1. Introduction
Although coupled core fibers are currently receiving research attention [
1], uncoupled multicore fibers (MCFs) are seen as a promising solution to support space-division multiplexing in long-haul MCF links where the available physical space is limited, such as submarine cables [
2,
3,
4] or even in shorter optical datacenter network links [
5,
6]. Long-haul terrestrial transmission links are typically composed of multiple spliced fiber segments (typically ~2 km in length) [
7], which are taken from different lots [
8]. As such, core dependent loss (CDL) due to manufacturing imperfections [
9,
10,
11] may vary from MCF segment to MCF segment [
8]. Moreover, in uncoupled MCF links with unidirectional transmission, intercore crosstalk (ICXT) may significantly impair the transmission performance [
12,
13]. The impact of CDL on the direct average ICXT power in two-core unsegmented uncoupled MCFs was studied theoretically [
8,
14]. It was concluded that the variation of the direct average ICXT power with constant CDL can reach up to 2 dB (for CDL in the range of ±0.04 dB/km) in comparison with MCFs with equal core losses [
14]. In two-core uncoupled segmented MCF links, the impact of random CDL from different concatenated MCF segments on the direct average ICXT power was studied numerically and analytically [
15]. We have shown [
15] that (i) random CDL leads to probability density functions (PDFs) of the direct average ICXT power that are nearly Gaussian, as long as the number of concatenated MCF segments is sufficiently high and (ii) the arbitrariness of the MCF segments concatenation may reduce the CDL impact on the direct average ICXT power relative to unsegmented MCF links with constant CDL. Using an analytical worst-case approximation, it has been shown that random CDL leads only to a 0.25 dB excess of direct average ICXT power relative to its mean for 2000 km long links [
15]. Shorter links will experience a higher excess of direct average ICXT power due to random CDL since less Gaussian PDF behavior observed for a lower number of concatenated segments enhances the relative spread of the direct average ICXT power [
15].
When deploying the transmission link, variable splice loss can also enhance the direct average ICXT power [
16,
17]. The combined effect of CDL and splice loss on the direct average ICXT power has been studied in [
16] for fixed loss values, and it was shown that its impact on the direct average ICXT power only depends on the total loss difference. The impact of the combined effect of random CDL and random splice loss on the direct average ICXT power in long-haul MCF links has been assessed in [
17]. For splice loss practical values, it was shown that the effect of random splice loss dominates the excess of ICXT power, leading to 2 dB and 0.6 dB of excess power, respectively, for 100 km and 2000 km long links [
17].
Other random effects resulting from imperfect fiber manufacturing, such as coupling coefficient variation along the MCF link [
18], or resulting from link implementation issues, such as segment length variation, may, after segment concatenation, intensify and enhance the direct average ICXT power. The impact of such effects remains to be assessed and quantified. Hence, this work numerically assesses the combined effect of the randomness of the segment length, power coupling coefficient, and CDL on the statistical behavior of the direct average ICXT power, namely, on its PDF, mean, standard deviation, relative spread, and excess kurtosis and on the induced excess of direct average ICXT power.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows.
Section 2 describes the numerical model of the MCF link, the theory, and the corresponding equations used to calculate the direct average ICXT power at the link output. In
Section 3, the numerical results regarding the direct average ICXT power are obtained, statistically studied, and discussed. The main conclusions are presented in
Section 4.
2. Numerical Model
This section describes the numerical model used to study the effect of concatenating arbitrary MCF segments with different characteristics on the statistical behavior of the direct average ICXT power in long-haul communication links. The equivalent model of the
k-th span is depicted in
Figure 1 and closely follows the model proposed in [
15]. Each uncoupled MCF link comprises
Ns spans, with the span length denoted as
Ls,k (with
k = 1, …,
Ns). At the end of each MCF span, a multicore-optical amplifier (MC-OA) compensates for the span loss. Each span is composed of
Nk concatenated MCF segments interconnected by splice points (totaling
Nk − 1 in the
k-th span), with the segment length denoted as
Li,k (with
i = 1, …,
Nk). The total length of the
k-th span is
.
The power at the output of the
k-th span,
Pout,c,k (with
c = 1 for core 1 and
c = 2 for core 2), is obtained using [
15] the following:
where
Pin,c,k (with
c = 1 or 2) denotes the power at the input of the
k-th span. Each matrix
Ti,k (with
i = 1, …,
Nk and
k = 1, …,
Ns), as given by (2), represents the coupled power equations with CDL between cores 1 and 2 in the
i-th MCF segment of the
k-th span [
8].
where
hi,k is the power coupling coefficient between the two cores in the
i-th segment of the
k-th span (we assume that
h12,i,k ≈
h21,i,k =
hi,k, which is valid in the practical range of CDL [
8,
14]);
is the average of the loss coefficients of the two cores in the
i-th segment of the
k-th span and is given by
= (
α1,i,k +
α2,i,k)/2, where
αc,i,k (with
c = 1 or 2) corresponds to the loss coefficient of core
c in the
i-th segment of the
k-th span; and
= (
α1,i,k −
α2,i,k)/2, with the loss coefficient imbalance defined by 2
and corresponding to CDL [
8].
As MCF segments can come from different lots, due to manufacturing imperfections, the MCF segments may exhibit different characteristics, such as different lengths, coupling coefficients, and CDL. CDL ranges of [−0.04, 0.04] dB/km have been reported [
11]. It is also very unlikely that CDL will be more than 0.1 dB [
8]. As CDL between segments can be (arbitrarily) different, the CDL in the
i-th each segment may be characterized as a random variable (RV) by assuming that the loss coefficients in the
i-th MCF segment are also RVs. A statistical distribution is assumed to characterize random CDL, where the loss coefficients
αc,i,k can only assume two values with a probability of ½. The PDF of this distribution is given by [
15] the following equation:
where
δ(
x) stands for the Dirac delta function. It should not be confused with the variable
δα,i,k that characterizes the loss coefficient imbalance. The two values
αc,min and
αc,max correspond to, respectively, the minimum and maximum loss coefficients that can be set in each MCF segment. It has been shown that the distribution given by (4) is a worst-case distribution that enhances the impact of random CDL on the direct average ICXT power at the output of the MCF link relative to other statistical distributions [
15]. The work reported in [
15] assumed that the power coupling coefficient is equal for all segments and that all segments have the same length.
The coupling coefficients between cores in each MCF segment and the segment lengths are also modeled as RVs. The power coupling coefficient in the
i-th segment of the
k-th span is generated uniformly in the interval
, where
Vh sets the maximum variation, in dB, of the power coupling coefficient relative to the reference case
href. The length of the
i-th segment of the
k-th span is generated uniformly in the interval
, where
sets the maximum fractional variation of the segment length relative to the reference case
Lref. This approach to study the effect of the segment length randomness on the direct average ICXT power follows the idea presented in [
19] for studying randomly variable map lengths in dispersion-managed links. We also assume that the random effects in each segment are considered independent of the random effects of other segments.
The MCF segments are interconnected by splices created during the construction of the MCF link. At each splice point, the matrices
Ci,k (with
i = 1, …,
Nk − 1 and
k = 1, …,
Ns) in Equation (1) are given by [
16] the following equation:
where
ηcc,i,k (with
c = 1 or 2) defines the loss of the splice point for core
c in the
i-th segment of the
k-th span and
ηcc’,i,k (with
c’ ≠
c) defines the mode coupling between the two cores at the
i-th splice point of the
k-th span. The splice loss difference definition considered in [
16] can be used to set the loss of each splice point. Additionally, the matrices
Ci,k in Equation (5) are typically diagonal matrices, since the ICXT caused by mode coupling at the splice point is usually low when compared to the MCF-induced ICXT [
16].
