Improved PBFT Algorithm Based on Comprehensive Evaluation Model
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Author proposed a TB-PBFT algorithm based on a comprehensive evaluation 506 model for consortium blockchain.
Author Response
请看附件
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
The author proposed a TB-PBFT algorithm based on a comprehensive evaluation model for consortium blockchain in this paper. The introduction, literature review, and Preliminaries are done quite extensively.
The analysis section is well presented.
- More references should be added in the Preliminaries
- in 178, it is not clear, why the standardized treatment formulas are obtained as (2) and (3)
- in 185, it is also not clear why the entropy e_j is obtained by the formula
Similar to a few formulas in section 2. Some references could be added for more details.
- More references should be added in section 3.
- In the Primary Node Selection section, each step is quite confusing. Please give more tails or some diagrams would be helpful.
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
I only have few suggestions for authors:
1. Although the mathematical concepts are correctly solved and written, some commas are missing at the end of equations;
2. There are few typos that are found, please review the whole article. Explain more about the single-soliton solution, double-soliton solutions, N-soliton solutions, singular traveling solutions ;
3. The physics behind the conclusions is explained thoroughly but the key results should be added to the abstract;
4. References are adequate but need careful review for punctuation;
5. If you used MATLAB or Mathematica, you should mention that;
6. Applications of the considered problem must be included in the abstract section;
7. Authors should remove the typo mistakes from the whole document and also improve the language quality in the revised manuscript;
8. Add the main findings and objective of the current study in the abstract;
9. Properly number each section in the revised version. Provide reference for fractal combined KdV-mKdV equation. Also add the future recommendation;
10. The following latest studies are very relevant. The authors must read and provide complete information on this topic through including these studies (Computational and Applied Mathematics, 41(4), 1-14, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, 162, 112388, Optical and Quantum Electronics, 54(9), 1-12, The European Physical Journal Plus, 137(9), 1-9)
Author Response
Please see the attachment
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 3 Report
My recommendation is accepting this version for publication
