**Micro-Electro Discharge Machining: Principles, Recent Advancements and Applications**

Editors

**Irene Fassi Francesco Modica**

MDPI • Basel • Beijing • Wuhan • Barcelona • Belgrade • Manchester • Tokyo • Cluj • Tianjin


*Editorial Office* MDPI St. Alban-Anlage 66 4052 Basel, Switzerland

This is a reprint of articles from the Special Issue published online in the open access journal *Micromachines* (ISSN 2072-666X) (available at: www.mdpi.com/journal/micromachines/special issues/Micro-Electro Discharge Machining).

For citation purposes, cite each article independently as indicated on the article page online and as indicated below:

LastName, A.A.; LastName, B.B.; LastName, C.C. Article Title. *Journal Name* **Year**, *Volume Number*, Page Range.

**ISBN 978-3-0365-1933-3 (Hbk) ISBN 978-3-0365-1932-6 (PDF)**

© 2021 by the authors. Articles in this book are Open Access and distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license, which allows users to download, copy and build upon published articles, as long as the author and publisher are properly credited, which ensures maximum dissemination and a wider impact of our publications.

The book as a whole is distributed by MDPI under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND.

## **Contents**


Reprinted from: *Micromachines* **2020**, *11*, 675, doi:10.3390/mi11070675 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . **125**


### **About the Editors**

#### **Irene Fassi**

Irene Fassi is currently Research Director at CNR-STIIMA where she leads the research group MEDIS, performing research activities in micro and meso scale manufacturing and robotics. She gives courses and seminars in robotics, precision engineering and advanced manufacturing systems, at University of Brescia and Politecnico di Milano. She is member of several Expert Evaluators Panel: European Commission, Agence Nationale de la Recherche, Norwegian Research Council, Eureka, MiSE, MIUR. She has been general or scientific chair of several international Conferences in the field of micromanufacturing, microsystems, and robotics, including the World Congress on Micro and Nano Manufacturing. She is a member of the Executive Board of SIRI (Italian Robotics and Automation Association), the Italian Association of Manufacturing Technologies (AITeM), the ASME Technical Committee on Micro and Nano Manufacturing, and currently serves as President of the International Institution for Micro Manufacturing

#### **Francesco Modica**

Francesco Modica is full time researcher at STIIMA-CNR, where he is currently researching mainly on micro-manufacturing and micro-engineering at the STIIMA-CNR MicroManufacturing laboratory in Bari. From 2000 to 2009, he has conducted research activities in mechatronic analysis and simulation of machine tools. From 2005 to 2009, he has been involved as researcher and project manager in collaboration with Sintesi s.p.a. developing mechatronic solutions (devices and simulations) for improving dynamic performance of machine tools. In 2009 he was visiting researcher at Katholieke Universiteit Leuven applying on micro-electrical discharge machining. Successively he has led different research activities concerning micro-manufacturing processes (in particular related to micro-EDM, micro injection moulding and Additive Manufacturing for micro applications) and design and fabrication of micro-components and devices.

### *Editorial* **Editorial for the Special Issue on Micro-Electro Discharge Machining: Principles, Recent Advancements and Applications**

**Irene Fassi 1,\* and Francesco Modica 2,\***


Micro Electrical Discharge Machining (micro-EDM) is a thermo-electric and contactless process most suited for micro-manufacturing and high-precision machining, especially when difficult-to-cut materials, such as super alloys, composites, and electro conductive ceramics, are processed. Many industrial domains exploit this technology to fabricate highly demanding components, such as high-aspect-ratio micro holes for fuel injectors, high-precision molds, and biomedical parts.

Moreover, the continuous trend towards miniaturization and high precision functional components boosted the development of control strategies and optimization methodologies specifically suited to address the challenges in micro- and nano-scale fabrication.

This Special Issue showcases 12 research papers and a review article focusing on novel methodological developments on several aspects of Micro Electrical Discharge Machining: machinability studies of hard materials (TiNi Shape Memory Alloys, Si3N4–TiN ceramic composite, ZrB2-Based Ceramics Reinforced with SiC Fibers and Whiskers, Tungstencemented carbide, Ti-6Al-4V alloy, Duplex Stainless Steel and Cubic boron nitride), process optimization adopting different dielectrics or electrodes, characterization of mechanical performance of processed surface, process analysis and optimization via discharge pulse-type discrimination, hybrid processes, fabrication of molds for inflatable soft microactuators, and implementation of low-cost desktop micro-EDM system.

