1. Introduction
Agates (banded chalcedony—SiO
2) are spectacular products of nature, which have been investigated for decades regarding the conditions of their formation (e.g., [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10]). In detail, agates have a very complex composition consisting of certain SiO
2 polymorphs and morphological quartz varieties (e.g., [
4,
11,
12,
13]). For instance, quartzine, opal-A, opal-CT and/or moganite can be intergrown or intercalated with chalcedony layers and macrocrystalline quartz in agate. Moreover, agates can contain considerable amounts of water (molecular water and/or silanol groups) and mineral inclusions, which are often responsible for the different colouration of agates [
4,
7,
12,
13,
14].
The process of agate formation is as complex as its composition and may differ depending on the type of parent rocks and formation environment. Most agates occur in volcanic host rocks.
The chemical and mineralogical composition of agates in volcanic host rocks as well as their association with certain mineral products of alteration processes (e.g., zeolites, clay minerals, iron oxides) led to the conclusion that the formation of these agates is closely connected to late- and post-volcanic alteration or weathering of the parent rocks (e.g., [
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11]).The complex processes lead to the accumulation of silica in cavities, so that agates represent a mixture of certain SiO
2 polymorphs and morphological quartz varieties (e.g., [
4,
7,
11,
12]).
Transport and accumulation of silica in cavities of the host rocks is predominantly realized by diffusion processes. In basic volcanics, vesicular cavities form during the solidification of the lava, whereas in acidic volcanics so-called lithophysae (high-temperature crystallization domains [
15]) are formed at first, due to the devitrification and degassing of the volcanic glass/melt.
The formation of vein agates is related to fissures and veins within different types of crystalline rocks, which enable a free movement of silica-bearing mineralizing fluids through a system of cracks. Here, SiO
2 is accumulated by hydrothermal-magmatic solutions, whereas silica in sedimentary agates preferentially derives from SiO
2-rich pore solutions [
16].
The accumulation and condensation of silicic acid result in the formation of silica sols and amorphous silica as precursors for the development of the typical agate structures. It is assumed that the formation of the typical agate microstructure is governed by processes of self-organization, starting with the spherulitic growth of chalcedony and continuing into chalcedony fibres [
10,
12]. Macrocrystalline quartz crystallizes when the SiO
2 concentration in the mineralizing fluid is low. The estimation of the temperature of agate formation using oxygen isotopes, Al concentrations or homogenization temperatures of fluid inclusions provided a temperature range between ca. 20 and 200 °C [
7].
Although much geochemical and mineralogical data of agates exist, there are still open questions and controversial discussions, especially regarding the transport of the enormous amounts of silica necessary for the formation of agates. In general, it is assumed that diffusion of monomeric silicic acid in pore fluids could be the main transport process (e.g., [
1,
7,
17,
18]). However, geochemical data indicate that a transport of elements and chemical compounds in aqueous fluids cannot be the only process involved in agate formation. In certain agates (especially those of acidic volcanic rocks), elevated concentrations of Ge (>10 ppm), U (>15 ppm) and B (>30 ppm) as well as the occurrence of paragenetic calcite and fluorite indicate that other fluids can play a role in the alteration of volcanic rocks and the mobilization and transport of SiO
2 and other chemical compounds [
11,
19]. In consequence, additional chemical transport reactions (CTR) of gases and liquids by stable fluorine (and chlorine) compounds such as SiF
4, BF
3, GeF
4 and UO
2F
2 could explain the processes during agate formation better than exclusive element transport by silicic acid in aqueous solutions (e.g., [
20,
21]). The analysis of the fluids in the different agates provides information about the chemical composition of mineral-forming fluids and for the reconstruction of the agate formation processes.
