3.2. Adsorption of Reactant Molecules on Modified LaMnO3 (001) Surface during NH3-SCR Process
There are L–H mechanisms and E–R mechanisms in the NH
3-SCR de-NO
x process involving catalysts. “L–H mechanism” refers to the heterogeneous catalytic mechanism in which two reactant molecules first adsorb onto the catalyst surface and then desorb after reaction to produce products, while “E–R mechanism” refers to the mechanism in which one reactant molecule adsorbs onto another to produce products. Many scholars have no consensus on this, but both reaction mechanisms clearly indicate that NH
3 will be adsorbed onto the catalyst surface first. As the reactant NH
3 molecule, its adsorption capacity on the catalyst surface has a great impact on NO
x removal [
30], so this paper will first study the adsorption capacity of NH
3 molecule.
Figure 3 shows the schematic diagram of NH
3 molecules adsorbed onto Mn and Fe active sites, while
Table 2 shows the bond angle, bond length, released adsorption energy, and Mulliken charge of adsorbed molecules after NH
3 molecules adsorbed onto Mn and Fe active sites.
It can be seen in this situation that NH3 can be absorbed onto the Mn and Fe sites with the N atom end, and a new chemical bond is formed. The NH3 bond angle adsorbed onto Mn active sites is greater than that of NH3 molecules adsorbed onto Fe active sites. This is because the number of electrons lost by the H atoms of NH3 molecules adsorbed onto Mn active sites is greater than that adsorbed onto Fe, which leads to the weaker repulsion of H atoms to hydrogen atoms, leads to a larger bond angle. The N-Mn bond length of the NH3 molecule adsorbed onto the Mn active site is longer than that adsorbed onto the Fe active site because the radius of the Mn ion is larger than that of the Fe ion. The adsorption energy released after adsorption and the energy released by NH3 adsorbed onto the Mn active site is less than that released by NH3 molecule adsorbed onto Fe active site, indicating that the NH3 molecule adsorbed onto the Fe active site is conducive to reaction. In addition, the Mulliken charges are all positive, indicating that electrons migrate from the NH3 molecule to the catalyst surface, which is due to the existence of lone pair electrons in the NH3 molecule, and the existence of a 3d empty orbital on the catalyst surface is sufficient to accept excess electrons. Moreover, the charge amount of the NH3 molecule adsorbed by the Mn active site is less than that of the Fe active site, because the electronegativity of Fe is greater than that of Mn. Therefore, in both adsorption processes, a large amount of energy is released, and a large number of electrons are transferred from NH3 molecules to the catalyst. Since the electronegativity of Fe ions is greater than that of Mn ions, there is more electron migration at the active site of Fe, the interaction between them is stronger, and more energy is released.
As one of the main reactants in SCR de-NO
x reaction, and under normal combustion temperature, the NO
x contained in the flue gas generated after the combustion of coal and other fuels is mainly NO and NO
2, of which NO accounts for more than 90% of the total NO
x, while NO
2 only accounts for 5–10%, so it is necessary to study its adsorption capacity on the catalyst surface [
31].
It has been shown that NO will approach the active surface sites in the form of N atoms and O atoms, respectively, to form a stable adsorption configuration. The corresponding parameters are list in
Table 3.
There are two kinds of adsorption of NO reactants in
Figure 4 on Mn and Fe active sites. It can be seen from
Table 3 that when NO is adsorbed onto the catalyst surface as a N atom end, its bond length is shorter than that in the form of O atom end proximity, and the adsorption energy in the case of N proximity is far greater than that in the case of O proximity. Therefore, the adsorption of NO molecules should mostly occur on Mn and Fe ions on the catalyst surface as a N atom end. During the adsorption process, no matter whether the NO molecule on Mn active site is adsorbed by a nitrogen atom or an oxygen atom, the energy released after adsorption is less than the energy released by the corresponding end of the NO molecule adsorbed onto the Fe active site, which also indicates that the NO molecule is more easily adsorbed onto the Fe active site. This is likely due to the fact that the electronegativity of Fe ions is greater than that of Mn ions, and their oxidation is stronger, which is also true of NH
3 molecules. This also shows that the doping of Fe is conducive to promoting the adsorption of NO. When the nitrogen atom is close, the bond length is shorter and more electrons are transferred, whereas when the oxygen atom is close, the bond length is longer and fewer electrons are transferred.
