1. Introduction
Cadmium is a chemical element denoted by the symbol (Cd) that is classified as a non-essential heavy metal, is commonly found in zinc ores, and is naturally extracted as a byproduct of zinc mining [
1]. Cd and its compounds are highly toxic and can be harmful to human health and the environment [
2]. Cd has been shown to have negative effects not just on human health but also on the surrounding natural ecosystem. Human activities are the primary cause of Cd pollution. These activities include metallurgical operations, mining, electroplating, paints, combustion emissions, and excessive use of fertilizers and pesticides [
1]. Equally, the use of synthetic phosphate fertilizers that include Cd as a contaminant is a prevalent reason for the rise in Cd content in groundwater and soil [
1]. The culmination of years of progress made in agriculture as well as industry has seen an increase in the amount of Cd found in agricultural soils [
3]. As a result of its high solubility and relative mobility in comparison to that of other metals in soil, it is rapidly absorbed by plants [
4]. After being taken in, Cd then moves to other areas of the plant and begins to accumulate there, presenting significant risks to human health and the plant itself [
5]. It is non-essential since it inhibits plant growth and development, causes chlorophyll loss, and affects photosynthetic activities [
2]. Additionally, because of its high mobility in the soil, its bioaccumulation and subsequent accumulation in the food chain surpass all other elements [
6].
Cadmium’s toxicity has a number of negative effects on plant life, including a reduction in chlorophyll content and activity, an inhibition of carbon fixation, and an overall slowing of photosynthesis. Plants that have been exposed to cadmium in the soil develop osmotic stress, which reduces the amount of relative water content, stomatal conductance, and transpiration in the leaves. This ultimately leads to plant physiology being impaired [
7]. The harmful effects of cadmium originate in the excessive formation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), which in turn causes damage to plant membranes as well as the destruction of cell macromolecules and organelles [
8]. As a consequence, Cd can inhibit growth and reduce crop yields [
9]. It can also cause chlorosis, necrosis, and other visible symptoms on the leaves and stems of plants [
10]. Generally, leafy vegetables have a relatively high potential for Cd uptake, translocation, and accumulation. As a result, Cd absorption and accumulation in food plants, as well as its potential impacts on human health, have received a lot of attention in recent decades. Vegetable consumption is predicted to provide 70–90% of total Cd intake by humans [
11]. Therefore, it is necessary to control the uptake, translocation, and accumulation of Cd in plants, particularly in their edible parts, to ensure food safety and security. Furthermore, to limit its exposure to humans and minimize the effects of Cd toxicity on plants and crops, it is important to control the levels of Cd in soil and water with appropriate crop management practices.
There are several management strategies that have been practiced to alleviate heavy metals in soil. Physical strategies such as soil replacement, capping, and thermal desorption are considered effective in alleviating heavy metals. Nonetheless, these techniques involve the use of expensive technology, require the exploitation of other areas that are not impacted by pollution, and only cover a limited spatial area [
12]. Phytoremediation has been practiced with promising biological methods, and it is an economically viable and effective in situ technology for mitigating pollutants from soil. However, this approach has limitations on application in elevated contaminated areas, and the plants used would likely be affected by heavy metal toxicity [
13]. Chemical leaching is another common chemical approach to heavy metal removal in soil. However, the level of soil washing expense is directly proportional to how thoroughly polluted areas are cleaned up. Additionally, the mineral dissolution that occurs during intense acid washing causes a decline in soil productivity and other undesirable changes to the soil’s chemical and physical composition, affecting plant production [
14]. Since the removal of pollutants from soil has become an issue with the limitations mentioned, other strategies and approaches must be established to reduce the toxicity effects of Cd on plants and preserve the security of crops and food supplies.
Therefore, the current study is making use of microalgae and macroalgae extracts to demonstrate their effectiveness in reducing the translocation of Cd in plant parts, thus reducing the toxicity effects on plants and increasing crop production. As far as we are concerned, there is no research on the potential of
Sargassum polycystum and
Spirulina platensis extracts in mitigating Cd toxicity, enhancing plant growth performance, or enhancing the gene expression of Pak Choi. In fact, information on
Sargassum polycystum and
Spirulina platensis extracts as bioremediation reagents is scarce in the literature. Macroalgae and microalgae are the two broad categories into which algae are most divided. Macroalgae are grouped into three main families according to their color: Phaeophyceae (brown), Chlorophyta (green), and Rhodophyta (red). It is estimated that there are more than 1500 different species of brown algae globally. With a reported total of more than 400 known species around the globe,
Sargassum is one of the brown algae species that is most prevalent and widespread [
15].