In further detail, Zhao et al. [1] have investigated Laser-Assisted Electrochemical Discharge Machining for micro-processing of insulating and hard-brittle materials typified by glass. This study compared morphological features obtained by means of single processing and hybrid processing methods concerning the fabrication of microgrooves on quartz workpiece. The combination of these two methods allows to transform gradually V-shaped microgrooves into U-shaped microgrooves. Micro Electrical Discharge Machining has been characterized by Zhu et al. [2] for Surface Modification of TiNi Shape Memory Alloys using a TiC Powder Dielectric. The study reveals that TiC powder addition with a concentration of 5 g/L had a positive effect on increasing the electro-discharge frequency and MRR, reducing the surface roughness. The machined surface presents a recast layer with good adhesion and high hardness, due to metallurgical bonding, and contains CuO2, TiO2, and TiC phases, contributing to an increase in the surface microhardness from 258.5 to 438.7 HV, which could be beneficial for wear resistance in biomedical orthodontic applications. In accordance with potential effects on mechanical properties and oxidation performance, a study on ZrB2-Based Ceramics reinforced with SiC Fibers and whiskers has been performed by Quarto et al. [3] By means of the pulse-type characterization, results indicated how reinforcement shapes affect the energy efficiency of the process and change the surface aspect. The microEDM milling machinability of the Si3N4–TiN ceramic composite was investigated through the discharge pulse-type discrimination algorithm evaluating the material removal rate, tool wear ratio and surface quality in [4] by Marrocco et al. The analysis shows

**Citation:** Fassi, I.; Modica, F. Editorial for the Special Issue on Micro-Electro Discharge Machining: Principles, Recent Advancements and Applications. *Micromachines* **2021**, *12*, 554. https://doi.org/10.3390/ mi12050554

Received: 6 May 2021 Accepted: 7 May 2021 Published: 13 May 2021

**Publisher's Note:** MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

**Copyright:** © 2021 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/).

that MRR was sensitive only to normal pulses, while the occurrence of arcs and delayed pulses induced unexpected improvements in tool wear. Additionally, the inspection of the surface, performed by SEM and EDS analyses, showed the presence of re-solidified droplets and micro-cracks, which modified the chemical composition and the consequent surface quality of the machined micro-features. Ablyaz et al. [5] have developed a Surface Characterization and a Tribological Performance Analysis of Electric Discharge Machined Duplex Stainless Steel considering the main process parameters and three variants of electrode material (Graphite, Copper–Tungsten and Tungsten). The results revealed that the machined surface at high spark energy in EDM oil portrayed porosity, oxide formation, and intermetallic compounds, and then exhibited 70% superior wear resistance compared to the un-machined sample and contextually improving surface wettability.

The machinability via Electrodischarge Drilling of microholes with 410 µm in diameter and 1 mm deep in difficult-to-cut cubic boron nitride (c-BN) material was studied by Wyszynski et al. [6]. Tests were executed using tungsten electrode tool in Exxol80 (hydrocarbon oil) and varying pulse on and off times, pulse frequency and working current. Results show that relatively high working current and short pulses improve machining quality. Wire electrical discharge grinding (WEDG) is adopted by Milana et al. [7] for shaping several molds to cast rubber and create complex void for inflatable soft microactuators. All microactuators that have a cylindrical shape with a length of 8 mm and a diameter of 0.8 mm have been characterized and tested showing that complex deformation patterns, such as curling, differential bending or multi-points bending, can be achieved.

