1. Introduction
Deep-sea mining systems are capable of efficiently collecting abundant mineral resources from the seabed and transporting them to surface mining vessels. This not only helps alleviate the growing global demand for critical mineral resources, but also provides high-quality and abundant metallic and non-metallic mineral resources for human use [
1]. The currently explored seabed resources include cobalt-rich ferromanganese crusts, as well as a variety of potentially exploitable polymetallic nodules and polymetallic sulfides [
2,
3]. Many countries have conducted relevant theoretical studies and offshore experiments on mineral extraction.
At present, most deep-sea mining systems adopt hydraulic pipeline lifting systems, in which the surface mining vessel is connected to the seafloor mining vehicle via a vertical riser and a lifting pump [
4]. After the mining vehicle collects and crushes seabed materials, the resulting sand and slurry are transported to the surface vessel through flexible hoses, intermediate buffer chambers, and the riser pipe, driven by the lifting pump [
5,
6,
7]. Among these components, the lifting system serves as the key conduit connecting the seafloor mining equipment to the surface vessel, and its structural integrity and dynamic response characteristics are directly related to the continuity of mining operations, the overall stability of the system, and deep-sea ecosystem security [
8,
9]. In particular, under complex and variable uncertain ocean environments, significant fluid–structure interaction occurs between the mining vessel and the riser system [
10]. The vessel undergoes multi-degree-of-freedom motions induced by ocean environmental loads such as waves, currents, and winds. These motions are transmitted to the riser through hangers and connectors, leading to time-varying dynamic structural responses including bending moments, axial tension, and fatigue accumulation.
Numerous studies have been conducted on the dynamic characteristics of the mining riser under the coupling effect between the mining vessel and the riser system. Song et al. [
11] developed an indirect time-domain coupled dynamic model for the mining vessel and riser system. Through simulation and experimental validation, they evaluated the effects of regular waves, intermediate buffer mass, and vessel speed on the vessel–riser coupling dynamics. They demonstrated that the coupling effect significantly influences the dynamic behavior of both the vessel and the riser. Chen et al. [
12] investigated the dynamic response and spatial position variations of the riser system under different cooperative velocities and directions of the mining vessel and vehicle. Their experimental results further confirmed that the dynamic characteristics of the riser system are strongly affected by the coupled motion of the surface vessel and the seabed mining vehicle. Wu et al. [
13], using a lumped mass approach, calculated the hydrodynamic forces induced by waves and the impact of vessel motion in irregular wave conditions on the dynamics of the riser system. Their results also identified wave-induced vessel motion as a critical driver of riser system response. Zhu et al. [
14] developed a coupled model incorporating the mining vessel, riser system, and lifting pump, which also accounted for dynamic positioning and active heave compensation of the vessel. Using a neural network–based approach, they predicted the dynamic responses of pump motion and riser tension, demonstrating that wave frequency motions exert a significant influence on the dynamic behavior of the seabed mining system. Similarly, Li et al. [
15] investigated the axial force variations and parametric vibrations of the deep-sea mining riser under the heave motions of the mining vessel. In addition, several studies have employed numerical simulations to investigate the coupled dynamics between floating structures and auxiliary equipment such as marine risers under wave action [
16,
17,
18,
19]. These existing studies have, to some extent, revealed the coupling mechanisms between vessels and risers under wave loading and their significant impact on system dynamics, emphasizing the need to ensure that the riser operates within safe limits in practical engineering applications.