Sargassum sp. has garnered much attention because it contains more phytohormones, macronutrients, and micronutrients than species in other phyla [
16]. Consequently, it has been continually applied as biofertilizers and growth stimulants in agricultural and horticultural settings. A liquid extract of
Sargassum wightii was found to enhance the root and shoot lengths of Vigna radiata [
17]. According to Prasedya et al. [
18],
Sargassum crassifolium extracts, both solid and liquid, boosted rice plant development and production.
Sargassum horneri extract showed potential for enhancing abiotic stress, antioxidant activity, and the growth of
Neopyropia yezoensis [
19]. Meanwhile, microalgae are believed to be an excellent alternative due to their beneficial properties as bioremediators. It has strong binding affinity, high tolerance, grows easily, provides a large surface area, is eco-friendly and cost effective [
20]. Microalgae of various species have shown remarkable resistance to Cd toxicity tests, metal absorption, alterations in cell shape, and impairments in internal photosynthetic activities [
21]. Soil fertilization and foliar spray of
S. platensis improved the sugar content, anthocyanin content, and flower numbers of
Begonia semperflorens [
22]. Foliar spray of
S. platensis extract had a significant and marked effect on the plant morphologies and mineral content of Dutch fennel [
23].
S. platensis was also tested as a good candidate for the removal of heavy metals from aquatic environments [
24], as it is able to chelate some heavy metals from wastewater up to 95% [
25]. Hence, algal extracts can eventually play a significant role in crop improvement while mitigating the negative effects of abiotic and biotic stresses, particularly Cd stress. Therefore, this study used
Sargassum polycystum and
Spirulina platensis extracts to mitigate Cd in Pak Choi seedlings.
S. polycystum, which belongs to the Sargassaceae family, has been recognized as a common species in Malaysia’s coastal areas.
S. polycystum biomass was discovered to be a reliable biosorbent of industrial metals Cd and Zn with a removal efficiency of 86.20% and 92.90%, respectively [
26].
In light of this, the purpose of this research was to evaluate the specific extracts from Sargassum polycystum and Spirulina platensis that have the potential to successfully mitigate the unfavorable effects of Cd stress on Pak Choi plants. It was postulated that the administration of these algae extracts would result in improved morpho-biochemical parameters, such as enhanced plant growth, lowered oxidative stress, and higher photosynthetic efficiency, in comparison to Cd-stressed plants that do not include the algal extracts. In addition, it is anticipated that the algal extracts would produce anatomical changes in the Pak Choi plants, such as increased stomatal density and changed leaf structure, which would then lead to improved Cd tolerance. It is predicted that the algal extracts could induce changes at the molecular level, and regulate the expression of genes linked with photosynthetic activities that are greatly impacted by Cd toxicity, therefore boosting the plant’s capacity to endure Cd stress. By carrying out this research, it is hoped that the findings could provide valuable insights into the potential of Sargassum polycystum and Spirulina platensis extracts as effective Cd stress alleviators and unravel the underlying mechanisms involved in Cd toxicity and tolerance in Pak Choi plants.
4. Discussion
As a result of heavy metal exposure, plants experienced profound changes in their development, photosynthetic pigments, and antioxidant defenses [
42]. This study demonstrates that Cd significantly affected the growth and development of Pak Choi. Exposure to 100 mg/kg of Cd showed an apparent reduction in plant height, fresh weight, and dry weight of Pak Choi. In previous studies, potato (
Solanum tuberosum L.) seedlings cultivated in pots experienced a reduction in shoot and root length as well as dry weight when subjected to Cd stress at 60 mg/kg compared to the control group [
43]. Despite this, the study identified that the negative effects of Cd stress on Pak Choi’s development could be mitigated with the application of algal extracts (
S. polycyctum,
S. platensis, and a combination of the two).
Sargassum sp. extracts from water-based extraction methods have been reported to have good biostimulant activity on the early growth of
Zea mays L. by improving the shoot and root growth [
16]. A considerable increase in rice plant growth and yields has also been observed after the application of
Sargassum extracts [
44].
Sargassum angustifolium extract has been reported to enhance the plant height, specific leaf area, root length and volume, and root and shoot dry weight of salt stress-treated milkweed seedlings at 1% concentration [
45].
