1. Introduction
As the depth of coal mining increases year by year, the difficulty of ensuring the stability of rocks that surround roadways in the face of complex geological conditions and mechanical environment poses a serious challenge to the safe and efficient mining of deep coal resources [
1]. In view of the high ground pressure, considerable disturbances, and plastic softening of rock mass in the deep roadway, several studies have been conducted on the control of surrounding rock in deep roadways focusing on three main areas: change characteristics of brittleness to ductility of deep rock mass, bearing mechanism of the rock, and the control technology used.
(1) Experimental studies have been conducted on the process of brittle–ductile transformation of deep rock mass, which laid a foundation for the study of control strategies for rocks surrounding deep roadways. He et al. [
2] put forward that deep rock masses have aging characteristics and transforms from brittleness to ductility under high confining pressure; Xu et al. [
3] studied the microscopic mechanism of brittle to plastic transformation of granite under high temperature, considering the characteristics of the high-temperature environment surrounding the deep rock mass; Gowd et al. [
4] and Fredrich et al. [
5] carried out triaxial compression tests on rocks and obtained the critical confining pressure value of the brittle–ductile transformation in rocks; Cao et al. [
6] and Zhao et al. [
7] established a statistical constitutive model of rock damage which can reflect the brittle–ductile characteristics and their mutual transformation characteristics based on the statistical damage theory and triaxial test curves.
(2) Theoretical studies have been carried out on the bearing mechanism of rocks surrounding roadways and have defined the main objects of roadway support. Based on the analysis of the plastic zone theory, Zhang et al. [
8] considered that the range and shape of the plastic zone of the surrounding rock is the theoretical basis for the quantitative design of the supporting structure, and proposed a support scheme for the weakly cemented soft rock roadway; Zhang et al. [
9] studied the distribution characteristics of surrounding rock loose circle in weak roadway, and guided the design of the supporting parameters; Zhu et al. [
10] studied the coordination effect of the primary and secondary bearing areas of the surrounding rock, and concluded that the surrounding rock compression domain is the main bearing area; Nazimko et al. [
11] studied the failure process of the surrounding rock in roadways under deep dynamic pressure by actual measurement. It was found that there were extruding and compressive zones in surrounding rock, and the compressive zone increased the stability of the surrounding rock; Kang [
12] put forward the key circle theory of rocks surrounding roadways, and expounded the influencing factors of the key bearing circle and its distribution characteristics; Zhang et al. [
13] studied the bearing mechanism of double bearing structures in deep soft rock roadways; considering the rock surrounding a broken roadway as a small bearing structure and the deep surrounding rock as a large bearing structure, Yang et al. [
14] proposed the superimposed coupling support technology for large and small bearing structures; Wang et al. [
15] and Yang et al. [
16] analyzed the bearing mechanism of rock surrounding roadways from the stress distribution.
(3) Based on the bearing mechanism of the rock, support technology for deep roadways was developed and implemented. Kang et al. [
17,
18] divided the relevant roadways in into five types, and concluded that rock bolting had become me the primary form of roadway support in Chinese coal mines; Zhao et al. [
19] proposed a U-shaped steel closed support with an inverted U-shaped steel arch in the floor for improving the support effect of the surrounding rock in deep roadway; Skrzypkowski, K. [
20] considered that the arched yielding support plays a decisive role in stability under dynamic loads in the deep mines and a new design of arch yielding support was proposed, in addition, in the conditions of the roof, made of rocks prone to sagging, an yielding rock bolt support be used [
21]; based on the “bolt-mesh-anchor-shed” combined support technology [
22,
23,
24], Li et al. [
25] and Xie et al. [
26] proposed a double anchor control technology and high pre-stressed anchor cable truss support, respectively.
However, the factors that influence the stability of the rock that surrounds roadways are complex, and it is necessary to carry out supporting research according to the specific geological conditions of the mine. At the same time, few studies delineate the interaction between the support structure and bearing area, and available analyses of bearing mechanism of surrounding rock are insufficient to guide support design quantitatively. Based on the bearing structure of the rock surrounding the roadways, this paper analyzes the factors that influence the stability of the surrounding rock in deep soft rock roadways under dynamic pressure, and proposes the coupling reinforcement support scheme. The results can provide references for surrounding rock control in deep dynamic soft rock roadways.
3. Control Mechanism of Surrounding Rock-Bearing Structure for Deep Soft Rock Roadway Under Dynamic Pressure
In addition to the influence of in situ stress, the stability of surrounding rock in deep roadway is also subject to strong disturbances and plastic softening of the rock mass. To clarify the bearing mechanism of the surrounding rock for deep soft rock roadway under dynamic pressure, based on the production geological conditions in the Pingdingshan coal industry group, the change characteristic of surrounding rock-bearing structure under different conditions is simulated using the Fast Lagrangian Analysis of Continua 3D software (FLAC3D version 5.0, Itasca Consulting Group, Inc., Minneapolis, MN, USA). The control effects exerted by different support methods on the surrounding rock are analyzed in this section.
