1. Introduction
As the techniques for using power converters have become more and more developed, high efficiency, high switching frequency, small size and good stability have become the basic requirements. However, as the switching frequency of the converter increases, the switching loss of the power switch also increases, thus reducing the efficiency of the power converter. In order to overcome the impact of traditional hard-switching power converters, the soft switching technique has been developed, which can effectively reduce the switching loss.
The methods of resonant power converters have been presented in [
1,
2], in which resonant inductors and resonant capacitors are added to converters to form resonant circuits, which are used to change the voltages on power switches or the currents flowing through the power switches to achieve zero-voltage or zero-current switching. However, the disadvantage is that the high voltage or high current caused by the resonance of the auxiliary circuit increases the component stress and, in turn, increases the conduction loss. In addition, since the resonance time of the auxiliary circuit is fixed, it is necessary to add variable frequency control in order to keep the output voltage stable at the prescribed value, which makes the design of the output filter difficult.
The literature [
3,
4] proposes adding auxiliary power switches and resonant elements to converters to generate resonant circuits to achieve zero-voltage or zero-current switching, and hence the fixed resonant time of the semi-resonant converter when it is on or off is improved, so that the converter does not need variable frequency control, and therefore fixed frequency control can be achieved.
The literature [
5,
6] also suggests that before the main power switch is turned on, the auxiliary power switch is turned on first or afterwards to form a resonant circuit, and by generating transient resonance, the voltage across the main power switch or the current flowing through the main power switch resonates to zero. This transient resonance occurs only during the instant of power switch switching, and does not resonate during the rest of the time, thus avoiding the problem of high voltage or high current stress, therefore reducing the conduction loss of the converter.
The literature [
7,
8] has proposed that the auxiliary power switch could generate two transient resonances in each switching cycle without affecting the circuit behavior. The main power switch can achieve zero voltage switching (ZVS) during the first transient resonance and zero current switching (ZCS) during the second transient resonance. Therefore, the main power switch has both ZVS and ZCS, but the disadvantage is that the auxiliary power switch cannot achieve ZVS or ZCS, and it is mostly floating, which not only increases the complexity of the gate driver circuit, but also requires multiple auxiliary components to make the main power switch have both ZVS and ZCS.
The main structure in [
9] is an interleaved boost converter, which features only one auxiliary switch with common ground and enables two main switches to realize ZVS and ZCS; the drawback is that the auxiliary switch needs four gate driving signals over one switching cycle, and the resonance condition is strict, which makes the mathematical mode analysis extremely complicated and difficult.
The topology shown in [
10] is a two-phase interleaved boost ZVT converter, whose characteristics are different from those shown in [a]. The circuit shown in [b] uses two auxiliary switches to realize the main switch with ZVS turn-on and ZCS turn-off and the used auxiliary switches have ZCS turn-off with only one gate driving signal over one switching cycle, but the drawback is that the two auxiliary switches are floating, thereby making the gate driving more difficult and greatly reducing the practicality of this converter.
The circuit shown in [
11] is a simple structure of a boost ZVT converter, which features a zero-current quasi-resonant circuit and an auxiliary switch with MOSFETs in series with diodes combined, and the auxiliary switch possesses common ground. In addition, the advantage is that the current waveform of the main switch has the characteristics of zero-current turn-on and zero-current turn-off, the switching control mode of the converter is fixed frequency, and the structure is simple, easy to analyze and low in cost.
The circuits shown in [
12,
13] both are boost converters using ZVT and ZCT technologies, but the feature of the circuit shown in [
12] is that it is easier to achieve ZVS and ZCS because the main switch and the auxiliary switch are common-grounded, but the drawback is that too many components are used, resulting in higher cost. The circuit shown in [
13] uses fewer components for the resonant circuit of the auxiliary switch and is easier to analyze, but the disadvantage is that the condition of the main switch to realize soft switching is more severe and difficult and the soft switching feature cannot be implemented all over the whole load range.
