*Review* **A Review on the Application of Cobalt-Based Nanomaterials in Supercapacitors**

**Lin Yang, Qinghan Zhu, Ke Yang, Xinkai Xu, Jingchun Huang, Hongfeng Chen \* and Haiwang Wang \***

A Key Laboratory of Dielectric and Electrolyte Functional Material Hebei Province, Northeastern University at Qinhuangdao, Qinhuangdao 066004, China

**\*** Correspondence: chf1405104586@126.com (H.C.); whwdbdx@126.com (H.W.)

**Abstract:** Among many electrode materials, cobalt-based nanomaterials are widely used in supercapacitors because of their high natural abundance, good electrical conductivity, and high specific capacitance. However, there are still some difficulties to overcome, including poor structural stability and low power density. This paper summarizes the research progress of cobalt-based nanomaterials (cobalt oxide, cobalt hydroxide, cobalt-containing ternary metal oxides, etc.) as electrode materials for supercapacitors in recent years and discusses the preparation methods and properties of the materials. Notably, the focus of this paper is on the strategies to improve the electrochemical properties of these materials. We show that the performance of cobalt-based nanomaterials can be improved by designing their morphologies and, among the many morphologies, the mesoporous structure plays a major role. This is because mesoporous structures can mitigate volume changes and improve the performance of pseudo capacitance. This review is dedicated to the study of several cobalt-based nanomaterials in supercapacitors, and we hope that future scholars will make new breakthroughs in morphology design.

**Keywords:** supercapacitor; cobalt-containing nanomaterials; morphological design

## **1. Introduction**

### *1.1. Background*

Using non-renewable resources such as fossil fuels will cause severe environmental pollution, and their prices are rising yearly due to their dwindling reserves. Therefore, it is urgent to develop sustainable green energy, among which wind and solar energy have been used on a large scale [1]. To better store and transport electricity from sustainable energy sources, energy storage technology has been developed significantly. Rechargeable batteries and supercapacitors (SCs) have been the major chemical energy storage devices.

At present, rechargeable lithium-ion batteries with good safety performance, high voltage and high energy density are widely used. However, with the rising demand for lithium-ion batteries, lithium resources are facing an extremely tight situation. Thus, sodium, an alkali metal, has attracted increasing attention in recent years due to its abundant content and low cost. However, poor cycle performance is still the most significant problem hindering the development of sodium-ion batteries. Compared to rechargeable batteries, SCs have faster charging and discharging processes (SCs: 1–10 s and batteries: 0.5–5 h), higher power density (SCs: 500–10,000 W kg−<sup>1</sup> and batteries < 1000 W kg−<sup>1</sup> ), longer lifetime (SCs > 500,000 h and batteries: 500–1000 h) and safer operation [2–5]. However, SCs have a disadvantage in terms of low energy density (SCs: 1–10 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> and batteries: 10–100 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> ) [2,6–9]. To get over the barrier of low energy density, one of the most common approaches is to develop high-performance electrode materials for SCs.

#### *1.2. Transition Group Metals Electrode Materials*

Transition group metal materials have been widely used as electrode materials for SCs in recent years, and include oxides/hydroxides [10–13], sulfides [14–17], phosphides [18],

**Citation:** Yang, L.; Zhu, Q.; Yang, K.; Xu, X.; Huang, J.; Chen, H.; Wang, H. A Review on the Application of Cobalt-Based Nanomaterials in Supercapacitors. *Nanomaterials* **2022**, *12*, 4065. https://doi.org/10.3390/ nano12224065

Academic Editor: Sergio Brutti

Received: 26 October 2022 Accepted: 16 November 2022 Published: 18 November 2022

**Publisher's Note:** MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

**Copyright:** © 2022 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/).

and other categories. Among these materials, RuO2, the most representative one, was considered the most desirable pseudocapacitive material for its theoretical specific capacitance (1300–2200 F g−<sup>1</sup> ) [19]. However, insufficient resources and the environmental toxicity of RuO<sup>2</sup> has unfortunately limited its further development [20]. This has led the relevant research on RuO<sup>2</sup> to its compound materials and other transition group metals to reduce the cost. Among them, cobalt-based materials are promising electrode materials for SCs because of their natural abundance, good cycle stability, abundant electroactive sites, high specific capacitance, and high electronic conductivity. In recent years, various cobalt-based materials, such as Co3O4, Co(OH)2, cobalt-based ternary metal oxides, and sulfides, have been widely studied and many advances have been made.

#### *1.3. Contents of This Review*

Scholars have done much research on cobalt-based nano-material electrodes. However, their broad application is limited due to low electrochemical potential window, poor structural stability, unsatisfactory cycle stability and low power density. Generally speaking, the morphology, chemical composition and crystal defects of cobalt-based electrode materials have a great influence on the electrochemical performance of energy storage devices. Researchers have explored this issue, including doping other elements, introducing oxygen vacancies, and controlling synthesis conditions to construct different spatial structures of materials to improve the performance of the above electrode materials.

As far as we know, most of the existing reviews classify cobalt-based nanomaterials into a specific class of materials for a brief overview, while few reviews summarize their applications in SC electrodes alone. To promote future breakthroughs in this field, we provide a more comprehensive description of the application of cobalt-based nanomaterials in supercapacitors. Starting from nano-structured cobalt-based materials (cobalt tetroxide, cobalt hydroxide, cobalt-containing ternary metal oxides) and their composites, the application of cobalt-based materials in supercapacitor electrodes is introduced. First, the working principle and classification of SCs are introduced. Second, the applications of cobalt-based nano-compounds in SCs are studied, including the structure and electrochemical properties of cobalt-based nano-materials, the synthesis methods of electrode materials, the construction of different nano-structures and composites with other materials. In addition, the influence of morphology on the properties of cobalt-based nanomaterial electrodes is emphasized. Finally, we look forward to the development and challenges of SCs and cobalt-based materials.

#### **2. Cobalt-Based Nanomaterials for SC Applications**

With the popularity of mobile electronic devices, electric vehicles, and new energy vehicles, energy storage systems have become an integral part of modern society. Among them, SCs have become electrochemical containers, and have attracted significant attention because of their safe operation, good cycle performance, fast charging capacity and highpower density.

As shown in Figure 1a, a SC mainly consists of a pair of parallel plate electrodes, an electrolyte solution, electrode materials and an ion-permeable separator [21]. The separator can separate the two electrodes effectively to prevent mutual contact and short circuit [22]. The energy storage mechanism of SCs include (1) reversible ion adsorption and desorption processes between active materials and electrolytes, and (2) reversible faradaic redox reactions during charging and discharging. Furthermore, according to the charge storage mechanism of SCs, they can be divided into three categories: electronic double-layer capacitors (EDLCs), pseudo-capacitors (PCs) and battery-type capacitors. The specific mechanisms of these three types of capacitors are explained below.

**Figure 1.** (**a**) Schematic diagram of the structure of an SC and energy storage mechanism of (**b**) an electric double layer capacitor, (**c**) a surface redox capacitor, (**d**) intercalation capacitor and (**e**) a battery-type capacitor. **Figure 1.** (**a**) Schematic diagram of the structure of an SC and energy storage mechanism of (**b**) an electric double layer capacitor, (**c**) a surface redox capacitor, (**d**) intercalation capacitor and (**e**) a battery-type capacitor.

EDLC is controlled by reversible adsorption/desorption of electrolyte ions at the electrode/electrolyte interface (Figure 1b), a process involving only the physical adsorption of ions but not any chemical reaction [23]. During the charging process, electrons migrate from the negative electrode to the positive electrode, accumulating positive and negative charges at the two electrodes. Then, the anions in the electrolyte solution move toward the positive electrode and the cations move toward the negative electrode. During the discharge process, the reverse procedure takes place. Since the potential drop is primarily limited to a small range (0.1–10 nm), EDLC has a higher energy density than the conventional capacitor, and its capacitance is related to the interface area of the electrodes. Therefore, common electrode materials mainly include porous carbon-based electrode materials with high specific surface area [24–26]. However, due to the absence of Faraday redox reactions in the energy storage process, the charging mechanism confines the capacitance EDLC is controlled by reversible adsorption/desorption of electrolyte ions at the electrode/electrolyte interface (Figure 1b), a process involving only the physical adsorption of ions but not any chemical reaction [23]. During the charging process, electrons migrate from the negative electrode to the positive electrode, accumulating positive and negative charges at the two electrodes. Then, the anions in the electrolyte solution move toward the positive electrode and the cations move toward the negative electrode. During the discharge process, the reverse procedure takes place. Since the potential drop is primarily limited to a small range (0.1–10 nm), EDLC has a higher energy density than the conventional capacitor, and its capacitance is related to the interface area of the electrodes. Therefore, common electrode materials mainly include porous carbon-based electrode materials with high specific surface area [24–26]. However, due to the absence of Faraday redox reactions in the energy storage process, the charging mechanism confines the capacitance to a lower range, exhibiting a higher power density but lower energy density and specific capacitance.

to a lower range, exhibiting a higher power density but lower energy density and specific capacitance. Based on the Faraday redox reaction, the pseudo-capacitance gives the SCs higher charge storage capacity. Similar to the charging and discharging processes occurring in batteries, the energy storage process in such SCs is a fast reversible Faraday reaction at or Based on the Faraday redox reaction, the pseudo-capacitance gives the SCs higher charge storage capacity. Similar to the charging and discharging processes occurring in batteries, the energy storage process in such SCs is a fast reversible Faraday reaction at or near the surface of the active material, but without causing phase changes in the electrode material [22,27]. PCs can be divided into two types: PCs controlled by surface redox

near the surface of the active material, but without causing phase changes in the electrode material [22,27]. PCs can be divided into two types: PCs controlled by surface redox reacreactions (Figure 1c) and PCs controlled by intercalation layers (Figure 1d). For the former PCs, during the redox pseudo-capacitance process, electron transfer occurs when ions in the electrolyte solution are attracted to or near the electrode surface. For the latter PCs, electron transfer occurs when ions are transferred into the gap or interlayer of the electrode and layered electrodes expose a larger area in an electrolyte solution. However, electrode materials are prone to shrinkage and expansion during charging and discharging due to the redox reaction at the electrode, leading to poor cycling performance [28]. Both capacitance and energy density of PCs are much larger than those of EDLCs. This is mainly attributed to the unique charge storage mechanism of the Faraday redox reaction rather than the fully reversible physical charge/discharge processes.

Battery-type SCs (their structures are shown in Figure 1e) are distinguished from PCs by their distinctive feature of exhibiting phase change behavior during charging and discharging [29–31]. The charge storage mechanism in battery materials involves the reaction with OH− in alkaline medium, which is controlled by the diffusion of electrolyte ions [31]. Battery-like materials usually have high charge storage capacity. However, the slow phase change of the material during charging and discharging reduces its kinetic performance, making its multiplicative performance low. In contrast, battery-type materials with unique nanostructures have a high specific surface area, creating great active sites for redox reactions and providing a shorter distance for the diffusion of electrolyte ions. Moreover, the rapid phase transition of battery-like materials during charge storage is mitigated by designing their nanostructures.

Transition metal oxides are widely studied as SC electrode materials because they possess higher energy density than carbon materials due to the Faraday electrolysis reaction involved in the electrochemical process. Among them, cobalt nanomaterial is a typical transition metal SC material. In recent years, research on SC electrode materials of Co3O4, Co(OH)2, MnCo2O4, NiCo2O4, ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> and their derivatives have been widely reported.

#### *2.1. Cobalt Oxide*

In recent years, transition metal oxides have attracted more and more attention as electrode materials with ultra-high electrochemical activity for SCs [32–38]. Among various transition metal oxides, Co3O<sup>4</sup> electrode materials and related composites have been widely studied because of their high specific capacitance, low price, and environmental friendliness. In addition, the Co3O<sup>4</sup> electrode material, with special microstructure and morphology, has excellent electrochemical capacitance behavior.

At present, several processes are used to prepare Co3O4, the common ones being hydrothermal [39,40], electrochemical deposition [41], thermal decomposition [42], and sol-gel methods [43]. The hydrothermal method is a process in which the dissolution and recrystallization of insoluble substances occurs in a closed reactor at high temperature and pressure. Experimental parameters, such as temperature, time and molar ratio of additives, have been found to have a significant effect on the morphology of the product [44]. Electrochemical deposition is another important method to prepare electrode materials. During the deposition process, electrical energy can provide a strong driving force for the redox reaction, thus ensuring the uniform growth of electrode materials on conductive substrates, such as stainless steel, nickel foam, and carbon cloth [45–47]. Meanwhile, the conductive substrate is used as the working electrode, and deposition conditions such as scan rate, number of cycles, electrolyte concentration and pH are used as control parameters to achieve high surface area and uniform deposition. On the other hand, the thermal decomposition method usually relies on the conversion of certain substances at high temperatures to achieve the modification of electrode materials. This avoids complex multiple synthesis steps and minimizes the use of solvents, making it simple and environmentally friendly. As for the sol-gel method, the process can be described as follows: precursors such as metal alcohol salts or inorganic compounds are hydrolyzed under certain conditions to form a stable and transparent sol system, then are agglomerated into a gel, and finally dried and sintered to form a solid. The advantages of this method are

low reaction temperature, easy control of the reaction, and high homogeneity of the sample down to the molecular or atomic level. The shape and size of the nanoparticles are usually controlled by adjusting the ratio of raw materials and the initial pH of the solution. the molecular or atomic level. The shape and size of the nanoparticles are usually controlled by adjusting the ratio of raw materials and the initial pH of the solution.

