1. Introduction
The concrete industry is one of the largest contributors of carbon dioxide [
1]. The use of cement in concrete has raised concerns about its sustainability due to the fact that the production of one ton of OPC releases approximately one ton of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere [
1]. In the past few decades, scientists and engineers have been able to partially replace the cement with supplementary cementitious materials, to reduce the extensive emission of CO
2 associated with the production of Portland cement and create more sustainable concrete. These materials are byproducts of other industries, such as fly ash, ground granulated blast furnace slag, silica fume, and other natural pozzolans. Not only have these supplementary cementitious materials have contributed in reducing the emission of CO
2, but they also provided the concrete with high-performance abilities in terms of strength and durability. The applications of nano-technology have been gaining popularity in different fields of science and technology, especially in concrete industries [
2]. The development of new materials with new functions or improvements in the properties of existing materials using nano-technology are new areas of interest in civil engineering. Nanoparticles (NPs) exhibit unique chemical and physical properties at the nano-scale. SiO
2, TiO
2, Al
2O
3, Fe
2O
3, ZnO
2, and carbon nanotubes are considered the most commonly used NPs in concrete production. The role of the NPs can be summarized as follows: (1) NPs not only act as fillers to improve the microstructure, but also as an activator to promote pozzolanic reactions; (2) NPs act as a nucleation site for C-S-H seeds, which then accelerate the cement hydration; (3) NPs (nano-silica [NS]) accelerate the consumption of C3S and the formation of portlandite (small-sized CH) crystals and homogeneous clusters of CSH composition; and (4) NPs improve the microstructure of the interfacial transition zone between aggregates and cement pastes [
3].
S. Abd.El.Aleem et al. [
3] carried out an experiment studying the hydration characteristic, thermal expansion, and microstructure of cement containing nano-silica. Seven different mixtures were used in this experiment that incorporated nano-silica at different dosages up to 6% partial replacement of OPC. The presence of nano-silica had remarkably increased the water demand, which, in consequence, retarded the setting time. This seemed to be controlled by the particle size distribution and the high specific surface area of NS in the presence of polycarboxylate superplasticizer [
3]. Furthermore, the values of pH and free portlandite decreased as the dosage of nano-silica increased. Due to the pozzolanic reaction of nano-silica, the chemically combined water contents increased with increasing nano-silica percentage dosage. The microstructure, and consequently the mechanical properties, of the investigated cement mortars are improved sharply with NS up to 3.0% and then slightly up to 5% [
3]. Additionally, using nano-silica as a partial replacement of Portland cement lowered the coefficient of thermal expansion of the hardened cement paste. Moreover, due to the continuous hydration of cement phases and the pozzolanic reaction of nano-silica, the thermal expansion of hydrated cement pastes incorporating 3% nano-silica dosage increased with curing time. The nano-sized SiO
2 up to 5% proved to be an effective mineral addition for blending with OPC to improve its chemical, physico-mechanical, and thermal properties [
3]. Finally, incorporating nano-silica increased the compressive strength because of the nano-filler effect, which improved the microstructure and promoted the highly pozzolanic reaction.
Hongjian Du et al. [
4] studied the durability properties of OPC concrete that contains nano-silica at dosages of 0.3% and 0.9%. Three different mix designs were prepared to be tested in this experiment, which are OPC concrete, 0.3 nano-silica concrete, and 0.9 nano-silica concrete. The compressive strength of each mix design was determined at 7, 28, and 91 days by preparing three (100 × 200 mm) cylinders for each day, while the water penetration depth was obtained by testing two (100 × 200 mm) cylinders at a water pressure of 0.75 MPa for seven days. On the other hand, water sorptivity was determined by using (100 × 500 mm) cylindrical slices. Along with the other tests used in this experiment, the researchers were able to come up with multiple conclusions. First, nano-silica showed a clear pozzolanic reaction with the Portland cement. This reaction, along with the nanofiller effect of nano-silica, made the microstructure of the concrete more homogeneous and less porous. Consequently, the permeability was reduced, which increased the compressive strength and the resistance of the concrete against water penetration and chemical attacks such as chloride ions.
