Islamic Friday Sermon in Italy: Leaders, Adaptations, and Perspectives

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

Editing of English language and style required. You need to review the transcriptions of the Arabic names. Be careful to always use the same transcription method (academic or simplified).

Author Response

Point 1: 

Editing of English language and style required. You need to review the transcriptions of the Arabic names. Be careful to always use the same transcription method (academic or simplified).

Response 1: 

I reviewed the article and rewrote all the Arabic words using the academic transcription method which I attach to this message.

Yours sincerely!

Author

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf

Reviewer 2 Report

Only for Arab terms in latin letter I find someone in scientific transliteration, but not every  time, some in a different form and even colloqial Arabic forms not indicated as such

If you put the Province after the name of a palce: ex. Cantù (CO) it is better to do the same for any palces: ex. Sassuolo (RE)

Some names of Imams are with capital initial letter: ex. Omar, but others are not: ex. usam

some Arab terms are attached in a single string: ex. al-kitabwas-sunnah

in 2 or 3 cases you wrote talat instead than salat

Author Response

Point 1- Only for Arab terms in latin letter I find someone in scientific transliteration, but not every  time, some in a different form and even colloqial Arabic forms not indicated as such

Point 2 If you put the Province after the name of a palce: ex. Cantù (CO) it is better to do the same for any palces: ex. Sassuolo (RE)

 

Point 3- Some names of Imams are with capital initial letter: ex. Omar, but others are not: ex. usam

 

Point 4- some Arab terms are attached in a single string: ex. al-kitabwas-sunnah

 

Point 5- in 2 or 3 cases you wrote talat instead than salat

Response 1: 

I reviewed the article and rewrote all the Arabic words using the academic transcription method witch  I attach to this message. I preferred to keep this transcription: "khutba" in keywords because it's most widespread. 

Response 2: 

I added the abbreviation of the Province in front of the locations.

Response 3: 

I have rewritten the names with the capital letters

Response 4: 

I added the line in the Arabic words that need it

Response 5: 

I corrected the errors about the transcription of salat.

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf