1. Introduction
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is one of the more common autoimmune diseases, affecting approximately 2 to 3 million people worldwide [
1]. The geographic distribution of patients with MS is not homogeneous and varies considerably from region to region. However, higher latitude is associated with a higher MS incidence, although there are exceptions to this rule [
2,
3]. As most affected individuals are in their early adulthood, MS has a significant impact on quality of life and is one of the most common causes of non-traumatic neurological disability in this age group in Europe and North America [
4]. The course of the disease is heterogeneous; hence, different degrees of disease severity can be observed [
5,
6]. The moment of diagnosis is a stressful, life-changing event for most patients and their families. Therefore, the recognition of the emotional burden and the risk of developing mental disorders of differing intensity and severity, as well as adequate support, are of crucial importance for improving quality of life and compliance in the treatment of the underlying disease [
7,
8].
In the course of MS, various mood, behavioral and cognitive disorders may also occur. Some of them are interpreted as a consequence of brain damage resulting from the demyelination of axons or treatment-related adverse effects [
9], while others are considered diverse psychological reactions to the progressive course of the disease, which leads to disability [
10,
11]. The pattern of their development is still under debate. However, it is believed that these various etiological factors often coexist [
12,
13]. Occasionally, patients in whom mental disorders are the first symptom of MS are also reported, which usually results in a delay in neurological diagnosis [
14,
15,
16]. The first study describing the co-occurrence of mental disorders in patients with MS was conducted as early as the 1920s [
17]. It was demonstrated that depressive episode symptoms occurred in 24–50% of MS patients, which is significantly more prevalent compared to the general population and most other neurological disorders [
13,
18,
19,
20,
21]. In addition, a higher rate of suicide is observed in the group of MS patients [
22]. The prevalence of anxiety disorders in the course of MS is estimated at 21–36% [
13,
23,
24]. Other less common disorders include bipolar affective disorders, psychotic disorders and personality disorders [
13,
25]. Although mental disorders manifest more frequently in patients with MS than in the general population, they are often undiagnosed in clinical settings [
26,
27]. Mental disorders have an additional negative impact on the severity of the disability. As a result, the main elements associated with the co-occurrence of mental disorders in MS patients include a significantly lower quality of life and poorer patient compliance in the treatment process [
28,
29].
This is the first study in Poland whose aim was to determine the prevalence of mental disorders in a group of patients with MS treated on an outpatient basis and to assess the impact of sex, age, duration and severity of MS symptoms on the occurrence of mental disorders.
4. Discussion
In this study, we assessed the prevalence of mental disorders in a group of MS patients treated on an outpatient basis. Compared to similar studies related to this subject, our study group was selected in appropriate proportions in terms of sex, which was significant [
35,
36,
37,
38].
The results confirmed the reports of a frequent co-occurrence of mental disorders with MS [
13,
19,
20,
21,
37,
39,
40]. According to the MINI Questionnaire, 33% of patients had a history of a depressive episode, while 8% had a depressive episode at the time of the assessment. Among anxiety disorders, GAD was the most prevalent (10.7%), followed by agoraphobia (8.7%) and panic disorder (7.8%), which is in line with other studies [
25,
36,
39,
41,
42]. In total, 24% of patients were diagnosed with a depressive episode (F32) and organic mood disorders (F06.3) prior to or at the time of the assessment.
We also showed that, at the time of the clinical assessment, psychiatrists confirmed the occurrence of current or past mental disorders in 67% of patients with MS. These results are in line with those obtained by Galeazzi et al. [
39]. Depressive disorders with symptoms meeting the criteria for a depressive episode and organic mood disorders were diagnosed in 24% of patients, anxiety disorders in 11.7% and adjustment disorders in 10.7%, whereas cognitive disorders were diagnosed in 7.8% of patients. Similar results were obtained by Marrie et al. [
36], who compared diagnosing mood disorders in a group of MS patients using questionnaire methods and medical examination. Medical examination showed depressive disorders in 28% of patients and anxiety disorders in 11%. Using the questionnaires, those authors confirmed depression in 33% and anxiety disorders in 18% of patients [
36].
Similar results were found in terms of the percentages of disorders using specific methods when our study was compared with the study by Marrie et al. [
36]. Furthermore, in both cases, a significant discrepancy of the results was reported in terms of depressive episodes between the MINI Questionnaire and the psychiatric diagnosis. In our study, a slightly higher percentage may result from considering past and current episodes.
Many studies assessing the occurrence of depressive disorders in MS patients are conflicting. Galeazzi et al. [
39] assessed 50 patients with relapsing–remitting MS and found that 46% of patients presented with a major depressive disorder in their lifetime, 12% presented with a current major depressive episode, 6% had bipolar affective disorders and 10% were diagnosed with dysthymic disorder. Anxiety disorders were diagnosed in 36% of patients, with a simple phobia being the most prevalent (12%). Gottberg et al. demonstrated the occurrence of depressive disorders in 19% of MS patients [
37]. Amtmann et al. [
43] evaluated 166 patients with MS and found a depressive episode in 29% of patients. Karimi et al. [
38] demonstrated depressive disorders in 47% of patients and anxiety disorders in 39% of MS patients. Feinstein et al. [
44] analyzed 100 patients with MS, and their results showed that 17% of subjects met the criteria for the diagnosis of a major depressive episode. Korostil and Feinstein [
45,
46] evaluated 140 patients using the SCID-I questionnaire to diagnose anxiety disorders. The lifetime prevalence of any anxiety disorder was found in 35.7% of patients, generalized anxiety was reported in 18.6% of subjects, panic disorder in 10% and obsessive-compulsive disorder in 8.6% of the study group. De Cerqueira et al. [
25] evaluated 60 patients with MS using the MINI Questionnaire. They found that 18.3% of subjects had a history of a depressive episode, 18.3% of patients were diagnosed with depression at the time of the assessment and 13.3% had a bipolar affective disorder. Among anxiety disorders, GAD was the most prevalent and was diagnosed in 16.7% of subjects, followed by panic disorders in 3.3% [
25].
We used a very similar protocol and research tools. Our study also confirmed that mood and anxiety disorders were the most prevalent. However, we reported a lower percentage of bipolar affective disorders (3.9%) and a higher prevalence of panic disorders (7.8%). The literature shows that the possibility of the occurrence of mental disorders during the diagnosis and treatment of a chronic somatic disease with a high risk of disability is affected by disease-related stress, changes in daily functioning, the presence and the quality of social support, treatment-related adverse effects (e.g., steroids and other drugs), pathological structural processes (atrophy, damage) and central nervous system (CNS) dysfunction [
9,
10,
11,
12,
39,
40,
46]. The simultaneous influence of these factors of varying severity on MS patients may account for the differences in the results published worldwide.
Attention should be paid to the group of 54% of patients who were simultaneously treated for other somatic comorbidities, which may influence the severity of mental disorders and may increase their prevalence, as indicated in the literature [
47]. Nevertheless, our study did not show a statistically significant correlation between the presence of comorbidities and increased rates of any mental disorder.
Over 95% of patients were diagnosed with multiple demyelinating lesions in the CNS. This is a very important etiological factor that can initiate, exacerbate or sustain the existence of mental disorders (mostly cognitive), as shown by Feinstein et al. [
46]. However, our study did not show a statistically significant correlation between the number of lesions on T2-weighted images and mental disorders.
The literature indicates that other possible factors for the co-occurrence of mental disorders with MS include adjustment difficulties associated with limitations, symptoms and social problems associated with MS, genetic susceptibility, structural brain abnormalities, an association between depression and immune and inflammatory changes and pharmacotherapy causing mental disorders, as well as personality features that predispose to the occurrence of mental disorders and diseases [
13,
48]. In terms of pharmacotherapy, Gasim et al. showed no statistically significant correlation between the use of disease-modifying therapy (DMT) and the occurrence of any adverse effects in the form of mental or behavioral disorders [
49]. However, our study did not evaluate such a correlation.
