2. Design of the PS-DC-PCF PBS and Theory
The cross-section of the designed PS-DC-PCF PBS is illustrated in
Figure 1. From
Figure 1, it can be observed that the proposed PS-DC-PCF PBS features a pentagonal overall air hole structure, with different arrangement patterns in the upper and lower sections. The upper half exhibits a quadrilateral arrangement of air holes, while the lower half presents a hexagonal arrangement. The central air hole, with a diameter of
d1, is filled with an NLC (E7). The NLC (E7), characterized by its anisotropy, significantly enhances the birefringence of the structure. The higher refractive index of the NLC (E7) ensures effective confinement of the optical field within the core region. Cores A and B are formed by selectively removing the left and right adjacent air holes to the central air hole, respectively. Surrounding the cores A and B, there are four types of air holes with different sizes: 9 small air holes adjacent to the core region in the y direction with a diameter of
d2, 5 small air holes above the core region, and 4 small air holes below the core region, thereby breaking the symmetry of the structure and achieving higher birefringence characteristics. In the x direction, the diameter of the two large air holes adjacent to cores A and B is
d3, while the diameters of the remaining air holes in the upper and lower halves of the cross-section are
d4 and
d5, respectively. The spacing between adjacent air holes in the y direction is denoted as
Λ, while in the x direction, it is denoted as
Λ for adjacent quadrilateral arranged air holes in the upper half of the cross-section and
Λ for adjacent hexagonal arranged air holes in the lower half. The substrate material of the PS-DC-PCF PBS is silica dioxide. To reduce the transmission loss of optical energy in simulations using the FV-FEM, a Perfectly Matched Layer (PML) is added as the outermost layer of the structure. The thickness of the PML is set to
Λ, with a refractive index 0.03 higher than that of the silica dioxide material [
15]. The proposed PS-DC-PCF PBS was modelled and analyzed using COMSOL Multiphysics 5.6 software. PML and scattering boundary conditions were used to fix the computational region and to absorb internal radiation, and the mesh delineation of the NLC center holes and air holes was carefully optimized to make the calculations more accurate.
The Sellmeier equation can be used to calculate the refractive index (
) of silicon dioxide at different wavelengths [
16,
17,
18].
where λ is the wavelength of the incident light in free space,
A1 = 0.6961663,
A2 = 0.407926,
A3 = 0.8974794,
B1 = 0.0684043 µm,
B2 = 0.1162414 µm, and
B3 = 9.896161 µm.
The refractive index of the NLC (E7) can be calculated using the Cauchy model [
19,
20], which includes the unusual refractive index no and the very refractive index ne. This refractive index is anisotropic over a range of temperatures.
The temperature dependent coefficients,
Ao,
Bo,
Co,
Ae,
Be and
Ce, are given in
Table 1. The definition of the relative dielectric constant tensor
of the NLC (E7) is as follows [
21]:
The inclination of the NLC molecule’s long axis concerning the x-axis is denoted by
φ, as illustrated in
Figure 1, with a value range of [0, 90°]. The magnitude of
φ is influenced by the external electric field, thereby allowing for controlled manipulation. For instance, positioning the proposed PS-DC-PCF PBS between two planar electrodes and adjusting the external electric field enables modification of the NLC (E7) molecule arrangement [
22,
23,
24]. Specifically, when the long axis of the NLC (E7) molecule aligns parallel to the x-axis,
φ equals 0 degrees, while an alignment parallel to the y-axis corresponds to φ being 90 degrees. This dynamic illustrates the tunable nature of
φ through external electric field adjustments within the proposed PS-DC-PCF PBS setup.
Since cores A and B of the PS-DC-PCF PBS are entirely symmetrical, and the distribution of the dielectric material is also identical, the propagating modes can be regarded as super-modes formed by the combination of four even and odd modes on the x-polarization (x-pol) and y-polarization (y-pol) directions. According to mode coupling theory, the propagation constants of the even and odd modes are different. As the x-pol and y-pol light propagates along the PS-DC-PCF PBS, it periodically transfers between the two cores. The propagation length required for the complete transfer of polarization light energy from one core to another is termed as the coupling length (CL). It is used to describe the distance required for x-pol light or y-pol light to be fully transmitted from one core to another. The calculation formula is as follows [
25,
26,
27].
where CL
x and CL
y represent the CLs of the x-pol and y-pol lights, respectively.
