1. Introduction
Viral diseases in cereals have gained importance during the last few decades. Several viruses belonging to different families have been found to infect wheat (
Triticum aestivum L.) at different levels, causing significant yield losses across the United States. They can be grossly distinguished in terms of being soil borne or insect transmitted. While the soil-borne
Polymyxa graminis transmits the wheat spindle streak mosaic virus (WSSMV) and soil-borne wheat mosaic virus (SBWMV), some other viruses such as barley and cereal yellow dwarf virus (B/CYDV) and wheat streak mosaic virus (WSMV) are transmitted by aphids and wheat curl mite, respectively. Two more viruses transmitted by mites have been identified as High Plains virus (HPV) [
1,
2] and Triticum mosaic virus (TriMV) [
3] to cause High Plains disease. The growing importance of detecting and controlling HPV and TriMV has led us to include these in the previously developed multiplex diagnostic test which detects the B/CYDVs, WSSMV, SBWMV, and WSMV [
4].
Identified as an unknown pathogen infecting corn in 1993 [
5,
6], HPV has been a growing concern in different states of the High Plains in the United States [
6]. High Plains disease has been characterized by the development of chlorotic spots evolving into stunting and eventually leading to the death of the plant. With environmental conditions playing a major role, several other factors such as host susceptibility, plant stage at the time of infection, and combinations of other infecting viruses contribute towards the intensity of the infection by this virus. Immunogold labeling experiments demonstrated thread-like particles from infected maize leaves under an electron microscope as a potential pathogen on the High Plains [
7]. On further analysis of the nucleic acid complement from infected leaf tissue, a putative viral coat protein of ~32 kDa associated with this virus was identified by SDS-PAGE [
8] and the sequence from the encoded protein was then submitted to the GenBank database (accession no. U60141) [
9]. Study of the variability in five different HPV isolates revealed an 18-amino acid sequence at the N-terminus of the 32 kDa nucleoprotein indicating that the current sequence in GenBank may be incomplete [
10] A disease survey on different infecting viruses in the state of Kansas has identified the cause of yield loss as “wheat streak complex”, with HPV being one of the major viruses, designated with a new name of wheat mosaic virus (WMoV) [
1]). For this publication, however, we will designate WMoV with its former name of High Plains virus (HPV).
Among several different families of viruses infecting wheat (
T. aestivum L.), wheat streak mosaic virus (WSMV) has always been economically important in the Great Plains and other parts of the United States. However, in the spring of 2006, temperature-sensitive WSMV-resistant wheat was infected with a virus identified as Triticum mosaic virus (TriMV) [
10]. Not geographically localized, the diseased wheat plants were found in different locations in Kansas and displayed similar symptoms caused by infection with WSMV and High Plains virus (HPV). Data from different purifications on sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis with cesium chloride density gradients, electron microscopy, and sequencing of the nucleotide and amino acid sequence were examined to identify TriMV as a new member of the genus
Potyviridae. Reported to be transmitted by the wheat curl mite
Aceria tosichella Keifer, just like WSMV, [
10], TriMV could be placed in the genus
Tritimovirus. However, it was found to be significantly divergent with only 23.2% similarity to the complete genome sequence of WSMV in contrast to 47–65% sequence identity to the available sequences of mature proteins of
sugarcane streak mosaic virus (SCSMV) strain AP [
10]. Complete nucleotide sequencing results of TriMV have reinforced this close relation to SCMV [
11]. However, with SCSMV not being a part of any genera of the family
Potyviridae [
12,
13] a new genus called
Susmovirus has been proposed for SCSMV [
11,
14] and TriMV has been suggested to be placed in the same. Other results showed an unusually long 5′ nontranslated region (NTR) with 739 nucleotides in TriMV suggesting a new genus
Poacevirus in the family of
Potyviridae.