The sample material includes agates from basic and acidic volcanic rocks, hydrothermal vein agates and agates of sedimentary origin to enable a comparison of these different formation environments. In the present study, a systematic study of gaseous and liquid fluids in agates from different localities and of different origin was performed by evolved gas analysis (in this case and further called thermogravimetry-mass-spectrometry). Moreover, microcrystalline chalcedony and macro-crystalline quartz were analysed separately to reveal possible differences in the fluid composition. Because of the lack of visible fluid inclusions within the micro-crystalline agate matrix, conventional techniques for the characterization of the fluids such as microscopy or Raman spectroscopy could not be applied.
3. Results
The focus of this investigation was the characterization of the compounds that escaped during heating at various temperatures. They were identified according to their mass-charge-ratio and the corresponding intensity relations of the associated fragments. The detected and measured fluids consisted of compounds of fluorine, chlorine, sulphur, carbon and nitrogen with oxygen and/or hydrogen.
By default, the thermographic curves were also logged, revealing total mass losses during heating to 1450 °C between 0.5% and 1.5% for chalcedony and <0.5% for the quartz samples. Some similarities are found between the samples: chalcedony tends to have a rather unspecific mass loss during heating, with two main loss ranges between 100–500 °C and above 1000 °C (e.g., Chemnitz-Furth, Chemnitz-Altendorf, St. Egidien, Zwickau). Quartz revealed even more unspecific characteristics, except for the samples from Chemnitz-Furth and St. Egidien, both showing a step at around 300 °C with mass loss of 0.1%–0.2%.
3.1. Detected Compounds
3.1.1. Hydrogen
Hydrogen does not occur separately but mainly results from splitting off from a compound after ionization. The remaining hydrogen either appears as H or H
2 on the m/q = 1 and 2 (
Figure 3), which also represent the mass-charge-ratios that identify hydrogen. Both H and H
2 mainly appear around 500–550 °C though H
2 often appears around 900–950 °C as well.
3.1.2. Chlorine
Chlorine occurs on the mass-charge-ratios 35 and 37. The main part (75.8%) belongs to
35Cl, which is consistent with the mass-charge-ratio 35. The rest is associated with
37Cl (24.2%) [
30]. The Cl
2 molecule appears on the mass-charge-ratios 70, 72 (for
36Cl which is not stable or
35Cl
37Cl) and 74, respectively. Together with H, chlorine forms HCl, which is detectable on the mass-charge-ratios 36 (
Figure 4), 37 and 38 (
Figure 5). In chalcedony, all mass-charge-ratios for chlorine could be identified except for the mass-charge-ratio = 35, which only occurred in the Rio Grande do Sul sample. However, in quartz all mass-charge-ratios could be identified, although m/q = 35 only occurs in the samples Chemnitz-Furth, St. Egidien and Rio Grande do Sul. The measurements showed that all compounds degas between 300–500 °C and around 1000 °C. The identification is difficult due to the interference with other compounds. The mass-charge-ratios 35 and 36 can be interfered by H
2S, 37 by
12C
31H and 38 by
19F
2 and
12C
31H
2. All chlorine molecules show interference with hydrocarbon compounds and with SO
2.
3.1.3. Nitrogen
Nitrogen occurs as
14N and
15N, though
15N only makes 0.4% of the natural nitrogen. The nitrogen molecule
14N
2 can be identified on the mass-charge-ratio 28 which is more abundant besides 29. NO, N
2O and NO
2 can be formed with oxygen and can be identified by the mass-charge-ratios 30 (
14N
16O), 44 and 45 (N
2 O) and 46 (
14N
16O
2). N
2O and associated fragments show dominant peaks at m/q = 44, 30, 16 and 14 (
Figure 6), whereas in NO
2 appears at m/q = 30, 46, 16 and 14. In combination with hydrogen,
14N
1H
3 is formed with m/q = 14–17, with the peak at m/q = 17 as the dominant. The main temperatures of degassing peak around 500 °C and around 900 °C. The nitrogen compounds show a variety of peak developments. In some samples (Zwickau, St. Egidien—see
Figure 7) no peak was formed but a continuous curve occurs, especially at the mass-charge ratios 28, 30 and 44. Sometimes, strongly increasing curves appear (e.g., m/q = 44, 45 and 46 in
Figure 8) and only a few samples exhibit well developed peaks (e.g., quartz in sample Chemnitz Furth and Rio Grande do Sul, respectively). A problem when identifying these compounds is the fact, that all of them (except m/q = 31 for
15N
16O) interfere with compounds of carbon.