Sun et al. [
20] demonstrated that under the influence of internal solitary waves, an installed deep-sea mining system can experience large-scale displacements, significantly increasing the risk of collision with other subsea equipment. This finding highlights the necessity of emphasizing the failure risks of the deep-sea riser system to ensure the safe implementation of mining operations. With regard to the performance and structural safety of rigid mining risers, existing studies have primarily focused on investigating their dynamic responses under complex ocean environmental conditions. Hu et al. [
21] established a numerical simulation model to conduct both static and dynamic analyses of the flexible hose. Based on key monitoring points identified in the analysis, they developed a neural network model to predict the dynamic response of the pipe, enabling early performance monitoring under complex ocean conditions. In a more comprehensive parameter sensitivity study, Cao et al. [
22] proposed a three-dimensional numerical model of the entire mining system based on the intrinsic finite element (VFIFE) method. They analyzed the influence of vessel motion, internal and external pipe flows, and buffer mass on the riser dynamics. Xiao et al. [
23] conducted numerical simulations to investigate the strength and hydrodynamic responses of flexible risers in a deep-sea mining system under coupled operations. They proposed a coordinated motion control strategy between two moored subsea devices, providing a safe and effective solution for mining control systems. Regarding the longitudinal vibration of mining risers, Liu et al. [
24] analyzed the vibration characteristics of a 5000 m riser under various wind conditions, offset angles, damping ratios, and ore hold weights. Moreover, given the considerable length of mining risers, which can extend several kilometers, current-induced vibrations of different modal responses are likely to occur, while vortex-induced vibrations (VIVs) can lead to fatigue damage. To ensure the safe operation of deep-sea mining systems, several studies have focused on the vibration characteristics of risers under transverse current loading [
25,
26,
27,
28] and the fatigue effects of vortex-induced vibrations on mining risers [
29,
30]. Lin et al. [
31] also investigated the VIVs of marine risers under non-uniform current loading. Using a CFD–FEM bidirectional fluid–structure interaction approach, they identified that the riser’s most vulnerable region lies in the upper one-third of its length. When the excitation frequency of VIV approaches the natural frequency of the marine riser, resonance may occur. Building on this issue, Wang et al. [
32] analyzed the natural frequencies of deep-sea mining risers under different tension conditions and the presence of buffer stations. To further mitigate VIVs, Deng et al. [
33] proposed a control strategy that combines the Iwan–Blevins wake oscillator model with Morison-based hydrodynamic analysis. Specifically, they demonstrated that adjusting the internal fluid density and buffer mass can effectively modify vibration amplitudes. The safety of riser vibrations must consider not only the influence of external currents but also the internal flow of mineral slurry. Dai et al. [
34] and Duan et al. [
35] developed multibody dynamic models that simultaneously account for internal and external flows, providing insights for pipeline design and performance evaluation. In addition to the normal mining operation phase, Wang et al. [
36] analyzed the deployment process of deep-sea mining risers under the influence of internal solitary waves, focusing on the riser configuration, tension, stress, upper-end rotation, offset, and transient responses. Their study identified the critical stages and key risk factors during deployment. In related offshore engineering applications such as oil and gas exploitation, Gu et al. [
37] considered wake interference effects, and based on the VFIFE method developed a dual-riser model to predict the probability of riser collision. Similarly, Mao et al. [
38] incorporated the coupled effects of external ocean currents and internal multiphase flows to establish a VIV response model for production risers, thereby improving the operational safety of riser systems in offshore oil and gas production.
Risk assessments require both qualitative understanding and quantitative estimations of failure probability. Some studies have applied methods such as the analytic hierarchy process (AHP), fault tree analysis (FTA), and Bayesian fault analysis for reliability assessments and identification of key risk factors in other offshore pipeline structures [
39,
40,
41,
42]. In the context of deep-sea mining, Ma et al. [
43] applied an AHP to conduct a comprehensive risk assessment of mineral extraction activities, covering political, economic, engineering, and environmental aspects. However, their work did not focus on the structural risks of mining equipment. Lu et al. [
44] developed a traversability evaluation model based on AHP and fuzzy comprehensive evaluations to assess the operational performance of mining vehicles and enhance the identification of hazardous seabed areas. Nevertheless, these approaches lack probabilistic modeling and analyses of stochastic environmental disturbances on deep-sea mining pipeline systems. Moreover, the AHP is inherently subjective, relying heavily on expert judgment and weight assignments, which can introduce bias into the results.
To provide a comprehensive summary and critical analysis of existing studies,
Table 1 presents a selection of representative papers along with their main research focus and limitations.
Based on the results summarized in
Table 1, it can be seen that significant progress has been achieved in the areas of dynamic modeling and response analyses of deep-sea mining risers, ship–riser coupled dynamics, and safety assessments and control of dynamic responses. However, several gaps remain. First, the systematic consideration of uncertainties in complex ocean environments is still insufficient. Many studies fail to fully capture the stochastic influences of waves, currents, winds, and their interactions on the dynamic response of rigid risers. Second, despite the fact that riser dynamics are subject to multi-factor interactions, probabilistic risk modeling and quantitative assessments remain underdeveloped, and a comprehensive probability-based framework for failure risk evaluation has not yet been established. Third, the lack of large-sample, multi-parameter sensitivity analyses make it difficult to identify the key risk factors governing riser safety. Moreover, studies on fully coupled ship–riser–current interactions are still limited. In addition, traditional risk assessment approaches used in related marine engineering equipment, such as the AHP and fault tree analyses, rely heavily on expert judgment and subjectively assigned weights, which limit their objectivity and statistical rigor. Consequently, there is still a lack of integrated methodologies capable of simultaneously analyzing riser dynamics and quantifying probabilistic risks under complex ocean conditions. Such methodologies are critical to ensuring that the operational safety of deep-sea mining risers remains within acceptable limits under random environmental disturbances.
