Role of Corn Silage in the Sustainability of Dairy Buffalo Systems and New Perspective of Allocation Criterion
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Detailed recommendations and suggestions are mentioned in the text. Few general comments are listed below:
- Keeping method is not precisely described. If the manuscript focuses only on lactating cows, it should be specified in the methodological section.
- The use of abbreviations should be clarified, not only in the text but also in the tables.
- Conclusions are general, more specified conclusions are needed. There were no comparative analysis of dairy cows and dary buffalos in this study.
Comments for author File: Comments.pdf
Author Response
Dear reviewer,
I read carefully your comments, useful to improve the manuscript. Corrections are highlighted in the attached file, in particular I hope that the additions about conclusions are satisfactory.
Yous Sincerely
Andrea Bragaglio
Author Response File: Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
This study delivered a LCA comparison between two dairy buffalo systems with feeding plans of without Corn Silage (NCS) and with Corn Silage (CS) based rations. The topic is of interest, the results are solid and fit in the scope of the journal.
Line 101-102, a repeated sentence as previous one.
Line 151, need a comma between the 2 and respectively.
Line 156, “to” should be removed.
Line 216, the expression of equation (2) is misleading, please modify.
Line 801, table or figure?
Author Response
Dear reviewer,
thanks for the tips. I followed your instructions, as specified in the attached file.
Yours Sincerely
Andrea Bragaglio
Author Response File: Author Response.docx