3.1.4. Fluorine
Fluorine compounds are associated with the mass-charge-ratios 19 to 21 (F = 19, HF = 20 and 21). The fluorine molecule
19F
2 appears at the mass-charge ratio 38. The degassing temperature was found mainly around 500 °C but also rises up to 1000 °C. Results of [
20] with degassing temperatures around 900 °C confirm the recent measurements. Due to their overlap with water (m/z =18–20) the curves for
19F and
1H
19F do not show one clear peak but either several peaks (e.g., Rio Grande do Sul, St. Egidien in
Figure 9) or a continuous curve of degassing. The interference of water with
19F and
1H
19F might be low but cannot be ignored.
19F
2 interferes with
1H
37Cl and
12C
31H
2.
3.1.5. Carbon
Carbon has the mass-charge ratios 12 and 13. The intensity on m/q = 12 should be significantly higher than that on m/q = 13. Several hydrocarbon compounds are formed in combination with H as well as CO and CO
2 with oxygen. They can be identified via the mass-charge ratios 28 (
Figure 10) and 44 which should show the highest intensity in comparison with other mass-charge ratios such as m/q = 12 (
12C), 16 (
16O), 29 (
13C
16O), 45 (
13C
16O
2) or 46 (
12C
17O
2). Furthermore, carbonic acid (
1H
212C
16O
3) is another compound formed with hydrogen and oxygen. It is detectable on the mass-charge-ratio 62 and the dissociation products on 61(
1H
12C
16O
3−) and 60 (
12C
16O
32−—
Figure 11).
Hydrocarbon compounds can also be present in hydrothermal and volcanic fluids. Studies of [
31] detected hydrocarbon in agates of acidic volcanic rocks from Novy Kosciol (Poland). The most important hydrocarbon compounds are methane (
12C
1H
4, m/q = 12), ethane (
12C
21H
6, m/q = 30), propane (
12C
31H
8, m/q = 44), butane (
12C
41H
10, m/q = 58), heptane (
12C
51H
12, m/q = 72), hexane (
12C
61H
14, m/q = 86) and heptane (
12C
71H
16, m/q = 100). During ionization hydrogen splits up from the compounds and several dissociation products can form.
Looking at the degassing curves, either distinct peaks or exponential-like increasing curves can occur. The exponential increase is characteristic for the mass-charge ratios 12 (
12C,
Figure 12), 28 (
12C
16O) and 44 (
12C
16O
2) in most samples except the agate from Chemnitz Furth (m/q = 12 and 44). All other compounds degas at temperatures around 500 °C with slight differences between quartz and chalcedony. An exception is m/q = 60 (
12C
16O
32−), which was only detected in chalcedony of the samples from Montana, Rio Grande do Sul, Zwickau, St. Egidien and Schlottwitz at 300–400 °C and in the quartz fraction of all samples around 400 °C. At higher temperatures (1000 °C) only hydrocarbon compounds degas.
Due to their complexity, carbon compounds interfere with many other compounds. For instance,
12C
16O and
12C
16O
2 interfere with the nitrogen compounds
14N
2,
14N
216O and
14N
16O
2, heptane with chlorine (m/q = 70, 72), or sulphur compounds at high mass-charge ratios with other hydrocarbon compounds. Furthermore, different carbon compounds can interfere among each other such as
12C
16O and
12C
21H
4 (m/q = 28—
Figure 9) or
12C
16O
2 and
12C
31H
8 (m/q = 44).
