*Secondary Sources*

Abe, Stanley K. 2001. Provenance, Patronage, and Desire: Northern Wei Sculpture from Shaanxi Province. *Ars Orientalis* 31: 1–30. Abe, Stanley K. 2002. *Ordinary Images*. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Andreeva, Petya. 2018. Fantastic Beasts of the Eurasian Steppes: Toward A Revisionist Approach to Animal-Style Art. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA.

Bachhofer, Ludwig. 1946. *A Short History of Chinese Art*. New York: Pantheon.

Behrendt, Kurt. 2003. *The Buddhist Architecture of Gandhara ¯* . Leiden: Brill.

Behrendt, Kurt, ed. 2007. *The Art of Gandhara in the Metropolitan Museum of Art*. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.

Bingenheimer, Marcus. 2020. On the Use of Historical Social Network Analysis in the Study of Chinese Buddhism: The Case of Dao'an, Huiyuan, and Kumaraj ¯ ¯ıva. *Journal of the Japanese Association of Digital Humanities* 5: 84–131. [CrossRef]

Brancaccio, Pia, and Kurt Behrendt, eds. 2006. *Gandharan Buddhism: Archaeology, Art, Texts*. Vancouver: UBC Press.

Cao, Xuexia. 2011. Nannieshui shike zaoxiang de minjian tese: Qiantan shike yishu zai qinxian de chuancheng yu fazhan 南 涅 水 石 刻 造 像 的 民 間 特 色:淺 談 石 刻 藝 術 在 沁 縣 的 傳 承 與 發 展 (Features of the Nannieshui Stone Statues: On the Inheritance and

Development of Stone Sculptures at County Qin). *Wenwu Shijie* 4: 30–42.

Caswell, James O. 1975. The 'Thousand-Buddha' Pattern in Caves XIX and XVI at Yün-Kang. *Ars Orientalis* 10: 35–54.

Chen, Bingying. 1988. Bei Wei Cao Tianhu zao fang shita 北 魏 曹 天 護 造 方 石 塔 (Square stone pagoda commissioned by Cao Tianhu in Northern Wei). *Wenwu* 3: 83–85, 93.


Cheng, Xiaozhong, and Fuxue Yang. 2003. *Zhuanglang shiku* 莊浪石窟 *(Zhuanglang Cave-Temples)*. Lanzhou: Gansu Wenhua Chubanshe. Davidson, J. Leroy. 1954. *The Lotus Sutra in Chinese Art: A Study in Buddhist Art to the Year 1000*. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Davy, Jack, and Charlotte Dixon, eds. 2019. *Worlds in Miniature: Contemplating Miniaturisation in Global Material Culture*. London: UniversityCollegeLondonPress.

Ding, Detian. 2016. Jingchuan Fojiao Kaogu Yanjiu. Ph.D. dissertation, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou, China.


Huang, Shaoxiong. 2015. *Daiguo Daijun tongzhi* 代國代郡通志 *(History of Dai)*. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju.

Hurvitz, Leon. 2009. *Scripture of the Lotus Blossom of the Fine Dharma (the Lotus Sutra)*. New York: Columbia University Press.

Ishimatsu, Hinako 石松日奈子. 2005. *Hokugi bukkyo z ¯ oz¯ oshi no kenky ¯ u¯* 北魏教造像史研究 *(Studies on the History of Northern Wei Buddhist Sculpture)*. Kunitachi-shi: Buryukke.

Jayne, Horace F. 1929. *The Buddhist Caves of Ching Ho Valley*, Eastern Art: Part. 1.


Lee, Sonya. 2010. *Surviving Nirvana: Death of the Buddha in Chinese Visual Culture*. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.

Leidy, Denise P. 1990. The Ssu-wei Figure in Sixth Century A.D. Chinese Buddhist Sculpture. *Archives of Asian Art* 43: 21–37.



Miu, Zhe. 2012. Chongfang louge 重訪樓閣 (Revisiting Towers and Pavilions). *Meishushi Yanjiu Jikan* 美術史研究集刊 33: 2–111.


Seckel, Dietrich. 1980. Stupa Elements Surviving in East Asian Pagodas. In ¯ *Stupa: Its Religious, Historical and Architectural Significance ¯* . Edited by Anna L. Dallapiccola. Wiesbaden: Steiner, pp. 249–59.


Twitchett, Denis. 1957. The Monasteries and China's Economy in Medieval Times. *BSOAS* 3: 526–49. [CrossRef]


#### **Struggle on the Axis: The Advance and Retreat of Buddhist Influences in the Political Axis of Capitals in Medieval China (220–907)**

**Yifeng Xie**

*Article*

Department of History, Yuelu Academy, Hunan University, Changsha 410082, China; xieyifeng@hnu.edu.cn

**Abstract:** Buddhist influences on the sacred axis of the capital during Medieval China (220–907) underwent a process of starting with little impact during the era of Eastern Han, Caowei, and Western Jin (220–317) to a more prominent influence from the late Southern and Northern Dynasties (386–589) to early Tang (618–907), peaked during the reign of Wu Zetian (690–705), and roughly returned to the layout patterns from the late Southern and Northern Dynasties to early Tang after the death of Wu Zetian. As maintained below, the process appears complex in terms of the interaction between Buddhism and political space throughout early Medieval China. There are roughly two modes of integration and interaction between Buddhist buildings and ritual buildings with Buddhist influences and the political axis of the capital: the first mode can be regarded as a typical mode after its establishment in the late Northern Wei Dynasty. This mode exhibits major Buddhist influences, particularly regarding the huge scale of monasteries and pagodas, and the location of high-rise pagodas as landmarks flanking the political axis of the capital. The second mode should be regarded as an atypical mode occurring during the late period of Emperor Wu of the Liang (464–549, r. 502–549), the period of Northern Qi (550–577), and the reign of Wu Zetian. At this point, Buddhist buildings and imperial ritual buildings with Buddhist characteristics and symbolic meanings were placed directly on the political axis of the capital, close to or located at the core of the palace. This practice was a sign that the influence of Buddhism in the political culture and ideology of the entire empire during these eras of Emperor Wu of the Liang, the Northern Qi, and the reign of Wu Zetian had reached their culmination. Architecture reflected the most intuitive embodiment of an external visual form in presenting the most symbolic image of power. With the decline of political enthusiasm for advocating Buddhism, Buddhist and related buildings no longer occupied the political axis of the capital. Various forces majeure such as natural fires, demolition, and reconstruction by subsequent rulers also led to the demise of Buddhist influence on the pollical axis of capital architecture in subsequent eras.

**Keywords:** capitals; the political axis; Buddhist influences; Emperor Wu of the Liang; Wu Zetian
