1. Introduction
With an increasing demand for electric energy and the expanding scale of power grid, the stability and security of power system operation are facing severe challenges, and the decreasing fossil energy, increasing environmental pollution and other issues become particularly acute. Environmental protection, efficient and flexible distributed generation technology is favored.
However, the problems of high cost, randomness and uncontrollability of distributed generation have brought adverse effects on power system operation and control. In order to solve the above problems, coordinate the power system and distributed energy, and bring higher value and benefits to the grid and users, micro-grid has been paid attention to and continuously developed in the world. According to statistics, there are 1437 microgrid projects published worldwide, with installed capacity exceeding 13 gigawatts, and more than half of them belong to remote microgrid [
1]. As an important part of smart grid, how to properly manage the renewable energy and energy storage capacity within the microgrid, how to optimize the operation of the microgrid considering the real-time electricity price in the market, and how to improve the economy of operation are the problems to be solved.
In order to achieve the economic operation of microgrid, scholars at home and abroad have done a lot of research. Reference [
2,
3,
4,
5,
6] establishes an optimization model aiming at maximizing the profit of the system. Reference [
7,
8,
9,
10,
11] synthetically considers the operation cost and emission cost of microgrid, and establishes a multi-objective optimization model to minimize the economic cost and emission of microgrid. Reference [
12] analyzed the characteristics of distributed generation and the mathematical model of optimization objectives in detail, and proposed a multi-objective immune algorithm of niche evolution for the optimal management of distributed power output in microgrid. Reference [
13] presents a mathematical model to minimize the comprehensive costs of system investment, operation and reliability. Reference [
14] establishes the reliability model of wind farm, which refers to availability of wind farm, based on Monte Carlo simulation method, and evaluates the reliability of combined generation and transmission schemes.
As part of the micro-grid, energy storage devices play a key role in improving the reliability of power supply on the user side when the grid runs in isolation [
15]. However, due to the high cost of energy storage devices, limited charging and discharging time and charge cycles, it is difficult to optimize the dynamic operation of microgrid. In Reference [
16], in view of the coordinated operation of microgrid with energy storage, a combination scheme of wind-solar power generation and power purchase is proposed according to the time-sharing price of power grid and the charging and discharging characteristics of storage batteries; in Reference [
17], a unit combination model with minimum cost is proposed, and the effects of uncertain factors such as power price, energy demand and environmental impact on the economic benefits of microgrid system are analyzed. Reference [
18] Aiming at the optimal dispatching problem of microgrid under grid-connected conditions, a new dispatching method of microgrid operation based on fixed dispatching strategy of energy storage unit and dynamic optimal dispatching of controllable micro-sources under a time-sharing tariff mechanism is proposed. Reference [
19] establishes a multi-objective model for optimal operation of microgrid with multiple distributed generators and energy storage, and proposes a multi-objective optimization method based on Improved Particle Swarm optimization.
In this paper, based on the load forecasting and the output of wind power and photovoltaic power, considering the time-sharing price of power grid, a dynamic economic dispatching model for microgrid with energy storage is established. Dynamic economic dispatching of microgrid (DEDM) is a large-scale mixed integer nonlinear programming problem. Many classic optimization techniques have been applied for solving DEDM problems. However, these techniques have severe limitations like (i) need of continuous and differential objective functions, (ii) they easily converge to local minima, and (iii) their difficulty in handling discrete variables. To overcome these limitations, the robust and flexible evolutionary optimization techniques have been applied. These evolutionary algorithms have shown success in solving the DEDM problems since they do not need the objective and constraints as differentiable and continuous functions [
20].
Considering multiple stakeholders, this paper establishes a multi-objective optimization function aiming at the lowest average purchase price of electricity for consumer, the lowest generation cost of micro-grid and the highest income of power grid. Conventional optimization methods can at best find one solution in one simulation run, thereby making those methods inconvenient to solve multiobjective optimization problems. On the contrary, the multiobjective evolutionary algorithms are getting immense popularity, mainly because of their ability to find a widespread of Pareto-optimal solutions in a single simulation run [
20].
