Quality Evaluation of Multi-Source Cropland Data in Alpine Agricultural Areas of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau

Accurate cropland distribution data are essential for efficiently planning production layouts, optimizing farmland use, and improving crop planting efficiency and yield. Although reliable cropland data are crucial for supporting modern regional agricultural monitoring and management, cropland data extracted directly from existing global land use/cover products present uncertainties in local regions. This study evaluated the area consistency, spatial pattern overlap, and positional accuracy of cropland distribution data from six high-resolution land use/cover products from approximately 2020 in the alpine agricultural regions of the Hehuang Valley and middle basin of the Yarlung Zangbo River (YZR) and its tributaries (Lhasa and Nianchu Rivers) area on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau. The results indicated that (1) in terms of area consistency analysis, European Space Agency (ESA) WorldCover cropland distribution data exhibited the best performance among the 10 m resolution products, while GlobeLand30 cropland distribution data performed the best among the 30 m resolution products, despite a significant overestimation of the cropland area. (2) In terms of spatial pattern overlap analysis, AI Earth 10-Meter Land Cover Classification Dataset (AIEC) cropland distribution data performed the best among the 10 m resolution products, followed closely by ESA WorldCover, while the China Land Cover Dataset (CLCD) performed the best for the Hehuang Valley and GlobeLand30 performed the best for the YZR area among the 30 m resolution products. (3) In terms of positional accuracy analysis, the ESA WorldCover cropland distribution data performed the best among the 10 m resolution products, while GlobeLand30 data performed the best among the 30 m resolution products. Considering the area consistency, spatial pattern overlap, and positional accuracy, GlobeLand30 and ESA WorldCover cropland distribution data performed best at 30 m and 10 m resolutions, respectively. These findings provide a valuable reference for selecting cropland products and can promote refined cropland mapping of the Hehuang Valley and YZR area.