1. Introduction
Ensuring the achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which were set by the United Nations as the successors of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), is imperative for human development, people’s well-being, and the planet’s future prosperity and sustainability [
1,
2]. Within SDGs, 169 targets and 17 goals were set to be met through the collaboration and mobilization of nations, countries, governments, organizations, and individuals to secure a better future [
3]. Specifically, SDGs can be regarded as a network of interrelated and interconnected goals and targets in which goals are met through the accomplishment of targets [
4]. Achieving SDGs is an integral part of the social movement for sustainable development, which can be defined as a holistic approach to pursuing societal, economic, and environmental development while taking the needs of the present and future generations into consideration and ensuring an inclusive society and a sustainable environment [
5].
Therefore, besides the need to foster sustainable practices, to apply drastic structural changes in all societal sectors, to capitalize on the interdependencies of the SDGs, and to adopt appropriate strategies, technologies, and policies, it is also essential to take into account the interlinkages among sectors, societal actors, and countries to successfully implement measures to meet the SDGs [
6,
7,
8]. Additionally, it is essential to apply proper conceptual and unified frameworks, new paradigms, and relevant indicators [
2,
9].
Furthermore, adopting and integrating technologies in societal, environmental, and industrial sectors is necessary to meet SDGs. Artificial Intelligence (AI) is one of the most impactful and promising technologies, as it can drastically influence several domains. AI is an interdisciplinary field that focuses on creating intelligent agents that can mimic human behavior and actions, simulate human intelligence to perform specific tasks effectively and autonomously, and make decisions requiring human-level intelligence without human interventions [
10,
11]. AI mainly aims to provide systems and processes with increased learning, communication, and reasoning capabilities, perception, rationality, adaptability, and understanding of their environment [
12,
13]. Several studies have already showcased the implications of AI and blockchain in technology and society and have demonstrated its key role in achieving the SDGs and targets and attaining sustainable development [
14,
15]. They have also highlighted the need for appropriate safety, security, transparency, and ethical standards [
16,
17]. The Internet of Things (IoT) is another key technology in the fulfillment of SDGs, as recent studies have also indicated [
18,
19]. IoT is based on interoperable communication protocols and can be characterized as a worldwide, self-configuring, self-adjusting, dynamic, and scalable network infrastructure of interconnected and interrelated systems, devices, physical objects, and services that are embedded with sensors and software [
20,
21,
22]. Within this flexible infrastructure, information and resources are shared between “things” that are seamlessly integrated into the network, have several advanced processes, and can communicate, sense, and interact with other “things” and their surrounding environment in real-time [
23,
24,
25].
A new field of study called Artificial Intelligence of Things (AIoT) is gaining ground. In particular, it combines AI with IoT services and devices and capitalizes on cloud computing [
26]. AIoT aims to create interconnected, intelligent, and autonomous IoT systems that use AI algorithms to interact and communicate with their environment and other systems, collect and analyze data, monitor processes, make autonomous decisions, and take actions in real-time. As a result, AIoT has the potential to transform and improve the efficiency of various sectors drastically, address societal and environmental challenges, and assist in achieving the SDGs through the optimization of the processes regarding the production, distribution, consumption, and reuse of renewable resources and the promotion of sustainable practices and decision-making. Due to its novelty, there still needs to be a systematic study that presents the state of the art of AIoT, its evolution over the years, and its use to achieve sustainable development.
Consequently, the aim of this study is to provide a systematic mapping and overview of the literature regarding AI, IoT, and AIoT and their use in achieving SDGs over the years through a bibliometric analysis. The main research question set to be explored was what the current state of the art is regarding the use of AIoT in achieving SDGs based on the existing literature. The remainder of the study is structured as follows:
Section 2 goes over the method adopted and the tools used, and
Section 3 presents and analyzes the results in detail.
Section 4 provides a cohesive discussion about the use of AI, IoT, and AIoT to achieve SDGs, its benefits, and challenges, as well as the findings of this study. Finally,
Section 5 offers conclusive remarks and suggests future research directions.
2. Method
One of the most widely used research methodologies to examine a broad topic and to analyze its evolution over the years is through the use of a bibliometric analysis [
27]. The present study followed the guidelines presented in Donthu et al. [
28] and adopted the bibliometric methodological approach showcased in Aria et al. [
29]. Scopus and Web of Science (WoS) which are two accurate, relevant, and impactful databases [
30,
31] were used to meet the specific requirements of conducting a bibliometric study [
28,
32].
