1. Introduction
In today’s market environment, the increase in market activity has led to a complete redefinition of the market role of buyers who, being market participants, intensify their involvement in its functioning [
1,
2]. The new economic reality is governed by entirely new technologies that are in close relationship with each other, intertwining and conditioning each other. The new modern economy is digital [
3]. The role of the consumer as a passive spectator has evolved into a partnership requiring high-quality communication in the form of an ongoing dialogue [
4,
5].
Over the past few decades, there have been numerous technological changes referred to as Web 1.0, 2.0, 3.0. Access to Internet resources has developed, mainly offered in the form of LTE (Long Term Evolution) [
6]. There are lots of products on the market with a huge range of possibilities, manifested by access to the network. The use of smartwatches, smartphones, or tablets enables mobile use of the Internet, which makes it possible to communicate without physical contact [
7]. That can be extremely important in times of crises [
8] as enterprises need to pay close attention to all social, environmental, and economic crises faced by the global community [
9] as these components contribute to sustainability [
10]. These components also contribute to the development of healthy lifestyle digital technologies that affect consumption patterns—especially of young people [
11].
Due to the increasing environmental awareness of consumers, companies have had to react by introducing sustainability strategies. Today, almost all companies and organizations regularly publish sustainability reports [
12,
13] and, while designing their market offer, take into account aspects of “sustainable development”. One element is related to green products.
Sustainable national development obviously depends on the profitability, global performance of enterprises [
14,
15], and renewable energy production [
16]; however, sustainable consumption should also play a prominent role in the formulation and implementation of the sustainable development goals [
17,
18]. Transforming both production systems and consumption patterns has become one of the most important trends towards achieving sustainable development [
19]. Sustainable production based on the green-marketing approach aims to protect the environment while producing goods and services. Thus, consumers, while satisfying their own needs, can easily find environmentally friendly products in the market [
20]. Buying green products, reducing consumption, eliminating disposable carrier plastic bags, or buying second hand products are important patterns in sustainable consumption [
21], while excessive consumption causes many negative environmental effects and aware, responsible consumers prefer organic products, or they keep other sustainable consumption patterns [
22].
The aim of this article is to describe the factors influencing the purchase of environmentally friendly products by young e-consumers as a determinant of sustainable consumption. A specific objective of the research was to verify different types of behaviors as well as to determine the factors that most often influence the purchase of organic products.
The paper is based on an empirical study conducted in November 2021 on a research sample of 620 respondents in a survey of Polish e-consumer attitudes towards organic products using a CAWI-compliant survey questionnaire.
3. Materials and Methods
The entire research process was divided into the stages of literature analysis and empirical research, which included preparing research questions, gathering data, statistical analysis and drawing conclusions. It was based on the use of a questionnaire sent to Polish adult e-consumers shopping for organic products chosen by means of purposive sampling (non-random sampling) [
64,
65]. At the beginning of the research, all the respondents were asked the filter question of if they purchase organic products online. Only an affirmative answer directed the respondent to the next part of the survey.
The minimum sample size calculated at the confidence level of α = 0.95 and margin of error of 5% for the population of adult Poles on the basis of data provided on the official site [
66] was defined as 385.
The sample size formula [
67] was as follows:
where:
n is the sample size, z is the z-score associated with a level of confidence,
p is the sample proportion expressed as a decimal, e is the margin of error expressed as a decimal, and N is the population size.
The final number of respondents exceeded the assumed minimum sample size in order to make the sample more representative [
68].
The survey was conducted in November 2021. During this period, a survey questionnaire was distributed to respondents following the standards of the CAWI technique. The research conducted in 2021 was the continuation of the research from 2020. The survey could not have been complemented by personal interviews because of the COVID-19 pandemic restrictions. The results of the questionnaires were processed using the SPSS Statistics program, for many years the most widely used program for quantitative data analysis in the social sciences. Thanks to SPSS Statistics, the data were analyzed in-depth, which allowed for statistically significant correlations between particular groups of respondents, as well as for verification of the hypotheses that were formulated.
The research problem in this paper is to analyze the purchasing behavior of Polish young e-consumers of organic products and to assess the importance of factors potentially influencing their beliefs and purchase decisions. Research findings from around the world indicate that the perception of health attributes of organic products is one of the most significant purchase intentions and choices in both developed and developing countries [
69,
70,
71]. Specifying the adopted research problem, the following questions were posed about the purchase behavior of young consumers in the area of organic products, in particular:
What are the most common buying behaviors among young e-consumers of organic products, and what are the main determinants?
What opinions do young e-consumers hold when making purchasing decisions?
Do e-consumers share opinions and suggest changes to the organic products offered?
These questions seem to be extremely relevant due to the increasing role of the social and environmental aspects in modern management concepts (Environmental Corporate Social Responsibility-ECSR) [
72,
73].
In order to answer the research questions posed in this way, it is necessary to use a lower level of specificity and define the research hypotheses in a declarative manner:
Hypothesis 1 (H1). Young consumers are willing to purchase organic products via the Internet.
Hypothesis 2 (H2). There should be a balance between technical attributes, market attributes, and feedback from other consumers.
Hypothesis 3 (H3). Feedback and feedback interaction from buyers is expected after the transaction.
The necessity of sustainable development of a business compels companies take this aspect into account in their strategies and directions of further development, and the awareness of the issue among young consumers is growing. Thus, solving the adopted research problem may give valuable practical indications for the managers of modern companies.
For the purpose of the research, a one-factor variance analysis was used as a method to verify the hypotheses. The null hypothesis with equal average values for the general population was verified by the F-test (Fisher-Snedecor). The application of this test was possible as the calculated indices could be considered as continuous variables with distributions close to normality (at the materiality level α = 0.05) based on the results of the Kolomogorov–Smirnov test. To verify the reliability of the questions concerning the surveyed companies, the Alpha Cronbach test was carried out, which made it possible to determine the variables with statistically significant correlations.
The socio-demographic characteristics of respondents is presented in
Table 1.
The questions and statements selected for the questionnaire reflected the phrases most frequently repeated during the interviews conducted in the 2020 pilot study and were worded to be unambiguous to respondents. The 5-grade Likert scale was applied to rank statements; depending on the statement, 1 indicated definitely no and 5-definitely yes, or 1 indicated never and 5-always. Interpretation of the Likert scale provides numerical information and tells us which responses in each group of respondents were selected most frequently. The respondent selects the statement that most closely matches his/her feelings. The number of possible choices should be odd (usually 5) so that the middle statement is neutral.
4. Results and Discussion
During the study, different types of buying behaviors attributable to young e-consumers in the organic market were verified. It was important to ask about the frequency of online purchases. 12% of respondents engage in this type of shopping every day or a few times a week, 48% make online purchases a few times a month but not more often than once a week, while for 39%, the frequency is a few times a year but not more often than once a month.
The matter to be verified was to determine the aspects that are important to the consumer when making purchases (see
Table 2). Responses could be given on a 5-point Likert scale, where 1 meant definitely not important, and 5 meant definitely important. The quality of the product and service is very important. It is followed by the price and the possibility of obtaining information about the product. It turns out that a significant number of consumers take into account the opinions of other Internet users when making purchases.
An important part of the research was the finding that a huge proportion of respondents are interested in consuming food products free of pesticides and fertilizers, medicines not subject to genetic modification, and products grown in harmony with nature to which a total of 432 individuals provided affirmative responses (n = 211 at level 4, while n = 221 at level 5). A total of 62 people gave negative responses (n = 25 at level 1, n = 37 at level 2). Thus, for many respondents, environmental aspects remain important when purchasing products online (334 respondents stated that ecological aspects are important for them at different levels, 145 people do not consider them important).
Before buying an organic product, customers like to look for information about it. Most often they carefully read the product labels. It is also not uncommon to browse through online stores and nutrition portals. Detailed information is presented in
Table 3.
The most common place to purchase eco-products is a stand in a supermarket, but to a large extent, customers purchase organic products from an online store. The exact distribution of responses is shown in
Table 4.
Another issue was the specification of technological attributes that guide the consumer in choosing organic food. It turns out that natural taste and a low level of processing are of great importance (
Table 5).
In terms of market attributes when choosing foods, consumers value health benefits the most, as well as their availability in hypermarkets and supermarkets (see
Table 6).
Among organic products, consumers most often choose healthy food, followed by natural cosmetics and beverages (
Table 7).
19% of respondents (n = 117) expect a personalized offer and only 13% (n = 82) share their opinions about organic products with other consumers online. An even smaller proportion of respondents (n = 38.6%) share their opinions about organic products with the producer after purchasing them. Only a few (n = 43.7%) suggested to the producer that they make changes to the organic products they offer.
