4.2. Results and Discussion
- (1)
Effects of screw speed on evaluation index of PLA micro tubes.
The screw speed has significant effects on the melt volume flow rate, since the melt is extruded from extruder through screw rotation. When studying the influence of screw speed on the evaluation index, the rotational speed of the extruder ranges from 1 to 8 r/min, and the die temperature, pulling speed, gas flow rate and vacuum degree are 200 °C, 10 m/min, 22 g/min and 0 inH
2O, respectively. The relationship between the screw speed and the evaluation index is shown in
Figure 6. It can be seen that both outer diameter and wall thickness of the micro tubes increase nonlinearly, and the increase trend become gradually slower with the increase of screw speed. When the rotational speed is lower than 4 r/min, the extruder rotational speed has little influence on the wall thickness uniformity and ovality. With the continuous increase of the extruder rotational speed, wall thickness uniformity decreases slightly and ovality increases significantly.
Figure 7 shows the cross-section of micro tubes extruded at the screw speed of 1 r/min, 5 r/min and 8 r/min, respectively.
There are two main reasons for the increase of microtubule outer diameter and wall thickness. On one hand, the increase of the screw speed leads to the increase of the melt volume flow rate, then the shear rate increases. For a pseudoplastic fluid, extrusion swelling ratio usually increases with the increase of the shear rate before melt fracture in the extrusion process [
19]. Therefore, outer diameter and wall thickness increase with the increase of the screw speed. On the other hand, according to the continuity theorem:
where
and
are separately melt flow rate in the cavity and sectional area of the cavity.
V and
S are separately pulling speed and sectional area of final micro tubes. An increase in screw speed means an increase in
, while
and
V do not change, then
S increases, that is, the wall thickness increases. Since the inner wall of the micro tubes cannot move inward under the gas injection pressure, the outer diameter of the micro tubes also increases. With the increase of screw speed, the shear rate of the melt increases resulting in shear thinning, which makes the increase of the melt volume flow rate slow down. Therefore, the increase in micro tubes outer diameter and wall thickness becomes gradually slower. In order to verify this point of view, the capillary rheological experiments were carried out.
The volume flow rate of capillary die can be expressed as
where
is volume flow rate,
n is non-newton index,
is shear rate,
R is radius of capillary die.
Capillary die is radius R is 0.25 mm. According to rheological data at any temperature by rheological experiments, the volume flow rate can be obtained by extracting the n and at different compression rates and substituting them into the formula.
For example, when the melt temperature is 200 °C, rheological experimental data are extracted to obtain
n,
and calculated shear rates at different compression rates, as is shown in
Table 2. The relationship between shear rate and volume flow rate is shown in
Figure 8. It can be seen that the volume flow rate increases with the increase of shear rate, and the increasing trend gradually slows down, which verifies the correctness of the proposed viewpoint, a the viewpoint is consistent with the extrusion molding of PP micro tubes [
20].
It is assumed that the gap between the die and the mandrel is equal at the extrusion die forming section, and the melt flow is balanced so each point on any concentric circle of the cavity cross section has the same velocity field and stress field. In theory, the wall thickness uniformity and ellipticity of the micro tubes are not affected as long as the gap between the die and the mandrel in the forming section is equal. Therefore, the shape accuracy of the micro tube mainly depends on the processing accuracy and assembly accuracy of extrusion die. However, in the actual extrusion process, there must be a certain error between the die and mandrel in the processing and assembly, which results in a gap in the molding section is not exactly equal, and with it the rotational speed of the extruder, the shear rate of the melt, the expansion rate, the wall thickness uniform and ovality increase. However, it is not obvious when the screw speed is at a low level. In addition, due to the increase of the screw speed and volume flow rate, the cooling and solidification rate become slow, leading to deformation under the influence of gravity. As a result, the wall thickness uniformity decreases and the ovality increases.
- (2)
Effects of pulling speed on evaluation index of PLA micro tubes
Micro tubes, under the action of the upper and lower splints of the tractor, make the extruded melt move along the extrusion direction. The pulling speed ranges from 7 m/min to 12 m/min. The screw speed, die temperature, gas flow rate and vacuum degree are 2 r/min, 200 °C, 11 g/min and 0 inH
2O respectively. The relationships between pulling speed and evaluation index are shown in
Figure 9. It can be seen that both the outer diameter and the wall thickness of the micro tubes decrease nonlinearly with the increase of pulling speed. The decrease is significant at the beginning, and with the continuous increase of pulling speed, the decrease trend becomes slower gradually. Pulling speed has little effect on wall thickness uniformity and ovality.
