OSA Upper Airways Surgery: A Targeted Approach
, B. Tucker Woodson 2, Venkata Koka 3, Giovanni Cammaroto 4, Giannicola Iannella 4, Marcello Bosi 5, Stefano Pelucchi 6, Giulio Romano Filograna-Pignatelli 1, Pierre El Chater 7 and Claudio Vicini 4Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Good work!
As noted in the paper, OSA is a multifactorial disorder.......treatment therefore cannot be a "one size fits all" approach. Different treatments must be available for the different pathophysiological factors.
This paper does an excellent job of describing the major anatomic and non anatomic factors, and then discussing the various surgical approaches based on those factors.
There is nothing adverse that I can say about the paper. Everything is well thought out and well-documented.
Author Response
All the Authors thank the reviewer's comment and suggestion.
The manuscript had been revised for the English language.
Reviewer 2 Report
The theme addressed in the paper is original, interesting, and important.
The authors presented the aims of their research.
There are 8 keywords.
Material and method are clearly presented.
In the bibliography, citations 25 and 58 are with different letter characters and colors than those used in the article.
The paper is well written, is clear, and easy to be read.
The research results are relevant and evidenced by arguments.
The paper addressed the proposed subject.
The authors highlighted the significance of their work and the conclusions are consistent through the presented arguments.
Ethics approval and patient consent are not applied because the article is a comprehensive review.
The comprehensive review of the researched data represents the novelty of the article.
Author Response
All the Authors thank the reviewer's comment and suggestion