The circuit shown in [
14] is a two-phase interleaved four-switch boost ZVT converter, using only one coupling inductor and one clamping capacitor, which is characterized by the ability to give the four main switches ZVS turn-on in the current conduction mode (CCM) without any auxiliary switches. This circuit is characterized by few auxiliary circuit components, easy analysis and ZVS capability for most of the load range. However, the disadvantage is that the auxiliary switch is on the secondary side and floating, which makes the feedback control difficult and the transient response poor.
This circuit shown in [
15] is characterized by a small number of components in the auxiliary circuit, easy analysis and the capability for ZVS for most of the load range, but the disadvantage is that the auxiliary switch is on the secondary side and is floating, resulting in a circuit with poor feedback control and poor transient response.
The circuit shown in [
16] is a full-bridge DC to AC ZVT converter with an auxiliary circuit using only three components (i.e., one inductor and two MOSFETs) to achieve ZVS turn-on for all four main switches and ZCS turn-off for the auxiliary switch. The advantage is that a small number of components is used to achieve soft switching, but the disadvantage is that the auxiliary switches are floating.
Reference [
17] presents a ZCZVT step-up converter. The advantage of this is that this circuit is the integration of three coupled inductors into a single magnetic element and the auxiliary switch has common ground and a soft switching feature. The disadvantage is that too many components are used to achieve soft switching, thereby making the auxiliary circuit too complex to analyze its operating principle.
Reference [
18] proposes a step-up and step-down ZVT converter with a demagnetized auxiliary circuit. The advantage is that the demagnetized winding is used to reduce the voltage stress on the auxiliary circuit, but the disadvantage is that the auxiliary switch is hard-switched.
In this paper, a boost converter with soft switching is developed, which is implemented only by one auxiliary switch, one resonant inductor and one resonant capacitor as compared to the traditional boost converter. In this circuit, the main switch has zero-voltage and zero-current transition (ZVZCT) whereas the auxiliary switch has zero-current switching (ZCS). Aside from this, the PWM auto-tuning technique based on a given lookup table is added to adjust the turn-on instant and turn-on time of the auxiliary switch, so that the efficiency is further upgraded, particularly at light load. Therefore, the curve of efficiency versus load current is made nearly flat all over the load range. Regarding the system control, the digital controller is designed directly from the z-domain.
2. Operating Principle
Figure 1 shows the proposed step-up converter with soft switching, in which the dashed box is the auxiliary circuit, which consists of an auxiliary power switch
, a resonant inductor
and a resonant capacitor
.
Figure 2 displays the illustrated waveforms of the proposed converter operating.
Prior to the analysis, the following assumptions are made:
- (1)
The power switches and diodes are regarded as ideal components;
- (2)
The parasitic resistances of the inductance and capacitance are negligible;
- (3)
The input inductance is extremely large and can be viewed as an ideal constant current source;
- (4)
The output capacitance is very large and can be considered as an ideal constant voltage source.
According to the above assumptions, the converter operating can be divided into twelve states over one switching cycle.
State 1 [
]: Before the start of the switching cycle, both the main power switch
Sm and the auxiliary power switch
Sa are in the off-state, and the output diode
Do is in the on-state. As displayed in
Figure 3a at the time
t0, the auxiliary power switch
Sa turns on first, and the auxiliary power switch current
iSa rises rapidly to equal the input current
ILm, causing the output diode
Do to turn off and then state 1 to come to the end.
The initial current of the resonant inductor is the input current ILm and the initial voltage of the resonant capacitor is VCr10.
The corresponding equations in this state are
By substituting the boundary condition
into (1), we can find that the corresponding time experienced by this state is
State 2 [
]: As displayed in
Figure 3b, when the auxiliary power switch current
rises to the input current
, the parasitic capacitor
of the main power switch discharges. When the parasitic capacitor
of the main power switch discharges to zero, state 2 ends.
