Validation of Automatic Cochlear Measurements Using OTOPLAN® Software
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Thank you for your interesting paper.
I have a question what AID (line76) means?
I have found only small typos - please add space before bracket in line 11, 12, 13, 16, 21 and 22 and after a colon in line 18, 21 and 22 for better reading. Please decide (in line 32) if the name is Takagi or Takahashi, like in references
Author Response
Line 76 issue - settled
Line 11 to 22 typ. issues - settled
Line 32 - the names and the referred citation have been updated accordingly
Thank you very much for your comments
Reviewer 2 Report
Dear Editor,
I reviewed the article entitled Validation of automatic cochlear measurements using 2 OTOPLAN® software By Paouris et al discussing the comparison between tha manual measurement of the cochlear parameters and those performed by the new version of Otoplan.
The article is well written (with small mistakes), consistent concerning the data and it may be useful for the scientific community dealing with hearing loss and cochlear implantation
Lines 98-99: I do not understand what the authors mean. Please rephrase.
Lines 217-218: “With the new AUTO approach, the process is much 217 faster: less than 1 minute is required for the full set of measurements. As with the fully AUTO method.” There are some problems with the spacing and I do not understand the second phrase…
Minor reviews are necessary.
Author Response
Lines 98-99: the sentence has been rephrased
Lines 217 - 218: the sentence has been rephrased
The English language has been revised and controlled throughout the whole manuscript.
Thank you very much for your comments