1. Introduction
The starry flounder (
Platichthys stellatus Pallas 1787) is a dominant and economically significant flatfish species cultured in various areas, including the eastern coastal regions of Korea. It is a large species widely distributed in low-temperature zones, extending from the north of central Japan to Russia’s Maritime Province, the Otsuk Sea, the Bering Sea, and California Bay in the United States [
1]. The annual production capacity of starry flounders is approximately 8000 tons, ranking third (9.7%) in Republic of Korea’s mariculture production and totaling 79,700 tons in 2023 [
2]. As a cold-water fish species, starry flounders actively feed at temperatures below 15 °C, with an optimal growth temperature of 13–18 °C [
3]. However, fish are susceptible to diseases in summer. Several infectious diseases, including infections caused by
Edwardsiella tarda [
4],
Streptococcus parauberis [
5], red sea bream iridovirus [
6],
Trichodina [
7], and
Enteromyxum leei [
8], have been reported in starry flounders.
In April 2023, a disease outbreak occurred across starry flounder farms in Pohang-si, Gyeongsangbuk-do, Korea, with a mortality rate of up to 30%. The water temperature was 13–14 °C. Diseased starry flounders exhibited exophthalmia, hemorrhage of the eyes, jaw, liver, gills covered with mucus, and spleen enlargement. The pathogens were isolated from lesions and identified as Aeromonas salmonicida subsp. masoucida.
Aeromonas salmonicida is the causative agent of furunculosis, a devastating disease characterized by skin ulceration and bleeding. The five subspecies of
Aeromonas salmonicida subsp.
masoucida can be divided into typical strains, including
A. salmonicida subsp.
Salmonicida, which primarily causes disease in salmonids; and atypical strains, including
A. salmonicida subsp.
achromogenes,
masoucida,
pectinolytica, and
smithia, which are mainly isolated from non-salmonid fish [
9]. All subspecies, except for
pectinolytica, have been associated with fish diseases. Epizootic outbreaks of
A. salmonicida in turbot (
Scophthalmus maximus) [
10,
11], halibut (
Hippoglosus hippoglosus) [
12], cod (
Gadus morhua) [
13], crucian carp (
Carassius auratus) [
14], Atlantic salmon (
Salmo salar) [
15], spotted wolffish (
Anarhichas minor) [
16], brook trout (
Salvelinusn fontinalis) [
17], sea bream (
Sparus aurata) [
18], black rockfish (
Sebastes schlegeli) [
19], and red swamp crayfish (
Procambarus clarkii) [
20] have been reported. Recently, the efficacy of vaccines against
A. salmonicida subsp.
achromogenes,
Vibrio anguillarum [
21], and
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida in turbot [
22] has been investigated. However, information regarding the molecular identification and pathology of
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida infections in starry flounders are scarce.
Although several pathogens are known to target starry flounder in the aquatic environment, novel pathogens may emerge due to natural disasters such as climate change. Therefore, epidemiological investigations are needed to identify potential pathogens so that appropriate management and treatment strategies can be employed in a timely manner.
In this study, we isolated, characterized, and investigated the pathogenicity of A. salmonicida subsp. masoucida infections in starry flounders. We performed phylogenetic tree analysis and an antimicrobial susceptibility test and analyzed the genomic and histopathological features of A. salmonicida subsp. masoucida in fish. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report investigating A. salmonicida subsp. masoucida in starry flounder, and our findings provide a scientific reference for the diagnosis and prevention of the emergence of new pathogenic strains in the Korean aquaculture industry.
4. Discussion
Domestic consumption of starry flounders has increased by 3.5-fold over the past 10 years due to its wide salinity tolerance and high marketability [
2,
45]. As the burden of management costs for olive flounders (
Paralichthys olivaceus) has rapidly increased, starry flounders have been increasingly produced as an alternative breed due to their higher mortality rates [
46]. However, the abnormal mortality rate of starry flounders, which are otherwise known for their high disease tolerance, has been reported since 2022, raising concerns among aquaculture farmers. This is believed to be caused by recessive inbreeding and climate change. Loss of genetic diversity and reduced immunity resulting from recessive inbreeding increase vulnerability to pathogens [
47]. Climate change has promoted the emergence of new strains of pathogens [
48]. For example,
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida, known to cause infections in other fish species, such as turbot [
22,
49], black rockfish [
19], and red swamp crayfish [
20], has recently been recognized as causing increased mortality rates in starry flounders for the first time.
