1. Introduction
This study took origin from the invitation received from the members of the city council of Vogogna, a town of about 1687 inhabitants, to arrange an academic workshop in its historical center. The municipality was looking for a collaboration with the university to develop the analysis of the locally built heritage, with the request to verify the possible development of a cultural path through the main points of interest offered by the context. Vogogna is a small town placed in Ossola Valley (
Figure 1), a mountainous district of North Italy, in the Piedmont region [
1]. The historical center includes a broad medieval settlement composed of multi-story houses, noble palaces, churches, porticoed streets and defensive structures. The town was an important administrative center of the Ossola Valley in the past, but nowadays it has undergone a serious economic crisis, diffused in this area of Piedmont [
2]. The changes in the main productive activities of the region, like metallurgical industry and the progressive abandonment of traditional trade linked to the rock quarries, produced a negative economic impact in the area. Among the various solutions promoted by local authorities, the empowerment of cultural services appeared as a promising asset for future job opportunities. Thus, the Municipality of Vogogna subscribed to a convention with the School of Architecture, Urban Planning, Construction Engineering of Politecnico di Milano, specifically with the Preservation Studio course coordinated by the authors.
The aim of the convention is to develop historical analyses, advanced geometrical surveys, investigation tests and conservation designs on some selected historical buildings of Vogogna. The request also concerned the ruins of the medieval fortress near the city center, built on a promontory of the mountain that rises behind the town. The municipality gave the opportunity to the course participants to access some public buildings and promoted the involvement of some private owners in the initiative to open some parts of their property to the students. The aim of the Preservation Studio is to offer training in setting up and finalizing a conservation design [
3]. The students, divided in teams and coordinated by the teaching staff, experienced the common activities requested by the Italian Cultural Heritage Code [
4] for achieving an in-depth knowledge of the historical buildings and developing the various steps of the conservation process: analysis of the urban context, the environmental scenario, the architectural features of the assigned buildings, the constructive techniques, defining the strategy for preserving the architectural heritage and for introducing new functions. The final goal of the studio was the setting of a valorization strategy for promoting the historical relevance of the analyzed building and its significance with respect to the local community [
5].
In Vogogna, a general idea of enhancement was indicated by the mayor, involved since 2020 with the regional councilor in the request for public fundings to the Ministry of Culture in Rome, for a set of interventions on different buildings of the city center. His public declarations indicated a plan for reinforcing the touristic role of the town in the Ossola Valley by the restoration of some public properties, a coordinated activity among new touristic services, the implementation of the local museum housed in the 14th century castle and the connection with different recreational paths offered by the natural park surrounding the town, the Val Grande park, characterized by the largest wilderness area in Italy [
6]. The presence of a relevant historical center and the cultural landscape offered by the protected natural area became the main assets for revitalizing the local economy.
An important part of the budget obtained by the Ministry of Culture was committed for the conservation design of the fortress of Vogogna, a military structure characterized by a tall square tower, belonging to a larger system of watchtowers, constructed to protect the Ossola Valley from the invasions coming from the neighboring Swiss cantons [
7]. The ruins are immersed in the forest that grows along the slopes of the mountain overlooking the city. This work presents the results matured by a multidisciplinary study campaign addressed to the analysis of the state of conservation of the fortress of Vogogna and the evaluation of the future reuse of its structures.
2. Research Questions and Goals
The main issue of the work concerns the complexity of the ruined fortress here considered. The building was organized on different levels, presenting an articulated distribution along the slope of the mountain, characterized by the presence of terraces, partially collapsed or completely hidden by the spontaneous vegetation. Accessibility is difficult, and the existing surveys of the fortress are limited to the plan of the higher level and two elevations. For the complete analysis of the ruin, a full survey is necessary: the graphic representation of the various portions of the building requires a survey of the main prospects and the development of several sections. The common survey techniques, like direct measurements and photogrammetry, are difficult to apply here due to the irregular condition of the ground and the irregular shape of the architectural elements. A laser scanner was considered the most reliable technique for obtaining the geometrical model of the fortress, but the relevant slope of the land and the vegetation required the use of a drone unit to survey all the parts of the site.
