Intercity Online Car-Hailing Travel Demand Prediction via a Spatiotemporal Transformer Method
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Good paper but assumes previous method knowledge of the reader. Could use more explanations.
The term "car-hailing" may be understood as hailing private cars. Consider using taxi-hailing or public car-hailing.
r78 define vanilla RNN
r94 LSTnet. All other references are LSTNet
r104 two issues vs r121 second challenge. Use same term.
r181 explain passenger flow in a grid. Passage presence at time t.
r188 AN STTnet. An?
r224 explain Query, Key and Value matrices
r225 use t and T?
(10) introduce dk
r319 introduce STT for ST-transformer
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File: Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
A very good article. I propose to add something about how renting an online vehicle and designing traffic for it together with the customer reduces congestion on the roads. I believe the rental system is designed to reduce the number of vehicles on the road. The key question is whether the planned road for the rented vehicles will not coincide with other rented vehicles. Every vehicle on the road is a chance for congestion. City managers are trying to discourage the use of their own vehicles in favor of rented ones. Thus, it is necessary to analyze whether the chance of congestion increases, or whether a large number of hired vehicles reduces the chance of congestion on the roads.
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File: Author Response.docx