Analysis of
16s rRNA and various housekeeping genes, including
gyrB,
rpoB,
cpn60, and
dnaJ, has been used to characterize
Aeromonas species [
50,
51]. Although the
16s rRNA gene is universally considered an efficient tool for identifying bacterial species, its use is controversial because of reading errors when it shows highly conserved regions within the genus
Aeromonas [
52].
A. trota and
A. caviae differ by up to three nucleotides in the
16s rRNA sequence [
53], whereas
A. sobria and
A. veronii differ by 12 nucleotides [
53]. To overcome the limitations of the high similarity of
16s rRNA,
gyrB (which encodes subunit B of DNA gyrase) and
dnaJ (which encodes heat shock protein 40), were used to differentiate the three strain groups. In this study, the strains ASM1, 2, and 3 were all identified
A. salmonicida based on the
16s RNA,
gyrB, and
dnaJ genes. A previous report examining the inter- and intraspecific relationships of 53
Aeromonas genera based on
gyrB sequences demonstrated a 2.2% nucleotide substitution rate in
A. salmonicida gyrB [
54]. Additionally, the mean gene divergences of
gyrB and
dnaJ in 32
Aeromonas strains were 5.2% and 6.8%, respectively, whereas those of
16s rRNA was 1.4% [
51]. Therefore,
gyrB and
dnaJ proved to be better identification genes than
16s rRNA for the characterization of the genus
Aeromonas after isolation from diseased starry flounders.
VapA, which encodes the A-layer surface protein array, serves as both an epizootiological marker and a molecular subtyping marker for
A. salmonicdia subspecies, with
vapA types ranging from 1 to 23 [
55]. The pathogenic strain isolated from turbot with skin ulcers was identified as
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida based on the
vapA gene sequence [
56]. In contrast, a pathogenic
A. salmonicida strain isolated from snakehead was reported to lack
vapA, as confirmed by
vapA gene cloning [
57]. Based on the results of the phylogenetic analysis, ASM 1, 2, and 3 were identified as
A. salmonicdia subsp.
masoucida, based on
vapA gene expression and their clustering with
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida ATCC 27013T. This finding aligns with previous studies that assigned the ATCC 27013 type strain as A-layer type 7 [
55]. Most A-layer types can be linked to a specific host with only one or a few
vapA clusters [
55]. While most A-layers in types 1 to 7 originate from the Norwegian coast, type 7 is found in the Pacific Ocean and Asia, suggesting regional specificity [
58]. It is necessary to obtain more
A. salmonicdia subsp.
masoucida strains to perform clustering analysis with various host fish species and to identify the geographic distribution of these hosts.
With the growing issue of antibiotic resistance in aquaculture, multi-drug resistance in
Aeromonas poses a serious public health problem [
29]. The only way to reduce antimicrobial resistance is through the use of commercial vaccines; however, to date, no vaccine exists for
A. salmonicdia subsp.
masoucida in starry flounder farming in the Republic of Korea, except for
S. parauberis vaccines, such as PRO-VAC
TM S PARA. In our study, we found that all strains were categorized as NWT for enrofloxacin, florfenicol, flumequine, oxolinic acid, and oxytetracycline resistance, indicating multi-drug resistance. Although no ECV criteria have been published for ampicillin and amoxicillin, the high MIC values of 16< and 128< are consistent with the characteristic of the
Aeromonas genus, which is innately resistant to β-lactams [
59]. Specifically, the ASM3 strain harbored antimicrobial resistance genes, including
ampC,
blaOXA, and
blaOXA, which are related to resistance to the β-lactam class. Furthermore, the presence of the
catB3,
catA2, and
floR genes in the ASM3 strain contributes to high MIC values of florfenicol at 64 μg mL
−1.
FloR has been identified either on the chromosomes or plasmids of Gram-negative bacteria and is associated with mobile genetic elements and genomic islands [
60]. Notably,
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida may be considered an agent of antimicrobial resistance dissemination from aquaculture to the natural environment.
Histopathological analysis revealed that the diseased starry flounder exhibited inflammatory cell infiltration of the gills with epithelial hyperplasia and fusion of secondary lamellae. Gills covered with mucus may occur because the gills serve as the first physical defense against bacterial invasion [
61]. This indicates that mucus viscoelasticity determines its ability to block many types of motile bacteria [
62]. Additionally, we observed bacterial colonies in the gills and heart, indicating that the bacteria circulated in the blood–vascular system. This was consistent with the immunohistochemistry results for