Jing Yu et al. [
5] investigated the use of nano-silica to improve mechanical and fractural properties of a fiber-reinforced high-volume fly as cement mortar. The materials used in this study were nano-silica, OPC type I 42.5 N, fly ash class F, PVA fibers, and river sand. Four series (16 mixes) of experiments were carried out to evaluate the effect of nano-silica (NS) on the fractural and mechanical properties of polyvinyl alcohol fiber-reinforced high-volume fly ash mortars (PVA/HVFAM), with the fly ash/binder ratio fixed at 50 wt%, NS/binder ratios of 0–1.5 wt%, and PVA fiber dosages of 0–1.0 vol% [
5]. After conducting the tests, multiple conclusions were drawn. First, the incorporation of 0.5–1.5 wt% nano-silica improved the compressive strength, tensile strength, elastic modulus, fracture energy, fracture toughness, brittleness index, and critical tip opening displacement compared to plain high-volume fly ash mortars (HVFAM). Second, compared to plain HVFAM, the incorporation of 0.2–1.0 vol% PVA fibers had no pronounced effect on the elastic modulus and compressive strength. However, it improved the tensile strength, fracture energy, fracture toughness, brittleness index, and critical tip opening displacement. Third, the synergetic effect of NS and PVA was observed, in terms of the post-peak behavior under static bending as well as the fracture parameters [
5]. Finally, the microstructure analysis, which was performed using the scanning electron microscopy, showed that additional C-S-H was formed and covered the surface of the PVA fibers due to the accelerated hydration process that occurred due to the high reactivity of NS. This improved the bond between the PVA fibers and the cement-based matrix and resulted in an efficient load-transfer by fiber bridging [
5].
D. Adak et al. [
6] conducted a study about the effect of nano-silica on the strength and durability of fly ash-based geopolymer mortar. Fly ash-based geopolymer mortar has a shortcoming, which is the need for heat activator to develop early strength. To overcome this, the researchers developed an experiment of using low calcium fly ash geopolymer with different molar concentrations of activator liquid and different nano-silica percentage dosages. The addition of 6% of nano-silica to the fly ash-based geopolymer mortar showed an obvious increase in compressive, flexural, and tensile strength at 28 days under ambient temperature curing. Furthermore, the same percentage of nano-silica reduced water absorption. The modification that took place in the geopolymer with 6% of nano-silica is due to the transformation of the amorphous compound to the crystalline compound.
A.M. Said et al. [
7] investigated the properties of concrete incorporating nano-silica. Two types of concrete were investigated in this experiment, which are concrete with ordinary cement and concrete with ordinary cement plus class F fly ash. To link macro and micro-scale trends and study the effect of using nano-silica, the research included tests of adiabatic temperature, rapid chloride ion permeability, mercury intrusion porosimetry, thermogravimetry, and backscattered scanning electron microscopy. Based on the test results, multiple conclusions were reached. Both types of concrete used in this experiment showed a remarkable improvement in performance due to the addition of nano-silica. The nano-silica was responsible for accelerating the kinetics of hydration reactions. The addition of nano-silica showed a modification to the inherently slower rate of gaining strength of concrete that contains class F fly ash. The physical penetration depth was decreased, which consequently decreased the conductivity. The specimens showed a significant reduction in porosity and threshold pore diameter.
Morteza Bastami et al. [
8] studied the performance of nano-silica modified high strength concrete at elevated temperatures. The main focus of this experiment was on the effect of elevated temperature on the compressive strength, tensile strength, spalling, and mass loss of high strength concrete modified with nano-silica. Six samples with different percentage dosages of nano-silica were considered in this experiment along with two samples without nano-silica. The performance of the nano-silica modified high strength concrete was measured by using (150 × 100 mm) cylinders that were heated to 400, 600, and 800 °C at a rate of 20 °C/min. In general, the results of this experiment demonstrated that the mass loss is decreased as the dosage of nano-silica is increased, and that is due to the improvement in tensile strength, which helped in preventing spalling. Moreover, the nano-silica also increased the residual compressive strength of the heated specimens.
Kiachehr Behfarnia et al. [
9] investigated the effect of nano-silica and nano-alumina on frost resistance and the mechanical properties of normal concrete. Seven different mixtures were used in this experiment. NSC3, NSC5, and NSC7 denoted the concrete containing 3 wt%, 5 wt%, and 7 wt% nano-silica, by the weight of cement, respectively [
9]. NAC1, NAC2, and NAC3 denoted the concrete containing 1 wt%, 2 wt%, and 3 wt% nano-alumina, by the weight of cement, respectively [
9]. The specimens were subjected to numerous tests. The compressive strength was determined at seven, 28, and 120 days. The percentage of water absorption was obtained after 28 days of moisture-curing. Furthermore, the seven mixtures were subjected to cycles of freezing and thawing. The loss of mass, change in length, increase in water absorption, and reduction in compressive strength of specimens was measured after a specified number of freeze and thaw cycles [
9]. The experiment results demonstrated that the addition of nanoparticles increased the compressive strength whether they were nano-silica or nano-alumina. However, the nano-silica addition showed a remarkable increase in the compressive strength compared to the addition of nano-alumina. For example, at 28 days, the NSC5 mixture showed an increase of 31.13% in the compressive strength, while the NAC3 mixture showed an increase of 8.00% in the compressive strength. Moreover, the mixtures that incorporated nanoparticles showed a remarkable decrease in the water absorption compared to the control specimen due to the nano-filler effect, which improved the pore structure of the concrete. The experimental results also showed that the addition of nanoparticles improved the frost resistance considerably. However, the frost resistance of concrete that incorporates nano-alumina was better than the concrete that incorporates the same amount of nano-silica.
Chenglong Zhuang and Yu Chen [
10] studied the effect of nano-silica on the properties of concrete. The partial replacement of Portland cement with nano-silica accelerated the hydration process and reduced the setting time due to the high pozzolanic activity of nano-silica. Nano-silica has a large specific surface due to its small particle size. In the process of concrete mixing, a large number of unsaturated bonds promoted the nano-SiO
2 to absorb more water molecules, which led to a decrease of a concrete slump [
10]. Chemically, due to the pozzolanic activity of nano-silica, more C-S-H was produced in the concrete mixing process, which reduced the number of pores. Physically, due to the nano-filler effect of nano-silica, the microstructure of nano-silica-based concrete was more compact and less porous. In the early stage, the early strength improvement effect of nano-silica concrete was more obvious due to the more sufficient pozzolanic reaction [
10]. As the curing time increased, the particle size decreased, which weakened the pozzolan response of nano-silica. Therefore, the improvement effect of nano-silica on concrete strength in the later period was reduced [
10].
M. Berra et al. [
11] conducted a study about the effects of nano-silica addition on the workability of Portland cement pastes. The nano-silica slurry used in this experiment consisted of 10.2 PH, 30 silica content (wt%), 0.56 titrable alkalis (wt% as Na2O), 1.22 Density (g/cm
3), 5.5 viscosity (mPa s), 10 mean particle size (nm), and 345 specific surface area (m
2/g). The workability of fourteen mixtures with different water/binder ratio and nano-silica concentrations in the liquid phase were evaluated using mini-slump tests. The addition of nano-silica to cementitious mixes produced a remarkable reduction of the mix workability, due to instantaneous interactions between the nano-silica sol and the liquid phase of the cementitious mixes (mainly dissolved alkalis), with the formation of gels characterized by high water retention capacities [
11]. The delayed addition of mixing water aliquots proved to be an effective way of reducing the adverse effect of nano-silica on mix workability, without changing the water/binder ratio and/or adding superplasticizer [
11]. However, the delayed water addition did not improve the workability of the Portland cement mixes. Moreover, due to the reduction of the nano-silica reactivity caused by the instantaneous interaction between superplasticizer and nano-silica, the immediate superplasticizer addition was considered to be useless in improving the workability of the mixtures. On the contrary, delayed addition of the superplasticizer, coupled with the use of an appropriate mixer for the break-down of the gels formed from nano-silica sol destabilization, proved to be the best procedure to uniformly disperse the mix ingredients, without significantly penalizing the nano-silica reactivity [
11].