The growth and development of plants are highly manipulated by their physiological functions, specifically photosynthesis activities. The process of photosynthesis is an essential physiological function that plants must consistently carry out. Cd stress, on the other hand, can persistently prevent plants from engaging in this obligatory action [
46] by altering physiological traits [
47]. These physiological functions are greatly affected since the processes through which Cd is absorbed by plant roots typically include competition for absorption sites with other nutritional minerals with comparable chemical properties. Cd in mineral form would substitute for other essential minerals with identical charge, ionic radius, and chemical behavior [
48]. As a result, Cd may inhibit the uptake of Mg, Fe, K, and P from soil, thus constraining the creation of leaf porphyrin rings and leading to a drastic decrease in chlorophyll synthesis and changes in chloroplast structure [
45].
In the present study, photosynthesis attributes were investigated to observe the effects of Cd stress. It was found that Cd substantially reduced chlorophyll
a,
b, carotenoid, quantum yield (Fv/Fm), and gas exchange parameters (net photosynthetic rate, stomatal conductance, internal CO
2, and transpiration rate) in Pak Choi. Fenugreek plants grown in the same concentration of Cd contaminated soil have shown similar results [
49]. Farooq et al. [
50] observed that stomatal conductance and the transpiration rate of
Gossypium hirsutum decreased by 74% and 70%, respectively, after Cd treatment in a hydroponic system. Reduced net photosynthetic rate and stomatal conductance may result from Cd-induced increases in ROS that damage chloroplast ultrastructure and the thylakoid membrane [
47]. Nonetheless, the study revealed that adding 100 mL/L of algal extracts (100SPI, 100SAR, and 100SS) to Cd-treated Pak Choi increased its chlorophyll
a,
b, carotenoid content, quantum yield, as well as gas exchange parameters. Extracts from algae have improved photosynthetic pigments by raising both stomatal conductance and photosynthetic capacity [
45]. The presence of bioactive compounds in algal extracts such as amino acids, betaines, and minerals is capable of inhibiting chlorophyll deterioration and stimulating the photosynthetic capacity of plants [
51]. Phytohormones such as auxins, abscisic acid, cytokinins, ethylene, and gibberellins were found in
Arthrospira, Chlamydomonas, Chlorella, Phormidium, Protococcus, and
Scenedesmus extracts that react as chemical messengers that help in stimulating plant growth and regulating the cellular activities in crops as well as responses to stress conditions [
52,
53,
54]. These phytohormones, which boost plant nutrient absorption, are viable in reducing the nutritional imbalance brought on by Cd toxicity and fostering healthier plant development and growth. A study reported that seed priming of maize plants using
S. platensis enhanced quantum yield (Fv/Fm) of Cd-treated plants, and an 0.83 ratio has been addressed as the optimum value for the healthy functioning of Photosystem II (PSII) [
55].
S. platensis extracts also significantly increased the carotenoids and chlorophyll content of both Cd-treated
Phaseolus vulgaris and salt-stressed
Triticum aestivum L. [
56,
57]. The addition of
S. polycystum and
S. platensis extracts also positively increased the gas exchange characteristics. Both water and alcohol extracts of
S. polycystum were found to induce seed germination and growth of pigeon peas (
Cajanus cajan L.) [
58]. Better growth in plants is due to high chloroplast and stomata numbers that receive more sunlight, which play a vital role in gas exchange during the photosynthesis process [
59].
Plants exposed to Cd stress exhibited drastic alterations in the activity of antioxidant enzymes [
11,
60]. Multiple studies have shown that excessive Cd exposure is associated with a rise in reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation and accumulation in cells, which include H
2O
2, O
2−, and OH
− [
47]. It can actually be observed as ROS interfere with the regular function of particular biomolecules such as proteins, nucleic acids, and membrane lipids [
61]. However, some evidence suggests that heavy metal exposure boosts antioxidant activity in plants as a defensive mechanism against oxidative stress [
62], including the enzymatic activities of catalase (CAT), ascorbate peroxidase (APX), superoxide dismutase (SOD), and peroxidase (POD) [
47]. This study found that the activity of antioxidant enzymes has been highly generated and boosted under 100 mg/kg of Cd. Consistent with earlier research. Mung beans [
63] and strawberries [
64] showed increased activities of GPX and CAT and a decrease in APX under Cd stress. According to Rahman et al. [
65], the activities of APX, SOD, and glutathione peroxidase (GPX) all increased in Cd-treated rice seedlings over control, while those of DHAR (dehydroascorbate reductase), GST (glutathione S-transferase), and CAT had been reduced. The current study has identified that algal extracts significantly increased the antioxidant enzyme activity of Cd-treated Pak Choi, with the highest concentration, 100 mL/L, dominating the activity level. In response to Cd stress, the PGR increased the activities of antioxidant enzymes, which in turn reduced oxidative stress in the plants [
11]. Previous research has demonstrated that brown algae,
Fucus spiralis, and
Cystoseira ericoides extracts had a considerable ameliorating impact on the development and physiological and biochemical parameters of tomato plants subjected to metal stress [
66]. An elevated level of SOD, CAT, and POD activity could be seen in
Hordeum vulgare L. plants that had been treated with
Sargassum spp. while being subjected to Cd stress [
67].
