3.2. Short-Term Effect of the DS Variants on the Viability and Cell Number in Cultures of Breast Cancer Cells
The biological effects of the structurally distinct DS variants were examined in three lines of breast cancer cells: a luminal type primary BT-483, a luminal type metastatic T-47D, and a triple-negative HCC-38, which differed in respect to their aggressiveness. These cells were cultured via their exposure to the tested isoforms, which were applied at three concentrations that covered a wide range of values. We selected 24 h as the basal time conditions of the viability test in the luminal cancer cell lines because prolonging the incubation period to 48 h led to a significant reduction in the obtained absorbance signal in both control and treated cultures of these cells (especially T-47D). In turn, the viability of the HCC-38 cells was examined at both time periods. As can be seen in
Figure 2A and
Supplementary Figure S2A, only some of the DS isoforms decreased the viability of cancer cells moderately when they were applied at the highest concentration (25 µg/mL) compared to the control; however, this effect was strongly dependent not only on the glycan structure but also on the cell type. NF, which exerted a statistically significant impact on both luminal cancer lines (
Figure 2A) was especially effective. In turn, PM markedly reduced the viability of only the BT-483 cells, whereas DF was able to decrease the viability of T-47D (
Figure 2A) although this effect was statistically insignificant (
p = 0.19). In contrast, no DS variant affected the viability of HCC-38 after either 24 h (
Supplementary Figure S2A) or 48 h of treatment (data not shown). In order to investigate whether the observed effects on the cancer cell viability could lead to alterations in the number of cancer cells by modulating their proliferation, we examined the DNA biosynthesis in the cultures that were grown for 24 and 48 h exposed to the tested DS variants. The trends as to the cancer cell proliferation that was found in these cultures were similar regardless of the length of the exposure time. Thus, to illustrate the persistence of the induced effects, we decided to show the data that concern the longer incubation period. These results clearly demonstrate (
Figure 2B and
Supplementary Figure S2B) that some of the structural DS isoforms such as NF and PM at a concentration of 25 µg/mL were able to effectively decrease not only the viability of BT-483 cells but also their proliferation compared to the control. Moreover, NF when applied at this concentration also exhibited a strong inhibitory effect on the DNA synthesis in the T-47D cells, but this alteration was statistically insignificant compared to the control (
Figure 2B). In turn, DF, which decreased (albeit statistically insignificantly) the viability of the T-47D cells, failed to affect their proliferation (
Figure 2B). Furthermore, none of the tested variants affected the DNA biosynthesis in the HCC-38 cultures (
Supplementary Figure S2B). To verify the data from the proliferation experiment in the luminal breast cancer cells, we examined the number of cells in the BT-483 and T-47D cultures that had been treated for 48 h with the DS variants exhibiting an inhibitory or non-inhibitory effect on the DNA biosynthesis. These variants were applied at a concentration of 25 µg/mL. Moreover, NF and PM were also used in the T-47D cultures at a concentration of 2.5 µg/mL, because the results of the proliferation test suggested that the variants can (insignificantly) stimulate the DNA biosynthesis under these conditions. The obtained data (
Figure 2C) confirmed that NF and PM can significantly reduce the number of BT-483 cells compared to the control. In contrast, both isoforms only insignificantly decreased the cell count in the T-47D cultures (
Figure 2C). However, unexpectedly, the most pronounced effect on these cells was exerted by DF, which reduced their number by almost two-fold compared to the control (
Figure 2C). These results suggest that compared to the other DS variants, DF can induce processes that have the most persistent consequences for the cell number in T-47D cultures. However, these processes can probably also stimulate proliferation in some of the T47D cells, which could explain the observed lack of differences in the DNA biosynthesis between the control and DF-treated cultures (
Figure 2B). On the other hand, the quantification of cellularity also showed that at a concentration of 2.5 µg/mL, neither NF nor PM had an effect on the number of T-47D cells (
Figure 2C).
3.3. Short-Term Impact of the DS Variants on the Induction of Death in the Luminal Breast Cancer Cells
All of the above-mentioned data indicated that free DS chains with some structural properties can initiate processes in the luminal breast cancer cells during a 24-h exposure, the effects of which persist for at least 48 h and affect various aspects of cancer cell activity. Thus, in order to identify these quickly activated processes, we assessed the effect of the selected DS variants on the induction of cell death in the BT-483 and T-47D cultures that had been grown for up to 24 h exposed to these molecules. We decided to verify this possibility because the existence of a clear relationship between DS and apoptosis has recently been well documented in various cell lines [
13,
18]. Furthermore, at this stage of our experiment, we focused especially on those DS variants that had been exhibited a significant impact on the cancer cells in the viability and cell count tests, i.e., NF and PM for BT-483 and DF for T-47D. However, to the investigation in the T-47D cultures, we also included PM, which had no visible effect on either their viability or cell number. This step enabled us to gain insight into the differences between BT-483 and T-47D in their response to PM in those previous tests.