,
,
, and
refer to the effective refractive indices of the x-pol and y-pol even and odd modes, respectively. To achieve complete separation of the x-polarized and y-polarized lights, the length L of the PS-DC-PCF PBS must satisfy L = mCL
x = nCL
y, and the CLR is defined as [
28]
when CLR is equal to 0.5 or 2 [
29], the splitting length of the PS-DC-PCF PBS can be expressed by CL
x or CL
y. The device length is shorter in this case.
Assuming only the input port is fiber core A and excluding any consideration of transmission-induced attenuation of optical wave energy, the normalized powers of x-pol and y-pol at the output ports of fiber cores A and B are as follows [
30]:
where
L denotes the splitting length, while
Pin and
Pout refer to the incident light power and the output light powers of the two cores, respectively. Equations (8) and (9) facilitate the determination of the change in the NOP concerning the splitting length at a specified wavelength, as well as the variation of the NOP concerning the wavelength at a given splitting length. Additionally, the extinction ratio (ER) is defined as [
31]
The performance assessment of the proposed PS-DC-PCF PBS can be conducted directly through the ER. An ER value exceeding 20 dB (or less than −20 dB) indicates that the power of one polarized light is 100 times greater than the other. This significant power discrepancy effectively facilitates the separation of the two orthogonally polarized beams [
32]. Consequently, the wavelength range characterized by an ER exceeding 20 dB (or less than −20 dB) can be deemed as the operational bandwidth of the PS-DC-PCF PBS [
33]. This criterion ensures efficient beam separation within the specified wavelength range.
The insertion loss (IL) is one of the key parameters used to evaluate the performance of PS-DC-PCF polarization beam splitters. It indicates the optical power loss suffered by the light signal after passing through the PBS, typically expressed in decibels (dB). Lower insertion loss implies higher optical signal transmission efficiency and better system performance. In optical communication systems, reducing insertion loss is crucial for ensuring the stability and reliability of signal transmission. Its calculation method is as follows [
34]:
3. Simulation Results and Discussion
The coupling and transmission characteristics of PS-DC-PCF were investigated using the FV-FEM. In the simulations, the incident light source was assumed to be a Gaussian beam, with the initial angle
φ of the NLC (E7) molecules set to 90°, and the DC-PCF was assumed to operate at a temperature of 25 °C. The initial structural parameters were set to
d1 = 0.9 µm,
d2 = 1.2 µm,
d3 = 2.4 µm,
d4 = 1.3 µm,
d5 = 1.4 µm, and
Λ = 2 µm, and the relationship between the effective refractive index of the even and odd super-modes for both x-pol and y-pol and the wavelength is shown in
Figure 2.
As depicted in
Figure 2, an evident trend emerges wherein the effective refractive indices of both x-polarized and y-polarized odd and even super-modes decrease with the augmentation of wavelength. Notably, a close proximity in the effective refractive indices of x-pol and y-pol odd super-modes is observed, contrasting with a discernible difference in the effective refractive indices of x-pol and y-pol even super-modes. This discrepancy underscores the substantial impact of including NLC (E7) material on the effective refractive indices of x-pol and y-pol even super-modes, rendering them more predisposed to differentiation. Furthermore,
Figure 2a highlights a progressive amplification in the disparity of effective refractive indices between x-pol and y-pol odd and even super-modes with increasing wavelength. Specifically, the divergence between x-polarized odd and even super-modes exceeds that between y-polarized odd and even super-modes, as evidenced by the graphical representation.