S. platensis has increased the CAT (18.10%) and APX (18.30%) of common beans treated with Cd [
56].
Overproduction of oxidative indicators, including ROS, free radicals, and lipid peroxidation, from Cd-contaminated soils generates oxidative stress in plants, which in turn reduces agricultural yields [
68]. Oxidative damage caused by a rise in ROS is a frequent response of plants to biotic or abiotic stress. It often manifests itself in a high accumulation of MDA and proline. Measurements of MDA and proline were performed to see the efficacy of algal extracts in counteracting the oxidative stress brought on by Cd in Pak Choi. The study discovered that MDA and proline content increased in Cd-treated Pak Choi compared to the control. Though both MDA and proline were distinctly dropped in Cd-treated Pak Choi with algal extract application. Extracts of algae have been shown to contain bioactive chemicals, particularly phenolic compounds, which have antioxidant characteristics. Phenolic compounds, including polyphenols, phenolic acids, flavonoids, and phenylpropanoids extracted from
Botryococcus braunii,
Chaetoceros calcitrans,
Chlorella vulgaris,
Isochrysis galbana,
Isochrysis sp.,
Neochloris oleoabundans,
Odontella sinensis,
Phaeodactylum tricornutum,
Saccharina japonica,
Skeletonema costatum, and
Tetraselmis suecica, have been reported to protect the plants from pathogens or other biotic and abiotic stress conditions, including scavenging reactive oxygen species (ROS) generated by Cd stress, preventing oxidative damage to plant cells [
52,
53,
69,
70,
71,
72]. While free fatty acids (saturated and unsaturated) from
Anabaena,
Chlorella,
Dunaliella,
Nannochloropsis,
Porphyridium,
Scenedesmus, and
Spirulina showed antioxidant, antibiotic, anticarcinogenic, antifungal, antioxidant, and antiviral activity, reducing the stress in plants [
52,
54,
73,
74,
75,
76].
For ionic and osmotic homeostasis, plants generate proline or other suitable solutes to regulate water balance and protein complex stability [
77]. A study by [
65] reported a 55.56% increase in proline in rice seedlings after 0.3 mM of Cd exposure. A maximum increase of MDA and H
2O
2 was reported at 20 mg/kg Cd stress on mung bean seedlings [
78]. The present study revealed that the utilization of algal extracts positively reduced both MDA and proline content under different concentrations of algal extracts, with 100 mL/L of
S. platensis and 50 mL/L of
S. platensis +
S. polycystum giving the maximum decrement, respectively. Brown algae, especially
S. polycystum, were reported to have a high fucoidan level that acts as an antioxidant that might increase ROS scavenging activity [
62], thus reducing excessive oxidative damage that causes high levels of MDA and proline.
S. platensis and
Chlorella vulgaris were revealed to reduce free proline content and MDA levels in the leaves of
Phaseolus vulgaris [
41].
According to the findings, Cd absorption and translocation occurred more often in the root system than in the shoot system. Similar findings were also observed in mustard (
Brassica juncea L.), which was exposed to toxic levels of Cd at 200 mg L
−1 and 300 mg L
−1 [
79], and other metals in
Panax notoginseng, Chlorophytum comosum,
Calendula offcinalis [
80], and
Solanum lycopersicum [
66]. Cd ions are trapped in roots by selectively binding to molecules or cell sites with high metal affinity. This mechanism involves phytochelatins (PCs), which are the major Cd chelators and generate Cd complexes that are sequestered in vacuoles and hence remain inside the root cells [
81]. These complexes lose their toxicity when they are trapped in the cell wall, cytoplasm, or vacuoles, respectively. Furthermore, Cd accumulation in root vacuoles mitigates its toxicity and prevents it from being transported great distances to the shoot. Nevertheless, the translocated Cd in shoots would be sequestered and detoxified in cell walls or the vacuole [
82]. The present study determined the potential of
S. platensis and
S. polycystum extracts in reducing Cd content in the root and shoot of Pak Choi, where Cd ions can be bound or chelated by substances found in algae extracts such as polysaccharides, peptides, and organic acids. This chelation mechanism aids in the sequestration of Cd and decreases its bioavailability, both of which lessen the toxicity of Cd to plants. In line with previous findings, a reduction of Cd from 74% to 91% was observed in common bean plants that had been treated through foliar spraying of
S. platensis extract [
56].