3.1. Change Characteristics of External Bearing Structure of Roadway-Surrounding Rock
According to the scheme in
Table 1, the corresponding numerical simulation models are established to analyze the change characteristic of the external bearing structure of rock surrounding the roadway under different conditions. The roadway is arranged in argillaceous sandstone, the roof is sandstone, the floor is mudstone, and the dip angle of rock stratum is 0°.
The shape of the roadway section is a straight wall arch, and the width and height dimensions of is 5 m × 3.5 m, and the buried depth is 900 m. The lateral and bottom boundary displacement are constrained, and the upper boundary represents the free surface. A constitutive model is selected, and the stress boundary is assigned according to the simulation scheme, and the coefficient of horizontal pressure was 0.5.
According to
Section 2.2, the area of external bearing structure is the area where the tangential stress of surrounding rock rises, and the tangential stress of roadway side is the vertical stress. Therefore, the location of the external bearing structure and the width of the external bearing structure at the roadway side are determined by the peak tangential stress and the vertical stress of the surrounding rock, respectively.
Figure 5 is the distribution of tangential stress of the surrounding rock under different conditions. The location of the external bearing structure is determined by the peak value of tangential stress.
Figure 6 shows the correlation curves between the external bearing structure parameters and deformation of the surrounding rock.
Figure 6 shows that the deformation of surrounding rock under dynamic load and creep is significantly higher than that under static load without creep, the external bearing structure of surrounding rock is far away from the roadway, and the thickness of external bearing structure increases. When the roadway is in a static load state and has no creep, the deformation associated with roof subsidence, floor heave, and the two-sided displacement are 114.5 mm, 51.52 mm and 69.09 mm, respectively. At this time, the tangential stress peak of the surrounding rock at the roadway side is 5.78 m away from the roadway, and the thickness of the external bearing structure is 3.77 m. When the roadway is subjected to dynamic load and creep occurs, the deformation of the surrounding rock of the roadway increases about 11 times. The peak of the tangential stress of the surrounding rock at the roadway side is 11.99 m away from the roadway and the thickness of external bearing structure is 7.30 m, which increases 2.07 and 1.94 times, respectively.
3.2. Control Effect of Roadway-Surrounding Rock-Bearing Structure Under Different Support Methods
To further clarify the control mechanism of rock that surrounds roadways under the influence of different support methods, this paper simulates the control effects of different support methods such as shed support, floor pressure relief, anchor cable support, and grouting reinforcement on the surrounding rock-bearing structure. The simulation scheme is shown in
Figure 7. The steel shed is made of 36 U-shaped steel, with an elastic modulus of 210 GPa and a tensile strength of 530 MPa. Pretension of anchor cable is 30 kN and the length of anchor cable is 6.5 m. According to the field test, the uniaxial compressive of surrounding rock in the grouting area is 8.87 MPa, and the tensile strength is 1.13 MPa.
According to the above analysis, increasing the support strength of the internal load-bearing structure, cohesion, and internal friction angle of the surrounding rock, and reducing the dynamic load coefficient can make the external bearing structure close to the roadway and the thickness of the bearing structure decreases, while the bearing capacity of the surrounding rock in the shallow roadway increases. At the same time, when the surrounding rock deformation of the roadway is large, the external bearing structure is far away from the roadway and the thickness of the bearing structure increases. Therefore, the thickness of the external bearing structure is used as the evaluation index of the control effect, and the simulation result is shown in
Figure 8.
The distribution of the thickness of the external bearing structure under different support methods is shown in
Figure 9.
Figure 9 shows that: (1) under the condition of creep in the rock that surrounds the roadways, the anchor cable support can effectively reduce the thickness of the external bearing structure at the roof and the side, and the thicknesses are 39.81% and 26.63% less than that without the support, respectively. In addition, when the pressure on the roadway floor is relieved, the thickness of the external bearing structure at the floor is reduced by 39.14%. (2) Under the dynamic load, when the anchor cable is used, the thickness of the external bearing structure is reduced by an average of 28.45%. When the floor is relieved, the thickness of the external bearing structure at the floor is reduced by 43.85%. (3) Under the conditions of creep and dynamic load, the thickness of the external bearing structure decreased by 41.93% and 23.88%, respectively, with the grouting reinforcement, and the thickness of the external bearing structure decreased by 12.87% and 8.52% with the shed support. It shows that grouting reinforcement has a good control effect under the condition of surrounding rock creep, and the support effect of the shed support is poor.