Interestingly, we found a statistically significant negative correlation between having a family and mental disorders at the time of the assessment. This fact supports the idea that MS patients who have a family may be less susceptible to mental disorders. This phenomenon could be explained by the support given to MS patients related to many spheres of life, including mental health. This phenomenon is not surprising, as it is widely believed that support from others can have a positive impact on mental and physical health [
50]. However, we did not demonstrate a similar statistically significant correlation in terms of current or past mental disorders.
In our study, we observed a statistically significant negative correlation between the level of education and the risk of suicide as assessed by the MINI Questionnaire. Patients with a higher level of education showed a lower risk of suicide. These results are in line with Karimi et al. [
38], who reported the same relationship between the severity of depression and education. Karimi et al. also showed a statistically significant negative correlation between the severity of depression and economic status. However, we did not show such a correlation.
We demonstrated a statistically significant correlation between the median EDSS score and the occurrence of clinically diagnosed mental disorders during a lifetime. However, there was no statistical significance between the EDSS score and the occurrence of mental disorders during a lifetime. The result was very close to the significance level (
p = 0.05), and the increase in the group size may have yielded clearer results. It seems that
p could have obtained a value below 0.05. Therefore, it seems reasonable to assume a potential association between higher EDSS scores (which reflect a higher level of disability) and a higher prevalence of mental disorders. Similar results were presented by Sarısoy et al., who demonstrated that MS patients with higher EDSS scores showed more severe symptoms of depression [
51]. Those authors also stressed a higher prevalence of other mental disorders in patients with MS, the severity of which also increased with higher EDSS scores. These mental disorders included somatization disorders, the occurrence of obsessive thoughts and activities, increased interpersonal sensitivity, aggressive behaviors, phobias, low self-esteem and eating disorders [
51]. However, Janssens et al. [
52] reported that MS patients and their partners showed high levels of anxiety and distress in the first years after diagnosis, but no statistically significant correlation between this finding and increased disability was found.
In our study, current or past cognitive disorders were clinically diagnosed in only 7.8% of patients with MS. Other studies showed that cognitive impairment occurred in 43–70% of patients [
53,
54], which is a significant discrepancy. In our study, it may be related to the lack of additional tools and tests to detect cognitive impairment apart from obtaining a history and physical examination, which is one of the important limitations of this study. Reports analyzing the prevalence of mental disorders in MS based only on medical examination are scarce, and their results correspond to our findings [
36]. Marrie et al. stressed the problem with diagnosing the real number of MS patients affected by depression or anxiety disorders [
36]. Diagnostic methods do not improve the detection rates of these disorders. This may be due to the similarity of some symptoms or their overlap, as in the case of mental/motor retardation, malaise and anxiety. Additionally, the existing cognitive impairment causes further problems related to contact with patients.
The literature indicates that there is over a 2-fold higher risk of suicide in MS patients compared to the general population, and this risk is particularly high within the first year after the diagnosis of MS [
52]. However, in our study, the risk of suicide as assessed by the MINI Questionnaire was low in most patients, medium in 1.9% of subjects and high in 3.9% of patients. These results are relatively lower than those published by Sarisoy et al. and Feinstein [
51,
55]. In those studies, 8.3% and 6.4% of patients had a history of a suicide attempt, and 8.3% showed a risk of suicide at the time of the assessment. In the above studies, all patients with a risk of suicide at the time of the assessment presented with the symptoms of depression when their medical history was taken [
51,
55]. These differences may be caused by a higher number of patients with progressive forms of MS who were enrolled in the study as compared to our study. Patients with suicidal tendencies were significantly more often alone, unsupported, had a family history of mental diseases, more social problems and comorbid episodes of depression, anxiety disorders or comorbid depression and anxiety disorders [
8,
40,
55,
56]. However, these are the features typical of a higher risk of suicide not only in the group of MS patients but in all patients. However, as previously mentioned, our study demonstrated a statistically significant negative correlation between the level of education of MS patients and the risk of suicide.