In order to deal with the high wear ratio bottleneck of micro-electrode tool, Huang et al. [8] have investigated the use of a liquid droplet suspended at the end of a capillary nozzle as an electrode. The liquid supply, the geometry and shape control of the tip were analyzed both via simulation and experimentation showing the feasibility of the method. The feasibility of a novel filling method to fabricate a composite 3D microelectrode for processing 3D microstructures via micro-EDM without steps is analyzed theoretically and experimentally by Lei et al. [9]. Wear and corrosion resistance of the Ti-6Al-4V alloy processed by EDM using multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) mixed with dielectric were experimentally investigated by Singh et al. [10]. The study reveals that the formation of intermetallic compounds, oxides, and carbides allows a dramatic enhancement of the wear-resistant and the corrosion protection efficiency up to 95%, and 96.63%, respectively, in comparison to using plan dielectric. Xu et al. [11] have proposed foil queue microelectrodes with tapered structures in order to solve the typical step effect issue when these microelectrodes are used for eroding 3D microstructure. The influence of the taper angle and the number of microelectrodes on the step effect were investigated and tested, reporting that the step effect on the 3D microstructure's surface became less evident when the taper angle and the number of foils–microelectrodes increase.

Wu et al. [12] have presented a low-cost desktop micro-EDM system for fabricating micro-holes in tungsten-cemented carbide materials reporting experimental test of micro-holes with a diameter of 0.07 mm and thickness of 1.0 mm drilled with a cut-side shaped micro-tool.

Finally, with the aim of helping researchers for selecting suitable powders and identifying different aspects of powder-mixed dielectric fluid of EDM, a paper review is presented by Abdudeen et al. [13]. The paper discusses and compares studies about various powders used for the process focusing on achieving a more efficient metal removal rate, reduction in tool wear, and improved surface quality of the powder-mixed EDM process.

We thank all the authors who submitted their papers to this Special Issue "Micro-Electro Discharge Machining: Principles, Recent Advancements and Applications". We would also like to acknowledge the reviewers who carefully reviewed all the submitted papers dedicating their time and helping to improve the quality of this Special Issue.

**Conflicts of Interest:** The author declares no conflict of interest.

#### **References**


### *Article* **An Investigation into Laser-Assisted Electrochemical Discharge Machining of Transparent Insulating Hard-Brittle Material**

**Douyan Zhao <sup>1</sup> , Zhaoyang Zhang 1,\*, Hao Zhu <sup>1</sup> , Zenghui Cao <sup>2</sup> and Kun Xu <sup>1</sup>**


**\*** Correspondence: zhaoyanz@ujs.edu.cn; Tel.: +86-0511-8878-0171

**Abstract:** Electrochemical discharge machining (ECDM) and laser machining are emerging nontraditional machining technologies suitable for micro-processing of insulating and hard-brittle materials typified by glass. However, poor machinability of glass is a major constraint, which remains to be solved. For the micro-grooves processed by ECDM, the bottom surface is usually uneven and associated with protrusion structures, while the edges are not straight with obvious wave-shaped heat-affected zones (HAZs) and over-cutting. Besides, the cross section of the micro-grooves processed by the laser is V-shape with a large taper. To solve these problems, this study proposed the laser-assisted ECDM for glass micro-grooving, which combines ECDM and laser machining. This study compared morphological features of the single processing method and the hybrid processing method. The results show that ECDM caused cylindrical protrusions at the bottom of the microgrooves. After processing these micro-grooves by laser, the cylindrical protrusions were removed. However, the edge quality of the microgrooves was still poor. Therefore, we used the laser to get microgrooves first, so we got micro-grooves with better edge quality. Then we use ECDM to improve the taper of microgrooves and the cross-sectional shape of the microgrooves transformed from a V-shape to a U-shape.

**Keywords:** electrochemical discharge machining; laser machining; glass; micro-groove

#### **1. Introduction**

Insulating and hard-brittle materials typified by glass are used widely in many fields such as chemical engineering, electronics, communications, instrumentation, and nuclear engineering. Especially in some complex, harsh, or extreme working environments, the parts made of glass materials show excellent corrosion resistance and high temperature stability. Although glass possesses many excellent characteristics, these materials are typically hard and brittle, and are therefore difficult to machine by conventional approaches, which affects the machining quality and limits its further application [1].

Traditional methods that have been reported for glass machining, including diamond grooving, mechanical grinding, micro-abrasive air jet [2] and water jet [3], in which material removed because of brittle crack formation caused by the cutting tool squeeze or jet impingement. Defects such as cracks and chipping easily produced during processing, leading to poor processing accuracy and surface quality.

