1. Introduction
In the 5G and beyond era, ultra-reliable low-latency communication (URLLC) is increasingly critical for supporting use cases associated with factory automation, transportation, and electrical power distribution [
1,
2]. The International Telecommunication Union (ITU-T) has specified that the maximum end-to-end user-plane latency for 5G URLLC services is 1 ms [
3]. For delivering future 6G services, even more challenging latency targets of <1 ms are envisaged, which has already been accepted by both academia and industry [
4]. As a direct result, exploring cost-effective solutions capable of satisfying such an extremely low latency requirement imposes unprecedented pressure on the telecommunications R&D community worldwide.
On the other hand, from the practical network implementation point of view, intensity modulation and direct detection (IMDD) passive optical networks (PONs) offer a cost-effective solution to construct the next generation of x-haul mobile access networks [
5], where standard single-mode fibers (SSMFs) are utilized to connect an optical line terminal (OLT) (interconnected to the central unit or distributed unit) and optical network units (ONUs) (interconnected to the distributed unit or remote unit). For a typical 20 km PON, a one-way fiber propagation delay is ~0.1 ms (~5 μs/km [
6]), which is nonnegligible in comparison with other latency-generating factors such as forward error correction (FEC) time delay (<0.5 μs [
7]).
In addition, numerous URLLC applications including autonomous vehicles, industrial automation, and telemedicine not only have stringent low latency requirements, but also impose a strong need for dynamically establishing communication connections between different users within a single mobile access network [
7,
8]. However, the communications between different end-users in a single PON-based mobile access network require passing the source ONU data to the OLT and then to the destination ONUs, which leads to a round-trip fiber propagation delay of ~0.2 ms (for 20 km PONs). Therefore, to effectively meet the ultra-low latency requirements of these applications, direct inter-ONU communications (also termed ONU-to-ONU communications in this paper), without passing data to the OLT and compromising upstream transmission performances, are highly desirable [
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14].
For practically achieving such direct inter-ONU communications in a PON, it is necessary to equip the remote node with the capability of redirecting and broadcasting each ONU signal to all other ONUs. For achieving this functionality, several techniques have been reported, where corresponding PON remote nodes are modified using cyclic arrayed waveguide gratings [
10,
11], fiber Bragg gratings [
12], optical switches [
13,
14], passive optical couplers [
9,
15,
16], cascaded optical interleavers [
17], and their combinations [
18]. The techniques based on dynamic optical switches [
13,
14,
19] cause their remote nodes to be active, thus leading to relatively high power consumption. A ring network topology would also deliver the desirable direct inter-ONU communications [
20,
21], which, however, may require modifying the existing network architecture. In comparison, the optical coupler-based remote nodes are simple, cost-effective, and transparent to wavelengths [
9,
15,
16,
22]. However, for PONs with a large number of ONUs, the optical coupler-based remote nodes introduce extremely high power losses for inter-ONU communications. For example, for a PON using a 64-by-3 optical coupler for supporting the inter-ONU communications between 64 ONUs, the inter-ONU signal power losses can be as large as ~43 dB. Existing optical coupler-based techniques use extra optical amplifiers to compensate for such power loss [
23], which, however, result in active remote nodes, and are thus not desirable for PON application scenarios. Considering the fact that future PONs are expected to support more ONUs, it is thus vital to explore advanced passive remote nodes with low inter-ONU signal power losses.
Apart from the aforementioned requirements to remote node modifications, IMDD point-to-multipoint (P2MP) flexible optical transceivers [
15,
16,
24], which allow multiple low-speed transmitters to concurrently communicate with multiple high-speed receivers, are also envisaged to be used for delivering the desirable concurrent direct inter-ONU and upstream communications by dynamically and flexibly aggregating/de-aggregating multiple inter-ONU and upstream channels. The utilization of such transceivers is beneficial for reducing the overall network transceiver count [
16] and further improving network scalability and upgradability [
24]. For previously reported IMDD P2MP optical transceivers, multiple channels are aggregated/de-aggregated in digital signal processing (DSP) by using digital orthogonal filtering (DOF) [
15,
16], cascaded inverse fast Fourier transform (IFFT)/fast Fourier transform (FFT) operations [
24], and a single-IFFT/FFT operation (i.e., different channels use different subcarrier groups) [
25]. In comparison, DOF-based channel aggregation/de-aggregation possesses a relatively large transceiver DSP complexity for aggregating/de-aggregating a large number of channels. On the other hand, a single-IFFT/FFT operation-based alternative requires extra DSP processes or frequency guard bands (i.e., null subcarriers) for reducing interferences between signals from different ONUs. The previously reported cascaded IFFT/FFT operations for channel aggregation/de-aggregation are preferable, where DOF is also employed for reducing interferences, as the operation possesses several advantages in terms of low transceiver DSP complexity, high spectral efficiency, and additional physical layer network security (because multiple channels are aggregated in two dimensions, i.e., the time domain and the frequency domain) [
24].
