3. Active Ingredients
Crayfish contain active ingredients with medicinal utility or physiological activity, such as enzymes, chitin, and astaxanthin. Chitinase degrades chitin and plays an essential role in the immunity of animals and the defense of plants. PcChitinase 2 may be involved in the innate immune response of crayfish through the modulation of the Toll pathway [
14]. Another enzyme named prophenoloxidase (proPO) was also found in crayfish, which is located in the cytoplasm of hemocytes with a critical role in the antibacterial innate immune response, and is involved in multiple physiological processes, such as melanization, cytotoxic reactant production, particle encapsulation, and hemocyte attraction, inducing phagocytosis, and the formation of nodules and capsules [
15]. Superoxide dismutases (SODs) are important antioxidant enzymes that remove excess amounts of biologically reactive oxygen intermediates. The SODs in crayfish play an important role in the innate immune responses against
Spiroplasma eriocheiris and
Aeromonas hydrophila [
16].
It was reported that crayfish shells contain approximately 20–40% of chitin [
17]. Chitin is an organic polymer compound, the second most abundant in nature after cellulose, and the only natural alkaline polysaccharide discovered so far [
18,
19]. Chitin is chemically stable, insoluble, and can be deacetylated to form chitosan (
Figure 2). Chitin is the primary product of the comprehensive utilization of freshwater crayfish and is widely used in daily chemicals, medicines, and food processing [
20]. Due to its biodegradability, biocompatibility, and renewability, the efficient utilization and degradation of this biomass resource has recently attracted intense research interest [
21]. It is a natural polymer material that is used as a wound-healing promoter, drug delivery carrier, and surgical suture with broad utility in biomedicine [
22]. As a major fishing nation, China ranks first in the world in terms of production of aquatic products and has experienced explosive growth over the past decade, resulting in a large amount of shellfish waste; therefore, hydrolysis of crayfish shells and further access to their hydrolysis products can solve the pollution of chitin waste and improve the use of the by-products with a high added value. There have been extensive literature reports on how to extract chitin from crayfish and its further processing and utilization, which would be discussed in the following section.
Astaxanthin is a type of carotenoid found mainly in aquatic animals and is responsible for the unique red color of crustaceans. It is also used as a natural pigment and can be extracted from algae, yeast, and shellfish by-products, including crayfish shells [
23]. It has high antioxidant activity due to its unique structure, which includes keto (C=O) and hydroxyl (OH) endings to donate hydrogen, and has a strong scavenging effect on free radicals and can act as an antioxidant, enhance immunity, prevent cancer, and improve human health through ultraviolet (UV) protection and anti-inflammatory activity [
24,
25]. Additionally, it can protect the central nervous and visual systems [
26,
27]. Moreover, as a therapeutic agent for a wide range of diseases without toxicity or side effects, it is an effective anti-tumor agent due to its ability to prevent the migration of cancer cells, anti-apoptosis, and anti-proliferation, and its involvement in the general support of the immune system [
28].
The lack of an adaptive immune system in crustaceans such as crayfish has led to the evolution of effective molecules such as antimicrobial peptides, which are used to defend against pathogenic microbes, which might inspire researchers to develop natural products rather than synthetic drugs for health or medical purposes. Anti-lipopolysaccharide factors (ALF) are a group of innate immunity effector molecules in arthropods that bind and neutralize lipopolysaccharides, and represent one of the most evolutionarily conserved cationic anti-microbial peptides broadly distributed among crustaceans. Sun presented the identification and characterization of an ALF from
P. clarkii (
PcALF1), and demonstrated a broad spectrum against Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria through the antimicrobial activity assay in vitro [
29]. Another new one from
Procambarus clarkii (
PcALF) showed a high level of transcription against the microbial pathogens administered, with a significant up-regulation against these pathogens being observed. PcALF may play a critical biological role in crayfish immune defense, suggesting a potential therapeutic agent for disease control and health management, based on its tissue expression patterns and responses to viral and bacterial challenges [
30]. It should be noted that only a few studies have described the ALF immune responses in invertebrates, especially crustaceans.