For higher machining efficiency, better processing accuracy and surface morphology, nontraditional technologies have proposed for glass in recent years [4], and the typical methods are laser machining [5–7] and electrochemical discharge machining (ECDM) [8–12], both of which are noncontact methods and removing materials in a stress-less manner. Therefore, noncontact methods can avoid the stress damage, and reduce the chipping and cracks [13] significantly improving the processing accuracy and surface quality.

Specifically, the two nontraditional methods have their own characteristics. For laser machining, the light beam focuses on a small area and the pulse energy emits within a short

**Citation:** Zhao, D.; Zhang, Z.; Zhu, H.; Cao, Z.; Xu, K. An Investigation into Laser-Assisted Electrochemical Discharge Machining of Transparent Insulating Hard-Brittle Material. *Micromachines* **2021**, *12*, 22. https://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ mi12010022

Received: 27 October 2020 Accepted: 24 December 2020 Published: 27 December 2020

**Publisher's Note:** MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

**Copyright:** © 2020 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/ licenses/by/4.0/).

or ultrashort pulse duration, and therefore achieves extremely high energy intensity up to GW/cm<sup>2</sup> even PW/cm<sup>2</sup> , leading to unique nonlinear light, heat, and force effects [14,15]. In the process of ultrashort laser processing, such as picosecond laser, the laser energy first absorbed by electrons in material, and the amount determined by the absorption rate of the material itself. The electrons in the material absorb photons and then migrate, and, then, the electrons excited to the conduction band further improve the energy absorption of the workpiece. When the electron density of the conduction band exceeds the critical value, a Coulomb explosion may occur, and helps increase material removal.

The ECDM shown in Figure 1, where the tool electrode and auxiliary electrode immersed in the solution. After the DC power turned on, a current loop formed. As the reaction continues, the bubbles would fuse into a gas film, insulating the tool electrode from the working fluid. When the potential difference between the tool electrode and the working fluid increased up to the discharge voltage that could cause breakdown in the gas film, a spark discharge occurred, releasing a huge amount of energy. The emitted discharge energy led to high temperature and high pressure within the tiny distance between the tool electrode and material, and therefore the material may melt or even vaporize, and is then thrown away by high-pressure impact. Meanwhile, the rise of temperature also promoted the chemical corrosion of the alkaline solution on the workpiece. The two work together to increase material removal [16–18].

**Figure 1.** Schematic of the electrochemical discharge machining (ECDM).

In the existing literature, scholars from various countries have carried out research on the micro-machining technologies of insulating and hard-brittle materials, and a wide range of hybrid processing methods have been proposed.

A hybrid method of ECDM and micro grinding using polycrystalline diamond (PCD) tools explored by Xuan et al. [19], which had experimentally shown the grinding under PCD tools reduced the surface roughness of ECDM structures. The fundamental material removal mechanisms of hard-brittle materials under indentation and material removal mechanisms in the gap between the tool side and the hole wall have been studied by Nath et al. [20]. Ho et al. [21] explored the feasibility of ECDM with an aiding flow jet on nonconductive quartz glass materials. This research found that an aid nozzle improved the drilling depth by ensuring that an enough flow of electrolyte was available for spark generation and debris removal. Chen et al. [22] added a magnetic field to ECDM. The mechanism of the magnetohydrodynamic effect in ECDM was researched. By using this hybrid method, the ECDM micro-hole drilling performance was significantly improved.

However, much work is still in early exploration and the experimental research stage. The hybrid processing technology for insulating and hard-brittle materials is still based on one of laser or spark discharge, and then introduces rotation, vibration, inflation, or grinding for aid. However, there is still little research on etching glass by combining the two main energies of laser and spark discharge to improve the processing quality. Therefore, there are many theoretical and technical issues that need to be studied for the optoelectronic composite stepwise processing of glass.

This study focused on the step-by-step composite processing of glass using different sequences of laser and ECDM. According to the thermal effect of laser shock wave and the principle of ECDM effect, this study compared and analyzed the morphology characteristics of different machining methods. It also analyzed the influence of laser pre-processing on forming an ECDM gas film and the ablation of materials.

#### **2. Experimental Design**

#### *2.1. Experimental Setup*

As shown in Figure 2, an ECDM system has developed for this study, including pulse power supply (GKPT series, Shenzhen Shicheng Electronic Technology Co., Ltd. Shenzhen, China), current probe (CP8030B, Shenzhen Zhiyong Electronics Co., Ltd. Shenzhen, China), motion controller, four-axis linkage processing platform, microscope camera, tool electrode, auxiliary electrode, reaction tank, oscilloscope (TDS2012C, American Tek company, Beaverton, OR, USA), etc.