In the process of the NH
3-SCR de-NO
x reaction, O
2 plays an important role as a reactant, which is helpful to the smooth progress of the reaction.
Figure 5 shows the schematic diagram of O
2 molecules adsorbed onto Mn and Fe active sites, and
Table 4 shows the corresponding adsorption parameters.
Table 4 shows that the N-Mn bond length of O
2 adsorbed onto Mn active site is longer than that on Fe active site. During the adsorption process, the energy released by O
2 adsorption on the Mn active site is less than that adsorbed onto Fe active site, indicating that O
2 is more easily adsorbed onto Fe. Since the oxidizability of oxygen atom in O
2 is stronger than that of Mn and Fe active sites, O
2 molecules obtain electrons during adsorption. Since the electronegativity of Fe ions is greater than that of Mn ions, the charge amount of O
2 molecule adsorbed by Mn active site is greater than that of O
2 molecules adsorbed by an Fe active site.
3.3. Study on Surface Reaction Process of Modified LaMnO3 (001) Surface
A large number of results show that NH
3 will first be adsorbed onto the catalyst surface, regardless of the E–R mechanism or L–H mechanism, and will decompose to produce NH
2, NH, and other intermediates under the action of lattice oxygen. Hence, it is necessary to study the process of NH
3 decomposition, which is shown in
Figure 6.
Figure 6 shows the process of dehydrogenation of NH
3 molecules into NH
2, NH, and N after adsorption at the Mn and Fe active sites in the absence of lattice oxygen. The NH
3 molecule is adsorbed onto the Mn active site. At this time, the N-Mn bond length is 2.075 Å, and the distances between the three hydrogen atoms of the NH
3 molecule and the nearest lattice oxygen are 2.738 Å, 2.747 Å, and 2.822 Å, respectively. Then, under the action of lattice oxygen, the hydrogen atom nearest to the lattice oxygen desorbs and combines with the lattice oxygen to form hydroxyl. The energy barrier and reaction heat of this process are 87.034 kJ/mol and 71.445 kJ/mol, respectively, indicating that this process is an endothermic process. After the formation of NH
2 radicals on the catalyst surface, the dehydrogenation process will continue under the action of the lattice oxygen. The energy barrier and reaction heat of the process are 148.695 kJ/mol and 72.741 kJ/mol, respectively, indicating that the process is also an endothermic process. After the formation of NH radicals on the catalyst surface, the dehydrogenation process will continue under the action of the lattice oxygen. The energy barrier and reaction heat of the process are 86.322 kJ/mol and 5.556 kJ/mol, respectively. While the NH
3 molecule removes three hydrogen atoms in turn, the energy barrier of NH
2 radical removing hydrogen atom is the highest, indicating that the occurrence of this process is difficult, which leads to less NH radical generation, and fewer NH radical sources also lead to fewer nitrogen ions finally formed. The same process will occur at the Fe site. The NH
3 molecule is adsorbed onto the Fe active site, which is an exothermic process. At this time, the N-Fe bond length is 1.999 Å, and the distances between the three hydrogen atoms of the NH
3 molecule and the nearest lattice oxygen are 2.620 Å, 2.659 Å, and 2.848 Å, respectively. It can be seen that the average distance between hydrogen atom and lattice oxygen is shorter than that adsorbed onto the Mn ion at this time. This is because the electronegativity of Fe ions is stronger than that of Mn ions. As a result, after the NH
3 is adsorbed onto the active site, the N atom adsorbed onto the Fe ion obtains more electrons, which weakens the repulsion of hydrogen atoms in NH
3 molecules, thus reducing the distance between hydrogen atom and lattice oxygen. Subsequently, under the action of the lattice oxygen, the hydrogen atom nearest to the lattice oxygen desorbs and combines with lattice oxygen to form hydroxyl. The energy barrier and reaction heat of this process are 98.583 kJ/mol and 53.631 kJ/mol, respectively. NH
2 radicals continue to dehydrogenate, and the energy barrier and reaction heat of this process are 136.380 kJ/mol and 80.549 kJ/mol, respectively. However, the NH radical continues the dehydrogenation process, and the energy barrier and reaction heat of the process are 119.181 kJ/mol and 60.320 kJ/mol, respectively. In comparison with the above analysis, the dehydrogenation process of NH
3 molecule at Mn and Fe active sites is basically the same, and the energy barrier of NH
2 radical removal of hydrogen atom is the highest. Therefore, NH
2 should be the main dehydrogenation product, which is the same as that of other catalysts [
32].