The initial current of the resonant inductor is the input current , the initial voltage of the resonant capacitor is VCr1, and the initial voltage of the parasitic capacitor across the main power switch is .
The corresponding equations in this state are
where
By substituting the boundary conditions into (3), we can find the corresponding time taken by this state is
State 3 [
]: As displayed in
Figure 3c, when the parasitic capacitance
of the main power switch is discharged to zero, the body diode
of the main power switch
is turned on. The initial current of resonant inductor is
ILr2 and the initial voltage of the resonant capacitor is
VCr2.
The corresponding equations in this state are
where
By substituting the boundary conditions into (6), we can find the corresponding time experienced by this state is
State 4 [
]: As shown in
Figure 3d, when the main power switch
is turned on with ZVS, the main power switch current
iSm starts to rise from zero to the input current
ILm. At this time, the auxiliary power switch
Sa is turned off with ZCS.
The initial current of the resonant inductor is ILm, and the initial voltage of the resonant capacitor is VCr3.
The corresponding equations in this state are
By substituting the boundary conditions into (9), we can find the time experienced by this state is
State 5 [
]: As displayed in
Figure 3e, when the main power switching current
is greater than the input current
ILm, the resonant inductor current
starts to flow in the opposite direction. When the resonant capacitor
Cr is discharged to zero, state 5 ends.
The initial current of the resonant inductor is zero, and the initial voltage of the resonant capacitor is VCr4.
The corresponding equations in this state are
By substituting the boundary conditions into (11), we can find the time taken by this state is
Sate 6 [
]: As displayed in
Figure 3e, this state continues to resonate. When the resonant inductor current
iLr resonates to zero, this state comes to end.
The initial current of the resonant inductor is ILr5, and the initial voltage of the resonant capacitor is zero.
The corresponding equations in this state are
By substituting the boundary conditions into (13), we can find the time experienced by this state is
State 7 [
]: As displayed in
Figure 3f, this state is like the magnetization state of the traditional boost converter, where the output capacitor
Co provides energy to the load. When the auxiliary power switch
Sa is turned on again, this state ends.
State 8 [
]: As displayed in
Figure 3g, when the auxiliary power switch
Sa is turned on, the resonant inductor current
iLr rises to the input current
ILm, and then state 8 comes to an end.
The initial current of the resonant inductor is zero, and the initial voltage of the resonant capacitor is .
The corresponding equations in this state are
By substituting the boundary conditions into (15), we can find the time experienced by this state is
State 9 [
]: As shown in
Figure 3h, when the resonant inductor current
is greater than the input current
, the main power switch current
starts to flow in the opposite direction. When the inductor current resonates to the input current
again, the main power switch is turned off at this time, so that the main power switch has ZCS turn-on.
The initial current of the resonant inductor is ILm, and the initial voltage of the resonant capacitor is .
The corresponding equations in this state is
By substituting the boundary conditions into (17), we can find the time taken by this state is
State 10 [
]: As shown in
Figure 3i, when the resonant inductor current
drops to zero, the auxiliary power switch
Sa is turned off with ZCS. Once the auxiliary power switch is turned off, this state ends.
The initial current of the resonant inductor is ILm, the initial voltage of the resonant capacitor is , and the initial voltage of the parasitic capacitor of the main power switch is zero.
The corresponding equations of this state is
By substituting the boundary conditions into (19), we can find the time experienced by this state is
State 11 [
]: As shown in
Figure 3j, when the voltage
on the parasitic capacitance of the main power switch rises above the output voltage
and the resonant inductor current rises linearly from zero to the input current
ILm, this state 11 ends.
The initial current of the resonant inductor is zero, and the initial voltage of the parasitic capacitor of the main power switch is .
The corresponding equations of state in this state are
where
By substituting the boundary conditions into (21), we can find the time experienced in this state is
State 12 [
]: As shown in
Figure 3k, this state is just like the input inductor demagnetization state of the traditional boost converter, sending energy to the output. When the auxiliary power switch
Sa is turned on again, this state ends and returns to state 1.