**Figure 2.** Schematic diagram of the experimental apparatus of ECDM.

The solution tank (size—160 × 120 × 80 mm<sup>3</sup> ) made of acrylic sheet fixed on the processing platform, which can precisely move along X–Y axes via a computer-controlled motion controller unit. The tool electrode clamped onto a vertical chuck rotated by a motor, and was moved up and down by the main spin. The negative pole of the DC pulse power supply connected to the tool electrode, and the positive pole connected to the auxiliary electrode. The high frequency current probe employed to monitor the current during ECDM, and the oscilloscope connected to it was used to display and store the collected current signal.

Tool electrodes and auxiliary electrodes are important in ECDM [23–25], and the material choice for them should be carefully considered. The tool electrode should not only have good electrical conductivity, but also needs to withstand the high temperature of electric spark discharge and strong alkali corrosion. Therefore, tungsten carbide (WC) was selected to make the tool electrode for this study. In addition, since the spiral thread electrode is more effective in expelling machining waste and renewing the electrolyte near the machining position compared to the smooth electrode, this experiment used a cylindrical tool electrode with a thread on the sidewall. The auxiliary electrode was made of block graphite with strong alkali resistance and good conductivity (size—80 × 20 × 15 mm<sup>3</sup> ).

Figure 3 shows the schematic of picosecond laser machining system, which was mainly composed of a picosecond laser, computer control system, optical path system, four-axes precision motion system, optical measurement system (charge coupled device camera, (CCD camera)), and other auxiliary equipment. A Nd: YVO4 laser (Edgewave PX100-1-GM) was employed in this study, which was operating in Gaussian mode at 1064 nm wavelength with a 12 ps pulse duration and the beam quality is M2 < 1.3. The maximum output power was about 70 W, while the pulse repetition frequency can change from 0.2 to 1 MHz, resulting in a maximum pulse energy of up to 260 µJ at the frequency of 0.2 MHz. The output power was adjusted by changing the high voltage (HV) level working on the HV modulator, which is superior to controlling the pump current as the

laser spot size not affected by the varied HV level in this laser machine. In addition, higher HV level results in more energy emission and therefore the increased laser intensity. The laser beam emitting from the generator first expanded by a beam expander (Eoptics VE-532–1064, JENOPTIK, Jena, Germany), then directed to a galvanometer (IntelliSCAN 14–1064, SCANLAB, Munchen, Germany) with a focal length of 100 mm and a typical marking speed of 2 m/s, and finally arrived at the target specimen surface. A mechanical beam blocker also included in the light path for a protection purpose. To keep the laser system in a stable operating stage, deionized and filtered water was looping inside the laser machine to remove the generated heat and hence maintain a constant temperature. By using this optical setup, a focusing laser spot of ∼20 µm in diameter achieved in the focal plane. ∼ μ

μ

**Figure 3.** Schematic of picosecond laser machining system.

#### *2.2. Machining Procedures*

In this experimental study, the laser machining and ECDM was first carried out separately. In the ECDM experiment, the workpiece was a square piece of quartz with a size of 20 × 20 × 1 mm<sup>3</sup> , which was fixed to the bottom of the solution tank by a bracket. The electrolyte was a 30 wt.% NaOH solution, and the electrolyte level was adjusted to 2 mm above the workpiece. The ECDM parameters selected in this experiment are shown in Table 1. In the experiment, the layer was fed 3 times, and each feeding amount was 0.2 mm.

