3.1. Structure and Composition of the Mn-Containing Titanates
To achieve high phase purity of the target titanates, the conditions of their high-temperature ceramic synthesis were varied in accordance with
Table 1. The final conditions providing preparation of the products not containing any detectable crystalline impurities were marked with a tick (∨). Generally, it was found that synthesis of the samples without manganese and with low substitution degrees (
x < 0.1) requires a slightly higher temperature than that of the other compounds (
x ≥ 0.1). All the products obtained were identified by means of powder XRD analysis. Diffraction patterns of the initial and Mn-containing titanates are presented in
Figure 1a (0.1 ≤
x ≤ 1.0) and
Figure S2a (0.002 ≤
x ≤ 0.05). As one can see, all the patterns are generally similar to each other and are consistent with those in the literature for unmodified titanate (ICDD card № 01-082-2323). All the diffraction peaks observed were successfully indexed in the tetragonal system (
I4 space group), and no significant impurities were detected.
Table 2 summarizes the calculated unit cell parameters for the compounds with different manganese content
x. The experimental data indicate that the partial substitution of titanium with manganese does not induce substantial structural transformations and the space group stays unchanged. However, there is a tendency for the parameter
c to decrease with increasing manganese content, which can be attributed to the smaller Shannon’s crystal radius of manganese (0.670 Å) compared to that of titanium (0.745 Å) in the corresponding coordination environment [
69].
Attempts to synthesize the titanates with higher substitution degrees (
x > 1.0) resulted in the appearance in the products of an impurity phase NaLaTi
2O
6 (
Figure 1a). Thus, the manganese content
x = 1.0 («by loading») proved to be the highest achievable for the titanates in question. This result is fully consistent with the previous literature reports on titanium substitution with manganese and ruthenium in the structurally related titanates, whose authors indicated the inevitable formation of undesirable by-phases when attempting to exceed the value
x = 1.0 [
60,
61].
The alkaline titanates prepared were converted into so-called protonated forms, (H,Na)
2La
2Mn
xTi
3−xO
10, via the substitution of interlayer sodium cations with protons in a diluted hydrochloric acid. Comparative analysis of the XRD patterns of the alkaline and protonated compounds (
Figure 1b and
Figure S2b) revealed a shift of the
00l reflections towards higher diffraction angles. This shift indicates a decrease in the interlayer distance (in essence, the
c parameter in
Table 2) upon the protonation associated with the difference in the radii of sodium cations and protons. Although the patterns of the protonated titanates can be satisfactorily indexed in the tetragonal system with
a =
b = 3.8 Å, it was found that the peak positions observed are better described in the orthorhombic symmetry (
a ≠
b,
Table 2).
Further structural investigation of the alkaline titanates obtained was carried out using the Rietveld full-profile analysis. It was performed for the unmodified compound Na
2La
2Ti
3O
10 and selected Mn-substituted samples with relatively high manganese contents (
x = 0.5 and
x = 0.9). The previously reported structure of Na
2La
2Ti
3O
10 [
70] served as a starting model. Firstly, the refinement of the undoped sample was performed using originally reported
I4/mmm and
I4 space groups. While the literature reports a fit in a
I4/mmm group with a weighted profile R-factor (Rwp) of 12.87%, in our case, the best Rwp = 9.03% was achieved (
Figure 2a). Peak shapes were mostly satisfactory described by a pseudo-Voigt function using a Stephens model of anisotropic peak broadening. Since layered oxides tend to form plate-like particles with high texturing, which affects peak intensities in XRD patterns, a preferred orientation along
001 and
011 planes was applied to negate these effects in the final fitting.
