We will describe our results in four subsections. The descriptive statistics are introduced in the first sub-section. Next, we present respondents’ personal experiences and attitudes towards environmental public participation. In the third subsection, information transparency, sources, and public trust are showed. Finally, e-participation, ICT roles and ranking in Beijing 2022 environmental public participation are described.
4.2. Personal Experiences and Attitudes towards Public Participation
Beijing 2022 needs public support and participation. The degree of people’s participation in the preparation process and activities is an important factor influencing the support of them. If people feel left out of an event and are presented with projects as faits accomplis that cannot be altered, support is likely to be dampened [
18]. After all, it is the residents who will have to live with the results of the decisions. However, only 7.2% of respondents participated in the activities of the 2022 Winter Olympics in our survey. The mean and standard deviation of the respondents’ participation action were 1.93 and 0.258. Mann–Whitney U test showed that there was no significant difference of the participation between male and female participants. Kruskal–Wallis ANOVA analysis indicated that the respondents’ demographic characteristics such as age and place of residence had no significant correlation with the respondents’ participation in Beijing 2022. There were significant differences between the respondents’ participation and their education level (
p = 0.029 < 0.05), profession (
p = 0.026 < 0.05), and annual household income (
p = 0.016 < 0.05). In terms of the sample–sample comparison, there was significant difference of the participation between respondents with annual household income of more than 150 thousand RMB and the other three groups with annual household income 10–50, 60–100, and 110–150 thousand RMB (
p = 0.000 < 0.05). As for the activities of participation, 59 respondents were directly involved in 13 activities in the past two years. Of them, 24.7% were involved in visiting the venues for the Winter Olympic Games, followed by a questionnaire survey on environmental impact assessment of the venue project (12.4%) and public hearing of the Winter Olympics bidding report and venue planning (12.4%). The least mentioned activity was a symposium and expert seminar on Winter Olympics Bidding and stadium construction (1.1%). The Beijing Organizing Committee for the 2022 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games created in December 2015 is a public institution responsible for the organization and coordination of all the preparations and delivery of the 2022 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games. Seventy-three respondents engaged in the Emblem of Olympic Winter Games Beijing 2022 Design Competition hosted by the Beijing Organizing Committee in 2017. Thirty-seven people took part in the Online Photos and Text Collection of Ice & Snow Season in 2016. Another 23 residents were involved in the Beijing 2022 Global Staff Recruitment in 2017.
The respondents’ support for Beijing 2022 was measured by a five-point Likert scale from “strongly oppose” to “strongly support”. 74.8% and 11.9% respondents indicated that they would “support” and “strongly support” Beijing 2022, respectively. Over 10.4% of respondents hold the neutral attitude. The respondents with “strongly oppose” and “oppose” attitudes were only 0.2% and 2.8%. A five-point Likert scale was also used to measure agreement of the host residents’ participation in the decision-making and its implementation of Beijing 2022. The respondents with “strongly disagreed” and “strongly agreed” attitudes accounted for 1.3% and 3.3%, respectively. Over half of respondents (52.6%) agreed to public participation in Beijing 2022, while 7.2% of respondents disagreed with it. Meanwhile, 35.7% of respondents were neutral. The mean and standard deviation of the respondents’ agreement levels among the different groups of the social and demographic variables are presented in
Table 3. The results showed that males had a higher agreement level than females. In general, the older respondents agreed more than the younger ones, especially for the residents aged 51–60 with the highest mean being 3.65. Respondents with the higher education level had lower levels of agreement, e.g., the mean was the lowest, 2.67, for respondents with master degrees. Similarly, respondents with the higher level of income had a lower level of agreement. Farmers and residents who lived in the rural area agreed more than other groups with public participation in the decision-making process and its implementation for Beijing 2022.
Mann–Whitney U test showed that agreement degree of the respondents was not significantly related to their sex. Kruskal–Wallis ANOVA analysis indicated that agreement of the host residents was not significantly related to the respondents’ annual household income. One-way ANOVA analysis showed that agreement of the host residents was significantly related to the respondents’ education level (p = 0.017 < 0.05), profession (p = 0.002 < 0.05), and place of residence (p = 0.009 < 0.05). Regarding the education level, there were significant differences of the agreement degree between master and primary school (p = 0.035 < 0.05); between middle school and college/university (p = 0.009 < 0.05), master degree (p = 0.026 < 0.05), high school (p = 0.035 < 0.05). In terms of profession of the respondents, there were significant differences of the agreement degree between farmer and government staff (p = 0.002 < 0.05), corporate employee (p = 0.034 < 0.05), self-entrepreneur (p = 0.000 < 0.05), student (p = 0.047 < 0.05), media and NGOs staff (p = 0.000 < 0.05); between government staff and media/NGOs staff (p = 0.012 < 0.05); between corporate employee and media and NGOs staff (p = 0.001 < 0.05); between teacher/researcher and media/NGOs staff (p = 0.035 < 0.05); between self-entrepreneur and media/NGOs staff (p = 0.007 < 0.05); between student and media/NGOs staff (p = 0.002 < 0.05); between retiree and media/NGOs staff (p = 0.001 < 0.05); between media/NGOs staff and no job (p = 0.002 < 0.05). Considering the living place, there was significant difference of the agreement degree between respondents from city and rural areas (p = 0.002 < 0.05).
Regarding the opinion on function of the environmental cooperation between the government and the public during the Beijing 2022 Winter Olympics, the residents had different views. Nearly 28.5% of respondents considered that the first role was helping the government to understand the public’s needs, followed by providing the public with needed environmental services (18.9% of respondents) and promoting cooperation with the relevant stakeholders (16.1%). The fourth and fifth functions were increasing interaction between government and public (15.5%) and promoting cross-sectoral environmental cooperation (12.5%). The last role was reducing the administrative costs (8.0%).
The respondents were asked to select the basic principle of environmental public participation related to the Beijing 2022 Winter Olympics. Eight principles were mentioned. The justice and fairness principle was considered the top principle by 24.5% of the respondents, followed by open and transparent principle (18.2%), voluntary principle (14.9%), principle of participation by law (12.5%), and inclusiveness principle (8.8%). The last three principles included representativeness principle (8.3%), convenience and accessibility principle (8.2%), and the principle of effectiveness and efficiency (4.5%).
In terms of the best stage for public participation in the venue construction project, over one-fifth of respondents (21.5%) selected public participation in the whole cycle. The planning and pre-construction preparation stage was the second option for 17.6% of the respondents, followed by the construction phase (17.3%) and the feasibility investigation stage (14.2%). The project proposal stage (10.1%), project completion and check stage (7.5%), and survey and design stage (7.0%) were considered the least important stages. The smallest number of people (4.9%) selected the assessment and evaluation stage.
Some scholars have noted how different participatory mechanisms constitute and produce the “public” they seek input from [
71]. For example, stakeholder consultations construct a “partisan public”, citizen juries construct a “pure public”, and consultative panels construct an “affected public.” Which indicator was used to indicate a good mechanism for public participation perceived by the residents? Openness of the participation process was thought as the first indicator by most respondents (21.3%). Legitimacy, that is the legalization and institutionalization of public participation, was perceived as the second indicator of good mechanism by 19.3% of the respondents. The next three factors were diversification of participants (17.1%), convenience of participation (16.9%), and issue diversity (14.8%), respectively. The last one had the maximum effectiveness and cost–benefit balance (10.6%).
For the factors influencing public participation, respondents could select at most three out of ten options (
Figure 3). The first option for the respondents (42.4%) was benefits to individual and family. The last two options were awareness of the right to know and participation power (12.5%) and influence of friends and relatives (15.6%). The other factors had similar rates from 25.9% to 36.6%, for example, legitimacy of participatory process and participation cost. Studies suggest that when it comes to hosting a mega-event, host community residents tend to place more importance on the positive social impacts such as community pride and international recognition than on the positive economic impacts an event can generate [
72].
To ensure public participation in the environmental decision making and management of the 2022 Winter Olympic Games, some institutional systems are necessary (
Table 4). The most important system perceived by the respondents was the citizen supervision and reporting system (31.6%). The next one was environmental right-to-know system (17.1%). Social trust mechanism was considered the third safeguard system by 12.4%. The people who selected these three systems accounted for over 60% of the respondents. The environmental litigation system was the least important system by only 2.3% of the respondents.