Figure 3 illustrates the relationship between the coupling lengths CL
x, CL
y, and CLR of the x-pol and y-pol odd and even super-modes with respect to wavelength, which can be calculated using Equations (5)–(7), respectively. From
Figure 3, it can be observed that as the wavelength increases, CL
x is always smaller than CL
y. CL
x decreases gradually from 45.09 μm to 32.30 μm, while CL
y initially slightly increases from 95.76 μm to 96.47 μm and then significantly decreases to 65.19 μm. Considering the changing trends of CL
x and CL
y, the CLR curve initially increases and then decreases. However, within the considered wavelength range of 1.3–1.8 μm, the CLR value remains greater than 2. Under these conditions, although the x-pol light and y-pol light can be separated, the splitting length is too long.
Figure 4a–d illustrate the distributions of mode fields for four distinct super-modes within the PS-DC-PCF PBS, considering an incident light wavelength of 1.55 μm. Analyzing
Figure 4a,b, it becomes apparent that the mode field energy associated with the x-pol and y-pol odd modes primarily resides within the fiber cores A and B, with only a minor portion extending into the central NLC aperture. Upon a closer examination of
Figure 4c,d), it becomes evident that a fraction of energy from both the x-pol and y-pol even modes couples into the central aperture filled with an NLC. However, the mode field energy of these modes does not entirely confine within cores A and B, with a noteworthy observation being the dominance of energy from the x-pol even mode within the NLC aperture compared to the y-pol even mode. This finding accentuates the notable influence of the NLC filling on polarization even modes, particularly emphasizing its impact on the x-pol even mode.
To achieve a PS-DC-PCF PBS with optimal performance, the relationship between the structural parameters (
d1,
d2,
d3,
d4, and
Λ) of the PS-DC-PCF PBS at a wavelength of 1.55 μm and CL
x, CL
y, and CLR was computed. The influence of
d1 on the CL
x, CL
y, and CLR of the PS-DC-PCF PBS is illustrated in
Figure 5. From
Figure 5, it can be observed that as
d1 increases from 0.6 to 1.0 µm, CL
x gradually increases from 33.67 µm to 36.55 µm, while CL
y increases to a maximum value of 85.89 µm from 63.55 µm and then gradually decreases to 75.07 µm. This is because the increase in
d1 enhances the influence of an NLC on mode coupling, thereby reducing the coupling strength in the x-pol direction and initially decreasing before increasing in the y-pol direction. Additionally, since the variation of CL
y is more pronounced than that of CL
x, the trend of CLR follows a similar pattern to that of CL
y. Furthermore, as
d1 increases, ε first increases from 1.89 to 2.41 and then decreases to 2.05.
The influence of
d2 on CL
x, CL
y, and CLR of the PS-DC-PCF PBS is depicted in
Figure 6. From
Figure 6, it can be observed that as
d2 increases from 1.1 μm to 1.5 μm, CL
x slightly decreases from 38.34 μm to 34.26 μm. In contrast, CL
y initially decreases significantly from 89.94 μm to 74.90 μm. With the increase in
d2, CLR first slightly increases from 2.35 to 2.37 and then decreases to 2.19. This indicates that the increase in
d2 weakens the confinement ability of the two cores for x-polarized odd and even super-modes, particularly for y-polarized odd and even super-modes, making the transmission between the two cores for x-pol and y-pol light easier.
Figure 7 illustrates the influence of
d3 on CL
x, CL
y, and CLR of the PS-DC-PCF PBS. From
Figure 7, it can be observed that as
d3 increases from 2.0 μm to 2.6 μm, CL
x decreases from 42.31 μm to 33.78 μm, and CL
y decreases from 103.47 μm to 76.40 μm. Additionally, CLR also gradually decreases from 2.45 to 2.26 with the increase in wavelength. The main reason is that as
d3 increases, the coupling strength of x-pol and y-pol light increases, thus reducing the coupling length required for x-pol and y-pol light to propagate from one core to the other.
