1. Introduction
The Bohai Sea is the only semi-enclosed inland sea in China and holds a pivotal position in the pattern of the marine economy, with an average water depth of 18 m [
1]. This special geographical condition is very convenient for marine economic activities, making the surrounding areas of the Bohai Sea a gathering place for many important ports and densely distributed offshore oil extraction facilities, with highly active marine economic activities. While these economic activities have promoted regional development, they have also led to a persistently high risk of oil spill accidents. Taking the oil spill accident at the Penglai 19-3 Oilfield in 2011 as an example, this accident caused about 6200 square kilometers of seawater to be polluted. The direct economic loss of fishery resources reached CNY 1.683 billion, and the loss of natural fishery resources was about CNY 3.641 billion [
2,
3]. These data serve as a warning that we must attribute great importance to the pollution risks posed by marine oil spills to China’s marine environment, and strengthen the research, prevention, and control of marine oil spills.
In the field of oil spill risk assessment, oil spill models are essential for supervision and emergency planning. They not only need to estimate the occurrence risk of oil spills (referred to as occurrence risk) but also evaluate the oil pollution risk after an oil spill occurs (referred to as oil pollution risk) [
4,
5]. The occurrence risk is the starting point of the entire oil spill risk assessment. Understanding the likelihood of oil spills helps to identify areas where oil spill accidents may occur in advance. For example, if we can determine which areas in the Bohai Sea are prone to oil spills due to frequent ship navigation, dense oil platforms, or harsh sea state, we can strengthen the supervision of ship navigation and oil platform operations in these high occurrence risk areas, establish stricter safety standards, and deploy special monitoring equipment. This can reduce the probability of oil spill accidents and control occurrence risk at an early stage. This not only mitigates potential pollution to the marine environment but also avoids a series of economic losses caused by oil spill accidents, such as damage to fisheries, interruption of maritime transportation, and impact on tourism.
An assessment of the oil pollution risk is also crucial. Once an oil spill accident occurs, accurately grasping the distribution of the oil pollution risk can help us quickly judge the possible pollution range and degree of the accident. By studying the differences in oil pollution risk in different seasons and regions, such as which regions are more likely to be polluted by oil spills in a specific season and the degree of impact of pollution on the coastline and marine biological habitats, relevant departments can reasonably allocate emergency resources and develop more targeted emergency response plans. For example, sufficient oil-cleaning equipment and materials can be pre-stored in high oil pollution risk (referred to as high-risk) areas, and professional emergency response teams can be trained. In this way, when an accident occurs, a rapid response can be made to minimize the harm caused by oil spill pollution.
Many previous studies have also been conducted regarding the occurrence and pollution risk in the Bohai Sea. For example, based on the distribution of ships and oil platforms in the Bohai Sea, the historical oil spill accident data in the Bohai Sea from 1973 to 2002, and the relevant literature, Liu et al. (2015) established a probability model to evaluate the oil spill risk in the Bohai Sea and identified seven high occurrence risk areas [
6]. However, their study mainly focused on constructing a probability model for an oil spill occurrence risk assessment, and it did not involve a numerical simulation of the oil spill pollution risk based on its occurrence risk. Subsequently, Guo et al. (2019) developed a statistical oil spill response model in the Bohai Sea [
7]. According to the distribution of offshore oil platforms in the Bohai Sea, 20 potential oil spill locations were selected. Over an 18-year time span, 200 oil spill moments were randomly selected and in each oil spill simulation, the volume of the oil spill was randomly assigned. Then, based on the simulation results of all scenarios, the probability distribution of oil spill pollution was statistically calculated, achieving a quantitative assessment of the oil pollution risks to the surrounding sea areas and coastlines caused by potential oil spill accidents at offshore oil platforms in the Bohai Sea. Although their study focused on the assessment of the oil spill occurrence and pollution risk, it did not thoroughly explore the characteristics of pollution risk in relation to the factors considered, and it ignored pollution risk in relation to the densities of shipping lines. Ke et al. (2022) adopted multi-source high-resolution satellite remote sensing data to extract the distribution of two main types of oil spill risk sources, namely ships and oil platforms, in the Bohai Sea. Combined with the satellite remote sensing monitoring results of oil spills in the Bohai Sea from 2015 to 2020, their study analyzed the imaging characteristics of different types of oil under various sensors. Through the nuclear density analysis method of oil spill sources, their study obtained the spatial–temporal distribution of oil spill events, and achieved a comprehensive evaluation of the degree of pollution risk in the Bohai Sea [
8]. Similarly, Tang and Su (2024) simulated the drifting and diffusion process of oil slicks in seawater under different working conditions in the sea area of Jingtang Port in the Bohai Sea, and discussed the impacts of oil spill pollution on nearby ecological protection zones, tourism and recreational areas, and fishery breeding and fishing areas [
9]. However, both of these studies were limited to short-term impacts in specific regions and conditions within the Bohai Sea, ignoring the overall oil pollution risk characteristics associated with the oil platform location and shipping route density across the entire Bohai Sea.