L.P. Singh et al. [
12] investigated the beneficial role of nano-silica in cement-based materials. The nano-silica in the concrete acted as a nucleation site to accelerate the hydration of cement and also filled the pores to give higher packing density, which led to higher strength with lesser porosity [
12]. The development of nano-silica based high-performance concrete will help in decreasing the consumption of cement for specific grades, which will help in protecting the environment to a great extent. Furthermore, due to the high compressive strength, the nano-silica based high-performance concrete will produce smaller structural members, which will reduce the total amount of materials placed and consequently reduce the overall cost of the structure. Moreover, the high early strength development of nano-silica based high-performance concrete will accelerate the construction process, which will save time, money, and materials. Finally, the long service life of the nano-silica based high-performance concrete will reduce the maintenance costs to a great extent.
Sattawat Haruehansapong et al. [
13] studied the effect of the particle size of nano-silica on the compressive strength and the optimum replacement content of cement mortar containing nano-silica. Three different particle sizes of nano-silica (12, 20, and 40 nm) were used in this experiment. Two groups of mixtures were tested, in which the first group incorporated different dosages of silica-fume, and it consisted of four mixtures, and the second group incorporated different dosages of nano-silica, and it consisted of four mixtures. Compared to the silica-fume mixtures, the compressive strength of the nano-silica mixtures was greater due to the pozzolanic activity and the packing ability. The mixture that incorporated 40 nm nano-silica showed the highest compressive strength compared to the mixtures with 12 and 20 nm nano-silica. One possible reason is poor dispersion and agglomeration of small particles of 12 and 20 nm-SiO
2 [
13]. The optimum replacement content of cement mortars with NS particle size of 12, 20, and 40 nm, as well as cement mortar with SF, was obtained with NS 9% by weight of cement, independent of NS particle size [
13]. SEM photographs showed that the microstructure of the cement pastes was improved by the incorporation of nano-silica making the paste more compact, homogeneous, and denser.
Bibhuti Bhusan Mukharjee et al. [
14] investigated the influence of nano-silica on the properties of recycled aggregate concrete. The properties of colloidal nano-silica used in this study are 1.12 specific gravity, 39% solid content, 8–20 nm particle size, 99.1% SiO
2 content, and 10.11 pH value. Eight different mixtures were cast, in which four of them contained natural coarse aggregate (NCA) and the other four contained recycled coarse aggregate (RCA). Multiple conclusions were obtained. As the percentage of nano-silica increased, the slump values decreased due to the high surface area of colloidal nano-silica, which causes absorption of mixing water by the nanoparticles. Furthermore, replacement of natural coarse aggregates with recycled coarse aggregates reduced the workability of the concrete mixture due to the high water absorption capacity of RCA, and a further decrease in workability was observed due to the addition of NS to RAC mixes [
14]. Moreover, the addition of nano-silica enhanced the compressive strength results in early days because of the nano-silica’s high pozzolanic activity at initial periods. A decrease of 14% of compressive strength was observed when replacement of NCA was done with 100% RCA [
14]. However, the addition of NS enhanced the compressive strength of RAC, and with the incorporation of 3% NS, the 28 days compressive strength equalized with control concrete [
14]. Compared to the natural coarse aggregate mixes, the recycled coarse aggregate mixes had weaker tensile strength. However, the decrease in tensile strength caused by using recycled coarse aggregate can be compensated by incorporating nano-silica.
Ehsan Ghafari et al. [
15] studied the influence of a nano-silica addition on the durability of ultra-high performance concrete (UHPC). The properties of nano-silica (NS) used in this experiment are (160 ± 20 m
2/g) specific surface area, (<99.9%) purity, amorphous crystal phase, (15 ± 5 nm) diameter, (<0.15 g/cm
3) density, and spherical morphology. Three different sets of mixtures were considered for this test, consisting of UHPC containing NS, UHPC without NS, and high-performance concrete (HPC) [
15]. Based on the obtained results, multiple conclusions were drawn. First, UHPC-NS presented the best corrosion resistance performance, as the time to crack effectively increased with the NS addition [
15]. Second, incorporating nano-silica contributed to extending the service life of concrete structures by delaying corrosion in steel rebars. Corrosion rate measurements, based on LPR and Tafel techniques, pointed out that the UHPC specimens containing NS addition had the lowest corrosion rate when compared with HPC and UHPC specimens [
15].