The work presented the first important issue regarding the most suitable advanced survey techniques to be integrated into a digital model for the elaboration of 2D geometrical views (plans, prospects and sections) and 3D representations [
8]. Connected to this kind of digital model, the representation of the material components of the building can be arranged by integrating high-resolution pictures and algorithms for digital rectification to obtain very detailed maps of the stone masonry characterizing the surfaces of walls, a fundamental step for further elaboration, including the mapping of materials and their decays.
This level of detail in the technical drawings is not available in the existing documentation, but a clear identification of the masonry patterns, together with the nature of the different stones, could allow further observations concerning the stratigraphic analysis of the building.
The conservation design includes the solutions for the interventions on the decayed materials and the task concerning the ruins of the structures that are exposed to the environment without any protection.
The aim of the study is to assess whether the fortress ruins can play a strategic role within the broader heritage enhancement plan proposed by the municipality of Vogogna, fostering stronger links with the tourism opportunities provided by the Val Grande National Park, to which the town belongs.
3. Materials and Methods
The work is based on a literature review which includes the last theoretical studies on three main issues: the valorization principles for the cultural heritage [
9,
10,
11], the digital twin applied to the built heritage [
12,
13], and the conservation practices for archeological sites exposed to the natural environment [
14,
15].
The research also includes on-field activities. Thanks to the agreement with the municipality of Vogogna, it was possible to consult archive documents useful for understanding the measures adopted to protect the fortress and make it part of a structured path with the other medieval architectures of the village. The collection of literary sources on local history, consisting of dated texts, often no longer on the market, was supported by some members of the local cultural association of Lower Ossola, whose guidance was also useful for understanding the cultural strategies introduced in the area in agreement with the municipal administration. Furthermore, the complexity of the fortress required two full days with three operators for recording the on-site measurements based on advanced survey techniques.
The municipality archive provided documents concerning conservation designs carried out on some public properties, and was also fruitful to outline the vision adopted by past and present administrators for the valorization of this territory, promoting challenging re-functionalization of some ancient buildings, like the Visconteo Castle and the Praetorium Palace, the concession of public properties to private subjects in exchange for the restoration of the building, like for the headquarters of the Val Grande Park, housed into an historical palace. Through the archive, it was observed that the fortress was regularly maintained against the growth of spontaneous vegetation on its walls, ensuring that the ruins receive basic care against dangerous interactions with the plant elements of the surrounding forest.
The advanced survey was carried out by laser scanning, organized through a topographic network, supported by a drone. The combination of the data recorded by these devises was fundamental to overpass several limitations during the acquisition phase, due to the roughness of the terrain, the presence of the vegetation and the risks connected to the steep terrain on some sides of the complex. The obtained 3D model was further used for the elaboration of the 2D views used during the analysis of the conservation state of the building and the preservation design.
3.1. Short Description of the Case Study and Its Context
The small town of Vogogna presents a wide medieval center, where palaces, churches, civic and defensive structures are constructed from stone masonry, sometimes covered with colored plaster, sometimes with exposed stone blocks, characterized by roofing systems with slates (
Figure 2). The defensive system of the town is now partially lost. It was set during the 14th century, when Giovanni Visconti, archbishop of Novara and future Lord of Milan, transformed the village into the seat of power for the south part of Ossola Valley [
16], in contrast with Domodossola, capital of the upper Ossola. In the medieval period, the main cities under Visconti rule replicated the civic model of the Broletto Palace, a building used for public functions [
17]. In Vogogna, this public building for the administration of justice and other public services was built in 1348 at the behest of the archbishop of Novara [
18] (pp. 177–188), in the main central square of the town. It is known as the Praetorium Palace. The castle, known as Visconti Castle (
Figure 3a), located on top of the town center, not far away from the Praetorium Palace, is considered part of a defensive system that includes walls and city gates. Some portions of the defensive walls are now incorporated into other buildings. The experts also considered the ruins of the fortress of Vogogna, housed on the mountain hanging over the village, as a component of that defensive system [
18] (p. 317), probably pre-existing, but later strengthened when the city increased its importance.
