1. Introduction
One of the most serious problems of the 21th century is that global food security of the growing population cannot be assured due to the limited freshwater resources and available cultivable land [
1,
2]. According to the Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations’ (FAO) 2019 report, the number of people suffering from hunger is about 820 million. Nutritional deficiencies mainly affects Africa, Southern and Western Asia, and Latin America [
3]; however, other forms of malnutrition (overweight, obesity, and micronutrient deficiencies) are globally present, not just in the developing countries, but also in the developed countries. In total, about 2 billion people experience some level of food insecurity in the world. Consequently, it is necessary to focus not only on the supply of sufficient quantities of food, but also on the nutritional quality of the diet [
4]. Dietary quality scores (DQSs) are used to evaluate the quality of diets. When DQSs are calculated, nutrients are often classified as qualifying or disqualifying, based on the dietary recommendations. According to these classifications, adequate intake of nutrients such as high-quality protein, dietary fibre, vitamin A, vitamin C, vitamin E, folate, calcium, and iron is considered to be qualifying. High saturated fat, added sugar, salt, and cholesterol content, as well as too low or too high energy intake, are classified as disqualifying. These factors are closely linked to undernutrition, obesity, and the development of non-communicable chronic diseases, such as cardiovascular diseases and type 2 diabetes mellitus [
5,
6].
According to several studies, the food industry is responsible for 26–50% of the greenhouse gas (GHG) emission, while agriculture is responsible for approximately 80% of the anthropological water footprint. High-quality protein production creates the greatest impact on the environment; since livestock breeding requires high amount of feed that is responsible for significant emission of GHGs, among others [
7,
8]. Based on FAO’s statement development on dietary guidelines, a healthy but also sustainable diet contains less food of animal origin (meat, fish, and dairy products) and legumes, wholegrain products, and seeds are instead recommended. The consumption of foods high in fat, salt, and sugar should be very limited; and efforts should also be made to consume minimally processed foods [
9].
Several studies from the past decade have focused on the role of edible insects since they can be one of the possible solutions to address the problem of food security. Entomophagy or “eating insects” was common in the prehistoric era and is still a part of the diet of certain areas of Latin America, Africa, and Asia [
10,
11]. More than 2000 edible species are known, including beetles, caterpillars, wasps, ants, and grasshoppers [
12]. The nutritional quality of edible insects is satisfying; however, it depends on the species, the feed, and the stage of the development [
13]. Generally, they contain high-quality protein, and their fatty acid composition resembles those of poultry and fish, but with higher amount of polyunsaturated type [
14]. Their carbohydrate composition is diverse; due to their exoskeletal chitin content, they are considered as a good source of dietary fibre. Regarding the micronutrients, their vitamin B and E, iron, magnesium, and zinc content are remarkable [
12,
14,
15,
16]. Thus, insects contain most of the nutrients considered to be qualifying, and could be used successfully in malnutrition management [
17].
Numerous studies have shown that the farming of edible insects has a lower environmental impact than that of other livestocks’. The land use of insect farming is significantly lower, as insects are suitable for indoor, urban, and vertical farming. Many types of agricultural, industrial, and household wastes can be recycled as insect feed, since they can digest forage higher in dietary fibre. Their GHG and ammonia emissions are minimal compared to beef or pork breeding. The required water for producing a unit amount of insect protein is a fragment of the amount used for the production of other types of animal proteins [
11,
18].
Using insects as feed or food has been proven to be beneficial from both nutritional and environmental point of view. Commercial farming and insect-based food production require a strict regulatory system, which is still being developed in the European Union. According to the European Food Safety Authority’s (EFSA) 2015 scientific opinion, further data generation is required on the field of food safety, especially on microbiological and chemical hazards and allergenicity [
19].
The consumer acceptance of insects as food depends on many influencing factors. Western people still have a negative attitude towards them; however, knowledge about edible insects and their nutritional value, previous taste experiences, and sensation seeking seem to increase acceptance. Many studies have proved that using insects in a non-visible form (e.g., insect powders) can increase the willingness to eat them. As a consequence, complementation of our everyday foods (e.g., bread, pasta, and other bakery and snack products), which are able to mask the insect component, can be the first step introducing insect-based foods to the market [
20,
21]. Several insect-containing food products have been described in the scientific literature recently, such as buckwheat pasta, breads, and energy bars [
22,
23,
24,
25].
Oat products are very popular nowadays since they are considered to be healthy. Oat
(Avena sativa) is a cereal belonging to the
Poaceae family. It has good nutritional qualities because of its relatively high protein, fibre, vitamin B, and mineral content [
26]. The most important type of fibre in oats is the soluble β-glucan, which is a heterogeneous group of non-starch polysaccharides. Many studies have proved that this type of fibre has beneficial effects on diseases such as obesity, diabetes mellitus, hypertension, and dyslipidaemia, among others [
27]. Shortbread-type biscuits are easy and simple to make, and many recipes are available that includes different type of cereal flours and also specifically oat flour.
The advantageous characteristics of insects and oat products as food ingredients can be mixed and a promising way of introducing insect-containing products would be the enrichment of oat biscuits with insect powders. Based on these, the aims of this study were to:
present the usability of different amounts of insect powder in a biscuit product,
examine the technological effect of insect enrichment on the finished products, and
discover how the insect content of the products affects the overall liking (OAL), and which attributes are the drivers of liking.
4. Conclusions
The obtained results suggest that samples containing 10 g/100 g flour mixture (CP10) and 15 g/100 g flour mixture (CP15) Acheta domesticus powder can be labelled as protein source based on the corresponding EU regulation. However, consumer sensory analysis revealed that CP10 and CP15 were significantly less liked compared with the control and 5 g insect/100 g flour mixture (CP5) based sample. The rejection can be attributed to the changes in appearance and not due to changes of textural attributes, as the technological analysis suggested. The major factors of rejection were Brown colour and Burnt flavour; hence further product developments should address these issues.
Literature data suggest that consumers prefer insect containing products at different levels, however, there are limited results available about biscuits, since the majority of the publications have focused on other bakery products.
Our results raise the attention of policy makers and producers to the fact that insects enhance the nutritional quality of bakery products even if they are made from gluten free cereals and/or pseudocereals.
Limitations of our study are the lack of representative sampling; however, it is still in line with Næs’ recommendation [
49]. According to a 2017 study, Hungarian consumers show slight rejection to insects as food, therefore, these results should not be generalized [
50].
Further analysis should be carried out to test the effect of different species on the sensory attributes of insect enriched bakery products. Sensory attributes–therefore acceptance–might also be influenced by different base materials (e.g., flour types and mixtures), spices (salted or sweet products) and processing technologies (e.g., drying, frying, cooking, baking).