The refined models based on
I4 and
I4/mmm space groups then were applied to the Mn-containing titanates with
x = 0.5 and
x = 0.9 (
Figure 2b,c) in order to additionally confirm the substitution of titanium by manganese, as well as determine its content and position in the structure. Refinement of the Ti/Mn occupancies showed that best fits were achieved for the models where Mn
4+ cations substitute the Ti
4+ ones in the middle sublayer of perovskite blocks and manganese content is close to the theoretical (0.4 for
x = 0.5 and 0.8 for
x = 0.9). As in case of the initial titanate Na
2La
2Ti
3O
10, the best Rwp factors for the Mn-containing materials were achieved using the
I4/mmm space group. The refined parameters are presented in the
Table 3. As one can see, their values for Na
2La
2Ti
3O
10 are in good consistency with the literature ones. The substitution of Ti
4+ by Mn
4+ leads to a gradual decrease in the unit cell volume, which, as already noted above, is considered to be caused by the differences in size of six-coordinated octahedral Ti
4+ (0.745 Å) and Mn
4+ (0.670 Å) [
69]. The structures refined are visualized in
Figure 3, and the corresponding crystallographic information files (CIFs) are included in the
Supplementary Materials (Information S3).
Raman spectra of the lattice vibrational modes (100–1000 cm
−1) of the alkaline titanates Na
2La
2Mn
xTi
3−xO
10 (
x = 0, 0.1, 0.3) are presented in
Figure 4. The assignment of vibrational bands of the perovskite lattice was carried out based on data from the publication [
71]. The bands below 400 cm
−1 belong to the alkali metal vibrational modes in the interlayer space. The vibrations at 902 cm
−1 are related to symmetric stretching of axial Ti–O bonds in terminal octahedra directed towards the interlayer space. These bands practically do not change their positions upon the titanium substitution with manganese in the perovskite sublattice. Meanwhile, the band of a slightly distorted central TiO
6 octahedra is seen to shift from 678 cm
−1 to 669 cm
−1 and 659 cm
−1 when Mn is introduced into the structure in amounts of
x = 0.1 and
x = 0.3, respectively. The vibration band around 580 cm
−1 is related to the stretching of axial Ti–O bonds in terminal octahedra directed towards the perovskite slab center. This band slightly shifts to 575 cm
−1 with an increase in the manganese content. Finally, the band at 453 cm
−1 is assigned to the asymmetric vibrations of equatorial Ti–O bonds in central TiO
6 octahedra. Upon the cationic substitution, this band insignificantly moves from 453 cm
−1 to 455 cm
−1 and 457 cm
−1. Raman spectra of the corresponding protonated titanates (H,Na)
2La
2Mn
xTi
3−xO
10 are shown in
Figure S3. Although their bands are more broadened, they also reveal shifts of the perovskite sublattice modes accompanying the partial titanium substitution with manganese. The mentioned shifts of the lattice vibrational bands are consistent with the Rietveld refinement results and indicate that the manganese cations are embedded precisely into central octahedra of the perovskite block.
Quantitative compositions of both alkaline and protonated titanates were studied by means of ICP-AES (after acid digestion) and EDX (
Table 4). The corresponding EDX spectra are presented in
Figure S4. The analysis of the protonated samples was carried out to refute or confirm the potential existence of amorphous Mn-containing by-phases on the alkaline titanates’ surface that are likely to dissolve during the protonation. Comparing the compositions of the alkaline and protonated compounds, one can see that the factual Mn:Ti ratios stay practically unchanged during the acid treatment, and the results obtained by the two different methods are in good agreement with each other. Since the manganese content in the alkaline and protonated titanates is quite close, it can be assumed that the main part of the detected manganese is indeed located in the perovskite lattice, not on the sample surface. Meanwhile, there is a slight discrepancy between the theoretical and experimental substitution degrees, indicating that manganese is still not completely incorporated into the structure and a small part of it might remain in the form of some amorphous impurities. The highest degree of substitution that was factually achieved was
x = 0.8–0.9, which corresponds to the degree «by loading» of 1.0.