S. platensis was utilized for Cd and Ni adsorption and Cu ion absorption from aqueous solutions [
49]. Four biomass types with different biochemical compositions of
Arthrospira (
Spirulina) platensis were utilized for the removal of heavy metals [
83]. The utilization of
Sargassum stolonifolium in reducing Cd content in
Brassica chinensis has been reported in previous studies. This is likely because of the presence of functional groups such as thiol, carboxyl, hydroxyl, amine, carbonyl, and other common compounds that are responsible for Cd binding [
84].
Our findings revealed that the translocation factor and tolerance index increased with increasing algal extracts. Contrarily, root retention has been greatly reduced with the application of algal extracts. A metal’s ability to move from underneath to the surface is referred to as translocation. Translocation factors (TF) (ratio of metal concentration in roots to those in the shoots) are greater in plants that can take up and distribute the metal throughout their entire system, while TF values are lower in plants that can restrict the movement of metals from the soil to the roots and from the roots to the shoots [
85]. Our findings are consistent with what has been discovered previously concerning Cd deposition and tolerance in other crops [
86,
87].
Root structure of Cd-treated Pak Choi was greatly stunted by the results of WinRHIZO software, as illustrated in
Figure 6 and
Table 6. Both root elongation and root architecture are influenced by Cd presence in the rhizosphere. Root apoplasm contains higher Cd levels than symplasm, and Cd levels decline from the outer to the interior root tissues [
88]. Since the root system is apparently unable to distinguish the cations of the required micronutrients for the plant, it is inevitable that it might absorb free Cd ions into the root system. However, this deleterious change was greatly reduced by the application of
S. polycyctum and
S. platensis extracts to Cd-treated Pak Choi. It is proven by the demonstrated results (
Table 6), where root length, root surface area, root projected area, average root diameter, root volume, root tip, and root fork numbers were positively enhanced after algal extract treatments. Algal extracts may contain micro and macro elements, vitamins, and other essential plant growth regulators (PGR) such as auxin, cytokinin, and gibberellin that help the growth of plants overcome the Cd toxicity effects [
89]. In addition, microalgae and macroalgae were reported to effectively bioremediate heavy metals from wastewater and soil, thus reducing heavy metal uptake by roots [
90].
An amount of 100 mL/L of algal extract mixture (100SS) shows better cell structure and histology. This is based on image analysis using a scanning electron microscope to observe the changes in the cellular structure of the Cd-treated Pak Choi’s leaf when treated with algal extracts. The result shows that treatment with algal extracts has improved stomatal size and opening. More gas and vapor exchange, which is crucial for photosynthesis, may take place through stomata that are bigger and have broader apertures [
91], thus, enhancing the photosynthesis activity, growth, and development of the plant. The leaf thickness and vascular bundle (xylem and phloem) were enhanced with 100 mL/L of algal extract exposure. Algal extracts have increased the activity of antioxidant enzymes that are involved in the production of H
2O
2, which is responsible for the prevention of oxidative damage to the cells [
92]. It was reported in previous studies that the small open vessel element has thicker tissue walls when compared with unstressed plants [
92].
Rubisco (ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase) is a carboxylating enzyme that is essential for photosynthesis as it catalyzes the transformation of atmospheric CO
2 into organic molecules, basically carbohydrates, that are needed by plants [
91]. This study found that exposure to Cd reduced
Rubisco gene expression in Cd-treated Pak Choi leaves. Consistent with our findings of reduced chlorophyll levels, quantum yield, and net photosynthetic rate, plant development and growth were stunted. Leaf photosynthetic rate is strongly influenced by the concentration of Rubisco, which triggers changes in plant activity [
92].
S. polycystum and
S. platensis extracts, however, reduced the oxidative damage to photosynthetic attributes by increasing the activity of Rubisco gene expression. When compared to 100Cd, which only had a fold change of 0.50, it was discovered that 100SS caused the biggest fold rise, which reached up to 0.99-fold. In conclusion, algal extracts have a great potential for reducing Cd oxidative stress and damage to the cellular structure of Cd-treated Pak Choi, thus increasing the number of fold changes in Rubisco gene expression.