In this paper, Non-Dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm (NSGA)-II algorithm has been modified by ordinal value, non-dominated sorting, and crowding distance to ensure better convergence and diversity and is termed as modified NSGA-II. Aiming at the conflict of several objective functions, this paper introduces the modified genetic algorithm NSGA-II, and uses the constraint processing method to intervene in advance. This paper compares and analyses the utilization of renewable energy and the role of energy storage elements through experimental examples, compares the system costs and comprehensive benefits, and achieves the economic optimization of multiple stakeholders.
2. Dynamic Optimization Strategy of Microgrid
2.1. Structural Chart of Microgrid Power Generation System
Microgrid systems include source, load, energy storage devices and control devices, forming a single controllable unit, while providing users with electricity and heat. Most of the power sources in the microgrid are micro-power sources, which are in fact the aggregation of actual, smaller-size entities and include various forms of power generation, such as renewable energy generation like wind energy, solar energy, non-renewable energy generation such as micro-gas turbine, fuel cell and energy storage devices such as supercapacitors, flywheels and batteries. A number of power conversion systems are needed in microgrid systems in order to link the renewable energy, non-renewable energy generation and grid.
Figure 1 is a simplified diagram of a microgrid system with wind turbine, photovoltaic, battery and conventional load.
2.2. Renewable Energy Output Model
In
Figure 1, the microgrid system consists of two renewable energy sources, photovoltaic power generation and wind power generation. The output power of photovoltaic power generation system can be calculated according to the standard test condition (STC) output power, actual illumination intensity and ambient temperature [
13]. Photovoltaic (PV) power generation
and tilt angle
can eventually establish the following functional relationship:
According to the research, it is found that the output power of the wind turbine is related to the wind speed and its own parameters, as shown in Equation (2):
In the model, vin, vout, vrate are cut-in, cut-out and rated wind speed, and Prate is rated power of wind turbine. a and b are constants, where a = Prate/(vrate − vin) and b = avin.
2.3. Battery Model
Batteries, as energy storage components, can play an important role in improving the quality of microgrid power supply, improving the economic benefits of microgrid, reducing the load peak-valley difference of power system, restraining power system oscillation and improving system stability. They are the key to the safe and reliable operation of microgrid, which refers to availability of microgrid. Assuming that the charging and discharging power of the battery is constant within a unit time interval, without considering the effects of battery loss and ambient temperature, the State-of-Charge (SOC) of the battery is determined by the following formula:
In this formula, the initial SOC state of the battery, and are the charging and discharging power of batteries in t periods, and are the charging and discharging power of batteries respectively, where , is the unit time interval, T is the total time interval and Eb is the capacity of the battery.
2.4. Microgrid Economic Optimizing Strategy
From
Figure 1, it can be seen that the load in the system is mainly supplied by wind power, photovoltaic power generation, energy storage devices and power grid. There are many power supply schemes for the load. When calculating the cost of renewable energy generation and the supply and sale price of microgrid to grid side, the unit price of load power supply is as follows:
In the model, Cw and Cv represent the equivalent price of wind power and photovoltaic power, respectively, after the wind turbine and photovoltaic power are sold and then purchased. Cwn and Cvn represent the generating cost of wind power and photovoltaic power, respectively, and Cs and Cb represent the selling price and purchasing price of microgrid, respectively.
According to the market situation, the outsourcing electricity price of microgrid is always higher than the sale price, that is, the Cb-Cs is positive, so the equivalent price is always greater than the generation cost of renewable energy itself. Therefore, when introducing new energy sources and energy storage devices, the micro-grid prefers the power supply strategy of “in-situ absorption”.
When the microgrid is selectively connected to renewable energy sources and energy storage devices, the economic dispatch between the main network and the microgrid can be carried out according to load demand and time-of-use power price mechanism. Specific dispatching strategies are as follows: Comparing the generation cost of microgrid with the purchase price, when the generation cost is higher than the purchase price, choose to abandon the wind power and the photovoltaic power, and purchase electricity from the main network to meet the load demand; conversely, if the cost of microgrid generation is lower than the purchase price, priority should be given to the micro-source output. At the same time, it should also be considered the condition that the micro-source has not reached the maximum output when it has met the load demand (supply exceeds demand). If the cost of generating electricity is lower than the price of selling electricity, the generating unit generates electricity with maximum power, and the surplus electricity will be sold to the main network; otherwise, the generating unit only needs to meet the load demand, and no more power will be generated.