4.3. Information Transparency and Public Trust
Opening data can be an essential measure to increase transparency and accountability, promote participation, and stimulate innovation in institutions. General knowledge of the Chinese people regarding Beijing 2022 proved high. Most of our respondents (>84%) have been seeing, reading, or hearing something about the Beijing 2022 bid in the past three years, which was widely reported in Chinese media. Beijing 2022 is a mega-event after the 2008 Beijing Summer Olympics in China. The respondents were aware of Beijing 2022, but did not know the details of the decision-making process. More than 70% of the respondents did not know the decision-making process of joint bidding and hosting of Beijing 2022. Only 1.5% of the respondents perceived they fully knew the process.
Transparency of information has a growing potential. The issue that many governments and companies are tackling today is not whether to open their data, but how to do so. The organizers of Beijing 2022 are striving to provide stakeholders with the necessary information about the Games’ preparations. For this purpose, the official website, official Wechat, and microblog have been held. Over a quarter of the respondents (26.9%) knew the BWOOC website (
https://www.beijing2022.cn/), while only 19.7% of respondents had browsed and accessed the website in last two years. In total 21.3% of respondents followed the official Wechat and microblog accounts of the BWOOC. Sixty-four (10.45%) respondents had also accessed the IOC’s website (
https://www.olympic.org/).
Data accessibility, reliability, accuracy and usability, data literacy, and trust in the data that governments share are also prerequisites for data usage. For environmental information on the 2022 Beijing Olympic Games,
Figure 4 showed that the respondents relied especially on TV (27.6%), the internet (19.9%), friends, neighbors, and relatives (11.4%), and WeChat public account and moments (10.1%). These four sources accounted for over 69.0% of the responses. The three least used information sources were the construction companies (0.3%), international organizations (0.4%), and personal videos and documentaries (0.7%). Other relevant information providers were radio, newspapers, the local and national government, etc. Such results are a little different in our previous study on high-speed railway, the first information source is “relatives and friends” (37%); but there is a similar finding with a study on nuclear power plants [
23], e.g., TV (61%) and the internet (13%) are main information sources. The Mann–Whitney U test showed that there was no significant difference of the information sources between male and female. Kruskal–Wallis ANOVA analysis showed that respondents’ information sources of Beijing 2022 were significantly related to their age (
p = 0.038 < 0.05), education level (
p = 0.025 < 0.05), and profession (
p = 0.046 < 0.05), but not significantly related to their annual household income and place of residence. In terms of the comparison of sample to sample, there were significant differences between the respondents over 60 years old and 18–30-year-olds (
p = 0.019 < 0.05), 31–40-year-olds (
p = 0.026 < 0.05). There were significant differences between the respondents with master degrees and primary school degree (
p = 0.011 < 0.05), middle school degree (
p = 0.014 < 0.05). There were significant differences between the farmers and governmental staff (
p = 0.009 < 0.05), teacher and researcher (
p = 0.013 < 0.05).
In fact, access to data alone is not enough to enable civic participation. Citizens need a belief in the quality of the information, trust in government responsiveness, and prior experiences often leave citizens skeptical about their ability to create change even when equipped with data. As showed in
Figure 4, TV is considered as the most trustworthy source of information (34.2%), followed by the national government (19.9%), and the Internet (18.7%). Very few considered the construction company (0.6%), the neighborhood committee (0.8%), and the environmental NGO (0.8%) as a trustworthy information source. This is quite different, and it contrasts similar studies on nuclear power plant and high-speed railway that the national government was the trustworthy information source [
23]. Mann–Whitney U test showed that there was no significant difference of the trusted sources between male and female. Kruskal–Wallis ANOVA analysis indicated that the trustworthy source was not significantly related to the respondents’ profession and place of residence. There were significant relationships between the trustworthy source and the respondents’ age (
p = 0.019 < 0.05), education level (
p = 0.033 < 0.05), and annual household income (
p = 0.009 < 0.05). Regarding the comparison of sample to sample, there was significant difference between the respondents with annual household income 10–50 and 60–100 thousand RMB (
p = 0.025 < 0.05).
