form of open consultation points, where a wide team of specialists and moderators are at the disposal of interested people on selected days. **Figure 22.** Public consultations regarding the development of the surroundings of the new Saska K˛epa-Gocław tram route in Warsaw, conducted in the form of open consultation points, where a wide team of specialists and moderators are at the disposal of interested people on selected days. needs of various social groups interested in the investment (see Figure 21; model—Version 3: the linear park).

the social dialogue, the version of the linear park next to the tram route will provide a green isolation zone of the track up to a width of 28.0 m and balance the interests and **Figure 23.** Insulating greenery along the planned Saska Kępa—Gocław tram route in Warsaw (three versions for public consultation). No 1. One-sided barrier of low and medium greenery (e.g., a strip of shrubs) along the tram route—with a width smaller than the width of the track itself—a frequent situation in densely built-up urban space. No 2. One-sided barrier of medium and high greenery (a belt of shrubs and trees), imitating the version of the 1st or 2nd model thanks to an additional green belt equal to one track width (the single width of tram lane). No 3. One-sided barrier of medium and high greenery—the green belt accompanying the tram reaches min. three times the width of the track (the triple width of tram lane), thanks to which it is possible to arrange greenery in a park style—linear layout—and to introduce a recreational program (roads, equipment, etc.). Graphics by J. Botwina. Compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz [10]. **Figure 23.** Insulating greenery along the planned Saska K˛epa—Gocław tram route in Warsaw (three versions for public consultation). No 1. One-sided barrier of low and medium greenery (e.g., a strip of shrubs) along the tram route—with a width smaller than the width of the track itself—a frequent situation in densely built-up urban space. No 2. One-sided barrier of medium and high greenery (a belt of shrubs and trees), imitating the version of the 1st or 2nd model thanks to an additional green belt equal to one track width (the single width of tram lane). No 3. One-sided barrier of medium and high greenery—the green belt accompanying the tram reaches min. three times the width of the track (the triple width of tram lane), thanks to which it is possible to arrange greenery in a park style—linear layout—and to introduce a recreational program (roads, equipment, etc.). Graphics by J. Botwina. Compiled by J. Łukaszkiewicz [10].

general concept to organize this development to avoid city congestion and suffocation in the near future. One of the ideas seems to be the careful planning of the urban space growth along the tram lines as backbones of this development. The authors think that in light of the city's traumatic past and subsequent rapid development, President Starzyński's plan of building a radial structure has been lost, and now it is time to bring forward suitable plans before it is too late. Fortunately, there are examples to be followed,

Sustainable development of the urban organisms involves the reduction of consumption of non-renewable spatial resources, assuming the reuse of wastelands or brownfields (e.g., [12,19–21]). Tram lines are often a perfect tool to integrate urban space, creating linear systems ("urban corridors"). In fact, the concept of development based on linear structures is not new in urban planning. The example is the idea of a linear city ("La Ciudad Lineal", ca. 1885) by the Spanish urbanist Arturo Soria y Mata (1844–1920) or the idea of "La Ville Radieuse" ("The Radiant City", 1920s) by Le Corbusier (1887–1965). Both theories later found further followers (e.g., [9,39]). For example, the concept of a "linear city" was applied in Curitiba (Curitiba), Brazil (approx. 3.0 million inhabitants) or in Australian cities (e.g., Melbourne, Coburg, and Sydney), where the tram is often an essential element

Many examples from around the world indicate that a tramway can contribute to the improvement of the visual quality of urban public space and the promotion of the image of the city itself. For example, tram lines in France (France now has 240 city tram networks) are a symbol of modernity and an expression of French cities' pro-ecological aspirations: restoring the lost public spaces, rationalizing access to public transport, and limiting the

traffic (e.g., Montpellier, Strasbourg or Bordeaux and many others) [1–5].

**4. Discussion** 

which are discussed here.

of "urban corridors" [2,5].

