1. Introduction
In November 2017, the clinical use of pan-genotypic, dual direct-acting antiviral agent (DAA) therapy using the non-structural protein (NS)3/4A protease inhibitor glecaprevir and the NS5A inhibitor pibrentasvir was approved in Japan for hepatitis C virus (HCV)-infected patients without cirrhosis or with compensated cirrhosis [
1,
2]. Glecaprevir/pibrentasvir (GP) therapy appears to offer three advantages over other DAA regimens: (1) shorter treatment duration; (2) stronger genetic barrier to viral resistance; and (3) no restriction among patients with renal impairment or on dialysis, because these drugs are all metabolized hepatically. GP therapy is now recommended as one of the first-line, pan-genotypic DAA therapies for HCV patients without cirrhosis or with compensated cirrhosis, including non-responders to previous DAA therapy [
3,
4,
5]. However, NS3 protease inhibitor-containing regimens are contraindicated in patients with decompensated cirrhosis and in patients with compensated cirrhosis with previous episodes of decompensation because the blood concentrations of these drugs are markedly higher in patients with decompensated cirrhosis [
3,
4,
5]. In fact, although the GP regimen shows a safe profile of adverse effects even in real-world settings [
6], serious liver injury develops in some patients, leading to therapy discontinuation or liver failure [
7,
8,
9,
10]. However, adequate methods for coping with GP-induced liver injury are still unclear, and no consensus has been reached on criteria for drug discontinuation, interruption, or dose reduction once the serious liver injury has developed. Serious GP-induced liver injury thus remains troubling for attending physicians. Risk factors for drug-induced liver injury represent crucial information in the selection of adequate DAA regimens, and optimal methods to deal with GP-induced liver injury must be established in the interest of the safe completion of therapy.
Ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA) has long been used empirically as a drug for cholestatic drug-induced liver injury to shorten the time to resolution [
11,
12]. For daclatasvir/asunaprevir as an NS3 protease inhibitor-containing regimen, Taki et al. indicated that the lower frequency of serious drug-induced liver injury compared to previous reports may have been attributable to the use of add-on UDCA [
13]. However, evidence for the efficacy of UDCA for protease inhibitor-induced liver injury remains insufficient.
The aim of the present study was to elucidate risk factors for GP-induced liver injury in a real-world setting and to evaluate the efficacy of add-on UDCA for such liver injury.
4. Discussion
This retrospective cohort study was conducted to establish how best to deal with GP-induced liver injury, which occasionally becomes serious and can lead to therapy discontinuation or liver failure. The present study indicated the frequency, time to onset, type of liver injury, and risk factors for GP-induced liver injury. In addition, the efficacy of add-on UDCA for GP-induced liver injury was also shown. The key characteristics of patients in this study were older age and smaller BMI than those in clinical trials. The median age in this study was 70 years old, and the median BMI was 22.8 kg/m
2. On the other hand, the median age for participants in clinical trials was around 50–60 years [
16,
17,
18,
19], and the BMI was around 25 kg/m
2 [
20]. These differences in patient characteristics must therefore be considered when interpreting the present results.
Some meta-analyses, including real-world cohorts, have already reported that the efficacy and safety of GP therapy were similar to those in clinical trials [
6,
20,
21]. The SVR rate was close to 100%, and the adverse event-related discontinuation rate was less than 1%. The efficacy and safety of GP therapy have thus been proven with high-level evidence. This post-marketing observational cohort study was also able to show extremely high efficacy and safety rates, even in the elderly.