Trust is a desirable Chinese traditional cultural value. Compared with Western societies such as the United States, Chinese societies are low-trust societies, though there is high level of trust in the government [
73]. Furthermore, there is also a consistent lack of institutional constraints in China. We asked the residents about their most trustworthy facet of environmental protection and management for Beijing 2022 Winter Olympics. The coverage and efficiency of the provided environmental services was considered as the most trustworthy one by 35.1% of the respondents. About one-fourth of the respondents (24.7%) believed the great efforts in environmental protection of governments. The next two included improvement of environmental decision-making procedure (16.6%) and environmental information disclosure (13.9%). Environmental professional competitiveness was ranked the last by 9.7% of respondents.
Effective communication could avoid (environmental) conflicts between different stakeholders. Beijing 2022 provides a unique communication platform that is not only recognized by sponsors but also by host cities’ residents. However, only 8.6% and 6.2% of respondents considered communication between the government and public, and between construction companies of venues and public as sufficient, respectively. Over 30% of the respondents considered any communication with governmental agencies and companies as “useless”. Almost 90% respondents experienced no communication between the key stakeholders for Beijing 2022.
4.4. Public Opinions on E-Participation, ICTs Roles and Ranking in Beijing 2022 Environmental Public Participation
Using ICTs, e-participation is a tool that promotes the inclusion of the public in participative and deliberative decision-making processes, thus contributing to a transformation of the interaction between government and citizens in environmental governance and sustainable development [
11]. Only 7.7% of respondents knew or had heard about the environmental e-participation concept in the past three years. According to the United Nations E-Government Survey 2016 [
42], China is ranked 22nd on the e-participation index, which has moved to the Top 25 performers from the Top 50 performers in the last two years. Mann–Whitney U test showed that there was no significant difference of the public knowledge of environmental e-participation between males and females. Kruskal–Wallis ANOVA analysis indicated that respondents’ knowledge of the environmental e-participation concept was not significantly related to their social and demographic characteristics. Based on China’s Internet Network Information Center (CNNIC) data (2019) [
74], the national internet users are 829 million, which accounts for 59.6% of the Chinese population at the end of 2018. The internet users are mainly younger people between 10–39 years old (67.8%) and 40–49 years old (15.6%). Utilization rate of WeChat Moments, Qzone (which was developed by a Chinese Tencent Company in 2005; its function is similar to blog), and Microblog was 83.4%, 58.8%, and 42.3% of the Chinese population at the end of 2018, respectively. In our survey, 77.4% of respondents had used the internet in last year, which is higher than the national average level. More than 80% and nearly 78% of respondents had smartphones and computers/laptops. The public reached out to the government, academia, and society through multiple channels such as WeChat groups/Moments/the official account (70% of respondents used), QQ (an instant messaging service similar to MSN in China, 37.6%), Microblog/blog (23.8%), and video websites (20.8%) in the past two years. Less than ten percent of respondents had used the internet bulletin board system (BBS) and personal log/website.
Information generation, processing, transmission, and use become fundamental (re)sources of power and transformation in environmental governance, in which ICTs gain transformative powers. Nearly 83% of respondents thought that, compared with the 2008 Beijing Summer Olympic Games, more and more people were participating in the dissemination of environmental information about the 2022 Winter Olympic Games through the Internet. Looking at ICTs as tools for dealing with environmental issues from a developing and emerging country perspective, the International Telecommunication Union (2008) noted six application categories: environmental observation, environmental analysis, environmental planning, environmental management and protection, impact and mitigating effects of ICT utilization, and environmental capacity building [
75]. Here we are mainly concerned with the environmental management and environmental capacity building aspects. The respondents were invited to give their opinions on the roles of ICTs in the environmental management and sustainability of Beijing 2022. A five-point Likert scale from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree) was applied into 19 aspects (
Figure 5). Total 26.5%, 26.2%, and 26.1% of respondents gave a “strongly agree” rating on reducing government investment and cost in environmental protection, expanding communication channels between government and public, and providing a space for public, governments, companies, and NGOs to communicate, respectively. Providing the environmental information to the public at anytime and anywhere, promoting more transparent use of environmental information, providing a space for public, governments, companies, and NGOs to communicate got an “agree” rating by 61.1%, 56.7%, and 56.6% of respondents. In general, over 70% of respondents had positive attitudes towards all items in the survey. Only less than 1.0% and 4.9% of respondents strongly disagreed or disagreed with the aspects of the ICTs in Beijing 2022. Other residents held a neutral stance.