#### 2.1.1. Co3O<sup>4</sup> 2.1.1. Co3O4

As mentioned above, Co3O<sup>4</sup> as a transition metal oxide, has a theoretical specific capacitance of 3560 F g−<sup>1</sup> , good reversibility, and excellent electrochemical properties [48]. Therefore, it is one of the most attractive electrode materials for SCs. However, the capacitive degradation of Co3O<sup>4</sup> at high current densities results in its poor reversibility [49,50]. This phenomenon leads to the actual obtained Co3O<sup>4</sup> specific capacitance being much lower than the theoretical value, so the application of Co3O<sup>4</sup> in SCs is severely limited. It has been reported that the electrochemical performance of Co3O<sup>4</sup> can be greatly improved by regulating the micromorphology of Co3O4. As mentioned above, Co3O4 as a transition metal oxide, has a theoretical specific capacitance of 3560 F g‒1, good reversibility, and excellent electrochemical properties [48]. Therefore, it is one of the most attractive electrode materials for SCs. However, the capacitive degradation of Co3O4 at high current densities results in its poor reversibility [49,50]. This phenomenon leads to the actual obtained Co3O4 specific capacitance being much lower than the theoretical value, so the application of Co3O4 in SCs is severely limited. It has been reported that the electrochemical performance of Co3O4 can be greatly improved by regulating the micromorphology of Co3O4.

In recent years, various morphologies of Co3O<sup>4</sup> have been synthesized by different methods (shown in Figure 2), such as Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanofibers [51], layered Co3O<sup>4</sup> [52], Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanoparticles [53], Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanorod arrays [54], core-shell Co3O<sup>4</sup> [55], porous Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanowires [56], and hollow coral-shaped Co3O<sup>4</sup> [57]. Several Co3O<sup>4</sup> electrode materials with typical morphologies are briefly described below, including their preparation processes, unique spatial structures, and their principles. For the convenience of readers, the electrical property data of these materials is listed separately in Table 1. In recent years, various morphologies of Co3O4 have been synthesized by different methods (shown in Figure 2), such as Co3O4 nanofibers [51], layered Co3O4 [52], Co3O4 nanoparticles [53], Co3O4 nanorod arrays [54], core-shell Co3O4 [55], porous Co3O4 nanowires [56], and hollow coral-shaped Co3O4 [57]. Several Co3O4 electrode materials with typical morphologies are briefly described below, including their preparation processes, unique spatial structures, and their principles. For the convenience of readers, the electrical property data of these materials is listed separately in Table 1.

**Figure 2.** Various morphologies of Co3O4. (**a**) Nano fibers; reprinted with permission from ref. [51]. (**b**) Layered Co3O4; reprinted with permission from ref. [52]. (**c**) Nano particles; reprinted with permission from ref. [53]. (**d**) Nanorod arrays; reprinted with permission from ref. [54]. (**e**) Core-shell Co3O4; reprinted with permission from ref. [55]. (**f**) Nano wires; reprinted with permission from ref. [56]. (**g**) Hollow coral shape; reprinted with permission from ref. [57]. **Figure 2.** Various morphologies of Co3O<sup>4</sup> . (**a**) Nano fibers; reprinted with permission from ref. [51]. (**b**) Layered Co3O<sup>4</sup> ; reprinted with permission from ref. [52]. (**c**) Nano particles; reprinted with permission from ref. [53]. (**d**) Nanorod arrays; reprinted with permission from ref. [54]. (**e**) Core-shell Co3O<sup>4</sup> ; reprinted with permission from ref. [55]. (**f**) Nano wires; reprinted with permission from ref. [56]. (**g**) Hollow coral shape; reprinted with permission from ref. [57].

**Cycling Performance** 

**(Cycles, Current Density) Year Ref.** 

**Morphology Specific Capacitance** 

**Table 1.** Electrochemical properties of each microscopic morphology.


**Table 1.** Electrochemical properties of each microscopic morphology.

Manish Kumar et al. prepared Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanofibers (shown in Figure 2a) by electrospinning technology [51]. Due to the large specific surface area and unique porous network morphology of this structure, the electrolyte solution can better contact with the electrode material. This is conducive to the transport of ions and electrons at the electrode-electrolyte interface, thus accelerating the redox progress. Duan et al. synthesized layered porous Co3O<sup>4</sup> films by a hydrothermal method [52]. As shown in Figure 2b, the prepared Co3O<sup>4</sup> films display a two-layer structure in which the lower structure consists of an array of Co3O<sup>4</sup> monolayer hollow spheres and the upper structure consists of porous mesh-like Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanosheets. The high porosity and large specific surface area provide a short path for ion/electron transfer, and the close contact between the active material and the electrolyte leads to high electrochemical activity, which enhances the pseudocapacitive performance. In addition, the graded porous structure can also moderate the volume changes caused by redox reactions, thus improving cycling performance. Deng et al. synthesized cobalt oxides (Co3O<sup>4</sup> and Co3O4/CoO) by burning a mixture of Co(NO3)2·6H2O and citric acid (Figure 2c) [53]. They experimentally confirmed that the morphology of the electrode materials could be influenced by adjusting the citric acid/Co(NO3)2·6H2O molar ratio. Based on this, they produced electrode materials with the best performance. As shown in Figure 2d, unique Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanorod arrays were synthesized through a simple chemical bath deposition and annealing process by Chen et al. [54]. Due to their high specific surface area and novel structure, the specific capacitance of Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanorod arrays is high. It was found that Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanorod arrays have good cycling stability, conductivity, and ion diffusion behavior. Liu et al. prepared Co3O<sup>4</sup> mesoporous nanospheres with a homogeneous core-shell by the solvothermal and rapid calcination methods (Figure 2e) [55]. The accumulation density of sub-nanoparticles and the thickness of Co3O<sup>4</sup> shell layer can be controlled by changing the annealing time. Both the tunable mesoporous and core-shell structures can facilitate the ion and electron transport efficiently while adapting to the volume change of the oxide electrode during cycling. Xu et al. successfully prepared one-dimensional porous Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanowires by thermal decomposition of coordination polymers with nitrilotriacetic acid as a chelating agent using a solvothermal method (Figure 2f) [56]. The porous structure of Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanowires consists of many nanoparticles. The special structure maximizes the exposure of the active material to the alkaline electrolyte, resulting in high specific capacity and good cycling stability. Wang et al. obtained hollow coral-shaped Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanostructures by calcining cobalt oxalate precursors in the air (Figure 2g) [57]. The hollow structure allows it to withstand volume changes during the reaction process and thus exhibits excellent cycling performance.

Starting from improving the contact area between electrode and electrolyte, Lu et al. prepared layered Co3O<sup>4</sup> electrode material by combining 2-methylimidazole cobalt salt and electro-spun nanofibers [58]. Its unique three-dimensional (3D) network and nano porous structure reduced the ion diffusion distance and increased the contact area between electrode and electrolyte, thus improving its electrochemical performance. The synthesized

Co3O<sup>4</sup> electrode can provide a high specific capacitance of 970 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , an energy density of 54.6 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at a power density of 360.6 W kg−<sup>1</sup> , and a capacitance retention rate of 77.5% after 5000 cycles at 6 A g−<sup>1</sup> .

The above study showed that the electrochemical performance of Co3O<sup>4</sup> can be significantly improved by adjusting its morphology. By designing a unique structure, the contact area can be increased, and the close contact between the active material and the electrolyte can lead to high electrochemical activity, which enhances the pseudocapacitive performance. In addition, the graded porous structure can also moderate the volume changes caused by redox reactions, thus improving the cycling performance.

### 2.1.2. Co3O<sup>4</sup> Composites

To further improve the performance of Co3O4, and meet the needs of various applications, one of the main means is to prepare Co3O<sup>4</sup> composites by anchoring Co3O<sup>4</sup> on a carbon-based material with high electrical conductivity. Among many carbon-based materials, graphene with large specific area, unique mechanical, and excellent electrochemical properties is considered to be an ideal carrier for loading Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanostructures [59]. Therefore, graphene-based Co3O<sup>4</sup> composites have become a research hotspot in recent years. For example, Tan et al. made self-supporting and non-adhesive Co3O<sup>4</sup> nano sheet arrays/graphene/Ni hybrid foams by in-situ synthesis of graphene and Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanosheets on nickel foam [60]. The SEM image shows that the porous structure supported by the composite remain good. At the same time, the substrate is completely covered by Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanosheets and there is no agglomeration. This self-supporting and adhesive free characteristic avoids the disadvantage of the high resistance of traditional graphene-based Co3O<sup>4</sup> composites due to the contact between hybrid particles, additives, adhesives, and collectors. The cycle performance of Co3O<sup>4</sup> nano sheet/graphene/Ni hybrid electrode has been studied. It was found that after 5000 cycles at a current density of 10 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , it had 112.2% of the initial capacitance. This indicates that the ability of this unique Co3O<sup>4</sup> nano sheet/graphene/Ni hybrid electrode can meet the requirements of good capacity and long cycle life at high current density.

Younis et al. synthesized Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanosheets by one-step electrochemical deposition on carbon foam followed by annealing [41]. The electrochemical properties of the Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanosheets were improved due to the good electrical conductivity of the composite carbon foam. In addition, a dense mesoporous structure could be observed in the SEM images, which may be one of the main reasons for the improved electrochemical properties. Electrochemical tests showed that the prepared Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanosheets had ideal capacitive properties with a maximum specific capacitance of 106 F g−<sup>1</sup> in 1 M NaOH solution at a scan rate of 0.5 V s−<sup>1</sup> . In this report, the prepared ultrathin nanosheets were simple in process, low in cost, and suitable for industrial applications, which have high reference value.

Introducing oxygen vacancies into transition metal oxides can change their geometric and electronic structures, improve their intrinsic conductivity and electrochemical activity, and improve their properties [61–64]. For example, Xiang and others prepared Co3O<sup>4</sup> nano sheet electrode materials with different oxygen vacancy content by different reduction methods [65]. They showed that Co3O<sup>4</sup> electrode with high oxygen vacancy content has better electrochemical performance. At the current density of 2 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the capacity retention percentage can reach 95% after 3000 cycles, while the capacitance retention rate of the original Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanosheet electrode was only 90% under the same conditions. This indicates that the introduction of oxygen vacancy can improve the conductivity, increase the capacitance, and significantly improve the electrochemical performance.

Yang et al. used the one-step laser irradiation method for the first time to synthesize ultrafine Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanoparticles/graphene composites with rich oxygen vacancies by laserinduced reduction and fragmentation [66]. Compared with the traditional method, the one-step laser irradiation method is simple, does not need to add reducing agents and additives, and solves the pollution problem of organic additives. At 10 A g−<sup>1</sup> current density, the capacitance retention of the composites after 2000 cycles could reach 99.3%, while the capacitance retention of porous Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanorods electrodes was only about 84.7%, indicating that Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanoparticles/graphene composites have excellent cycle stability.

### *2.2. Co(OH)<sup>2</sup>*

Similar to transition metal oxides, transition metal hydroxides have excellent pseudocapacitive properties [67]. Among them, Co(OH)<sup>2</sup> has become one of the promising materials in SCs due to its high theoretical capacitance (3460 F g−<sup>1</sup> ) and low cost. With electrode materials, reversible redox reactions take place during charge and discharge. The specific process is that Co(OH)<sup>2</sup> stores charge by participating in the O-H bond breaking and recombination reaction in the electrolyte. The redox reaction can be expressed as [68]:

$$\text{Co(OH)}\_{2} + \text{OH}^{-} \rightarrow \text{Co(OH)} + \text{H}\_{2}\text{O} + \text{e}^{-} \tag{1}$$

The oxidation product CoOOH can further undergo a deprotonation reaction and carry out the second redox reaction [22]:

$$\text{CoOOH} + \text{OH}^- \rightarrow \text{CoO}\_2 + \text{H}\_2\text{O} + \text{e}^- \tag{2}$$

Although the theoretical capacitance of Co(OH)<sup>2</sup> is very high, it is difficult to meet the requirements of fast electron transport rate at high power density because it is a Ptype semiconductor. An effective way to alleviate the above problems is to construct conductive matrix hybrid nanostructures of Co(OH)2. For example, Pan et al. synthesized Co(OH)2/Ni nano-lake array with porous structure by hydrothermal and electrodeposition methods [69]; its microstructure is shown in Figure 3. As a conductive substrate, nickel foam forms a porous conductive network, which can shorten the diffusion path of ions and electrons, and improve the charge efficiency, thus effectively improving the electrochemical performance of SC. When the charge and discharge rate changes from 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> to 40 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the capacitance retention rate reaches 87.6%, while that of pure Co(OH)<sup>2</sup> nano-lake array is only 76.4% under the same conditions.

Li et al. prepared a 3D independent Co(OH)2/Ni heterostructure electrode by depositing sea urchin-like Co(OH)<sup>2</sup> microspheres on nickel foam using a one-step hydrothermal method [70]. According to the analysis of its electrochemical performance, the capacitance could reach 1916 F g−<sup>1</sup> at 10 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , and 79.3% of the original capacitance was maintained after 5000 charge and discharge cycles at 80 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> current density. The reason for this decrease in capacitance is that some sea urchin-like Co(OH)<sup>2</sup> microspheres become inconspicuous rod-like and stacked plate-like CoOOH due to changes in composition and structure during charging and discharging.