4. Processing and Preservation of Crayfish
Pretreatment: The industrialization challenges faced by farmers and producers in the crayfish industry, such as seasonal production and sales, have limited their development. In recent years, the crayfish processing industry has experienced rapid growth to address these issues. As an aquatic crustacean that grows in swamps and wetlands, thorough cleaning before processing is essential for ensuring food safety. The food industry has seen a trend towards the use of non-thermal techniques in the disinfection of food products due to their minimal impact on the texture, appearance, aroma, and nutritional composition of food products. Non-thermal disinfection techniques encompass high-pressure treatment, low-temperature plasma, ultrasound technology, ultraviolet radiation application, intense pulsed light utilization, and chemical disinfectants. Ultra-pressure treatment causes partial protein denaturation and muscle tissue tightening, resulting in increased hardness and reduced springiness. Treatment at 200 MPa for 5 min is optimal for peeling crayfish and preserving meat quality [
31]. It has been reported that moderate ultra-high-pressure treatments (less than 300 MPa) could be applied to modify the protein structure and water distribution of crayfish muscle [
32]. However, these critical technologies and processes for the production of the above products are immature, which to some extent limits the in-depth development of the crayfish industry. Ultrasound followed by ozone-water cleaning showed a better effect on the reduction of the total viable count (TVC) of crayfish than ozone-water cleaning followed by ultrasound cleaning and simultaneous ozone-water and ultrasound cleaning. The samples subjected to ozone-water cleaning treatment showed myofibril separation in tail meat and an increase in the pH, the myofibril fragment index, and thiobarbituric acid reactive substance (TBARS) content, but no significant effect on physical and sensory qualities was found [
33]. Recently, a decontamination technology that combines ultrasound and plasma-activated water was proposed and found to be more useful in microbial decontamination compared to the natural microbiota of crayfish, effectively inhibited microbial growth, and suppressed the oxidation of proteins and lipids during storage, resulting in a longer shelf life, and also effectively delayed the degradation of the textural and sensory properties of crayfish [
34].
Processing: The current processed product categories mainly include frozen boiled crayfish flesh, quick frozen cooked crayfish tails, quick frozen cooked whole crayfish, etc. [
35]. Research into crayfish processing methods has demonstrated that different techniques yield varying effects on crayfish quality(
Table 4). Generally, thermal treatment is a crucial step in the production of crayfish products. Elevated temperatures can effectively eliminate most surface and internal microorganisms in crayfish, deactivate enzymes, and reduce subsequent sterilization time, thereby enhancing product safety. Additionally, it can facilitate moderate nutrient hydroxylation, promoting improved human digestion and absorption. Furthermore, heating results in bright red coloration, an elastic and dense texture, as well as a distinctive flavor in crayfish. A study of the effect of cooking temperature and duration on the physicochemical, textural, structural, and microbiological characteristics of fresh crayfish showed that crayfish cooked at 93–95 °C for 3–5 min had the highest hardness at around 330–373 g. Higher temperatures also significantly reduced the total viable count [
35]. However, as the heating time increased, water loss and damage to the endomuscular membrane caused the muscle fiber microstructure to change from a compact to a loose state. The effect of different cooking techniques such as steaming (100 °C), boiling (100 °C), frying (160 °C), and high-pressure steaming (121 °C) on the quality of crayfish was compared. The astaxanthin content in crayfish increased significantly after cooking, and the content in the steamed crayfish (81.43%) was significantly higher than other cooking methods. The results indicated that both steaming and boiling resulted in superior taste and texture, while steaming also proved to be more effective in preserving the edible quality of crayfish meat due to its lower content of volatile compounds compared to frying, suggesting that steaming could be better for crayfish meat to maintain the edible quality [
36]. Microwave heating caused nutrient loss within acceptable ranges, but significantly decreased the fresh flavor and taste of crayfish following a linear trend. The effects of microwave and boiling on the quality of crayfish tail were studied using the visualization method, providing a new strategy for food cooking evaluation, and the loss of moisture during microwave heating of crayfish tails was much lower than that of whole crayfish when the tails were heated selectively and cooked rapidly [
37].