According to previous studies, there are still some limitations in the research on oil spill risk assessment in the Bohai Sea. On the one hand, the historical oil spill data in the Bohai Sea region are relatively sparse, specifically, detailed records of small-scale oil spill accidents. This data deficiency is particularly crucial when attempting to link occurrence risks to the oil platform location and shipping route density. In the region of highly concentrated oil platforms or busy shipping lines, even small-scale spills can accumulate over time and lead to significant pollution. Without sufficient data on these minor incidents, the risk assessment process lacks the necessary data support. As a result, accurately quantifying the occurrence risk needs to consider comprehensive factors including sea state, oil platform location, and shipping route density. On the other hand, studies regarding the distribution characteristics of oil pollution risk in the Bohai Sea remain scarce. In fact, the marine environment of the Bohai Sea exhibits substantial spatial–temporal variations. Factors such as circulation and wind significantly affect the diffusion and pollution extent of oil spills.
Therefore, this study intends to (1) construct an oil spill occurrence risk assessment model by considering multiple factors such as sea state, oil platform location, and shipping route density, and depict an occurrence risk map of potential oil spills to illustrate the spatial distribution characteristics of occurrence risk in the Bohai Sea, providing a more intuitive and effective decision-making foundation for relevant departments; (2) depict and analyze the pollution risk in the Bohai Sea, taking into account multiple dynamic factors such as circulation and monsoon, so as to present the pollution impact of various regions, and furnish a scientific basis for formulating targeted prevention and control strategies.
2. Materials and Methods
As mentioned above, this study explores two types of risks, namely the occurrence risk of oil spills (referred to as occurrence risk) and the pollution risk after an oil spill occurs (referred to as pollution risk). These two types of risks are crucial for comprehensively understanding the threat of oil spills in the Bohai Sea, ensuring the safety of the marine environment in the Bohai Sea, and the stable development of related industries.
This study begins with identifying the environmental characteristics of the Bohai Sea and the current situation of oil spill accidents, then constructs a systematic assessment system, and conducts detailed index calculations and analyses for these two types of risks. The specific content is shown in the following.
2.1. Occurrence Risk
The occurrence of oil spills may be caused by various factors, including harsh sea conditions, ship collisions, and offshore oil platform leaks. This paper assumes that the occurrence risk of oil spills is mainly related to these three factors. According to the research of Guo et al. (2019), the weights of these three factors are set to 0.2, 0.4, and 0.4, respectively [
7]. That is, the calculation of the occurrence risk index (
Roccur) of oil spills in the Bohai Sea is as follows:
where
Rocean,
Rroute, and
Rplatform are the risk indexes of sea state, shipping route density, and oil platform location, respectively.
2.1.1. Marine Environments
Harsh marine environments are closely related to large waves, strong currents, and strong winds. Generally, in the Bohai Sea, we define harsh sea conditions as when the wind speed exceeds a certain threshold (such as Beaufort scale 7, with a wind speed of 13.9–17.1 m/s), the current velocity is greater than a specific value (such as 1 m/s), and the wave height reaches a certain height (such as an effective wave height exceeding 2 m). In such sea conditions, the stability of ship navigation decreases, and the external forces acting on oil platform equipment increase, thus significantly increasing the occurrence risk.
According to the research of Guo et al. (2019) [
7], this study uses three indicators, namely the effective wave height, current velocity, and wind speed, to establish the degree of harsh sea conditions, which is expressed as follows:
where
Socean represents the sea state severity;
i and
j represent the grid points corresponding to longitude and latitude;
Hwave,
Ucurrent, and
WWind represent the effective wave height, current velocity, and wind speed, respectively; the subscript max represents the maximum value of this indicator in the Bohai Sea region during the research period.
Figure 1 shows the spatial distribution of sea state severity in the Bohai Sea. It can be observed that areas with relatively severe sea states are concentrated near Liaodong Bay and the Bohai Strait.
