1. Introduction
The contamination of freshwater ecosystems is a multifaceted issue, and the solutions to it require a deeper understanding of the ecosystem’s structure and the appropriateness of the methods used to assess its condition. The methods and indices used to evaluate the impact of pollution on natural water bodies are based on an ecological perspective, focusing on the relationship between the water and the biota, including algae and plants. The production of proteins is a crucial aspect of this process, as it involves the primary producers, such as algae and higher plants, which can serve as bioindicators of pollution.
The evaluation of the ecological condition of water bodies encompassed the examination of the composition and density of phytoplankton, macroalgae, and angiosperms [
1,
2]. Macrophytes, a diverse group of aquatic plants, are crucial for assessing the water quality of surface waters, as they can become abundant and often dominate the ecosystem, reflecting the trophic state of the water body [
3,
4]. The method of bioindication, which involves studying the reaction of living organisms to alterations in their surroundings, is crucial for assessing the impact of pollution on aquatic habitats [
5,
6]. Bioindicators are aquatic organisms, including plants, plankton, animals, and microorganisms, that are employed to assess the well-being of the natural environment [
1]. Plants serve as highly responsive indicators for forecasting and identifying environmental stressors. In the modern era, industrialization and urbanization have exacerbated the issue of water contamination and pollution [
7,
8]. The presence or absence of certain plant species or other vegetation can serve as a reliable indicator of the state of the environment [
8,
9]. The saprobity index S is calculated for phytoplankton communities to evaluate the pollution of the ecosystem and assess the risk [
10]. This approach is based on the specific bioindicator characteristics of species and the abundance of primary producers in the entire community. It is closely related to the trophic chemical components and is therefore used to assess the trophic state of water [
11].
The saprobity index S can be determined for the macrophyte community and then integrated into the framework for evaluating water quality, particularly regarding organic pollution [
4,
12]. This approach is particularly relevant for lakes and wetlands, where macrophytes are frequently employed for assessing the impact of human activities [
13]. Additionally, a system was created that utilized a combination of assessment techniques for diatoms, invertebrates, macrophytes, and other aquatic organisms [
14,
15].
The aquatic plant
Potamogeton perfoliatus L. (clasping-leaf pondweed), a submerged macrophyte, is a keystone species in freshwater ecosystems, particularly in shallow, nutrient-rich lakes and ponds [
16]. It plays a critical role in maintaining ecological balance through oxygen production, nutrient cycling, and habitat provision for aquatic organisms [
17,
18]. However, its survival and metabolic functions are increasingly threatened by urbanization, climate change, and the unique challenges of permafrost regions—factors that alter water chemistry, light availability, and sediment dynamics [
19,
20].
In urbanized areas, lakes face compounded stressors such as nutrient runoff, heavy metal contamination, and temperature fluctuations due to anthropogenic activities [
20,
21]. These perturbations disrupt the photosynthetic efficiency and nutrient uptake mechanisms of
P. perfoliatus, as observed in studies linking periphyton accumulation to reduced light penetration and altered spectral quality, which force morphological and physiological acclimations in the plant [
22]. For instance,
P. perfoliatus exhibits shade-avoidance traits, such as elongated internodes and increased leaf area, under low red-to-infrared light ratios caused by periphyton coverage [
18]. Such adaptations may divert energy from growth to stress mitigation, altering its metabolic priorities.
Permafrost thaw introduces additional complexity. Recent studies highlight that thawing permafrost mobilizes iron, sulfates, and toxic trace metals (e.g., Zn, Ni) into aquatic systems, lowering pH and increasing turbidity [
20,
23]. These changes impair macrophyte production by up to 80% in affected water bodies [
22], while microbial shifts in permafrost soils further modify nutrient cycling pathways [
23]. In Arctic regions, abrupt transitions from clear to iron-rich “orange streams” have been linked to declines in macroinvertebrate diversity and fish populations, indirectly destabilizing macrophyte habitats [
20].