During the 15th century, several attacks against Vogogna were documented [
19] (pp. 9–52). The antagonism between the southern Swiss cities, Domodossola and Vogogna, was testified by frequent military sieges. In 1514, during an attack coordinated by the army from Domodossola, the fortress was deeply damaged and never repaired. Its decadence was characterized by the progressive degradation of its structures that were also reused for rural activities. The ruins of the fortress present a significant portion of the square tower, considered the first original nucleus of a complex, large defensive walls and two circular towers at the south-east and south-west corners. The experts consider that the square tower, at the highest point of the fortification, was part of an observation system along the valley of the Toce river [
18,
19]: other similar square towers were built halfway up the hill and the ones in Cadezza, Valle Anzasca and Cimamulera are still visually connected. When Giovanni Visconti constructed the Praetorium Palace in Vogogna, new integrations were added to the fortress, expanding its perimeter and adapting the walls with new buttress and round surfaces for better contrasting the new gunpowder-based weapons since the 15th century.
The ruins of the fortress (
Figure 3b) are part of the cultural landscape of the area. They appear from a peak of the Orsetto Mountain, behind the historical center of Vogogna, and are close to the rural hamlet of Genestredo (
Figure 3c), a village located a few hundred above the town, made of stone houses organized on different levels due to the slope of the land, crossed by narrow paved paths, with some squares for community activities provided with washboard and fountain, and a 16th century chapel with a wide pronaos decorated with fresco works.
3.2. The Countermeasures Against the Negative Socio-Economic Trend in Ossola Valley
Since the last decades of the 20th century, the strong de-industrialization that occurred in several valleys of Piedmont produced a deep socio-economic impact in the mountainous areas of the region [
20]. The north-east Province of Verbano-Cusio Ossola, where the large number of workers were employed in the mechanical and mining industries, experienced a deep conversion towards the tertiary sector. The socio-economic scenario, based on permanent positions in the secondary sector, experienced an increment in the building sector and the business services [
21]. The analysts consider the new condition to be associated with a more diffused precarious employment [
22] as the cause of the depopulation of some areas of this district. Vogogna, where the rural economy was replaced by the extractive activities for stones and metals, still preserves some industrial archeological sites. Nowadays, marble quarries and metallurgic factories are misused. The promotion of the service industry appeared through the increasing development of commercial and craft. Those ones are established along the main communication roads, like the Simplon Street, the axis connecting Milan to France across Lombardy and Piedmont, passing through Vogogna. The consequence was the drastic decline of commercial activities from the historical center of Vogogna, where the ancient medieval galleries are now facing closed shops. Even those fundamental services housed here for centuries, like the pharmacy and the doctor’s surgery, moved out of the center with other traditional businesses, like the bakery, the dairy and the ironmonger.
The lack of services and a built heritage characterized by housing conditions that are very far from the standard requirements of contemporary living led to a remarkable depopulation of the historical center. The residents moved to the outer city, where parking spaces are available, and the main services are reachable by car. The ancient properties in the center are not abandoned, but simply unexploited. The owners guaranteed the correct maintenance, even the restoration in such cases, renewing the plasters, controlling the roof efficiency with the arrangement of the slates, strengthening the load-bearing walls, but some buildings are now showing signs of neglectfulness, with the disruption of the coatings, and in some cases, the collapse of the roofs.
The reduction in the population, due to the migration of the young residents to other towns offering better working opportunities, left a segment of the elderly citizens in Vogogna. The residences in the city center, like in Genestredo hamlet, are now used as second houses during the holiday periods. As a result, the town has lost several essential services for the community, from the public medical clinic to the secondary schools, making the context of Vogogna very similar to that of the so-called “internal areas”. Those territories are characterized by small towns presenting severe limitations in essential services: health, education and mobility. To contrast the marginalization of such areas, since 2014, some legislative acts have been implemented to promote territorial cohesion at national level [
23]. The national strategy for the revitalization of fragile contexts is part of the cohesion policies for the territories coordinated by the European Government and implemented by national and regional measures. The issue is duly treated in recent studies [
24], providing a clear picture of the situation that several small centers like Vogogna are experiencing; small villages cannot survive due to the birth-rate fall, the migration of the few young subjects, the increase in a population composed by old people not able to keep the community alive. This condition brings the small centers to an inevitable impoverishment, with the drying up of the local activities, the suppression of public services and the disappearance of the cultural characteristics of the place.
