3.1. Physicochemical Characterization
Elemental analyses of C, H, N, and S weight percentages were performed to obtain a better understanding of the electrocatalysts’ compositions. The results including the standard deviations from the triple measurements for each electrocatalyst are summarized in
Table 2. It can be observed that after activation treatment at 700, 750, and 800 °C, nitrogen disappeared. This was because macroalgae have a low nitrogen ratio, which can result in nitrogen loss during pyrolysis treatment as NH
3, N
2O, or even HCN, as reported by composting algae studies [
40]. After C
5H
5N doping, a low amount of nitrogen was incorporated to the material, which, according to previous studies, can be tuned by manipulating the solvothermal treatment temperature. On the other hand, seaweeds contain sodium alginate [
41] and high amounts of calcium carbonate (CaCO
3) [
39], therefore, the samples pyrolyzed at the highest temperature (800 and N800) showed the highest post-pyrolysis carbon amount (68.86 and 80.95 wt %, respectively) among all samples. Finally, the sulfur content was low for the 700 and 750 samples, lower than the detection limit for 800, and dropped to zero after doping treatment for all three sample types. It is noteworthy that these carbon and sulfur contents are in agreement with the amounts found from the EDS results discussed below.
The electrocatalysts’ N
2 adsorption–desorption isotherms are presented in
Figure 1a. They exhibit a type I shape associated with microporous solids. In particular, N750 shows type H3 hysteresis, which is typical in solids consisting of aggregates or particle agglomerates forming slit-shaped pores with a nonuniform size and/or shape [
42]. The MP plot shown in
Figure 1b confirms the electrocatalysts’ microporosity with the majority of micropores being between 0.5 and 1.0 nm. The isotherms’ textural properties are summarized in
Table 3. The synthesized electrocatalysts had high BET surface areas, which suggests a greater availability of active sites for the ORR to occur. As expected, the BET surface area increased with each heat treatment; N800 showed the highest surface area (2765 m
2 g
−1) because the acid treatment removed any alkaline or inorganic residue when cleaning its structure. To the best of our knowledge, this is the highest surface area reported for electrocatalysts from biomass wastes used for ORR performance studies.
The electrocatalysts mesoporous structures are given in
Figure 2a–f. In accordance with the surface area results, the micrographs show similar highly porous structures. It can be seen that after doping treatment, such pore structures remained, but
Figure 2e,f clearly display some agglomerates and fragments that could have been formed due to the doping treatment. EDS spectra confirmed the presence of inorganic compounds (2.29 wt % calcium, 1.29 wt % chloride, 0.96 wt % sodium, 0.86 wt % potassium and 0.66 wt % magnesium) in the raw
Sargassum spp. which were completely removed after activation and doping treatment. Moreover, the carbon content increased after chemical treatments from 53.67 wt % in raw seaweed to 83.85, 85.42, 85.89, 83.20, 87.29, and 88.12 wt % for 700, 750, 800, N700, N750, and N800, respectively. The sulfur content decreased after doping treatment, confirming the CHNS elemental analysis results. On the other hand, 0.06, 0.03, 0.04, 0.13, 0.17, 0.16 wt % chloride was found in 700, 750, 800, N700, N750, and N800, respectively.
Furthermore, the Raman spectra were studied to understand the structure and quality of the carbon materials. D- and G-band existence was confirmed for the 700, 750, 800, N700, N750, and N800 samples. As presented in
Figure 3a, the D-band (1354 cm
−1) corresponds to a defective sp
3-phase and the G-band (1588 cm
−1) to an ordered sp
2-phase [
26]. The D-band was present more often than the G-band for all electrocatalysts and structural properties, and defective sites were determined through the D-band and G-band relationship (I
D/I
G), providing information regarding the surface defects. In particular, sample 700 presented a lower index (I
D/I
G = 1.35 ± 0.03), indicating that it had fewer sp
3 carbon defects and more sp
2 carbon. Sample 750 showed a slightly superior index (I
D/I
G = 1.44 ± 0.03), suggesting that the number of defects increased as the chemical treatments were applied. Finally, sample 800 was the most disordered sample (I
D/I
G = 1.47 ± 0.03), providing evidence that the disorder degree was affected by the temperature. Likewise, N-doped electrocatalysts showed an enhancement in D-band intensity, leading to higher I
D/I
G indices of 1.40 ± 0.01, 1.45 ± 0.01, and 1.44 ± 0.02 for N700, N750, and N800, respectively. Finally, the amorphous nature of the electrocatalysts was confirmed in
Figure 3b by the amorphous carbon diffraction patterns.