Figure 7 shows the decomposition process of NH
2NO. On the catalyst surface, after the formation of NH
2, it will react with gaseous NO to generate NH
2NO. In this step, the reaction potential barrier can be ignored, and the reaction is very rapid, and then NH
2NO will decompose. At Mn active site, NH
2NO molecule removes a hydrogen atom to the lattice oxygen to form the NHNO molecular structure, which is a linear structure. The energy barrier and reaction heat of the process are 28.128 kJ/mol and 24.510 kJ/mol, respectively, indicating that the process is endothermic. The generated NHNO molecule is unstable, which will further undergo dehydrogenation and finally decompose into N
2 and hydroxyl. The energy barrier and reaction heat of this process are 204.640 kJ/mol and −206.557 kJ/mol, respectively, indicating that this process is an exothermic process. Since the product N
2 has been generated, the reaction is complete, and the generated hydroxyl group will combine with the free hydrogen atom to generate the product H
2O. At the Fe active site, the NH
2NO molecule will also break an N-H bond and adsorb the desorbed hydrogen atom onto the oxygen ion in the NH
2NO molecule to form an O-H bond. The energy barrier and reaction heat of the process are 155.849 kJ/mol and −39.559 kJ/mol, respectively, indicating that the process is exothermic. The NHNO generated is unstable, so dehydrogenation will occur further and eventually produce N
2 and H
2O. The energy barrier and reaction heat of the process are 58.345 kJ/mol and −201.643 kJ/mol respectively, which also indicates that the process is exothermic. Compared with the above analysis, the reaction process of NH
2 free radicals at Mn and Fe active sites is the same, and there is a higher energy barrier step in both reaction processes, but the reaction will eventually release a lot of energy. Combined with the change in reaction energy, the occurrence of the reaction will gradually be easy to realize as the reaction proceeds.
Yang et al. pointed out that during the process of SCR, the surface oxygen on the catalyst surface has a high mobility, and its oxidation is stronger than that of lattice oxygen. Therefore, the decomposition process of O
2 molecules on the catalyst surface was studied in this paper [
16]. The corresponding process is shown in
Figure 8.
Figure 8 shows the decomposition process of O
2 after adsorption on Mn and Fe active sites. The O
2 molecule is adsorbed onto the active site, and then under the influence of the active site, O
2 decomposes and adsorbs an oxygen atom on the active site respectively. At the Mn site, the energy barrier and reaction heat of this process are 220.707 kJ/mol and −2.854 kJ/mol, respectively, and at the Fe site, they are 254.764 kJ/mol and 12.224 kJ/mol, respectively. By comparing the above data, it can be seen that the energy barrier of the decomposition process of O
2 molecule on the active site is relatively high, among which the energy barrier of the decomposition process of O
2 molecule adsorbed onto the Fe active site is higher, which indicates that the breaking of O=O bond requires more energy, and also indicates that the decomposition process of O
2 molecule on Mn and Fe active site is difficult to occur. This result is similar to the results on the surface of iron oxide [
33]. The decomposition process of O
2 molecule adsorbed onto Mn active site is exothermic, while the decomposition process of O
2 molecule adsorbed onto Fe active site is endothermic process, indicating that O
2 molecule adsorbed onto Mn active site is easier to decompose.