G. Quercia et al. [
16] conducted a study about the self-consolidating concrete (SCC) modification by the use of amorphous nano-silica. Three different SCC mixes were studied in the experiment, in which the first mix did not contain nano-silica, the second mix contained colloidal nano-silica, and the third mix contained powder nano-silica. Under the laboratory conditions, the compressive and tensile splitting strength of the reference SCC was improved by the addition of both types of nano-silica [
16]. The colloidal nano-silica SCC mix had higher compressive strength and lower splitting tensile strength compared to the powder nano-silica SCC mix. All durability indicators of the SCC studied (conductivity, chloride migration and diffusion coefficients, and freeze–thaw resistance) were significantly improved with the addition of 3.8% of both types of the nano-silica [
16]. Compared to the powder nano-silica SCC mix, the colloidal nano-silica SCC mix showed slightly better performance in terms of durability properties.
Ramesh. N and Eramma. H [
17] studied the behavior of ground granulated blast-furnace slag (GGBS) and nano-silica on the strength properties of concrete. The properties of nano-silica used in this experiment are 23.6 pH (1.08–1.11). It used specific gravity and a 219 nm particle size. Eight different mixes were tested, in which mixes 1, 2, 3, and 4 contained zero nano-silica and 0%, 10%, 20%, and 30% GGBS, respectively, and mixes 5, 6, 7, and 8 contained 1%, 2%, 3%, 2% nano-silica and 0%, 0%, 0%, and 30% GGBS, respectively. Based on the test results, multiple conclusions were obtained. First, mix #8 (30% GGBS and 2% nano-silica) achieved the highest seven-day and 28-day compressive and split tensile strength results. Similarly, mix 8 had the highest flexural strength compared to the other mixes. Second, the SEM test shows that the microstructure of nano SiO
2 concrete was more uniform and compact than the normal concrete [
17]. Third, the silica nanoparticles addition improved the pore structure of concrete.
D. V. Prasada Rao and U. Anil Kumar [
18] conducted an experimental investigation on the strength properties of concrete containing micro-silica and nano-silica. The properties of nano-silica used in this experiment are 39.5–41% nano solids, 9–10 pH, 1.29–1.31 specific gravity, and milky white liquid texture. Seven different mixtures were tested in which the mixes contain 0, 19, 38, 19, 38, 19, and 38 kg micro-silica and 0, 0, 0, 14.25, 14.25, 28.5, and 28.5 L colloidal nano-silica, respectively. The addition of 1.5% nano-silica to the 5% and 10% micro-silica mixes had better mechanical properties compared to the addition of 3% nano-silica to the 5% and 10% micro-silica mixes. Overall, in terms of its strength performance, the addition of 1.5% nano-silica and 10% micro-silica achieved the highest results compared to the other mixes.
Maitri Mapa et al. [
19] investigated the mechanical properties of silica and GGBS incorporated cement mortar. The properties of nano-silica used in this experiment are 2.4 specific gravity, 2200 kg/m
3 bulk density, 640 m
2/g fineness, and white color. Eleven different mixes were tested consisting of different dosages of GGBS, densified silica fume, and nano-silica. Numerous conclusions were obtained from this experiment. First, the initial and final setting times were directly proportional to the GGBS content. The increase in initial setting time of GGBS incorporated cement paste was higher than the increase of final setting time for cement paste [
19]. Therefore, the incorporation of GGBS retarded the initial hydration of cement. Second, the compressive strength of silica added mortar mixes showed good improvement in the early age’s compressive strength as compared with the GGBS cement mix [
19].