μ μ μ μ μ In this ultrashort pulsed laser micromachining process, the laser used to heat the material may cause melting, vaporization, plasma formation, or direct phase explosion as in the femtosecond laser. The workpiece with a size of 20 × 20 × 1 mm<sup>3</sup> was fixed to the worktable of the laser system, and the CCD camera that comes with the laser, which is used for accurate focusing, such that the laser focused on the upper surface of the workpiece to process microgrooves. In the experiment, the scanning path designed by the computer in the laser processing system was a parallel line, the scanning distance between two adjacent parallel lines was 10 µm, the number of scanning lines was 20, and the scanning length was 2 mm. After each time the laser scanned a layer, the laser focus fed down by 20 µm to scan again, for 10 feeds. Because the laser focus diameter was 20 µm, the scanning distance between two adjacent parallel lines was 10 µm, and the scanning lines were 20, microgrooves with a width of around 200 µm were processed by this method. The laser machining parameters selected in this experiment are shown in Table 2. The scanning velocity and repetition times can be set by controlling the galvanometer. After the laser machining was completed, the workpiece was immersed in an alcohol solution for ultrasonic cleaning for 10 min and dried to remove the attached processing products.


**Table 1.** Parameters for ECDM.

**Table 2.** Parameters for laser machining.


Figure 4 was taken by a microscopic camera, showing the cross-sectional morphology of the microgrooves, respectively processed by laser and ECDM. The results show that although the edge profile of microgrooves processed by laser is relatively flat and neat, the cross-sectional taper is relatively large, showing a clear V-shape. On the contrary, the microgrooves processed by ECDM have almost no taper, but the edges have obvious wave-shaped heat-affected zones.

**Figure 4.** Cross-sectional morphology of the microgrooves respectively processed by laser and ECDM.

In order to obtain microgrooves with a small taper and good surface quality, the laser machining and ECDM carried out in a certain sequence on the same position to form a hybrid machining method, which combined the advantages of the two methods.

Figure 5 illustrates the processing sequence. Figure 5a shows ECDM pre-groove processing. The first step is to process the microgrooves on the workpiece by ECDM. Then the workpiece immersed in alcohol for ultrasonic cleaning for 10 min and dried to remove the attached processing products. The second step is to fix the workpiece to the laser processing platform. Then, use the CCD camera to observe the position of the microgroove, and use the software in the computer to focus on the center of a microgroove. In this way, the microgrooves processed by laser can completely overlap with the microgrooves processed by ECDM in the first step. The parameters used in these two steps were the same as described above. Except that the number of layer feeds in this ECDM experiment was one and the rotating speed is 0 RPM. Figure 5b shows laser pre-groove processing. The order of this processing method was reverse to that in Figure 5a. In the first step, a laser used to process microgrooves on the workpiece. Then the workpiece is immersed in alcohol for ultrasonic cleaning for 10 min and dried to remove the attached processing products. The second step is to fix it on the ECDM platform. Then observe the position of the microgroove with a microscopic camera, align the tool electrode at the center of a microgroove, and perform the ECDM. The parameters used in these two steps were the same as described above. Except that the rotating speed is 0 RPM.

**Figure 5.** Processing diagram: (**a**) laser pre-groove processing and (**b**) ECDM pre-groove processing.

After processing, the glass was cleaned and dried. The scanning electron microscope (SEM, Hitachi S-3400N) was used to observe the surface morphology of the processed microgrooves. Because the glass itself is an insulator, it is necessary to spray a metal film or carbon film on the material to form a conductive layer before observation.

#### **3. Results and Discussion**

#### *3.1. ECDM Preprocess*

μ Figure 6 is the SEM image of a microgroove processed by ECDM. Taking the dotted line as the boundary in the figure, the left side shows the morphology of a microgroove produced by ECDM only, while the right side matches the result of post-processed by laser machining after ECDM. The ECDM parameters of Figure 6a were 1000 Hz and 0 RPM. Protrusions appear regularly at the bottom of the microgroove, and these protrusions are cylindrical with steep sidewalls. Further, the distance between the peaks of two adjacent protrusions is about 70 µm, while the bottoms not connected. Figure 6b shows the microgrooves processed with different ECDM parameters (800 Hz and 0 RPM). Compared with Figure 6a, the regularity of the protrusions' distribution decreases. The protrusions are nearly cone-shaped with a gentle sidewall. The distance between the tops of the adjacent two protrusions is about 30–80 µm, and the bottoms are connected.