The open-source R package “Bibliometrics” [
29] is capable of using both Scopus and WoS data, among others, and was developed with the aim of assisting in carrying out studies that focus on exploring the literature through bibliometric analysis and scientific mapping. The query used in both databases was: (“artificial intelligence” OR “ai” OR “internet of things” OR “iot” OR “artificial intelligence of things” OR “aiot”) AND (“sustainability” OR “sustainable development” OR “sustainable development goal” OR “sdg”). All entries before 2023 were identified and retrieved. Hence, a total of 12,675 documents (8733 from Scopus and 3942 from WoS) during the period 1989–2022 were set to be examined. In total, 3208 duplicates were identified between the two datasets retrieved, which were removed. Due to the nature of the study, which is to present the current state of the art, the inclusion criteria set were for the document to involve the use of AI, IoT, and/or AIoT and focus on SDGs. Additionally, 285 documents were missing multiple key fields and were removed. As a result, the total number of documents that were in line with the inclusion criteria set and examined in this study was 9182. The result analysis, which is presented in the next section, was grouped into (1) Main information, (2) Citations, (3) Sources, (4) Authors, (5) Countries, and (6) Documents. The results are presented using tables, figures, and diagrams. The complete research process and steps followed are presented in
Figure 1. Remarkably, the research process consisted of four main stages and involved (i) the initial search for appropriate topics, keywords, and data sources, (ii) the data identification, exportation, preprocessing, and import to Bibliometrix, (iii) the conduct of the bibliometric analysis and scientific mapping of the literature, and (iv) the result interpretation and conclusions.
4. Discussion
The 17 SDGs set by the United Nations to be achieved by 2030 characterize a global partnership among all countries to share a commonly accepted plan for meeting them and attaining sustainable development, which, in turn, will lead to dignity, peace, and prosperity. Nonetheless, to address this urgent call for action, innovative solutions are required to ensure the achievement of the SDGs. The current decade is regarded as the decade of action toward reaching the 2023 milestone. Ambitions and plans must now turn into reality. Novel technologies, such as AI, IoT, and AIoT, can contribute to facilitating and accelerating the progress toward the realization of the SDGs. The acceleration and transfer of technological innovations is a common concern of humankind, transcending the boundaries of a single country and requiring international collaboration and collective actions. In this context, digital advances are regarded as crucial for supporting and achieving each of the 17 SDGs.
This bibliometric and scientific mapping study aimed to analyze how AI, IoT, and AIoT are being used in the context of sustainable development, examine their role in achieving the SDGs, and explore their evolution over the years. To address this aim, the descriptive statistics and characteristics of the related studies, the most common keywords, the most popular topics, and the most relevant and impactful sources, authors, affiliations, countries, and articles, as well as how the topic evolved over the years, were explored. The study involved 9182 documents from Scopus and WoS published in 3641 different sources from 1989 to 2022. The results were grouped into main information, citations, sources, authors, countries, and documents.
To sum up the results of the analysis, the scientific interest regarding the use of AI, IoT, and AIoT in achieving SDGs and sustainable development has been increasing annually, with a significant increase in the annual production of documents being observed since 2018 and afterward. The annual growth rate is 26.34%, the average age of the documents is 4.07 years, and each article received an average of 12.9 citations, which highlights the recency of the topic over the last few years. Most documents were published as conference papers, followed closely by documents that were published in scientific journals. The international co-authorship rate was 2.69%, while the average number of co-authors in each document was 3.77. Most documents were published from 2018 to 2021, and the average number of citations per year increased from 2011 to 2020.
In total, 3641 international outlets were used, which were clustered into three groups following Bradford’s law. “Journal of Cleaner Production” (h-index 47), “Sustainability” (h-index 42), “Sustainable Cities and Society” (h-index 30), “IEEE Access” (h-index 24), and “Sensors” (h-index 21) were the top five sources with the largest local impact, having the highest h-index and the most total citations. When taking the sources production over time into account, “Sustainability” (508 documents), “Communications in Computer and Information Science” (199 documents), “Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing” (161 documents), “Lecture Notes in Computer Science” (154 documents), and “Journal of Cleaner Production” (141 documents) were the top five sources.