#### **4. Discussion**

Warsaw, the capital of Poland, is a rapidly growing urban organism badly needing a general concept to organize this development to avoid city congestion and suffocation in the near future. One of the ideas seems to be the careful planning of the urban space growth along the tram lines as backbones of this development. The authors think that in light of the city's traumatic past and subsequent rapid development, President Starzy ´nski's plan of building a radial structure has been lost, and now it is time to bring forward suitable plans before it is too late. Fortunately, there are examples to be followed, which are discussed here.

Sustainable development of the urban organisms involves the reduction of consumption of non-renewable spatial resources, assuming the reuse of wastelands or brownfields (e.g., [12,19–21]). Tram lines are often a perfect tool to integrate urban space, creating linear systems ("urban corridors"). In fact, the concept of development based on linear structures is not new in urban planning. The example is the idea of a linear city ("La Ciudad Lineal", ca. 1885) by the Spanish urbanist Arturo Soria y Mata (1844–1920) or the idea of "La Ville Radieuse" ("The Radiant City", 1920s) by Le Corbusier (1887–1965). Both theories later found further followers (e.g., [9,39]). For example, the concept of a "linear city" was applied in Curitiba (Curitiba), Brazil (approx. 3.0 million inhabitants) or in Australian cities (e.g., Melbourne, Coburg, and Sydney), where the tram is often an essential element of "urban corridors" [2,5].

Many examples from around the world indicate that a tramway can contribute to the improvement of the visual quality of urban public space and the promotion of the image of the city itself. For example, tram lines in France (France now has 240 city tram networks) are a symbol of modernity and an expression of French cities' pro-ecological aspirations: restoring the lost public spaces, rationalizing access to public transport, and limiting the traffic (e.g., Montpellier, Strasbourg or Bordeaux and many others) [1–5].

Similar to France, the promotion of many English cities is based on the local tram system, which is used to give the city center a new identity (e.g., Sheffield, Manchester, or Nottingham). In Germany, trams are also a tool for promoting a new public image of cities, accessibility, and good quality of city life (e.g., Heilbronn, Zwickau, Bad Wildbad, and others). In Oslo (Norway), the tram, which is part of the public transport, is promoted for its functionality—as a well-developed integrated system ensuring better city connections. In the Italian region of Calabria a modern tram line connecting the metropolis of Cosenza-Rende and the University of Calabria has been implemented since the 1980s [1,6,9].

The most interesting solutions involving trams in the urban spaces include the revitalization of the riverside area of Abandoibarra in Bilbao (Spain). The "Bilbao Effect" means a transformation of a mining and industrial port into a center of culture, art, and entertainment [67]. Similarly, a city-wide redevelopment of infrastructure was implemented in Petržalka district (Bratislava, Slovakia). Due to the introduction of a tram-train line running through the core of the district, the integration of the existing green spaces into a defined urban green system was achieved [68].

In the Czech Republic, the Prague municipality has approved an increase in the number of green tram lanes, applying mainly local, native species of drought-resistant plants, extensive drought-loving grasses, etc. [69–72]. The vegetation-modified tram lanes in Brno serve as additional urban greenery. Such green areas are often covered with herbaceous communities, transitioning between perennial beds and landscaped lawns [73].

It should be noted that in many cases, significant sections of tram routes run fully autonomously from the traffic zones (street, roads, etc.), combining fragmented parts of urban greenery, such as in Bordeaux or Strasbourg (France), Saarbrücken or Wolfartsweier Nord (Germany), Sheffield (England), Bratislava (Slovakia), and Bilbao (Spain). In practice, greenery appears in connection with tram tracks most often for two different reasons, which may partially complement each other. The first is the need to introduce insulating greenery to act as a barrier/cover instead of a classic fence, where the tracks are separated from other road users and pedestrians by linear shrub plantings, or where medium and high

green plantings separate the entire length of the tracks from the traffic zone (e.g., Zwickau, Wolfartsweier, or Freiburg im Breisgau—Germany) (Figure 24). The second reason is the integration of the tram routes with the urban greenery system (existing and newly developed) thanks to coherent city-wide landscape strategies (e.g., Strasbourg, Bordeaux, and Montpellier—France, or Heilbronn—Germany) [1–3,12,20,21,67,68]. zone (e.g., Zwickau, Wolfartsweier, or Freiburg im Breisgau—Germany) (Figure 24). The second reason is the integration of the tram routes with the urban greenery system (existing and newly developed) thanks to coherent city-wide landscape strategies (e.g., Strasbourg, Bordeaux, and Montpellier—France, or Heilbronn—Germany) [1– 3,12,20,21,67,68].