As many previous reports of GP therapy did not show minimal hepatic abnormalities like grade 1, the actual incidence of GP-induced therapy is unclear. The frequency of GP-induced liver injury in the present study was higher than expected. In Japanese clinical trials of GP therapy, hyperbilirubinemia was the only grade 3 hepatic abnormality encountered and was found in 2% (1/56) of cirrhotic patients. The incidence of TB elevation grade ≥ 2 in patients with and without cirrhosis was 2.7% (6/219) and 10.7% (6/56), respectively, and that of the cirrhotic patient group was higher than that of the non-cirrhotic patients’ group [
1,
2]. In a pooled analysis of five phase II/III trials of GP therapy for non-Japanese Asian patients, hepatic abnormalities ≥ grade 3 were rare (0.8%) [
19]. However, a systematic review and meta-analysis revealed that GP-induced liver injury occurred frequently, and hyperbilirubinemia occurred the most frequently, particularly in patients with cirrhosis [
22]. Furthermore, the meta-analysis also indicated that the most frequent grade 3 treatment-related abnormality among laboratory parameters was TB elevation. Comparing patients with and without cirrhosis, the incidence risk ratio of grade 3 hyperbilirubinemia was high, at 2.724 [
22]. In the present study, the most common liver abnormality was again TB elevation and necessitated therapy discontinuation or dose reduction in two patients. Careful attention to bilirubin elevation is therefore warranted during treatment.
Regarding the time to onset for GP-induced liver injury, the most frequent onset time was after 2 weeks, with more than half of GP-induced liver injuries developing within 4 weeks after the start of therapy. Laboratory testing should therefore be performed every 2 weeks during treatment for safety.
The present study analyzed risk factors for GP-induced liver injury. Univariate analysis revealed age, height, weight, BMI, white blood cell and platelet counts, ALT, γ-GT, PT, albumin, TB, and ALBI grade as significant. Although these factors were confounding, elderly, small-sized, cirrhotic patients might logically be considered at high risk of GP-induced liver injury. Among the risk factors identified as significant from univariate analyses, age and TB remained as independent factors after multivariate analysis. Some Japanese real-world cohorts with median ages around 65 years old revealed that the incidence of GP-induced hyperbilirubinemia was within the range of 0.6–2% [
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28]. However, Tamori et al. indicated in their real-world cohort that the median age of patients with hyperbilirubinemia was high, at 70 years old [
23]. The frequency of TB elevation grade ≥ 3 in the present study was 3.8%, higher than those in previous Japanese real-world cohorts. This is probably attributable to the higher median age in the present study compared to previous Japanese real-world cohorts. Therefore, other DAA regimens without an NS3 protease inhibitor, such as sofosbuvir/velpatasvir, should thus be selected for elderly patients with compensated cirrhosis.
Glecaprevir is mainly metabolized by liver cytochrome P450 (CYP)3A [
4,
5]. Glecaprevir plasma exposure was increased by 33% in patients with compensated cirrhosis relative to normal subjects [
29]. CYP content in the human liver decreases with age, and drug metabolism is reduced by around 30% after 70 years old [
30]. In addition, as the dose of GP therapy is not adjusted by body weight, drug plasma concentrations may tend to increase among low-body-weight patients compared to standard-weight patients. Accordingly, glecaprevir plasma concentrations can be expected to be increased in elderly cirrhotic patients compared to non-elderly cirrhotic patients. A reduced dose (e.g., around 30% reduction) of GP may thus be preferable for elderly cirrhotic patients for safety reasons.
In the present study, as TB and ALP elevations were frequently seen in GP-induced liver injury, the main GP-induced liver injuries can be considered to be cholestatic in nature. UDCA is classically used for the treatment of drug-induced cholestatic liver injury [
11,
12]. In the present study, elevated TB due to GP was significantly decreased in the add-on UDCA group but not when no UDCA was added to GP. This result reflects the efficacy of UDCA for GP-induced hyperbilirubinemia. Glecaprevir is a weak CYP3A inhibitor [
5]. On the other hand, UDCA reportedly prevents drug-induced reductions in hepatic CYP isozymes in rats [
31]. UDCA may therefore prevent or improve CYP3A enzyme reductions.
Some limitations of the present study should be considered. First, this was a single-center, retrospective cohort study with some biases. Furthermore, the numbers of patients of the add-on UDCA and the no UDCA groups were small. To validate the efficacy of add-on UDCA for GP-induced liver injury, future randomized studies are needed. Second, as no serious elevations in transaminases were seen in the present study, the efficacy of UDCA for GP-induced hepatocellular liver injury remains unknown. Third, from our results, whether UDCA can prevent the onset of GP-induced liver injury is still unknown.