In the cultures that had been grown in the presence of the tested variants for several time periods, we found an increase in both the Annexin V (AnV) binding to the plasma membrane and in the nuclear uptake of propidium iodide (PI) compared to the control (
Figure 3B and D and
Supplementary Figure S3). Moreover, almost all of the dying cells in the treated cultures had an AnV+ phenotype, which suggests that they died via the programmed process. Notably, in the cultures that had been exposed to NF, and especially to DF, the dying cells had preserved or even enhanced the size of their nuclei and had formed distinct clusters or large foci (
Figure 3B,D). Calculations of the percentages of the AnV-positive and/or PI-positive cells revealed that two DS variants, i.e., NF and DF strongly stimulated cell death in the BT-483 (
Figure 3A) and T-47D (
Figure 3C) cultures, respectively. However, these processes had different dynamics. NF progressively increased the number of AnV-positive cells over the incubation period starting at 4.5 h (
Figure 3A). In turn, DF exerted a single-peak stimulatory effect that was observed after 4.5 h of treatment (
Figure 3C). In contrast to NF and DF, PM manifested unexpected effects in both breast cancer cell lines. Despite the fact that this variant significantly reduced both the viability and cell number in the BT-483 cultures, it was unable to cause any significant effect on the dying cell number in these cultures during the entire incubation period (
Figure 3A), although at 4.5 and 12 h of treatment, there was a statistically insignificant ~two-fold increase in the AnV-positive cell number compared to the control. On the other hand, PM had a neutral or poor impact on the cell viability and count in the T-47D cultures, but markedly increased the number of dying cells in these cultures compared to the control at both 4.5 h and 12 h of the incubation (
Figure 3C). However, these alterations were a few-fold less than those that were induced by DF at 4.5 h of the treatment (
Figure 3C). These results indicate that some DS variants can quickly trigger processes in the breast cancer cells that lead to the programmed cell death of these cells in a structure-specific and/or cell type-specific manner.
In order to investigate whether apoptosis was really this form of programmed cell death that was initiated by the tested variants of DS in the luminal breast cancer cells during the short-term incubation, we examined the activity of the so-called effector caspases (caspase-3/7) in the cultures that had been exposed to these molecules for the same time periods as in the cell death assay. A quantitative analysis of the obtained images (
Figure 4B,D and
Supplementary Figure S4) revealed that NF markedly increased the percentage of BT-483 cells that had caspase-3/7 activity compared to the control only at 24 h of the incubation (
Figure 4A), whereas DF exerted this effect in the T-47D cultures at 12 h of the treatment (
Figure 4C). However, it should be emphasized that the percentage of caspase-3/7-positive cells in the cultures that had been exposed to NF or DF was a few-fold less than the total percentage of the cells that exhibited AnV binding in these cultures (
Figure 3B,D and
Supplementary Figure S4). In turn, PM did not affect the number of caspase-3/7-positive cells in the T-47D cultures compared to the control over the entire incubation period (
Figure 4C), although it insignificantly increased the quantity of these cells in the BT-483 line that had been grown in its presence for 12 h (
Figure 4A). The data above clearly indicate that apoptosis is not the only or even the major type of programmed death that can be triggered by the DS variants in luminal breast cancer cells during short-term exposure.
The phenotypical features of the breast cancer cells that died in response to the DS variants such as AnV binding, the lack of caspase-3/7 activity, and the presence of large, often visibly swollen nuclei suggest that these cells might undergo a necroptotic death. In the classical pathway of this lytic form of programmed death, which is induced after the activation of death receptors such as receptor-1 for tumor necrosis factor alfa (TNF-alfa), two receptor-interacting serine/threonine protein kinases (RIPK)-1 and -3 assemble into a cytosolic oligomeric complex that is called a necrosome [
19]. Within this complex, the activated RIPK-3 phosphorylates the effector component of necroptosis—mixed lineage kinase domain-like pseudokinase (MLKL) [
19]. Then, the activated MLKL oligomerizes and is translocated to the plasma membrane, where it perforates this membrane [
19]. Moreover, phosphorylated MLKL is also an executor of the necroptosis that is triggered via alternative signaling after the activation of the Toll-like receptors 3 and 4 [
20]. However, the execution of necroptosis can be inhibited by compounds such as NSA, which is believed to block the MLKL transfer into the plasma membrane [
21]. Therefore, we used NSA at a concentration that did not significantly reduce the cell number in the control cultures in our preliminary experiment, in order to determine whether this inhibitor might affect the DS variant-mediated induction of programmed death in the breast cancer cell lines. In this examination, we focused only on the short-term (up to 12 h) exposure of BT-483 and T-47D to the variants because the majority of them demonstrated their stimulatory effects on programmed cell death during such a period (
Figure 3). The application of NSA eliminated any statistically significant increases in the percentage of AnV-positive cells that had been observed in BT-483 and T-47D cells exposed to NF or DF/ PM, respectively, for 4.5 and/or 12 h (
Figure 5A and
Figure 6A vs.