In conclusion, the deformation of rock surrounding the roadway increases significantly under the conditions of creep and dynamic load, and the external bearing structure is far away from the roadway and the thickness increases. In the process of supporting the deep, soft surrounding rock, the thickness of the external bearing structure or the thickness of the plastic zone of the surrounding rock can be reduced to improve the bearing capacity of the surrounding rock using anchor cable support and floor pressure relief. Anchor cable support can effectively control the deformation of the roof and the sides of the roadway. Pressure relief of the floor is effective in controlling the deformation of the floor heave. Grouting reinforcement can be used to control the deformation of the surrounding rock when it is prone to creep or fracture.
4. Reinforcement Support Technology for Deep Soft Rock Roadway Under Dynamic Pressure and Its Application
According to the control mechanism of the surrounding rock-bearing structure, the support design of the main inclined shaft is quantitatively analyzed for the No. 4 coal mine in Pingdingshan coal industry group. The coupling reinforcement support scheme of the deep dynamic soft rock roadway has been proposed.
4.1. Engineering Situation
The main inclined shaft of the No.4 coal mine is 1200 m in length, with a slope of 19°20′. It obliquely penetrates three groups of coal seams, namely the D, E, and F coal seams, with a depth of 700 m~900 m and a design section of 27.78 m
2. It is responsible for the main pedestrian and ventilation tasks at the second and third levels. The layout of the main inclined shaft layout space is shown in
Figure 10. Due to the development needs of mine, after the construction of the main inclined shaft, the F
15 coal seam is mined first, followed by the E
8 coal seam, and finally, the F
16 coal seam.
The surrounding rock of the main inclined shaft is mainly composed of sandy mudstone and mudstone, which accounts for 73.17% of the total length of the roadway. The roadway was originally supported by the combination of “bolt-mesh-anchor-shed”, but control effect was not good. The length of large deformation roadway is 1100 m.
4.2. Control Analysis of Bearing Structure of Rock Surrounding the Roadway
The surrounding rock of the main inclined shaft is mainly composed of sandy mudstone and mudstone, which easily disintegrate, soften, and expand when meeting with water, and the strength of surrounding rock is reduced. Some sections pass through the fault, the surrounding rock is broken, and the entire bearing capacity is reduced. Meanwhile, the roadway is arranged in the protection coal pillars of district dip. The surrounding rock has large in situ stress, stress concentration, and is affected by the mining of the two wings working faces. The main inclined shaft is a typical deep dynamic soft rock roadway.
Combined with the variation characteristics of the surrounding rock stress and the geological conditions when the coal seam groups are mined, the roadway can be divided into three areas: the upper part of the main inclined shaft (range of 0~50 m under the E8 coal seam floor) is greatly affected by the dynamic load, mainly the deformation of the roof and floor; the middle part of the main inclined shaft (range of 50~120 m under the E8 coal seam floor) is affected by the mining of the working face and the creep of the surrounding rock, the roof subsides, and the top corner of roadway is severely compression damaged. The lower part of the main inclined shaft (range of 120~170 m under the E8 coal seam floor) is greatly affected by the creep of the surrounding rock, the floor heave is serious, and the roof and side are intact.
The middle part of the main inclined shaft is selected to analyze the bearing structure characteristics. The roadway width is 5 m, the compressive strength of surrounding rock is 3.5 MPa, the internal friction angle and cohesion are 30.57° and 3.2 MPa respectively, the rock mass strength softening modulus is 0.05 GPa, and the expansion gradient of plastic softening zone in the surrounding rock is 1.5, when the dynamic load coefficient and the lateral pressure coefficient are 3 and 1.2 respectively, the bearing structure of the roadway is shown in
Figure 11a. At this time, the thickness of surrounding rock broken zone at the roadway side is 0.48 m, the thickness of plastic zone is 5.51 m, the inner radius of the external bearing structure is 0.78 m from the roadway, the external radius is 7.33 m, and the thickness of external bearing structure is 6.55 m.
Based on the analysis in
Section 3.2, for the roadway under creep and dynamic load, the anchor cable support and grouting reinforcement can effectively reduce the distance to the roadway and thickness of the external bearing structure at the roof and side, and control the surrounding rock deformation of corresponding positions. The floor pressure relief has an obvious effect in controlling the floor heave. According to the deformation characteristics and key influencing factors of surrounding rock in different areas of the main inclined shaft, the following reinforcement measures and supporting parameters are proposed (
Figure 11b):
In the upper- and middle-part areas of the roadway, the anchor cable is used to control the roof subsidence. The anchor cable needs to be anchored in the elastic zone to prevent the external bearing structure from moving outward. The length of the anchor cable should not be less than 5.99 m.
Implement deep-shallow composite grouting in the surrounding rock fragmentation area of the roadway to improve the bearing capacity of the internal and external bearing structures. When the exposed length of grouting bolt is 0.35 m, the length of the shallow grouting bolt is not less than 0.83 m. The length of the deep grouting bolt is not less than 2.13 m if the deep grouting range is calculated based on 1 m depth of the external bearing structure.