P. perfoliatus in such environments may face oxidative stress, as reactive oxygen species (ROS) and caspase-3-like proteins—key regulators of aerenchyma formation—are sensitive to redox imbalances [
24].
This study investigates the metabolic responses of
P. perfoliatus to pollutant elements as urban and permafrost-driven stressors in lakes across a permafrost urban gradient in parallel with planktonic microalgae and cyanobacteria. By analyzing photosynthetic efficiency, nutrient assimilation, and stress biomarkers (e.g., ROS activity), we aim to elucidate how synergistic pressures reshape the plant’s physiology in the environmental pollution and trophic base gradient defined by planktonic microorganisms and water chemistry. The findings will advance our understanding of ecological resilience in freshwater systems and inform conservation strategies for aquatic flora in rapidly changing Arctic and sub-Arctic urban landscapes [
21].
4. Discussion
The concentration of nitrogen and phosphorus compounds was high in all of the studied lakes, which is consistent with the eutrophic assessment based on microalgae. However, the highest content of these biogenic substances was found in Lakes Ytyk-Kyuyol and Dachnoe. Lake Ierelyakh is not subject to anthropogenic load, and in Lake Saysary, periodic work is carried out to clear the bottom sediments and aerate the water as part of the municipal program for the reclamation of urban water bodies. Apparently, this explains the fact that in these two lakes the concentration of nitrogen and phosphorus compounds, color, and COD were the lowest among the studied water bodies. According to the classification of S. P. Kitaev [
45], based on the content of mineral nitrogen, Lakes Ytyk-Kyuyol and Dachnoe were classified as hypertrophic water bodies, while the other lakes were classified as β-eutrophic. Based on the concentration of total phosphorus, all water bodies were classified as hypertrophic according to the classification of R. G. Wetzel [
46]. In this case, the greatest biomass of phytoplankton was achieved only in Lakes Dachnoe and Ytyk-Kyuyol, where the bloom of water bodies was noted visually by the greenish tint of the water. According to the classification of G. K. Nürnberg [
47], Lakes Dachnoe and Ytyk-Kyuyol were β-eutrophic water bodies according to the biomass of phytoplankton, while the other lakes were α-β-mesotrophic. It should be noted that all lakes were characterized by a high amount of total iron. It is known that in waters rich in oxygen and iron, the proportion of biologically available phosphorus can be only a part of its total amount [
48]. Therefore, despite the increased content of biogenic substances in the studied water bodies, their biological availability could be limited. Based on the bioindicator properties of planktonic microalgae, we have noted the strongest anthropogenic pressure for Lakes Dachnoe and Ytyk-Kyuyol.
All the studied lakes are in the stage of overgrowing with higher aquatic vegetation. The ecological state for this stage is normal. The influx of biogenic elements into the lakes was compensated for by the rapid development of aquatic vegetation in the Lakes Ierelyakh and Saysary, where it played the role of a biological filter and prevented “water bloom” (development of planktonic microalgae).
Potamogeton is widespread in lakes and is a good indicator of organic pollution. There are 12 known species of
Potamogeton, for which the species-specific saprobity index S [
4,
49] has been calculated. Moreover,
P. perfoliatus has one of the highest indices (S = 2.30), being an indicator of rather high organic pollution and, thus, a high trophic status of the lake. The dynamics of phosphate concentration and other production indicators is associated with changes in the saprobity indices of the aquatic community [
50]. Thus, having data on phosphates, one can judge the trophic status of the reservoir, and the saprobity indices show how actively the processes of self-purification and their utilization proceed. In our case, phosphates decrease in the series of Lakes Dachnoye–Ierelyakh, where the phytoplankton saprobity indices were about 2.04, while
Potamogeton perfoliatus has a species saprobity index of 2.30 [
4]. This shows how much more actively macrophytes, which live for a long time and form a large biomass during the year, purify the water of the lakes [
12,
51].