According to a WHO report, 27% of the respondents in European Union countries experienced at least one mental disorder within a year [
57]. In our study, the occurrence of current or past mental disorders was found in 67% of patients with MS, which indicates the significance of the problem in this group of patients. In their epidemiological study conducted in Poland in 2015, Kiejna et al. [
58] showed that a major depressive disorder was present in 3% of subjects. It was significantly more prevalent in women (4%) than in men (1.9%). These data could be compared with our results. We found that 33% of MS patients had a history of a depressive episode or were diagnosed with such an episode at the time of the assessment. Such a comparison shows the enormous scale of mental disorders in the group of MS patients. Furthermore, these data suggest the need for psychological assistance for MS patients, particularly those with more severe disability, those without a family and those with a lower level of education.
Patients with MS have numerous psychological challenges. It is well known that depression, fatigue and cognitive impairment are intertwined in MS. Fatigue is a crucial and exceedingly common symptom in the course of MS, and it is an urgent problem in the mental health matter of MS patients. In fact, this symptom affects motor function, sleep patterns, anxiety, depression and, consequently, overall quality of life in the course of this disease [
59]. Fatigue has been shown to be a key aspect of overall quality of life in the course of MS [
60]. Appropriate therapy for this condition is therefore extremely important. Physical activity, cognitive-behavioral therapy and pharmacotherapy have been shown to be beneficial in this regard [
59]. Work capacity is also significantly impaired due to fatigue in the course of MS [
60]. Work capacity is also affected by the cognitive impairment, emotional distress and heat sensitivity experienced due to the condition. In addition to fatigue, other important predictive factors are age, gender, EDSS score and education level [
60]. Apart from the psychological problems classified in the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (ICD-10), it should be noted that patients also experience clinically known problems such as “chronic sorrow” as well as “MS euphoria”, where the subject shows cheerfulness and happiness but at the same time ignorance of the dysfunction and hardship in the course of the disease [
61,
62]. It is therefore important to quickly identify such patients and provide psychological help promptly.
In a study by Johansson et al., the occurrence of symptoms of mood disorders and depression was shown to be variable over a 2-year period in the course of MS, and during that time half of the patients experienced depressive symptoms at least once [
63]. This indicates that it is of crucial importance to develop strategies to identify these symptoms in MS patients and consequently to implement appropriate psychological and medical assistance, which could result in a definite improvement in these patients’ quality of life [
63]. In addition, a study by Binzer et al. found that patients who have MS and depression have a significantly increased risk of worsening disability [
64]. This finding highlights the importance of diagnosing depression in patients with MS as soon as possible, as well as implementing appropriate treatment [
64]. Given the prevalence of depressive and anxiety disorders in the course of MS, it seems reasonable to consider the administration of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) in these patients. It was shown that, due to the improvement in mental status, appropriate monitoring but also adequate treatment of psychiatric symptoms can improve the long-term prognosis of the disease [
65]. Moreover, studies are underway on the effect of SSRIs on the pathogenesis of MS. Indeed, serotonin has been shown to modulate the Th-17 immune response in the course of this condition [
66]. Thus, it can be speculated that, abstracting from the very important role of SSRIs in improving mental status, they may exhibit strict effects targeting MS pathogenesis. This even creates a rationale for considering therapy with serotonergic drugs as an additional therapy for relapsing–remitting MS [
66].
The most important limitations of this study include the size of the group and the lack of detailed assessment of the severity of depressive and cognitive disorders. Patients with the exacerbation of their underlying disease were not excluded from the study, which may have influenced the number of patients with mental disorders. In addition, the assessment of suicide risk based on the MINI Questionnaire does not seem to be completely reliable, although the results of a systematic review were not known before the completion of the study [
67]. The lack of the specified “inter-rater reliability” for psychiatrists who clinically assessed patients is another limitation of this study.