XPS studies were carried out to investigate the surface composition and chemical bonding of the electrocatalysts. The atomic concentrations of carbon, oxygen, nitrogen and sulphur were obtained from the survey and are summarized in
Table 4. High-resolution spectra were obtained for C1s, N1s, and O1s and are shown in
Figure 4 and
Figure 5. The fitting was done at 284.5 eV using C1s as a reference. Carbon was the most abundant element with 90.16, 89.63, 87.32, 89.08, 90.94, and 93.06 wt % for 700, 750, 800, N700, N750, and N800, respectively. C1s peaks located at 284.5 ± 0.2 eV corresponded to C=C/C–C [
43], while peaks at 285.9 ± 0.1 and 287.2 ± 0.1 eV were assigned to amorphous carbon and sp
2 carbon atoms bonded to oxygen, respectively [
44]. The peaks located at 288.6 and 290.0 eV were assigned to C–O bonds (O–C–O/C=O and O–C=O, respectively), and the peak at 291.5 ± 0.1 was related to the π–π* shake-up satellite, which is common in high-temperature treated carbons [
44]. High-resolution spectra for N1s showed peaks which were assigned as follows: N1 from 398.1 to 399.3 eV; N2 from 399.8 to 401.2 eV, and N3 from 401.1 to 402.7 eV [
23]. Pyridine treatment eliminated the sulphur from doped samples and changed the nitrogen-bond type. Originally, all samples presented N1, but, after C
5H
5N treatment, the nitrogen shifted to N2 and N3, while the N1 type disappeared.
3.2. Electrochemical Characterization
The electrocatalytic activity of the as-prepared NPC was studied using the rotating disk electrode (RDE) technique with linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) in a three-electrode system.
Figure 6a shows the ORR polarization curves catalyzed by 700, 750, 800, N700, N750, N800, and 10% commercial Pt/C in O
2-saturated alkaline electrolyte (0.5 M KOH) at a 5 mV s
−1 scan rate and 2000 rpm. All measurements were performed at room temperature under the same conditions and catalyst load, and the background currents were subtracted. Current density values were determined at 0.0 V and the onset potential, as reported in literature [
45]; these are summarized in
Table 5. In the LSV data, it is noteworthy that the current density increased in parallel with the rotation rate, but none of the samples reached the plateau of the diffusion limiting current
The ORR polarization plots show that the pyrolysis temperature played an important role in the ORR activity. Both undoped and N-doped electrocatalysts exhibited good performance for the ORR. As expected, slower ORR kinetics were shown at the lowest temperature for the 700 sample, whose cathode reduction peak appeared at 0.827 V leading to a maximum current of 2.93 mA cm−2. In addition, the doping of sample 700 improved its performance, as revealed by the N700 current density value (4.15 mA cm−2); however, it exhibited a more negative potential (0.812 V), which could be associated with physicochemical properties, such as its low nitrogen content.
In addition, when the catalysts were synthesized at 750 °C, the current density improved as compared with samples at 700 °C. Specifically, it increased by 33% (3.89 mA cm−2), probably due to its larger surface area and nitrogen content, and increase in disorder, as studied by Raman spectroscopy, while its onset potential remained constant (0.828 V). In the same way, doping of the 750 sample improved its current density to 4.32 mA cm−2, but its N750 onset potential shifted to a more negative value (0.811 V).
Finally, at the highest temperature, more positive onset potentials were shown by the 800 and N800 samples. In particular, the N800 sample showed a well-defined curve and the best ORR activity, possibly as a result of having the highest surface area among all samples.
In brief, the electrocatalyst activity order in terms of the current density was N800 > N750 > N700 > 750 > 800 > 700, while the onset potential decreased in the following order: N800 > 800 > 750 > 700 > N700 > N750.
In general, the ORR performance of the electrocatalysts was attributed to their structures, namely, the increase in active sites, which facilitate oxygen diffusion and electron transport.