Figure 8 demonstrates the impact of
d4 on CL
x, CL
y, and CLR of the PS-DC-PCF PBS. As shown in
Figure 8, with the increase in
d4 from 1.2 µm to 1.6 µm, CL
x remains approximately at 36.1 µm and CL
y is essentially constant at about 84.7 µm, both exhibiting only minimal variations. This indicates that changes in
d4 have almost no effect on the mode coupling between the two cores. Consequently, CLR consistently remains around 2.34 as
d4 increases.
Figure 9 depicts the influence of
d5 on CL
x, CL
y, and CLR of the PS-DC-PCF PBS. As
d5 increases from 1.3 µm to 1.7 µm, CL
x experiences a slight decrease from 36.56 µm to 35.72 µm, while CL
y decreases slightly more than CL
x, from 85.07 µm to 83.94 µm. CLR remains essentially constant at around 2.3, with minimal variations observed. This suggests that the variation in
d5 has a negligible impact on the mode coupling between the two cores.
Figure 10 illustrates the impact of
Λ on CL
x, CL
y, and CLR of the PS-DC-PCF PBS. From
Figure 10, it can be observed that as Λ increases from 1.85 μm to 2.1 μm, CLx gradually increases from 27.53 μm to 42.57 μm, and CL
y increases from 57.64 μm to 108.18 μm. The primary reason for this is that with the increase in pitch, the distance between core A and core B increases, leading to a weaker coupling strength between x-polarized and y-polarized light and thus an increase in coupling length. Additionally, since the increase in CL
y is always greater than the increase in CL
x, CLR also increases with the increase in
Λ, rising from 2.09 to 2.54.
By comparing the observations from
Figure 5,
Figure 6,
Figure 7,
Figure 8,
Figure 9 and
Figure 10, we can notice that variations in each structural parameter influence the trends of CL
x, CL
y, and CLR. Particularly, when adjusting the parameters
d1 and
Λ, the changes in CLR are relatively significant, with a span of approximately 0.5. This is because
d1 represents the aperture size of the central pore in the NLC, while
Λ corresponds to the periodic structure of the photonic crystal. The periodic structure of the photonic crystal plays a crucial role in optical systems, determining the propagation of light within the crystal and the formation of photonic bandgaps. Therefore, fine-tuning these parameters directly affects the optical performance. In addition to the periodic structure of the photonic crystal, the NLC also plays a crucial role. The NLC possesses controllable birefringence characteristics, enabling precise control of light transmission behavior in optical devices. Hence, the role of the NLC cannot be overlooked in such structures. It complements the periodic structure of the photonic crystal, collectively influencing the ultimate optical performance.
After a thorough analysis of the impacts of structural parameters on CLx, CLy, and CLR, and by considering both the operational efficiency and fabrication intricacies associated with the PS-DC-PCF PBS, optimal structural parameters were identified: d1 = 0.98 μm, d2 = 1.4 μm, d3 = 2.55 μm, d4 = 1.3 μm, d5 = 1.5 μm, and Λ = 2.0 μm. These refined parameters are deemed conducive to achieving desired performance characteristics while minimizing fabrication complexities.
Figure 11 illustrates the relationship between the optimized CL
x, CL
y, and CLR with wavelength in the presence and absence of an NLC filling in the central hole. From
Figure 11a, it can be observed that when the PCF central hole is not filled with the NLC, i.e., when the central hole is an air hole, CL
x and CL
y are large, showing a decreasing trend within the wavelength range of 1.3–1.8 μm. CL
x decreases rapidly from 278.20 μm to 127.25 μm, and CL
y decreases from 357.85 μm to 161.60 μm, indicating a significant change. However, the change in CLR at this point is not very noticeable, showing an overall decreasing trend as the wavelength increases, from 1.286 to 1.270, almost staying between 1.27 and 1.29, far from the optimal value of 2 for CLR, which is not conducive to manufacturing shorter PBS. In contrast, from
Figure 11b, it is evident that after filling the PCF central hole with the NLC, CL
x and CL
y decrease significantly and exhibit a more stable change. As the wavelength increases from 1.3 μm to 1.8 μm, CL
x gradually decreases from 39.59 μm to 27.48 μm, while CL
y initially increases from 56.59 μm to a maximum of 65.65 μm at a wavelength of 1.475 μm, then decreases to 55.83 μm. Comparing these two scenarios, without an NLC filling in the central hole, there is a large variation in CL
x and CL
y, which may lead to an unstable propagation path of light in PCF, thus not conducive to polarization separation. However, after filling with the NLC, the infiltration of the NLC enhances the birefringence effect of PCF, greatly increasing the coupling intensity of x-pol and y-pol polarized light and making the light propagation path in PCF more controlled, which is beneficial for polarization separation, thereby achieving a shorter PBS splitter length and improving PBS performance. Additionally, as the wavelength increases, CLR shows an increasing then stabilizing trend. After calculation, it is found that CLR is closer to 2 at a wavelength of 1.625 μm, indicating that the optimized PS-DC-PCF PBS can achieve a shorter splitter length at this wavelength.