Figure 3). Thus, the obtained data suggest that necroptosis might be the predominant, if not the only form of programmed death that is induced by at least some structural variants of DS during their short-term action on luminal breast cancer cells. In order to further corroborate this hypothesis, we examined the presence of activated MLKL oligomers in the breast cancer cells that had been exposed to the DS variants for three time periods. Such complexes were detected in single cells of the control cultures in which they formed either delicate linear structures extending along the cell membrane (BT-483 cells) (
Figure 5C and
Supplementary Figure S5A) or large light clusters that were located peripherally in the cell bodies (T-47D cells) (
Figure 6C and
Supplementary Figure S5B). It is intriguing whether such localization of phosphorylated MLKL might regulate the permeability of the cell membrane in the control cells thereby facilitating intercellular communication. On the other hand, the exposure of the cancer cells to NF or DF brought about a marked increase in the fluorescence signal (
Figure 5C and
Figure 6C and
Supplementary Figure S5), which suggests the intensification of both the MLKL activation and oligomerization, although the dynamics (
Figure 5B and
Figure 6B) of this process and its nature (
Figure 5C and
Figure 6C) were strongly dependent on the variant structure and cell type. NF generated the appearance of many fine-grained fluorescence-active structures in BT-483 cells at 2.5-h incubation (
Figure 5C). These structures were most likely able to form larger aggregates that were apparent in the coexistence with the former in the cell cultures after 3.5 h of treatment (
Supplementary Figure S5A). In addition, the occurrence of both types of these anti-phospho-MLKL-reactive structures also persisted after 11 h of treatment (
Figure 5B and
Supplementary Figure S5A). Notably, although the NF-triggered activation/oligomerization of MLKL was visible in almost all of the BT-483 cells, especially after 2.5 and 3.5 h of treatment, these cells differed markedly in respect to the intensity of their responsiveness (
Figure 5C and
Supplementary Figure S5A). In turn, DF mainly induced the formation of larger-size fluorescence-active structures in T-47D cells (
Figure 6C and
Supplementary Figure S5B). More-over, this process was most pronounced after 3.5 h of incubation and often affected the neighboring cells (
Figure 6B,C), which overlapped with the focal occurrence of AnV–positive cells in these cultures (
Figure 3D). However, it should be emphasized that regardless of the DS variant that was used, the activation of MLKL that was induced by it was time-correlated with programmed cell death, and clearly preceded the manifestations of this death in both the BT-483 and T-47D cells (
Figure 5B and
Figure 6B vs.
Figure 3).
In contrast, immunocytochemical analysis of the MLKL activation in the BT-483 and T-47D cells that were exposed to PM did not provide any clear answer as to the nature of the programmed cell death that was triggered by this variant (
Figure 5B and
Figure 6B) mainly due to the low level of the induced fluorescence signal. Nevertheless, based on the results of both the effector caspase activity test and the experiment with NSA it can be assumed that PM can induce apoptosis in the BT-483 cells and necroptosis in the T-47D cells during its short-term action. Therefore, in order to resolve this issue, we compared the levels of phospho-MLKL in these cell lines that had been treated with PM using immunoblotting analysis. The obtained data (
Figure 5D,E and
Figure 6D,E) indicate that both breast cancer lines had some basal level of MLKL activation, which was observed by the detection of a phospho-MLKL band in the extracts from the control cultures. On the other hand, the immunoblot analysis clearly showed that PM was able to increase the level of the activated MLKL only in the T-47D cells during both the 4 h and 11 h treatments (
Figure 6D,E vs.
Figure 5D,E). Thus, this observation supports the suggested differences in the response to PM between the T-47D and BT-483 cell lines.