Meanwhile, most respondents (80%) recognized that the national policy would have a major influence on the public participation in the environmental management of Beijing 2022. In addition, more than 85% of respondents were optimistic about the role of ICTs in promoting environmental public participation in 2022 Winter Olympics. Mann–Whitney U test showed that there was no significant difference of the optimistic attitude towards the role of ICTs between males and females. One-way ANOVA analysis showed that there was not a significant difference for the optimistic attitudes of ICTs roles by the respondents regarding their age, annual household income, and place of residence. Kruskal–Wallis ANOVA analysis indicated that the optimistic attitudes of ICT roles by the respondents was not significantly related to the respondents’ education level and profession.
Communication is a fundamental human activity. The advancement of ICTs has helped to advance the ways in which we communicate with each other. In view of the aspects of ICTs in promoting communication among government, enterprises, and the public, nearly 25% of respondents considered “increasing communication channels” as the most important aspect, followed by “increasing possibility of policy recommendations from the public” (17.7%), “using the required information at any time” (15.2%), “increasing the possibility of contacting the public” (8.2%), and “speeding up the possibility of contact” (8.2%).
ICTs have a wide application in different levels of environmental public participation. According to our survey on Beijing 2022, ICTs can play the greatest role in national-level actions (42.5%), followed by organization/social group level activities (18.2%), regional action (13.4%), community-level activities (12.9%), individual actions (7.7%), and international-level actions (5%).
We asked the respondents to rank the role of different ICTs in the environmental public participation in Beijing 2022. Ten ICTs were listed here including newspapers, letters, and magazines, which are broadly communication technologies (
Table 5). If the role of one ICT was ranked first, it would get 10 points. The tenth role of an ICT would get 1 point. The ranking of each role is calculated by total points (multiplying the number of respondents by role points of ICT). The average score of each ICT equals the total score over total respondents of the survey (614). The results showed that the ranking score of ICT roles ranged from 9 to 1710. Based on total score and average score, the order of different ICT roles is the TV > smart phone > the internet > radio > video > newspaper > community bulletin > magazine > fax/landline phone > letter. Television got the highest score with 4693 and an average of 7.64. However, 171 respondents (27.9%), 152 respondents (24.8%), and 148 respondents (24.1%) considered the internet, TV, and smart phone to come first, respectively. Smart phone was most commonly selected to rank second by 21.3% of the respondents, followed by TV. Generally, letter got the lowest score with 1988 and 3.24.
The respondents also ranked eight current specific functions of ICTs in environmental public participation in Beijing 2022 (
Table 6). If one function was ranked first, it would get 8 points. The eighth function would get 1 point. Total points equaled to multiplying the number of respondents by points of function. The average score is calculated by total points over total respondents of the survey (n = 614). The total score changed from 2288 to 3233, and the average score was from 3.74 to 5.27. The most important function of ICTs was real-time access to information on environmental issues and sustainability of Beijing 2022. About 24% of respondents put it as the No.1 role. The order of different functions is as follows: real-time access to information > release and present opinion freely > communicate and reveal ideas > participate in the decision-making > involve online vote and survey > organize the collective actions > engage in the consultation. The least important function was “engage in the consultation.” The average score was only 3.74. Only 7.3% of respondents put it as the No.1 role.
No doubt, ICTs greatly influence the involved stakeholders, the process of public participation, and society. These effects were presented in different aspects, as our study showed (
Figure 6). To promote transparency of the governmental decision-making was perceived as the most important impact by 17.3% of respondents. The next one was increasing the level of public participation and influence on decision-making (16.3%). The third one was helping society to form the atmosphere of environmental protection (11.9%). The least influence was reducing cost of organizational action and improving efficiency (6.0%).