According to the above-mentioned considerations, Vogogna appears in a borderline condition, intent on managing the changes in the local economy, looking for a solution to combine the needs of the present with the preservation of the remarkable historical center and the surrounding natural environment. The tourist vacation of the place is emerging as a strategic asset for the future development of the town. Vogogna hosts the headquarters of the Val Grande natural park and is listed in the association “Most beautiful villages in Italy”, on behalf of the National Association of Italian Municipalities (ANCI).
Since the rediscovery of proximity tourism, after the recent COVID health crisis [
25], growing flows of tourists coming from nearby areas were also observed in Vogogna. Here the visitors can find a well-structured offer for exploring the natural park, while the cultural services are still limited. Vogogna presents several points of interest, but they are not always open and accessible. The role of the cultural institutions of the town requires coordinated interventions and general empowerment, in line with the recommendations issued by the Department for the Territorial Cohesion, indicating the local cultural heritage as the driving force for the development of small communities, through the reinforcement of local traditions and the protection of tangible and intangible values embodied in the built heritage. The focus is to reconnect the inhabitants with their living context, reinforcing the relationship among history, traditions, work activities and cultural aspects. This place-based strategy does not invest on specific driving sectors, like industrial or agricultural activities, for developing business and employment opportunities, but prefers to consider the different fields characterizing a territory and address them to a common convergence, the preservation of technical knowledge, investing on the formation of a human capital that in a long-view perspective will provide the conditions to improve and reactivate economic, social, cultural and environmental sectors of the territory [
26].
Since 2022, the administration of Vogogna has been working on the issue of the depopulation of its historical center. Following the recommendations issued at a national and regional level to counteract the marginalization of mountain towns, the municipality managed to obtain fundings to be allocated to a series of interventions with a dual objective: to conserve the architectural heritage and to structure an effective cultural path that leads visitors from the historic center, through the hamlet of Genestredo, to the fortress and then inside the paths of the natural park. As requested by the administration in the Convention between the municipality and Politecnico di Milano, the authors analyzed the case of the fortress, considering its role in the natural context, but also its role and the relationship with the local community, developing a design proposal for its valorization.
5. Discussion on the Valorization Principles for the Reuse Design of the Fortress
The various steps of the conservation process are useful to develop a deep knowledge of the building from a historical and technological point of view. The challenging goal of the preservation plan is the activation of that wealth of knowledge developed during the analysis of the different aspects of the building. This is a way to share knowledge, from the historical facts concerning this fortification, to the constructive solutions expressed by the local building culture in different periods of time. The involvement of visitors and members of the local community is considered the key point for guaranteeing a virtuous relationship with the building and the requirements for maintaining its structures in an efficient condition [
44], preserving its material components, recognizing eventual decays before their degeneration, providing the continuous fruition of its spaces and the chance to interpretate tangible and intangible significance from its physical parts.
Until now, the fortress was a ruin belonging to the archeological path set into the borders of the natural park Val Grande. In detail, from the hamlet of Genestredo, a pedestrian path takes the visitors to the fortress, surrounded by the forest, accessible from an arched opening into the north wall. The entire area shows the deep relationship between the inhabitants and the landscape, characterized by several dry walls as many terraces along the footway. Left in a misused condition, without any surveillance, the fortress appears along the lane as a suggestive memory of the past, like a romantic trace of the Middle Ages, now colonized by nature. For the visitors, its attractivity is more an esthetic experience than a dive into the past of this location. A deeper connection to the building can be established, improving the accessibility to the site and safe areas into its fence. In this way, visitors can be given the chance to explore deeper significance by observing the various spaces of the complex and interpreting its articulated stratifications. This condition is close to the idea of ruin discussed by Simmel [
45] and Benjamin [
46], based on the esthetics of the sublime, intended as melancholy derived from the vision of nature appropriating man’s work and reducing it to ruin. The topic of ruins belonging to medieval castles has been considered by several authors in Europe with the diffusion of the adaptive reuse design [
47].
