The Long Ninth Century: Christian Reactions to Islamization and Islamication in Palestine and Al-Andalus
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
The article is clear. However, the writing is not as thorough as it should. Many small paragraphs. The use of the word story is excessive and the author assumes the readers know what he/he refers to in terms of the history of Islam.
The article needs minor revision of English.
Author Response
Reviewer 1 had only general comments: that I could have slightly improve the language & style, and that it would be possible to further elaborate some issues. I checked the manuscript and made some corrections.
Reviewer 2 Report
I found the article excellent from all view-points, obviously within the framework which is specified in the Abstract and introduction. Just some minor mistakes. In this connection I advice the author to check what follows
Please check page 6 line 286. It looks like something is missing, most probably 'Arabic language'. Just check!
Author Response
Reviewer 2 rightfully found an omission on Page 6 line 286 'Arabic language'.
S/he was correct, and I added the missing words.