The floor pressure relief in the upper and lower areas of the roadway can release the broken deformation energy and reduce the floor heave in a controlled manner.
4.3. Zone Reinforcement Support Scheme and Field Application
4.3.1. Zone Reinforcement Support Scheme
According to the analysis of reinforcement countermeasures, the main inclined shaft division reinforcement support scheme of “cable fix to shed, floor pressure relief, deep-shallow composite grouting” is proposed. The support parameters are determined according to the analysis of internal and external bearing structures. The specific scheme is shown in
Figure 12.
“Cable fix to shed” is the use of a U-shaped steel structure to fix the anchor cable and the steel shed together. Shed is equivalent to the anchor cable tray. The tension of the anchor cable is evenly transmitted to the rock mass anchored by increasing the rigidity and resistance of the tray. The cable adopts the bird-nest anchor cable, the specification is Φ 19.8 mm × L 6500 mm, the column spacing is 1000 mm, and the anchor cable tray uses 36 U-shaped steel fixtures.
“Deep-shallow composite grouting” means that whole shallow grouting section is first implemented, deep hole grouting reinforcement is applied subsequently after the shallow surrounding rock is effectively reinforced. Shallow grouting bolt specification is Φ 26 mm × L 1500 mm, deep grouting bolt is Φ 26 mm × L 2500 mm, and the row and column spacing is 1500 mm × 2000 mm.
4.3.2. Field Application
Construction is carried out according to the reinforcement support scheme, and the “cross measurement method” is used to monitor the displacement of the surface surrounding rock of the main inclined shaft for six months. In the first 60 days, anchor fix shed reinforcement and initial shotcrete were carried out. At the same time, pressure relief slots were excavated, and roadway floor cutting was carried out to ensure the roadway section shape; 60–90 days grouting bolts were installed, and shallow grouting was carried out; 90–120 days deep grouting and secondary shotcrete were implemented.
After construction, the shape of the roadway section is complete, the shed does not have obvious deformation (
Figure 13a), and the displacement change curve of the roadway surface is shown in
Figure 13b.
Figure 13 shows that due to the fixing cable and shed and enlargement in the first 60 days, the deformation of the rock surrounding the roadway fluctuates greatly. From 60 days, the deformation of the surrounding rock tends to be stable due to the reinforcement of “cable fix to shed, floor pressure relief”. The roof-to-floor convergence is 277 mm and the two-sided displacement is 135 mm. The control effect of the surrounding rock is good.
5. Conclusions
In view of the characteristics of high ground pressure, strong disturbance, and plastic softening of rock mass in deep roadways, this work studies the bearing mechanism and control technology of surrounding rock from the internal and external bearing structure of rock that surrounds roadways. The main conclusions are as follows:
(1) The distribution characteristics of the surrounding rock internal and external bearing structure for deep roadway under dynamic non-uniform stress field and its influencing factors were analyzed in theory. The stress distribution mechanical model of the rock surrounding the roadway was established. The calculation result shows that it can control the development of the broken zone and plastic zone of the rock surrounding the roadway, make the external bearing structure close to the roadway and reduce the thickness of the bearing structure through increasing the supporting strength of the internal bearing structure, cohesion, and internal friction angle of the surrounding rock and reducing the influence of mining. That can improve the bearing capacity of the shallow surrounding rock in the roadway and make the roadway easy to maintain.
(2) The deformation characteristics and control mechanism of surrounding rock in deep dynamic soft rock roadway were numerical simulated. Under the condition of dynamic load and creep, the deformation of rock surrounding the roadway is significantly higher than that without creep and under static load. The external bearing structure is far away from the roadway, the thickness of the bearing structure is increased, and the distance to the roadway and thickness of the external bearing structure are increased by 2.07 and 1.94 times, respectively. For the deep soft rock surrounding the roadway under dynamic load, anchor cable support and floor pressure relief have better control effects on the roof-side deformation and the floor heave respectively, and the thickness of the external bearing structure is reduced by 30.84% and 41.50% respectively. When the surrounding rock is prone to creep or fracture, grouting reinforcement can reduce the thickness of the external bearing structure by 41.93%, and it has a better control effect on the surrounding rock.
(3) In combination with field practice, the length of the anchor cable and the scope of surrounding rock grouting reinforcement are defined based on the distribution characteristics of the surrounding rock-bearing structure. The length of the anchor cable should not be less than 5.99 m, the lengths of shallow grouting bolt and deep grouting bolt should not be less than 0.83 m and 2.13 m, respectively. The zonal reinforcement scheme of the “cable fix to shed, floor pressure relief, deep-shallow composite grouting” is put forward and applied, which gave good results.