1. Introduction
Covalent organic frameworks (COFs), discovered in 2005 [
1], are very interesting crystalline organic porous materials exhibiting very important surface properties concerning their large specific surface area and porosity [
2]. Many research projects on COFs and their synthesis were developed, due to their suitability to be used as excellent materials in various applications such as catalysis [
3,
4,
5,
6,
7], rechargeable batteries [
8,
9,
10], separation processes [
11], light-emitting materials [
12], biomedicine, biosensors and bioelectronics [
13,
14].
Some promising covalent organic frameworks, such as 2D COFs composed of layered 2D polymers, exhibited excellent thermal conductivity [
15] and heterogeneous catalytic activity [
16]. Two-dimensional imine-based covalent organic frameworks, such as single-crystalline (SC) and polycrystalline TAPPy-TPA-COF (PC) (
Figure 1) synthetized from 4,4′,4″,4‴-(pyrene-1,3,6,8-tetrayl) tetraaniline (TAPPy) and terephthalaldehyde (TPA), were recently studied by several authors [
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22]. The physicochemical properties of 2D COFs were studied by inverse gas chromatography at infinite dilution by Natraj et al. [
18] and Yusuf et al. [
19].
This paper is devoted to determining the London dispersive, polar free energy, Lewis acid
and Lewis base
components of polar surface energy
of 2D single-crystalline and polycrystalline covalent organic frameworks such as TAPPy-TPA-COFs. The used technique was inverse gas chromatography (IGC) at infinite dilution [
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40] based on the experimental determination of the net retention time
and volume
of several organic molecules adsorbed on the solid materials. The fundamental thermodynamic equation of IGC allowed for the calculation of the free energy of adsorption
of any organic solvents on a solid surface, given in infinite dilution by Equation (1):
where
T is the absolute temperature of the chromatographic column containing the solid material,
R the perfect gas constant,
m the mass of the solid material of a specific surface area
s, and
and
are two reference characteristics referred to as the two-dimensional state and atmospheric pressure, respectively.
In the case of non-polar solvents such as n-alkanes, the only free energy of adsorption is that of the London dispersion component
given by the following:
For polar organic molecules, the specific free energy
of adsorption has to be added following Equation (3):
Many methods and models have been proposed in the literature [
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33] to determine the
of polar solvents adsorbed on solid materials and the London dispersive surface energy
of the studied materials. These chromatographic methods used the linearity of
or
of n-alkanes (from n-pentane to n-decane) adsorbed on a solid surface as a function of a chosen thermodynamic parameter at different temperatures. The separation between the dispersive and specific free energy of adsorption was based on the use of polar organic molecules such as dichloromethane, chloroform, tetrachloromethane, benzene, acetone, toluene, ethyl acetate, diethyl ether, etc. The boiling point
of organic solvents [
30] was first used to study the surface properties of solid materials. Next, a method based on the vapor pressure
of the solvents was proposed [
23,
24,
25] to separate the dispersive and specific components of the free surface energy. This most popular method was then followed by another one that used the dispersive component
of the surface energy of the probes [
26]. Later, the deformation polarizability
[
27] was introduced to solve the same problem consisting in the determination of the specific energy of adsorption. Next, the standard enthalpy of vaporization
[
31] was proposed. The topological index
[
28,
29] was then used to evaluate the specific interactions between solids and organic molecules.
The values of
and
obtained by the various chromatographic methods are very different and strongly depend on the molecular model and IGC method used. In previous papers, it was shown that the surface area of organic molecules not only depends on the chosen surface areas of molecules but also on the temperature [
32,
33,
34,
35,
36], and this certainly affects the different surface thermodynamic parameters. On the other hand, the proposed expressions of the surface areas of organic molecules leading to the correction of
of solids cannot be always transferred to any other solid.
In a recent paper [
41], a new method based on the London dispersion expression [
42] was proposed by using a new thermodynamic parameter
dependent both on the deformation polarizability
of the probe and on the ionization energies of the solid
and the solvent
:
This new method constituted a correction of Donnet et al.’s method that used the concept of the deformation polarizability of molecules. The proposed method took into consideration all physicochemical parameters intervening in the London equation [
42] that were neglected in the approach of Donnet et al. [
27]. This method, based on the equation of the London dispersion interaction [
42], was used to better quantify the different Lewis acid–base contributions to the surface energy of single-crystalline and polycrystalline COFs as well as their polar surface energy. By using this new method, it was possible to obtain an accurate separation between the two dispersive and polar free energies of adsorption of polar solvents on the two COF surfaces.