3.1.6. Sulphur
Natural sulphur consists of 95%
32S, 4.2%
33S and 0.75%
34S [
30]. It can form compounds with hydrogen and oxygen, such as SO
2, H
2S, H
2SO
4 and their decomposition products. SO
2 can be identified with the mass-charge ratios 64 (
32S
16O
2,
Figure 13), 48 (
32S
16O) and 32 (
32S), which are the most important besides 65, 50, 49, 34 and 33. H
2S should show the highest intensities on the mass-charge ratios 34 (
1H
232S,
Figure 14), 35(
1H
233S) and 32 (
32S), whereas m/q = 35 and 36 have lower intensities. H
2SO
4 is detectable on the mass-charge ratios 80 (
Figure 15), 81, 82, 98, 64 and 65, which are important for identification.
Most sulphur compounds degas at low temperatures between 300 and 350 °C such as 32S16O (m/q = 48), 1H232S (m/q = 34) and S (m/q = 33). The mass-charge ratio 64 often shows no distinct degassing peak but a strongly increasing curve, except for the agate from St.Egidien which shows a strong peak around 500 °C. For the m/q = 32, which only occurs in the chalcedony samples Rio Grande do Sul, St. Egidien and Zwickau, a curve with concave shape to the underground appears. In the quartz samples, this mass-charge ratio is not detectable in the agate from Chemnitz Furth.
Sulphur compounds show interferences with chlorine compounds, e.g., on the mass-charge ratios 35 (1H233S and 35Cl) and 36 (1H234S and 1H35Cl) and with hydrocarbon compounds (except 33S m/q = 33 and 32S16O m/q = 48).
3.2. Volatiles Compounds in Agates of Different Origins
3.2.1. Agates from Mafic Volcanic Rocks
The agates from Rio Grande do Sul (Brazil) and Heads of Ayr (Scotland) originate from mafic volcanic rocks (basalts). The quartz part of the Rio Grande agate degasses between 250 and 550 °C with no degasification at a higher temperature range, whereas chalcedony of these samples shows degassing between 850 and 1300 °C. In contrast, both quartz and chalcedony from Heads of Ayre degas at low and high temperatures. The lower temperature range is between 150 and 600 °C with a maximum of degassing at 500 °C. At higher temperatures between 950 and 1200 °C only few volatiles could be detected (mainly hydrocarbon compounds). Both samples contain various sulphur-, chlorine- and hydrocarbon compounds as well as HF only in chalcedony.
3.2.2. Agates from Acidic and Intermediate Volcanic Rocks
Agates originating from acidic to intermediate volcanic rocks are represented by the samples from Zwickau, Chemnitz-Furth and St. Egidien, Germany. Two main ranges of degasification were detected at 400–500 °C and 900–1000 °C with some additional compounds degassing between. Chalcedony tends to degas at slightly higher temperatures (up to 1250 °C, Zwickau), whereas the escape temperatures of volatiles in macrocrystalline quartz are mostly below 1000 °C.
All samples contain compounds of nitrogen, chlorine, sulphur and carbon. The fluorine compounds 19F and 19F2 were detected in all samples, whereas 1H19F was only found in the chalcedony separates. Carbonates were detected as well, preferentially in quartz. For instance, H2CO3 and associated fragmentary compounds were measured during degassing of macrocrystalline quartz in the agate from Chemnitz Furth.
3.2.3. Vein Agates
Vein agates are represented by the samples from Chemnitz Altendorf and Schlottwitz. Both investigated agates contain sulphur and chlorine compounds as well as 1H212C16O3. In addition, 19F and 19F2 were detected in the Chemnitz-Altendorf sample and 12C16O32−, 1H12C16O3 as well as nitrogen compounds in the agate from Schlottwitz.
The agate from Chemnitz Altendorf showed a narrow temperature range of degasification. Both chalcedony and quartz mainly degas at 500 °C, quartz shows an additional escape of volatiles at a temperature of ca. 1000 °C (up to 1200 °C). The thermal behaviour of the agate from Schlottwitz is quite different. Volatiles in macrocrystalline quartz show narrow degassing temperature ranges around 250, 550 and 1000 °C, whereas chalcedony starts to degas in a wider range between 300 and 500 °C up to 950–1250 °C with some mass-charge-ratios showing additional escaping fluids in the temperature range between.