To improve the density of SCs while maintaining their flexibility, Zhao and his colleagues deposited Co(OH)<sup>2</sup> on nickel oxide/hydroxide coated nano porous nickel (np-NiOxHy@Ni) by electrochemical deposition [71]. Then they successfully synthesized a Co(OH)2/np-NiOxHy@Ni hybrid electrode with a hierarchical porous structure and excellent flexibility. The layered porous structure improves the surface area and effectively promotes ion diffusion. At the same time, the coordination between Co(OH)<sup>2</sup> and NiOxH<sup>y</sup> electroactive materials significantly improves the electrochemical reaction activity of electrode materials. The capacitance of Co(OH)2/np-NiOxHy@Ni electrode was 1421.1 F cm−<sup>3</sup> at 0.5 A cm−<sup>3</sup> current density, and 81.6% of the original capacitance remained after 8000 cycles at 2 A cm−<sup>3</sup> current density.

#### Li et al. prepared a 3D independent Co(OH)2/Ni heterostructure electrode by depos-*2.3. Cobalt-Containing Ternary Metal Oxide*

iting sea urchin-like Co(OH)2 microspheres on nickel foam using a one-step hydrothermal method [70]. According to the analysis of its electrochemical performance, the capacitance could reach 1916 F g−1 at 10 mA cm−2, and 79.3% of the original capacitance was maintained after 5000 charge and discharge cycles at 80 mA cm−2 current density. The reason for this decrease in capacitance is that some sea urchin-like Co(OH)2 microspheres become inconspicuous rod-like and stacked plate-like CoOOH due to changes in composition and structure during charging and discharging. To improve the density of SCs while maintaining their flexibility, Zhao and his colleagues deposited Co(OH)2 on nickel oxide/hydroxide coated nano porous nickel (np-Ni-OxHy@Ni) by electrochemical deposition [71]. Then they successfully synthesized a Co(OH)2/np-NiOxHy@Ni hybrid electrode with a hierarchical porous structure and excellent flexibility. The layered porous structure improves the surface area and effectively Cobalt-containing ternary metal oxides are typical spinel structures, and the cells of spinel consist of eight small cubic cells, which are four A-type cells and four B-type cells interconnected (Figure 4). Each A-type or B-type unit has four O2<sup>−</sup> for a total of 32. M ions are in the center of the A-type unit (tetrahedral gap) and half of the vertices of the eight small cubic units for a total of eight. Cobalt ions occupy each of four octahedral gaps, for a total of 16. The cell general formula of cobalt-based spinel is M8Co16O32, and the chemical formula is summarized as MCo2O4. Furthermore, in general, the alkaline electrolytes of different Co-based spinel MCo2O<sup>4</sup> (M = Co, Ni, Fe, and Mn) undergo approximately the same reversible electrochemical redox reactions with the discharge products of M ions as hydroxyl oxides MOOH [72–74]. The resulting MOOH (M = Co, Fe, and Mn) further discharges and produces the corresponding CoO<sup>2</sup> [72], FeO<sup>4</sup> <sup>2</sup><sup>−</sup> [75] and MnO2. Because of the presence of Cu(I)/Cu(II) pairs, the discharge products of Zn2+ and Cu2+ are Zn(II) [76] and Cu(I)/Cu(II) [77] hydroxides.

promotes ion diffusion. At the same time, the coordination between Co(OH)2 and NiOxHy

at 0.5 A cm−3 current density, and 81.6% of the original capacitance remained after 8000

cycles at 2 A cm−3 current density.

**Figure 4.** Schematic crystal structure of MCo2O4. **Figure 4.** Schematic crystal structure of MCo2O<sup>4</sup> .

*2.3. Cobalt-Containing Ternary Metal Oxide* 

Cu(I)/Cu(II) [77] hydroxides.

Metal oxides with multiple metal cations generally have higher conductivity and capacitive activity than single metal oxides [78]. Among them, ternary transition metal oxides provide more active sites for redox reaction and improve electronic conductivity because they have two different cations [79]. Compared with binary transition metal oxides such as Co3O4, the electrochemical properties of ternary transition metal oxides (MnCo2O4, NiCo2O4, ZnCo2O4, etc.) are significantly improved under the influence of the synergistic effect generated by the coupling of two transition metals [36]. Metal oxides with multiple metal cations generally have higher conductivity and capacitive activity than single metal oxides [78]. Among them, ternary transition metal oxides provide more active sites for redox reaction and improve electronic conductivity because they have two different cations [79]. Compared with binary transition metal oxides such as Co3O4, the electrochemical properties of ternary transition metal oxides (MnCo2O4, NiCo2O4, ZnCo2O4, etc.) are significantly improved under the influence of the synergistic effect generated by the coupling of two transition metals [36].

Cobalt-containing ternary metal oxides are typical spinel structures, and the cells of spinel consist of eight small cubic cells, which are four A-type cells and four B-type cells interconnected (Figure 4). Each A-type or B-type unit has four O2− for a total of 32. M ions are in the center of the A-type unit (tetrahedral gap) and half of the vertices of the eight small cubic units for a total of eight. Cobalt ions occupy each of four octahedral gaps, for a total of 16. The cell general formula of cobalt-based spinel is M8Co16O32, and the chemical formula is summarized as MCo2O4. Furthermore, in general, the alkaline electrolytes of different Co-based spinel MCo2O4 (M = Co, Ni, Fe, and Mn) undergo approximately the same reversible electrochemical redox reactions with the discharge products of M ions as hydroxyl oxides MOOH [72–74]. The resulting MOOH (M = Co, Fe, and Mn) further discharges and produces the corresponding CoO2 [72], FeO42− [75] and MnO2. Because of the presence of Cu(I)/Cu(II) pairs, the discharge products of Zn2+ and Cu2+ are Zn(II) [76] and

#### 2.3.1. MnCo2O4 2.3.1. MnCo2O<sup>4</sup>

MnCo2O4 is a typical compound with a spinel structure. It can show two lattice structures: (a) normal spinel [80,81], (b) anti spinel [82]. Due to the diversity of crystal structure, the variation of charges (Mn and Co) occupied in octahedron and tetrahedron makes it have excellent redox stability [83]. Manganese transmits more electrons and has higher capacity, while cobalt has higher oxidation potential. Many experiments have proved that MnCo2O4 improves the electrochemical performance of single Co3O4 and shows better conductivity, structural stability, and cycle performance [84–86]. The reaction principle of MnCo2O4 is as follows: MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> is a typical compound with a spinel structure. It can show two lattice structures: (a) normal spinel [80,81], (b) anti spinel [82]. Due to the diversity of crystal structure, the variation of charges (Mn and Co) occupied in octahedron and tetrahedron makes it have excellent redox stability [83]. Manganese transmits more electrons and has higher capacity, while cobalt has higher oxidation potential. Many experiments have proved that MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> improves the electrochemical performance of single Co3O<sup>4</sup> and shows better conductivity, structural stability, and cycle performance [84–86]. The reaction principle of MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> is as follows:

$$\mathrm{MnCo\_2O\_4} + \mathrm{OH^-} + \mathrm{H\_2O} \to \mathrm{MnOOH} + 2\mathrm{CoOHH} + \mathrm{e^-} \tag{3}$$

$$\text{MnOOH} + \text{OH}^- \rightarrow \text{MnO}\_2 + \text{H}\_2\text{O} + \text{e}^- \tag{4}$$

$$\text{CoOOH} + \text{OH}^- \rightarrow \text{CoO}\_2 + \text{H}\_2\text{O} + \text{e}^- \tag{5}$$

MnCo2O4 reacts under alkaline conditions to form MnOOH and CoOOH, and the resulting MnOOH and CoOOH continue to react with OH− to form MnO2 and CoO2, while releasing electrons. MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> reacts under alkaline conditions to form MnOOH and CoOOH, and the resulting MnOOH and CoOOH continue to react with OH− to form MnO<sup>2</sup> and CoO2, while releasing electrons.

Based on the above studies, MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> is considered an ideal candidate material for SCs, so it has been widely studied. Various forms of MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> materials have been prepared, such as flower shaped hollow microspheres [87], core-shell structures [88], nano cages [89], nano needles [90], ellipsoids [91], and sea urchins [92]. For example, Dong et al. synthesized MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> with a hierarchical nanocage structure using a bimetallic zeolite imidazolate framework as the precursor and template [89]. The preparation process and morphological characterization are shown in Figure 5. Through the analysis of its micro morphology, it can be found that many interconnected nanoparticles form a highly porous nanocage structure. This unique nanocage structure exposes a large area of surface and mesoporous structure, which promotes the diffusion of ions and ensures its excellent electrochemical performance in SCs. By testing the electrochemical performance of MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> electrode, it was found that it can show 95% capacitance retention after 4500 cycles at 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , which proves its superior cycle stability. Che et al. synthesized flower-shaped MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> hollow microspheres with a nano flower structure by the template free method of mixing and heating the solvent to 180 ◦C [87], and then calcining at 350 ◦C for two hours. An SEM microscopic image is shown in the Figure 6. The larger surface area and porous structure

provide more active sites, promote the transfer of ions and electrons, accelerate the reaction rate, and greatly enhance its electrochemical storage performance. The capacity retention rate of the electrode was 93.6% after 2000 consecutive cycles at a high current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> . hours. An SEM microscopic image is shown in the Figure 6. The larger surface area and porous structure provide more active sites, promote the transfer of ions and electrons, accelerate the reaction rate, and greatly enhance its electrochemical storage performance. The capacity retention rate of the electrode was 93.6% after 2000 consecutive cycles at a high current density of 1 A g−1. MnCo2O4 hollow microspheres with a nano flower structure by the template free method of mixing and heating the solvent to 180 °C [87], and then calcining at 350 °C for two hours. An SEM microscopic image is shown in the Figure 6. The larger surface area and porous structure provide more active sites, promote the transfer of ions and electrons, accelerate the reaction rate, and greatly enhance its electrochemical storage performance.

Based on the above studies, MnCo2O4 is considered an ideal candidate material for SCs, so it has been widely studied. Various forms of MnCo2O4 materials have been prepared, such as flower shaped hollow microspheres [87], core-shell structures [88], nano cages [89], nano needles [90], ellipsoids [91], and sea urchins [92]. For example, Dong et al. synthesized MnCo2O4 with a hierarchical nanocage structure using a bimetallic zeolite imidazolate framework as the precursor and template [89]. The preparation process and morphological characterization are shown in Figure 5. Through the analysis of its micro morphology, it can be found that many interconnected nanoparticles form a highly porous nanocage structure. This unique nanocage structure exposes a large area of surface and mesoporous structure, which promotes the diffusion of ions and ensures its excellent electrochemical performance in SCs. By testing the electrochemical performance of MnCo2O4 electrode, it was found that it can show 95% capacitance retention after 4500 cycles at 1 A g−1, which proves its superior cycle stability. Che et al. synthesized flower-shaped MnCo2O4 hollow microspheres with a nano flower structure by the template free method of mixing and heating the solvent to 180 °C [87], and then calcining at 350 °C for two

Based on the above studies, MnCo2O4 is considered an ideal candidate material for SCs, so it has been widely studied. Various forms of MnCo2O4 materials have been prepared, such as flower shaped hollow microspheres [87], core-shell structures [88], nano cages [89], nano needles [90], ellipsoids [91], and sea urchins [92]. For example, Dong et al. synthesized MnCo2O4 with a hierarchical nanocage structure using a bimetallic zeolite imidazolate framework as the precursor and template [89]. The preparation process and morphological characterization are shown in Figure 5. Through the analysis of its micro morphology, it can be found that many interconnected nanoparticles form a highly porous nanocage structure. This unique nanocage structure exposes a large area of surface and mesoporous structure, which promotes the diffusion of ions and ensures its excellent electrochemical performance in SCs. By testing the electrochemical performance of MnCo2O4 electrode, it was found that it can show 95% capacitance retention after 4500 cycles at 1 A g−1, which proves its superior cycle stability. Che et al. synthesized flower-shaped

*Nanomaterials* **2022**, *12*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 11 of 34

*Nanomaterials* **2022**, *12*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 11 of 34

**Figure 5.** Preparation process of a nanocage MnCo2O4 electrode. Reproduced with permission from Yanying Dong, Facile synthesis of hierarchical nanocage MnCo2O4 for high performance supercapacitor; published by Elsevier, 2016 [89]. **Figure 5.** Preparation process of a nanocage MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> electrode. Reproduced with permission from Yanying Dong, Facile synthesis of hierarchical nanocage MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> for high performance supercapacitor; published by Elsevier, 2016 [89]. **Figure 5.** Preparation process of a nanocage MnCo2O4 electrode. Reproduced with permission from Yanying Dong, Facile synthesis of hierarchical nanocage MnCo2O4 for high performance supercapacitor; published by Elsevier, 2016 [89].

ping (**c**–**e**) taken from the square area marked in Figure 6a. Reproduced with permission from Hongwei Che, Template-free synthesis of novel flower-like MnCo2O4 hollow microspheres for application in supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2016 [87]. **Figure 6.** SEM images (**a**,**b**) of the calcined MnCo2O4 products and the corresponding elements mapping (**c**–**e**) taken from the square area marked in Figure 6a. Reproduced with permission from Hongwei Che, Template-free synthesis of novel flower-like MnCo2O4 hollow microspheres for application in supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2016 [87]. **Figure 6.** SEM images (**a**,**b**) of the calcined MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> products and the corresponding elements mapping (**c**–**e**) taken from the square area marked in Figure 6a. Reproduced with permission from Hongwei Che, Template-free synthesis of novel flower-like MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> hollow microspheres for application in supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2016 [87].