2. IGC Method and Materials
The chromatographic measurements obtained in other studies [
18,
19] led to the free energy of adsorption
or
of adsorbed molecules on solid substrates as a function of temperature. The proposed method is that using the deformation polarizability
of the adsorbed molecule and the harmonic mean of the ionization energies, given by Relation (5):
where
is Avogadro’s number,
the permittivity of vacuum,
S denotes the solid particle and
X the solvent molecule separated by a distance
. By choosing
as a thermodynamic parameter and considering the adsorption of n-alkanes on the solid material, Equation (6) can be then written as follows:
where
is an interaction constant of the adsorbed molecule and
is given by Equation (7):
The variations in
as a function of
gave a straight line called the “n-alkanes straight line”. In the case of polar molecule
X, it was possible to deduce the specific or polar free energy of the interaction between the adsorbed molecule and the solid surface from Equation (8) at a temperature
T:
The determination of
versus the temperature led to the specific enthalpy
and entropy
of polar solvents and therefore to the Lewis acid–base constants
KA and
KD by using Equation (9):
where
AN and
DN are the electron donor and acceptor numbers of the polar molecule, respectively, calculated by Gutmann [
43] and corrected by Riddle and Fowkes [
44]. Several organic solvents were used in this study: n-alkanes including n-pentane, n-hexane, n-heptane and n-octane; polar probes including Lewis acid solvents such as dichloromethane, basic solvents such as ethyl acetate, diethyl ether and tetrahydrofuran and amphoteric solvents such as acetonitrile. The experimental conditions of the IGC technique were identical to those given in previously published papers [
32,
33,
34].
4. Conclusions
The London dispersive and polar surface thermodynamic parameters of single-crystalline and polycrystalline TAPPy-TPA-COFs were determined by the inverse gas chromatography technique (IGC) at infinite dilution. A new method for the separation of London dispersive and polar surface energies was proposed. A new intrinsic thermodynamic parameter was proposed which associates the deformation polarizability of molecules to the harmonic mean of the ionization energies of solid surface and organic molecules. The measurements of the net retention volume of the adsorbed solvents on COF surfaces and the use of the new parameter as a function of the temperature led to the polar interaction energy of the different polar molecules adsorbed on the COF surfaces. This led to the different components of acid–base surface energies of solid surfaces and their total surface energy that all depend on the temperature. The new results showed that the values of the total acid–base surface energies of polycrystalline COFs ranged between 11.50 and 7.50 mJ/m2 with a total surface energy equal to 105.3 mJ/m2 at 120 °C; in contrast, the acid–base surface energies corresponding to the single-crystalline COFs were lower than 4.6 mJ/m2 with a total surface energy equal to 70.8 mJ/m2 at the same temperature.
All polar surface parameters of the polycrystalline COF surface revealed higher values than those obtained with the single-crystalline surface. An excellent linearity of versus of polar molecules adsorbed on the two COF surfaces was obtained and allowed an accurate determination of Lewis acid–base constants. The acidity of the polycrystalline surface was proved to be 1.5 times higher than that of the single-crystalline surface.
This new method allowed for the determination of the dispersive and specific enthalpy and entropy of adsorption, in both cases of single-crystalline (SC) and polycrystalline (PC), and proved the following equation:
Two new characteristics of solid substrate and were proposed representing the interaction temperature and the free interaction energy of the solid, respectively. The values of temperatures and showed that the highest intrinsic temperature was obtained by the single-crystalline COF with a difference between the two temperatures equal to 67.4 K. These values are probably related to the melting point or decomposition temperature of materials. This result has to be confirmed with other solid surfaces in future studies.
The comparison between the results of this work and those obtained by the Donnet et al. method showed very large differences in the values of the specific or polar surface interactions. This deviation resulted from the fact that the Donnet method neglected the effect of the harmonic mean of the ionization energies on the different surface thermodynamic parameters.
These new results also allowed the determination of an average value of the separation distance between the COF surfaces and the organic molecules equal to for the crystalline COF and for the polycrystalline form. This promising method will be used in other future studies for more accurate determination of the polar surface energy and Lewis acid–base surface energies of solid surfaces such as oxides, polymers, fibers, etc.