3.2.4. Sedimentary Agates
The agate from Montana, USA is also known as Dryhead agate which is formed in sedimentary rocks [
26]. In this agate type compounds of nitrogen, chlorine, fluorine, sulphur and carbonate were detected. Chalcedony seems to contain more nitrogen compounds (
14N
1H
3 and
14N
1H
2), whereas fluorine (
19F) is more abundant in macrocrystalline quartz.
Between 200–600 °C and 900–1050 °C, maxima of degassing were detected in both chalcedony and macrocrystalline quartz, although the escape of fluids from quartz occurred in a narrower range with a maximum around 500 °C. Chalcedony on the other hand shows varying maxima of degassing. Both show additional slight degasification between or above these temperature ranges on some mass-charge-ratios.
4. Discussion
The results of the experiments illustrate that there is a number of fluids present in chalcedony and macrocrystalline quartz of agates of different genetic types and from different occurrences worldwide. The main compounds together with the corresponding degassing temperatures are summarized in
Table 2. It has to be considered that the chemical compounds listed are not identical with the primary fluids included in the agate samples. During degassing and ionization of the fluids at elevated temperature, processes of dissociation can change the original chemical composition of the compounds. Therefore, the detected compounds provide only indications regarding the chemical composition of the included fluids.
The degassing curves (
Figure 3,
Figure 4,
Figure 5,
Figure 6,
Figure 7,
Figure 8,
Figure 9,
Figure 10,
Figure 11,
Figure 12,
Figure 13,
Figure 14 and
Figure 15) illustrate that the escape of fluids can occur in two different ways: abruptly or as diffusion process. Sharp peaks (spikes) are interpreted to be explosion-like decrepitation effects due to the rupture of inclusions, caused by the increasing pressure in the inclusions and resulting in abrupt degassing [
32]. On the other hand, a steeply rising curve is assumed to be correlated with the opening of cracks (around 800 °C). Whereas the spikes were detected at varying temperatures, in our samples the crack-correlated increase of the signals occurred around 500 and 900 °C respectively.
Diffusion, on the other hand, results in broad maxima because of a rather slow and continuous process of volatile release. It occurs when structurally bound molecules diffuse out of the quartz structure at a certain temperature. The simultaneous occurrence of crack opening and diffusion processes causes defined peaks with a broad foot, which are found for most mass-charge ratios [
33,
34].
The chemical composition of fluids found in nearly all samples is characterized by carbonates, nitrogen-, sulphur- and fluorine compounds as indicated in
Table 2. Furthermore, chlorine was found though it shows interference with other compounds. Its presence, especially the mass-charge ratio 35, was verified by Götze et al. [
19], who found chlorine as a salt in the inclusions of the samples Chemnitz-Furth and St. Egidien.
Although there was no marked difference in abundance of measured fluid compounds between quartz and chalcedony the mass charge ratios measured in quartz occurred at more temperature ranges. In addition, carbonates seem to appear more commonly in macrocrystalline quartz, whereas fluorine compounds were more frequently detected in chalcedony.
Except for the sample Heads of Ayr, the investigated samples, show two ranges of degasification for both chalcedony and macrocrystalline quartz. Most compounds escape in the lower temperature range around 500 °C. At higher temperatures between 950–1050 °C mainly hydrocarbon compounds, carbonates and sulphur compounds were detected. Chalcedony showed additional degassing between 150 to 350 °C and 1100 to 1250 °C, which is interpreted as degassing from liquids from grain boundaries and enclosed inclusions.
Differences were detected for agate samples from different genetic environments, in particular when comparing the temperatures of degassing. In general, agates from mafic volcanic rocks tend to have a broad temperature range of degassing, whereas the agates of felsic origin show a narrower one. The first release of volatiles happens around 500 °C, the second degassing around 1000 °C is more pronounced in the agates from felsic host rocks. Agates from a sedimentary host rock show two temperature ranges of degassing with the lower one between 200 and 500 °C. These different degassing temperatures show that differences in the agate micro-structure may influence the thermal release of fluids. A looser structure results in degassing at lower temperatures.