μ The formation of this protrusion structure may be explained by two aspects. On the one hand, the discharge is more difficult to generate at the center of the tool electrode that is flat-bottomed. Specifically, Jiang et al. [26,27] conducted a finite element analysis on the current density of the tool electrode with this shape, as shown in Figure 7. Compared to the center of the cylindrical tool electrode, the current density near the edge of the contour is stronger. Therefore, if geometric defects are not considered, sparks tend to generate along the edge of the tool electrode, and it is more difficult to generate near the geometric center of the bottom, so the material in this part is more difficult to remove. Figure 8 is the picture of a crater created by the ECDM process using a cylindrical tool of 0.5-mm diameter with the discharging duration of 2 s, which illustrates that material near the rim of the cylindrical tool was removed, indicating release of sparks distributed around the rim, or the "fringing effect". On the other hand, during the ECDM, bubbles will produce at the bottom of the tool electrode. Because the solution has a high viscosity and the bubbles

mainly stressed in the vertical direction, the bubbles will accumulate at the bottom of the electrode and are difficult to discharge, which hinders the electrolyte into the gap between the tool electrode and the workpiece, making this part difficult to produce electrochemical discharge [28], and the material is difficult to remove. As a result, the morphology with protrusions at the bottom is created.

1000Hz

800Hz

**Figure 6.** Morphology comparison of micro-grooves machined by ECDM only (left part) and hybrid method with laser processing. (**a**) 1000 Hz and (**b**) 800 Hz.

**Figure 7.** Finite element simulation of current density in electrochemical reaction on cylindrical electrode [26].

μ

ℎ μ <sup>௧</sup>

<sup>௧</sup> ൌ െ 2ℎ

**Figure 8.** Crater created by a cylindrical tool electrode. Machined with 35-V electrode voltage and 2-s machining time [26].

It can be clearly seen from the topography on the right side of the dotted line in Figure 6 that the protrusions in the microgrooves were removed after laser machining, resulting in a smoother surface. Because ECDM preprocessing can promote the nonlinear absorption of the high-energy pulsed laser in the processing area and induce plasma generation. It can selectively remove the protrusion structures of different shapes formed in the ECDM. Besides, when the picosecond pulsed laser acts on a transparent medium, the high peak power can produce a strong nonlinear effect inside the transparent medium, and reduce the heat-affected zone effectively, which greatly improves the morphology quality.

But the drawbacks of this processing method are obvious. Although laser scanning can effectively remove the protrusion structures, the removed debris still existed at the bottom, and the surface roughness was not good. To further improve the morphology quality and composite effect, and to explore the influence of laser preprocessing on the gas film formation and material ablation in ECDM, the sequence of laser machining and ECDM was adjusted to form a laser-assisted ECDM microgroove machining method, as given in the details of the next section.

#### *3.2. Laser Preprocess*

 μ ℎ μ <sup>௧</sup> In the laser preprocess experiments, the microgroove was processed by laser first, and then post-processed by ECDM. Specifically, the tool electrode with a suitable diameter was selected according to the width of the microgroove processed by laser pre-machining. In this experiment, the width *W* of the micro-groove was 200–240 µm, and the gas film thickness *h* was about 20 µm. The tool electrode diameter *d<sup>t</sup>* is:

$$d\_t = \mathcal{W} - 2h \tag{1}$$

therefore, a tool electrode with a diameter of 200 µm was selected.

During the machining process, the relative position of the tool electrode tip and the pre-groove was monitored by connecting the micro camera to the computer to make the traces of ECDM and laser machining overlap accurately and completely. Figure 9 illustrates the change in the relative position of the tool electrode in the laser preprocessed groove during ECDM. First, the tool electrode descended to position A, where the tip of the tool electrode was slightly lower than the microgroove inlet level, but it was not in contact with the sidewall. ECDM was performed to remove burrs without forming a heat-affected zone on the edge of the microgroove. As the tool electrode continued to dive, it arrived at position B. At this time, there should be contact between the tool electrode and the sidewall of the microgroove. However, due to the discharge, this part formed a melting zone, which is further melted and eroded under the action of the electrolyte. As the tool electrode continued to dive, it finally reached position C, the bottom of the microgroove. As the

ECDM proceeded, the cross-section is changing gradually from V-shaped to U-shaped, and the taper decreased significantly.

