Intelligent Cyber-Security System for IoT-Aided Drones Using Voting Classifier
, Muhammad Umer 3,† and Michele Nappi 4,*Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
The article needs a more recent approach compared with appropriate result evaluation is required.
It must refer to the recent journals with similar context and must be illustrated with a comparison to climb the effectiveness of the proposed system.
Author Response
We have responded to the reviewer all comments in response to the reviewer file attachment.
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
1.The methods of UAV safety authentication and control access based on machine learning proposed in this paper are not clearly expressed and need more detailed explanation.
2.In this paper, the system model and the scheme to solve the security problem are crossed together, so the level of the article is not clear enough and the readability is poor.
3.The description of relevant research work in this paper is chaotic.
4.Original and complete data should be provided in the experimental part of this paper.
Author Response
We have responded to the reviewer comments in response to the reviewer file attachment.
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments to the authors
Manuscript ID: electronics-1456383
Title: Intelligent Cyber-security System for IoT-Aided Drones using Voting Classifier
1) Provide a list of contributions and provide sufficient evidences to support your claim.
2) Literature review could be improved. There is an extensive literature on cyber attacks on control systems that could be used to improve the literature review. For instance, look at the following recent work regarding denial of service attack:
a) “On the Detection of Low-Rate Denial of Service Attacks at Transport and Application Layers” Electronics, 2021.
b) “Active Attack Detection and Control in Constrained Cyber-Physical Systems Under Prevented Actuation Attack”, American Control Conference (ACC), 2021.
3) It is not clear how the structure presented in Figure 2 can improve safety and security of drones. More elaboration is required.
4) What is the rationale behind selection the sigmoid function as in (1)? Any impact on the performance? Can the readers select another function instead?
Author Response
We have responded to the reviewer comments in response to the reviewer file attachment.
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 3 Report
No further comment.