Preservation: Crayfish quality inevitably changes during storage. Enzymes such as trypsin-like proteases, cathepsin B, polyphenol oxidase, prophenol oxidase, and ATPase play important roles in proteolysis, melanin formation, and adensine triphosphate degradation, leading to muscle softening, melanosis, and loss of umami [
38]. More importantly, microbial activity is the main cause of off-flavors in crayfish during cryopreservation. Storage technology is key to processing and circulation. Commonly used storage technologies include freezing, ultra-high-pressure treatment, the addition of preservatives, edible coating, and modified atmosphere packaging (
Table 5). These storage methods focus on delaying the decomposition and deterioration of crayfish internal components, microbial growth and propagation, and reducing enzyme activity. At faster freezing rates, the formation of small intracellular ice crystals with minimal mechanical damage to structural properties would preserve cell membrane integrity to maintain supercooling status, contributing to better biochemical properties [
39]. The freezing temperature (liquid nitrogen, −80, −30, and −18 °C) and storage time (1, 4, 12, and 24 weeks) on the properties of red swamp crayfish were studied [
40]. The results showed that the freezing/storage temperature difference and freezing rate influenced the final quality of crayfish products, and freezing at −30 °C could be considered a suitable processing method for crayfish. Biochemical characterization results showed that liquid nitrogen freezing was helpful in inhibiting quality degradation, such as reducing TVC, TVB-N, and TBA, decreasing α-glucosidase and β-glucosidase enzyme activities, and delaying protein denaturation.
Edible coatings can effectively inhibit the reproduction of spoilage bacteria and enzyme activity during storage and delay the oxidation and decomposition of fat, thus maintaining product quality for a longer period. The application of an edible coating during crayfish storage can effectively inhibit the breeding of spoilage bacteria and enzyme activity and delay the oxidation and decomposition of fat, thus maintaining product quality for a longer period [
41]. The packaging of shelled crayfish with an edible coating containing red pitaya peel extract (RPPE) and ε-polylysine (ε-PL) retarded the quality deterioration of shelled crayfish during storage, and the coating combined with 2.0% RPPE was found to be preferred [
42].
Modified Atmosphere Packaging (MAP) is an innovative packaging technology utilized for the preservation of meat and meat products, effectively extending their shelf life without the need for preservatives [
43]. MAP involves carefully adjusting the composition of gases surrounding the food within a package, with oxygen to prevent anaerobic growth and maintain color, carbon dioxide to inhibit microbes, yeast, and mold, and nitrogen to prevent package collapse. Compared to traditional aerobic packaging, MAP significantly reduces microbial growth while ensuring the market quality and safety of meat products. Cremades revealed that by packaging cooked crayfish tails in a modified atmosphere consisting of 60% N
2 and 40% CO
2, the deterioration of quality was delayed from 6 days to 11–12 days [
44]. The safety of MAP might become a concern when meat preservation was subjected to elevated storage temperatures, as it may lead to the proliferation of anaerobic spoilage and pathogenic microbes [
43]. In this situation, smart label sensors with predictive models to indicate the quality of meat packed in a modified atmosphere are a potential technology to monitor the quality and safety of ready-to-eat foods like crayfish.
A variety of preservation methods are currently available, and utilizing biological preservatives instead of chemical ones can circumvent the impact of high-temperature sterilization on product quality. However, there remains a challenge in achieving sufficient sterilization and bacteriostatic effects when transitioning from single cryogenic storage technology to a combination of cryogenic and other preservation technologies. A study of the effects of lactic acid on the growth and survival of
Listeria monocytogenes in crayfish tail meat stored under refrigerated and various gaseous environments revealed that the combination of lactic acid and a modified atmosphere has significant potential to inhibit
L. monocytogenes growth [
45]. Furthermore, employing low-concentration complex organic acids alongside autoclave treatments has shown promise in enhancing the quality characteristics of crayfish meat, including texture, color, and sensory attributes, thereby presenting a novel approach for developing ambient storage crayfish products [
46]. Additionally, microwave treatment in combination with sodium lactate and the antimicrobial peptide nisin has shown significant efficacy in inhibiting the spoilage of crayfish tails, as evidenced by the reduced total viable count after 3 days of storage at room temperature, which meets the transit time requirements of most logistics companies in China [
47].