The scientific problem addressed in this study is how to develop a dynamic model that accurately captures multi-factor ship–riser coupling under complex, uncertain ocean conditions, and on that basis to quantify failure risk and assess the reliability of rigid mining risers. Compared with qualitative risk assessment methods like AHP, Monte Carlo simulations offer greater numerical modeling capability and objective statistical significance without requiring complex evaluations [
45]. This approach has been increasingly applied in engineering practices for structural risk analyses [
46,
47,
48]. Therefore, this study proposes introducing a Monte Carlo simulation into the risk assessment of the mining riser under vessel–riser coupled conditions. The objective is to establish a risk modeling approach for riser dynamic responses in uncertain ocean environments, integrating a frequency-domain hydrodynamic response analysis, vessel–riser dynamic coupling simulations, a Monte Carlo-based reliability assessment, and a sensitivity analysis. This framework aims to provide a robust technical foundation for future structural safety evaluations and layout optimization of deep-sea mining pipelines. To achieve this objective, a high-fidelity mining vessel model was first established in ANSYS AQWA 2024 R2, and a hydrodynamic analysis was performed to obtain the six-degree-of-freedom response amplitude operators (RAOs). These RAOs were then imported into OrcaFlex as boundary conditions to develop a coupled vessel–riser dynamic model of the deep-sea mining system [
49]. A large number of stochastic sea state samples were generated using Latin hypercube sampling, and a probabilistic risk model of the rigid riser dynamic response was constructed based on the Monte Carlo method to quantify failure probability and system reliability. Subsequently, a multi-parameter Sobol sensitivity analysis was conducted to identify the environmental risk factors with the greatest influence on riser safety. Finally, operational guidelines for the safe performance of rigid risers in complex environments were proposed, providing a theoretical foundation for structural design optimization, real-time monitoring, and risk-informed decision making. Beyond theoretical contributions, these insights hold substantial practical significance in translating the findings into actionable engineering guidelines.
3. Risk Analysis Framework for Mining Risers Based on Monte Carlo Simulation
The overall risk analysis workflow for the deep-sea mining riser system under vessel–riser coupling conditions is illustrated in
Figure 2.
The overall analysis procedure begins with the development of a hydrodynamic model of the deep-sea mining vessel in AQWA, where the six-degree-of-freedom RAOs are obtained and subsequently imported into the OrcaFlex simulation model to construct a coupled vessel–riser system. For the Monte Carlo simulation, input models of ocean environmental parameters were first established, and a large number of stochastic samples were generated using Latin hypercube sampling (LHS). Each random sea state sample was used to drive the coupled model, yielding the dynamic responses of three key riser parameters—the effective tension, bending moment, and von Mises stress. Based on predefined failure criteria, the occurrence probability of failure events was statistically estimated to quantify risk. To further identify the relative contributions of environmental factors to riser response risk, a global sensitivity analysis was conducted. Finally, the quantitative results were used to provide practical guidance for structural design optimization, operational strategies, and emergency planning.
3.1. Hydrodynamic Modeling of the Deep-Sea Mining Vessel
Based on an existing multi-purpose vessel (MPV) hull form, a finite element model of the mining vessel was established in ANSYS. Subsequently, a frequency-domain hydrodynamic analysis was conducted using AQWA to obtain the vessel’s RAOs under regular wave excitation. The computed RAOs were then imported into OrcaFlex as motion inputs for the vessel, thereby enabling a fully coupled dynamic response analysis with the connected riser system.
In the AQWA simulations, the vessel was modeled as a rigid body, with specified mass properties, a center of gravity location, and hydrostatic parameters. The vessel’s moments of inertia were also defined. For regular-shaped ships, the radii of gyration often depend on empirical formulas and can be approximated as follows [
50]:
where
is the vessel breadth and
is the vessel length. Based on the radius of gyration, the moment of inertia can be calculated using the following relation:
where
is the moment of inertia,
m is the vessel mass, and
is the radius of gyration.
The specific parameters of the mining vessel adopted in this study are summarized in
Table 2.
To ensure the accuracy of the hydrodynamic calculations, mesh refinement was applied near the waterline, and uniform meshing was adopted for the submerged hull surfaces. The mesh size for the vessel model was set to 0.8 m. The simulated deep-sea domain was configured as a rectangular basin with a depth of 5000 m and horizontal dimensions of 1000 m × 1000 m.
