Two research methods, i.e., dynamic light scattering (DLS) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM), were used to investigate the size, shape, as well as the size distribution of silver nanoparticles. The analysis of silver nanoparticles using the DLS method included the determination of the size of nanoparticles and their aggregates, their numerical and volume share, and the intensity of scattered light. In the DLS method, the measurement of the size of the nanoparticles is only possible in the solution. Nanoparticles moving freely in the solution may have a tendency to agglomerate, which means that only signals from the agglomerates of nanoparticles on which strong light scattering takes place are recorded. As can be seen from previous experiments, the presence of even a relatively small amount of agglomerates can interfere with the scattering of light on nanoparticles of small diameter [
20]. For TEM studies, the observation of nanoparticles occurs in the fibre, which means that the actual image of the “frozen” nanoparticles in the polymer matrix is observed. Therefore, the TEM results can be fruitfully compared with the results obtained with the DLS method [
20]. The characterisation of silver nanoparticles using the TEM technique is based on completely different principles from the DLS method, which allows the independent comparison of their results [
19]. An additional advantage of the TEM method is the possibility of direct observation of objects, as well as the estimation of the shape and distribution of silver nanoparticles in the polymer matrix of the fibre.
3.2.2. Estimation of the Size and Shape of Silver Nanoparticles in Cellulose Fibres Using the TEM Method
The TEM method allows to characterise more precisely the generated silver nanoparticles, closed in the polymer matrix of cellulose fibres. The created images allowed to observe the size distribution and shape of the nanoparticles and their agglomerates obtained in fibres, and their distribution in the polymer matrix of fibres (images in the “bright field”). The TEM images analysis allowed to determine the histograms of the size distribution of nanoparticles (these histograms were developed on the basis of the count of nanoparticles in over a dozen photos). For the histograms, the average size of the particles, the minimum and maximum diameters (Dmin, Dmax), as well as the average aspect of elliptical particles (W) and eccentricity of ellipse (e) were calculated.
Selected, typical TEM images and histograms of the size distribution of silver nanoparticles obtained at 20 °C for different times of synthesis and introduced into cellulose fibres are shown in the figures below.
In the case of the analysis of the diameters of nanoparticles synthesised at 20 °C, the only reliable method to observe the nanoparticles closed in the fibre matrix was using the TEM technique. This is due to the fact that nanoparticles were generated in various conditions, mainly in direct contact with cellulose pulp and in the elevating temperature, as shown by UV-Vis (
Figure 2). The TEM results should not be compared with the results obtained for the small amount of nanoparticles in NMMO solution, which were shown by DLS method. Based on the obtained results, it can be concluded that the synthesis of silver nanoparticles in NMMO at 20 °C at different times allows the generation of nanoparticles with diameters of 2–40 nm, as shown in
Table 1. When those nanoparticles were introduced to the fibres, theirs size increased significantly which is typical and characteristic of nanoparticles generated in direct contact with cellulose [
19]. In the case of AgNPs generated at relatively low temperatures (20 °C), the TEM results show a mixture of nanoparticles obtained under different conditions.
The TEM images analysis of silver nanoparticles synthesised at 20 °C for different times and then introduced into the fibre matrix shows that with the increase of particle synthesis time, their shape changes from elliptical to spherical. A spherical shape is observed for particles generated in the longest time of synthesis of 168 h. The 48 and 72 h synthesis of nanoparticles allows to obtain the majority of small nanoparticles with diameters from about 2 to 5 nm (
Figure 3(a1,b1,c1)). The majority of large particles and their aggregates in the analysed fibre matrix are observed in fibre F-Ag/20/12. This causes large distances between the obtained nanoparticles, as well as their low density in the fibre matrix. The TEM images and histograms made for F-Ag/20/12, F-Ag/20/24 and F-Ag/20/48 have been shown in previous work [
20,
21]. The TEM images show that in the F-Ag/20/168 fibre modified with nanoparticles synthesised in the longest time (168 h), the size of the nanoparticles ranged between 4 and 34 nm and were relatively evenly distributed in the polymer matrix of the fibre. In addition, the aggregates of particles are not observed in the F-Ag/20/168 matrix (
Figure 3). In the analysed fibres, apart from monocrystalline particles, polycrystalline nanoparticles (a1–2) can also be noticed.
Typical TEM images and size distributions of silver nanoparticles synthesised in NMMO at 50 °C for different times and introduced into the fibres are shown in
Figure 4.
