Semi-Targeted Profiling of the Lipidome Changes Induced by Erysiphe Necator in Disease-Resistant and Vitis vinifera L. Varieties
, Domenico Masuero 2, Pietro Franceschi 3, Luca Zulini 4, Marco Stefanini 4, Michael Oberhuber 5, Peter Robatscher 5, Giulia Chitarrini 2,5 and Urska Vrhovsek 2,*
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Although paper seems very fascinating, for usual reader, I recommend to do the abbreviations' list at the beginning. Earlier in literature, main attention paid to volatile essential oils of the species as a resistance factor against any infection. Are lipids that you studied more effective in a comparison with essential oils?
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
This is a manuscript review for Semi-targeted profiling of the lipidome changes induced by Erysiphe necator in disease-resistant and Vitis vinifera L. varieties.
The article added important new knowledge on lipidome changes. The article is well written. There are a few minor collections.
Table 1: Resistance-related powdery mildew loci (Ren/Run) should be in italics if they are genes. Check the rest of the manuscript.
Table 1: Does n.d. mean not determined? Add a footnote or description.
Fig 4: A bit more description of the graphics should be added in the legend.
Supplementary figures need renumbering for clarity.
Supplementary Figure 1: There is no legend accompanying the figure
Supplementary Table 3: When the file is opened it shows Table 3. Add 'S' or 'supplementary' before 'S'
Supplementary Table 2: The file name shows ' Supplementary Table 2' but when opened, Supplementary Table 1 is seen. Revise.
Supplementary Table 1: The file name is 'Supplementary Table 1' but when opened, the first worksheet shows Supplementary Table 4, The next sheet is Table S3 and the next sheet has no legend.
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