A. salmonicida subsp.
salmonicida in challenged turbots, which showed a strong positive reaction in the lumen of the blood vessels of the secondary lamellae and heart [
63]. Our results align with the infection route, indicating that the gills, intestine, and skin, as mucosal immune-related tissues, are the main infection sites of
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida with changes in the bacterial amount [
64]. Therefore, it is assumed that the bacteria enter the bloodstream after colonization and are then transmitted to internal tissues, resulting in septicemia with mass mortality. Inflammatory cell infiltration of the mucosal layer indicates that intestinal epithelial cells target pathogens by producing inflammatory cytokines [
65]. TNF-α, IL-1β, and IL-8 mRNA expression were significantly increased in the intestine after infection with
A. hydrophila from grass carp [
66]. Skin nodules are the atypical representative symptoms of
A. salmonicida [
67], and we found that the main clinical signs were hemorrhages around the jaw and mouth. Although a few previous studies have presented findings that were directly comparable with our results, granulomatous dermatitis was prominent in turbot challenged with
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida, indicating that it may facilitate infection by pathogens [
22,
49]. Therefore,
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida may present different clinical signs according to the host species specificity. The importance of
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida as a fish pathogen has been previously confirmed.
CARD analysis demonstrated that genes responsible for resistance to peptide antibiotics constituted to the highest proportion of antibiotic resistance genes, but it was difficult to compare the MIC results owing to the lack of MIC data for peptide antibiotics. In addition, peptide antibiotics, including colistin and bacitracin, have only been approved for use in cattle, pigs, and chickens and not for fish in the Republic of Korea. The possession of resistance genes for unapproved antibiotics indicates the emergence of resistant bacteria in aquaculture and potential horizontal transmission between livestock and humans. Similarly, the transposon of a 67-kb plasmid of
A. salmonicida subsp.
salmonicida carried the
catB3 gene, which aligns with the findings of our study and suggests the possibility of transfer through conjugation to
A. hydrophila [
68]. The
Aeromonas genus includes 4 major and 14 minor categories of virulence factors, as identified in the VFDB database. Analysis of whole genome sequencing data revealed 1156 virulence factors coding for nutritional/metabolic factors, effector delivery systems, and exotoxins. We found that the
T3SS and
T6SS genes, which encode the secretion system, contribute to the virulence.
A. hydrophila possesses a
T3SS that delivers four effector proteins to target host cells, whereas
T6SS-associated virulence factors play a role in the secretory apparatus, promoting bacterial virulence [
69]. The genomes of 105
Aeromonas strains isolated from environmental or pathogenic sources were used to identify the distribution and cytotoxicity of 21
T3SS effector families [
70]. The deletion of two genes (
hcp1 and
vgrG1) encoding type VI secretion system proteins of the
T6SS in virulent
A. hydrophila resulted in a 2.24-fold reduction in virulence when tested in catfish fingerlings [
71].
Aerolysin, a hemolytic toxin, was detected in our study, as well as in
A. hydrophila [
72] and
A. veronii [
73]. Additionally, the isolates harbored the
rtxA gene, an exotoxin-encoding lysine acyltransferase.
rtxA is restricted to the phylogroups Hydrophila and Salmonicidia, including
A. salmonicida subsp.
pectinolytica, among 65
Aeromonas strains [
74]. Therefore, our findings suggest that genomic detection of these virulence genes may help identify targets for developing new vaccines against this emerging pathogen. Phages are viruses that infect bacterial cells, disrupt bacterial metabolism, and cause bacterial lysis [
75]. In the present study, ASM3 exhibited two intact prophage regions. Most phages of
A. salmonicida were classified as those belonging to the
Myoviridae family and are more prevalent than other phages [
76]. In particular, modification of the receptor, including lipid A of the lipopolysaccharide and the A layer of the outer membrane protein, has been reported as the main mechanism of resistance to phages of
A. salmonicida [
77]. Bacterial mobile elements, such as plasmids, prophages, transposons, and insertion sequences, can be transmitted vertically with cell division or horizontal transfer. Mobile elements are known to potentiate gene gain and loss, contributing to genetic adaptation to new environments and the emergence of a bacterial population [
78]. The prophage region present in ASM3 strains is supposed to contribute to its adaptation to a new host, like starry flounders. Further studies are needed to evaluate the potential of
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida in the treatment and prevention of phage
A. salmonicida subsp.
masoucida.
In summary, A. salmonicida subsp. masoucida, a newly discovered pathogenic Aeromonas species, is currently pathogenic to starry flounders. Future research should aim to expand testing to investigate the A. salmonicida subsp. masoucida virulence characteristics through challenge experiments to determine its full host susceptibility. Studies examining the control of pathogenic factors unique to A. salmonicida subsp. masoucida should also be performed to understand the main causes of infection in starry flounders. Multifaceted research will enable a better understanding of host susceptibility, assessment of host risks, and the development of vaccines to prevent diseases.