A key finding of this review is that although over 90% of international trade is based on processed products, live fish/shellfish are particularly appreciated in Asia and other niche markets where aquariums and tanks displaying live fish are increasingly common in seafood restaurants, supermarkets, and retail outlets. Particularly, people prefer to consume fresh crayfish, preferably when they can see it alive before processing; in this case, keeping alive is more important than preservation. The stress response, caused by exposure to adverse environmental conditions or physical handling, is an adaptive mechanism to cope with stressors in order to maintain a homeostatic state. It involves a series of sequential events (responses), beginning with an initial neuroendocrine response that results in changes in appearance and quality [
48,
49]. It has been studied in many different vertebrate and invertebrate species. For example, during the long-time transportation of white leg shrimp (
Penaeus vannamei), the pH of the water and the content of total ammonia nitrogen and non-ionized ammonia were elevated. Shrimp muscle water holding capacity, hardness, and shear were also reduced with intensive myofibrillar protein degradation [
50]. Packing in pre-cooled sawdust or wood shavings is used to minimize stress during transport. Black tiger shrimp (
Penaeus monodon) and freshwater shrimp (
Macrobrachium rosenbergii) can be packed in plastic bags containing water and oxygen, and softshell blue crabs are shipped at 4 °C in moist marsh grass or newspapers [
51]. At present, it mainly focuses on the development and application of preservation technology for crayfish, and researchers need to focus on crayfish habits and study how to keep crayfish alive during long-term logistics and shelf life.
Table 4.
Various processing methods on the quality of the crayfish.
Table 4.
Various processing methods on the quality of the crayfish.
Processing Methods | Effects | Reference |
---|
Steaming | Excellent taste; good hardness and chewiness; low cooking loss rate; low fat oxidation degree. | [36] |
Frying | More cooking loss; high fat oxidation degree; more volatile compounds. | [36] |
High-pressure steam | More cooking loss; high astaxanthin content; good smell; decrease in springiness. | [36] |
Microwave | More cooking loss; high cooking uniformity. | [37] |
Sous vide cooking | Less cooking loss; good texture; low TBA value. | [52] |
Table 5.
Various preservation technologies on the quality of the crayfish.
Table 5.
Various preservation technologies on the quality of the crayfish.
Technologies | Conditions | Effects | Reference |
---|
Freezing treatment | Storage at freezing temperature with liquid nitrogen (−80, −30, and −18 °C) for 1, 4, 12, and 24 weeks | The Ca2+-ATPase activity, the salt soluble protein content, and the total and reactive sulphhydryl content of the myofibrillar protein extracted from crayfish were significantly decreased (p < 0.05), and the expressible moisture was significantly increased (p < 0.05). The recommended shelf life for crayfish is 1 month. | [40] |
Edible coating | A solution of chitosan containing propolis extract emulsions | Compared to the control group, the shelf life of the crayfish was increased by 7 days. | [41] |
Gelatin incorporated with red pitaya peel methanol extract | The values for total volatile basic nitrogen (TVB-N), K maintenance, and free amino acids (FAAs) decreased significantly (p < 0.05). | [42] |
MAP | 60% N2 and 40% CO2 | Inhibited the growth of psychrophilic bacterial, hydrogen sulfide-producing bacteria, and Enterobacteriaceae, reduced the content of TVB-N, and inhibited lipid peroxidation. | [44] |
Ultrasound assisted | Alginate oligosaccharide (1%, w/v) with ultrasound-assisted (40 W, 3 min) soaking | Increased the water retention, α-helix and β-fold content of cooked crayfish after five freeze–thaw cycles, and contributed to the structural stability of myofibrillar protein. | [53] |
Ultrasound-assisted chitosan nano-composite water retaining agent | TVB-N, the content of myofibrillar protein, and the Ca2+-ATPase activity of the muscle protein were significantly delayed, thus preserving the integrity of the tissue structure. | [54] |
Combination | Complex organic acids, high-temperature sterilization | Improved meat quality after sterilization, such as texture, color, and sensory characteristics. | [46] |
Microwave, sodium lactate, and the antimicrobial peptide nisin | Significant inhibition of spoilage as measured by total viable count (4.15 log CFU/g) after 3 days storage at room temperature. | [47] |
6. Safety Evaluation
The factors affecting the safety of crayfish products can be broadly categorized into two types: microbial and chemical pollutants. Microorganisms include pathogenic bacteria, parasites, and viruses, whereas chemical pollutants include heavy metals, pesticide residues, and veterinary drug residues. Crayfish are similar to many other aquatic organisms in terms of pesticide residues and microbials-related safety issues, so instead of discussing them here, we focus on heavy metal and drug enrichment due to crayfish growth habits. In addition, another risk of consuming crayfish are allergens.