Under current field conditions, it has become extremely important to determine the incidence of HPV and TriMV and the methods to control them. Regulations on these viruses require an effective detection method. ELISA and Western blot as reliable indexing methods have been developed to identify HPV in association with WSMV [
15]. The study included the common vector wheat curl mite and two detection methods of indirect protein A sandwich (PAS-ELISA) and Western blot were employed where the latter was found to be more sensitive in detecting the viruses and discriminating between WSMV and HPV in single and mixed infections. The partial sequence of the RNA3 from the GenBank database for HPV, however, helped in developing an RT-PCR method as a detection method to test seeds infected with HPV in New Zealand [
16] and was recommended for quarantine purposes in seeds. When identifying the wheat curl mite (
Aceria tosichella Keifer) acting as the vector for Triticum mosaic virus, a similar indirect ELISA method was conducted as a detection method [
3,
10]. Until recently, conventional methods such as ELISA were used as a diagnostic method to differentiate in between WSMV and TriMV in infected wheat samples. Extending this to real-time PCR, a new multiplex method has been developed which detects both these viruses in a single sample with a primer/probe combination using Taqman [
17]. To advance the study of detection of these viruses in a more ecological and epidemiological way, this study reports the first multiplex RT-PCR method to precisely diagnose TriMV and HPV in association with other wheat viruses in a wheat sample with multiple infections. The method described in this paper assigns specific primers to detect both single and mixed infections from TriMV and HPV, providing a feasible method to demonstrate as well as control the spread of these viruses.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Plant Materials
Wheat leaf tissue infected with TriMV was kindly sent by Dr. Jeff Ackerman from Kentucky State University. Mr. Jordan Eggers from state of Oregon, at Harmiston Agriculture Research and Extension Center, provided us with the nucleic acid samples containing High Plains virus. Healthy corn seeds and the ones infected with HPV were sent from Colorado State University and were planted and harvested at the two-leaf stage to be used as controls. Leaf tissue infected with different isolates of HPV was received from North Dakota and Ohio. B/CYDV isolates were provided by Dr. Stewart M. Gray, Ithaca, NY in the form of infected wheat tissue. Other control samples for WSSMV, SBWMV, and WSMV came from different parts of the country. Leaf tissue samples with mixed infections from different fields across the country were also received and processed to determine the efficiency of our detection system.
2.2. Plant RNA Extraction and Reverse Transcription
A TRIzol-based (Invitrogen Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA, USA) method was used to extract total plant RNA from infected leaf tissue. Leaf tissue was frozen in liquid nitrogen and ground in a DNase- and RNase-free mortar and pestle. RNA was extracted from approximately 250 mg of this frozen ground tissue using TRIzol, following the manufacturer’s protocol. The RNA pellet was re-suspended in 50 µL of diethyl pyrocarbonate-treated (Sigma-Aldrich Corp. St. Louis, MO, USA) water and quantified using an ND-1000 spectrophotometer (NanoDrop Technologies, Wilmington, DE, USA). The RT protocol was adapted from Bio-Rad (Hercules, CA, USA) using their iScript cDNA synthesis kit. Then, 2 µg of the total RNA was used to synthesize cDNA using random primers from this kit in a 20 µL reaction following the manufacturer’s protocol. The cDNAs were further diluted 10-fold with sterile distilled water for using them in the multiplex PCR reaction.
2.3. Design of Virus-Specific Primers
The most important aspect of a multiplex PCR reaction is the empirical choice of oligo primers and the utilization of hot start-based PCR methodology. To facilitate the automation, it is important to design primers with similar melting temperatures (Tm). To achieve uniform amplification of all ten viruses in a single reaction, it was necessary to make sure that the primers were compatible with each other, avoiding any kind of false positive and formation of primer dimers. Different isolates found in the NCBI database (
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/) (accessed on 9 December 2022). for both TriMV and HPV were aligned using ClustalW (
http://www.ebi.ac.uk/Tools/sequence.html) (accessed on 9 December 2022) separately. To maximize the ability of the primers to detect these viruses despite sequence variation, the primers were designed to target the most conserved coat protein region between the isolates for each virus.
Table 1 lists the primers used previously for B/CYDVs, WSSMV, SBWMV, and WSMV [
4] along with the TriMV and HPV. The primers were predicted to be free of any self-secondary structure, dimers, and hair-pin loops. No heteroduplexes were predicted after primer duplex analysis. The candidate primer pairs specific to these viruses were tested extensively against the other existent primer pairs in the multiplex in all different combinations for false positives. The forward primer from each primer pair for each virus was 5′ end-labeled with commercially available fluorescent dye FAM (MWG Biotech, High Point, NC, USA) for use in capillary electrophoresis.
2.4. Multiplex Polymerase Chain Reaction
Multiplex PCR is a demanding technique that requires various optimizations with the concentrations of the PCR reagents such as 10X polymerase buffer, MgCl2, dNTPs, and primers. Cycling conditions for the reaction were also optimized with the appropriate cycles, annealing temperature, and extension time to produce comparable yields from each set of primer pairs. Once the conditions were optimized for each virus, each PCR reaction included approximately 60 ng of cDNA, 2.2 mM MgCl2 (Promega, Madison, WI, USA), 3.0 mM of a dNTP mixture with each dNTP at 100 mM (Invitrogen Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA), 10× Polymerase Buffer (Promega, Madison, WI), and 0.11 U of hot-start Taq polymerase (Qiagen Inc., Valencia, CA, USA) and the primers. To multiplex for all ten viruses, 0.3 µM for each of the forward and reverse primer from each primer set was added as the final concentration in the PCR mix. The samples were amplified in a PTC-100 Peltier Thermal Cycler (Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA). For fast and efficient amplification for each virus set, a touchdown PCR was performed. Hot-start Taq polymerase was activated at 95 °C (10 min) followed by denaturation at 95 °C (30 s), annealing at 60 °C (30 s) with the annealing temperature decreasing by 1 °C in each successive step, and extension at 72 °C (60 s) up to the first 10 cycles. This was followed by 30 cycles of 95 °C (30 s), 55 °C (1 min), 72 °C (30 s), then final extension at 72 °C for 10 min.
2.5. Detection of Amplified Products
The PCR products amplified were analyzed by gel electrophoresis on a 2% metaphor-agarose gel in a ratio of 1:1 with normal agarose. Sodium boric acid electrophoresis buffer was used to cast and run the gel. The gel was stained with ethidium bromide to view the target product. The PCR products were visualized using UV light using a gel imaging system (GelDoc, UVP Inc., Upland, CA, USA). HyperLadder IV (BioLine, Taunton, MA, USA) was used as a molecular DNA marker on the agarose gel to determine the sizes of the amplified products.
2.6. Cloning and Sequencing
The multiplexed PCR products were cloned into the vector pCR TOPO-4 (Invitrogen Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA) for sequencing. Colony PCR helped to select the clones containing the different amplified inserts specific to each virus and were sent for sequencing to the Genomics Facility (Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA) to confirm their identity. The sequencing data were then verified with the nucleotide database by a BLAST search (
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/blast) (accessed on 9 December 2022).
2.7. Capillary Electrophoresis
Forward primers for each set of virus-specific primers were labeled at the 5′ end with 6-FAM (MWG Biotech, High Point, NC). The labeled forward and unlabeled reverse primers for the ten sets of primers were used for the multiplex reaction for the samples to be subjected to capillary electrophoresis. A 1 µL aliquot of a 50-fold diluted PCR product in deionized sterile water was then added to 9 µL of hi-diformamide (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA). The mixture also contained a 100-fold dilution of Genescan 500 LIZ size standard (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA). The LIZ standard acted as a fluorescent size standard to determine the size of the amplicons when run on a 3130xl Genetic Analyzer instrument (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA). The results were analyzed using the GeneMarker v1.5 software (SoftGenetics LLC, State College, PA, USA).
Mention of trade names or commercial products in this article is only for the purpose of providing specific information and does not imply recommendation or endorsement by the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
3. Results
Two new viruses, Triticum mosaic virus (TriMV) and High Plains virus (HPV), were successfully added for detection to the multiplex RT-PCR assay which already identified the five YDV strains, WSSMV, SBWMV, and WSMV. Individual PCR reactions for each of these viruses produced the expected single amplicon at a particular base pair with their respective primers (
Figure 1, Lanes 2–11). In the presence of all ten primer pairs, the cDNAs representing each virus except TriMV and HPV were pooled together and identified as the earlier published multiplex ladder with eight viruses [
4] (
Figure 1, Lane 13). However, upon adding the corresponding template for these two viruses, it identified TriMV and HPV at designated sizes in the existing multiplex RT-PCR amplifying all ten viruses in a single lane (
Figure 1, Lane 14).