*Land* **2021**, *10*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 18 of 24

into a defined urban green system was achieved [68].

Similar to France, the promotion of many English cities is based on the local tram system, which is used to give the city center a new identity (e.g., Sheffield, Manchester, or Nottingham). In Germany, trams are also a tool for promoting a new public image of cities, accessibility, and good quality of city life (e.g., Heilbronn, Zwickau, Bad Wildbad, and others). In Oslo (Norway), the tram, which is part of the public transport, is promoted for its functionality—as a well-developed integrated system ensuring better city connections. In the Italian region of Calabria a modern tram line connecting the metropolis of Cosenza-

The most interesting solutions involving trams in the urban spaces include the revitalization of the riverside area of Abandoibarra in Bilbao (Spain). The "Bilbao Effect" means a transformation of a mining and industrial port into a center of culture, art, and entertainment [67]. Similarly, a city-wide redevelopment of infrastructure was implemented in Petržalka district (Bratislava, Slovakia). Due to the introduction of a tram-train line running through the core of the district, the integration of the existing green spaces

In the Czech Republic, the Prague municipality has approved an increase in the number of green tram lanes, applying mainly local, native species of drought-resistant plants, extensive drought-loving grasses, etc. [69–72]. The vegetation-modified tram lanes in Brno serve as additional urban greenery. Such green areas are often covered with herbaceous

It should be noted that in many cases, significant sections of tram routes run fully autonomously from the traffic zones (street, roads, etc.), combining fragmented parts of urban greenery, such as in Bordeaux or Strasbourg (France), Saarbrücken or Wolfartsweier Nord (Germany), Sheffield (England), Bratislava (Slovakia), and Bilbao (Spain). In practice, greenery appears in connection with tram tracks most often for two different reasons, which may partially complement each other. The first is the need to introduce insulating greenery to act as a barrier/cover instead of a classic fence, where the tracks are separated from other road users and pedestrians by linear shrub plantings, or where medium and high green plantings separate the entire length of the tracks from the traffic

Rende and the University of Calabria has been implemented since the 1980s [1,6,9].

communities, transitioning between perennial beds and landscaped lawns [73].

**Figure 24.** The tram train traveling in the "green corridor" consisting of grassy tracks, bordering trees, shrubs, and climbers attached to electric poles. Freiburg im Breisgau (Germany) has implemented numerous green tracks since 1980 [74]. **Figure 24.** The tram train traveling in the "green corridor" consisting of grassy tracks, bordering trees, shrubs, and climbers attached to electric poles. Freiburg im Breisgau (Germany) has implemented numerous green tracks since 1980 [74].

Due to their often favorable location in the compact urban structure, tram lanes are predisposed to be transformed into green areas of phytoremediation, climatic, and biocenotic importance (e.g., [1–6,9,61,67–73,75]). For example, in Strasbourg, the skillfully shaped and maintained coherent continuity of green communication lanes outside the city center has resulted in biodiversity corridors—migration routes for small animals and plant seeds [1,3].

The vegetation along tram lanes is very welcome to mitigate the city's climate, e.g., the level of air pollution, the effects of climate change, etc. [23,28,61,75–79]. Naturally, the ability of plants to absorb pollutants and clean the air (phytoremediation) depends on their size and vitality—trees play the most significant role in this process. In general, research shows that the appropriate structure and the maintenance of tall greenery—both its arrangement (forms, spatial arrangements) and internal structure—are of greater importance for air quality improvement. The highest efficiency in the accumulation of dust particles is achieved by isolating tall greenery forms located 3.0–15.0 m from the source of transport emissions. It is relatively more than 2.5 times more than in the case of similar tree stands, but still growing further (e.g., [28–30,34,79,80]). Air purification of dust (PM) is optimal with a sufficiently loose tree crown structure (40% of density), reaching the optimal canopy density of approx. 35–70%. By increasing size or tree density of the smallest urban green spaces (e.g., around tram lanes), a real and most noticeable effect can be achieved in cleaning up the urban atmosphere (e.g., [28–30,33–35,80,81]).