2.1.2. Shipping Route Density
Ship collisions are also an important cause of offshore oil spill accidents. This study assumes that the ship collision risk is related to the density of shipping routes. The Bohai Sea is divided into 0.1′ × 0.1′ grid areas. The number of shipping routes passing through the grid in 2024 is counted using Marine Traffic
®, and then the shipping line density (
Droute) distribution in the Bohai Sea region is obtained. The calculation method is as follows:
Subsequently, the shipping route density in the research area is normalized to obtain a standardized shipping route density index, which can more intuitively reflect the relative shipping route density (
Rroute) of different grid areas within the entire Bohai Sea.
The calculated
Rroute is shown in
Figure 2. The route density is relatively high in the Bohai Bay, Laizhou Bay, and Bohai Strait.
2.1.3. Oil Platforms
Offshore oil platforms are potential sources of oil spill risks. Considering that the number of platforms is limited and their impact on risks has a spatial distribution characteristic (
Figure 3), a unified influence radius of 10 km is assigned to each platform, representing the range within which it has a significant impact on the surrounding area. The setting of this influence radius is based on multiple considerations. On the one hand, from the perspective of the impact range of historical oil spill events, under certain sea conditions and environmental conditions, after an oil spill occurs on a platform, the diffusion of oil on the sea surface is more significant within a range of 10 km. On the other hand, combined with the actual situation of the Bohai Sea, a range of 10 km can better cover the potentially affected area around the platform without overly expanding the influence range and reducing the accuracy of the risk assessment. For each grid cell, the distance to the nearest platform is calculated, and the platform influence (
Iplatform) in the grid cell is defined using the distance-weighted method, as follows:
where
i and
j represent the row and column coordinates of the grid cell,
Nplatform is the total number of offshore oil platforms in the research area, d is the distance from the grid cell to the
k-th platform, and
λ is a scale parameter used to adjust the attenuation rate of the distance on the platform influence. In this study,
λ is taken as 2.
2.2. Oil Pollution Risk
Uniformly distributed oil spill sources are set in the Bohai Sea. The pollution impact of each oil spill source is associated with the occurrence risk of oil spills in that area, and finally, the results of all oil spill pollutions are superimposed to obtain the overall pollution risk distribution in the Bohai Sea, which is calculated through the oil spill model, as follows.
According to the study of Cao et al. (2021) [
4], the oil spill model uses the Lagrange particle tracking method to simulate the convective-diffusion process of oil spills. Specifically, the motion of oil particles in three-dimensional space satisfies the following relationship:
where
S = (
x,
y,
z) is the displacement vector of the oil particle;
x,
y, and
z are the three-dimensional coordinates of the particle;
Uc is the current velocity;
Ud is the diffusion velocity, representing the turbulent diffusion effect;
wb is the buoyancy velocity of the oil droplet, representing the wind stress effect, where α = 0.03 is the wind stress drag coefficient;
W is the wind speed at a height of 10 m above the sea surface;
D is a transformation matrix used to calculate the wind deflection angle. For the specific model introduction, please refer to Cao et al. (2021) [
10]. This particle tracking framework has been validated across multiple scenarios in previous studies. For example, Li et al. (2018) and Cao et al. (2021) showed an agreement between model outputs and field observations from the Penglai 19-3 oil spill, particularly in simulating pollution extents and coastline impacts [
10,
11]. Cao et al. (2023) further validated the model using observation data from drones and a ship radar related to the
A Symphony oil spill incident, confirming its capability to predict oil transport under complex hydrodynamic conditions. Cao et al. (2022) and Li et al. (2022) also verified the model’s parameterization of wave-induced mixing and oil weathering processes based on laboratory experiment data [
12,
13]. These independent validations across different spatial scales, environmental conditions, and spill magnitudes, establish the model’s reliability in simulating oil spill transport.
Simulations are carried out in four seasons, respectively (i.e., spring: March–May; summer: June–August; autumn: September-November; winter: December–February). The time span is 20 years, from 2001 to 2020, and the simulation duration is from the beginning to the end of each season, that is, 3 months.
The oil pollution risk (OPR) is calculated as the ratio of the cumulative number of times a grid cell is polluted to the number of runs (Equation (7)):
where
N is the time span of 20 years;
M is the number of oil spill sources;
Wm is the influence weight of the
m-th oil spill source, which is determined by the occurrence risk index of oil spills; F
m is a logical matrix used to determine whether the grid points in the area are polluted by the
m-th oil spill source (i.e., polluted grids are marked as 1). The coastline of the Bohai Sea is discretized into several segments through grids with a resolution of 0.01° × 0.01°. The length of the polluted coastline
LP is calculated by adding up the lengths of all polluted coastline segments, as follows:
where
K is the total number of polluted coastline segments and
Lk is the length of the
k-th polluted coastline segment.