According to the above dispatching strategy, it can be seen that flexible management of micro-source output by utilizing the law of power market is conducive to the optimization of micro-grid economic benefits.
5. Example Analysis
In order to analyze and verify the rationality of the proposed multi-objective dynamic optimal dispatching model for grid-connected microgrid and the effectiveness of the improved algorithm, this paper used the wind/solar/storage grid-connected microgrid system shown in
Figure 1 to solve the optimal economic operation mode of the microgrid based on the modified NSGA-II algorithm.
5.1. System Parameters [16,18,19]
The technical parameters of each micro-source in
Figure 1 are shown in
Table 1, and the time-of-use power price mechanism of power grid is shown in
Table 2. Assuming that the microgrid system is close to the client, without considering transmission line loss and internal system loss, and prefer to use wind and photovoltaic output to reduce load, without considering battery loss. At the same time, the number of battery charges and discharges per day should not exceed 8 times.
Figure 3 shows the load, wind turbine and photovoltaic output forecast curve in the next 24 h.
5.2. Result Analysis
According to the multi-objective optimization model established in this paper, which considers the benefits of users, power grid, new energy and storage battery, the load power supply structure of each period is simulated by MATLAB (R2017a, MathWorks, Natick, MA, USA) as shown in
Figure 4.
From
Figure 4, it can be seen that the period from 0:00 to 7:00 was the period of low power consumption, the load was all supplied by the power grid, and the battery was charged at this time. During the period from 7:00 to 10:00, the cost of the power grid rose, and the wind turbine power generation was almost enough to provide the load power, thus, the power supply of the power grid was almost 0. During the period from 10:00 to 15:00, the electricity price of the power grid was highest, and the new energy can meet the load demand at the beginning, thus, it was all generated by the micro-grid, with excess electricity sold to the grid, after a period of time, micro-grid self-generation was insufficient to meet the load. At this time, the battery discharged and got a small amount of electricity from the grid. During 15:00 to 18:00, the output of the new energy generation declined continuously while the user load increased and the price fell. In this time frame, the electricity was provided by the grid and microgrid in a hybrid way, and the batteries were charged; 18:00-21:00 peak period, grid power. At this time, both wind power and photovoltaic power were full. In order to save the cost of electricity purchase, the storage battery was in discharge state, and the rest of the load was supplied by the power grid. After 21:00, the electricity price of the power grid decreased, which made the wind power full. At the same time, the power grid needed to supply power to the micro-grid. However, due to the limitation of transmission power, the power balance was maintained by storage batteries.
From the above analysis, it can be seen that the battery can charge when the micro-grid power is excessive or the grid price is low, and discharge when the grid price is high and the peak period of power consumption. This can not only reduce the cost of load supply, but also improve the utilization rate of the battery. At the same time, the battery can also maintain the power balance of the system.
Figure 5 shows the charging and discharging conversion process of batteries in the whole dispatching process. It can be seen that the charging and discharging times of batteries in the whole process are not more than eight times, which meets the economic requirements.
In order to verify the effectiveness of the proposed model, the results of this model are compared with those of the single objective optimization model which only considers the minimum cost of load supply. The benefits of each stakeholder are shown in
Table 3.
From
Table 3, it can be seen that the multi-objective optimization model, which is composed of the minimum average load cost, the lowest generation cost of micro-grid and the highest income of grid, is superior to the single-objective optimization model in total power supply cost without considering AC power constraints. Therefore, while considering the benefits of various stakeholders, the method proposed in this paper is more practical and effective.
5.3. Analysis of Microgrid Day-ahead Scheduling Results under Different Optimized Conditions
The day-ahead optimal dispatch of microgrid is not only related to the combination of generators and economic costs within microgrid, but also to the power exchange between microgrid and main network. Generally, the economic dispatch of microgrid is to adjust the energy storage capacity and renewable energy according to the demand of load and the price of electricity purchased and sold, and complete the electricity transaction between microgrid and main network. In this paper, according to the time-of-use power price mechanism and the demand of micro-power supply and energy storage in the micro-grid itself, and considering the economic cost, the day-ahead optimal dispatch of the micro-grid is realized. According to output of renewable energy, energy storage and power limitation with power grid, this paper gives six different optimization conditions.