The composition of the titanates (H,Na)
2La
2Mn
xTi
3−xO
10 in terms of their protonation degree (completeness of sodium substitution with protons) and amount of intercalated water was additionally investigated by means of EDX and TG analysis (
Table 5,
Figure S5). The TG curves were processed using a technique reported in the literature [
72] based on the assumption that the low-temperature stage of mass loss (approximately below 300 °C) mainly corresponds to the deintercalation of the interlayer water molecules, while the subsequent stage predominantly relates to the decomposition of the anhydrous compound. In accordance with this, the actual formulae of the protonated titanates under consideration should be presented as H
2x′Na
2−2x′La
2Mn
xTi
3−xO
10∙yH
2O, where the protonation degree
x′ falls in the range of 0.70–0.95 and the intercalated water content
y varies from 0.05 to 0.30 depending on the specific sample (
Table 5). Moderate discrepancies in the protonation degrees found via the two methods could be associated with the semi-quantitative nature of EDX and potential changes in the manganese oxidation state during TG analysis. In general, the titanates with higher manganese contents were found to contain greater amounts of intercalated water.
XPS was employed to determine the oxidation state of manganese in the titanates.
Figure 5a shows the core level Mn 2p spectra of the protonated samples (H,Na)
2La
2Mn
xTi
3−xO
10 (
x = 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 1.0). The spectra contain two distinct peaks at 654.0 and 642.5 eV, corresponding to the spin-orbit doublets of Mn 2p
1/2 and 2p
3/2, respectively. Deconvoluted Mn 2p
3/2 peaks centered at 642.5 and 641.2 eV correspond to the Mn
4+ and Mn
3+ oxidation states, respectively [
73]. A quantitative analysis of the different oxidation state concentrations was conducted based on the integrated peak areas. The results indicate that the Mn
4+ concentrations are 100%, 85%, 89%, 83%, and 93% for
x = 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9 and 1.0, respectively. The existence of some manganese ions in the Mn
3+ state points to the presence of oxygen vacancies in the titanates obtained.
Estimating the concentration of oxygen vacancies using XPS is a difficult task due to the similar binding energies of oxygen vacancies and adsorbed oxygen.
Figure 5b presents the O 1s XPS of the protonated titanates. The deconvolution of the O 1s signal reveals the presence of the different contributions, including lattice oxygen (O
L) located at low binding energies (529.5 eV for
x = 0), while the second contribution (531.2 eV for
x = 0) includes oxygen vacancies, adsorbed oxygen, hydroxyl and carbonate groups on the surface (O
def+ads) [
74]. The relative content of the lattice oxygen for each of the titanates is presented in
Table 6. The results obtained do not demonstrate a clear correlation. However, the data indicate that the incorporation of manganese into the crystal structure for all the samples except
x = 0.1, 0.5 led to a decrease in the proportion of the lattice oxygen, which could be associated with an increase in the number of defects.
Figure 5c,d illustrate the La 3d and Ti 2p core-level XPS of the protonated titanates. The binding energy of La 3d (834.2 and 838.1 eV for La 3d5/2, and 851.0 and 854.9 eV for La 3d3/2) can be attributed to La
3+ [
75]. The Ti 2p spectrum shows Ti 2p3/2 and Ti 2p1/2 peaks at approximately 458.4 and 464.2 eV, respectively, which can be recognized as Ti
4+ [
76]. Incorporating manganese into the structure does not lead to a significant change in the appearance of the La 3d and Ti 2p spectra.
The morphology of the titanates obtained was studied using SEM (
Figure S6). It is seen that particles of all the materials have a similar plate-like shape that is typical of layered oxides [
77]. The samples represent polydisperse powders with lateral particle dimensions of 0.4–2 μm and a thickness of 200–600 nm. A comparison of the unmodified and Mn-containing titanates indicates that all the materials have a similar morphology, which does not change significantly during the protonation process.
3.2. Photophysical Properties of the Mn-Containing Titanates
Further photophysical characterization and photocatalytic investigation was performed for the protonated forms of the titanates that, unlike the alkaline precursors, are stable in aqueous media with respect to the interlayer ion exchange.
