1. Introduction
With the development of science-intensive technologies, the need for the creation of structural materials that work in critical conditions is sharply increasing. These materials include titanium alloys. The creation of technological processes allowing to ensure high quality of titanium alloys and their minimum cost is the key task of technologies for obtaining high-tech structural materials. The development of modern technologies for the chemical processing of titanium concentrates and the synthesis of high-purity metallic titanium is one of the main processes preceding the creation of titanium alloys, since the physicochemical properties and cost of products made of titanium and its alloys depend on the content of impurities in a titanium product.
Currently, two main methods are used in industry for processing titanium-containing concentrates: sulfate (sulfuric acid) and chloride. The main problem, as well as the disadvantage of sulfate technology, is environmental pollution due to the need to discharge a large amount of waste in the form of CaSO
4 into the environment. As a result, the production cost of titanium dioxide using sulfate technology is very high. However, the sulfate method has the advantage that it does not require a high titanium feedstock [
1]. The chloride method is considered to be more advanced and environmentally friendly. However, the main disadvantage of the method is that a large amount of gaseous, liquid and solid toxic chloride waste is discharged, and the total amount of titanium extracted into pure titanium chloride does not exceed 89% of the mass. In addition, for the chlorination process to be highly efficient, the titanium content (as TiO
2) in the starting material must be high (>90%). In this case, it becomes necessary to carry out auxiliary operations for the purification of raw materials and the recycling process in order to increase the titanium content in the raw materials to a level corresponding to technological requirements. As a result, only 10 to 50% of titanium metal can be obtained from raw materials, which significantly increases its cost [
2].
The current production rate of titanium dioxide in the world is about 2750 thousand tons/year, corresponding to the amount of harmful solid waste by chlorination method of about 1467 thousand tons/year (under the condition that all factories are equal, switch to chloride technology) [
3,
4].
In the last decade, the development of the sulfate method associated with the introduction of various reagents (additives) sulfuric acid. For example, in [
5] a water technology is described, in which it is recommended to use a mixture of H
2SO
4 (10% vol.)-HF (15% vol.) to open titanium ores. At opening, TiF
62− is first formed, which, upon subsequent interaction with H
2SO
4, forms Ti(SO
4)
2 [
5]. In [
6,
7,
8], the process of sulfate-fluoride leaching of titanium from ilmenite and the formation of fluorotitanate ions in aqueous solutions and the subsequent synthesis of Ti(SO
4)
2 in a sulfuric acid medium is proposed. In fact, this is a modification of the well-known sulfate technology of titanium ore opening. The main disadvantage of this technology is the formation of a large amount of calcium sulfate, which must be separated from production waste and spend significant funds on its storage.
An aquatic technology is being developed for opening titanomagnetite ore by selective extraction of titanium with solutions containing ammonium fluoride (ammonium and fluorine ions) [
9]. A technology based on the use of metal and ammonium hydrofluorides for opening titanium ores and concentrates is presented [
10]. As a result of the interaction of titanium and iron oxides with aqueous solutions of ammonium fluoride, aqueous solutions of HF (hydrofluoric acid) are formed, which, under the conditions of the process, have a strong corrosive effect on the material of the apparatus. This does not allow the use of this method in an industrial environment.
A high-temperature technology for the synthesis of titanium slag based on TiO
2, suitable for metallothermal reduction and synthesis of metallic titanium, has been described [
11]. However, if magnesium is used as a metal-reducing agent in the reduction in slag, then this is actually the well-known Kroll process, which is the only method used in industrial conditions to obtain titanium sponge.
The process of synthesis of rutile from titanium slags from the Panzhihua deposit (China) by oxidative roasting of these slags at 1100 °C for 2 h is presented [
12]. However, this method is not new since it is described in the preparation of various titanium ores for the Kroll process—the reduction in TiO
2 with magnesium.
Recently, various types of titanium electrolytic reduction processes in fluoride-chloride-salt melts have been intensively developed. TiO
2 is used as a starting material. These are FFC-, MER-, PRP-, Osaka-, Suzuki- and Chinuka-processes [
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18]. However, these processes have not yet passed the stage of laboratory tests and research using “pilot” installations.
In the near future, we can expect a breakthrough in the creation of new titanium technologies, which will significantly reduce its prime cost. In this case, the cost of titanium can become commensurate with the cost of stainless steel. As a result, titanium consumption could skyrocket and replace stainless steel and other materials in the global market.