An investigation regarding how random splice loss affects the direct average ICXT power in long-distance transmission was performed in [
16,
17]. Due to its high magnitude, splice losses may dominate the ICXT power enhancement and may conceal the impact of the coupling coefficient randomness and segment length randomness on such enhancement. To avoid this situation, in the remainder of this work, we consider that the splices have equal losses in the two cores and along the long-haul MCF link.
After
Nk MCF segments, an ideal MC-OA perfectly compensates the optical loss in each core. As the main goal of this work is to study the effect of concatenating arbitrary MCF segments on the direct average ICXT power, the noise of the amplifiers is neglected. The gain of each core is equal to the overall loss of the
k-th span, with the diagonal matrix
TOA,k in Equation (1) defined by
where the mode coupling in the MC-OAs is assumed to be negligible in comparison with the ICXT induced by the MCF.
At the output of the long-haul MCF link with total length
Ltot, the optical power in each core is calculated using
The direct average ICXT power,
XTdir, in core
c (with
c = 1 or 2), after
Ns spans, at the output of the long-haul MCF link is obtained by [
14] the following equation:
where the coupled power
Pcou,c(
Ltot) at the long-haul link output for core
c is obtained from
Pout,c,Ns, as given by (7), by injecting power
Pin,c’,1 at the link input in the other core (with
c’ ≠
c), and the signal power
Psig,c(
Ltot) is obtained from
Pout,c,Ns, by setting the power coupling coefficients in each segment to zero [
14].
3. Numerical Results and Discussion
In this section, the statistical dependence of the direct average ICXT power at the output of the long-haul uncoupled MCF link on concatenating arbitrary MCF segments with random CDL, segment length, and power coupling coefficient is assessed. Monte Carlo (MC) simulation is used to characterize these statistical dependences. In each iteration of the MC simulation, one realization of the long-haul MCF link is composed of MCF segments with different characteristics that depend on the statistical distributions considered for the RVs, αc,i,k, hi,k, and Li,k.
All results presented in this work are obtained for the simulation parameters shown in
Table 1. The same power is considered at the input of the two cores. The total link length is 2000 km. The link has 20 MCF spans, each 100 km long. An equal number of segments in each span is considered. The reference segment length is 2 km. The attenuation coefficients
αc,i,k are generated in the interval [
αc,min,
αc,max] dB/km to obtain a maximum loss core imbalance of 0.08 dB/km. The reference coupling coefficient is set to reach the average ICXT level of
href·Ltot = −30 dB at the output of the 2000 km long link. This average ICXT level maximizes the spectral efficiency in uncoupled MCF repeated coherent systems with span lengths of around 100 km [
3].
Figure 2 shows the PDFs of the direct average ICXT power obtained with random CDL, considering (a) random segment lengths
Li,k (and constant power coupling coefficient,
href, along the MCF link); (b) random power coupling coefficients,
hi,k, with
Vh = 3 dB (and constant segment length,
Lref = 2 km); and (c) random power coupling coefficients,
hi,k, with
Vh = 6 dB (and constant segment length,
Lref = 2 km). Gaussian PDFs with the same mean and standard deviation as the ones obtained by simulation are also shown in
Figure 2. As a Gaussian PDF has null excess kurtosis, the excess kurtosis
κE is also shown in
Figure 2 to quantify how much an estimated PDF is close to the Gaussian shape [
20]. As a reference, with random CDL only, i.e., with
Vh = 0 and Δ
L= 0, the PDF mean, standard deviation, and excess kurtosis are, respectively,
μ = 1.01 × 10
−3,
σ = 2.41 × 10
−5, and
κE = 1.27 × 10
−2 [
15]. Each PDF shown in
Figure 2 is obtained with 10
6 iterations of MC simulation of the long-haul MCF link. In each iteration, one MCF link realization is created with segments that have random characteristics. For that link realization, the direct average ICXT power is obtained at the MCF link output from Equation (8). Considering all MC realizations, a histogram of the direct average ICXT power is built, from which the PDF is calculated, and the corresponding mean, standard deviation, and excess kurtosis are obtained.
Figure 2a shows that the randomness of the segment length does not significantly affect the direct average ICXT power, leading to a similar PDF (mean, standard deviation, and excess kurtosis) as the PDF obtained considering only the CDL randomness.
Figure 2b,c show that the power coupling coefficients randomness increases the mean and standard deviation of the direct average ICXT power in comparison with the PDF shown in
Figure 2a obtained for a constant coupling coefficient. For
Vh = 6 dB, the mean increases by 2.9 dB, and the standard deviation increases by 3.9 dB relative to the mean and standard deviation obtained with constant
href = 5 × 10
−10 m
−1 (
Vh = 0 dB) in
Figure 2a. The Gaussianity of the PDFs is not particularly affected by the randomness of the power coupling coefficients, as the excess kurtoses shown in
Figure 2 are very similar.
Figure 3a–d show, respectively, the mean
μ, standard deviation
σ, relative spread
σ/
μ, and excess kurtosis
κE of the direct average ICXT power as a function of the link length for different scenarios concerning the randomness of the segment length and the power coupling coefficient. Three scenarios are considered: (i) random
Li,k (with constant
hi,k equal to
href); (ii) random
hi,k (with constant
Li,k equal to
Lref) with
Vh = 3 dB, 6 dB, and 10 dB; and (iii) random
Li,k and
hi,k with
Vh = 10 dB. Random CDL is considered in all scenarios. For each scenario, 10
7 iterations of MC simulation of the long-haul MCF link are required to obtain stabilized values of the excess kurtosis.
Figure 3a shows that the mean of the direct average ICXT power is practically independent of the randomness of the segment length for the variation between [1.5, 2.5] km considered for
Li,k. This is concluded from the overlapping of the curves corresponding to the mean obtained with random
Li,k (‘ο’symbols) and the mean obtained with random CDL only ( ‘+’ symbols). Hence, it can be concluded from
Figure 3a that the mean practically depends only on the power coupling coefficient randomness, growing for higher
Vh, since the power coupling between the two cores is enhanced for higher
hi,k. For
Vh = 6 dB (‘☐’ symbols), the mean of the direct average ICXT power practically doubles after 2000 km, relative to the case of random CDL only. For
Vh = 10 dB, the mean reaches 5 × 10
−3 (−23 dB) after 2000 km. In
Figure 3a, considering the coupling coefficient randomness, and since
Ns spans of equal length have been assumed, we have concluded that the mean is approximated well by
, where
stands for the mean of the direct average ICXT power at the output of the first span [
15]. At the output of the first span, the mean can be estimated well by
. The solid lines shown in
Figure 3a show the results obtained with this analytical approximation for
Vh = 0, 3, 6, and 10 dB (violet, red, blue, and green lines, respectively) and are very close to the corresponding numerical results (represented by the symbols with the same corresponding colors). It is important to also notice that in
Figure 3a, for
Vh = 10 dB, the curves obtained with random
Li,k and
hi,k (symbols ‘∗’) and obtained with random
hi,k (symbols ‘×’) are superimposed.
Figure 3b shows that the standard deviation of the direct average ICXT power grows with the power coupling coefficient randomness since the coupled power increases for higher
hi,k. For
Vh = 6 dB, the standard deviation of the direct average ICXT power almost triples after 2000 km, relative to the case of random CDL only. Further inspection of the results revealed that the standard deviation varies with the number of spans
, where
stands for the standard deviation of the direct average ICXT power at the output of the first span. This behavior has also been observed in [
15], with only random CDL generation. As for the mean, the impact of the randomness of the segment length is practically negligible on the standard deviation in comparison with the scenario of random CDL only.