Figure 10 shows the cross-section of micro tubes extruded at the pulling speed of 7 m/min, 12 m/min, respectively.
The reduction in the outer diameter and wall thickness of micro tubes can still be analyzed according to Equation (14). As the pulling speed V increases, while and do not change, the S inevitably decreases. That is, wall thickness decreases, which leads to an inward contraction of the outer wall, i.e., the outer diameter decreases. Die swell occurs when the melt leaves the die. Deformation caused by die swell is first straightened under the traction force. Therefore, the microtubule outer diameter and wall thickness decrease more obviously at low pulling speed. With the continuous increase of pulling speed, the deformation caused by die swell is gradually weakened, and even disappeared. So, the decrease becomes slow gradually.
The pulling speed mainly affects the tensile ratio of micro tubes, and has little effect on wall thickness uniformity and ovality. However, it is worth noting that the appropriate range of pulling speed should be selected, or the gap of tractor clamping should be adjusted at different pulling speeds when studying the influence of pulling speed on evaluation index. Otherwise, the experiment will fail. The reason is that the micro tubes are large and are easily compressed and deformed by the splint of the tractor at low pulling speed, resulting in an increase of ovality. On the contrary, when pulling speed is too high, the diameter of the micro tubes are too small, leading to the splint can not effectively hold the micro tubes.
- (3)
Effects of die temperature on evaluation index of PLA micro tubes
Die temperature mainly affects the viscosity of the melt. When studying the influence of die temperature on the evaluation index, the die temperature ranges from 190 °C to 220 °C. The screw speed, pulling speed, gas flow rate and vacuum were 2 r/min, 10 m/min, 8 g/min and 0 inH
2O, respectively. The relationships between the die temperature and the evaluation index are shown in
Figure 11. It can be seen that the outer diameter and wall thickness of PLA micro tubes are affected very little by die temperature. When the temperature is lower than 205 °C, the wall thickness uniformity and ovality almost do not change with the increase in temperature. When the die temperature is higher than 205 °C, the wall thickness uniformity decreases slightly, and the ovality increases slightly.
Figure 12 shows the cross section of micro tubes at the die temperatures of 190 °C, 205 °C and 220 °C, respectively.
The die temperature mainly affects the viscosity of the melt, however, it has little effect on volume flow rate. Therefore, the outer diameter and wall thickness are minimally affected by temperature. The point of this view can also be verified by rheological experiments.
The non-Newton index
n, corrected shear rate
in the rheological data of PLA at temperatures of 190 °C, 200 °C, 210 °C and 220 °C were extracted and substituted into Equation (14). The volume flow rates at different temperatures were obtained by calculation, as shown in
Figure 13. It can be seen that as the temperature increases, the melt volume flow rate hardly change. Therefore, the temperature has almost no effect on the outer diameter and wall thickness of micro tubes.
When the die temperature is high, the wall thickness uniformity decreases and the ovality increases slightly. The reason is that when the melt leaves the die, the cooling and solidification rate become slow, leading to deformation under the influence of gravity.
- (4)
Effects of gas flow rate on evaluation index of PLA micro tubes
During the extrusion, gas is injected into the interior of the micro tubes at a certain rate to prevent parison from sticking together for the deformation caused by gravity when the melt leaves the die. When studying the influence of gas flow rate on the evaluation index, the gas flow rate ranges from 5 to 50 g/min. The screw speed, die temperature, pulling speed and vacuum degree were 3 r/min, 200 °C, 8.5 m/min, 0 inH
2O, respectively. The relationships between gas flow rate and the evaluation index are shown in
Figure 14. It is worth noting that when gas flow rate is lower than 20 g/min, billet deformation is serious, so the wall thickness and outer diameter are not measured. It can be seen from
Figure 14 that with the increase of gas flow rate, microtubule outer diameter increases and microtubule wall thickness decreases, and both the changes are nonlinear, ahe rate of changes decreases gradually. The effect of gas flow rate on the wall thickness uniformity is small. The ovality decreases with the increase of the gas flow rate. The decrease is significant at the beginning and becomes stable when gas flow rate reaches a certain level.