According to Equations (8) and (9), the normalized output power (NOP) of x-pol and y-pol light in cores A and B will undergo periodic changes along the propagation distance.
Figure 12a,b illustrate the relationship between NOP of x-polarized and y-polarized light at a wavelength of 1.625 µm and the propagation length. As shown in
Figure 12a,b, as the propagation length increases from 0 to 61.9 µm, the NOP of x-polarized light completely transfers from core A to B and then returns to core A, reaching a maximum value of 1. Therefore, the shortest splitting length is 61.9 µm. At this length, the NOP of x-polarized light in core A reaches its minimum value, while that of y-polarized light reaches its maximum value. Conversely, in core B, the NOP of x-polarized light reaches its maximum value, while that of y-polarized light reaches its minimum value. Thus, when the splitting length is 61.9 µm, x-pol and y-pol light at a wavelength of 1.625 µm are completely separated in the two cores.
Figure 13 depicts the ER as a function of wavelength when the splitting length of the proposed PS-DC-PCF PBS is 61.9 µm. From
Figure 13, it can be observed that as the wavelength increases from 1.3 µm to 1.325 µm, ER increases from 14.43 dB to 20.35 dB. As the wavelength continues to increase, ER reaches its first peak at 72.94 dB at a wavelength of 1.36 µm, and its second peak at 52.51 dB at a wavelength of 1.65 µm. At a wavelength of 1.75 µm, ER decreases to 20 dB. Therefore, within the wavelength range of 1.325 to 1.75 µm, ER stays above 20 dB, with a bandwidth of 423 nm, covering most of the communication bands (including O + E + S + C + L + U).
In order to comprehensively characterize the spectral properties of the PS-DC-PCF PBS,
Figure 14 depicts the insertion losses (IL
x and IL
y) as a function of wavelength. An examination of
Figure 14 reveals distinct behaviors in IL
x and IL
y over the considered wavelength range. IL
x demonstrates a discernible decreasing trend until reaching a wavelength of 1.625 µm. Notably, IL
x experiences a rapid reduction from 2.23 dB, attaining a nadir of 8.99 × 10
−6 dB at 1.625 µm, followed by a gradual increase to 0.70 dB at 1.8 µm. Conversely, IL
y exhibits comparably minor variations. Within the wavelength range of 1.3 to 1.36 µm, IL
y showcases a descending trajectory, plummeting from 0.10 dB to 1.50 × 10
−7 dB. Subsequently, in the range of 1.36 to 1.47 µm, IL
y gradually ascends to 0.04 dB before declining anew within the 1.47 to 1.65 μm wavelength range, bottoming out at 2.43 × 10–5 dB at 1.65 μm, and eventually ascending to 0.13 dB within the 1.65 to 1.8 μm wavelength range. These observations underline the wavelength-dependent characteristics of IL
x and IL
y, thus highlighting the nuanced behavior of the PS-DC-PCF PBS across the specified spectral range.
To ensure the practical applicability of the designed PS-DC-PCF PBS, it is crucial to investigate the manufacturing tolerances of various structural parameters. Current manufacturing technologies can control errors within 1%, allowing for a precise evaluation of parameter variations. In this study, the impact of ±1% changes in different structural parameters on ER is analyzed. From the results illustrated in
Figure 15a–f, it is apparent that the most significant influences on ER come from changes in the diameter of the central NLC-filled air holes (
d1) and the diameter of the adjacent air holes in the x-direction (
d3). According to
Figure 15a, a 1% decrease in
d1 results in a wavelength range of 1.31 to 1.71 µm with ER exceeding 20 dB, yielding an effective working bandwidth of approximately 400 nm. Conversely, a 1% increase in
d1 expands the wavelength range with ER over 20 dB to 1.34~1.75 µm, widening the bandwidth to about 410 nm. This indicates that a reduction in d1 leads to a blue shift, while an increase leads to a red shift. Similarly,
Figure 15c shows that a 1% decrease in
d3 yields an ER bandwidth of 1.32~1.74 µm (420 nm), while a 1% increase leads to a bandwidth of 1.33~1.73 µm (410 nm). The analysis also reveals that within the 1.34 to 1.71 µm wavelength range, ER remains consistently above 20 dB, regardless of variations in
d1,
d2,
d3, or
Λ.
Figure 15d,e show that 1% changes in
d4 and
d5 do not impact the operating bandwidth, with only minor variations in peak ER. In summary, even with a ±1% error margin during manufacturing, the designed PS-DC-PCF PBS maintains robust splitting performance across a broad bandwidth.
Due to the temperature-dependent refractive index of the NLC (E7), the relationship between ER and wavelength of the proposed PS-DC-PCF PBS at different temperatures is illustrated in
Figure 16. It can be observed from
Figure 16 that as the temperature varies from 15 °C to 35 °C, ER remains greater than 20 dB within the wavelength range of 1.37 μm to 1.68 μm. Additionally, with an increase in temperature from 15 °C to 35 °C, the operating bandwidth of the PS-DC-PCF PBS shifts towards shorter wavelengths, indicating a blue shift phenomenon. At 15 °C, the operating bandwidth is 400 nm, covering a wavelength range of 1.37 to 1.77 µm. Similarly, at 35 °C, the operating bandwidth is also approximately 400 nm, covering a wavelength range of 1.28 to 1.68 µm. These results demonstrate that the proposed PS-DC-PCF PBS can operate normally within the temperature range of 15 to 35 °C.
Table 2 presents a comparison of the simulation results between the proposed PS-DC-PCF PBS and other reported DC-PCF PBSs. By observing
Table 2, it is noted that the maximum ER values in references [
12,
14,
35,
36,
37] are all higher than those within this study. However, it is worth noting that the operational bandwidth of PCF PBS refers to the wavelength range where ER is greater than 20 dB, while in some studies, the operational bandwidth may only exceed 10 dB [
12,
38] or 15 dB [
36]. Therefore, even if the maximum ER value at a certain wavelength is high, the final spectral bandwidth may not necessarily be the widest. Hence, the crucial aspect lies in comparing the lengths of the splitters and the widths of the operational bandwidth. A further examination of the results in
Table 2 reveals that most DC-PDF PBSs [
13,
35,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40,
41] neither possess the operational bandwidth proposed in this paper nor do they have shorter splitter lengths than the one in this study. It is important to note that the DC-PCF PBS structures proposed in references [
35,
36,
38,
41] include elliptical holes, indicating an increase in manufacturing complexity. Moreover, reference [
41] employs a gold wire in their DC-PCF PBS structures, while this study utilizes an NLC, which is significantly cheaper than gold. Furthermore, this study does not include elliptical holes but adopts only circular holes, thus reducing manufacturing costs and structural manufacturing complexity. Additionally, it is noteworthy that references [
12,
13,
14,
37] also introduce an NLC to enhance the birefringence of PCF. Although the splitter lengths in references [
12,
14] are slightly shorter than those in this study, the operational bandwidth of this study exceeds theirs. In summary, the PS-DC-PCF PBS proposed in this study can simultaneously achieve shorter splitter lengths and a wider operational bandwidth, with lower costs and simpler manufacturing processes.