Table 4 gives the comparison results of total cost and average cost under six different optimization conditions.
As can be seen from
Table 4, the cost of selective acceptance of renewable energy is significantly lower than that of full utilization. This is due to the high cost of wind turbines and photovoltaic power generation. When the load requirements are met and the selling price is lower than the cost, selective generation can greatly reduce the total power supply cost. However, the cost of energy storage and discharge is lower, thus, the cost will also be reduced when energy storage is added. Taking into account the interests of various interest groups, we can achieve better economic benefits.
Figure 6 shows the comparison curves of power exchange power and time-sharing purchase cost of each generation unit, micro-grid and grid under different conditions.
From
Figure 6, it can be seen that the peak power supply cost is significantly reduced with energy storage when abandoning the wind power and the photovoltaic power. At this time, the load is mainly supplied by battery discharge and wind and solar output, which reduces the cost of purchasing from the main network at a high price. In the low load period, reducing the output of renewable energy reduces the cost of power generation, and the battery can be charged by purchasing electricity from the main network at a low price to ensure the subsequent discharge.
Through the analysis of the example, the general strategy of microgrid economic dispatch can be obtained as follows: when the cost of generating electricity is higher than the price of purchasing electricity, the microgrid does not generate electricity, and the load demand is satisfied by purchasing electricity from the main network. However, when the cost of generating electricity is lower than the price of purchasing electricity, the microgrid supplies the load demand through its own micro-source. At the same time, when the generating unit has not reached the maximum output, it can meet the load demand, that is, when the supply exceeds the demand, it is necessary to compare the cost of generating electricity with the price of selling electricity. When the cost of generating electricity is lower than the price of selling electricity, the micro-grid will sell more power to the main network; otherwise, the generating unit will not generate more power. Using real-time electricity price and other electricity market rules to flexibly dispatch the operation status of micro-grid can realize the optimization of micro-grid day-ahead dispatching and improve economic benefits.
At the same time, the charging and discharging capacity of storage battery should be considered. When the price of purchasing electricity from the main network is low, the storage battery can be charged, so that the total power generation of all units is less than the total load demand when the peak load and the price of purchasing electricity are high. The storage device of storage battery can reduce the purchasing power from the main network by discharging, so as to reduce the economic cost. If the load cannot be balanced after the battery discharge, the power loss in the microgrid can be satisfied by purchasing power from the large power grid; when the energy storage device has excess power, it can be considered to sell power to the main network for profit.
According to the above analysis, the day-ahead optimal scheduling of microgrid is a multi-objective, multi-interest group’s overall economic optimization, but also limited by the number of battery charges and discharges, capacity, life and power exchange between the main network and other factors. Therefore, the reasonable optimal scheduling model and constraints established in this paper play an important role in realizing economic scheduling, can get more comprehensive and reasonable scheduling schemes, and provide efficient help for the operation of the actual microgrid system.
6. Conclusions
The day-ahead optimal scheduling of microgrid is not only related to the combination of generators and economic costs within microgrid, but also to the power exchange between microgrid and main network. Generally, the economic dispatch of microgrid is to adjust the energy storage capacity and renewable energy according to the demand of load and the price of electricity purchased and sold, and completes the electricity transaction between microgrid and main network. According to the time-of-use power price mechanism and the micro-power supply and energy storage requirements of the micro-grid itself, this paper fully considers the economic costs of the users, the grid and micro-sources within the micro-grid, and achieves the day-ahead optimal scheduling of microgrid. By comparing the economic dispatching results under different circumstances, the economy of the proposed scheme is verified.
Through the research results of this paper, we can see that the day-ahead optimal scheduling of microgrid is a multi-objective, multi-interest group of the overall economic optimization. However, it is also limited by the number of battery charges and discharges, capacity, life and exchange power between the main network and other factors. The multi-objective optimization model established in this paper considers the interests of users and power grid, and establishes a reasonable optimal scheduling model and constraints. At the same time, the NSGA-II algorithm has been modified by ordinal value, non-dominated sorting and crowding distance to ensure better convergence and diversity and an external penalty function has been introduced to deal with the constraints, so the solution accuracy of the multi-objective optimization model is improved, which provides great help and application prospects for realizing the economic dispatch of microgrid and improving the economy and intelligence of power marketing.