Based on TEM images of modified fibres, it can be concluded that AgNP synthesis at 50 °C allows the formation of small monocrystalline particles (diameters from 2 to 6 nm), as well as very small particle aggregates which correlates with the diameters of nanoparticles, which were observed in the NMMO dispersion by the DLS method (
Table 2). It was noticed that with the extension of AgNP synthesis time (from 12 to 48 h), the proportion of small particles with diameters of 4–6 nm (from about 2% to about 50%) increased which is also confirmed by the DLS results of diameter of silver nanoparticles in NMMO dispersion. Large aggregates of nanoparticles (from about 100 to 400 nm) are observed in the fibre matrix. The histograms show that in fibres F-Ag/50/72 and F-Ag/50/168 smaller amounts of tiny particles in the range of 4–6 nm (about 30%) are observed than in fibres F-Ag/50/24 and F-Ag/50/48. Only very small aggregates of particles with a size of just a few nanometres can be observed in the TEM images.
Selected TEM images and size distributions of silver nanoparticles synthesised in NMMO at 70 °C for different times and introduced into the fibres are shown in
Figure 5.
The synthesis of silver nanoparticles at 70 °C allows for such modification of cellulose fibres, whereby the particles are statistically distributed in the fibres matrix, in the range of 2–42 nm. The highest numerical share of particles (
Figure 5(a1–c1)), with the majority of particles which have a radius diameter ranging from 2 to 5 nm (about 90%), is clearly visible in TEM images of fibre F-Ag/70/12. A small proportion of nanoparticle aggregates and agglomerates can be noted in this fibre. In the fibres modified with AgNPs synthesised in longer times, i.e., from 24 to 168 h, smaller amounts of particles are observed. In fibre F-Ag/70/168 modified with nanoparticles synthesised at 70 °C for the longest time (168 h), the smallest amount of particles can be observed (
Figure 5(c3)). This is related to the presence of a majority of particles with relatively large diameters in the fibre matrix (mainly between 6 and 13 nm), as well as their aggregates (between 20 and 100 nm) in comparison to the size of nanoparticles in other fibres. In the obtained fibres modified with nanoparticles synthesised at 70 °C, polycrystalline particles (a3) can also be observed.
It can be clearly observed that both the temperature increase to 70 °C and the long synthesis time of silver nanoparticles in NMMO adversely affect the process of studying nanoparticle size using the DLS method. Comparing the obtained results of nanoparticle diameters in NMMO with the diameters of nanoparticles closed in cellulose fibres, it can be noticed that the analysis of nanoparticles using the DLS method shows mainly aggregates of silver nanoparticles that are formed in NMMO under such synthesis conditions and which can also be seen in the fibres in the TEM images (
Figure 5(b1)). However, the TEM research showed the participation of nanoparticle aggregates in a small proportion, with a predominance of nanoparticles with dimensions at the level of 2–13 nm. It was noticed that even a short time of conducting the DLS test favours the formation of agglomerates of silver nanoparticles generated in such conditions. Selected TEM images and size distributions of silver nanoparticles synthesised in NMMO at 100 °C over 20 min and introduced into the fibres are shown in
Figure 6.
In fibre F-Ag/100/0.33 modified with AgNPs synthesised at 100 °C in 20 min, mainly polycrystalline particles ranging between 3 and 22 nm with spherical shape were obtained and this is visible in the fibre matrix. A sizeable number (70%) of quite large nanoparticles, between 7 and 15 nm, with a very small amount of aggregates (about 30 nm) can be observed in the fibre matrix. In the case of the synthesis of nanoparticles at the highest temperature and the shortest time, DLS studies of the NMMO-AgNP dispersion showed the participation of only small nanoparticles with a diameter of 3 nm, the share of which is visible in the fibre matrix. Nevertheless, it can be concluded that the analysis of fibres by the TEM method is more precise and showed that there are also nanoparticles of larger dimensions in the fibre, and the largest proportions of nanoparticles have diameters of 7–15 nm. The results of measurements of the size of nanoparticles and particle agglomerates carried out by TEM methods are compared in
Table 5.
The applied synthesis conditions, temperature and time, play an important role in the process of obtaining silver nanoparticles. Increasing the temperature of synthesis causes an increase in the precursor reduction rate, which increases the nucleation rate and, as a result, yields large (up to about 10 nm) and extremely small (below 2 nm) spherical nanoparticles. Increasing the reaction temperature shortens the synthesis time significantly.
The high degree of conversion of the precursor eliminates extremely difficult to control factors during cellulose dissolution, i.e., the temperature and composition of the mixture. The mentioned factors change during the cellulose dissolution process.
An important parameter affecting the synthesis of silver nanoparticles in NMMO is time. For reaction temperature equal to 20 °C only a significant prolongation of the AgNO3 reduction time is sufficient to increase the rate of silver nitrate conversion and produce more small silver nanoparticles.
The application of higher temperatures shortens significantly the time of synthesis. It has been noted that in the synthesis of nanoparticles at higher temperatures (50 and 70 °C), prolonging the synthesis time may affect the process of generating nanoparticles. In addition to the formation of very small nanoparticles, aggregates and agglomerates of these particles may be formed (
Table 5).