Aquatic macrophytes of the genus
Potamogeton, which play a crucial role in the functioning of freshwater ecosystems, exhibit diverse adaptive mechanisms in response to anthropogenic stressors such as heavy metal pollution, eutrophication, and changes in hydrological regimes. Studies have shown that the toxicity of metals to these plants varies in the order Zn > Cu > Pb, with species differing in their ability to accumulate elements:
P. pectinatus accumulates more copper, while
P. perfoliatus accumulates more lead, highlighting the importance of metal phytotoxicity in sediments rather than their total content [
52,
53]. The impact of metals on plant physiology, including reduced photosynthetic activity (Fv/Fm) and oxidative stress, is modulated by both their combined effects (e.g., the antagonism between Zn and Cu) and external factors such as light quality. For instance, blue light reduces cadmium toxicity in
P. crispus by enhancing antioxidant defenses and pigment synthesis [
54,
55]. Simultaneously, eutrophication combined with shading disrupts the carbon–nitrogen metabolism of macrophytes, leading to the accumulation of free amino acids and oxidative stress, which explains their decline in eutrophic water bodies [
56]. Stress resistance also depends on morphological plasticity:
P. perfoliatus alters leaf and shoot structure in response to water depth, trophic status, and wave exposure, demonstrating adaptability critical for survival in dynamic conditions [
57,
58]. Life strategies such as vegetative reproduction through turions and the presence of rhizomes ensure long-term resilience, as observed in narrow-leaved
Potamogeton species in changing river ecosystems [
59]. However, prolonged droughts, even for relatively resilient species like
P. nodosus, result in high mortality, necessitating water resource management to minimize risks [
60]. Biochemical adaptations, including the restructuring of membrane lipid composition and the activation of antioxidant systems, play a key role in cadmium tolerance, where low metal concentrations may stimulate photosynthetic pigment synthesis, while high concentrations disrupt tissue structural integrity [
61]. Considerable variations were noted in the studied lakes in terms of the content of pollutant elements accumulated in the tissues of
Potamogeton perfoliatus and the intensity of the associated metabolic processes in the plant. The pronounced enrichment in aluminum (Al), silicon (Si), iron (Fe), and rare earth elements (Nd, Ce, La) in plants from Lake Dachnoe, as well as elevated levels of heavy metals (Cu, Cr, Ni, V) indicate a complex interaction of geogenic and anthropogenic factors. The total concentration of pollutant elements (∑) in the tissues of
P. perfoliatus from Lake Dachnoe was almost four-times higher than in the relatively unpolluted Lake Ierelyakh, which emphasizes the heterogeneity of the ecological conditions of water bodies in urbanized permafrost areas. It is noteworthy that the 24.8-fold increase in Al content in Lake Dachnoe compared to Lake Ierelyakh is consistent with regional geochemical features, where the weathering of aluminosilicate rocks and cryogenic processes in permafrost soils promote the natural release of Al and Si into aquatic systems [
62]. However, the simultaneous increase in concentrations of Cu, Cr, Ni, and V—elements typically associated with anthropogenic activities such as urban runoff, transport emissions, and industrial waste—indicates local human impact in areas near Lake Dachnoe [
63]. Thus, Lake Dachnoe stands out as the reservoir with the highest concentrations of most elements compared to the control Lake Ierelyakh. This may be due to natural geochemical processes. However, it is also likely to be due to anthropogenic impact. In the basin of Lake Dachnoe, there are two potential sources of man-made impact: a municipal controlled landfill dump and a sand quarry (
Figure 1). Geographically, these objects are quite remote from Lake Dachnoe, but the runoff into the lake is possible from their territory. And given the features of the permafrost zone, where frozen soils are impermeable to water and with surface runoff, dissolved substances may not be immediately absorbed by the soil and can be transported over significant distances.
From the dynamics of Potamogeton development in the studied lakes, its biomass is greater where the trophic status of the lake is higher in phosphorus and where there are most pollutants in the bodies of plants. Consequently, Potamogeton perfoliatus can be not only a good indicator of the concentration of organic pollutants, but also an indicator of the high ability of the lake ecosystem to self-purify, which is also indicated by the high biomass of phytoplankton.