In general, the results from a recent study [
35] are confirmed by this investigation. Moxon [
35] differentiated between different types of water with distinct degassing temperatures (e.g., molecular water <190 °C and silanol water >1000 °C). Although the focus in the present study was more on the different compounds that evolve during heating, distinct temperature ranges were also found for both the mass loss and the detected components (see
Table 2). Differences in the temperatures that were described in detail in [
35] and the presented data may be found in the different design and objective of the experiments.
An interesting result is the possible role of chlorine and fluorine compounds in the transport and accumulation of silica and other elements during agate formation [
20]. Both compounds could be detected, although the presence of chlorine is uncertain due to the strong interference with other compounds. Nevertheless, the results indicate the possible transport of silica in other forms than as diffusing silicic acid in aqueous pore solutions. Such a scenario is emphasized by Schrön [
21], who proposed the volatile transport of silica as SiF
4.
The results in
Table 2 emphasize that fluorine compounds were in particular detected in agates from volcanic environments. This can be explained by the preferred occurrence of F-bearing volatiles in volcanic processes, which can act as transport media for certain chemical compounds. Götze et al. [
20] detected high concentrations of Ge, U and B in agates of acidic volcanic rocks and concluded that other fluids than aqueous ones can play a role in the alteration of volcanic rocks and the mobilization and transport of SiO
2 and other chemical compounds. Chemical transport reactions by stable fluorine compounds such as SiF
4, BF
3, GeF
4 and UO
2F
2 could be responsible for the accumulation of these elements and additional phases such as calcite or fluorite besides SiO
2 modifications in volcanic agates. Accordingly, element transport for agate formation in volcanic environments is not exclusively related to aqueous solutions.
The results of the present study also provided some more information regarding the participation of different fluids during the formation of the agates. The occurrence of hydrocarbon compounds in agates of volcanic origin was proven, which was first suggested by Dumańska-Słowik et al. [
31] and Götze et al. [
20]. In the case of the agates from Nowy Kościół (Poland), Dumańska-Słowik et al. [
31] detected solid bitumen, which they related to algal or a mixed algal-humic origin based on the stable carbon isotope composition.
In the agates investigated in this study, certain hydrocarbon compounds as well as carbonic acid could be detected. The incorporation of hydro-carbon compounds as inclusions into the SiO2 microstructure points to co-precipitation of both materials, probably from the same source. Hydrothermal methane and/or higher-molecular hydrocarbon compounds in the volatiles participating in the silica accumulation could have served as precursors for the detected organic fluids in the agate.
5. Conclusions
Separated chalcedony and macrocrystalline quartz from eight agates of different origin and localities were analysed by thermoanalysis directly coupled with a mass spectrometer. The temperature ranges at which degassing occurs were mainly found around 500 and 1000 °C. The analysed volatiles consisted of compounds of C, N, S, F and Cl with H and/or O. They could be identified according to their specific mass-charge ratio and the corresponding temperature of degassing. Due to interferences of different compounds with similar mass-charge ratios not all compounds could be definitely identified. Nevertheless, the results gave indications regarding the sources and transport of silica for the agate formation. Besides the transport and accumulation of silica in aqueous solutions, the possible role of fluorine compounds, CO2 and other fluids in the alteration of rocks and the mobilization and transport of SiO2 have to be taken into account.
The method of thermogravimetry-mass-spectrometry used is suitable for the investigation of fluid phases in minerals because of the limited requirements for preparation and the possibility for direct measurements of escaping gases. However, limitations in the proper verification of chemical compounds are given by interfering mass-charge-ratios due to the limited resolution of the mass-spectrometer. Moreover, the measured chemical compounds are not always identical with the primary included fluids, since ionization and dissociation of the volatiles at elevated temperatures can change the original chemical composition of the compounds. Therefore, the detected compounds often represent fragments of the primary volatiles.