In the hydrodynamic simulation of the mining vessel, the wave frequency range was set from 0.04 to 0.5 Hz (equivalent to wave periods of 2 to 25 s), covering the majority of ocean wave frequencies. The wave direction was varied from 0° to 180° in increments of 30°, resulting in seven incident directions.
3.2. Simulation Modeling and Validation of Vessel–Riser Coupling
3.2.1. Vessel–Riser Coupled Simulation Modeling
After obtaining the six-degree-of-freedom RAO values of the mining vessel under wave excitation, these RAOs were used as boundary conditions in the OrcaFlex simulation model of the deep-sea mining system. The environmental parameters used in the simulation are summarized in
Table 3.
The vertical riser and flexible hose models were constructed based on actual geometric dimensions and material properties. The detailed parameters of the rigid riser are provided in
Table 4. Since the sizes of the intermediate buffer and lifting pump are both less than 1% of the riser length, they were simplified in the model as pipe elements with equivalent mechanical properties. The mining vessel and seafloor mining vehicle were modeled using the Vessel module in OrcaFlex, while the riser and transport hose system were modeled using the Line module. For the flexible transport hose, a suspended arch-shaped configuration was achieved through the implementation of Clump modules, which represent distributed buoyancy modules.
3.2.2. Convergence and Discretization Analysis
To evaluate the stability and reliability of the proposed deep-sea mining system simulation model, a convergence analysis was performed. Specifically, the time step size of the riser model was systematically varied while keeping the environmental conditions constant. The simulations were conducted for a duration of 50 s with time steps of 0.01 s, 0.05 s, 0.1 s, 0.5 s, and 1.0 s. The convergence was assessed by examining the variations in the maximum values of three key dynamic response parameters of the riser upon completion of the dynamic calculations.
The maximum values of the effective tension, bending moment, and von Mises stress of the riser under different time step sizes are summarized in the
Table 5, with the smallest time step (0.01 s) taken as the reference solution. When the time step was set to 1.0 s, the bending moment exhibited the largest relative error of 4.2463%, while the relative errors for all other time steps remained below 1%. With the reduction in the time step, the relative errors of the three dynamic response parameters consistently decreased and converged toward stable values. These results indicate good convergence and demonstrate the numerical stability of the proposed simulation model. To ensure a balance between computational efficiency and accuracy, a time step of 0.1 s was selected for subsequent analyses.
In OrcaFlex, line-type objects such as risers are discretized by specifying the segment length. To assess the numerical accuracy of the riser model under spatial discretization, a convergence study was further performed with segment lengths of 12.5 m, 10 m, 7.5 m, 5 m, 2.5 m, and 1.25 m. The key structural response parameters examined included the effective tension, bending moment, and Von Mises stress. The results obtained with the finest discretization (1.25 m) were treated as the reference solution, against which the relative errors of other segment lengths were evaluated.
The maximum values of the effective tension, bending moment, and von Mises stress of the riser under different segment lengths are summarized in
Table 6. It can be observed that the relative errors in effective tension and von Mises stress are extremely small (<0.001%), indicating that these responses are largely insensitive to riser segmentation. In contrast, the bending moment gradually converges to a stable value as the segment length decreases, confirming the numerical consistency of the model under spatial discretization. The relative error at a segment length of 12.5 m reaches 27.0344%, whereas it decreases to 1.6715% at 2.5 m, which lies within an acceptable engineering range. This observation indicates that the bending moment, as a local response parameter, is more sensitive to segment length and requires sufficiently fine discretization to obtain reliable results. Considering both simulation efficiency and discretization accuracy, a segment length of 2.5 m was adopted for the riser model in this study.
The convergence analyses with respect to both the time step size and spatial discretization demonstrate that the proposed deep-sea mining system simulation model is numerically stable and reliable. The key dynamic and structural responses of the riser, including the effective tension, bending moment, and Von Mises stress, converge consistently toward stable values as the time step decreases and the segment length is refined. While the effective tension and Von Mises stress are largely insensitive to discretization, the bending moment, as a more localized response, shows higher sensitivity and requires sufficiently fine temporal and spatial resolutions. Based on these results, a time step of 0.1 s and a segment length of 2.5 m were selected, providing a good balance between computational efficiency and accuracy. Overall, these findings validate the numerical correctness of the simulation model and support its use for subsequent analyses.
3.3. Uncertainty Modeling and Sample Generation
To estimate the structural failure probability and reliability indices—and to further quantify the sensitivity of system responses to various uncertain ocean environmental parameters—it is essential to establish probabilistic distribution models for these uncertainties and generate large-scale samples before the Monte Carlo simulation.