In Italy, the adaptation designed by Werner Tscholl for the Firmiano Castle [
48] is a milestone for this design approach and the idea that valorization of existing buildings can be obtained by integrations and the addition of functions and services [
49], as a balance between conservation of the past with contemporary needs [
50]. This trend characterizes similar solutions on medieval castles in other European regions [
51], as stated by communitarian researchers on the reuse of ruins [
52]. Ruins can be used as simple site museums, like in the Castle of Urquhart in Scotland [
53], becoming part of stage performances, using the large areas into their fortified fence, or museums articulated in various exposition spaces with areas for touristic services. In this last case, the reuse design can present an adaptive approach, due to the modifications required for the setting up of the new functions. Despite the different scale compared to the Vogogna case, the three castles in Bellinzona constitute an interesting term of comparison between the Ossola fortress and the possible solutions for its reuse. As observed in the historical analysis of Vogogna, the Visconti family and later the Sforza Family implemented the fortifications of Bellinzona, part of the Duchy of Milan until 1499, when the Helvetic coalition defeated the army from Milan. The lower fortress, Castelgrande, houses the museum of the history of the town. Here, the reuse design curated by Aurelio Galfetti [
54] introduced important strategic services for the visitors into hidden and partially underground areas of the complex, remodeling the public space into the fence as an urban park to reconnect the isolated defensive building to the rest of the town. The exhibited contrast between the modern interventions and the historical architecture is evocative of the famous post-war intervention conducted by Carlo Scarpa at the Castelvecchio museum in Verona [
55]. The transformations are less exhibited, even if recognizable, in the other two castles in Bellinzona: the Montebello Castle, smaller than the first, with its archeological museum housed in the surviving buildings of the complex, and the Sasso Corbaro Castle, museum of itself. These last two castles underwent some transformations due to the introduction of the new functions, but in these cases, the adaptive design follows a coevolutionary approach, a way to address the focus on the dynamic relationships between the historical building and the contemporary reality.
The difference between adaptive reuse and coevolution was recently analyzed by Della Torre [
56], emphasizing the dynamic interplay between buildings and their social and environmental contexts, shifting the conservation of the built heritage from a static approach to the process of managing change. The cultural value of architecture, such as historical, esthetic and social significance, is not crystallized in time but evolves along with social changes. Coevolution requires the continuous re-evaluation of these values during the preparation and application of the protection process. Coevolution emphasizes the participation of stakeholders, such as communities and experts, to achieve the social and economic sustainability of the costs required by conservation practices through collaboration empowerment. To this purpose, the valorization design of the fortress in Vogogna was founded on the community involvement through the implantation of the accessibility to the archeological site. A similar project can be observed in the Liguria region, where the ruins of the Dolceacqua Castle were restored and valorized through the implementation of pathways to improve the accessibility of the site for residents and tourists [
57]. To allow people with mobility difficulties to visit the site, which is divided into several levels by steep flights of stairs, the designers introduced new ramps and stairs, in Corten steel, equipped with stairlifts. The intervention is placed-based and attributes to the community engagement the key role for maintaining continuous attention on the historic building by frequent site visits, to allow the development of citizen-driven organizations (simple volunteers or public associations) involved in the control of the state of conservation of the ruins and in verifying the appropriate use of their spaces. This idea of an upgrading project based on the necessary transformations and integrations for assuring universal accessibility to cultural sites is also proposed for the analysis of the Pescopagano Castle (Potenza Province) in South Italy [
58]. In this case, presenting some similarities with the fortress in Vogogna, the relationship between the ruins on an unreachable hill and the community of the city below are put together again through an inclined lift. According to these examples, the proposal for the valorization of the fortress in Vogogna considered the setting of a footpath to access the archeological site.
To access inside the fence, the visitors must leave the path in the woods and walk on a rock-bed lane. It is not safe due to the presence of stone surfaces with different inclinations, and the passage is also close to a slope along the west side of the promontory. A solution to extend the accessibility for all into a natural park is hard to find, but in Europe there are some experiences showing possible alternatives. According to the site’s topography, electric shuttle services or lift systems are used to ensure accessibility for visitors with disabilities in these protected areas. In the case of the upper castle of Vogogna, the proposal for valorizing the archeological site can include a strategic cultural path from the center of the town to the upper hamlet of Genestredo, with its characteristic vernacular architecture, to the fortress (
Figure 12). To this purpose, the design proposal includes a dedicated route to explore the fortress from a disappeared pathway, developed around the walls of the building, from the lower terraces to the top. This hypothesis was supported by the design of a footway composed of ramps and stairs to facilitate access to the fortress. This solution cannot match the requirements of complete accessibility for all [
59], but it goes in the direction of a constant community involvement to give life to the site and maintain constant control over it. Thus, a system of stairlifts was proposed to guarantee the inclusion of subjects with limited walking capacity.