Heavy metals are a group of metals with relative densities greater than 4.0. Elements like lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), and chrome (Cr) and metallic elements like arsenic (As) may increase the risk of cardiovascular disease, teratogenicity, skin disorders, and cancer [
104,
105,
106]. Mercury (Hg) damages the central nervous system, while inorganic Hg compounds damage the kidneys [
107]. Crayfish have strong accumulation characteristics for heavy metals, and the heavy metal content in their bodies may be several times that of the surrounding environment. Therefore, the problem of heavy metal residues in crayfish has been a concern. The exposure of crayfish to Cd causes histological alterations in the intestines and alters the richness, diversity, and composition of the intestinal microbiota [
108]. The concentrations of Cr, As, Pb, Cd, and Hg were recorded in the abdominal muscle, gonads, and hepatopancreas. The hepatopancreas is the primary organ for Cd, As, and Pb deposition, the abdominal muscle is the ideal organ for Cr and Hg deposition, and the gonads are the primary organs for As deposition [
107]. The concentrations of copper (Cu), Cr, Cd, zinc (Zn), and Pb were measured in the water and sediment, and in the muscles and exoskeletons of crayfish. The bioaccumulation of heavy metals in crayfish is within standard guidelines, except in highly polluted drains. It is recommended that crayfish in drainage and contaminated waterways should not be consumed by humans, as muscles and exoskeletons specifically accumulate Hg and Ni, respectively; meanwhile, Cd, Zn, Cu, Pb, and Cr primarily accumulate in the hepatopancreas [
109]. There were significant differences in the distribution of heavy metals in wild and farmed crayfish. In general, the average concentration of heavy metals is higher in the wild crayfish than in the cultured crayfish. In both farmed and wild crayfish, hepatopancreas was the most concentrated tissue, followed by gills, exoskeleton, and abdominal muscle [
110]. The accumulation sequence of the elements in the different tissues was gill > foot > muscle, with most of the elements accumulating in the gill tissues, whereas Hg was concentrated in the abdominal muscle and Zn in the foot tissues. It is worth noting that the levels of toxic elements were lower in the abdominal muscle than in the exoskeleton and hepatopancreas, which are not recommended for consumption [
111].
In order to obtain better quality crayfish, some pharmaceuticals may be used in the breeding process. Pyrethroid pesticides are used for pest control in both agriculture and aquaculture. The study showed that deltamethrin induces DNA damage, immunotoxicity, and neurotoxicity in crayfish through the excessive generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) [
112]. Deltamethrin is acutely toxic to crayfish hemolymph, gill, muscle, and liver, and the study showed LC50s for 24, 48, and 96 h of 0.156, 0.099, and 0.056 μg/L, respectively [
113]. Diclofenac (DCF) is an anti-inflammatory drug widely used worldwide for veterinary and medical purposes. It can induce the differential expression of immune- and redox-related genes in crayfish, and regulate the processes of molting, amino sugar metabolism, proteolysis, and intracellular protein transport in crayfish. In addition, DCF can alter the relative abundance of microbial families in the gut, leading to the disruption of the gut microbiota, which may further contribute to intestinal metabolic dysfunction in crayfish [
114].