Figure 15 shows the cross section of micro tubes at gas flow rates of 5 g/min, 20 g/min, 35 g/min and 50 g/min respectively.
The increase of the gas flow rate leads to a pressure increase of the parison inner wall, then the parison gradually expands outwardly under the pressure difference of inside and outside parison, meanwhile, the parison becomes thinner. Therefore, the outer diameter of the micro tubes increases and the wall thickness decreases. With the continuous increase of the outer diameter of the micro tubes, the degree of molecular orientation in the circumferential direction of the melt increases, and intermolecular force is enhanced. Therefore, the deformation caused by the gas pressure would be suppressed. As a result, the rate of changes of the outer diameter and wall thickness of the micro tubes gradually decreases with the increase of the gas flow rate.
The effect of gas flow rate on wall thickness uniformity and ovality is mainly reflected in the case of low gas flow rate. When the gas flow rate is at a low level, the gas pressure inside the parison is not sufficient to resist the deformation caused by gravity, which leads to a serious deformation of the micro tubes, therefore the effects of the gas flow rate on wall thickness uniformity and ovality are prominent. When gas flow rate increases to a certain degree, the internal pressure of the parison is sufficient to resist the deformation caused by gravity, then gas flow rate has little effect on wall thickness uniformity and ovality.
- (5)
Effects of vacuum degree on evaluation index of PLA micro tubes
Vacuum degree refers the pressure of the gas above the water surface in the cooling water tank. When studying the influence of vacuum degree on the evaluation index, the vacuum degree ranges from 0 to 45 inH
2O. The screw speed, die temperature, pulling speed and gas flow rate were 4 r/min, 200 °C, 9 m/min, 26 g/min, respectively.
Figure 16 shows the relationships between evaluation index and vacuum degree. It can be seen that with the increase of vacuum degree, the outer diameter, wall thickness and wall thickness uniformity almost do not change, and the ovality slightly decreases.
Figure 17 shows the cross section of micro tubes at vacuum levels of 0 inH
2O and 45 inH
2O, respectively.
The vacuum degree mainly affects the pressure in the cooling water. Due to the small size of the micro tubes, the force on the micro tubes is small, so the vacuum degree has little influence on the outer diameter, wall thickness and wall thickness uniformity. With the increase of vacuum degree, the ovality decreases slightly, which is because the micro tubes will have a certain deformation under the influence of buoyancy and water gravity in the cooling water. When the vacuum degree increases, a certain negative pressure will be formed on the cooling water, which will reduce the pressure in the cooling water, thus reducing the deformation of the microtubule products.
In summary, the screw speed, pulling speed and gas flow rate have significant effects on the microtubule outer diameter and wall thickness. The die temperature and the vacuum degree have almost no effects on the microtubule size. Therefore, the required outer diameter and wall thickness of PLA micro tubes can be obtained by coordinating the screw speed, pulling speed and the gas flow rate. The extrusion process parameters have little influence on wall thickness uniformity and ovality within a certain range, which mainly depends on the processing accuracy and assembly accuracy of the extrusion die. However, if the process parameters are too large or too small, wall thickness uniformity and ovality will also be greatly affected. For example, when the screw speed and die temperature are too high and the traction speed is too low, the parison is seriously deformed due to gravity, resulting in poor wall thickness uniformity and large ovality; even the extrusion will be interrupted due to the inability to pull the parison. If the gas flow rate is too small, the deformation caused by the insufficient pressure of the parison inner wall to support gravity will also lead to the reduction of the wall thickness uniformity and the increase of the ovality. If the gas flow rate is too large, the parison will be broken, and the extrusion will be interrupted. With the increase of vacuum degree, ovality decreases, but the variation range is very small. Therefore, in order to obtain better shape accuracy, the screw speed and die temperature should not be too high, the gas flow rate should be sufficient and properly increase the vacuum degree. Accordingly, a series of PLA micro tubes with high shape accuracy that meet the design requirements were processed by adjusting the process parameters.
Table 3 lists the specific size and shape accuracy of some representative micro tubes, and the cross-sections are shown in
Figure 18. Finally, a micro tube with an outer diameter of 2.50 mm and a wall thickness of 0.15 mm was processed into a vascular stent structure by laser engraving process. During the engraving process, the inability to cut or partially cut did not occur, and the engraved vascular stent is shown in
Figure 19.