The archeological site can be accessed from two directions. The old path, originating from Vogogna Castle and leading to the foot of the fortress on the western slope, could be reopened. This way, currently obscured by vegetation, features a long-distance external stair lift to facilitate access for those with mobility impairments. This solution not only facilitates access for people with disabilities but also creates a direct connection between the castle and the fortress, faster than the existing path from Genestredo, enriching the tourist offering with the creation of a circular circuit. The other entry is from the hamlet of Genestredo, easily accessible by car. From there, a path leads directly to the fortress. At the end of this path, a footbridge provides a connection to the main entrance, avoiding the winding and dangerous existing path (but maintaining its layout).
The reuse design is founded on the assumption that the consolidated image of the ruined castle should be preserved, with the mass of the square tower still recognizable and a few crenelated structures barely drafted because of war devastation and long abandonment. The ramps of the footway are integrated with the stones of the fortress by using the aesthetical properties of Corten steel plates (
Figure 13). The walkways, constructed with a steel load-bearing structure complete with Corten steel railings and a walking surface made of non-slip composite wood planks, features expanded Corten steel sheeting underneath to cover the void below (
Figure 14). This sheet follows the slope of the land, visually recalling the typical stepped structures of terraced landscapes. The new path is connected by stairs integrated with the existing levels of the terraces, leading to the initial level of the walkway on the west elevation.
Inside the fence of the fortress, the embarkments are leveled to host safe draining funds. The aim is to improve the accessibility to the ruin for public use of the internal area of the fortress to improve the direct contact of the visitors with the ruins for their contemplative fruition, and to establish new relationships based on the contemporary context: art performances, sport activities, etc.
Among the various public events that could be organized inside the ruined fortress, the authors focused on a sport discipline that has taken hold in the area in recent years. The design of the spaces contemplates the possible transformation of the site into an outdoor climbing gym, exploiting the sturdy walls of the fortress as rock faces. Minimum climbing heights are respected in selecting suitable climbing walls. Recent initiatives promoted by sport associations took place on the medieval walls of the lower fortress of Vogogna, the Visconteo castle (
Figure 15). In this area, surrounded by mountains, trekking, canyoning and climbing are diffused in local communities. The proposal for assigning the function of a climbing training area to the fortress matured during a direct confrontation with some exponents of the public institutions of Vogogna, attributing a positive spillover effect to the climbing competition organized on the Visconteo Castle. Furthermore, suitable areas are selected for three different types of climbing. Among the various disciplines, bouldering, top rope and lead climbing are easily adaptable to the project, and each has its own specific characteristics and requirements (
Figure 16).
Bouldering is a form of climbing practiced on rocks or walls without the use of safety ropes. Climbers tackle sequences of technical moves in short routes. The lack of heavy equipment, requiring only a pair of climbing shoes and a specific mat placed on a flat surface to prevent falls, makes it accessible to a wide audience and a very popular discipline in urban parks and natural areas.
Top-roping involves climbing with an anchor placed at the top of a wall, through which a rope is passed, connected to the climber and secured to a partner on the ground. This system offers a high level of safety, making it ideal for beginners and those who want to enjoy climbing without excessive exposure to risk. A set of equipment is required, including ropes, carabiners and a harness, as well as a large surface at the base so that the climber can support the partner.
Lead climbing, on the other hand, requires the climber to carry the rope while climbing. It is a more advanced discipline, requiring greater technical skill and concentration. The climber secures the climb by regularly attaching the rope to anchor points, called “quickdraws,” located on the wall. This form of climbing requires more thorough preparation and more advanced equipment, including a dynamic rope, carabiners, quickdraws and harness. In this discipline, large surfaces at the starting point are not required.