Structural equation modeling (SEM) is a multivariate quantitative technique combining aspect of factor analysis and multiple regression employed to describe the relationships among observed variables [
74,
75]. SEM was estimated using the maximum likelihood method. It involves examining in a purely hypothetical model the relationships between variables, both measured and latent, that is, variables that are not directly observable [
76]. There was no basis to reject the null hypothesis that the residual values of the empirical and theoretical matrices are equal to zero (χ
2 = 445.4;
p = 0.001). The root mean square error of approximation, RMSEA value = 0.088, indicates that the model is a good fit to the data. To determine the reliability of the data, the value of Cronbach’s alpha coefficient was determined to be 0.704.
To verify the hypotheses, H1, H2, and H3, an analytical-deductive process was carried out, which required first listing the observable and unobservable endogenous variables. The structural model estimated by the maximum likelihood method (
Figure 1) includes the following:
Observable endogenous variables: 2-age; 9_1-price; 9_2-UX friendly; 9_3-quality of a product/service; 9_4-delivery time; 9_5-guarantee; 9_6-product information; 9_7-payment form; 9_8–opinions of other Internet users; 9_9-after-sales service; 9_10-organic origin of products; 10-desire to consume foods that have not been produced using pesticides, fertilizers, or drugs; 11-the extent to which environmental aspects are important when purchasing; 14-size of the pool of money spent on green purchases per month.
Unobservable endogenous variables: Y-buying behavior.
Model measurement errors: e1, e2, e3, e4, e5, e6, e7, e8, e9, e10, e11, e12, e13, e14, e15.
The random component of the structural model: e16.
Figure 1.
Estimated structural model. Source: own. Note: *** means p < 0.001.
Figure 1.
Estimated structural model. Source: own. Note: *** means p < 0.001.
Further in the process of analyzing the results, the non-standardized and standardized coefficients of the model were counted (
Table 8 and
Table 9).
The non-standardized coefficients of the model tell how many units the value of the explanatory variable will change when the value of a given explanatory variable increases by a unit. Standardized coefficients, on the other hand, describe by how many standard deviations the value of the explained variable will change when the value of the explanatory variable increases by one standard deviation [
77,
78].
The above interpretations are valid only if the values of other variables remain unchanged. The coefficient values thus describe the direction (positive/negative) and strength of the influence on the explanatory variable. The strength of influence on the explained variable can be compared between explanatory variables by means of standardized coefficients. This is because the values of non-standardized coefficients depend on the units in which the variables are measured [
79,
80,
81,
82].
One of the methods to quantify the relationship between variables is to use the Pearson correlation coefficient, which is a measure of the linear relationship between the variables. The value of this coefficient is defined between −1 and 1.
Table 10 shows the strength of the correlation between the variables, where: −1 means a perfectly negative linear correlation between two variables; 0 means no linear correlation between the two variables; and 1 means a perfectly positive linear correlation between the two variables. The further the correlation coefficient is away from zero, the stronger the measured relationship between the two variables.
In light of the statistical analyses performed, it can be assumed that the posited H1 has been partially confirmed. Young consumers are willing to buy organic products via the Internet, taking into account only some selection criteria. Based on the standardized coefficients of the model, it was found that the variable, Y-purchasing behavior, is most strongly influenced by the variables, 9_6-product information, 9_3-service/product quality, and 9_5-warranty.
The statistical analyses conducted showed that all variables, except 14-the size of the pool of money spent on green purchases per month, are statistically significant, that is, the influence on variable Y (shopping behavior), except for the mentioned variable 14, is statistically significant, p < 0.001. In turn, the least influence on shopping behavior is exerted by variable 10-willingness to consume food products in which no pesticides, fertilizers and drugs were used in the production.
Therefore, it can be concluded that purchasing behavior is mainly determined by three types of factors. The first is product information drawn from a variety of sources, such as nutrition portals, organic food producer websites, online store websites, experts and professionals in the field, family and friends, and product labels. Another factor is the quality of the product and service, including issues such as the ability to purchase products without preservatives, low level of processing, natural taste and appearance, products produced without artificial fertilizers, pesticides, added hormones, and antibiotics, produced in a clean environment, and guaranteeing health benefits. The third important factor is the guarantee, which includes the right to lodge a complaint. Therefore, H2 posed in the discussion can be considered confirmed, with product information, quality, and warranty factors having the greatest influence on this balance. Thus, placing emphasis on the listed groups of factors by producers will allow purchasing activities to intensify among young e-consumers, as well as contribute to the harmonious functioning of the sustainable consumption market.