Although the electrochemical performance of an MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> electrode is significantly improved compared with a single Co3O<sup>4</sup> electrode, its development is limited by its poor cycle stability in long-term use. To solve this problem, one of the effective methods is to compound it with some carbonaceous material with light electric power or other pseudocapacitive oxide or hydroxide to improve its cycle stability. For example, Wang et al. synthesized a 3D porous structure based on MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> modified graphene [93]. The specific capacitance reached 503 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> . After 5000 charge-discharge cycles (current density of 10 A g−<sup>1</sup> ), 97.4% of the specific capacitance was retained.

Zhao et al. synthesized an MnCo2O4@Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> multicomponent composite by a stepwise hydrothermal method [88]. The synthesis process is shown in Figure 7. First, layered double hydroxides of cobalt and manganese were generated with hexamethylenetetramine as a structure guide. With the directional attachment process as the driving force, the nanoparticles finally grew into MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanostructures. Then, using nickel chloride and hexamethylenetetramine as the lead solution, an ultra-thin Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> nano sheet was fixed on the nano alloy by hydrothermal method to produce a layered MnCo2O4@Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> core-shell structure. The discharge time of MnCo2O4@Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> was about four times that of MnCo2O4.

**Figure 7.** Schematic illustration of the general electrode design process. Reproduced with permission from Limin Wu, Preparation of MnCo2O4@Ni(OH)2 Core-Shell Flowers for Asymmetric Supercapacitor Materials with Ultrahigh Specific Capacitance; published by Wiley-VCH Verlag, 2016 [88]. **Figure 7.** Schematic illustration of the general electrode design process. Reproduced with permission from Limin Wu, Preparation of MnCo2O4@Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> Core-Shell Flowers for Asymmetric Supercapacitor Materials with Ultrahigh Specific Capacitance; published by Wiley-VCH Verlag, 2016 [88].

Although the electrochemical performance of an MnCo2O4 electrode is significantly improved compared with a single Co3O4 electrode, its development is limited by its poor cycle stability in long-term use. To solve this problem, one of the effective methods is to compound it with some carbonaceous material with light electric power or other pseudocapacitive oxide or hydroxide to improve its cycle stability. For example, Wang et al. synthesized a 3D porous structure based on MnCo2O4 modified graphene [93]. The specific capacitance reached 503 F g−1 at a current density of 1 A g−1. After 5000 charge-discharge

Zhao et al. synthesized an MnCo2O4@Ni(OH)2 multicomponent composite by a stepwise hydrothermal method [88]. The synthesis process is shown in Figure 7. First, layered double hydroxides of cobalt and manganese were generated with hexamethylenetetramine as a structure guide. With the directional attachment process as the driving force, the nanoparticles finally grew into MnCo2O4 nanostructures. Then, using nickel chloride and hexamethylenetetramine as the lead solution, an ultra-thin Ni(OH)2 nano sheet was fixed on the nano alloy by hydrothermal method to produce a layered MnCo2O4@Ni(OH)2 core-shell structure. The discharge time of MnCo2O4@Ni(OH)2 was about four times that

cycles (current density of 10 A g−1), 97.4% of the specific capacitance was retained.

The specific capacitance of activated carbon electrode can reach 328 F g−1 at 0.2 A g−1, and the maximum energy density of asymmetric SC (ASC) can reach 48 W h kg−1 when the mean power density is 1.4 kW kg−1, which is significantly higher than that of most commercial batteries. In addition, the capacitance retention of the hybrid electrode is about 90% after 2500 cycles at a current density of 6 A g−1, and the structure of the nano alloy remains good. The above results show that the electrochemical performance of MnCo2O4 is significantly improved and its cycle stability is higher by compounding MnCo2O4 with Ni(OH)2. As mentioned above, compared with a single MnCo2O4 material, MnCo2O4 com-The specific capacitance of activated carbon electrode can reach 328 F g−<sup>1</sup> at 0.2 A g−<sup>1</sup> , and the maximum energy density of asymmetric SC (ASC) can reach 48 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> when the mean power density is 1.4 kW kg−<sup>1</sup> , which is significantly higher than that of most commercial batteries. In addition, the capacitance retention of the hybrid electrode is about 90% after 2500 cycles at a current density of 6 A g−<sup>1</sup> , and the structure of the nano alloy remains good. The above results show that the electrochemical performance of MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> is significantly improved and its cycle stability is higher by compounding MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> with Ni(OH)2.

pounded with other materials has higher cycle stability and greater prospects. Although the electrochemistry of the material can be improved to some extent by changing the morphology and structure or compounding with other materials, the low conductivity of MnCo2O4 has hindered its wide application as an energy storage device. At the same time, how to accurately control the micro morphology of the composite still needs further exploration. As mentioned above, compared with a single MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> material, MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> compounded with other materials has higher cycle stability and greater prospects. Although the electrochemistry of the material can be improved to some extent by changing the morphology and structure or compounding with other materials, the low conductivity of MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> has hindered its wide application as an energy storage device. At the same time, how to accurately control the micro morphology of the composite still needs further exploration.

### 2.3.2. NiCo2O<sup>4</sup>

of MnCo2O4.

2.3.2. NiCo2O4 As a typical cobalt-containing ternary metal oxide, NiCo2O4 is also a transition metal oxide with a spinel structure. It has the advantages of high electrochemical activity, good conductivity, high theoretical capacitance, low cost, and simple synthesis. Therefore, NiCo2O4 is also one of the most attractive electrode materials in SCs [94–98]. In its structure, nickel ions occupy octahedral sites, and cobalt ions diffuse in octahedral and As a typical cobalt-containing ternary metal oxide, NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> is also a transition metal oxide with a spinel structure. It has the advantages of high electrochemical activity, good conductivity, high theoretical capacitance, low cost, and simple synthesis. Therefore, NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> is also one of the most attractive electrode materials in SCs [94–98]. In its structure, nickel ions occupy octahedral sites, and cobalt ions diffuse in octahedral and tetrahedral sites [99]. The electronic conductivity and electrochemical activity of NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> are significantly higher than those of nickel oxide and cobalt oxide alone due to the synergistic effect of Ni with Co.

At present, various nanostructures of NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> have been prepared, such as nanowires [100], nanosheets [101], nanoflowers [102], and nanorods [103]. Among them, hollow nano materials have a large surface area, large gap and short effective transmission distance of electrolyte ions [104]. They provide more electroactive sites for rapid ion insertion of the whole electrode material and show excellent electrochemical performance. Xu et al. synthesized hollow NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanospheres with a layered structure [104]. When using them as electrodes, the specific capacitance at 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> is 1229 F g−<sup>1</sup> , which is higher than that of NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> hollow spheres (1036 F g−<sup>1</sup> at 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> ) [105], NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> hollow spheres (1141 F g−<sup>1</sup> at 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> ) [106], hollow NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> sub microspheres (678 F g−<sup>1</sup> at 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> ) [107], urchin-like NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> hollow microspheres (942.2 F g−<sup>1</sup> at 0.5 A g−<sup>1</sup> ) [108], and mesoporous NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> hollow microspheres (987 F g−<sup>1</sup> at 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> ) [109]. After 3000 cycles at 50 mV s−<sup>1</sup> , the total specific capacitance retention of hollow NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanosphere electrode is 86.3%, while the total specific capacitance retention of NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> microsphere electrode is 83.7%.

Although hollow microspheres can effectively improve surface area, the single-structure NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> electrode material still has the disadvantages of low conductivity, limited kinetics,

and poor electrochemical performance [110–114]. To improve its electrochemical performance, constructing NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> layered nanostructure composites has become an important means [115–119]. For example, Zhou and others synthesized 3D porous graphene/NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> hybrid films with copper oxide as a template [120]. Its unique 3D porous structure can store many electrolytes and provide rich active centers, thus improving the electrochemical performance. At 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the specific capacitance can reach 708.36 F g−<sup>1</sup> . After 6000 cycles at 10 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the initial capacitance of 94.3% is maintained. Li et al. prepared flower-like hollow C@MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> with high specific surface area. At a discharge current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the discharge capacitance reached 728.4 F g−<sup>1</sup> , and after 1000 cycles at 8 A g−<sup>1</sup> the initial capacitance retention of the composite was 95.9% [121]. Zhao et al. synthesized ultra-thin NiCo2O4/NiO nanosheets grown on silicon nitride [122]. After 2000 cycles at 20 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> current density, the specific capacitance retention was 90.9%, and the energy density was 60 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> when the power density was 1.66 kW kg−<sup>1</sup> . Cheng et al. prepared a 3D layered NiCo2O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> nuclear shell nanowires/nanowire sheet array on nickel foam, with a capacitance retention rate of 85.2% after 3000 cycles at a current density of 20 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> [123]. After a long cycle, the volume resistance of the ASC device increased slightly from the initial 0.40 Ω to 0.42 Ω. The above shows that the prepared composites have good cycle stability. Lee et al. synthesized MnCo2O4-NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> composite with layered nanostructure by one-step chemical bath deposition method [124]. When used as an electrode, the specific capacitance reached 1152 F g−<sup>1</sup> at 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> . After 3000 cycles at 6 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the specific capacitance retention of the composite was 95.38%, while NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> is 86.14% and MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> was 61.65%, indicating that the composite of the two materials significantly increased the cycle stability of the material.

The electrochemical properties of the above NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> composite have been significantly improved. However, due to lattice mismatch between NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> and other components, this leads to poor structural stability, lower specific capacitance and cycle life. Therefore, Wang et al. compounded NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> and NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> with the same lattice type to prepare 3D delamination NiCo2O4@NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> [94]. The preparation process of the core-shell nano cone array is shown in Figure 8. First, NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> is grown vertically on nickel foam by hydrothermal method. After annealing, neat NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> nano-cone arrays is formed first. Then, the NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanosheet is coated on the NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> surface formed in the previous step. Finally, layered core-shell NiCo2O4@NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanostructures are fabricated on nickel foams after subsequent annealing.

After 21,000 cycles at 4 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the capacitance retention rate of the electrode reached 85.3%, and the structure did not change significantly during charge and discharge. When used in SCs, NiCo2O4@NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> core-shell nanostructure had a capacitance of 2045.2 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , which is better than the single component of NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanosheet (346.4 F g−<sup>1</sup> ) and NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> nano cone (1381.8 F g−<sup>1</sup> ).

### 2.3.3. ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup>

Similar to MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> and NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> mentioned above, ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> has the advantages of high theoretical capacitance, high conductivity, environmental friendliness, and low cost, and is considered as a potential SC material [125]. At present, ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> materials with various nanostructures, such as nanowires [126], nanosheets [127,128] nanoparticles [129], and nanospheres [130,131], have been prepared. For example, Wang and colleagues synthesized ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowire electrode materials grown on nickel foam [132]. First, the precursor ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowire arrays were grown on nickel foam by a hydrothermal reaction and then calcined in air. Finally, ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowire arrays supported by nickel foam were obtained. The synthesized ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowires have a porous structure, which makes the material have large specific surface area and can promote the diffusion of reactants. The prepared ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowire/nickel foam electrode had a specific capacitance of 1625 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 5 A g−<sup>1</sup> , and 94% of the original capacitance was maintained after 5000 cycles at 20 A g−<sup>1</sup> .

**Figure 8.** Schematic of the fabrication process for 3D NiCo2O4@NiCo2O4 hierarchical core-shell NCAs on Ni foam. Reproduced with permission from Xiuhua Wang, Three-Dimensional NiCo2O4@NiCo2O4 Core-Shell Nanocones Arrays for High-Performance Supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2018 [94]. **Figure 8.** Schematic of the fabrication process for 3D NiCo2O4@NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> hierarchical coreshell NCAs on Ni foam. Reproduced with permission from Xiuhua Wang, Three-Dimensional NiCo2O4@NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> Core-Shell Nanocones Arrays for High-Performance Supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2018 [94].

