Optimal Transshipment Route Planning Method Based on Deep Learning for Multimodal Transport Scenarios
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments for author File: 
Comments.pdf
Author Response
1.Answer:
The shortest path problem is an important topic in the field of GIS and computer science. Dijkstra algorithm is a commonly used method to find the shortest path, which is usually used to find the least cost path from a single source. Based on the analysis and research of traditional Dijkstra algorithm, this paper points out the problems of Dijkstra algorithm and optimizes it to improve its storage capacity and operation efficiency. Then, combined with the traffic elements, a new network based optimal path planning method is established. I have modified it.
2.Answer:
The introduction has introduced the novelty, problem statement and contribution of this study.
3.Answer:
The advantages and disadvantages of intelligent transportation system, intelligent navigation system and optimal route planning are all introduced.
4.Answer:
The optimal path planning can enable people to plan the optimal route ahead of time or at any time during the travel process. Now it is a basic application of the vehicle navigation system in the urban road network. I added.
5.Answer:
Various path optimization standards exist in path planning. The quality of the route depends on many factors, including distance, driving speed, road structure, location and number of traffic lights, which are called travel costs. People can choose their own travel routes according to the shortest distance or the shortest travel time. Different standards may plan different paths. We know that when people search the path through the vehicle navigation system, they usually pay attention not only to the shortest distance, but also to the time and cost spent in the driving process. Users can choose a suitable planning scheme according to different needs.
6.Answer:
Yes
7.Answer:
I have modified it.
Reviewer 2 Report
This paper proposed a path optimization method based on deep learning for transshipment, which is of certain interest to the readers of this journal. The following issues should be clarified before publication.
1. The wording of this paper should be modified intensively to make it concise and accurate.
2. In the abstract, the data used is not very clear. For example, what is the meaning of 50% emission and what is the emission limit, [100, 200]?
3. In the introduction, it has been mentioned the previous similar works have not been applied in real life and the related advantages have not been clearly demonstrated. It may not be appropriate.
4. In this paper, a simulation has been conducted to support the points. There are many route planning software available. Is it possible to have a simple experiment to compare?
5. It has been mentioned that the many factors can affect the route planning, such as the weather and road condition. Have the effects of those factors investigated in the paper?
Author Response
- Answer: I have modified
- Answer: The emission limit is variable, which is a critical value for measurement.
- Answer: Reasonable path planning can effectively reduce urban traffic congestion and reduce urban traffic resources. Through reasonable path planning, traffic congestion and other problems can be effectively reduced, thus shortening the time required to reach the destination. This can not only save a lot of traffic resources, but also reduce vehicle exhaust emissions and environmental pollution. Therefore, the optimization path problem has important practical value.
- Answer: This software is relatively large and requires a lot of design work. TrailRunner for Mac is a route planning software on the Mac platform. TrailRunner for Mac is suitable for various long-distance sports, such as running, cycling, hiking, in-line skating, skiing, etc.
- Answer: Yes, although there is no experiment in the article, it is explained.
Reviewer 3 Report
-Contribution is not clear. Include contribution of this paper in Introduction section in a separate paragraph in the bulleted for form so that it can be easily followed by the readers.Suggest to add recent literature work in the introduction.
Suggested to recheck minor errors in related to abbreviation and grammatical mistakes.
Introduction is short and not complete. My suggestion is to divide the introduction into three subsections: 1) motivation and incitement, 2) literature review and 3) contribution and paper organization. some works are recommended to be added, such as:
-Coordinated design of PSS and SVC damping controller using CPSO
-Damping controller design for power system oscillations using hybrid GA-SQP
-Golden Search Optimization Algorithm
The quality of the figures is low. Also, if the mentioned figures are taken from another paper, the number of the references must be located at the end of the title of the figure.
Author Response
Suggest to add recent literature work in the introduction.
Answer:I have added it.
Suggested to recheck minor errors in related to abbreviation and grammatical mistakes.
Answer:I have modified the touch up.
Introduction is short and not complete. My suggestion is to divide the introduction into three subsections: 1) motivation and incitement, 2) literature review and 3) contribution and paper organization. some works are recommended to be added, such as:
-Coordinated design of PSS and SVC damping controller using CPSO
-Damping controller design for power system oscillations using hybrid GA-SQP
-Golden Search Optimization Algorithm
The quality of the figures is low. Also, if the mentioned figures are taken from another paper, the number of the references must be located at the end of the title of the figure.
Answer: I have adjusted. MorsaliJavad applies fractional order PI&D controller to the design of series capacitor damping controller based on thyristor control, and cooperates with the secondary integral controller as the automatic generation control loop.
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
1. The paper is generally well written and structured.
2. Paper Accepted for Publication.
3. Problem formulation is good and also is relevant
4. Results are good
5. Literature survey is comprehensive
Reviewer 2 Report
The problems listed in the previous review have been addressed. This paper can be published as it is.
Reviewer 3 Report
Accept in present form