In the opinion of the authors of the article, in order to expand the areas of application of titanium and its alloys, it is necessary to develop a technology that makes it possible to effectively separate titanium from impurities, and then convert the volatile titanium compound into metallic titanium (powder or sponge). The number of stages of such a process should be minimal (no more than 3–4 stages). Such a process can be the process of direct fluorination of titanium concentrates with elemental fluorine, which makes it possible to transfer titanium into a gaseous compound, for example, TiF4, and at the same time effectively separate non-volatile impurity fluorides from TiF4. Subsequently, the reduction in TiF4 should be carried out in a high-frequency pulse discharge, and the resulting elemental fluorine should be recycled again into the fluorination process. In order to study the mechanism of chemical processes occurring in this proposed technology, it is necessary to start from basic studies, namely thermodynamic and kinetic.
In this paper, a method of processing titanium-containing minerals is introduced by fluorine technology with rutile as the raw material, and some thermodynamic and kinetic parameters are calculated to evaluate and propose a schematic diagram of a facility for fluorination of rutile concentrate in industrial conditions.
3. Results
The thermodynamic study of the fluorination of rutile ore concentrates was conducted at temperatures from 300 K to 1800 K. For the main reaction of interest is the reaction between TiO
2 and F
2, at different temperatures. The process that took place was described in detail in our previous Procedia Chemistry conference report [
19] with the main reactions of the process including:
In addition, reactions occur between F
2 and other components of the original rutile concentrate:
The dependence of the change of the logarithmic equilibrium constant of these reactions on the temperature lg
kp =
f(
T) was presented in
Figure 2. According to the obtained results of thermodynamic equilibrium calculations, the fluorination of components in the ilmenite concentrate took place easily, without limitation, and the reverse oxidation to produce oxides did not happen. The main products formed in this process are fluoride salts. The composition and structure of an isolated thermodynamic system at the equilibrium moment was determined and evaluated using the ASTRA software (version 1.06, Moscow State Technical University N.E. Bauman, Russia).
To evaluate the dependence of the TiF
4 content obtained in the product on the temperature, the experiments were carried out with the temperature from 300 to 1000 K, under the condition of 10% F
2 excess, 50% F
2 excess, and 10% F
2 deficiency and 50% F
2 deficiency, corresponding to the ratio TiO
2/F
2 by mass: The results were shown in
Figure 3. Here, the observed target products are TiF
4 and O
2, for other substances with high content. In total, <0.0001 mole/kg were removed from the calculation results. The need to conduct research under conditions of 10% and 50% fluorine deficiency is determined by the fact that in industrial conditions the fluorination process is carried out in two stages: the first—in an excess of fluorine, the second—in a fluorine deficiency. This is necessary to ensure the full use of fluorine in the process. In this case, at the first stage, the completeness of the fluorination of the rutile concentrate is ensured. For this, it is necessary to provide an excess of fluorine. In the second stage, it is necessary to capture the excess fluorine from the first stage. For this, the solid phase (rutile concentrate) is supplied in excess relative to the amount of fluorine leaving the first stage. As a result, titanium oxyfluorides and other components (solids) are formed, which are then returned to the first stage together with the rutile concentrate. From
Figure 3, it could be seen that a higher TiF
4 content was observed in the equilibrium ratio of the phases under ideal conditions, however, in the system, there was still unreacted TiO
2 (analyzed by solid phase XRD). The concentration of TiF
4 (gas) was determined in the temperature range from 400 K to 600 K. Its value increased from 0.05% by mass to ~75% by mass under ideal conditions (with a large excess of F
2), and with a 10% excess of F
2 it was approximately 72%. When the temperature reaction was higher 600 K, the concentration of TiF
4 was stable and not changing. In the products, at both 400 K and 600 K, there is a small amount of V
2O
5 (solid) approximately 0.053% by mass and theunreacted gas F
2 ~4.5%. Therefore, the optimal condition for carrying out fluorination (at first stage) is 10% excess F
2 of its amount required for carrying out reactions (2–10).Thus, the amount of F
2 required for fluorination should not exceed 10%. This corresponds to the initial content of substances used in the main process equal to% (mass): TiO
2—48.43 and F
2—53.63.
It can be seen from the results obtained that: TiF4 (gas) begins to form at a reaction temperature of >400 K, and a significant amount of gaseous TiF4 begins to form at 500 K. Therefore, the study of the process of rutile fluorination should be carried out at temperatures >500 K.