To effectively deliver the desirable inter-ONU communications in future PON-based mobile access networks with a large number of ONUs, in this paper, a novel concurrent direct inter-ONU and upstream communication network is proposed and experimentally demonstrated. An advanced passive remote node architecture is proposed, which, depending on the employed optical components, can be implemented using two approaches. In comparison with an X-by-3 optical coupler-based conventional remote node [
15,
16], these two remote node implementation approaches can reduce the inter-ONU signal power losses by >12.2 dB and >16.6 dB, respectively. In addition, the cascaded IFFT/FFT-based IMDD P2MP flexible transceivers are also used in all of the ONUs and the OLT.
The proposed network is experimentally evaluated in a 27 km, >62.47 Gbit/s upstream IMDD PON. The experimental results show that the network has three salient features, including (1) concurrently providing ultra-dense, fast, and dynamic ONU-to-ONU and upstream (ONU-to-OLT) connections each adaptively tailored according to specific requirements of an inter-ONU/upstream communications; (2) excellent tolerance to various transmission system impairments including chromatic dispersion, the Rayleigh and Brillouin backscattering effects, and the channel interference effects; and (3) supporting dynamic channel allocations without considerably compromising the channel performances.
3. Experimental Demonstrations of Concurrent Direct Inter-ONU and Upstream Communications in IMDD PONs
In this section, a representative 27 km, 62.47 Gbit/s upstream IMDD PON capable of supporting the direct inter-ONU communications is constructed using the cascaded IFFT/FFT-based P2MP flexible transceivers [
24] and off-the-shelf optical components. Spectral attention is given to the explorations of the upstream and direct inter-ONU transmission performances, the channel interference effects between different ONUs, and dynamical channel allocations.
3.1. Experimental Setups and Parameters
The experimental setups of the 62.47 Gbit/s@27 km IMDD PON offering simultaneous upstream and direct inter-ONU communications are illustrated in
Figure 4, where two ONUs are considered. A dual-channel arbitrary waveform generator (AWG, Keysight M8195A) operating at 32GSample/s is used to represent these two ONUs. Each ONU produces an optical signal conveying 4 independent channels, of which, 2 high (low) bitrate channels are used for the upstream (inter-ONU) connections.
In each ONU’s transmitter DSP, the cascaded IFFT-based multi-channel aggregation process presented in
Figure 2a is implemented to aggregate 4 independent channels. The IFFT sizes of the required three IFFT operations are 16/32/64. As such, the numbers of data-bearing subcarriers of the aggregated 4 channels are 8/8/16/32. Adaptive bit loading is implemented to maximize the spectral efficiency by adaptively varying each subcarrier modulation format from DBPSK to 64-QAM [
24]. Following the cascaded IFFT operations, a CP containing 4 samples is inserted at the beginning of each symbol. After S/P conversion, a 4× digital up-sampling operation and a digital orthogonal filtering operation are performed successively [
24]. A Hilbert-pair approach [
28] is utilized to produce the required two orthogonal digital filter pairs, and the baseband prototype filter has a square-root-raised cosine profile. To effectively reduce imperfect digital filter-induced signal distortions, a digital filter length of 32 and an excess bandwidth factor of 0, which are optimized in [
16], are employed in this paper. Subsequently, a signal clipping operation with a clipping ratio of 14 dB and a digital domain time delay operation are implemented successively. The digital domain time delay operation is to adjust the ONU timing for synchronizing the involved two ONUs [
24]. To enable the ONUs to achieve the best transmission performances, the AWG- and oscilloscope-embedded pre-compensation functions are used to flatten the PON transmission system frequency responses [
24].