Table 1 summarizes the product sizes for each of these ten viruses detected in the new multiplex RT-PCR including five strains of B/CYDVs (-PAV, -RPV, -MAV, -RMV, and -SGV), WSSMV, SBWMV, WSMV, TriMV, and HPV. The demanding nature of this multiplex PCR technique to amplify several products in a single reaction required extensive optimization to ensure noninterference from primer dimers and other nonspecific products. The first step in optimizing was to determine the set of cycling conditions that produced comparable yields from each specific primer pair. A touchdown PCR was designed in developing this protocol where, for a certain number of cycles, the annealing temperature decreases with each cycle and then stays steady for the rest of the PCR. The mechanism of touchdown was helpful in making sure each primer pair annealed to its specific target to avoid any nonspecific products and was further optimized in terms of annealing temperature and the number of cycles for simultaneous amplification (data not shown). Once the conditions were determined, multiplex PCR was attempted with a series of reactions that varied the different PCR components such as MgCl
2, dNTPs, primers, and hot-start DNA polymerase (data not shown). Optimizations substantially improved the PCR performance and were standardized for subsequent experiments.
Several field samples were collected from different parts of the country and were tested with the new multiplex PCR. The main target of the test was to try to detect the new viruses, Triticum mosaic virus and High Plains virus, added to the eight virus multiplex systems in naturally infected samples from the High Plains area. Series of samples were tested of which a subset is shown (
Figure 2). The amplified product at 560 bp was found in most of the isolates from Kansas (FS 1, Lane 2), Texas (FS 3, Lane 4), Oklahoma (FS 4 and 5, Lanes 5 and 6), and North Dakota (FS 7, Lane 8), identified as Triticum mosaic virus. Similarly, a 490 bp amplicon showed the presence of High Plains virus in FS 2 from North Dakota (Lane 3) and faintly in FS 4 (Lane 5) but brightly in FS 5 (Lane 6), both from Oklahoma. This multiplex RT-PCR also detected co-infecting viruses such as RPV (FS 3 and FS 6, Lanes 4 and 7), RMV (FS 1, 2, and 7, Lanes 2, 3, and 8), SGV in most lanes (Lane 1, 2 3, 4, 5, and 7), and other wheat viruses. Among all the field samples collected, FS 6 from Missouri showed the presence of other wheat viruses than the TriMV and HPV. No discernible difference between the sizes of each virus obtained from the naturally infected samples indicated the universal nature of the primers for each virus. To assess the specificity of the amplicons, all the amplifications from simplex as well as multiplex from the field samples were purified, cloned, and sequenced. Sequences of the amplified products showed 98–100% identity to the original sequences from NCBI.
To evaluate the robustness of the system, it was important to verify the specificity of the primer pairs. A similar “drop-out” experiment to a previous publication [
4] was performed where, in a series of multiplex RT-PCRs, each set of the primer pairs was absent at a time with all pooled virus samples to analyze the specificity of the primers. It was clearly noticed that the BYDV-PAV band in the gel was absent in the absence of its respective primers (
Figure 3, Lane 2) while the TriMV band at 560 bp had disappeared in the absence of its respective primers (
Figure 3, Lane 10). In a similar fashion, the band at 490 bp for HPV is not visible when the reaction does not have its specific primer pair (
Figure 3, Lane 11). In comparison to the amplification of all ten viruses in the control multiplex RT-PCR with all primer pairs (
Figure 3, Lane 14), the rest of the viruses were found to act similarly (
Figure 3, Lanes 2–11) in the drop-out experiment. This experiment was very successful in determining the specificity of each primer pair, ruling out the possibility of cross reaction to produce false positives.