After 21,000 cycles at 4 A g−1, the capacitance retention rate of the electrode reached 85.3%, and the structure did not change significantly during charge and discharge. When used in SCs, NiCo2O4@NiCo2O4 core-shell nanostructure had a capacitance of 2045.2 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−1, which is better than the single component of NiCo2O4 nanosheet (346.4 F g−1) and NiCo2O4 nano cone (1381.8 F g−1). 2.3.3. ZnCo2O4 Similar to MnCo2O4 and NiCo2O4 mentioned above, ZnCo2O4 has the advantages of high theoretical capacitance, high conductivity, environmental friendliness, and low cost, and is considered as a potential SC material [125]. At present, ZnCo2O4 materials with various nanostructures, such as nanowires [126], nanosheets [127,128] nanoparticles [129], and nanospheres [130,131], have been prepared. For example, Wang and colleagues synthesized ZnCo2O4 nanowire electrode materials grown on nickel foam [132]. First, the precursor ZnCo2O4 nanowire arrays were grown on nickel foam by a hydrothermal reaction and then calcined in air. Finally, ZnCo2O4 nanowire arrays supported by nickel foam were Xu et al. prepared a ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanostructure with a porous structure and found that the conversion between nanosheets and nanowires was obtained by regulating hydrothermal temperature [133]. When the current density was 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> had a specific capacitance of 776.2 F g−<sup>1</sup> , and the energy density was 84.48 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> when the mean power density was 0.4 kW kg−<sup>1</sup> . It had 84.3% capacity retention after 1500 cycles (3 A g−<sup>1</sup> ). Venkatachalam et al. prepared hexagonal-like ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanomaterials by a simple hydrothermal method [134]. The prepared electrode materials had a specific capacitance of 845.7 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , and retained 95.3% of the original capacitance after 5000 cycles at 5 A g−<sup>1</sup> . Shang et al. synthesized 3D layered peony flower-like ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> electrode nanomaterials by a simple solvothermal method and annealing without additives [135]. The microstructure is shown in Figure 9. The assembled ASC ZnCo2O4//active carbon had an energy density of 29.76 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at a power density of 398.53 W kg−<sup>1</sup> . In addition, the peony-shaped ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> electrode material had a specific capacitance of 440 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , and the capacitance was maintained at 155.6% after 3000 cycles (2 A g−<sup>1</sup> ).

obtained. The synthesized ZnCo2O4 nanowires have a porous structure, which makes the material have large specific surface area and can promote the diffusion of reactants. The prepared ZnCo2O4 nanowire/nickel foam electrode had a specific capacitance of 1625 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 5 A g−1, and 94% of the original capacitance was maintained after 5000 cycles at 20 A g−1. Xu et al. prepared a ZnCo2O4 nanostructure with a porous structure and found that the conversion between nanosheets and nanowires was obtained by regulating hydrothermal temperature [133]. When the current density was 1 A g−1, ZnCo2O4 had a specific capacitance of 776.2 F g−1, and the energy density was 84.48 W h kg−1 when the mean power density was 0.4 kW kg−1. It had 84.3% capacity retention after 1500 cycles (3 A g−1). Venkatachalam et al. prepared hexagonal-like ZnCo2O4 nanomaterials by a simple hydrothermal method [134]. The prepared electrode materials had a specific capacitance of 845.7 F g−1 at a current density of 1 A g−1, and retained 95.3% of the original capacitance after 5000 cycles at 5 A g−1. Shang et al. synthesized 3D layered peony flower-like ZnCo2O4 electrode nano-Although the above nano ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> materials have specific applications in SCs, the insufficient utilization efficiency and poor conductivity of the materials limit their electrochemical properties to a certain extent and there are difficulties in them meeting the needs of practical applications. To solve this problem, one of the commonly used methods is to introduce oxygen vacancies. The existence of an oxygen vacancy can significantly improve the conductivity of ZnCo2O4, adjust the electronic structure, increase the active sites, and promote the electrochemical performance of SCs. For example, Xiang and his colleagues prepared two-dimensional (2D) ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanosheets rich in oxygen vacancies [136]. The nanoscale thickness and large surface area effectively improved the utilization of the electrode while promoting electron transfer. A specific capacitance of 2111 F g−<sup>1</sup> was attained at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , while the specific capacitance of the original ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nano sheet at the same current density was only 1121 F g−<sup>1</sup> . When the power density was 160 W kg−<sup>1</sup> , the energy density of ASC constructed by ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanosheet (with oxygen vacancy)//activated carbon is 34.6 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> , and 93% of the original capacitance was maintained after 3000 cycles at 2 A g−<sup>1</sup> .

materials by a simple solvothermal method and annealing without additives [135]. The microstructure is shown in Figure 9. The assembled ASC ZnCo2O4//active carbon had an energy density of 29.76 W h kg−1 at a power density of 398.53 W kg−1. In addition, the peony-shaped ZnCo2O4 electrode material had a specific capacitance of 440 F g−1 at a Combining ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanostructures with conductive metal or carbon materials to construct composites is one of the methods to alleviate the above problems. For example, Wu et al. synthesized a series of ZnCo2O4@Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> nanostructures grown on nickel foam by a two-step hydrothermal method; the preparation process is shown in Figure 10 [137].

First, the ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowires were uniformly covered on the nickel foam by a hydrothermal method and then Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> nanosheets were grown on the ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowire after a second hydrothermal reaction. ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowires were used as the substrate and Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> nanosheets were used as the upper layer. The strong binding force between them reduced the contact resistance and promote the transfer of electrons to enhance the electrochemical reaction activity of the material. The synthesized hybrid structure was used to fabricate capacitors with an energy density of 57.3 W kg−<sup>1</sup> at 4675.3 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> , and an initial capacitance of 48.6 C g−<sup>1</sup> at 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , which retained 90.5% after 10,000 cycles at the same current density. *Nanomaterials* **2022**, *12*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 15 of 34 current density of 1 A g−1, and the capacitance was maintained at 155.6% after 3000 cycles (2 A g−1).

**Figure 9.** SEM images of ZnCo-preprepared with different reaction times: (**a**) 4 h, (**b**) 6 h, (**c**) 12 h, (**d**) 18 h, (**e**) 21 h, and (**f**) 24 h. Reproduced with permission from Liangyu Shang, Self-assembled hierarchical peony-like ZnCo2O4 for high-performance asymmetric supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2017 [135]. **Figure 9.** SEM images of ZnCo-preprepared with different reaction times: (**a**) 4 h, (**b**) 6 h, (**c**) 12 h, (**d**) 18 h, (**e**) 21 h, and (**f**) 24 h. Reproduced with permission from Liangyu Shang, Self-assembled hierarchical peony-like ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> for high-performance asymmetric supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2017 [135]. *Nanomaterials* **2022**, *12*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 16 of 34

by a two-step hydrothermal method; the preparation process is shown in Figure 10 [137]. First, the ZnCo2O4 nanowires were uniformly covered on the nickel foam by a hydrothermal method and then Ni(OH)2 nanosheets were grown on the ZnCo2O4 nanowire after a second hydrothermal reaction. ZnCo2O4 nanowires were used as the substrate and Ni(OH)2 nanosheets were used as the upper layer. The strong binding force between them **Figure 10.** Synthesis schematic of synthesized ZnCo2O4@Ni(OH)2 samples. Reproduced with permission from Meizhen Dai, Ni Foam Substrates Modified with a ZnCo2O4 Nanowire-Coated Ni(OH)2 Nanosheet Electrode for Hybrid Capacitors and Electrocatalysts; published by ACS Publications, 2021 [137]. **Figure 10.** Synthesis schematic of synthesized ZnCo2O4@Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> samples. Reproduced with permission from Meizhen Dai, Ni Foam Substrates Modified with a ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> Nanowire-Coated Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> Nanosheet Electrode for Hybrid Capacitors and Electrocatalysts; published by ACS Publications, 2021 [137].

reduced the contact resistance and promote the transfer of electrons to enhance the electrochemical reaction activity of the material. The synthesized hybrid structure was used to fabricate capacitors with an energy density of 57.3 W kg−1 at 4675.3 W h kg−1, and an

Xie et al. synthesized a ZnCo2O4@ZnWO4 nanowire array with a core-shell structure on nickel foam, and the synergistic effect between ZnCo2O4 nanowire and ZnWO4 sheet effectively improved the electrochemical performance of hybrid electrode [138]. The syn-

owires are first grown on nickel foam, and then ZnWO4 nanosheets arrays are produced by a simple hydrothermal method using ZnCo2O4 nanowires as skeletons. The constructed ZnCo2O4@ZnWO4//active carbon ASC had an energy density of 24 W h kg−1 at a power density of 400 W kg−1. The original capacitance retention was 98.5% after 5000 cy-

**Figure 11.** Schematic illustrating the fabrication process of the ZnCo2O4@ZnWO4 core-shell nanowire arrays on a nickel foam substrate. Reproduced with permission from Li Xie, Core-shell structured ZnCo2O4@ZnWO4 nanowire arrays on nickel foam for advanced asymmetric supercapacitors;

Table 2 summarizes the structure, specific capacity and cycling performance of MnCo2O4, NiCo2O4 and ZnCo2O4. The electrochemical performance of the electrodes was significantly improved after designing unique morphologies for the materials. By constructing effective structures, such as spherical, rod-like, and hollow structures, the

cles at a current density of 100 mA cm−2.

published by Elsevier, 2018 [138].

same current density.

cations, 2021 [137].

Xie et al. synthesized a ZnCo2O4@ZnWO<sup>4</sup> nanowire array with a core-shell structure on nickel foam, and the synergistic effect between ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowire and ZnWO<sup>4</sup> sheet effectively improved the electrochemical performance of hybrid electrode [138]. The synthesis process is like that of ZnCo2O4@Ni(OH)2. As shown in Figure 11, ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowires are first grown on nickel foam, and then ZnWO<sup>4</sup> nanosheets arrays are produced by a simple hydrothermal method using ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanowires as skeletons. The constructed ZnCo2O4@ZnWO4//active carbon ASC had an energy density of 24 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at a power density of 400 W kg−<sup>1</sup> . The original capacitance retention was 98.5% after 5000 cycles at a current density of 100 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> . Xie et al. synthesized a ZnCo2O4@ZnWO4 nanowire array with a core-shell structure on nickel foam, and the synergistic effect between ZnCo2O4 nanowire and ZnWO4 sheet effectively improved the electrochemical performance of hybrid electrode [138]. The synthesis process is like that of ZnCo2O4@Ni(OH)2. As shown in Figure 11, ZnCo2O4 nanowires are first grown on nickel foam, and then ZnWO4 nanosheets arrays are produced by a simple hydrothermal method using ZnCo2O4 nanowires as skeletons. The constructed ZnCo2O4@ZnWO4//active carbon ASC had an energy density of 24 W h kg−1 at a power density of 400 W kg−1. The original capacitance retention was 98.5% after 5000 cycles at a current density of 100 mA cm−2.

**Figure 10.** Synthesis schematic of synthesized ZnCo2O4@Ni(OH)2 samples. Reproduced with permission from Meizhen Dai, Ni Foam Substrates Modified with a ZnCo2O4 Nanowire-Coated Ni(OH)2 Nanosheet Electrode for Hybrid Capacitors and Electrocatalysts; published by ACS Publi-

*Nanomaterials* **2022**, *12*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 16 of 34

**Figure 11.** Schematic illustrating the fabrication process of the ZnCo2O4@ZnWO4 core-shell nanowire arrays on a nickel foam substrate. Reproduced with permission from Li Xie, Core-shell structured ZnCo2O4@ZnWO4 nanowire arrays on nickel foam for advanced asymmetric supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2018 [138]. **Figure 11.** Schematic illustrating the fabrication process of the ZnCo2O4@ZnWO<sup>4</sup> core-shell nanowire arrays on a nickel foam substrate. Reproduced with permission from Li Xie, Core-shell structured ZnCo2O4@ZnWO<sup>4</sup> nanowire arrays on nickel foam for advanced asymmetric supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2018 [138].

Table 2 summarizes the structure, specific capacity and cycling performance of MnCo2O4, NiCo2O4 and ZnCo2O4. The electrochemical performance of the electrodes was significantly improved after designing unique morphologies for the materials. By constructing effective structures, such as spherical, rod-like, and hollow structures, the Table 2 summarizes the structure, specific capacity and cycling performance of MnCo2O4, NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> and ZnCo2O4. The electrochemical performance of the electrodes was significantly improved after designing unique morphologies for the materials. By constructing effective structures, such as spherical, rod-like, and hollow structures, the contact area can be increased, resulting in close contact between the active material and the electrolyte, which leads to high electrochemical activity and enhanced pseudocapacitive performance. In addition, the porous structure can alleviate the volume change caused by the redox reaction, thus improving the cycle performance, so the materials in the table are often designed as porous structures. Among the various unique morphologies, 2D microstructures are an important category because such structures increase the contact area between the electrolyte and the electrode material. For example, Younis et al. designed various micro morphologies including nanowires, nanocables, nano-micro biscuits, and micro-walls [139]. Among them, nano-micro biscuits with distinct 2D structural features exhibited the best electrochemical performance. Xiang et al. designed ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanosheets with nanoscale thickness and large surface area, which could improve the electron transfer efficiency and electrode utilization [136]. In addition, Zhang et al. prepared NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanosheets with a more ordered crystal structure, high specific surface area and diffusion channels [140]. Liu et al. prepared MnCo2O<sup>4</sup> with a nanoflower-like morphology and porous structure [141]. Because of its unique nanostructure, the prepared electrode had high capacity and good rate performance. In conclusion, 2D nanostructures usually have a large surface area and dense porous structure. This structure is beneficial to increase the contact area between electrolyte and electrode, thus improving the electron transfer efficiency.


**Table 2.** Summary of materials, structures, and electrochemical properties of cobalt-containing ternary metal oxides.

#### *2.4. Cobalt-Containing Ternary Metal Oxide Derivatives*

As mentioned above, cobalt-containing ternary metal oxides have great potential in the application of SCs. To further improve their electrochemical performance, researchers have focused on the derivatives of these metal oxides. Transition metal sulfides have high electronic conductivity, two orders of magnitude higher than the corresponding oxides, because the valence states of the transition metals in the sulfides closely resemble those of the metals [142–144]. At the same time, because sulfur is less electronegative than oxygen, it can produce a more flexible structure instead of oxygen. This can effectively avoid the structural disintegration of transition metal sulfide-based electrodes due to interlayer elongation, which facilitates the transport of electrons in the internal structure [145]. In addition, combining two or more sulfides can improve the electrical properties of transition metal sulfides, resulting in a richer redox reaction [146–148] because bimetallic sulfides possess more prosperous diverse states, smaller optical band gaps, and better chemical stability than single-metal sulfides [144,148]. Compared with single metal oxide, transition metal sulfides such as Co-Mo-S, NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> have higher capacitance, multivalent redox reactions and higher conductivity [149], so they have great potential.