Figure 9 shows the dehydrogenation process of NH
3 molecules at Mn and Fe active sites. During this process, NH
3 adsorbed onto Mn and Fe active sites undergoes dehydrogenation by oxygen ions generated by the decomposition of O
2 molecules, producing NH
2 radicals and hydroxyl groups. The hydroxyl groups combine with free hydrogen atoms on the catalyst surface to form the product H
2O. The energy barriers of this process are 50.761 kJ/mol and 63.411 kJ/mol, respectively, and the reaction heats are 25.879 kJ/mol and 46.599 kJ/mol, respectively, indicating that this process is endothermic. Comparing the above process with the process of removing one hydrogen atom from NH
3 molecules under anaerobic conditions, it can be found that under the influence of surface oxygen, the energy barrier for NH
3 molecule dehydrogenation is lower, and the reaction heat absorption is also lower. This indicates that NH
3 molecules are more inclined to react with surface oxygen and undergo dehydrogenation when surface oxygen is present. This is because surface oxygen has more coordination numbers to accommodate more hydrogen atoms. The NH
2 free radicals generated by the reaction will react with NO molecules in the air to generate NH
2NO molecules, which will then decompose and ultimately generate N
2 and H
2O products, as shown in
Figure 7. In addition, the generated NH
2 radicals will continue to react with surface oxygen and undergo dehydrogenation.
Figure 10 depicts the dehydrogenation process of NH
2 radicals at Mn and Fe active sites. During this process, NH
3 adsorbed onto Mn and Fe active sites undergoes dehydrogenation by oxygen ions generated by the decomposition of O
2 molecules, resulting in the formation of NH
2 radicals and hydroxyl groups, which combine with free hydrogen atoms on the catalyst surface to form the product H
2O. The energy barriers of this process at Mn and Fe sites are 374.292 kJ/mol and 101.089 kJ/mol, respectively, and the reaction heats are 27.39 kJ/mol and 50.537 kJ/mol, respectively, indicating that this process is endothermic.
By comparing the above processes, it can be seen that the energy barrier for the dehydrogenation process of NH2 radicals adsorbed onto Fe active sites is significantly lower than that of NH2 radicals adsorbed onto Mn active sites. This indicates that increasing Fe active sites by doping iron is beneficial for the dehydrogenation process of NH2 radicals adsorbed onto active sites under aerobic conditions. The generated NH radicals will continue to react with surface oxygen and undergo a dehydrogenation process to generate nitrogen ions. However, based on the previous analysis, it can be seen that the generation of NH radicals and oxygen ions is relatively small. Therefore, this article does not consider the reaction between NH radicals and surface oxygen and the dehydrogenation process.
The generated NH radicals will react with NO molecules in the air to generate NHNO molecules, as shown in
Figure 11, which shows the formation process of NHNO on the catalyst surface.
Figure 11 shows that NH radicals adsorbed onto Mn and Fe active sites combine with NO molecules in the air to form NHNO molecules. In this structure, N-Mn and N-Fe bonds still exist, while oxygen ions in NHNO molecules do not form stable chemical bonds with the active sites. The energy barriers of this process are 28.537 kJ/mol and 30.629 kJ/mol, respectively, and the reaction heats are −150.812 kJ/mol and −132.462 kJ/mol, respectively, indicating that this process is an exothermic process.
By comparing the above processes, it can be found that the reaction process between NH radicals adsorbed onto Mn and Fe active sites and NO molecules in the air is different, and the reaction energy barrier and reaction heat also differ significantly. The reaction energy barrier between NH radicals adsorbed onto Mn active sites and NO molecules in the air is lower than that between NH radicals adsorbed onto Fe active sites and NO molecules in the air. The reaction heat is that the energy released by the reaction between NH radicals adsorbed onto Mn active sites and NO molecules in the air is higher than that released by the reaction between NH radicals adsorbed onto Fe active sites and NO molecules in the air. The above data indicates that NO molecules are more inclined to react with NH radicals adsorbed onto Mn active sites. However, since both reaction processes are exothermic, the occurrence of the reaction will gradually become easier to achieve as the reaction progresses.
From the analysis of the adsorption of NO
2 molecules on Mn and Fe active sites mentioned earlier, it can be concluded that the adsorption of NO
2 molecules near the nitrogen atom end on the active site or the adsorption of NO
2 molecules on the Fe active site is beneficial for the reaction, and when both conditions are met simultaneously, the reaction is most favorable. Therefore, this article studied the generation process of NO
2 at Mn and Fe active sites using this approach, as shown in
Figure 12.