In Warsaw, the prospective opportunity for the rapid development of the tram network system is essential and dictated by the economy rules as the environmental burden is smaller than in the case of the underground (no need to make deep excavations, deal with their negative effects on the hydro-groundwork conditions, use enormous amounts of building materials, transport masses of earth—an effect of earthmoving, disorganized public transport, closed streets, construction sites, boreholes, etc.).

Increasing the biologically active area in the center zone of Warsaw is now a necessary requirement. Although greenery is introduced in every possible way (green roofs, green walls, greenery on terraces, etc.), the main disadvantage of these forms of vegetation is their limited or complete lack of access to all users of urban public spaces. Such persons become only passive viewers (often only from a considerable distance) of such isolated arrangements. In terms of environmental advantages, forms such as green roofs, green walls, greenery on terraces, etc., undoubtedly play an important role—they serve to increase the biologically active surface and help to reduce the urban "heat island" phenomenon; however, in terms of social values—apart from a positive aesthetic effect—they do not have a more significant impact.

The greenery which is in Warsaw associated with tram lanes is also, to some extent, excluded from direct use (especially green tracks), but it is still visually closer as it is on the street level. Undoubtedly, this has a positive effect on the reception of a given space, which thus adopts a harmonious landscape appearance. In addition, the green tram lanes are real biocenotic corridors—they allow for unhindered existence and movement of small fauna (e.g., birds, insects, earthworms). Adding the technical considerations discussed earlier (protective function), it can be concluded that the vegetation accompanying tram routes is the simplest and most advantageous way of introducing greenery into the downtown area.

The model of the greenery version interrelated to tram tracks in Warsaw presented herein carries plenty of resemblance to solutions applied in other cities and countries. This is a concise conceptualization allowing for a choice of a specific greenery version in relation to the width of the lane of the accessible ground. In the widest version of the model (Version 3), the option to introduce linear parks along the tram tracks was also taken into account. In this case, the greenery is also a recreational space, besides having the isolating function. Such solutions are popular around the world [1–6,9,67–73], and this trend is also provided for in the design of the environment of tram route Saska K˛epa—Gocław, in which the authors participated [10]. Furthermore, the conceptual research concerning the greenery structure accompanying the tram lines has shown great socioeconomic importance of the public consultations at the stage of the project preparation.

The presented case studies of cities show that a complex, coherent, and thoughtful approach to tramway lane design results in their successful integration with the urban surroundings [2,3,5,9,10,67]. The current world standard trams are environmentally friendly; they move almost noiselessly—often on surfaces covered with vegetation or in "green corridors"—without degrading visually valuable, often historic downtown areas. The tramways meet the expectations and carry out the communication tasks of modern cities, not only without generating adverse environmental effects but also positively influencing the process of shaping public spaces [1–4,39].

Moreover, one cannot forget that every—even the smallest—fragment of visible urban greenery is of great importance in relieving stress and mental disorders in city dwellers forced to stay in confinement during the global COVID-19 pandemic [13–15].

To sum up, those responsible for development of the future shape of a city and its public transport should take a leaf out of the book on other European cities, written by the decentralization and competition between cities across Europe and all over the world, showing that the evolution of urban theories makes it necessary to combine public transport with a high-standard multifunctional urban space. The tram system is a core of such projects, implementing not only communication functions without adverse effects on the environment (compared to other means of public transport), but also positively influencing the process of shaping urban public spaces by using "green thinking" as a key factor [1–3,5].

#### **5. Conclusions**

Trams are a key part of EU public transportation. The great importance of urban tram systems for the everyday transportation of masses of people is confirmed by the EU and Polish statistics data. The ecological advantages of trams are recognized in successive EU strategies and policies related to urban development and environmental protection. Globally, trams seem to be a vital tool for the development of urban space, which allow

arranging and consolidating structures called "urban corridors". As additional green areas can be introduced into densely urbanized space through tramlines, the real social, environmental, and functional importance of this form of transport is finally tangible. The Warsaw tram system case study (total length over 300 km of single tracks in service in 2019) was implemented in order to simulate the potential growth of a biologically active area connected with an increasing share of greenery around tram lanes in Warsaw.