In constructing the Monte Carlo simulation framework, uncertainty modeling of ocean environmental parameters is based on engineering experience and statistical data, with appropriate probability distributions selected accordingly. The wave height, being non-negative and exhibiting long-tail characteristics—with a non-negligible probability of extreme values—is modeled using the Weibull distribution. The wave direction is assumed to follow a uniform distribution, reflecting the equal likelihood of wave incidence from all directions. For simplification, both current and wind directions are assumed to be aligned with the wave direction, which is consistent with the directional correlation often observed in wind–wave–current conditions in offshore environments. The current speed is modeled using a triangular distribution, which effectively captures the bounded nature of current speeds and their central tendency, aligning with measured current statistics in deep-sea regions. The wind speed is modeled by a log-normal distribution to reflect its right-skewed and heavy-tailed nature, in agreement with empirical wind data from marine observations.
Empirical studies and engineering experience suggest that the wave height and wave period are statistically correlated in deep-sea mining zones; in general, higher waves are associated with longer periods. This correlation originates from wave energy propagation mechanics and generation processes. To ensure that sampled scenarios remain physically realistic, this statistical dependency must be preserved in the sampling process. While a deterministic or linear relationship can be assumed in some cases, such strong coupling may obscure the results of the sensitivity analysis. Therefore, in this study, a nonlinear conditional mean function is employed to determine the wave period corresponding to each sampled wave height. A power-law function is selected to represent the nonlinear trend between the wave height and period, with small random perturbations introduced to account for variability. The detailed parameters for each probability distribution are listed in
Table 7, while the extreme sea states referenced in this study are based on wave and current statistics from the South China Sea, as provided by the Offshore Oil Research Center (
Table 8).
Latin hypercube sampling (LHS), a widely used stratified sampling technique in Monte Carlo-based uncertainty quantification and reliability analyses [
51], is employed to generate 10,000 samples encompassing the wave height, wave period, wave direction, current speed, and wind speed. The marginal distributions of the sampled parameters are shown in
Figure 3a–e, with the nonlinear relationship between the wave height and wave period illustrated in
Figure 3f.
3.4. Failure Criteria Definition
The calculation of response limit values is performed following the API RP 2RD standard [
52], which adopts a two-thirds yield strength criterion in combination with a design condition factor
. This regulatory framework is particularly suitable for evaluating the safety of deep-sea risers subjected to tension-bending coupled loading, which governs their structural performance.
The allowable von Mises stress is defined by:
In this study, the riser is constructed using P110-grade steel, with material yield strength values ranging from 758 MPa to 965 MPa. According to API RP 2RD, the design factor is set to 1.0 under normal operational conditions.
The maximum allowable effective tension of the riser is determined based on the von Mises yield criterion and calculated as:
where
is the effective cross-sectional area of the riser, defined for an annular section as:
The maximum allowable bending moment is evaluated based on the yield strength and the section modulus
of the riser, as follows:
For a circular cross-section, the section modulus is given by:
The computed maximum allowable values for effective tension, bending moment, and von Mises stress are summarized in
Table 9.
3.5. Sensitivity Analysis
To identify the dominant environmental factors influencing the riser response, this study employs the Spearman rank correlation coefficient as a surrogate for the first-order Sobol sensitivity index. This approach captures the nonlinear monotonic relationship between each uncertain sea state parameter and the riser’s structural response, while computing the corresponding p-values to assess the statistical significance of the correlations. In addition, a second-order response surface regression model is constructed to establish a multi-input–single-output sensitivity analysis framework.
Generally, if p < 0.05, the correlation is considered statistically significant; if p < 0.001, the correlation is regarded as highly significant and statistically robust. Conversely, when p ≥ 0.05, it indicates that the sample data do not provide sufficient evidence to confirm a statistically meaningful relationship between the input variable and structural response, suggesting the observed correlation may result from random variability.
Additionally, special consideration is given to the wave direction, which is a cyclical variable ranging from 0° to 360°. Directly using its numeric values in Sobol-type sensitivity analyses would lead to inaccurate results, as angles such as 0° and 360°, or 90° and 270°, are physically equivalent in terms of directional excitation on the riser but numerically distant. To address this, the wave direction is vectorized using a trigonometric transformation, where it is represented by two continuous variables:
The variables and represent the horizontal and vertical projections of the wave direction on the unit circle, respectively, with value ranges normalized to [−1, 1]. This transformation effectively eliminates the periodic discontinuity of directional angles, allowing the sensitivity analysis to more accurately quantify the influence of the wave direction on the structural responses of the riser system.