Hongru Zhang et al. [
20] studied the modification effects of a nano-silica slurry on microstructure strength and strain development of recycled aggregate concrete applied in an enlarged structural test. Three concrete groups were prepared in this study, i.e., the commercial natural aggregate concrete (CNAC), the original recycled aggregate concrete (ORAC), and the modified recycled aggregate concrete (MRAC) [
20]. For both ORAC and MRAC, the percentage replacement of recycled aggregate was 50%. The strengthening slurry prepared for this experiment contains 100 kg cement, 50 kg water, 1 kg superplasticizer, and 1 kg nano-silica dispersant. Multiple conclusions were obtained during this experiment. First, mechanical properties of ORAC and MRAC, i.e., the compressive strength and the splitting strength, were inferior to those of CNAC, given the mixture proportions employed in this study, i.e., the dosage of water, cement, and aggregates were kept the same among the three concrete groups [
20]. Second, at an early age (before 28 days), the resistance of CNAC to shrinkage caused by deformation in the target beam was found to be inferior to ORAC and MRAC. However, after 90 days, CNAC showed long-term superiority to ORAC and MRAC in its deformability against loads, given the loads applied to the target beams similar [
20]. Third, the employed nano-slurry had verified a beneficial role in the deformability against shrinkage and loads of MRAC, which were applied in RC beams in a real project.
Jing Xu et al. [
21] studied the modification effects of nano-silica on the interfacial zone in concrete. At macro-scale level, compressive and flexural strength tests showed that the addition of nano-silica is beneficial for the improvement of the interfacial transition zone (ITZ) performance in particular [
21]. On the other hand, at the micro-scale level, the addition of nano-silica accelerated the hydration process, which played a major role in improving the interfacial transition zone (ITZ) at an early age.
A. Ghazy et al. [
22] studied the nano-modified fly ash concrete as a repair option for concrete pavements. Numerous outcomes were obtained from this research. The incorporation of 6% nano-silica in concrete with up to 30% fly ash significantly shortened the dormant period and accelerated the rate of hydration reactions, which discounted some of the retarding effect of class F fly ash on the rate of hardening concrete [
22]. Furthermore, the addition of nano-silica improved the early-age and the long-term compressive and tensile strength. Moreover, it refined the pore structure of the fly ash concrete. Hence, the nano-modified fly ash concrete presented a viable option for a suite of repair applications in concrete pavements [
22].
Youkun Cheng and Zhenwu Shi [
23] conducted an experimental study on nano-silica improving concrete durability of bridge deck pavements in cold regions. The materials used in the study were OPC grade 42.5, fine aggregate, coarse aggregate, water reducer agent, defoaming agent, and nano-silica. The technical parameters of the used nano-silica are 15 nm average grain diameter, 99.5% purity, globospherite crystal form, 300 m
2/g specific surface area, 0.05 g/cm3 apparent density, and white color. It was found out that the addition of nano-SiO
2 in bridge deck pavement concrete improved the durability of the concrete effectively, prolonged the service life of the bridge deck pavement, reduced the early onset of damage to bridge deck pavement, and reduced repair and maintenance costs; consequently, using it has significant social and economic value [
23]. Furthermore, the incorporation of nano-silica greatly improved frost resistance, resistance to CI
− ion permeability, and abrasion resistance of concrete. Nano-silica incorporated into concrete effectively absorbed Ca(OH)
2, which is released in the early stage of hydration of cement and increased the content of hydrated calcium silicate, which improved the interface between the hardened cement paste and aggregate [
23].
Comparison between Nano-Silica and Micro-Silica
Both of them are not crystalline materials (amorphous); therefore, they will not dissolve in concrete. Nano-silica is more reactive than micro-silica, because it contains more silicon dioxide content. Nano-silica has a smaller particle size than micro-silica. Consequently, it has a larger surface area. Therefore, nano-silica has a larger impact on the reactivity, strength development, and the refinement of the pore structure of the concrete. The weight per unit volume (bulk density) of nano-silica is lighter than both as produced and densified micro-silica due to its lighter mass. Both of them have a specific gravity of 2.2, which is lighter than Portland cement. Thus, adding nano-silica or micro-silica will not increase the density of the concrete. Nano-silica has a larger specific surface than micro-silica due to its smaller particle size. However, due to its smaller particle size, it has a higher water demand. Thus, it is necessary to use a water-reducing admixture or a superplasticizer in the mixture.
The purpose of this study is to develop nano-silica sustainable concrete mixtures and evaluate the fresh and mechanical properties of the developed nano-silica concrete mixtures. Furthermore, the purpose is to study the morphological characteristics of nano-silica concrete.