The range of intrinsic light absorption of the protonated titanates was studied by means of DRS with the Kubelka–Munk transformation of the spectra obtained (
Figure 6a and
Figure S7a). As one can see from
Table 7, the optical bandgap energy E
g of the initial unmodified sample (
x = 0) is 3.20 eV, which allows it to function as a photocatalyst utilizing only mid-near ultraviolet with wavelengths up to 388 nm. Meanwhile, the partial substitution of Ti with Mn leads to a sharply pronounced band gap contraction. Particularly, even extremely low Mn contents (
x = 0.002–0.005) prove to be already sufficient to shift the long-wave absorption edge of the samples to the visible range (E
g < 3 eV, λ
max > 410 nm). With a further increase in the substitution degree
x, the absorption maximum rises monotonically and, starting from
x = 0.5, the titanates acquire the ability to absorb even near-infrared light. That being said, the absorption maximum achieved is 919 nm at
x = 1.0. Thus, the insertion of Mn into the perovskite sublattice turned out to be an effective approach to expand the spectral area of potential operation of photocatalysts based on the titanates in question, which is of great importance for utilizing the visible and near-infrared parts of solar radiation.
The band edge potentials E
V and E
C of the protonated titanates were approximately estimated based on the above E
g values and VB-XPS data (
Figure 6b and
Figure S7b). As can be seen from
Figure 6c, the partial substitution of Ti with Mn is accompanied by shifts of both E
V and E
C values, which indicates participation of the Mn orbitals in the formation of both energy bands. Particularly, when moving from
x = 0 to
x = 1.0, the valence band top changes from 2.55 to 1.75 V and the conduction band bottom shifts from −0.65 to 0.40 V vs. SHE. Despite the incredibly wide light absorption range, the aforementioned displacement of the band edge potentials upon Mn insertion may adversely affect the possibility of using the corresponding photocatalysts in some practically valuable reactions. For instance, the E
C value of the titanates with
x ≥ 0.3 is more positive than the standard 2H
+/H
2 reduction potential (0 V vs. SHE at pH = 0, 0.41 V vs. SHE at pH = 7), which may limit their use in hydrogen production reactions. At the same time, the samples with lower Mn contents (
x = 0.002–0.01) should be, in principle, capable of functioning as hydrogen evolution photocatalysts at least in weakly acidic reaction media.
The intensity of the radiative electron–hole recombination in the protonated titanates was indirectly estimated using TR-PLS with excitation in the intrinsic absorption area (
Figure 7). It was found that all the samples, being excited at
λ = 340 nm, exhibit pronounced photoluminescence peaks at 400–450 nm, whose shape and position are practically independent of the Mn content in the compounds. Meanwhile, the partial substitution of Ti with Mn results in a slight increase in the average photoluminescence lifetime
τ from 3.32 μs at
x = 0 to 3.69 μs at
x = 1.0 (
Table 7). Thus, the insertion of Mn, apparently, does not increase the electron–hole recombination rate, although Mn is a foreign element in the crystal structure of the titanates that is potentially capable of being one of the recombination centers. This result is consistent with previous reports on cationic substitution (doping) in the structure of other perovskites, which was shown to improve charge carrier dynamics and separation efficiency [
78,
79].
3.3. Photocatalytic Activity of the Mn-Containing Titanates with Respect to Hydrogen Production
The photocatalytic properties of the protonated titanates and their exfoliated forms (nanosheets) were evaluated in the reactions of light-driven hydrogen evolution from 1% (mol.) aqueous methanol under the irradiation of a DRT-125 mercury lamp (
λ > 220 nm) and LED source (
λ = 425 nm). All the materials were subjected to the in situ platinization (1% Pt in the final composites) aimed at improving the spatial charge separation and creating active sites of hydrogen formation [
80]. The resulting kinetics curves of photocatalytic hydrogen generation are presented in
Figure 8 and
Figure S8. The rates and apparent quantum efficiencies of the reactions are summarized in
Table 8 and visualized as bar graphs in
Figure 9.