Figure 12 shows the formation process of NO
2 molecules at Mn and Fe active sites, with energy barriers of 199.664 kJ/mol and 205.752 kJ/mol, respectively, and reaction heats of −18.586 kJ/mol and −8.590 kJ/mol, respectively, indicating that this process is exothermic.
By comparing the above processes, it can be found that the energy barrier of NO
2 generation at both Mn and Fe active sites is relatively high. The energy barrier of NO
2 generation at Mn active sites is slightly higher than that of NO
2 generation at Fe active sites. At the same time, the reaction heat released by NO
2 generation at Mn active sites is greater than that released by NO
2 generation at Fe active sites. The results also indicate that NO
2 molecules are more easily generated at Mn active sites. However, since both reaction processes are exothermic, the occurrence of the reaction will gradually become easier to achieve as the reaction progresses. There is literature indicating that when NO
2 is present, nitric acid will be generated to further generate NH
4NO
3. Under the action of surface acidic sites, NH
4NO
3 will be reduced by NO to NH
4NO
2, which is extremely unstable and can decompose into N
2 and H
2O at 100 °C, which is a rapid SCR reaction [
34,
35,
36].
3.4. Analysis of NH3-SCR De-NOx Reaction Mechanism
The NH3-SCR denitrification reaction process on the surface of modified LaMnO3 (001) catalysts can be divided into three processes: adsorption, reaction, and desorption. The adsorption of NH3 molecules on the catalyst surface can be divided into adsorption at Mn active sites and adsorption at Fe active sites, with NH3 molecules having the highest adsorption energy at Fe active sites. The adsorption of NO molecules on the catalyst surface can be divided into two types: adsorption on the Mn active site, adsorption on the Fe active site, or adsorption on the active site near the nitrogen atom end of NO molecules; and adsorption on the active site near the oxygen atom end of NO molecules. Among them, the adsorption energy of NO molecules on the Fe active site near the nitrogen atom end is the highest.
The reaction process is shown in
Figure 13, listing the relationships between the various elemental reactions. Under anaerobic conditions, the adsorbed NH
3 molecules will undergo dehydrogenation with lattice oxygen on the catalyst surface to generate NH
2 radicals. Subsequently, NH
2 radicals will continue to dehydrogenate with lattice oxygen to form NH radicals.
Figure 13a shows that the energy barrier of this step is 148.695 kJ/mol, while
Figure 13b shows that the energy barrier of this step is 136.380 kJ/mol, indicating that the reaction energy barrier of this step is the highest under anaerobic conditions. Therefore, the generation of NH radicals is relatively low, leading to a very low generation of nitrogen ions. Under aerobic conditions, NH
3 molecules will also react and dehydrogenate with oxygen ions adsorbed onto the catalyst surface to generate NH
2 radicals. NH
2 radicals will also continue to dehydrogenate with surface oxygen to form NH radicals. The NH
2 radicals generated under anaerobic and aerobic conditions will react with NO in the air and generate NH
2NO molecules. Due to the instability of NH
2NO molecules, they will subsequently decompose and ultimately produce N
2 and H
2O products. The generated NH radicals will also react with NO molecules in the air and generate NHNO molecules. Similarly, due to the instability of NHNO molecules, they will also undergo decomposition and ultimately produce N
2 and H
2O products. After N
2 and H
2O molecules detach from the catalyst surface, the SCR reaction is completed. Comparing the generation of NH
2 and NH radicals under anaerobic and aerobic conditions, it can be found that the reaction proceeds more easily under aerobic conditions. By comparing the reactions between Mn active sites and Fe active sites, it can be seen that the reactions involving NH
3 molecules, NH
2 radicals, and NH radicals located at Fe active sites are more easily carried out. In addition, under aerobic conditions, the participation of O
2 will cause the oxidation of NO molecules into NO
2 molecules, and the participation of NO
2 molecules will undergo a “rapid SCR reaction”, accelerating the progress of the SCR reaction.