The AWG outputs two analogue signals, each having a spectral bandwidth of 8 GHz and an amplitude of 900 mV. Their spectra can be found in
Figure 4a,b. Each analogue signal contains 4 independent channels, and their bitrates are given in
Table 2. The total bitrates of ONU1 and ONU2 are about 31.29 Gbit/s and 31.17 Gbit/s, respectively, thus resulting in an aggregated bitrate of 62.47 Gbit/s. Following the AWG, two optical intensity modulators (Thorlabs MX35D) are used to perform intensity modulation. Each optical modulator has a 15 kHz linewidth laser source and a 35 GHz Mach–Zehnder modulator (MZM). The wavelengths of the two ONUs are 1565.495 nm and 1564.678 nm, respectively, which give rise to a wavelength spacing of ~0.8 nm for effectively mitigating the optical beating interference effect [
16]. Such a wavelength spacing is large enough to allow the involved two ONUs to use free-running lasers. For ONU2 occupying the high-frequency spectral region, a tunable optical filter (TOF, Yenista XTM-50 filters) is used to produce an optical single sideband signal (OSSB) for mitigating the channel fading effect [
29]. The optical filter bandwidth and its passband central frequency are adjusted to ensure that the channel interference effects between different ONUs are negligible. Two Erbium-doped fiber amplifiers (EDFAs) each followed by a 0.8 nm bandwidth TOF fix the ONU output optical powers at ~6 dBm.
At the remote node, for the proof-of-concept demonstrations, a 50:50 passive optical coupler and an optical circulator are used for realizing the simultaneous upstream and direct inter-ONU communications. The optical power launched into the 25 km feeder fiber is ~6 dBm. For the upstream communications, in the OLT, the received optical signals’ spectra are plotted in
Figure 4e. After direct detection, the corresponding electrical signal spectra containing eight channels are presented in
Figure 4d. In addition, for the direct inter-ONU communications, the ONU-received optical and electrical signals’ spectra are also illustrated in
Figure 4f and
Figure 4c, respectively.
The optical detection and signal demodulation processes of the upstream signals and the direct inter-ONU communication signals are similar. A 40 GHz bandwidth PIN photodetector is used to convert the two optical signals to an electrical signal consisting of eight independent channels. Following the PIN, a 40 GHz@64GSample/s digital sampling oscilloscope (Keysight UXR0402A) digitizes the received electrical signal. The signal demodulation processes are conducted offline, which include S/P conversion, CP removal, 256-point FFT operation, conventional single-tap subcarrier equalization, multi-channel de-aggregation, and BPSK/QAM decoding. For the multi-channel de-aggregation process, two cascaded FFT operations with the sizes of 32 and 16 are, respectively, implemented for each ONU.
For the considered PON architectures, both the direct inter-ONU and upstream communications suffer from the Rayleigh and Brillouin backscattering effects. Because the fibers between each ONU and the optical coupler are only ~2.2 km as seen in
Figure 4, the upstream communication-experienced backscattering effects arising from the broadcasted direct inter-ONU signals are negligible in comparison with the backscattering effects suffered by the direct inter-ONU communications [
16]. This is further verified by
Figure 4g,i, where the Stokes and anti-Stokes components of the upstream communication-suffered Brillouin backscattering effects are not obvious in comparison with the backscattered components suffered by the direct inter-ONU communications. For the inter-ONU communications, the Brillouin backscattering effects lead to a power peak at a radio frequency of ~10.8 GHz in the directly detected direct inter-ONU communication signals, as seen in
Figure 4h. The results presented in
Section 3.4 show that for the case considered here, both the Rayleigh and Brillouin backscattering effects can only cause negligible channel capacity reductions when upstream channels are reallocated to inter-ONU communications.
3.2. Upstream and Direct Inter-ONU Communication Performances
The measured bit error rate (BER) performances of the considered eight channels are presented in
Figure 5. To explore the fiber transmission-induced performance degradation at a 20% overhead soft-decision FEC threshold at a BER of 2 × 10
−2 [
16], the corresponding back-to-back (B2B) transmission performances of the considered eight channels are also measured and presented in
Figure 5. It can be found from the figure that: (1) for all the channels, the receiver sensitivities are ~−5 dBm for achieving their BERs at the considered FEC limit, and (2) for the upstream (direct inter-ONU) communications, the fiber transmission-induced power penalties are <1.5 dB (<0.7 dB) for all the involved channels.
