Kinematic Fields Measurement during Orthogonal Cutting Using Digital Images Correlation: A Review

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

Good orgnization and originality was found in the review paper, and the quality of the work as far as the amount of the reported data for the key issues of kinematic fields measurent using DIC are very appreciable. And the munuscript can be accept after minor revision.

Fig. 2, readability needs to be improved, change the direction of text.

Fig. 6, change "Based polishing technique" to "Polishing based technique".

Author Response

Hello,

"Please see the attachment"

You find attached response to Reviewer 1.

Modifications are made to the manuscript according to the comments.

Best regards,

Haythem

 

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf

Reviewer 2 Report

The paper presents an intensive review of the use of digital image correlation for the measurement of kinematic field in otrthogonal cutting. The review paper is of good quality and cite relevant sources. There are only few detail comments:

line 164: 'overlap between the speckle is possible' this needs additional information: is it an issue ? are there solutions to theses issues ?

line 169: 'Moreover, most of the commertial and academic DIC softwares are used the local approach' typo in 'commertial', word missing between 'are used' and 'the local'

under equation (3): some comment would be necessary concerning the difference and the relative advantages/drawbacck of the methods cited

line 174: a more detailled conclusion is needed on that part to guide the reader on that point

 

Author Response

Hello,

 

"Please see the attachment".

You find attached response to Reviewer 2.

Modifications are made to the manuscript according to the comments.

Best regards,

Haythem

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf