The Political Dimension of Liturgical Prayers of Remembrance: Lists of Rulers in the Confraternity Books of the Carolingian Period
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Minor spell check required, ex "war" for "was", specially "Agilofings/Agilolfings"
Author Response
Thank you very much for reading my article, I have corrected the errors you pointed out.
Reviewer 2 Report
This is aa well-researched paper, clearly organized, and making some helpful points about the use of monastic brotherhood lists and associated lists for corroborating early medieval history. The use of manuscript pages and the accompanying charts was helpful, though the resolution of the manuscript pages limited their effectiveness. (However, the URL was given to go directly to the original image if the reader wished to.) There were some minor problems with the English:
. 146 - und instead of and
155 - und instead of and
241 and often - in the USA it is usual to say Charles Martell, not Karl Martell.
line 272 - instead of very use vary
278 - instead of war use was
286 - instead of instated use installed
322 - Charles
340 - Charles
368 - Charles
432 - and
445 - and
559 - Charles
Author Response
Thank you very much for reading my article, I have corrected the errors you pointed out.