Due to ONU2′s (ONU1′s) utilization of OSSB modulation (low-frequency spectral locations), ONU2 (ONU1) suffers the negligible channel fading effects, as verified by
Figure 4d, where no obvious power fading dips can be found for both ONUs. The fiber nonlinearity effects are also negligible for both the upstream and direct inter-ONU communications due to the adopted low optical launch powers and relatively short transmission distances. Therefore, for the considered PONs, the major factors causing the transmission system impairments include chromatic dispersion, the Rayleigh and Brillouin backscattering effects, the channel interference effect between different ONUs, practical hardware impairments, and the interplay between the abovementioned elements. The channel interference effects between different ONUs mainly arise from the signal-to-signal beating interference (SSBI) noise by directly detecting ONU2′s OSSB signals and imperfect digital filter-induced power leakages, which are explicitly explored and discussed in
Section 3.3. As discussed in
Section 3.1, the upstream (direct inter-ONU) communications suffer from the negligible (relatively strong) backscattering effects. As such, for the direct inter-ONU communications, the power penalties of <0.7 dB in
Figure 5a are mainly caused by the Rayleigh and Brillouin backscattering effects and chromatic dispersion. For the upstream communications, the observed <1.5 dB power penalties in
Figure 5b are mainly due to chromatic dispersion. Such small power penalties imply that the proposed technique has excellent tolerance to chromatic dispersion and the Rayleigh and Brillouin backscattering effects.
3.3. Channel Interference Effect
For the proposed technique, due to the digital filtering operation in the transmitters, spectral guard bands are not used between adjacent ONUs to improve the spectral utilization efficiency, as seen in
Figure 4d. In addition, in the considered PONs, to effectively mitigate the channel fading effects, low-frequency ONU1 and high-frequency ONU2 employ optical double sideband (ODSB) and OSSB signals, respectively. As such, it is easy to understand that channel interferences between different ONUs occur mainly due to SSBI arising from directly detecting ONU2′s OSSB signals and the imperfect digital filter-induced power leakages.
To investigate the channel interference effects between different ONUs and further evaluate the resultant transmission performance degradations, based on the experimental parameters used in obtaining
Figure 5, the power penalties caused by the channel interference effects between the considered two ONUs are measured and illustrated in
Figure 6, which presents the receiver sensitivity variations of each channel of an ONU with the other ONU’s 4 channels being switched on and off [
16]. For ONU2, the channel interference effects can only lead to negligible power penalties of <0.6 dB for both the upstream and direct inter-ONU communications. This indicates that for the considered digital filter length of 32, the imperfect digital filter-induced channel interference effects are negligible, which agrees with the results obtained in [
24]. However, in comparison with ONU2, ONU1 suffers extra power penalties of <1.8 dB (2.35 dB–0.57 dB = 1.8 dB). This is mainly caused by the ONU2-produced SSBI effects, which locate at the baseband spectral regions after direct detection, and are spectrally overlapped with ONU1′ signals [
29].
For practical implementation, to further mitigate the SSBI-induced channel interference effects, conventional SSBI estimation and cancellation techniques [
30,
31] may be employed in the receiver DSPs to jointly cancel the SSBI effect. On the other hand, other channel fading mitigation techniques/solutions may also be applied to replace the adopted optical filter-based OSSB signal generation techniques, including IMDD system linearization techniques [
32], modified OSSB techniques with reduced SSBI [
33], dispersion compensating fibers/devices [
34], chirp-managed lasers [
35], and O-band optical transmissions [
36].
In addition, as seen in
Figure 6, it can also be found that for each ONU, CH3 suffers a relatively large power penalty in comparison with all other channels of the same ONU. Such a relatively high power penalty suffered by CH3 is a result of the interplay between the channel interference effects and the transceiver-embedded cascaded IFFT/FFT operations [
24].
3.4. Dynamic Channel Allocation
For the proposed current upstream and direct inter-ONU communications, for each ONU, dynamic channel allocation can be made adaptively according to actual user communication requirements. To comprehensively evaluate the dynamic channel allocation-induced impacts on the channel performance, three cases are considered: for Case I (Case III), for each ONU, all the involved four channels are allocated for the upstream (direct inter-ONU) communications. For Case II, for each ONU, CH1/CH2 (CH3/CH4), is used for the direct inter-ONU (upstream) communications.
For each considered case, the maximum achievable aggregated overall signal transmission capacity is measured and presented in
Figure 7a. Adaptive bit-loading is used for each channel to achieve the maximum aggregated bitrates [
24]. The received optical power is fixed at −2 dBm for all the considered cases. It can be found that for the considered three cases, their aggregated overall signal transmission capacity differences are <2.2 Gbit/s, thus indicating that dynamic channel allocation has negligible impacts on aggregated overall signal transmission capacity.
It is also interesting to find from the figure that the highest aggregated overall signal transmission capacity is achievable when all the channels are allocated for upstream communications. When more channels are allocated for direct inter-ONU communications, the aggregated overall signal transmission capacity is slightly reduced. To understand the physical mechanisms behind the observed overall signal transmission capacity variations, for each case, the corresponding channel capacities of each ONU are presented in
Figure 7b,c. It can be found that for each ONU, in comparison with Case I’s CH3/CH4 (Case III’s CH1/CH2), Case II’s CH3/CH4 (CH1/CH2) can deliver similar transmission capacities. This implies that dynamic channel allocations can only slightly influence the performances of the channels that the channel reallocation operations are activated, and have negligible negative impacts on all other channels. As discussed in
Section 3.1, in comparison with the upstream communications, the direct inter-ONU communications suffer from relatively lower chromatic dispersion, while the Rayleigh and Brillouin backscattering effects are, however, more pronounced. Therefore, it is easy to understand that when an upstream channel is reallocated to direct inter-ONU communications, its channel transmission capacity is slightly reduced mainly due to the backscattering effects.
The advantages associated with the proposed PONs in terms of overall network throughput, latency, flexibility, scalability, adaptability, and network resource utilization efficiency are more pronounced in comparison with existing PONs with long transmission distances and/or high optical powers. Technically speaking, our previous research [
16] indicates that (1) increasing the fiber length (either the distribution fiber length or the feeder fiber length) can enhance the chromatic dispersion effect and the Rayleigh and Brillouin backscattering effects, thus resulting in relatively large signal distortions and lower signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs). Additionally, (2) when the fiber lengths are >25 km and the ONU optical launch powers are <6 dBm, an ONU launch power increase can just lead to a slight increase in the Rayleigh and Brillouin backscattering effects. When the ONU optical launch powers are >6 dBm, a further ONU launch power increase can result in a nonnegligible power increase in the backscattered Brillouin stoke components. In practically implementing the proposed network, the optimum ONU launch powers and the maximum achievable transmission performance/capacity should be adaptive to the actual network status.
For the proposed network, the power budget can be considerably enhanced by: (1) all the techniques capable of significantly improving IMDD PON transmission performances, as mentioned in
Section 3.3; (2) high-sensitivity avalanche photodiodes (APDs) adopted in the receiver [
37]; (3) relatively high ONU launch powers [
37]; and (4) optical preamplifiers prior to optical–electrical conversion in the receiver [
37].
4. Conclusions
This paper proposed a cost-effective concurrent direct inter-ONU and upstream communication IMDD PON with an advanced passive remote node. In comparison with existing PONs, the advanced PON considerably improves the overall network throughput, flexibility, scalability, and adaptability, thus giving rise to a significantly enhanced network resource utilization efficiency. In addition, it also significantly reduces the latency and power loss for inter-ONU communications. Furthermore, as each ONU and OLT utilize a single pair of the cascaded IFFT/FFT-based P2MP flexible optical transceivers, multiple ONU-to-ONU and ONU-to-OLT connections can be established simultaneously and dynamically, each of which is tailored to meet the requirements of a specific direct inter-ONU or upstream communication service.
The proposed network has been experimentally explored in a 27 km IMDD upstream PON with two ONUs, where the low-frequency and high-frequency ONUs, respectively, utilize a conventional intensity modulation-produced ODSB signal and an optical filter-produced OSSB signal. The experimental results have shown that for both upstream and direct inter-ONU communications, the impacts of the transmission system impairments including chromatic dispersion, the Rayleigh and Brillouin backscattering effects, and the channel interference effects are negligible. Moreover, for each ONU, dynamic channel allocation can be made according to actual end-user communication requirements without considerably compromising its transmission capacity.