2.3. Experiments Procedure
The hydrodynamic background field input of the model is generated by the Regional Ocean Modeling System (ROMS) with the Simulating Waves Nearshore (SWAN) wind-wave generation and propagation model with a spatial resolution of 2 km, a temporal resolution of 1 h, and 20 vertical layers [
14,
15]. The hydrodynamic field is validated based on in situ observations in previous studies [
4,
10], and shows a good consistency with the observational data, indicating that the hydrodynamic background field is reliable. The wind field was derived from the NCEP Climate Forecast System Version 2, with a spatial resolution of 0.5° and temporal resolution of 6 h.
In this study, the crude oil mainly produced in the Bohai Oilfield is selected as the object of the oil spill simulation, and the results of its property analysis are shown in
Table 1.
In this study, 113 potential oil spill locations are evenly distributed in the Bohai Sea at intervals of 0.25° (orange dots in
Figure 4). The uniform distribution of potential oil spill points ensures that each area has an equal probability of encountering oil spill pollution. Randomly selecting oil spill locations may lead to uneven distribution of these locations, resulting in a possible denser distribution in higher-risk areas. Then, in the four seasons (i.e., spring: March–May; summer: June–August; autumn: September–November; winter: December–February), with a time span of 21 years from 2001 to 2021, the simulation duration is from the beginning to the end of each season, that is, 3 months. This study assumes that the oil spill occurs on the sea surface and does not consider human intervention.
The simulation duration is set to 3 months, which allows the oil spill to have sufficient time to spread and fully takes into account the characteristics of seasonal ocean currents and wind fields. Moreover, when the oil spill has spread for 3 months, emergency responders also have enough time to respond to oil spills threatening the coastline. For oil spills far from the coastline, on the one hand, human intervention may not bring meaningful social and economic benefits and may even exacerbate ecological damage [
16]. On the other hand, the oil spill can also be consumed through the natural weathering process after 3 months [
17].
4. Conclusions
This study constructs an oil spill risk assessment model that comprehensively considers factors such as the oil platform location and shipping route density, and systematically assesses the occurrence risk and pollution risk of oil spills in the Bohai Sea. The research results clarify the distribution characteristics of oil spill risks in different areas of the Bohai Sea, providing an important scientific basis for oil spill prevention and emergency management.
In terms of the occurrence risk of oil spills, the central part of the Bohai Sea, the southern tip of the Liaodong Peninsula, and the Bohai Strait area show a relatively high occurrence risk of oil spills due to busy maritime traffic and harsh sea conditions. In contrast, in some areas in the northern, western, and southern parts of the Bohai Sea, due to weak maritime activity intensity and weak internal circulation, the occurrence risk of oil spills is relatively low. However, limited by the existing data, this study did not conduct an in-depth exploration of the seasonal variation in the occurrence risk of oil spills. Future research should introduce seasonal shipping route density information to obtain a more accurate assessment result.
In terms of the oil pollution risk, the risk distribution of the sea surface and coastline in the Bohai Sea shows significant seasonal characteristics. In spring, the waters around the Liaodong Peninsula are high-risk areas for oil spills, but the risk of the coastline being polluted is relatively low. In summer, the west coast of the Liaodong Peninsula is a high-risk area in the ocean, and some oil spills flow into the Yellow Sea, with the coastline risk concentrated around the Liaodong Peninsula. In autumn, as the wind direction changes, the Northern Shandong Coastal Current strengthens, and the high-risk areas of the coastline are concentrated in Laizhou Bay. In winter, the high-risk areas of sea-surface oil spills are concentrated on the east side of the Bohai Strait, and the pollution risk of the coastline of Bohai Bay is at its highest. These seasonal changes are mainly affected by multiple dynamic factors such as circulation, monsoon, and seawater exchange.
Based on the distribution of oil pollution risk, several policy recommendations are proposed. Seasonally targeted measures include implementing stricter navigation regulations for tankers in the high-risk area of the Bohai Strait and Laizhou Bay. Optimizing the deployment of oil spill response equipment by pre-positioning relevant tools in high-risk areas and establishing regional emergency response teams is also crucial. Systematically, strengthening cross-regional cooperation among marine management agencies and integrating risk distribution results into existing marine environmental protection policies are both necessary.
Future research should focus on data refinement by introducing monthly or seasonal shipping route data. Additionally, sensitivity analysis should be expanded to evaluate the impact of changes in dynamic factors on oil spill risk assessment results.