Capillary electrophoresis was employed in this technique with the potential of being a high-throughput detection system. Individual PCRs for each of these viruses with the 5′-labeled forward primer were conducted using capillary electrophoresis (
Figure 4) followed by the multiplex reaction (data not shown) that detected all ten wheat viruses as peaks at expected product sizes. Blue peaks in the electropherogram (
Figure 4) for each virus corresponded to their product sizes in base pairs when viewed in an agarose gel. The LIZ-labeled marker in red (
Figure 4) acted as a molecular weight standard to determine the size of the amplicons. It is very conspicuous that the peaks for each virus were very close to the targeted amplicon size as listed in
Table 1. The specificity and robustness of the method were tested in capillary electrophoresis with the same field samples that had mixed infection and were run in an agarose gel, to compare the data (data not shown). Results from the gel and the capillary electrophoresis for the field samples matched well to confirm the benefits of the high-throughput capillary electrophoresis method.
4. Discussion
In view of the considerable increase in yield loss with the emerging diseases caused by various wheat viruses, an improved multiplex PCR diagnostic test that can detect and differentiate between them will be very useful. The study involved diagnosing five yellow dwarf viruses (BYDV-PAV, BYDV-MAV, BYDV-SGV, BYDV-RMV, and CYDV-RPV), wheat spindle streak mosaic virus, soil-borne wheat mosaic virus, wheat streak mosaic virus, Triticum mosaic virus, and High Plains virus. The tool uses specific primer pairs for each of these viruses in a multiplex RT-PCR to distinguish them in a single reaction.
Availability of the sequences of different viruses and the variations in the isolates have led to adoption of RT-PCR methods and reduced use of the traditional ELISA method as a detection method. Exploiting the differences in the sequences of the viruses as well as the conserved domains among the various isolates, it has been easier to multiplex them to lower the cost while increasing the sensitivity at the same time. With the possibility of mixed infection being the most common in fields, multiplex PCR has been gaining importance in simultaneous detection for different plant viruses. Several articles report the use of techniques as rapid and reliable methods [
18,
19,
20] with some being quantitative enough with the advantage of monitoring in real time [
20,
21,
22,
23]. Screening with different sets of specific primers in a multiplex PCR poses a bigger challenge with the increase in the number of viruses to be detected in one test. However, with the advantage of being cost effective, several systems have been developed for the detection of couples of viruses [
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30]. There have been studies that have reported methods to detect multiple viruses, with three [
31,
32] or more in a single detection system [
33,
34,
35,
36]. There have been fewer reports on detecting a larger number, with seven or eight viruses in a single test 4 [
37]. To our knowledge, in this paper, we are the first to report an RT-PCR-based diagnostic test for up to ten wheat viruses.
Degenerate primer design based on the sequences of the respective virus isolates [
10] available from GenBank was used for robust detection of the different viruses by simplex and multiplex RT-PCR. The extent of homology between the targets and the primers, primer length, GC content of the primers, the melting temperatures, and the possibility of any secondary structures were studied to develop this protocol to act as a universal diagnostic tool. Troubleshooting with several pairs of primers for TriMV and HPV was performed to check their compatibility with the other eight viruses in the multiplex RT-PCR. It was important to amplify the new viruses with a certain pre-decided product size to fit into the existent multiplex ladder of eight viruses to be readily identify them. Choosing the right primers for TriMV and HPV was a challenge, but it resulted in ten different well-spaced fragments in the range from 154 bp to 560 bp, specific to each virus. The consistent results of the multiplex RT-PCR were always compared with simplex PCR for detection of each virus pathogen. This sensitive and simultaneous detection of the viruses using the multiplex RT-PCR decreases the risk of contamination, requires less time, and reduces the cost compared to other conventional methods such as ELISA.
Results of false positives can be a problem in the conventional multiplex RT-PCR. Multiple primer pairs in various combinations in a reaction may interfere in the amplification of the target sequence. To ensure the reliability of this diagnosis, each primer pair for a specific virus was tested in simplex PCR with all other viruses and their isolates. It was important for the primers to be very specific so that they did not cross react with the other sets to give false positives. The “drop-out” experiment was intuitive enough to show the specificity of each primer pair even in the presence of all viruses.
In conclusion, this multiplex RT-PCR method is a simple, specific, rapid, reliable, yet sensitive and cost-effective, diagnostic tool for multiple wheat viruses. The method can be successfully utilized for in detecting all ten viruses individually as well as in multiple infections from the same plant. Plant improvement programs can also greatly benefit from this tool in reference to different breeding techniques in creating resistant varieties.