The kinetics of the process of fluorination between TiO2 with fluoride was studied on samples with a particle size from 2 × 10−6 to 2 × 10−5 m with the specific surface area of ~3.5 m2/g.
These studies were performed on TiO2 samples; where the weight of each sample is ~280 mg and thickness of up to 4 mm. The temperature of the study was conducted in range from 300 to 550 °C. During the kinetics study, the temperature, partial pressure and sample mass parameters are recorded continuously over time. The fluorine gas used in this study is technical fluorine purified from HF by adsorption at 370–380 °C on NaF material.
The fluorination reaction occurs on the contact surface of the solid phase (sample) and gaseous phases. The process consists of several main stages: (1) supply of fluorinating gas (F2) to the surface of the solid phase (TiO2); (2) adsorption of gas on the surface of solid particles; (3) the chemical reaction of the sorbed gas with a solid; (4) desorption of gaseous TiF4 from the surface of the solid product; (5) diffusion of the desorbed TiF4 product into the gas phase.
When studying the kinetics of heterogeneous processes, the most difficult is to choose a mathematical model to describe the process under consideration. To describe reactions proceeding according to a mechanism that assumes that the rate of interaction of all particles located both on the surface of the powder layer and in its volume is the same and the process proceeds with a decrease in the particle size, the equations of “contracting sphere”, “contracting cylinder” are usually used, Kazeev-Erofeev, Yander, Gistling, Prout-Tomkins. For processes in which reactions develop in a branched mechanism, Prout-Tompkins et al. used equations [
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26].
The reaction rate of TiO2 with fluorine will be a function of the temperature of the process, the partial pressure of the gas F2 and the physico-chemical properties of the original rutile-TiO2 material. Qualitative observations have been established temporarily at temperatures of 500 K and below, the process rate is very slow, as suggested by the authors, possibly related to the formation of the intermediate product—titanium oxyfluoride. The first compound forms a film on the surface of the titanium dioxide particles, in fact the process is stopped, the reaction taking place at a remarkable rate only at 630 K and above. At 830 K the reaction rate increases gradually and the vaporization of titanium in the gaseous form of titanium tetrafluoride ends within 12 to 14 min.
The experimental dataof the kinetic study are shown in
Figure 4, which was carried out in the temperature range of 580–830 K.
The obtained values of the accuracy of the approximation R
2, of the activation energy
Ea, of the pre-exponential coefficient
k0 are presented in
Table 1.
The closest to unity value of the reliability of approximation R2 was obtained using the equation of a “reduced sphere”.
If the assumption about the fluorination of a spherical particle of the rutile concentrate is valid, then in the coordinates time −1 − (1 −
α)
1/3 the experimental points should lie on a straight line. The time dependences of 1 − (1 −
α)
1/3 changes at different temperatures are shown in
Figure 5.
From these data it can be seen that a directly proportional relationship is observed throughout the entire fluorination process, with the exception of the initial and final moments. The deviation from the straight-line relationship at the beginning of the process is due to the filling of the system with nitrogen, which is necessary to remove air from the system; in the last stage of the process, not the rutile concentrate is fluorinated, but the formed intermediate oxyfluorides of titanium and impurity elements of the rutile concentrate. Thus, the presented model of fluorination of a rutile concentrate particle describes well the process of its interaction with fluorine.
Using the data shown in
Figure 5, the rate constants of the process of fluorination of rutile concentrate at various temperatures were determined and shown in
Table 2.
4. Discussion
The kinetic curves of the fluorination process of rutile were S-shaped (
Figure 4), characteristic of heterogeneous gas-solid processes [
23,
24,
25]. Three areas could be distinguished on the kinetic curves and include:
At stage 1, an induction stage characterized by a low velocity and associated with the diffusion of the initial titanium dioxide into intermediate product—titan oxyfluorides. In this stage, the formation of the phase interface, consisting of an intermediate compound (oxyfluoridation), took place. Fluorine atoms diffuse into the original solid reagent, becoming cores for intermediate compounds.
At stage 2, as new cores form, the rate of the process increases, reaching a maximum value, and in this part of the kinetic curves there is determination by the advancement of the interface.
At stage 3—A high degree of conversion is achieved, the solid particles are reduced, the specific surface is reduced, so the conversion rate increases slowly—a decrease in the rate of conversion [
25,
26,
27,
28,
29].