#### 2.4.1. Co-Mo-S

Co-Mo-S matrix composites have great potential as SC electrode materials because of their advantages of reversible redox reaction band gap, high conductivity, and low electronegativity [149–159]. For example, Balamurugan et al. used ion exchange reaction technology to synthesize a porous nano foam support structure composed of ultra-thin Co-Mo-S nanosheets [160]. When Co-Mo-S nanosheets are used as the electrode of the SC, they can provide an ultra-high specific capacitance of 2343 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , and the capacitance remains 96.6% after 20,000 cycles. In addition, the energy density and power density of Co-Mo-S/nitrogen doped graphene nanosheets assembled in ASC are 89.6 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> and 20.07 W kg−<sup>1</sup> . The capacitance retention rate can reach 86.8% after 50,000 cycles. The unique electrochemical properties of Co-Mo-S nanosheets are attributed to the ultra-high contact area with 3D nickel foam and electrolyte.

Xu et al. prepared amorphous CoMoS<sup>4</sup> by a simple precipitation method and used it as an SC material for the first time [161]. Changing the current density from 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> to 3 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the galvanostatic charge/discharge curves are shown in Figure 12 when the potential is from 0 V to 0.6 V. The specific capacitance was calculated according to these curves. The results show that it had a specific capacitance of 661 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> . Simultaneously, the constructed CoMoS4//reduced graphene oxide hybrid SC had a particular capacity of 77 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 0.5 A g−<sup>1</sup> , and its energy density was 27.2 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at a power density of 400 W kg−<sup>1</sup> . In addition, after 10,000 cycles at 80 mV s−<sup>1</sup> , the original capacitance was maintained at about 86%. *Nanomaterials* **2022**, *12*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 19 of 34

**Figure 12.** Galvanostatic charge/discharge curves of CoMoS4. Reproduced with permission from Xiaoyang Xu, Amorphous CoMoS4 for a valuable energy storage material candidate; published by Elsevier, 2016 [161]. **Figure 12.** Galvanostatic charge/discharge curves of CoMoS<sup>4</sup> . Reproduced with permission from Xiaoyang Xu, Amorphous CoMoS<sup>4</sup> for a valuable energy storage material candidate; published by Elsevier, 2016 [161].

Recently, Sun et al. synthesized Co-Mo-S nanosheet networks by a simple two-step hydrothermal method [162]. The ASC assembled with the product as the cathode had an energy density of 72.25 W h kg−1 at 2700 W kg−1. After 9000 cycles at 2 A g−1, the capacitance retention rate reached 83.4%. Recently, Sun et al. synthesized Co-Mo-S nanosheet networks by a simple two-step hydrothermal method [162]. The ASC assembled with the product as the cathode had an energy density of 72.25 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at 2700 W kg−<sup>1</sup> . After 9000 cycles at 2 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the capacitance retention rate reached 83.4%.

Although Co-Mo-S has excellent potential in SCs, its relatively poor rate capability and cycle stability limit its application. Overcoming these disadvantages and improve its electrochemical properties has become a key problem of Co-Mo-S capacitor materials. A practical method is to achieve excellent cycle capacity and rate performance by construction of the electrode material structure. Ma et al. designed and constructed hollow coreshell CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S nanotubes on carbon cloth for the first time by a hydrothermal method and electrodeposition process [163]. The preparation process of Co-S nanotubes is shown in Figure 13. First, Co(OH)F nanowire arrays are synthesized by hydrothermal reaction under high temperature and high pressure with carbon cloth as a current collector. Then, Co(OH)F nanowires and (NH4)2MoS4 precursor solution ae transformed into CoMoS4 nanotubes. Finally, 3D layered CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S nanotube hybrid arrays are synthesized by electrochemical deposition method. Among them, Ni-Co-S nanosheets are closely arranged around CoMoS4 hollow nanotubes, which is conducive to the exposure of electrochemical active sites and keeps the structure stable to a certain extent during charge and discharge. At the same time, the core-shell structure facilitates the close contact of the electrode/electrolyte and avoids the aggregation of Ni-Co-S. The novel CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S electrode had an excellent specific capacitance of 2208.5 F g−1 at 1 A g−1 and good cycle life (91.3% capacitance retention over 5000 cycles at 3 A g−1). In addition, the assembled CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S//activated carbon ASC had an energy density of 49.1 W h kg−1 at 800 W kg−1 and a capacity retention rate of 90.3% after 10,000 cycles. Although Co-Mo-S has excellent potential in SCs, its relatively poor rate capability and cycle stability limit its application. Overcoming these disadvantages and improve its electrochemical properties has become a key problem of Co-Mo-S capacitor materials. A practical method is to achieve excellent cycle capacity and rate performance by construction of the electrode material structure. Ma et al. designed and constructed hollow core-shell CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S nanotubes on carbon cloth for the first time by a hydrothermal method and electrodeposition process [163]. The preparation process of Co-S nanotubes is shown in Figure 13. First, Co(OH)F nanowire arrays are synthesized by hydrothermal reaction under high temperature and high pressure with carbon cloth as a current collector. Then, Co(OH)F nanowires and (NH4)2MoS<sup>4</sup> precursor solution ae transformed into CoMoS<sup>4</sup> nanotubes. Finally, 3D layered CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S nanotube hybrid arrays are synthesized by electrochemical deposition method. Among them, Ni-Co-S nanosheets are closely arranged around CoMoS<sup>4</sup> hollow nanotubes, which is conducive to the exposure of electrochemical active sites and keeps the structure stable to a certain extent during charge and discharge. At the same time, the core-shell structure facilitates the close contact of the electrode/electrolyte and avoids the aggregation of Ni-Co-S. The novel CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S electrode had an excellent specific capacitance of 2208.5 F g−<sup>1</sup> at 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> and good cycle life (91.3% capacitance retention over 5000 cycles at 3 A g−<sup>1</sup> ). In addition, the assembled CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S//activated carbon ASC had an energy density of 49.1 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at 800 W kg−<sup>1</sup> and a capacity retention rate of 90.3% after 10,000 cycles.

**Figure 13.** Schematic illustration of the fabrication of a hierarchical core-shell hollow CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S nanotubes electrode. Reproduced with permission from Fei Ma, Hierarchical core-shell hollow CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S nanotubes hybrid arrays as advanced electrode material for supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2019 [163]. **Figure 13.** Schematic illustration of the fabrication of a hierarchical core-shell hollow CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S nanotubes electrode. Reproduced with permission from Fei Ma, Hierarchical core-shell hollow CoMoS4@Ni-Co-S nanotubes hybrid arrays as advanced electrode material for supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2019 [163].

#### 2.4.2. NiCo2S4 2.4.2. NiCo2S<sup>4</sup>

As mentioned earlier, NiCo2O4 and its composites have great potential in SCs. The conductivity of NiCo2S4 is 100 times that of NiCo2O4, and NiCo2S4 shows higher electrochemical activity and capacitance than other cobalt nickel compounds because of its inherent redox reaction center. However, NiCo2S4-based electrodes suffer from defects such as easy oxidation in alkaline electrolytes and poor long-term cycling stability [164]. Therefore, effective space structures need to be designed to improve their drawbacks. So far, 3D NiCo2S4 nanostructures such as nanoflowers, core-shell and dendrites have been synthesized. As mentioned earlier, NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> and its composites have great potential in SCs. The conductivity of NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> is 100 times that of NiCo2O4, and NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> shows higher electrochemical activity and capacitance than other cobalt nickel compounds because of its inherent redox reaction center. However, NiCo2S4-based electrodes suffer from defects such as easy oxidation in alkaline electrolytes and poor long-term cycling stability [164]. Therefore, effective space structures need to be designed to improve their drawbacks. So far, 3D NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanostructures such as nanoflowers, core-shell and dendrites have been synthesized.

For example, Shi et al. synthesized layered sea urchin-like hollow NiCo2S4 by a template-free solvothermal method [165]. The capacitance reached 1398 F g−1 at 1 A g−1, and the specific capacity retention rate reached 74.4% after 5000 cycles at 10 A g−1. Zhang et al. synthesized nano NiCo2S4 with 3D honeycomb structure by a hydrothermal method and vulcanization method [166]. When the current density was 1 mA cm−2, its maximum specific capacity exceeded 14 mA h cm−2. After 1000 cycles at a current density of 10 mA cm−2, the specific capacity remained at 96.96%. For example, Shi et al. synthesized layered sea urchin-like hollow NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> by a template-free solvothermal method [165]. The capacitance reached 1398 F g−<sup>1</sup> at 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , and the specific capacity retention rate reached 74.4% after 5000 cycles at 10 A g−<sup>1</sup> . Zhang et al. synthesized nano NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> with 3D honeycomb structure by a hydrothermal method and vulcanization method [166]. When the current density was 1 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , its maximum specific capacity exceeded 14 mA h cm−<sup>2</sup> . After 1000 cycles at a current density of 10 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , the specific capacity remained at 96.96%.

These structures have been widely used in electrode materials. However, their poor electronic conductivity and potential risk of structural collapse and damage during longterm use limit the application of NiCo2S4 materials. One of the main methods to solve this problem is to build 3D hierarchical structure materials and increase the contact area with electrolyte. These structures have been widely used in electrode materials. However, their poor electronic conductivity and potential risk of structural collapse and damage during longterm use limit the application of NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> materials. One of the main methods to solve this problem is to build 3D hierarchical structure materials and increase the contact area with electrolyte.

Li et al. successfully synthesized layered dendritic NiCo2S4@NiCo2S by a three-step continuous hydrothermal method, and the layered microstructure of the highly porous structure facilitated ion transport during charge and discharge, resulting in a significant improvement in electrochemical performance. When the current density was 240 mA cm−2, the electrode discharge specific capacity of the dendritic structure reached 4.43 mA h cm−2. When the current density was increased from 40 mA cm−2 to 240 mA cm−2, its rate capability reached 70.1% [167]. Tang et al. synthesized ultra-high load (10.33 mA cm−2) 3D layered NiCo2S4/Ni3S2 nanosheets with an energy density of 4.69 W h m−2 (power density Li et al. successfully synthesized layered dendritic NiCo2S4@NiCo2S by a three-step continuous hydrothermal method, and the layered microstructure of the highly porous structure facilitated ion transport during charge and discharge, resulting in a significant improvement in electrochemical performance. When the current density was 240 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , the electrode discharge specific capacity of the dendritic structure reached 4.43 mA h cm−<sup>2</sup> . When the current density was increased from 40 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> to 240 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , its rate capability reached 70.1% [167]. Tang et al. synthesized ultra-high load (10.33 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> ) 3D layered NiCo2S4/Ni3S<sup>2</sup> nanosheets with an energy density of 4.69 W h m−<sup>2</sup> (power density of 10.33 W m−<sup>2</sup> ), and a stability of 91.4% after 8000 cycles at 20.66 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> [168].

of 10.33 W m−2), and a stability of 91.4% after 8000 cycles at 20.66 mA cm−2 [168]. Zhang et al. synthesized NiCo2S4 spheres with granular nuclei by a simple two-step hydrothermal reaction [169]. A NiCo2(OH)6/C precursor was prepared using a carbon pellet cluster as a template. Granular NiCo2S4 was synthesized by reacting with sodium Zhang et al. synthesized NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> spheres with granular nuclei by a simple two-step hydrothermal reaction [169]. A NiCo2(OH)6/C precursor was prepared using a carbon pellet cluster as a template. Granular NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> was synthesized by reacting with sodium

sulfide, and then the NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> precursor was grown on the periphery of the granular NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> to form a unique structure. The specific surface area of the prepared NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> ball was 26.61 m<sup>2</sup> g −1 , which is about twice that of the particle NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> (11.41 m<sup>2</sup> g −1 ). This higher specific surface area increased the electroactive sites that can transfer charge and shortens the transmission path, which is conducive to improving the electrochemical activity of the material. When the current density was 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the specific capacitance of the granular NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> spherical electrode reached 1156 F g−<sup>1</sup> , which was 71% higher than that of the NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> electrode. In addition, after 1000 charge-discharge cycles (5 A g−<sup>1</sup> ), the NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> sphere electrode with granular nuclear showed 82% capacitance retention, and the cycle stability was significantly better than that of the granular NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> electrode. sulfide, and then the NiCo2S4 precursor was grown on the periphery of the granular NiCo2S4 to form a unique structure. The specific surface area of the prepared NiCo2S4 ball was 26.61 m2 g−1, which is about twice that of the particle NiCo2S4 (11.41 m2 g−1). This higher specific surface area increased the electroactive sites that can transfer charge and shortens the transmission path, which is conducive to improving the electrochemical activity of the material. When the current density was 1 A g−1, the specific capacitance of the granular NiCo2S4 spherical electrode reached 1156 F g−1, which was 71% higher than that of the NiCo2S4 electrode. In addition, after 1000 charge-discharge cycles (5 A g−1), the NiCo2S4 sphere electrode with granular nuclear showed 82% capacitance retention, and the cycle stability was significantly better than that of the granular NiCo2S4 electrode.