After deducing from the above-mentioned states, the soft switching status of the power switch can be found from
Table 1.
Table 1 display soft switching status of the power switches.
3. Modeling Based on Dual Time Scale Averaging Method
In this paper, the averaging method for dual time scale [
19] is used to derive the small-signal mathematical model of the proposed circuit. This averaging method can be used to classify the system into slow state variables and fast state variables. The slow state variables are input inductance current
and output capacitance voltage
, and the fast state variables are resonant capacitance voltage
and resonant inductor current
.
Figure 4 shows the equivalent circuit of the converter used after averaging. The dashed line shows the averaging mode of the fast state variables relative to the slow state variables.
The equations for the slow state variables can be listed from
Figure 4 as
where
is the average function of the main power switch over one switching period
Ts, i.e.,
;
is the average function of the output diode current over one switching period
Ts, i.e.,
. Therefore, the averaging mode of the slow state variables can be obtained by finding the average function of
and
. The symbols are defined herein first to reduce the complexity of the analysis, as follows:
where each time function includes the DC component and the AC small-signal component.
The definition of the average function of
, i.e.,
and the average function of
, i.e.,
and the solution
and
at each state can be obtained from the derivation in
Section 2, as follows:
Equations (27) and (28) can be expressed as
where
Equations (24) and (25) can be rewritten according to Equation (30) as
Since there are nonlinear terms in (29), differential equations based on the averaging mode are nonlinear. To obtain linear equations, Taylor series expansions at the DC operating point of the converter must be performed to remove nonlinear terms, and so that
where the small-signal AC equations are
At the quiescent DC operating point, applying (34) and small-signal AC disturbances shown in (35) to (31) and (32) can obtain (36) and (37), as follows:
After obtaining (36), the transfer function
Gvg(
s) of input voltage
to output voltage
and the transfer function
Gvd(
s) of duty cycle
to output voltage
can be obtained as follows:
where the denominator is defined as
Table 2 shows the system and component specifications.
By substituting the system and component specifications shown in
Table 2 into Equations (38) and (39), the input-to-output transfer function
Gvg(
s) can be found as
Furthermore, the duty-to- output transfer function is
After finding the transfer function of the proposed structure with resonant small signals by the dual time scale averaging method, the corresponding transfer function is compared with the small-signal transfer function of the traditional boost converter, which can be expressed as
From (42) and (43), the difference in zero value between them is not significant. However, the pole values in (42) are , and the pole values in (43) are . From these pole values of both equations, we can see that the proposed structure has a larger bandwidth because the resonance parameters are taken into considerations. That is to say, if the resonance parameters are ignored in the controller design, the designed controller is not suitable for the proposed structure.
4. Controller Design in Z-Domain
As shown in
Figure 5, the design of the digital controller proposed in this paper is designed directly in the
by the pole-zero configuration and the pole-zero cancellation design method.
Figure 5 shows the digital control loop with loop gain
:
where
is the discrete transfer function of the boost converter,
is the divider gain,
is the PWM gain, AD gain, z
−1 is the delay factor, and Equation (45) is the discrete transfer function of this controller, where
zp1 and
zp2 are poles,
zo1 and
zo2 are zeroes, and
Kc2 is the gain.
When the controller is not added, the phase margin of the system known from the Bode plot of the loop gain is . After designing the controller to make the system meet the prescribed specifications, the following steps will briefly describe the controller design.
Step 1: The gain margin is greater than 6 dB above and the crossover frequency is equal to one-tenth of the switching frequency.
Step 2: Configure poles zp1 and zp2 to match the gain margin and crossover frequency set by the system. Assuming a gain of Kc2 = 1 and using the Matlab software assistant tool, named SISO, to configure and observe the two poles zp1 and zp2 several times, zp1 and zp2 are finally selected to meet the prescribed gain margin and switching frequency.