A total of 23,917 different authors from different disciplines and backgrounds have contributed to these studies. The vast majority of authors were involved either in a single article (81.9%) or two articles at the most. Liu Y. (h-index 19), Wang X. (h-index 14), Wang Y. (h-index 13), Zhang Y. (h-index 13), and Wang J. (h-index 13) were the top five authors that published the most. Liu Y. (72 documents), Wang X. (68 documents), Liu X. (64 documents), Wang J. (63 documents), and Zhang Y. (56 documents) were the top five most impactful authors based on their h-index. Roy A. (2177 total citations), Agiwal M. (2152 total citations), Saxena N. (2152 total citations), Hossain M. (1966 total citations), and Islam S. (1854 total citations) were the top five most impactful authors when taking their total number of citations into account.
The top five affiliations that produced the most significant number of publications out of the 9461 different affiliations within this dataset were Chongqing University (72 documents), University of Johannesburg (54 documents), National University of Singapore (47 documents), Tsinghua University (46 documents), and Cornell University (44 documents). In the studies examined, authors from 177 different countries were involved. The countries that contributed to the publication of the most documents related to the topic were China (1698 documents), the United States of America (1064 documents), India (988 documents), Italy (567 documents), and the United Kingdom (530 documents), while China (12,865 total citations), the United States of America (11,488 total citations), Korea (6743 total citations), Italy (6469 total citations), and the United Kingdom (6094 total citations) were the top five most cited countries.
Out of the 9182 documents examined, the top five most impactful ones according to the total number of citations received were Agiwal et al. [
33] (total citations: 2152), Riazul Islam et al. [
34] (total citations: 1849), Kshetri [
35] (total citations: 865), Kusiak [
36] (total citations: 654), and Kamble et al. [
37] (total citations: 624). “Sustainable development”, “artificial intelligence”, “internet of things”, “decision making”, and “decision support systems” were the most commonly used keywords. Based on the co-occurrence network of the keywords, most documents were associated with sustainable development, AI, and IoT. This fact was in line with the thematic evolution of the topic.
5. Conclusions
This study aimed to examine the use of AI, IoT, and AIoT in the context of sustainable development, explore their role in achieving the SDGs, and analyze how they evolved over the years. Hence, this study contributed a scientific mapping analysis and a bibliometric analysis, which involved 9182 documents from Scopus and WoS over the period from 1989–2022. Different factors were taken into account to analyze the data. The descriptive statistics of the related documents and the annual scientific production were explored. The most relevant and impactful authors, articles, outlets, affiliations, countries, and keywords were identified. Moreover, the most popular topics and research directions throughout the years, the advancement of the field, and the research focus were also examined. The recency and significance of the topic are evident in the results. The increasing number of published documents on this topic in all types of sources over the last years and the fact that the topic is widely studied by researchers from different disciplines and countries across all continents from both private and public universities and institutes further showcase the importance of achieving SDGs. The gradual transition from traditional systems to technology-enabled intelligent systems and the focus shifting to pursuing more sustainable approaches, methods, and resources were observed. AIoT emerged as an important aspect of realizing sustainability and meeting the SDGs.
Consequently, the results and findings of this study contribute to bridging the gap in the existing literature regarding the adoption and integration of AI, IoT, and AIoT in the context of sustainable development. Given the fact that only seven years remain until the 2030 milestone, this study highlights the role of AI, IoT, and AIoT as significant contributors to achieving SDGs. Despite this fact, as was evident from the results, AIoT as a field is currently in its infancy but has demonstrated great potential to influence and transform several sectors and be a leading aspect in achieving a sustainable future. Given the importance of creating ideal conditions that will enable sustainable development and the achievement of SDGs, this study hopes to pave the way for new lines of work to be developed.
Due to the interdisciplinary nature of SDGs and AIoT, future studies should focus on exploring their intersection from different directions while targeting at specific SDGs or domains. Thus, collaboration among researchers of different backgrounds, expertise, and disciplines is encouraged. There is also a clear need for common evaluation metrics, standards, and models to be created. Ensuring the security and safety of critical infrastructure in the context of SDGs is also crucial. Hence, future studies should examine how AIoT can be used to enhance the security of critical infrastructure. Finally, there currently needs to be more empirical studies that involve the application of AIoT-enabled systems and platforms in real scenarios.