Wu et al. prepared a hierarchical nanostructured NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanoflower@NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanosheet material by a hydrothermal method (Figure 14) [170]. Using this composite as the electrode in the SC, it had a specific capacity of 338.1 mA h g−<sup>1</sup> at 2 mV s−<sup>1</sup> , which is about three times higher than that of a single NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanosheet. In addition, 90% of the original capacity was maintained after 4000 reaction cycles at a current density of 20 A g−<sup>1</sup> . The synthesized NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanoflowers@NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanosheets//NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanoflowers@NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanosheets symmetrical SC device had an energy density of 18.05 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at a power density of 750 W kg−<sup>1</sup> . The capacitance retention rate of the symmetrical SC device was 89% after 4000 cycles (10 A g−<sup>1</sup> ). The multilayer 3D structure can explain this improvement in electrochemical performance. The upper nanoflowers are composed of many rough nanotubes, which increase the surface volume ratio and the contact range of the electrolyte. This unique structure can provide more electrochemical active sites, promote ion adsorption, and reduce the volume expansion in the charge and discharge process. Furthermore, the lower layer nanosheet arrays on the nickel foam can avoid damage and increase the stability of the electrochemical reaction. Wu et al. prepared a hierarchical nanostructured NiCo2S4 nanoflower@NiCo2S4 nanosheet material by a hydrothermal method (Figure 14) [170]. Using this composite as the electrode in the SC, it had a specific capacity of 338.1 mA h g−1 at 2 mV s−1, which is about three times higher than that of a single NiCo2S4 nanosheet. In addition, 90% of the original capacity was maintained after 4000 reaction cycles at a current density of 20 A g−1. The synthesized NiCo2S4 nanoflowers@NiCo2S4 nanosheets//NiCo2S4 nanoflowers@NiCo2S4 nanosheets symmetrical SC device had an energy density of 18.05 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at a power density of 750 W kg−1. The capacitance retention rate of the symmetrical SC device was 89% after 4000 cycles (10 A g−1). The multilayer 3D structure can explain this improvement in electrochemical performance. The upper nanoflowers are composed of many rough nanotubes, which increase the surface volume ratio and the contact range of the electrolyte. This unique structure can provide more electrochemical active sites, promote ion adsorption, and reduce the volume expansion in the charge and discharge process. Furthermore, the lower layer nanosheet arrays on the nickel foam can avoid damage and increase the stability of the electrochemical reaction.

**Figure 14.** Schematic diagram showing the fabrication of NiCo2S4 nanoflowers @NiCo2S4 nanosheets. Reproduced with permission from Wenling Wu, Hierarchical structure of Self-Supported NiCo2S4 Nanoflowers@NiCo2S4 nanosheets as high rate-capability and cycling-stability electrodes for advanced supercapacitor; published by Elsevier, 2021 [170]. **Figure 14.** Schematic diagram showing the fabrication of NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanoflowers @NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanosheets. Reproduced with permission from Wenling Wu, Hierarchical structure of Self-Supported NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> Nanoflowers@NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanosheets as high rate-capability and cycling-stability electrodes for advanced supercapacitor; published by Elsevier, 2021 [170].

Densely arranged and structurally stable nanosheets can act as a charge transport interconnectors with nickel foam, further improving the charge transport rate. This unique synergistic effect between nanoflower and nanosheet structure effectively increases the structural stability and electrochemical active sites of the material. The effect also promotes charge transfer and ion transport, which is conducive to accelerating the electrochemical reaction rate and improving the energy storage effect of the material. Densely arranged and structurally stable nanosheets can act as a charge transport interconnectors with nickel foam, further improving the charge transport rate. This unique synergistic effect between nanoflower and nanosheet structure effectively increases the structural stability and electrochemical active sites of the material. The effect also promotes charge transfer and ion transport, which is conducive to accelerating the electrochemical reaction rate and improving the energy storage effect of the material.

As mentioned above, the construction of 3D multilayer hierarchical structures can improve the electrochemical properties of materials and in-use stability. At the same time, the construction of nanostructured composites by doping other impurity atoms is the foremost solution to the problem of low electronic conductivity and poor stability of NiCo2S4 As mentioned above, the construction of 3D multilayer hierarchical structures can improve the electrochemical properties of materials and in-use stability. At the same time, the construction of nanostructured composites by doping other impurity atoms is the foremost solution to the problem of low electronic conductivity and poor stability of

NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> materials. Among them, carbon material has superior conductivity [170], which can promote charge transfer. Due to the strong coupling between the carbon substrate and metal-based oxide, the composite of carbon material and NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> can effectively increase the electrochemical activity of electrode material [171]. For example, Pezzotti and co-workers synthesized a kelp-like NiCo2S4-C-MoS<sup>2</sup> composite by hydrothermal and solvothermal methods [172]. It had a specific capacitance of 1601 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 0.5 A g−<sup>1</sup> and 75% of the initial specific capacity after 2000 cycles at a current density of 2 A g−<sup>1</sup> . Shim et al. synthesized a hollow C-NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nano-lake sheet structure with a one-step solvent method [173]. The specific capacitance reached 1722 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , and 95.60% capacity retention after 5000 cycles at a current density of 10 A g−<sup>1</sup> . materials. Among them, carbon material has superior conductivity [170], which can promote charge transfer. Due to the strong coupling between the carbon substrate and metalbased oxide, the composite of carbon material and NiCo2S4 can effectively increase the electrochemical activity of electrode material [171]. For example, Pezzotti and co-workers synthesized a kelp-like NiCo2S4-C-MoS2 composite by hydrothermal and solvothermal methods [172]. It had a specific capacitance of 1601 F g−1 at a current density of 0.5 A g−<sup>1</sup> and 75% of the initial specific capacity after 2000 cycles at a current density of 2 A g−1. Shim et al. synthesized a hollow C-NiCo2S4 nano-lake sheet structure with a one-step solvent method [173]. The specific capacitance reached 1722 F g−1 at a current density of 1 A g−1, and 95.60% capacity retention after 5000 cycles at a current density of 10 A g−1.

In addition, since the electronegativity and atomic radius of P and S atoms are similar, introducing P atoms results in lattice distortion, providing more active sites. Therefore, the introduction of the P atom is also a way to improve the electrochemical activity of materials. Based on the above, Liu et al. introduced P and C elements into a NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> electrode material by a one-step solvothermal method and phosphating process [174]. As the electrode material of SCs, it had a specific capacity of 1026 C g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , and an original capacity retention rate of 89% after 20,000 cycles at 10 A g−<sup>1</sup> . In comparison, NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> only reached 65% of the original capacity under the same conditions. The ASC had an energy density of 131.40 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at a power density of 1355.37 W kg−<sup>1</sup> , and 96.3% of the original capacity was maintained after 10,000 cycles at a current density of 2 A g−<sup>1</sup> . In addition, since the electronegativity and atomic radius of P and S atoms are similar, introducing P atoms results in lattice distortion, providing more active sites. Therefore, the introduction of the P atom is also a way to improve the electrochemical activity of materials. Based on the above, Liu et al. introduced P and C elements into a NiCo2S4 electrode material by a one-step solvothermal method and phosphating process [174]. As the electrode material of SCs, it had a specific capacity of 1026 C g−1 at a current density of 1 A g−1, and an original capacity retention rate of 89% after 20,000 cycles at 10 A g−1. In comparison, NiCo2S4 only reached 65% of the original capacity under the same conditions. The ASC had an energy density of 131.40 W h kg−1 at a power density of 1355.37 W kg−1, and 96.3% of the original capacity was maintained after 10,000 cycles at a current density of 2 A g−1.

Dai et al. prepared relatively stable ZnCo2O4@Ni [171]. The specific capacity of Ni-Co-S composite electrode material was 1396.9 C g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> , while ZnCo2O<sup>4</sup> nanorods and Ni-Co-S showed a specific capacity of 1025.5 C g−<sup>1</sup> and 1026 C g−<sup>1</sup> , respectively, under the same conditions. At the same time, the device showed a capacity retention rate of 85.5% after 1000 charge-discharge cycles at 4 A g−<sup>1</sup> . Bai et al. prepared 2D Co3O4@Ni(OH)<sup>2</sup> [175]. The SC synthesized by this method had a specific capacitance of 98.4 F g−<sup>1</sup> in the potential range of 0–1.7 V at 5 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> and an energy density of 40.0 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at a power density of 349.6 W g−<sup>1</sup> . In addition, the original specific volume retention rate was 90.5% after 5000 cycles (1.61 A g−<sup>1</sup> ). This proved that the composite with core-shell structure can retain the advantages of each component, and the synergistic effect between them can be used to improve the electrochemical properties of the material. Based on the above, Zhang et al. synthesized layered core-shell polyporrole nanotubes@NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> materials by coating NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanosheets on conductive polypyrrole nanotubes [144]; the formation process is shown in Figure 15. The material had a specific capacitance of 911 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 1 A g−<sup>1</sup> and maintained a capacitance of 592 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a current density of 20 A g−<sup>1</sup> . After 4000 cycles at a current density of 5 A g−<sup>1</sup> , the original capacitance was 93.2%. Dai et al. prepared relatively stable ZnCo2O4@Ni [171]. The specific capacity of Ni-Co-S composite electrode material was 1396.9 C g−1 at a current density of 1 A g−1, while ZnCo2O4 nanorods and Ni-Co-S showed a specific capacity of 1025.5 C g−1 and 1026 C g−1, respectively, under the same conditions. At the same time, the device showed a capacity retention rate of 85.5% after 1000 charge-discharge cycles at 4 A g−1. Bai et al. prepared 2D Co3O4@Ni(OH)2 [175]. The SC synthesized by this method had a specific capacitance of 98.4 F g−1 in the potential range of 0–1.7 V at 5 mA cm−2 and an energy density of 40.0 W h kg−1 at a power density of 349.6 W g−1. In addition, the original specific volume retention rate was 90.5% after 5000 cycles (1.61 A g−1). This proved that the composite with coreshell structure can retain the advantages of each component, and the synergistic effect between them can be used to improve the electrochemical properties of the material. Based on the above, Zhang et al. synthesized layered core-shell polyporrole nanotubes@NiCo2S4 materials by coating NiCo2S4 nanosheets on conductive polypyrrole nanotubes [144]; the formation process is shown in Figure 15. The material had a specific capacitance of 911 F g−1 at a current density of 1 A g−1 and maintained a capacitance of 592 F g−1 at a current density of 20 A g−1. After 4000 cycles at a current density of 5 A g−1, the original capacitance was 93.2%.

**Figure 15.** Schematic illustration of polyporrole nanotubes@NiCo2S4 core-shell formation. Reproduced with permission from Jun Zhang, Hierarchical polypyrrole nanotubes@NiCo2S4 nanosheets core-shell composites with improved electrochemical performance as supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2017 [144]. **Figure 15.** Schematic illustration of polyporrole nanotubes@NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> core-shell formation. Reproduced with permission from Jun Zhang, Hierarchical polypyrrole nanotubes@NiCo2S<sup>4</sup> nanosheets core-shell composites with improved electrochemical performance as supercapacitors; published by Elsevier, 2017 [144].

Among other cobalt-containing materials, Co3O4@NiMoO4 has been most studied because NiMoO4 has good conductivity, which can improve the energy storage capacity of

*2.5. Other Cobalt-Containing Materials* 

Co3O4.

#### *2.5. Other Cobalt-Containing Materials Nanomaterials* **2022**, *12*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 23 of 34

Among other cobalt-containing materials, Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> has been most studied because NiMoO<sup>4</sup> has good conductivity, which can improve the energy storage capacity of Co3O4.

Zhang et al. used hydrothermal and annealing methods to synthesize flower-like hybridized arrays on nickel foam [176]. Using Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanowire arrays as scaffolds, NiMoO<sup>4</sup> nanosheets were grown on the surface to form a new type of 3D layered battery electrode Co3O4@NiMoO4. The specific capacity of the hybrid array of the prepared Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> was 636.8 C g−<sup>1</sup> at 5 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> . Moreover, the retention rate was 84.1% at 20 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> after 2000 cycles and showed excellent electrochemical performance. The prepared hybrid capacitor (Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> as the positive electrode and activated carbon as the negative electrode) reached a high energy density of 58.5 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> at 389 W kg−<sup>1</sup> . Zhang et al. used hydrothermal and annealing methods to synthesize flower-like hybridized arrays on nickel foam [176]. Using Co3O4 nanowire arrays as scaffolds, NiMoO4 nanosheets were grown on the surface to form a new type of 3D layered battery electrode Co3O4@NiMoO4. The specific capacity of the hybrid array of the prepared Co3O4@NiMoO4 was 636.8 C g−1 at 5 mA cm−2. Moreover, the retention rate was 84.1% at 20 mA cm−2 after 2000 cycles and showed excellent electrochemical performance. The prepared hybrid capacitor (Co3O4@NiMoO4 as the positive electrode and activated carbon as the negative electrode) reached a high energy density of 58.5 W h kg−1 at 389 W kg−1. Yang et al. adopted a similar method using mesoporous Co3O4 nanowires directly

Yang et al. adopted a similar method using mesoporous Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanowires directly grown on the nickel foam as the skeleton to support the NiMoO<sup>4</sup> nanosheet coating, and obtained Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> [177]. The high specific capacitance of the synthesized Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> was 3.61 F cm−<sup>2</sup> at a current density of 2 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> . After 9000 cycles, about 101.3% of the initial capacity was still retained. Such a unique structure can significantly improve the permeability of electrolyte ions in the material. grown on the nickel foam as the skeleton to support the NiMoO4 nanosheet coating, and obtained Co3O4@NiMoO4 [177]. The high specific capacitance of the synthesized Co3O4@NiMoO4 was 3.61 F cm−2 at a current density of 2 mA cm−2. After 9000 cycles, about 101.3% of the initial capacity was still retained. Such a unique structure can significantly improve the permeability of electrolyte ions in the material.