Step 3: After step 2, the crossover frequency is fixed and the system phase margin is adjusted. Finally, the phase margin is set to 60 degrees. The gained
Kc2 value, which is the value required to adjust the phase margin to 60 degrees, can be found by the Matlab syntax to obtain a gain
Kc2 value of 0.81.
After the above steps, the discrete transfer function of the controller can be obtained as follows along with
zo1 and
zp2 :
The discrete transfer function of the above equation is converted into a difference equation, so that the difference equation can be written into programming language for digital control of the system.
Figure 6 shows the Bode plot of the system loop gain to verify the correctness of the designed controller.
5. Auto-Adjustment Technique
In this paper, the auto-adjustment technique is implemented by using the lookup table to regulate the on-time and triggering instant of the auxiliary power switch to further improve the efficiency, especially at light loads, and to make the overall efficiency of the converter present a flat curve. In addition, when the load increases or decreases, since the efficiency does not vary regularly with the on-time of the preceding and following transients of the auxiliary power switch and the triggering instant relative to the main power switch, a look-up table is used instead of a complex calculation to determine the required on-time and triggering instant of the auxiliary power switch.
Figure 7a,b show the auto-adjustment technique for the auxiliary power switch operating at light load and rated load, respectively. This auto-adjustment technique is based on the following two conditions: first, the auxiliary power switch must reach zero current cutoff, as shown in
Figure 7 at points A and B; second, when the auxiliary power switch current
iSa resonates to equal to the input current
ILm, the main power switch is turned on, as shown in
Figure 7 at points C and D. Therefore, by using the above-mentioned technique and using the input inductance current as the self-variable of the lookup table, the design steps are as follows.
Step 1: The light load to full load currents are divided into ten intervals and recorded separately based on no ADC sampling [
20]. The sampled count value of the input inductance current is recorded.
Step 2: Within the set ten current intervals, the on-time before and after transients of the auxiliary power switch and the triggering instant relative to the main power switch are adjusted and recorded, respectively, from full load to light load.
Step 3: According to the above two steps, the turn-on time and triggering time of the auxiliary power switch can be determined by this prescribed look-up table.
It is worth mentioning that the addition of a hysteresis band is required to avoid the oscillation caused by the current interval change.
6. Design of Resonant Inductor and Resonant Capacitor
In this section, the resonant capacitor
and resonant inductor
are designed based on the results of states 1, 2 and 10 in
Section 2. Without affecting the circuit operation behavior, it is determined that the overrun lead time of the auxiliary power switch must be less than or equal to one-tenth of the on time of the main power switch, i.e., less than or equal to
. Accordingly, the elapsed time
T1+
T2 shown in
Figure 2 must be less than or equal to
, where the elapsed time
is the time it takes for the current
of the auxiliary power switch
to rise to the input inductance current
after the auxiliary power switch is turned on, and the elapsed time
is the time it takes for the parasitic capacitor
of the main power switch to discharge to zero. The rise time
tr and the fall time
tf in the power switch instruction manual correspond to the characteristics of the current flowing through the power switch, so we can know that the time
. Therefore, the elapsed time
is less than or equal to
[
21], so the following equation can be found:
where
can be obtained by state 2 as follows:
where
is the average value of the rating input inductance current, and
can be obtained by state 10 as follows:
where the elapsed time
can be known from the following equation:
Therefore, can be found as .
Sequentially, let the resonant frequency
be greater than or equal to ten times the switching frequency, i.e.,
, and substitute (47) and (48) into (49) to obtain
The resonant capacitance
can be obtained as
from (53). The allowable error of the actual capacitance is considered, so the resonant capacitance
is chosen as
. After obtaining the resonant capacitance
, the resonant inductance
can be obtained as
Therefore, the value of resonance inductance can be obtained as , so this paper selects the resonance inductance as 1 .