The final element of the discussion is H3, which assumed that following the fashion and communication trends among young consumers, they would be very active in building interactions and feedback. Meanwhile, in question 19 of the survey, only 282 out of 620 respondents (45%) indicated that they shop for organic products online. Based on further questions, 22, 23, 24, and 25, out of these 282 people, only 41% expect to be offered personalized organic products, only 29% share their opinion about organic products online with other organic consumers after purchase, and only 15% have ever suggested to the manufacturer to make changes to the organic products they offer.
Thus, it can be assumed that the H3 posed in the study has not been confirmed because at this level of after-sales activity, it is difficult to discuss a significant way of building a relationship or loyalty with the potential customer of the younger generation for organic products. This is an important conclusion for sellers of organic products in the studied group of respondents.
5. Conclusions
The presented statistical correlations highlight the significant correlations of purchasing behaviors of young e-consumers and the strength of their influence. Thus, it is possible to set universal purchasing trends, taking into account that the purchasing behavior of young e-consumers is mainly influenced by product information and product and service quality and warranty. Quite surprising is the fact that willingness to consume food products produced without pesticides, fertilizers, and drugs was the least important to young e-consumers.
The findings of this study suggest several important recommendations that may be of interest to managers of green e-markets to attract producers and increase e-consumer demand for organic products.
Most importantly, the results confirm the relationship between e-marketplace purchase willingness and e-consumer attitudes. The importance of focusing on online information about fair trade and environmental and health benefits when attracting consumers to green e-markets has been revealed. This has become a major way to differentiate these buy-sell platforms from traditional competitors. The traditional organic market needs to be adapted to online contacts through electronic communication tools. The quality of service in this case requires that product attributes are designed in such a way to facilitate the online transaction [
56]. Offline and online shopping induce consumers to behave differently due to the lack of physical contact with the product [
83]. When making an offline purchase, reliable information comes from personal sensory examination, whereas online shopping is influenced by the customer’s purchase intention in addition to social influence or knowledge and curiosity [
84]. To overcome the barrier of not being able to view products before purchasing them [
85], good trust in shopping requires high quality online services [
86,
87] and professional online platforms [
88]. Improved trust when shopping online occurs when full information about product attributes is available, and for this reason, care should be taken with this aspect of online sales.
It should also be taken into account that young e-consumers make purchases with reference to current trends and fashion and that they are usually affected by their environment [
89]. The marketing messages directed to them by producers and marketers may therefore include aspects of both belonging to a group and following trends created by an authority—a trendsetter or influencer. The social aspect of consumer decisions is an extremely important element, especially among young people, who on the one hand desire the feeling of uniqueness and individuality but on the other hand strongly desire to be part of a larger community [
90].
Another aspect that may be intriguing for retailers is to try to combine the environmental and health messages associated with their products to leverage the positive effect of consumer attitudes about both topics. Even though certain factors have been shown to influence the willingness to purchase separately, actual purchasing behavior is often influenced by a combination of variables that cannot be easily clarified. Therefore, it would be prudent for vendors to try to track their efforts to increase e-sales of organic food by encouraging e-customers to participate in loyalty programs and by carefully analyzing the data of customers already participating in these programs.
However, offerors are not the only group that can benefit from the results of the research. Based on the study’s findings and the factors identified as mattering most in organic product choices, key players such as socio-environmental organizations and organic product marketers need to redefine their operations, aligning them with the needs of organic product e-consumers. In the long run, this can result in the development of local markets for organic products and influence sustainable development in Poland.
The results of the conducted study can also enrich the literature in terms of understanding consumer behavior in the “green market”.
The research described in this article does not fully exhaust the questions related to the online behavior of young consumers on the organic market. The main limitation of this study is associated with both a convenient sample and a finite geographic area. The survey was conducted only among e-consumers and it would be interesting to compare on what basis consumers make purchase decisions in stationary shops. Additionally, the study took place during the coronavirus pandemic, so the study authors did not have the opportunity to meet the respondents in person and conduct a more detailed interview, which can certainly be considered an important limitation of this study. Further qualitative research and analysis would be valuable to uncover the hidden, non-parametric motives for organic purchasing behavior.
It would also be interesting to perform a similar scientific study conducted among respondents from abroad to compare domestic and foreign surveys.