Li et al. designed and synthesized nanowire/nanosheet arrays directly grown on carbon cloth by a two-step hydrothermal method [178]. Growing uniformly on carbon cloth collectors, the crystalline Co3O<sup>4</sup> nanowires were used as backbone supports and provided reliable electrical connections for NiMoO<sup>4</sup> nanosheet coatings with mesoporous structures. This enabled NiMoO<sup>4</sup> to be fully utilized by creating faster electron/ion conductivity and electroactive sites. When the current density was 3 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , the specific capacitance of the prepared 3D hybrid nanocomposites was 3.61 F cm−<sup>2</sup> , and when the current density increased from 3 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> to 15 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , the capacitance retention was 82%. The combined effect of the 3D nanostructure and the pseudo capacitance of the electrode materials resulted in superior electrochemical performance. Li et al. designed and synthesized nanowire/nanosheet arrays directly grown on carbon cloth by a two-step hydrothermal method [178]. Growing uniformly on carbon cloth collectors, the crystalline Co3O4 nanowires were used as backbone supports and provided reliable electrical connections for NiMoO4 nanosheet coatings with mesoporous structures. This enabled NiMoO4 to be fully utilized by creating faster electron/ion conductivity and electroactive sites. When the current density was 3 mA cm−2, the specific capacitance of the prepared 3D hybrid nanocomposites was 3.61 F cm−2, and when the current density increased from 3 mA cm−2 to 15 mA cm−2, the capacitance retention was 82%. The combined effect of the 3D nanostructure and the pseudo capacitance of the electrode materials resulted in superior electrochemical performance.

Cai et al. fabricated a 3D structure Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> using a similar method as above [179]. A shown in Figure 16, the prepared material showed a significantly enhanced surface capacitance of 5.69 F cm−<sup>2</sup> when the current density was 30 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , which was five times that of the original Co3O<sup>4</sup> electrode (1.10 F cm−<sup>2</sup> ). With a power density of 5000 W kg−<sup>1</sup> , the energy density of the hybrid electrode was 56.9 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> . Cai et al. fabricated a 3D structure Co3O4@NiMoO4 using a similar method as above [179]. A shown in Figure 16, the prepared material showed a significantly enhanced surface capacitance of 5.69 F cm−2 when the current density was 30 mA cm−2, which was five times that of the original Co3O4 electrode (1.10 F cm−2). With a power density of 5000 W kg−1, the energy density of the hybrid electrode was 56.9 W h kg−1.

**Figure 16.** (**a**) Long-term cycling stability of the Co3O4 and Co3O4@NiMoO4 hybrid electrodes. (**b**) Impedance Nyquist plots of the Co3O4 electrode and the Co3O4@NiMoO4 hybrid electrode before and after 3000 cycles. Reproduced with permission from Daoping Cai, Three-Dimensional Co3O4@NiMoO4 Core/Shell Nanowire Arrays on Ni Foam for Electrochemical Energy Storage; published by ACS Publications, 2014 [179]. **Figure 16.** (**a**) Long-term cycling stability of the Co3O<sup>4</sup> and Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> hybrid electrodes. (**b**) Impedance Nyquist plots of the Co3O<sup>4</sup> electrode and the Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> hybrid electrode before and after 3000 cycles. Reproduced with permission from Daoping Cai, Three-Dimensional Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> Core/Shell Nanowire Arrays on Ni Foam for Electrochemical Energy Storage; published by ACS Publications, 2014 [179].

Dong et al. first prepared a layered tubular yolk-shell composite by electrospinning and hydrothermal methods, and then calcination to prepare a Co3O4@NiMoO4 composite [180]. As shown in Figure 17, the Co3O4@NiMoO4 composite was made into an electrode Dong et al. first prepared a layered tubular yolk-shell composite by electrospinning and hydrothermal methods, and then calcination to prepare a Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> compos-

with a specific enhanced capacitance of 913.25 F g−1 at a high current density of 10 A g−1, and a capacitance retention of 88% due to its unique structure and chemical composition.

ite [180]. As shown in Figure 17, the Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> composite was made into an electrode with a specific enhanced capacitance of 913.25 F g−<sup>1</sup> at a high current density of 10 A g−<sup>1</sup> , and a capacitance retention of 88% due to its unique structure and chemical composition. When the current density changes from 0.5 A g−<sup>1</sup> to 20 A g−<sup>1</sup> , it had remarkable cycle stability. *Nanomaterials* **2022**, *12*, x FOR PEER REVIEW 24 of 34 When the current density changes from 0.5 A g−1 to 20 A g−1, it had remarkable cycle stability.

**Figure 17.** Specific capacitance of CO@NMO, CO/C@NMO, NiMoO4 andCo3O4 electrodes. Reproduced with permission from Ping Yang, Synthesis of hierarchical tube-like yolk-shell Co3O4@Ni-MoO4 for enhanced supercapacitor performance; published by Elsevier, 2018 [180]. **Figure 17.** Specific capacitance of CO@NMO, CO/C@NMO, NiMoO<sup>4</sup> andCo3O<sup>4</sup> electrodes. Reproduced with permission from Ping Yang, Synthesis of hierarchical tube-like yolk-shell Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> for enhanced supercapacitor performance; published by Elsevier, 2018 [180].

Hong et al. prepared a uniform 2D Co3O4 structure by a simple chemical etching assisted method followed by thermal annealing, and then synthesized Co3O4@NiMoO4 by a simple hydrothermal method [181]. The specific capacitance of the 3D hybrid nanostructures was1526 F g−1 at the current density of 3 mA cm−2, and the capacitance retention was 72% when the current density increased from 3 mA cm−2 to 30 mA cm−2. On this basis, a Co3O4@NiMoO4 ASC was designed, and the maximum energy density of activated carbon was 37.8 W h kg−1 when the power density was 482 W kg−1. Hong et al. prepared a uniform 2D Co3O<sup>4</sup> structure by a simple chemical etching assisted method followed by thermal annealing, and then synthesized Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> by a simple hydrothermal method [181]. The specific capacitance of the 3D hybrid nanostructures was1526 F g−<sup>1</sup> at the current density of 3 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> , and the capacitance retention was 72% when the current density increased from 3 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> to 30 mA cm−<sup>2</sup> . On this basis, a Co3O4@NiMoO<sup>4</sup> ASC was designed, and the maximum energy density of activated carbon was 37.8 W h kg−<sup>1</sup> when the power density was 482 W kg−<sup>1</sup> .

The above describes another cobalt-containing material, Co3O4@NiMoO4. Among them, NiMoO4 can improve the electrochemical performance of Co3O4. The electrochemical performance and stability of the two materials can be greatly improved by rational design of their microstructure, which has great potential. The above describes another cobalt-containing material, Co3O4@NiMoO4. Among them, NiMoO<sup>4</sup> can improve the electrochemical performance of Co3O4. The electrochemical performance and stability of the two materials can be greatly improved by rational design of their microstructure, which has great potential.

#### **3. Summary and Outlook 3. Summary and Outlook**

In conclusion, this paper reviews the application of cobalt-based nanomaterials in supercapacitors and presents the contributions of many scholars in this field in recent years. These scholars have tried many approaches to improve the electrode materials and enhance the supercapacitor performance. The properties of cobalt-based materials and the issues related to supercapacitors are also discussed. In conclusion, this paper reviews the application of cobalt-based nanomaterials in supercapacitors and presents the contributions of many scholars in this field in recent years. These scholars have tried many approaches to improve the electrode materials and enhance the supercapacitor performance. The properties of cobalt-based materials and the issues related to supercapacitors are also discussed.

In this paper, we first introduce the classification and working principle of SCs. According to the charge storage mechanism of SCs, they can be classified into three categories: EDLCs, PCs and battery-type capacitors. EDLCs store charge through a physical adsorption process controlled by reversible adsorption/desorption of electrolyte ions at the electrode/electrolyte interface without any chemical reaction involved. In contrast, PCs and battery-type capacitors benefit from Faraday redox reactions and have a unique charge storage mechanism with much larger capacitance and power density than EDLCs. Among the many electrode materials for these SCs, common cobalt-based materials include cobalt oxide, cobalt hydroxide, and cobalt-containing ternary metal oxides. Among them, the theoretical specific capacitance of Co3O4 (3560 F g−1) is slightly higher than that of Co(OH)2 (3460 F g−1), and electrodes made from Co3O4 usually exhibit better cycling performance than that of Co(OH)2. Compared to these two substances, the ternary metal In this paper, we first introduce the classification and working principle of SCs. According to the charge storage mechanism of SCs, they can be classified into three categories: EDLCs, PCs and battery-type capacitors. EDLCs store charge through a physical adsorption process controlled by reversible adsorption/desorption of electrolyte ions at the electrode/electrolyte interface without any chemical reaction involved. In contrast, PCs and battery-type capacitors benefit from Faraday redox reactions and have a unique charge storage mechanism with much larger capacitance and power density than EDLCs. Among the many electrode materials for these SCs, common cobalt-based materials include cobalt oxide, cobalt hydroxide, and cobalt-containing ternary metal oxides. Among them, the theoretical specific capacitance of Co3O<sup>4</sup> (3560 F g−<sup>1</sup> ) is slightly higher than that of Co(OH)<sup>2</sup> (3460 F g−<sup>1</sup> ), and electrodes made from Co3O<sup>4</sup> usually exhibit better cycling performance than that of Co(OH)2. Compared to these two substances, the ternary metal

oxides (MnCo2O4, NiCo2O4 and ZnCo2O4) show significantly higher performance due to

To further enhance the performance of the above cobalt-based materials, the main

the synergistic effect of the two transition metals coupled together.

oxides (MnCo2O4, NiCo2O<sup>4</sup> and ZnCo2O4) show significantly higher performance due to the synergistic effect of the two transition metals coupled together.

To further enhance the performance of the above cobalt-based materials, the main methods are: (1) designing the morphology of the electrode materials; (2) introducing other elements, such as S, P, and Mn, among others; (3) compounding with other materials, and (4) improving the preparation process. First, designing unique morphologies is an effective and commonly used means to enhance the electrochemical performance of electrode materials. Microstructures such as nanoparticles, nanowires, nanotubes, nanosheets, and nanospheres are mainly used in the many studies reported in this paper. Among these morphologies, mesoporous structures play a major role. On the one hand, a mesoporous structure can significantly increase the surface area and shorten the diffusion length for electron and ion transport, thus accelerating the redox process and improving pseudocapacitance performance. On the other hand, it can moderate the volume change during the charging/discharging process, thus improving the cycling capability. Second, the introduction of other elements can further improve the performance of cobalt-based nanomaterials. As mentioned above, transition metal sulfides have significantly higher electrical conductivity and redox ability than corresponding metal oxides. Meanwhile, compounding cobalt-based nanomaterials with other materials can combine the advantages of both materials and improve the performance of electrodes. As mentioned above, many scholars have compounded cobalt-based nanomaterials with carbon-based materials, which are very commonly used today. Among the many carbon-based materials, graphene, which has a large specific surface area and excellent mechanical and electrochemical properties, is an ideal carrier. As a result, many graphene-cobalt-based nanomaterial composites have emerged in recent years. Finally, the electrode performance can also be enhanced by improving the current process. Among the many studies presented in this paper, hydrothermal methods have been widely used, which can easily alter the morphology and structure of nanomaterials. In addition, processes such as electrochemical deposition, electrostatic spinning, and sol-gel methods are also widely used due to their advantages in preparing nanostructures.

Some researchers have investigated the effects of some external factors (e.g., ultraviolet radiation, annealing temperature, deposition potential, etc.) on the performance of SCs. Ultraviolet irradiation increases the crystallinity of raw materials, and the electrochemical performance of supercapacitors made from ultraviolet-irradiated electrode materials was significantly improved [182]. During the annealing process, the grains agglomerate to form large particles, resulting in a uniform and dense porous microstructure [183]. This porous microstructure facilitates electrolytic ion insertion and electron transfer at the electrode/electrolyte interface, resulting in effective charge storage. As for the deposition potential, it has been shown that lower deposition potential leads to lower mass transfer rate and lower electrochemical performance.

In recent years, the field of energy storage devices has been developing rapidly, and sodium-ion batteries, potassium-ion batteries, and various kinds of SCs are being widely and deeply researched, among which miniature SCs (MSCs) are gradually attracting the attention of many researchers. MSCs are miniaturized SCs that have a similar composition to conventional SCs, but with significant structural differences. Conventional SCs have a vertical sandwich structure with inherent limitations including short-circuiting within a narrow distance between two electrodes, increased ion transport resistance, and high mass loading of active materials at an appropriately long distance [184,185]. By contrast, MSCs have a planar structure with a narrow insulating gap between the two electrodes, which avoids the use of a separator. This increases the mass loading of the active material, resulting in high power and energy density, low ion transport resistance, and short electrolyte ion diffusion distance [186]. Due to their small size and excellent electrochemical properties, MSCs could soon be widely used in various applications. Therefore, it is important to study the application of cobalt-based nanomaterials in MSCs.

It should also be noted that studies have shown that a deficit in cobalt supply could occur as early as 2030 [187]. This means that the advantage of the low cost of cobalt-based materials compared to RuO<sup>2</sup> will gradually decrease. The solutions to this problem are as follows: (1) finding alternative materials, such as Ni, Mn, Zn, and other transition group metals with good performance; (2) hybridizing cobalt-based materials with conductive materials with good performance to reduce the content of cobalt in monoliths while ensuring performance (there have been studies on doping polyaniline, polypyrrole, carbon nanotubes, and graphene, among other substances, into cobalt-based materials), and (3) further developing more efficient, convenient, and low-cost SCs recycling technology.

**Author Contributions:** Writing—original draft preparation and data curation, L.Y. and H.C.; writing review and editing, H.W., Q.Z., K.Y., X.X. and J.H.; supervision, H.W.; project administration, H.W.; funding acquisition, H.W. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

**Funding:** This work was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant 21604007.

**Institutional Review Board Statement:** Not applicable.

**Informed Consent Statement:** Not applicable.

**Data Availability Statement:** Not applicable.

**Conflicts of Interest:** The authors declare no conflict of interest.

#### **References**