The suggested revitalization of the existing and designing the future tram lanes as green corridors is in line with the generally accepted concept of urban green infrastructure. Therefore, the authors aim to present their views on this significant issue in a condensed fashion, within the program of the revitalization of Warsaw landscape by converting the existing tram lines, where possible, and planning new ones according to the "green point of view".

The information used as a basis to analyze the relevant situation in Warsaw came from other studies, European as well as global, presenting the development of urban tram systems. The authors' experience in designing of the tram lane surroundings in Warsaw was of key importance for the research presented, especially in terms of greenery forms—their functionality, utility, and visual quality.

The synthesis of these issues is presented as a model with several versions, applied to Warsaw itself in the first place (as it is the case study of our research); however, the model could be applicable in other cities of the world. The development of such a model aims to indicate a potential solution to a specific problem, namely the shaping of tram route surroundings, especially with high greenery used. Our findings provide fundamental and valuable, yet overlooked, guidelines for urban tram system managers, urban policymakers, and local planners. The authors do not claim that the presented model is the only and best possible solution to the principles of designing and revitalization of greenery along tram routes. Nevertheless, it seems to be a viable overall proposition with which one can create detailed solutions adapted to the conditions of the specific site.

The paper indicates that in Warsaw—similar to other capital cities—some selected areas along the tram routes can be designed and arranged as linear parks with additional recreational functions, following the prevailing world trend. The linear park is, in a way, a contemporary approach to more traditional spatial linear forms such as a boulevard or a promenade. An excellent example of such a solution is the case of a planned tram line from Saska-K˛epa to Gocław district in Warsaw. Moreover, also based on this example, this publication emphasizes the great importance of public consultations in planning new tram lines.

Taking into account all the results obtained so far, the main conclusions are as follows: (1) The presented case study (Warsaw) allows one to determine to what extent the introduction of green tracks (i.e., covered with herbaceous vegetation or additionally surrounded by tall vegetation) would realistically increase the biologically active area in the scale of the entire city; (2) With the adoption of minimum area parameters, the introduction of greenery associated with tram lines allows one to generate a biologically active area equal to a size of at least one large city park; in the case of Warsaw, it is an additional several dozen hectares of greenery in the densely built-up zone; (3) This is important especially in the central area—with dense, high-rise buildings and extensive technical infrastructure where there is a shortage of space available for the introduction of new natural objects (parks, squares, promenades, etc.). Often, green tram tracks are the only rational way of introducing "ground-layer" vegetation into this zone; (4) The plans of city development should also consider the "green" tram lines leading to recreational areas on the outskirts, serving at the same time as "ventilation corridors"; (5) The case of Warsaw and the spatial simulations presented in this paper seem to confirm that this kind of approach, already successfully applied in many cities around the world, appears to be the best way of tackling some key environmental issues during the continuous development of Poland's capital.

**Author Contributions:** Conceptualization, methodology, and formal analysis: J.Ł. and B.F.-A.; investigation and resources: J.Ł., B.F.-A., and J.F.; data selection: J.Ł. and Ł.O.; writing—original draft preparation: J.Ł.; writing—review and editing: J.Ł., B.F.-A., and J.F.; visualization: J.Ł., B.F.-A., and Ł.O.; supervision: J.Ł., B.F.-A., and J.F. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

**Funding:** This research received no external funding.

**Institutional Review Board Statement:** Not applicable.

**Informed Consent Statement:** Not applicable.

**Acknowledgments:** We would like to thank Vˇera Koláˇrová for her extremely competent help in language proofreading. We would like to thank our colleague Wi´sniewski for his help in preparing graphic materials. The authors would like to thank the anonymous reviewers and editors for their constructive comments and suggestions.

**Conflicts of Interest:** The authors declare no conflict of interest.

#### **References**