As can be seen from
Figure 8, the hydrogen evolution curves over the most active photocatalysts demonstrate predominantly linear behavior throughout the whole measurement time. Meanwhile, some of the curves show a so-called activation period followed by the subsequent reaction rate growth, one of the reasons for which might be associated with a slow process of photocatalytic Pt reduction from H
2PtCl
6. Some of the measurements also included dark stages (shown for the titanate with
x = 0 in
Figure S8) when the light source was turned off. After this, the kinetic curves gradually reach a plateau, indicating that the hydrogen generation stops.
It was established that the hydrogen evolution activity of the protonated titanates and their nanosheets under the DRT-125 lamp rises when moving from the unmodified sample (
x = 0) to that with the lowest manganese content (
x = 0.002) and then starts to decrease (
Figure 9). That being said, the samples with
x = 0.002 and
x = 0.005 outperform the initial titanate in terms of both the hydrogen generation rate and apparent quantum efficiency. Moreover, the exfoliated forms of the titanates exhibit up to 20 times greater photocatalytic performance as compared to the protonated precursors with an equal Mn content (in the range
x ≤ 0.05), which is associated with the high specific surface area (small specific volume) of the nanosheets providing greater lifetimes of photogenerated electron-hole pairs and effective reactant adsorption. For instance, as shown in our previous publication [
63], the exfoliated and reassembled titanate H
2La
2Ti
3O
10 possesses a more than 18-times higher specific surface area in comparison with that of the bulk precursor (60 vs. 3.2 m
2/g). Since the titanate nanosheets in this study are tested without preliminary reassembly, one can expect even greater differences in the active surface, explaining the pronounced improvement in the photocatalytic performance. However, the activity of the titanates and their nanosheets with
x > 0.1 proved to be extremely low, despite the impressively wide range of intrinsic light absorption (
Table 7). This result may be explained based on the energy diagrams of the corresponding semiconductor materials (
Figure 6c): their conduction band minima E
C are located lower (are more positive) than the standard reduction potential E
0(2H
+/H
2), which makes the hydrogen evolution reactions over these photocatalysts thermodynamically forbidden. In addition, the titanates with high Mn content may also contain amorphous impurities on the surface, adversely affecting the photocatalytic activity. These facts are also consistent with the photocatalytic activity of the titanates under purely visible irradiation of the LED source with
λ = 425 nm. As can be seen from
Table 8, the trace hydrogen amounts are evolved over the samples with low substitution degrees 0.002 ≤
x ≤ 0.01, while the other materials do not provide the formation of any detectable hydrogen volumes.
Thus, low degrees of Ti substitution with Mn in the titanates (particularly,
x = 0.002 and
x = 0.005) turned out to be preferable for creating photocatalysts for hydrogen evolution. The corresponding materials, on the one hand, are capable of utilizing a wider range of irradiation than the unmodified compound and, on the other hand, their conduction band minimum still remains sufficiently negative to provide proton reduction. The aforementioned experimental fact is in good consistency with the numerous literature results indicating that the photocatalytic performance of cation-substituted layered perovskite-like oxides often passes through a maximum observed at relatively low substitution degrees. Particularly, this trend was confirmed by the Ti/Cr and Ti/Fe substitution in La
2Ti
2O
7 [
81], Ti/Fe [
59,
82], Ti/Zn [
56], Ti/V [
57] and Ti/Nb [
58] substitution in K
2La
2Ti
3O
10, and Nb/Mo substitution in HSr
2Nb
3O
10 [
35], as well as Nb/Cr substitution in KSr
2Nb
3O
10 [
36] and HPb
2Nb
3O
10 [
83]. However, the Mn-substituted titanates with greater Mn content obtained may be of great interest for other photocatalytic reactions (for instance, water purification from organic pollutants) [
84] or use in fuel cells [
85]. Moreover, their representatives with high Mn contents are practically black, which makes them promising materials for thermo-assisted photocatalysis aiming to utilize the thermal energy of the sun to accelerate photocatalytic processes [
86,
87,
88,
89].