The partitioning of metabolomes between lakes revealed by PCA, particularly the clear clustering of samples from Lake Dachnoe, highlights the sensitivity of P. perfoliatus to environmental gradients. The contribution of sugars, organic acids, and fatty acids to the observed variance supports the role of these metabolites in mediating plant responses to pollutant stress. Such metabolic plasticity may enhance the species’ resilience in polluted habitats, although long-term exposure may impair physiological functions, as evidenced by the sharp decline in energy-rich compounds.
Metabolomic analysis revealed distinct changes in primary and secondary metabolites in P. perfoliatus tissues under different pollutant loads. The data obtained may be associated with the adaptation of Potamogeton perfoliatus to stressful growing conditions. It is known that sucrose and monosaccharides play a key role in the energy metabolism of plants, and their decrease may be associated with an increase in energy costs for detoxification and the body’s defense mechanisms.
One of the key changes in the metabolome of
Potamogeton perfoliatus was a decrease in the content of sucrose, monosaccharides, and polyols as a result of an increase in pollutant elements. It is known that carbohydrates play an important role in the energy metabolism of plants, and their decrease may indicate the inhibition of photosynthetic activity and energy balance disturbance. This can be confirmed by the inverse correlation of the content of sucrose (
r = −0.83;
p = 0.02), mannose (
r = −0.85;
p = 0.02), glucose (
r = −0.91;
p = 0.01), and fructose (
r = −0.85;
p = 0.02) relative to the content of pollutant elements in the tissues of
Potamogeton perfoliatus (
Figure 6). Similar changes were observed in other studies, where heavy metal pollution led to a decrease in the content of sugars and polyols in the tissues of aquatic plants [
19,
64]. Under ocean acidification (OA) conditions, the macroalgae
Ulva prolifera exhibited a reduction in sucrose concentration, which was associated with enhanced growth rates and elevated energy costs for protein biosynthesis [
65]. These findings indicate a shift in sugar resource allocation towards growth-related processes, despite the presence of environmental stress.
The glucose concentration showed a negative correlation with the trophic status of the lake in the form of phosphate concentration (r = −0.96; p = 0.01), as well as with the development of microalgae in terms of the biomass (r = −0.85; p = 0.07) and abundance (r = −0.85; p = 0.07) of phytoplankton.
Organic acids such as glyceric, malic, erythronic, fumaric, succinic, and citric acids also showed a decrease in concentration in the tissues of
Potamogeton perfoliatus with an increase in the content of pollutant elements and trophic state of the lake. These acids are involved in key metabolic pathways, including the tricarboxylic acid cycle (TCA), which is the main source of energy for cells. A decrease in their content may indicate a disruption in energy metabolism and oxidative phosphorylation, which is consistent with data on the toxic effects of heavy metals on plant enzymatic systems [
66]. This fact can be confirmed by the inverse correlation of citric acid (
r = −0.78;
p = 0.03), fumaric acid (
r = −0.61;
p = 0.05), succinic acid (
r = −0.79;
p = 0.03), and malic acid (
r = −0.72;
p = 0.03) with respect to the content of pollutant elements in the tissues of
Potamogeton perfoliatus (
Figure 7). Under copper (Cu) stress, the marine algae
Sargassum fusiforme exhibited a decline in malate, succinate, and citrate levels, likely driven by the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). This reduction in key metabolites is thought to impair the efficiency of the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle [
67].
Fatty acids such as linoleic (
r = −0.88;
p = 0.06) and linolenic (
r = −0.95;
p = 0.05) also showed a decrease in concentration in the tissues of
Potamogeton perfoliatus with an increase in pollutant elements. These acids are important components of cell membranes and are involved in the regulation of fluidity and permeability. A decrease in their content can lead to a disruption of membrane integrity and an increase in the sensitivity of cells to oxidative stress. Similar changes were observed in studies where heavy metal pollution caused oxidative stress and damage to lipid membranes [
19,
68]. Under OA conditions,
Ulva prolifera exhibited triglyceride remodeling, marked by a reduction in polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) and an increase in palmitic acid content. This shift may reflect adaptations to optimize membrane fluidity and energy storage [
65]. In a separate study, cadmium exposure in
Ulva lactuca resulted in a threefold rise in n-6 PUFAs (18:3 ω-6 and 18:2 ω-6), potentially mitigating oxidative stress by modulating lipoxygenase activity [
69]. These findings underscore the dual role of lipids as both structural elements and key players in signaling pathways and antioxidant protection.