μ

μ

**Figure 9.** Schematic diagram of tool electrode position.

μ Figure 10 is a comparison diagram of the microgrooves with a width of 200 µm processed by combination method and ECDM only. Taking the dotted line in the figure as the boundary, the left side of the dotted line is combination, and the right side represents ECDM only. μ

**Figure 10.** Comparison of microgrooves processed by combination method and ECDM only.

It can be clearly seen that the edges of the microgroove processed by ECDM only are tortuous. In addition, the processing quality is relatively poor, and there is a wave-shaped heat-affected zone on the upper surface of the microgroove edge. This is because the molten material overflowed under the action of gas film agitation and thermal impact during the processing, and then cooled and solidified and accumulated on the edge of the microgroove, eventually forming a wave shape slightly higher than the surface of the material.

The edge of the microgroove processed by the combination method is flat, and the sidewall profile is more regular and smoother, and there is no visible wave-shaped heat-affected zone on the upper surface of the edge, showing the morphology of laser processing only.

Gas film is an important parameter which formed around the tool electrode and leads to discharge activities. The size and stability of the gas film significantly affected the material removal and accuracy of the microgrooves. A more stable gas film prepares a suitable condition for uniform discharges. The edge of the microgrooves presents the morphology of laser machining instead of ECDM, showing the microgrooves formed by

laser preprocessing can reduce the thickness of the gas film, shorten the distance of electrical discharge erosion, and achieve better quality and less overcutting. This was because of the lack of material produced by laser processing increased the thickness of the liquid layer between the edge of the microgroove and the discharge area of the tool electrode, which increased the stability of the gas film. At the same time, the processed microgrooves squeezed the gas film on the tip of the tool electrode, which had a restrictive and standard effect on the ECDM energy. The dual action improved the localization of ECDM, reduced the amount of overcutting, and greatly improved the machining accuracy. Therefore, the edge of the laser preprocessed microgroove was not affected by the discharge, and still presents a neat edge of the preprocessed laser.

While the bottom surface presents the morphological characteristics of ECDM instead of laser machining. Since the microgrooves processed by the laser show a certain taper, the width of the microgrooves become narrower as the depth of the microgrooves increases. When the distance between the material and the tool electrode is less than the critical distance of electric discharge erosion (Figure 9, positions B and C), the material at that place will be eroded by ECDM. And since the final position of the tool electrode in the bottom of the groove reaches the effective processing range, the depth of ECDM is deeper than laser, so the bottom surface presents the morphological characteristics of ECDM instead of laser machining. As shown in the enlarged detail of Figure 9, laser-assisted ECDM can keep the laser processing morphology on the upper edge of the microgroove, and ECDM only affects the middle and lower regions. Therefore, the experiment can obtain highquality microgrooves, which can have flat edges and small tapers. As shown in Figure 11, the width of the microgrooves of the combined machining is generally smaller than that of the ECDM. This study used different voltage parameters to verify that the combined method can improve the overcut phenomenon caused by ECDM, thereby improving the processing quality.

**Figure 11.** Comparison of width processed by combination method and ECDM only.

In summary, the microgroove first processed by laser, and then a tool electrode with an appropriate diameter was selected for ECDM according to the width of the groove. The combination of the two methods can effectively improve the edge quality of the microgrooves to obtain a more straight and neat edge morphology with less overcutting. At the same time, the taper of the microgroove can be effectively reduced, and the cross section is closer to a U-shape.

#### **4. Conclusions**

This study explored ECDM and laser processing of quartz, and compared the morphological differences between single processing methods and combined processing methods. The experimental results are summarized:


**Author Contributions:** Conceptualization, D.Z.; Investigation, Z.C.; Methodology, D.Z.; Resources, K.X.; Supervision, H.Z. and Z.Z.; Writing—original draft, D.Z.; Writing—review and editing, D.Z. and Z.Z. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

**Funding:** This research was funded by National Natural Science Foundation of China, grant number 51675242, 51905226; Natural Science Research of Jiangsu Higher Education Institutions of China, grant number 18KJB460006, 18KJB460005; Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province, grant number BK20180875.

**Institutional Review Board Statement:** Not applicable.

**Informed Consent Statement:** Not applicable.

**Data Availability Statement:** Data available on request due to restrictions e.g., privacy or ethical. The data presented in this study are available on request from the corresponding author. The data are not publicly available due to it was not agreed by all co-authors.

**Conflicts of Interest:** The authors declare no conflict of interest.

#### **References**


*Article*