Although the power coupling coefficient randomness increases the mean and standard deviation of the direct average ICXT level,
Figure 3c,d show that the relative spread and the excess kurtosis are marginally affected by the randomness of
hi,k (and also
Li,k), particularly for long link lengths. The relative spread determines the excess of direct average ICXT power induced by the random effects between segments relative to the case without randomness. The definition of the excess of direct average ICXT power is given by [
15] the following equation:
where
k sets the range of variation of Δ
XTdir. Considering
k = 3 in Equation (9) (corresponding to the 3
σ rule of thumb), 99.7% realizations of the long-haul MCF link have direct average ICXT power in the range [
μ − 3
σ,
μ + 3
σ], and half of them lead to Δ
XTdir ≥ 0 dB. In
Figure 3c, as for shorter link lengths the relative spread is higher, the excess of direct average ICXT power is also higher. For a 100 km link length, Δ
XTdir = 1.496 dB (
σ1/
μ1 = 0.1371), for random
hi,k and
Vh = 10 dB, and Δ
XTdir = 1.21 dB (
σ1/
μ1 = 0.1070), for random CDL only. Considering only random
hi,k, for a 100 km link length, there is an increase of only 0.26 dB of excess ICXT power, relative to the case of random CDL only. As the relative spread approaches zero for longer link lengths, the excess of the direct average ICXT power is also reduced with the increase in the link length. For a 2000 km long link, Δ
XTdir = 0.38 dB (
σ/
μ = 0.0306), for random
hi,k and
Vh = 10 dB, and Δ
XTdir = 0.33 dB (
σ/
μ = 0.0263) for random CDL only. In the results shown in
Figure 3c, it can be concluded that the excess of direct average ICXT power, for links with
Ns equal length spans, can be estimated well by knowing the relative spread at end of the first span,
, even in the presence of coupling coefficient randomness and segment length randomness.
In
Figure 3d, with the increase in the link length (a higher number of concatenated segments), the excess kurtosis decreases and approaches zero, meaning that, for longer link lengths, the PDFs of the direct average ICXT power become more Gaussian-distributed [
15]. In these cases, the number of MCF segments is sufficiently high to meet the central limit theorem. For shorter link lengths (a lower number of concatenated MCF segments), as the excess kurtosis is farther away from zero, the PDFs are less Gaussian [
15]. The Gaussian behavior variation with the link length seems to be tied to the behavior of the relative spread of the direct average ICXT power with the link length. For longer link lengths, lower relative spreads are observed for more Gaussian PDFs. For shorter link lengths, the lower Gaussianity of the PDFs leads to higher relative spread.
Figure 4a,b show, respectively, the mean and standard deviation of the direct average ICXT power as a function of the link length, considering the randomness of CDL and of the power coupling coefficient with
Vh = 3 dB and 6 dB. The shaded areas represent the variation of the mean and standard deviation, considering random CDL, but with constant (deterministic)
hi,k along all MCF segments. The boundaries of the shaded area correspond to the minimum and maximum coupling coefficients of, respectively,
hi,k = 2.5 × 10
−10 m
−1 and
hi,k = 1 × 10
−9 m
−1, for
Vh = 3 dB (red area), and to the minimum and maximum coupling coefficients of, respectively,
hi,k = 1.25 × 10
−10 m
−1 and
hi,k = 2 × 10
−9 m
−1 for
Vh = 6 dB (blue area).
Figure 4 shows that the randomness of the coupling coefficient along the MCF segments leads to a reduction in the mean and standard deviation of the direct average ICXT power (lines with symbols) relative to considering a constant
hi,k with the maximum value (upper bound of the shaded areas). Hence, in
Figure 4, it can be concluded that the arbitrariness of the MCF segments concatenation may reduce the power coupling coefficient impact on the direct average ICXT power relative to MCF links with a constant coupling coefficient. This advantage provided by the random concatenation of MCF segments with different characteristics has been also observed in numerical studies when only considering the impact of random CDL on the direct average ICXT power in MCF links [
15] and in field experiments with concatenated MCF segments with common characteristics but fabricated by different manufacturers [
18].