Phenolic compounds, which also showed a decrease in concentration in the tissues of
Potamogeton perfoliatus with increasing pollutant elements, are known to play an important role in protecting plants from oxidative stress and pathogens. Their decrease may indicate a disruption of antioxidant defenses and an increase in the vulnerability of plants to the toxic effects of pollutants. Phenolic compounds, including flavonoids and tannins, have been shown to play a critical role in mitigating heavy metal toxicity by chelating metal ions and reducing their bioavailability. However, with long-term exposure to high concentrations of heavy metals, the production of these compounds may decrease due to the suppression of key enzymes involved in their biosynthesis [
70].
5. Conclusions
The degree of anthropogenic load on four water bodies of urbanized territory in the zone of continuous permafrost distribution was estimated by methods of bioindication and direct analysis of the concentrations of the main chemical components of lake waters. The anthropogenic impact on the studied water bodies is accompanied by an increase in their trophic level. Only in the lake located within the city limits was the anthropogenic impact compensated for by reclamation works. Data on the concentrations of pollutant elements in the tissues of Potamogeton perfoliatus confirm the results based on the bioindication properties of planktonic microalgae. Pollutant accumulation in P. perfoliatus tissues reached 19,940 mg kg⁻1 DW in Lake Dachnoe, with aluminum concentrations 24.8-fold higher than the control. The results of metabolomic analysis indicate that the pollution of water bodies with pollutant elements has a significant effect on the metabolism of Potamogeton perfoliatus, leading to a decrease in the content of key metabolites, such as carbohydrates, organic acids, fatty acids, and phenolic compounds. Significant inverse correlations to the sum levels of pollutant elements of carbohydrates such as sucrose (r = −0.83; p = 0.02), mannose (r = −0.85; p = 0.02), glucose (r = −0.91; p = 0.01), and fructose (r = −0.85; p = 0.02), as well as tricarboxylic acid cycle metabolites including citric acid (r = −0.78; p = 0.03), fumaric acid (r = −0.61; p = 0.05), succinic acid (r = −0.79; p = 0.03), and malic acid (r = −0.72; p = 0.03), highlight the disruption of metabolism. These changes may be associated with the disruption of energy metabolism, oxidative stress, and damage to cell membranes caused by an increase in the concentration of pollutant elements in the cells of Potamogeton perfoliatus.
In a comprehensive study of the response of primary producers (planktonic microalgae and Potamogeton) to the level of anthropogenic stress and the trophic status of lakes in the permafrost region, a positive correlation was found between the trophic status of the lake, the accumulation of pollutants in the body of higher plants, and the biomass of planktonic microalgae. However, a negative correlation was observed between these indicators and the metabolic activity of Potamogeton, indicating its suppression during water body pollution. The study also showed the high Potamogeton accumulation capacity, which makes it possible to recommend its colonization for the remediation of water bodies in the permafrost zone. As a practical recommendation to implement urban lake restoration programs, for the better removal of phosphates and nitrates, planting is proposed of Potamogeton and removal of its biomass in autumn, at the end of the growing season, together with accumulated pollutants.
As a result of this research, it was found that the accumulation of pollutant elements in plant tissues decreases in order of decreasing trophic status of the lake and decreasing eutrophic microalgae indicators. This study has shown the relevance of complex work based on the bioindicator properties of microalgae and metabolomic analysis of higher aquatic vegetation to assess the anthropogenic load on aquatic ecosystems of permafrost territories.