The results of the electrocatalyst cyclic voltammetry (CV) assessment in N
2-saturated alkaline electrolyte (0.5 M KOH) at a 20 mV s
−1 scan rate under room temperature conditions are presented in
Figure 6b. All samples exhibited a pseudo-rectangular shape, which is associated with good charge propagation throughout the porous carbon framework, as well as good electronic conductivity and an accessible porous structure [
46].
The K-L plots shown in
Figure 7 were obtained from RDE polarization curve data recorded at various rotation rates (200, 400, 800, 1200, 1600, 2000 rpm) applying
, where
j is the absolute measured current density (mA cm
−2),
jk is the kinetic current,
ω is the electrode rotation rate (rpm), and
B is determined from the K-L graph slopes.
Based on the K-L plot slopes and the intercepts obtained from 0.2 to 0.6 V vs. RHE (V vs. RHE),
Figure 8 shows the electron-transfer numbers (
n) calculated from the
equation, where
n is the total number of transferred electrons per O
2 molecule,
F is the Faraday constant (96,485 C mol
−1),
D0 is the O
2 diffusion coefficient (1.9 × 10
−5 cm
2 s
−1),
C0 is the O
2 global concentration (1.0 × 10
−6 mol cm
−3) [
47], and
υ is the electrolyte kinetic viscosity (0.01 cm
2 s
−1) [
10].
According to the slopes of the K-L plots, the averaged ORR electron transfer numbers were 3.4, 3.1, 3.5, 1.2, 2.2, and 3.7 for 700, 750, 800, N700, N750, and N800, respectively. There was a first-order dependence between 700, 750, 800, and N800 ORR kinetics and potentials from 0.2 to 0.5 V vs. RHE that proceeded mainly through a four-electron reduction pathway (2H2O + O2 + 4e− → 4OH−). For these electrocatalysts, as the potential increased, the number of transferred electrons decreased to around 3.5; hence, both electron pathways coexisted for these materials. In contrast, the N700 and N750 kinetics reactions followed a mechanism closer to a two-electron transfer at potentials lower than 0.55 V.
A brief comparison of the yield vs. other doped biomasses is provided in
Table 6 for more insights.
3.3. Fuel Cell Studies
Figure 9 presents the fuel cell polarization and power density curves from MEA with NPC at 30 °C and 100% relative humidity using H
2 and O
2 gases prepared as described above. A correlation parameter brief for each cathode is provided in
Table 7. The anode loadings were 0.4 mg Pt cm
−2 (34 wt % Pt, 40 wt % C, and 25% ionomer), while, at the cathode, they were 4, 1, 4, 2, 2, and 2 mg cm
−2 (75 wt % electrocatalysts and 25% ionomer) for 700, 750, 800, N700, N750, and N800, respectively. All samples outperformed the 700 sample’s onset potential, indicating higher activity because of the N-doping effect and the pyrolysis temperature increase. The doping of the 700 sample influenced its polarization curve shape, as N700 demonstrated a higher activity (peak power 9.427 m
2 g
−1 and 0.793 V) than the 700 sample. Both 750 and N750 showed similar OCVs, but different peak power densities. At 0.8 V, N750 performed slightly better than 750, but in the mass transport area, 750 had the best performance. Although 800 and N800 had the highest temperatures, and N800 had the highest BET surface area (2675.4 mA cm
−2), they exhibited a mass transfer limitation at a low potential (starting at 0.55 V), whereas samples at 700 and 750 °C did not. It is noteworthy that low loading cathodes (750 = 1.14 mg cm
−2 and N750 = 1.59 mg cm
−2) exhibited the best performance, so further electrode optimization must be performed, as both anode and cathode catalyst loading must be constant in order to get comparable results.
To summarize, the performance improved as the temperature increased from 700 to 750 °C, but further temperature increase reduced the power density. Additionally, the doping treatment favored the power density for each temperature, so that the maximum power density of the MEA prepared from NPC was 12.72 mW cm−2 from N700, which was close to that from Pt/C MEA on both the anode and cathode (14.42 mW cm−2). The performance of N750 is attributed to its graphitic nitrogen (22.4 wt %) content, high surface area (2594.3 m2 g−1), and high disorder structure, as studied by Raman spectroscopy. Compared to the Pt/C current density (42 mA cm−2), 750 and N750 were shown to be competitive, and their low production costs make them an efficient catalyst for AFC.