3.4. Short-Term Effects of the DS Variants on the Mitochondrial Function and Oxidative Stress in the Cytoplasm of Breast Cancer Cells
In order to investigate the mechanism(s) that are triggered by the DS variants in the breast cancer lines and are potentially up-stream of the induction of necroptosis, we assessed the function of the mitochondrion in the BT-483 and T-47D cells during their short-term (up to 12 h) exposure to the glycans by measuring the transmembrane potential ∆Ψm. A reduction in ∆Ψm, which is detected as a decrease in the ratio between the red and the green fluorescence, is a reflection of the phenomenon that is called the mitochondrial permeability transition. This process represents a key mechanism that is implicated in the induction of several forms of programmed death such as apoptosis or necroptosis [
22]. A quantitative analysis (
Figure 7A,C) of the obtained images (
Figure 7B,D and
Supplementary Figure S6) showed that the exposure of BT-483 cells to NF led to a progressive reduction in ∆Ψm that began at 3 h of treatment and was statistically significant compared to the control at 12 h of the incubation period (
Figure 7A) These changes in the mitochondrial function occurred in parallel with an increase in the percentage of the AnV-positive and NSA-sensitive cells in these cultures (
Figure 7A vs.
Figure 3A and
Figure 5A). In turn, the PM that did not significantly affect the percentage of the AnV-positive BT-483 cells (
Figure 3A) was still able to trigger ∆Ψm pulsations (
Figure 7A), which were manifested as alternations of the reductions (significant at 4.5 h of the incubation period compared to the control) and increases (significant at 3 h of the treatment compared to the control) of this parameter. The open question is whether this pulsatory manner of the PM-mediated changes in ∆Ψm might be associated with the lysosomal processing of this variant in the BT-483 cells and the liberation of unknown biologically active sequences from its chains. In turn, the presence of PM in the T-47D cultures after an initial, statistically significant reducing effect on ∆Ψm had a neutral or even stabilizing impact on this parameter over the remaining exposure period compared to the control (
Figure 7C). The observed dynamics of the ∆Ψm alterations were poorly correlated with the mode of the occurrence of the AnV-positive and NSA-sensitive cells in the T-47D cultures that had been exposed to PM (
Figure 7C vs.
Figure 3C and
Figure 6A). In contrast, the exposure of T-47D to DF caused a significant decrease in ∆Ψm of these cells compared to the control over almost the entire period of the treatment (
Figure 7C). However, these alterations in the mitochondrial function were also poorly associated with the dynamics of the DF-mediated induction of necroptosis in the T-47D cells (
Figure 7C vs.
Figure 3C and
Figure 6A). Thus, it can be concluded that DS clearly affects the mitochondrial function in the luminal breast cancer cells in both a structure-dependent and cell-type-dependent manner. However, there were no close mutual relationships between the DS variant-mediated short-term effects on ∆Ψm and on the induction of necroptosis, especially in the T-47D cultures.
It has recently been found that the reactive oxygen species (ROS)-mediated oxidation of RIPK-1, which is a cytosolic molecule, can trigger necroptosis [
23]. Thus, to further explore the mechanism(s) that can be up-stream of the induction of necroptosis and that might be rapidly triggered by DS in breast cancer cells, we examined the dynamics of oxidative stress in the cytoplasm of BT-483 and T-47D that had been exposed to the tested variants of this GAG for up to 12 h. The quantitative analysis (
Figure 8A,C) of the obtained data (
Figure 8B,D and
Supplementary Figure S7) clearly indicated that all of the tested variants are able to rapid (visible after 1 h of treatment) induction of oxidative stress in the cytoplasm of both cancer lines. It is noteworthy that this phenomenon temporarily preceded the DS-triggered alterations in ∆Ψm in the BT-483 cells (
Figure 8A vs.
Figure 7A), but co-existed with the DS-dependent compromising of the mitochondrial function in the T-47D cells (
Figure 8C vs.
Figure 7C). This observation suggests that the DS-mediated overproduction of ROS in the cytoplasm might lead to mitochondrial discrimination in at least in BT-483 cells. However, after treatment of longer than 1 h, most of the tested DS variants lost their ability to generate oxidative stress in the cytoplasm of the BT-483 or T-47D cells (
Figure 8A,C). Only NF supported or even increased the oxidative stress in the cytoplasm of the BT-483 cells throughout the entire exposure period (
Figure 8A). A comparison between the dynamics of the DS variant-induced ROS overproduction in the cytoplasm and the dynamics of programmed death/necroptosis manifestations clearly indicated a similar manner of the occurrence of these phenomena albeit the first of them preceded the latter (
Figure 8A vs.
Figure 3A and
Figure 5A as well as
Figure 8C vs.
Figure 3C and
Figure 6A).