The kinetic curve of fluorination process at 580 K was characterized by a large induction stage. A significant increase in the rate of fluorination at 780 K and above to 830 K due to the fact that the reaction switches to combustion mode. It should be noted that fluorination releases considerable heat, making it difficult to maintain isothermal conditions of the process.
The effect of reaction time on fluorination process according to the “reduced sphere” equation was showed in
Figure 6 (temperature range from 580 to 830 K).
Temperature influence on the process rate of the fluorination of concentrate rutile, being calculated by the “reduced sphere” equation, is shown in
Figure 6. For the definition of process activation energy (
Ea) performed linearization of experimental points in graph with coordinates ln
k and 1/
T.
If the beginning and the end of the process are considered separately, then a linear dependence is maintained throughout the entire process. In the first stage, there is a deviation due to inert gas—nitrogen in the system to remove air, so the partial pressure of fluorine gas is not stable. In the final stage, mainly titanium oxyfluoride intermediate product is formed.
Based on the data in
Figure 6, the seeming activation energy of the process
Ea (4654.2 Joule/mole) and the pre-exponential coefficient (
k0 = 0.72 min
−1) have been calculated. The kinetic equation will then be represented:
The obtained activation energy values show that the fluorination process takes place in the second control stage—chemical adsorption of F2 gas on the solid phase surface—rutile. If the process takes place in the kinetic field, then Ea must be greater than 40,000 J/mol.
It should be noted that all the mechanisms described above relate to the case of using a large excess of fluorine, although in practice a minimal excess is usually used. When receiving intermediate fluorides from rutile, the processing rate is high enough, and the F2 can be used almost completely. When titanium tetrafluoride is obtained from intermediate fluorides, it is possible to achieve quantitative use of fluoride only with a very long contact of the rutile and gas F2; this is possible in a counter-current process where fresh fluoride is supplied to the partially perfluorinated product and the off-gases are treated with fresh rutile.
In static conditions (or at the insufficient intensity of stirring) and at a high concentration of fluoride we observed significant overheating of a solid material. Since intermediate titanium oxyfluoride and admixtures, contained in the rutile concentrate, can sinter, the bad stirring of solid and gaseous phases leads to the fusion of material and to even greater deterioration of conditions of phases contact. Therefore, it is more favorable to carry out the process of titanium tetrafluoride formation in gaseous suspension. Under these conditions, the heating up of a particle is insignificant, as its temperature is practically equal to the gas temperature.
A schematic diagram of a facility for fluorination of rutile concentrate in industrial conditions is shown in
Figure 7. Fluorination of rutile must be carried out in two stages. At the first stage, according to reactions (2-10), in an excess of elemental fluorine at 1500–2000 K, the process of fluorination of rutile concentrates proceeds.
At this stage, both volatile fluorides TiF
4, SiF
4, and VF
5 and nonvolatile fluorides MgF
2, MnF
2, AlF
3, FeF
3, and CaF
2 are formed. Elemental fluorine is an expensive reagent; therefore, in the process of fluorination, it is necessary to ensure conditions under which its losses are minimal, and the utilization rate is maximum. To ensure these conditions, the second stage of rutile fluorination is carried out—capturing the excess of elemental fluorine from the first stage of fluorination, proceeding according to the reaction:
In this case, in the process of interaction of elemental fluorine with TiO2, a nonvolatile compound, TiOF2 is formed, which ensures the full use of fluorine.
A two-stage scheme of the fluorination of rutile concentrates is shown in
Figure 7.
From the upper part of reactor 6 for collecting elemental fluorine from the first stage of fluorination, the dust-gas phase enters filter 7, designed to separate particles of the solid phase (dust) from the gas stream. Titanium tetrafluoride is desublimated from the gas phase purified from solid particles at 278 °C in desublimator 10 to form a solid phase—titanium tetrafluoride powder. The resulting TiF4 powder is collected in tank 11. From this tank, titanium tetrafluoride is sent for further processing, for example, in the process of titanium powder synthesis.
The gas-phase leaving the desublimator 10 contains trace amounts of fluorine, oxygen and nitrogen. In order to ensure the possibility of removing this gas phase into the atmosphere, it is necessary to clean it from traces of fluorine. This process is carried out in two apparatuses—a scrubber for cleaning fluorinated gases 12 and a column 13 for additional purification of waste gases from fluorinated components with a 10% sodium carbonate solution. As a result, a gas phase is obtained, in which a mixture of oxygen and nitrogen is obtained, in which the fluorine content does not exceed the limiting value, which allows this gas mixture to be discharged into the atmosphere.