Outdoor climbing walls, especially in picturesque locations, can attract adventurous tourists and nature lovers, contributing to the local economy. However, it is crucial to carefully manage the environmental impact of climbing. Excessive and unregulated access in the absence of a plan can cause damage to the stone walls, compromising the appropriate use of the ruins. It is essential to implement sustainable practices in the management of climbing areas to preserve the integrity of the sites.
Although these kinds of sport happenings could give the idea of an inappropriate use of the heritage, the combination between sport activities and cultural tourism can match the requirements for a valorization plan of the archeological site. For this work, some striking images have been chosen to incisively represent a specific idea of the use of the fortified structures still present. Such events are concentrated in a few appointments throughout the year, and only few experts have the ability, and consequently can obtain permission, to climb medieval towers to the top. The risk, for such sportive events, is that the historical building remains a sort of pleasant background in pictures and videos used by media creators. Thus, it should be remarked that one of the goals of this sport category is to introduce younger people to mountain climbing activities. Among the various categories available for participants, the one reserved for younger athletes is among the largest. Children and teenagers, supported by parents and older friends, can become familiar with the sport, while also experimenting with play while testing their limits. Beyond the recreational and sporting component, in a setting like the Vogogna fortress, young people can be educated about heritage to gain insight into a lost medieval world, and to experience firsthand the physical substance of its structures. In other words, these activities teach healthy living and the discovery of heritage, with the hope of developing an awareness of the historical values to which a given community belongs, and to see a growing respect and desire to protect and care for such places.
6. Conclusions
The authors showed an integrated approach to analyze an archeological complex and set the conservation process, from restoration practices to valorization strategies. The work was based on the integration of different lines of research concerning the historical evolution of the building, its geometry, material components, and the conservation state of its main structures, in order to deepen the understanding of the monument. The limitations imposed by the hard accessibility of the site were overpassed using an advanced survey, combining topographic assessment with laser scanning and photogrammetry. The result revealed several details of the fortress that were previously only drafted, like the precise organization of the terraces in the surrounding areas and the complex distribution of the spaces formed by the fence and the dry walls of the internal parts of the ruins.
The advanced survey allowed us to represent the altimetric organization of the fortress, reproducing vertical prospects and sections and the displacement of the land, with artificial terraces and embarkments contained by dry walls. The geometrical analysis was used to integrate the fundamental historical steps of the evolution of the fortress. The survey constituted a base for the analysis of the stratigraphic settlements of the building, the identification of materials, and their alterations and decays to quantify the main stones used for the masonry technology and the extension of the areas presenting specific pathologies and conservation issues.
The development of a 3D geometrical model of the fortress constituted important support for the setting of the upgrading proposal for the fortress. Comparing other similar cases, different experts observed that the reuse of ruins can match the requirements for a dynamic coevolutionary adaptation through the implementation of the site accessibility. The proposal for a long footway in Corten steel implemented by stairlifts here presented could appear as mere academic speculation, but this kind of solution was proposed and implemented for other valorization projects, presenting some points in common with the fortress of Vogogna. The strategy consists of reactivating interest in an underused building, situated in a position that is not easy to reach, and presenting some risks in its internal accessibility. Limiting its condition to a sort of static background along the walkway from Vogogna to its upper hamlet, Genestredo, would not improve people’s engagement towards the building and its role in the natural park. Thus, the possibility of extending the touristic offer to sports activities, such as climbing services, directly connected to the massive walls of the fortress, could bring new attention to this ruin, its significance and its preservation.
The proposed workflow shows the relationship between local communities and cultural assets. The case study, a ruined fortress, can activate very specific knowledge paths through the conservation process described in this work. The study included a picture of the town, its economic and social conditions, to identify the potentialities represented by the historical center and the peculiar cultural landscape present here. Among the various historical buildings, the fortress could provide a strategic solution for reviving social and cultural activities in this area. The model proposed here was set on the peculiar characteristics of Vogogna and its archeological settlement, deeply connected to the natural environment, but the applied methodology represents a reliable approach that could be used for other underused sites. Moreover, the proposed advanced survey provides an innovative digital tool that can be implemented for future preventive planned conservation design to support the management of the archeological settlement and its constant care.