Additionally, serious allergic reactions can occur in some people who consume crayfish. Common symptoms include skin symptoms, gastrointestinal reactions, and systemic symptoms such as rashes, vomiting, respiratory distress, and shock in severe cases, which can be life threatening. Tropomyosin, arginine kinase, triose-phosphate isomerase, and hemocyanin subunits are the main identified and characterized allergens of crayfish [
115,
116]. Tropomyosin, a thermally stable myofibrillar protein consisting of two subunits with molecular masses of 36–38 kDa, is the major allergen in crayfish, which has been purified and immunologically characterized. Now, research on other allergens and cross-reactivity is being strengthened gradually. Chen et al. identified crayfish arginine kinase as an allergen, cloned the protein for B-cell epitope prediction, and evaluated physicochemical, processing stability, and immunological properties [
117]. The sarcoplasmic calcium-binding protein with a molecular mass of 22 kDa was also confirmed as a novel red crayfish allergen by mass spectrometry determination of its IgE-binding activity. Physicochemical characterization showed it to be a highly stable allergen, and it was recently reported to be cross-reactive with triosephosphate isomerase [
118]. Myosin light chain myosin and light chain isoform 1 were reported to be novel allergens in crayfish by Zhang et al. [
119] and Yang et al. [
120], respectively. Crayfish light chain isoform 1 showed a high degree of primary and secondary structural identity with myosin light chain, its epitopes were located in the structurally conserved regions, and its cross-reactivity between related species was demonstrated by immunological assays.
With the increasing prevalence of crayfish allergy, scientifically sound processing methods have become an important option available for preventing allergic subjects from anaphylactic reactions; for example, light chain isoform 1 was stable at 30 to 100 °C and under highly acidic and alkaline conditions, and retained its IgE-binding activity at different temperatures and pH values. The sarcoplasm calcium-binding protein is a stable polymorphic allergen in crayfish, and all its isotypes and subunits are allergenic. The common desensitization processing technologies are ultra-high pressure treatment [
121], high intensity ultrasound [
122], radiation reduction [
123], enzymatic treatment [
124], etc. Food-sourced chemical reagents or food ingredients could be a novel way applied to specifically eliminate allergic reactions, with the advantages of fewer adverse effects, high safety, and low cost [
125]. Recently, the immunoregulatory properties of natural bioactive compounds, such as polyphenols, polysaccharides, and oligosaccharides, have been extensively studied. This suggests their potential in the prevention and treatment of human diseases. However, the utilization of natural products for eradicating crayfish allergens has been infrequently documented. Chlorogenic acid, as one of the most abundant acids within the realm of phenolic acid compounds, naturally occurring in extracts of green coffee and tea, can address crayfish allergies by reducing the sensitizing properties of tropomyosin through covalent or noncovalent binding, altering its secondary structure and masking the linear epitope of tropomyosin [
126].
8. Conclusions
The crayfish, abundant in proteins, minerals, trace elements, and a variety of vitamins, is an aquatic delicacy with exceptional nutritional value. The future will see continued research and development in the nutritional composition, functional components, and bioactive properties of crayfish. In addition, the advancements in crayfish deep processing techniques are demanded to create products such as fried/dried crayfish meat and crayfish-sourced sauce, which would involve flavor retention problems during processing and fermentation manufacturing. Moreover, various preservation technologies, especially the technology of keeping alive, should be developed and combined to overcome seasonal or regional limitations and develop safe and efficient methods for preserving crayfish. These innovations will expand the utilization of crayfish and open up new opportunities for the growth of the industry.
Driven by increasing market demand, the crayfish industry is expected to maintain a medium-to-high growth rate. In this context, the efficient utilization of such a scale of waste or by-products will present itself as both an opportunity and a challenge. Intensive processing will also progress steadily with a focus on efficiently utilizing by-product resources from crayfish to produce high-value items like enzyme preparations and chitosan microcapsules that can find applications in biomedicine, cosmetics, food, fertilizers, and environmental protection materials. Furthermore, efforts will be made to upgrade extraction technology to explore new environmentally friendly methods for effectively utilizing by-product resources from crayfish, as only a single component of crayfish shell can be recovered through traditional chemical processes, and the ideal by-products’ comprehensive utilization should be biorefining combing with other eco-technologies, which are proposed to separate them into different fractions that can be converted into valuable products.